Comparison of carotid vessel wall area measurements using three different contrast-weighted black blood MR imaging techniques

Evaluation of carotid atherosclerotic plaque surface characteristics utilizing simultaneous noncontrast angiography and intraplaque hemorrhage (SNAP) technique

PURPOSE

To evaluate the feasibility of the Simultaneous Noncontrast Angiography and intraPlaque hemorrhage (SNAP) technique in identification of carotid plaque surface characteristics compared with the conventional multicontrast vessel wall imaging protocol.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Thirty symptomatic patients with carotid plaque were recruited and underwent carotid artery magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) (3.0T) using a conventional multicontrast protocol and SNAP sequence. As an intrinsic multicontrast sequence, SNAP could generate a gray blood reference (Ref) image set, a black blood corrected real (CR) image set, and a bright blood MR angiography (MRA) image set. A bright blood SNAP Ref2 image was implemented by combining Ref and MRA images for facilitating plaque surface characteristics evaluation. The presence/absence of calcification (CA), juxtaluminal calcification (JCA), and ulceration was assessed. The agreement between SNAP and multicontrast vessel wall protocol in identifying CA, JCA, and ulceration was analyzed using Cohen's kappa analysis. The interreader and intrareader reproducibility of SNAP imaging in identifying plaque surface characteristics was also assessed.

RESULTS

Good to excellent agreement was found between SNAP and conventional multicontrast protocol in identifying CA (κ = 0.74, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.54-0.93), JCA (κ = 0.81, 95% CI: 0.66-0.97), and ulceration (κ = 0.82, 95% CI: 0.65-0.99). In addition, excellent intrareader and interreader reproducibility was found for SNAP imaging in identification of CA, JCA, and ulceration.

CONCLUSION

SNAP imaging showed excellent agreement with multicontrast imaging and high reproducibility in identification of both JCA and ulceration, suggesting that SNAP imaging may be a time-efficient, alternative tool in identification of plaque surface characteristics in carotid arteries.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4 Technical Efficacy: Stage 1 J. Magn. Reson. Imaging 2018;47:634-639.

Systematic reviews and meta-analyses for more profitable strategies in peripheral artery disease

In the peripheral arteries, a thrombus superimposed on atherosclerosis contributes to the progression of peripheral artery disease (PAD), producing intermittent claudication (IC), ischemic necrosis, and, potentially, loss of the limb. PAD with IC is often undiagnosed and, in turn, undertreated. The low percentage of diagnosis (∼30%) in this setting of PAD is of particular concern because of the potential worsening of PAD (amputation) and the high risk of adverse vascular outcomes (vascular death, coronary artery disease, stroke). A Medline literature search of the highest-quality systematic reviews and meta-analyses of randomized controlled trials documents that, due to risk of bias, imprecision, and indirectness, the overall quality of the evidence concerning diagnostic tools and antithrombotic interventions in PAD is generally low. Areas of research emerge from the information collected. Appropriate treatments for PAD patients will only derive from ad-hoc studies. Innovative imaging techniques are needed to identify PAD subjects at the highest vascular risk. Whether IC unresponsive to physical exercise and smoking cessation identifies those with a heritable predisposition to more severe vascular events deserves to be addressed. Devising ways to improve prevention of vascular events in patients with PAD implies a co-ordinated approach in vascular medicine.

Experimental foundation for in vivo measurement of the elasticity of the aorta in computed tomography angiography

OBJECTIVE

This study was performed to determine the feasibility of measuring the elastic properties of the arterial wall in vivo. To prove this concept, elastic parameters were calculated from an aortic model of elastic behavior similar to a human aorta using computed tomography angiography (CTA) images.

METHODS

We first constructed an aortic model from polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS). This model was inserted into a pulsatile flow loop. The model was then placed inside a computed tomography scanner. To estimate the elasticity values, we measured the cross-sectional area and the pressure changes in the model during each phase of the simulated cardiac cycle. A discrete wavelet transform (DWT) algorithm was applied to the CTA data to calculate the geometric changes in the pulsatile model over a simulated cardiac cycle for various pulsatile rates and elasticity values of the PDMS material. The elastic modulus of the aortic model wall was derived from these geometric changes. The elastic moduli derived from the CTA data were compared with those obtained by testing strips of the same PDMS material in a tensile testing machine. Our two aortic models had elastic values at both extremes of those found in normal human aortas.

RESULTS

The results show a good comparison between the elastic values derived from the CTA data and those obtained in a tensile testing machine. In addition, the elasticity values were found to be independent of the pulsatile rate for mixing ratios of 6:1 and 9:1 (p = .12 and p = .22, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

The elastic modulus of a pulsatile aortic model may be measured by electrocardiographically-gated multi-detector CTA protocol. This preliminary study suggests the possibility of determining non-invasively the elastic properties of a living, functioning aorta using CTA data.

Impact of T2 decay on carotid artery wall thickness measurements

PURPOSE

To investigate the impact of T2 relaxation of the carotid wall on measurements of its thickness.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The common carotid artery wall was imaged using a spin echo sequence acquired at four echo times (17 ms to 68 ms) in 65 participants as part of VALIDATE study. Images were acquired transverse to the artery 1.5 cm proximal to the flow divider. Mean wall thickness, mean wall signal intensity, lumen area, and outer wall area were measured for each echo. Contours were also traced on the image from the fourth echo and then propagated to the images from the preceding echoes. This was repeated using the image from the first echo. Mean wall signal intensity measurements at the four echo times were fit to a mono-exponential decay curve to derive the mean T2 relaxation time for each set of contours.

RESULTS

Mean wall thickness decreased with increasing echo time, with an average thickness reduction of 8.6% between images acquired at the first and last echo times (TE) (0.93 mm at TE 17 ms versus 0.85 mm at TE 68 ms, P < 0.001). Average T2 relaxation time of the carotid wall decreased by 3% when the smaller contours from the last echo were used, which excluded the outer-most layer (54.3 ± 7.6 ms versus 52.7 ± 6.6 ms, P = 0.03).

CONCLUSION

Carotid wall thickness measurements decrease with echo time as expected by the fast T2 relaxation time of the outer-most layer, namely the adventitia. A short echo time is needed for thickness measurements to include adventitia, which plays an important role in plaque development.

Carotid artery disease and stroke: assessing risk with vessel wall MRI

Although MRI is widely used to diagnose stenotic carotid arteries, it also detects characteristics of the atherosclerotic plaque itself, including its size, composition, and activity. These features are emerging as additional risk factors for stroke that can be feasibly acquired clinically. This paper summarizes the state of evidence for a clinical role for MRI of carotid atherosclerosis.

Visualization of coronary wall atherosclerosis in asymptomatic subjects and patients with coronary artery disease using magnetic resonance imaging

BACKGROUND

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is sensitive to early atherosclerotic changes such as positive remodeling in patients with coronary artery disease (CAD). We assessed prevalence, quality, and extent of coronary atherosclerosis in a group of healthy subjects compared to patients with confirmed CAD.

METHODOLOGY

Twenty-two patients with confirmed CAD (15M, 7F, mean age 60.4 ± 10.4 years) and 26 healthy subjects without history of CAD (11M, 15F, mean age 56.1 ± 4.4 years) underwent MRI of the right coronary artery (RCA) and vessel wall (MR-CVW) on a clinical 1.5T MR-scanner. Wall thickness measurements of both groups were compared.

PRINCIPAL FINDINGS

Stenoses of the RCA (both < and ≥50% on CAG) were present in all patients. In 21/22 patients, stenoses detected at MRI corresponded to stenoses detected with conventional angiography. In 19/26 asymptomatic subjects, there was visible luminal narrowing in the MR luminography images. Fourteen of these subjects demonstrated corresponding increase in vessel wall thickness. In 4/26 asymptomatic subjects, vessel wall thickening without luminal narrowing was present. Maximum and mean wall thicknesses in patients were significantly higher (2.16 vs 1.92 mm, and 1.38 vs 1.22 mm, both p<0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

In this cohort of middle-aged individuals, both patients with stable angina and angiographically proven coronary artery disease, as well as age-matched asymptomatic subjects. exhibited coronary vessel wall thickening detectable with MR coronary vessel wall imaging. Maximum and mean wall thicknesses were significantly higher in patients. The vast majority of asymptomatic subjects had either positive remodeling without luminal narrowing, or non-significant stenosis.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

ClinicalTrials.gov NCT00456950.

Immobilized contrast-enhanced MRI: Gadolinium-based long-term MR contrast enhancement of the vein graft vessel wall

An implantable MR contrast agent that can be covalently immobilized on tissue during surgery has been developed. The rationale is that a durable increase in tissue contrast using an implantable contrast agent can enhance postsurgical tissue differentiation using MRI. For small-vessel (e.g., vein graft) MRI, the direct benefit of such permanent "labeling" of the vessel wall by modification of its relaxation properties is to achieve more efficient imaging. This efficiency can be realized as either increased contrast leading to more accurate delineation of vessel wall and lesion tissue boundaries, or, faster imaging without penalizing contrast-to-noise ratio, or a combination thereof. We demonstrate, for the first time, stable long-term MRI enhancement using such an exogenous contrast mechanism based on immobilizing a modified diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid gadolinium(3+) dihydrogen complex on a human vein using a covalent amide bond. Signal enhancement due to the covalently immobilized contrast agent is demonstrated for excised human vein specimens imaged at 3 T, and its long-term stability is demonstrated during a 4-month incubation period.

Imaging biomarkers of cardiovascular disease

Cardiovascular disease (CVD) is a leading cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide. Current clinical techniques that rely on stenosis measurement alone appear to be insufficient for risk prediction in atherosclerosis patients. Many novel imaging methods have been developed to study atherosclerosis progression and to identify new features that can predict future clinical risk. MRI of atherosclerotic vessel walls is one such method. It has the ability to noninvasively evaluate multiple biomarkers of the disease such as luminal stenosis, plaque burden, tissue composition and plaque activity. In addition, the accuracy of in vivo MRI has been validated against histology with high reproducibility, thus paving the way for application to epidemiological studies of disease pathogenesis and, by serial MRI, in monitoring the efficacy of therapeutic intervention. In this review, we describe the various MR techniques used to evaluate aspects of plaque progression, discuss imaging-based measurements (imaging biomarkers), and also detail their validation. The application of plaque MRI in clinical trials as well as emerging imaging techniques used to evaluate plaque compositional features and biological activities are also discussed.

Minimization of MR contrast weightings for the comprehensive evaluation of carotid atherosclerotic disease

OBJECTIVE

Multicontrast, high-resolution carotid magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has been validated with histology to quantify atherosclerotic plaque morphology and composition. For evaluating the lipid-rich necrotic core (LRNC) and fibrous cap, both of which are key elements in determining plaque stability, the combined pre- and postcontrast T1-weighted (T1W) sequences have been recently shown to have a higher reproducibility than other contrast weightings. In this study, we sought to determine whether contrast weightings beyond T1W (pre- and postcontrast) are necessary for comprehensive, quantitative, carotid plaque interpretation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Our HIPAA compliant study protocol was approved by the IRB and all participants gave written, informed consent. Sixty-five participants with carotid stenosis >50% detected by ultrasound underwent carotid MRI with a standard multicontrast protocol (time-of-flight [TOF], T1W, contrast-enhanced [CE]-T1W, proton density [PD], and T2W). For each subject, images were partitioned into 3 combinations of contrast weightings (CW): (1) 2CW: T1W and CE-T1W; (2) 3CW: T1W, CE-T1W, and TOF; and (3) 5CW: T1W, CE-T1W, TOF, PD, and T2W. Each CW set was interpreted by 2 reviewers, blinded to results of each of the other CW combinations, via consensus opinion. Wall, lumen, and total vessel volumes, along with mean wall thickness were recorded. The presence or absence of calcification, LRNC, intraplaque hemorrhage (IPH), and surface disruption was also documented.

RESULTS

Compared with 5CW, there was strong agreement in the parameters of plaque morphology for 2CW (intraclass correlation coefficient, 0.96-0.99) and 3CW (intraclass correlation coefficient, 0.97-1.00). Agreement with 5CW for the detection of plaque composition was stronger for 3CW compared with 2CW: Cohen's kappa, 0.59 versus 0.42 for calcification; 0.75 versus 0.47 for LRNC; 0.91 versus 0.88 for IPH; and 0.74 versus 0.34 for surface disruption. Using 5CW as the reference standard during receive-operating-characteristics analysis, 3CW compared with 2CW showed a larger area-under-the-curve for classifying the presence or absence of calcification (0.78 vs. 0.69), LRNC (0.98 vs. 0.69), and surface disruption (0.87 vs. 0.65), and similar area-under-the-curve in classifying IPH (0.96 vs. 0.94).

CONCLUSION

Comprehensive, quantitative carotid plaque interpretation can be performed with T1W, CE-T1W, and TOF sequences. Elimination of PD and T2W sequences from the carotid MRI protocol may result in a substantial reduction in scan time. The ability to perform plaque interpretation on images acquired within a clinically acceptable scan time may broaden the research utility of carotid MRI and increase translatability to clinical applications.

Quantification of carotid vessel wall and plaque thickness change using 3D ultrasound images

Quantitative measurements of carotid plaque burden progression or regression are important in monitoring patients and in evaluation of new treatment options. 3D ultrasound (US) has been used to monitor the progression or regression of carotid artery plaques. This paper reports on the development and application of a method used to analyze changes in carotid plaque morphology from 3D US. The technique used is evaluated using manual segmentations of the arterial wall and lumen from 3D US images acquired in two imaging sessions. To reduce the effect of segmentation variability, segmentation was performed five times each for the wall and lumen. The mean wall and lumen surfaces, computed from this set of five segmentations, were matched on a point-by-point basis, and the distance between each pair of corresponding points served as an estimate of the combined thickness of the plaque, intima, and media (vessel-wall-plus-plaque thickness or VWT). The VWT maps associated with the first and the second US images were compared and the differences of VWT were obtained at each vertex. The 3D VWT and VWT-Change maps may provide important information for evaluating the location of plaque progression in relation to the localized disturbances of flow pattern, such as oscillatory shear, and regression in response to medical treatments.

Serial MRI of carotid plaque burden: influence of subject repositioning on measurement precision

MRI has the potential to track changes in the size of carotid atherosclerotic plaques for patient monitoring or in clinical trials. For either application, highly reproducible serial measurements are critical for drawing accurate conclusions. This study investigates the role of inconsistent repositioning of the artery from scan to scan in overall measurement variability. The total variability of cross-sectional area measurements is modeled as a combination of variability due to segmentation differences, changes in orientation of the artery, and longitudinal offsets of the image location. Model parameters were generated using measurements from carotid arteries imaged in vivo. Comparison with actual reproducibility measurements for the lumen and outer wall boundaries showed that the errors were accurately predicted by the model, including a strong correlation between lumen and wall measurement differences. Orientation variability was the single most important factor that affected reproducibility, which suggests that methods are needed to obtain consistent orientation of the artery relative to the image plane.

Three-dimensional Black-Blood MR Imaging of Carotid Arteries with Segmented Steady-State Free Precession: Initial Experience

This HIPAA-compliant study had institutional review board approval. Informed consent was obtained. The purpose was to prospectively evaluate a segmented three-dimensional (3D) double inversion recovery (DIR)-prepared steady-state free precession (SSFP) magnetic resonance (MR) imaging sequence for fast high-spatial-resolution black-blood carotid arterial wall imaging. Carotid wall-lumen contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) obtained with this sequence was compared with those obtained with two-dimensional (2D) single- and multisection black-blood fast spin-echo (SE) sequences. MR imaging of both carotid artery bifurcations over 3 cm of transverse coverage was performed in eight volunteers (seven men, one woman; age range, 26-56 years) with no known history of carotid artery disease. Adjusted for section thickness and imaging time per section, higher effective mean CNR was achieved with segmented 3D DIR-prepared SSFP than with single-section 2D DIR-prepared fast SE or multisection 2D saturation-band fast SE (P < .05). Segmented 3D DIR-prepared SSFP enables black-blood carotid arterial wall MR imaging with contiguous thin-section coverage and greater imaging speed and effective CNR than conventional 2D fast SE techniques.

Short-term tracking of atherosclerosis in operated and unoperated human carotid arteries by high resolution magnetic resonance imaging

INTRODUCTION

A previous study demonstrated the efficacy of a phospholipid (PL) complexed with a protein (apoAI Milano) in causing 4.6% regression of atheroma volume as assessed by intravascular ultrasonography (IVUS) in a group of 47 patients with carotid atherosclerosis. The results of this study raised the question of whether the phospholipid alone could produce a similar effect.

METHODS

To answer this question a trial of 39 subjects at five sites was designed. Patients with > 15% stenosis of at least one carotid artery as determined by US underwent intravenous PL (200 mg/kg) or placebo infusions weekly for 8 weeks. The wall/outer wall ratio, percent lipid-rich/necrotic core, and percent calcification were measured as a proportion of the vessel wall by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) at 0, 4, 8, and 14 weeks.

RESULTS

The substudy of seven of these patients evaluated at our site allowed comparison of the dimensions of five unoperated-unoperated carotid pairs and two operated-unoperated pairs. In patient 1, MRI measurements on unoperated left and unoperated right carotids tracked almost identically over the 14-week study. Both carotids showed similar increases in the volumes of the total wall (+61% vs. 56%), the normal wall (+51% vs. 49%), and plaque (+99% vs. 85%). Both carotids showed similar decreases in lumen volume (-11% vs. -17%). The other four unoperated-unoperated carotid pairs showed dimensional changes over 14 weeks similar to those of patient 1. In patient 2, who underwent left endarterectomy, the operated carotid had a total artery volume of 2300 mm(3), about twofold greater than the unoperated carotid (1100 mm(3)). Operated and unoperated carotid measurements tracked in parallel. The unoperated carotid had volume increases of 25% (+200 mm(3)) in total wall, +19% (+100 mm(3)) in normal wall, and 43% (+75 mm(3)) in plaque. The operated carotid lumen showed no significant changes. Patient 7, who also underwent left endarterectomy, exhibited carotid changes similar to those of patient 2.

CONCLUSIONS

Individual unoperated carotid pairs have volumes that track almost identically. In unilateral operated carotid pairs, the operated artery has 1.5- to 2.0-fold greater volume than unoperated carotids. In each of our two unilaterally operated patients, the operated carotid had decreased plaque volume (-3%, -58%), whereas the unoperated carotid had increased plaque volume (+43%, +7%). Among the five unoperated patients, one pair had 85%/99% increase in plaque volume; one pair had -15%/-10% decrease; and the other three pairs had intermediate changes. This study provides additional support to the view that unoperated human carotid arteries are bilaterally symmetrical.

Automated measurement of mean wall thickness in the common carotid artery by MRI: a comparison to intima-media thickness by B-mode ultrasound

PURPOSE

To determine whether the mean wall thickness (MWT) of the common carotid artery (CCA) measured by MRI is comparable to B-mode ultrasound (US) measurement of the intima-media thickness (IMT), an established marker of cardiovascular risk.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

As part of the two-year ORION trial, 43 patients with 16-79% stenosis by duplex US underwent high-resolution MRI and B-mode US examinations of their carotid arteries. Twenty-eight carotid arteries were identified as having both sufficient proximal coverage and adequate image quality of the CCA on MRI and a corresponding US. A novel algorithm utilizing statistical shape modeling was developed to automatically detect and measure MWT to within subpixel accuracy. The interrater and interscan reproducibility of the MWT measurement was computed as the root-mean-square (RMS) difference. The MWT and IMT measurements were compared via the Pearson correlation coefficient.

RESULTS

The MWT and IMT had a high Pearson correlation coefficient (r = 0.93; P < 0.001). The RMS difference between readers and between scans was 0.01 mm and 0.04 mm, respectively. Our automated algorithm correctly identified the lumen in 28 cases (100%) and the outer-wall boundary in 26 cases (93%).

CONCLUSION

Automated measurements of the MWT by MRI are reproducible and have a high correlation with the IMT by B-mode US.

Effect of contrast enhancement on the measurement of carotid arterial lumen and wall volume using MRI

PURPOSE

To investigate whether gadolinium (Gd)-based contrast enhancement (CE) affects high-resolution magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) measurements of carotid arterial wall volume.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The common carotid artery (CCA), bifurcation, and internal carotid artery (ICA) of 50 consecutive patients were imaged using 1.5T MRI. T1-weighted (T1W) images were obtained before and after Gd administration. Pre- and post-CE measurements were compared among different arterial locations of the CCA, bifurcation, and ICA, and among different atherosclerotic lesion types.

RESULTS

In comparison to pre-CE T1W images, post-CE images showed an increase in the apparent wall volume measurement of 28.2% (108.7 mm3 vs. 84.7 mm3, P < 0.001). The post-CE measurement increases in wall volume for the CCA, bifurcation, and ICA were 26.7%, 29.2%, and 28.0%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Gd CE causes a significant increase in the apparent volume of the carotid wall throughout multiple carotid artery locations, which may be associated with improved visibility or neovascularization.

Thematic review series: Patient-Oriented Research. Imaging atherosclerosis: state of the art

The ability to image obstructive arterial disease brought about a revolution in clinical cardiovascular care; the development of newer technologies that image arterial wall thicknesses, areas, volumes, and composition allows valid imaging of atherosclerosis for the first time. Development of noninvasive imaging of atherosclerosis has further led to a quantum shift in research in the field by enabling the study of asymptomatic populations and thus allowing investigators to focus on preclinical disease without the many biases associated with the study of symptomatic patients. These noninvasive investigations have broad implications for clinical care as well. Coronary angiography, computed tomographic (CT) imaging of coronary calcium, intravascular ultrasound, multidetector CT angiography, B mode ultrasound of the carotid arteries, and MRI of the carotid arteries all have unique strengths and weaknesses for imaging atherosclerosis. Certain of these techniques are extremely useful as outcome variables for clinical trials, and others are uniquely useful as predictors of the risk of cardiovascular disease. All are informative in one way or another with regard to the role of plaque remodeling and composition in disease causation. CT and MRI technology are advancing very rapidly, and research and clinical uses of these imaging modalities promise to further advance our understanding of atherosclerosis and its prevention.

Spontaneous acute dissection of the internal carotid artery: high-resolution magnetic resonance imaging at 3.0 tesla with a dedicated surface coil

PURPOSE

Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) has become the method of choice in the evaluation of patients with suspected cervical artery dissection (CAD). However, reliable identification of acute CAD might be impaired by the limited spatial resolution of standard 1.5 T MRI. In this preliminary study, we implemented a multicontrast high-resolution noninvasive vessel wall imaging approach at 3.0 T in patients with spontaneous CAD.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Ten patients with CAD of the internal carotid artery (ICA) were included in the study. 3.0 T MRI (Gyroscan Intera, Philips) was acquired using a dedicated phased-array coil. MRI-protocol consisted of: (1) bright blood 3D inflow MRA (TR/TE/FA = 25 milliseconds/3.1 millisecond/16 degrees , 120 slices, reconstructed voxel size 0.3 x 0.3 x 0.8 mm); (2) black blood cardiac-gated water-selective T1w 3D spoiled GE (TR/TE/FA = 31 milliseconds/7.7 milliseconds/15 degrees , 36 slices, 0.3 x 0.3 x 1.0 mm); and (3) black blood cardiac triggered fat suppressed T2w TSE (TR/TE/ETL = 3 heart beats/44 milliseconds/7, 18 slices, 0.3 x 0.3 x 2 mm). Three observers in consensus performed image analysis. Special attention was paid to the integrity of the luminal and adventitial vessel boundary and the presence of a communicating intimal tear or flap.

RESULTS

3.0 T MRI provided excellent delineation of vessel lumen and vessel wall as a result of the nearly complete suppression of arterial blood signal. An intramural hematoma could be identified in all patients, confined between the luminal and adventitial vessel boundary. In no patient a communicating intimal tear could be identified. Clear distinction between intramural hematoma and thrombus was possible.

CONCLUSION

High-resolution vessel wall imaging in patients with acute CAD is feasible. The increased signal-to-noise ratio at 3.0 T can be invested to obtain a higher spatial resolution, permitting depiction of intimal and adventitial vessel wall boundary and the intramural hematoma in the diseased vessel segment. The morphologic information that is gained is helpful in the understanding of the underlying pathomechanismen of CAD.

Imaging of atherosclerosis using magnetic resonance: state of the art and future directions

Atherosclerosis is the leading cause of morbidity and mortality in industrialized societies, and its incidence is projected to increase in the future. Because the atherosclerotic process begins in the vessel wall, the focus of cardiovascular imaging is shifting from the arterial lumen to imaging of the vessel wall, with the goal of detecting preclinical atherosclerosis. MRI, because of its high resolution, three-dimensional capabilities, noninvasive nature, and capacity for soft tissue characterization, is emerging as an important modality to assess the atherosclerotic plaque burden in the arterial wall and can monitor atherosclerosis in different arterial beds, including the carotid arteries, aorta, and more recently, the coronary arteries. Furthermore, it has also been successfully utilized to monitor plaque regression following therapeutic interventions. Finally, the emergence of high-resolution MRI and development of sophisticated contrast agents offers tremendous promise for in vivo molecular imaging of the atherosclerotic plaque.

3D Cryo-Section/Imaging of Blood Vessel Lesions for Validation of MRI Data

Vascular disease is a leading cause of death and disability in the western world. Diagnosis and staging of atherosclerosis is a challenge, especially with regards to the identification of plaque vulnerability. We are developing imaging methods based upon MRI and intravascular microcoils. In order to rigorously validate our MRI imaging methods and algorithms, we have developed a new cryo-imaging system that allows one to alternately section and image the block face of tissue. We obtain 3D pathology of vessel segments excised from cadaver and we characterize the tissues of atheroma using episcopic autofluorescence and bright field microscopy images. After embedding the vessel, the block is frozen, and block face microscopic images are taken every 200µm with an image resolution of 30µm×30µm. The series of images is then corrected for uneven illumination, serially registered to one another, and the 3D vessel segment is reconstructed. Some sections are recovered and processed with histological staining for validation. Seven tissue types can be readily identified from the cryo-images: necrotic core, calcification, lipid pool, media, adventitia, fibrosis, thrombus, and normal intima. Since the whole vessel segment is available, we could register 3D data to images from MR, or other modalities, for validation. In addition, visualization tools such as multi-planar reformatting 3D rendering can be used to study 3D plaque morphology, in microscopic detail.

Evaluation of carotid artery wall volume measurement using novel semiautomated analysis software

PURPOSE

To evaluate semiautomated analysis software for measuring the total carotid arterial wall volume (TWV) as a measure of atheroma burden.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Semiautomated-software and manual analyses of TWV measured by cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) were compared in two phantom models, 10 subjects with no known carotid artery disease, and eight subjects with known carotid disease. The subjects were scanned twice for reproducibility.

RESULTS

In subjects with no known carotid disease, semiautomated analysis of 98% of slices showed an improved interstudy coefficient of variation (COV) compared to manual analysis of 50% of slices (4.0% vs. 6.2%, P = 0.02). The proportion of matched cross-sectional slices usable for TWV measurement was superior (99% vs. 49%, P = 0.005) and the median analysis time was shorter (31 minutes vs. 90 minutes, P < 0.001) using the semiautomated software. In subjects with known carotid disease, semiautomated (99% of slices) and manual (56% of slices) analyses had comparable interstudy COVs (4.1% vs. 3.9%, P = 0.01). However, the proportion of matched cross-sectional slices usable for TWV measurement was greater using semiautomated contouring (96% vs. 56%, P = 0.01).

CONCLUSION

Carotid CMR measurement of TWV using novel semiautomated analysis software shows good reproducibility, enables greater coverage of arterial vessel wall length, and is considerably faster compared to manual contouring.

Comparison of 15 different stents in superficial femoral arteries by high resolution MRI ex vivo and in vivo

PURPOSE

To evaluate the MRI compatibility of 15 different commercially available, new generation, U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved stents suitable for deployment in superficial femoral arteries (SFAs), and to identify the ones that permit MRI to visualize the wall and lumen of stented arteries with sufficient spatial and contrast resolution to quantify restenosis after stent placement.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 13 nitinol stents and two stainless-steel stents were placed in excised cadaveric SFAs and imaged by MRI at 1.5 T ex vivo. The images were evaluated qualitatively for the presence of artifacts and for the effects of the stent on image contrast, and quantitatively for the effect on signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of the lumen of the artery inside the stent compared to the SNR of the fluid outside the artery. A nitinol stent was placed in the SFA of a 60-year-old man and imaged at 1.5 T in vivo.

RESULTS

Both the vessel wall and the lumen could be visualized in cadaveric SFAs containing either the Absolute nitinol stent, the Dynalink nitinol stent, or the aSpire nitinol-covered stent. Their inside stent/outside stent SNR was 0.7, 0.8, and 0.8, respectively. The other 10 nitinol stents tested obscured the lumen but did not cause major image shape artifacts. Both stainless-steel stents tested, the WallGraft and WallStent, completely obscured the lumen and caused significant distortion of the image shapes. When the Dynalink stent was inserted into a highly stenosed SFA in vivo, the image showed a dark expanded eccentric lumen, circumscribed by a medium intensity band containing the stent.

CONCLUSION

MRI can be used to visualize both the lumen and wall of SFAs containing selected nitinol stents ex vivo and in vivo. These results suggest that MRI can be used to monitor restenosis in stents placed in the femoral arterial bed.

Tracking regression and progression of atherosclerosis in human carotid arteries using high-resolution magnetic resonance imaging

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) can accurately and reproducibly measure the volume of atherosclerotic plaque in human carotid arteries. Atherosclerotic plaques may either progress or regress over time, depending on individual risk factors and treatment regimens. This study was designed to determine if regression or progression of human carotid atherosclerosis in patients receiving statin therapy over 24 months can be detected by high-resolution MRI.

METHODS

In 11 subjects who had undergone unilateral carotid endarterectomy and were on statin therapy, volumes for total carotid artery, concentric wall (normal wall), eccentric wall (plaque), and lumen were quantified at 0, 16 and 24 months using a 1.5-T human imager equipped with 6-cm phased array coils.

RESULTS

The interobserver mean coefficient of variation (CV) was lowest for the lumen volume (3.1%) and highest for the plaque volume (9.8%). The interscan mean CV was lowest for the total artery volume (3.2%) and highest for the plaque volume (9.9%). As much as 26% regression and 35% progression were observed in individual subject's carotid artery eccentric wall (plaque) volumes over time. Mean eccentric wall volume increased 5% by 16 months and 8% by 24 months. Mean total wall volume increased slightly at both 16 and 24 months (+1.2% and +1.8%).

CONCLUSIONS

High-resolution MRI provides a noninvasive reproducible method of tracking changes in carotid atherosclerosis. This pilot study detected changes in individual subjects at both 16 and 24 months. MRI tracking of changes in atherosclerotic plaques should prove useful in assessing vascular disease risk and monitoring the efficacy of interventions designed to induce regression or retard progression.

Interstudy reproducibility of three-dimensional volume-selective fast spin echo magnetic resonance for quantifying carotid artery wall volume

PURPOSE

To assess the interstudy reproducibility of a three-dimensional volume-selective, fast spin echo (FSE) magnetic resonance technique for the assessment of carotid artery wall volume, which is a marker for total carotid plaque volume.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Interstudy reproducibility was evaluated in 10 subjects with evidence of carotid artery atherosclerotic disease on carotid Doppler ultrasonography. Subjects were scanned twice with an interscan time of one hour to four days. The carotid artery was imaged in cross-section, and the total carotid arterial wall volume (TWV) was calculated by subtraction of the total carotid lumen volume from the total outer carotid vessel volume.

RESULTS

The mean carotid TWV for the scans was 741 and 734 mm3, respectively, with no significant difference (mean difference 7 mm3; P = 0.5). The time for each study was approximately 20 minutes. The standard deviation of the differences between the measurements was 33 mm3, yielding an interstudy coefficient of variation of 4.4%. Sample size calculations showed that 16 patients would enable this difference in plaque volume over time to be detected with 80% power at a P value of 0.05.

CONCLUSION

Volumetric analysis with CMR of carotid artery plaques using a three-dimensional volume-selective FSE is efficient with good interstudy reproducibility, and is well suited for longitudinal studies of progression of carotid atheroma with reasonable sample sizes.

MRI of atherosclerosis

The emergence of high-resolution, rapid imaging methods has enabled MRI to noninvasively image the fine internal structure of atherosclerotic artery walls. This capability has, in turn, captured the interest of clinicians, who see it as an opportunity to assess disease severity based on the characteristics of atherosclerotic lesions themselves, rather than only their effects on the vessel lumen. MRI of atherosclerosis thus has the potential to be used in medical treatment decisions or to assess the effects of experimental treatment options. Given this potential, a number of research groups have been investigating MRI of atherosclerosis in an effort to establish the ability of MRI to determine atherosclerotic plaque burden, detect plaque composition, and ultimately identify vulnerable plaque before it leads to a clinical event. In this review, the current state of the art is summarized for the three primary vessel targets: the carotid artery, the aorta, and the coronary arteries.

Relationship between arterial stiffness and subclinical aortic atherosclerosis

BACKGROUND

Noninvasive measures of arterial compliance may be useful for the detection of subclinical atherosclerosis.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Measures of calf and thigh arterial compliance (MaxV50) were recorded in 267 subjects who also underwent MRI of the distal aorta to quantify distal aorta atherosclerosis. The average of calf and thigh MaxV50 was strongly predictive of extent of aortic atherosclerosis and risk of being in the top quartile of aortic atherosclerosis after adjustment for the Framingham Coronary Risk Score (FCRS) or the combination of the FCRS and C-reactive protein (P<0.0001). The areas under the receiver operating curves predicting the top quartile of gender-specific aortic atherosclerosis were 0.57, 0.60, and 0.75 for models containing the FCRS, the FCRS and C-reactive protein, and the FCRS, C-reactive protein, and the average of calf and thigh MaxV50.

CONCLUSIONS

Lower-extremity arterial compliance may identify subjects with extensive subclinical atherosclerosis. Further studies examining the potential value of arterial stiffness as a screening tool to guide initiation of more aggressive preventive interventions are warranted.

Quantification of multicontrast vascular MR images with NLSnake, an active contour model: In vitro validation and in vivo evaluation

Vessel-wall measurements from multicontrast MRI provide information on plaque structure and evolution. This requires the extraction of numerous contours. In this work a contour-extraction method is proposed that uses an active contour model (NLSnake) adapted for a wide range of MR vascular images. This new method employs length normalization for the purpose of deformation computation and offers the advantages of simplified parameter tuning, fast convergence, and minimal user interaction. The model can be initialized far from the boundaries of the region to be segmented, even by only one pixel. The accuracy and reproducibility of NLSnake endoluminal contours were assessed on vascular phantom MR angiography (MRA) and high-resolution in vitro MR images of rabbit aorta. An in vivo evaluation was performed on rabbit and clinical data for both internal and external vessel-wall contours. In phantoms with 95% stenoses, NLSnake measured 94.3% +/- 3.8%, and the accuracy was even better for milder stenoses. In the images of rabbit aorta, variability between NLSnake and experts was less than interobserver variability, while the maximum intravariability of NLSnake was equal to 1.25%. In conclusion, the NLSnake technique successfully quantified the vessel lumen in multicontrast MR images using constant parameters.

Triple contrast technique for black blood imaging with double inversion preparation

This work reports on the development of a pulse sequence to simultaneously acquire proton density, T(1), and T(2) weighted images in a single magnetization prepared fast spin echo acquisition. The technique is based upon the application of a magnetization preparation consisting of a global inversion followed by slice-selective 180 degrees and 90 degrees pulses to prepare the signal of specific slices. Slices are acquired in an interleaved manner with time delays appropriate for the desired image contrasts. Data acquisition is repeated for all combinations of slice interleaving covering the region of interest until images from all slice locations have been acquired with all desired image contrasts. The multiple image contrasts obtained with this technique should be useful in applications where discrimination between different types of tissue components is desired, such as in the analysis of plaque in cervical carotid artery disease.

Accuracy and uniqueness of three in vivo measurements of atherosclerotic carotid plaque morphology with black blood MRI

High-resolution MRI provides unique information about morphology of atherosclerotic carotid plaque. In this study, the accuracy and precision of measurements of carotid plaque burden and lumen narrowing were determined for in vivo black blood MRI assessment with respect to ex vivo MRI in a group of 37 atherosclerosis patients who underwent carotid endarterectomy (CEA). Three different plaque measures were compared between paired in vivo and ex vivo MR images: maximum wall area (MWA), minimum lumen area (mLA), and wall volume (WV). MWA and WV are measures of plaque burden, while mLA is a measure of lumen narrowing. The matched in vivo and ex vivo measurements showed good agreement (the correlation coefficients for in/ex vivo WV, MWA, and mLA were 0.92, 0.91, 0.90, respectively) with predictable bias. This study indicates that in vivo black blood MRI can be used to directly estimate the morphology of the plaque. Comparison of the three plaque measures showed that mLA and MWA or WV provide different information regarding the atherosclerotic lesions (the correlation coefficients between mLA and MWA or WV were less than 0.3). Black blood MRI technique is a potentially powerful clinical tool to characterize the severity of atherosclerotic plaque. It can provide accurate measurements on different aspects of the plaque, from plaque burden to lumen narrowing.

Measurement of carotid wall volume and maximum area with contrast-enhanced 3D MR imaging: initial observations

PURPOSE

To investigate whether postcontrast three-dimensional (3D) magnetic resonance (MR) imaging would yield more accurate measurement of carotid artery wall volume and maximum wall area, which are both measures of plaque burden, than precontrast 3D MR imaging.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Eleven consecutive patients scheduled to undergo carotid endarterectomy were recruited for the study. A 3D fast gradient-recalled-echo sequence was applied to acquire both precontrast and postcontrast images of the carotid artery wall. The same sequence was used to image the ex vivo excised plaque as a reference for measurement of carotid wall volume and maximum wall area.

RESULTS

The mean difference in maximum wall area between the precontrast in vivo measurements and the ex vivo measurements (mean +/- SD, 18.22 mm2 +/- 15.61) was significantly larger than that between the postcontrast in vivo measurements and the ex vivo measurements (12.33 mm2 +/- 14.49) (P =.02). The difference in wall volume between the precontrast in vivo measurements and the ex vivo measurements (41.81 mm3 +/- 36.51) was larger than that between the postcontrast in vivo measurements and the ex vivo measurements (32.73 mm3 +/- 35.00) (P =.004). Postcontrast images yielded better correlation with ex vivo images than did precontrast images, in both carotid luminal area (R = 0.88 for postcontrast images, R = 0.80 for precontrast images) and outer wall boundary area (R = 0.79 for postcontrast images, R = 0.71 for precontrast images) measurements.

CONCLUSION

Postcontrast 3D MR imaging may be useful in the measurement of carotid artery plaque burden.

Carotid atherosclerotic wall imaging by MRI

High spatial resolution magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is one of the most promising modalities for visualizing the carotid atherosclerotic plaque. MR allows direct visualization of the diseased vessel wall, is capable of characterizing plaque morphology, and can potentially monitor progression of the disease. Though ultrasound and angiography have been the principal methods for determining the severity of carotid atherosclerosis and the need for endarterectomy, these methods only measure percentage of vessel stenosis. There is strong evidence that this is not the best indicator for assessing clinical risk. Improved imaging techniques are therefore needed to reliably identify the high-risk plaques that lead to cerebrovascular events. This article focuses on the current state-of-the-art in MR carotid atherosclerotic plaque imaging to evaluate plaque morphology and composition.

CT angiography and MR angiography in the evaluation of extracranial carotid vascular disease

CTA and MRA techniques likely will continue to increase in use in the evaluation of the extracranial cerebrovascular system. The increasing reliance on noninvasive tests mirrors an overall concern with the risks and costs of more invasive examinations. Given the rapid development of the computer technology, data acquisition, and reconstruction algorithms in the past few years, it is apparent that CTA and MRA also will continue to improve.