Role of signals from the dorsal root ganglion in neuropathic pain in a rat model

Protein kinase G signaling pathway is involved in sympathetically maintained pain by modulating ATP-sensitive potassium channels

BACKGROUND

Sympathetically maintained pain (SMP) involves an increased excitability of dorsal root ganglion (DRG) neurons to sympathetic nerve stimulation and circulating norepinephrine. The current treatment of SMP has limited efficacy, and hence more mechanistic insights into this intractable pain condition are urgently needed.

METHODS

A caudal trunk transection (CTT) model of neuropathic pain was established in mice.Immunofluorescence staining, small interfering RNA, pharmacological and electrophysiological studies were conducted to test the hypothesis that norepinephrine increases the excitability of small-diameter DRG neurons from CTT mice through the activation of cyclic guanosine monophosphate-protein kinase G (cGMP-PKG) signaling pathway.

RESULTS

Behavior study showed that CTT mice developed mechanical and heat hypersensitivities, which were attenuated by intraperitoneal injection of guanethidine. CTT mice also showed an abnormal sprouting of tyrosine hydroxylase-positive nerve fibers in DRG, and an increased excitability of small-diameter DRG neurons to norepinephrine, suggesting that CTT is a useful model to study SMP. Importantly, inhibiting cGMP-PKG pathway with small interfering RNA and KT5823 attenuated the increased sympathetic sensitivity in CTT mice. In contrast, cGMP activators (Sp-cGMP, 8-Br-cGMP) further increased sympathetic sensitivity. Furthermore, phosphorylation of ATP-sensitive potassium channel, which is a downstream target of PKG, may contribute to the adrenergic modulation of DRG neuron excitability.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings suggest an important role of cGMP-PKG signaling pathway in the increased excitability of small-diameter DRG neurons to norepinephrine after CTT, which involves an inhibition of the ATP-sensitive potassium currents through PKG-induced phosphorylation. Accordingly, drugs targeting this pathway may help to treat SMP.

Postlaminectomy stabilization of the spine in a rat model of neuropathic pain reduces pain-related behavior

STUDY DESIGN

Spine deformity and pain-related behavior after laminectomy with and without spine stabilization were investigated.

OBJECTIVE

We tested hypothesis that spine stabilization after extensive laminectomy can prevent spine deformation and consequent pain-related behavior.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Various ablative procedures requiring laminectomy have been tested for prevention or reversal of pain-related behavior in studies using experimental animals. However, there is no precise description indicating how laminectomy should be performed. Lack of standardized surgical techniques makes it difficult to achieve uniformity of result reporting and to compare results of different research groups meaningfully.

METHODS

To test our hypothesis, extensive laminectomy with and without spine stabilization was performed in Sprague-Dawley rats. U-shaped surgical wire was used for stabilization of the spine. A validated test of mechanical hyperalgesia was used to test the development of neuropathic pain behavior after surgery. Deformity of the spine was evaluated by calculating deviation from the central axis on radiographs obtained in anteroposterior projection.

RESULTS

Surgical stabilization of the spine after laminectomy prevented development of spinal deformity. Laminectomy without stabilization induced hyperalgesia on the 8th and 15th days after surgery. Group with stabilized spine exhibited significant reduction in pain-related behavior on the 8th and 15th postoperative days compared with the group without stabilization.

CONCLUSION

Surgical stabilization of the spine after laminectomy prevented development of spinal deformity and pain-related behavior. Our results suggest that spine stabilization procedure should be used in all experimental pain models in which laminectomy is performed.

Key role of the dorsal root ganglion in neuropathic tactile hypersensibility

Cutting spinal nerves just distal to the dorsal root ganglion (DRG) triggers, with rapid onset, massive spontaneous ectopic discharge in axotomized afferent A-neurons, and at the same time induces tactile allodynia in the partially denervated hindlimb. We show that secondary transection of the dorsal root (rhizotomy) of the axotomized DRG, or suppression of the ectopia with topically applied local anesthetics, eliminates or attenuates the allodynia. Dorsal rhizotomy alone does not trigger allodynia. These observations support the hypothesis that ectopic firing in DRG A-neurons induces central sensitization which leads to tactile allodynia. The question of how activity in afferent A-neurons, which are not normally nociceptive, might induce allodynia is discussed in light of the current literature.

Governing role of primary afferent drive in increased excitation of spinal nociceptive neurons in a model of sciatic neuropathy

Previously we reported that the cuff model of peripheral neuropathy, in which a 2 mm polyethylene tube is implanted around the sciatic nerve, exhibits aspects of neuropathic pain behavior in rats similar to those in humans and causes robust hyperexcitation of spinal nociceptive dorsal horn neurons. The mechanisms mediating this increased excitation are not known and remain a key unresolved question in models of peripheral neuropathy. In anesthetized adult male Sprague-Dawley rats 2-6 weeks after cuff implantation we found that elevated discharge rate of single lumbar (L(3-4)) wide dynamic range (WDR) neurons persists despite acute spinal transection (T9) but is reversed by local conduction block of the cuff-implanted sciatic nerve; lidocaine applied distal to the cuff (i.e. between the cuff and the cutaneous receptive field) decreased spontaneous baseline discharge of WDR dorsal horn neurons approximately 40% (n=18) and when applied subsequently proximal to the cuff, i.e. between the cuff and the spinal cord, it further reduced spontaneous discharge by approximately 60% (n=19; P<0.05 proximal vs. distal) to a level that was not significantly different from that of naive rats. Furthermore, in cuff-implanted rats WDR neurons (n=5) responded to mechanical cutaneous stimulation with an exaggerated afterdischarge which was reversed entirely by proximal nerve conduction block. These results demonstrate that the hyperexcited state of spinal dorsal horn neurons observed in this model of peripheral neuropathy is not maintained by tonic descending facilitatory mechanisms. Rather, on-going afferent discharges originating from the sciatic nerve distal to, at, and proximal to the cuff maintain the synaptically-mediated gain in discharge of spinal dorsal horn WDR neurons and hyperresponsiveness of these neurons to cutaneous stimulation. Our findings reveal that ectopic afferent activity from multiple regions along peripheral nerves may drive CNS changes and the symptoms of pain associated with peripheral neuropathy.

The extent of laminectomy affects pain-related behavior in a rat model of neuropathic pain

One of the unresolved questions in neuropathic pain research is whether we can prevent or reverse mechanical hyperalgesia by rhizotomy or ganglionectomy. However, one of the obstacles in answering that question is lack of a standardized surgical procedure used in experimental ganglionectomy. We tested the hypothesis that laminectomy performed during ganglionectomy induces lumbar column deformity. We further examined whether spinal deformity is a source of pain-related behavior. Five conditions were studied. Fifth and sixth lumbar (L5 and L6) ganglionectomy were performed in rats using either minimal or extensive laminectomy technique. Two other groups had minimal and extensive laminectomy without ganglionectomies. A final control group had no surgery. Sensory responsiveness of the plantar aspect of the hind paw was repeatedly tested, and a plain radiograph in anteroposterior projection was made to assess the extent of deformity by measurement of deformity angles. Hyperalgesia resulted in groups with extensive laminectomy regardless of performance or absence of ganglionectomy, while in groups with minimal laminectomy there was no increase in pain-related behavior. Lateral deformity of the spine was observed in rats with or without ganglionectomy, confirming that laminectomy can produce deformity. The extent of deformity was more pronounced in rats exposed to the extensive laminectomy. Our results indicate that laminectomy can produce spine deformity and that there is a direct relationship between the extent of laminectomy and the development of mechanical hypersensitivity. The data presented suggest that there is a need for standardization of laminectomy procedure in rat experimental pain models.

Importance of hyperexcitability of DRG neurons in neuropathic pain

A number of good animal models have been developed in recent years that provide insights into the mechanisms of neuropathic pain. It now becomes evident that there are two separate peripheral components influencing neuropathic pain: one dependent on the hyperexcitability of axotomized dorsal root ganglion (DRG) neurons and the other independent of this hyperexcitability. The purpose of this review is to consider one of these components, the hyperexcitability of axotomized DRG neurons, as one of the important mechanisms underlying neuropathic pain. Several hours after nerve lesions, some axotomized DRG neurons become hyperexcitable and begin to show ongoing discharges that last many days or weeks. These ectopic discharges then enter the spinal cord and induce central sensitization, the underlying central mechanism for the generation of pain and allodynia. Although the exact causes of the development of hyperexcitability and ectopic discharges are not clear, various ion channels seem to play important roles, particularly sodium channels. In addition, important modulatory factors for ectopic discharges are purinergic and adrenergic components of the sympathetic nervous system. These findings suggest that manipulating sodium channels and/or adrenergic and purinergic receptors on axotomized DRG cells may give neuropathic pain sufferers some relief that is not available from present treatment regimens.

Increased sensitivity of injured and adjacent uninjured rat primary sensory neurons to exogenous tumor necrosis factor-alpha after spinal nerve ligation

Tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF) is upregulated after nerve injury, causes pain on injection, and its blockade reduces pain behavior resulting from nerve injury; thus it is strongly implicated in neuropathic pain. We investigated responses of intact and nerve-injured dorsal root ganglia (DRG) neurons to locally applied TNF using parallel in vivo and in vitro paradigms. In vivo, TNF (0.1-10 pg/ml) or vehicle was injected into L5 DRG in naive rats and in rats that had received L5 and L6 spinal nerve ligation (SNL) immediately before injection. In naive rats, TNF, but not vehicle, elicited long-lasting allodynia. In SNL rats, subthreshold doses of TNF synergized with nerve injury to elicit faster onset of allodynia and spontaneous pain behavior. Tactile allodynia was present in both injured and adjacent uninjured (L4) dermatomes. Preemptive treatment with the TNF antagonist etanercept reduced SNL-induced allodynia by almost 50%. In vitro, the electrophysiological responses of naive, SNL-injured, or adjacent uninjured DRG to TNF (0.1-1000 pg/ml) were assessed by single-fiber recordings of teased dorsal root microfilaments. In vitro perfusion of TNF (100-1000 pg/ml) to naive DRG evoked short-lasting neuronal discharges. In injured DRG, TNF, at much lower concentrations, elicited earlier onset, markedly higher, and longer-lasting discharges. TNF concentrations that were subthreshold in naive DRG also elicited high-frequency discharges when applied to uninjured, adjacent DRG. We conclude that injured and adjacent uninjured DRG neurons are sensitized to TNF after SNL. Sensitization to endogenous TNF may be essential for the development and maintenance of neuropathic pain.

Neuronal hyperpolarization-activated pacemaker channels drive neuropathic pain

Neuropathic pain is a common and often incapacitating clinical problem for which little useful therapy is presently available. Painful peripheral neuropathies can have many etiologies, among which are trauma, viral infections, exposure to radiation or chemotherapy, and metabolic or autoimmune diseases. Sufferers generally experience both pain at rest and exaggerated, painful sensitivity to light touch. Spontaneous firing of injured nerves is believed to play a critical role in the induction and maintenance of neuropathic pain syndromes. Using a well characterized nerve ligation model in the rat, we demonstrate that hyperpolarization-activated, cyclic nucleotide-modulated (HCN) "pacemaker" channels play a previously unrecognized role in both touch-related pain and spontaneous neuronal discharge originating in the damaged dorsal root ganglion. HCN channels, particularly HCN1, are abundantly expressed in rat primary afferent somata. Nerve injury markedly increases pacemaker currents in large-diameter dorsal root ganglion neurons and results in pacemaker-driven spontaneous action potentials in the ligated nerve. Pharmacological blockade of HCN activity using the specific inhibitor ZD7288 reverses abnormal hypersensitivity to light touch and decreases the firing frequency of ectopic discharges originating in Abeta and Adelta fibers by 90 and 40%, respectively, without conduction blockade. These findings suggest novel insights into the molecular basis of pain and the possibility of new, specific, effective pharmacological therapies.

Selective increase of tumour necrosis factor-alpha in injured and spared myelinated primary afferents after chronic constrictive injury of rat sciatic nerve

Chronic constriction of the sciatic nerve, leading to a hyperalgesic state, results in a partial lesion wherein some axons are injured and others remain intact. Here we sought to characterize reactive changes which occur in DRG cell bodies of injured and uninjured axons projecting to skin and muscle. Using immunohistochemistry combined with flurorogold and fluororuby retrograde labelling to define DRG cell bodies associated with injured and uninjured axons, we analysed the DRG immunoreactivity (IR) for tumour necrosis factor-alpha (TNF), interleukin-10 (IL-10), the sensory neuron-specific channel vanilloid receptor 1 (VR1), isolectin B4 (IB4) and calcitonin-gene-related peptide (CGRP) 4 days after a unilateral chronic constriction injury (CCI) of the rat sciatic nerve. TNF IR was predominantly localized in neuronal DRG cells. In DRG with an intact nerve, TNF IR was present in 45%, IL-10 IR in 46%, VR1 IR in 44%, IB4 IR in 51% and CGRP IR in 40% of all neuronal profiles. Four days after CCI, TNF IR was increased in medium-sized neurons, whereas IR for IL-10, VR1 and IB4, predominantly present in small neurons, was reduced. Importantly, not only injured but also adjacent spared neurons contributed markedly to increased TNF IR. Neurons projecting to both muscle and skin displayed upregulated TNF IR after CCI. TNF in medium-sized neurons colocalized with neurofilament and trkB, but not with IB4, trkA or RET, suggesting a selective phenotypic switch in presumably low-threshold myelinated primary afferents. Spared myelinated fibres with intact sensory functions but upregulated TNF expression may contribute to behavioural changes observed after nerve injury.

Long-term alteration of S-type potassium current and passive membrane properties in aplysia sensory neurons following axotomy

In many neurons, axotomy triggers long-lasting alterations in excitability as well as regenerative growth. We have investigated mechanisms contributing to the expression of axotomy-induced, long-term hyperexcitability (LTH) of mechanosensory neurons in Aplysia californica. Electrophysiological tests were applied to pleural sensory neurons 5-10 days after unilateral crush of pedal nerves. Two-electrode current-clamp experiments revealed that compared with uninjured sensory neurons on the contralateral side of the body, axotomized sensory neurons consistently displayed alterations of passive membrane properties: notably, increases in input resistance (R(in)), membrane time constant (tau), and apparent input capacitance. In some cells, axotomy also depolarized the resting membrane potential (RMP). Axotomized sensory neurons showed a lower incidence of voltage relaxation ("sag") during prolonged hyperpolarizing pulses and greater depolarizations during long (2 s) but not brief (20 ms) pulses. In addition to a reduction in spike accommodation, axotomized sensory neurons displayed a dramatic decrease in current (rheobase) required to reach spike threshold during long depolarizations. The increase in tau was associated with prolongation of responses to brief current pulses and with a large increase in the latency to spike at rheobase. Two-electrode voltage-clamp revealed an axotomy-induced decrease in a current with two components: a leakage current component and a slowly activating, noninactivating outward current component. Neither component was blocked by agents known to block other K(+) currents in these neurons. In contrast to the instantaneous leakage current seen with hyperpolarizing and depolarizing steps, the late component of the axotomy-sensitive outward current showed a relatively steep voltage dependence with pulses to V(m) > -40 mV. These features match those of the S-type ("serotonin-sensitive") K(+) current, I(K,S). The close resemblance of I(K,S) to a background current mediated by TREK-1 (KCNK2) channels in mammals, raises interesting questions about alterations of this family of channels during axotomy-induced LTH in both Aplysia and mammals. The increase in apparent C(in) may be a consequence of the extensive sprouting that has been observed in axotomized sensory neurons near their somata, and the decrease in I(K,S) probably helps to compensate for the decrease in excitability that would otherwise occur as new growth causes both cell volume and C(in) to increase. In peripheral regions of the sensory neuron, a decrease in I(K,S) might enhance the safety factor for conduction across regenerating segments that are highly susceptible to conduction block.

Burst discharge in primary sensory neurons: triggered by subthreshold oscillations, maintained by depolarizing afterpotentials

Afferent discharge generated ectopically in the cell soma of dorsal root ganglion (DRG) neurons may play a role in normal sensation, and it contributes to paraesthesias and pain after nerve trauma. This activity is critically dependent on subthreshold membrane potential oscillations; oscillatory sinusoids that reach threshold trigger low-frequency trains of intermittent spikes. Ectopic firing may also enter a high-frequency bursting mode, however, particularly in the event of neuropathy. Bursting greatly amplifies the overall ectopic barrage. In the present report we show that subthreshold oscillations and burst discharge occur in vivo, as they do in vitro. We then show that although the first spike in each burst is triggered by an oscillatory sinusoid, firing within bursts is maintained by brief regenerative post-spike depolarizing afterpotentials (DAPs). Numerical simulations were used to identify the cellular process underlying rebound DAPs, and hence the mechanism of the spike bursts. Finally, we show that slow ramp and hold (tonic) depolarizations of the sort that occur in DRG neurons during physiologically relevant events are capable of triggering sustained ectopic bursting, but only in cells with subthreshold oscillatory behavior. Oscillations and DAPs are an essential substrate of ectopic burst discharge. Therefore, any consideration of the ways in which cellular regulation of ion channel synthesis and trafficking implement normal sensation and, when disrupted, bring about neuropathic pain must take into account the effects of this regulation on oscillations and bursting.

Neuropathic pain: what do we do with all these theories?

Only a generation ago there were few ideas as to what might cause neuropathic pain, and even fewer relevant data. In contrast, we can currently point to hundreds of distinct cellular changes that are triggered by nerve injury and that might be relevant to the emergence of pain symptomatology. The number may soon increase to thousands. It is essential, therefore, to redirect efforts towards the development of experimental strategies for testing which of these are essential parts of the pain process and which are tangential. In this paper I point out four such strategies: timing, deletion, prevention and genetic heterogeneity, and summarize how one neuropathic pain theory, the ectopic pacemaker hypothesis, holds up to scrutiny.

Association of kappa opioid receptor mRNA upregulation in dorsal root ganglia with mechanical allodynia in mice following nerve injury

This study examined the contribution of nerve injury alone or nerve injury with signs of neuropathic pain to alteration of kappa opioid receptor (KOR) mRNA expression. Two groups of mice, both of them were subjected to unilateral transection of the inferior and superior caudal trunks at the S1spinal nerve, were compared with respect to KOR mRNA expression by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction. One group showed exclusive pain behavior (PB+) as mechanical allodynia, and the other group exhibited no enhanced sensitivity to innocuous mechanical stimulation to the tail (PB-). Expression of total KOR and variants B and C mRNA increased ipsilaterally in dorsal root ganglia (DRG) of PB+ mice, whereas KOR variant A mRNA was not detected in DRG. These results show that KOR mRNA expression differs between PB+ and PB- groups of mice after nerve injury, and suggest an association of KOR expression with mechanical allodynia.