Effect of collateral vessels on prognosis in patients with one vessel coronary artery disease

Prognostic impact of collaterals in patients with a coronary chronic total occlusion: A meta-analysis of over 3,000 patients

OBJECTIVES

To assess the prognostic implications of the degree of coronary collaterals on outcomes in patients with a CTO.

BACKGROUND

Coronary chronic total occlusions (CTO) are identified frequently in patients undergoing coronary angiography and have been associated with poorer prognosis. Whether the degree of coronary collaterals, the hallmark of CTOs impacts prognosis, is unknown.

METHODS

A search of EMBASE, MEDLINE, and Cochrane Library was conducted to identify studies reporting on coronary collaterals and risk of all-cause mortality, acute myocardial infarction (AMI) and successful percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI). Patients with Rentrop grade 0 or 1 collaterals were defined as poor collaterals, while Rentrop grade 2 or 3 were defined as robust collaterals.

RESULTS

Twelve studies with a total of 3,369 were included. Patients with robust collaterals did not have lower rates of AMI (OR: 0.89, 95%CI: 0.39-2.04) or lower rates of all-cause mortality (OR: 0.81, 95% CI: 0.42-1.58), however were more likely to have successful PCI (OR: 4.04, 95%CI: 1.10-14.85).

CONCLUSION

The presence of robust collaterals is not associated with lower rates of AMI or mortality, but does increase the likelihood of successful CTO PCI. These results have importance implications with respect to the indications for CTO PCI as well as selecting appropriate patients to undergo the procedure.

Exercise training and peripheral arterial disease

Peripheral arterial disease (PAD) is a common vascular disease that reduces blood flow capacity to the legs of patients. PAD leads to exercise intolerance that can progress in severity to greatly limit mobility, and in advanced cases leads to frank ischemia with pain at rest. It is estimated that 12 to 15 million people in the United States are diagnosed with PAD, with a much larger population that is undiagnosed. The presence of PAD predicts a 50% to 1500% increase in morbidity and mortality, depending on severity. Treatment of patients with PAD is limited to modification of cardiovascular disease risk factors, pharmacological intervention, surgery, and exercise therapy. Extended exercise programs that involve walking approximately five times per week, at a significant intensity that requires frequent rest periods, are most significant. Preclinical studies and virtually all clinical trials demonstrate the benefits of exercise therapy, including improved walking tolerance, modified inflammatory/hemostatic markers, enhanced vasoresponsiveness, adaptations within the limb (angiogenesis, arteriogenesis, and mitochondrial synthesis) that enhance oxygen delivery and metabolic responses, potentially delayed progression of the disease, enhanced quality of life indices, and extended longevity. A synthesis is provided as to how these adaptations can develop in the context of our current state of knowledge and events known to be orchestrated by exercise. The benefits are so compelling that exercise prescription should be an essential option presented to patients with PAD in the absence of contraindications. Obviously, selecting for a lifestyle pattern that includes enhanced physical activity prior to the advance of PAD limitations is the most desirable and beneficial.

The impact of the coronary collateral circulation on mortality: a meta-analysis

AIMS

The coronary collateral circulation as an alternative source of blood supply has shown benefits regarding several clinical endpoints in patients with myocardial infarction (MI) such as infarct size and left ventricular remodelling. However, its impact on hard endpoints such as mortality and its impact in patients with stable coronary artery disease (CAD) is more controversial. The purpose of this systematic review and meta-analysis was to explore the impact of collateral circulation on all-cause mortality.

METHODS AND RESULTS

We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, ISI Web of Science (2001 to 25 April 2011), and conference proceedings for studies evaluating the effect of coronary collaterals on mortality. Random-effect models were used to calculate summary risk ratios (RR). A total of 12 studies enrolling 6529 participants were included in this analysis. Patients with high collateralization showed a reduced mortality compared with those with low collateralization [RR 0.64 (95% confidence interval 0.45-0.91); P= 0.012]. The RR for 'high collateralization' in patients with stable CAD was 0.59 [0.39-0.89], P= 0.012, in patients with subacute MI it was 0.53 [0.15-1.92]; P= 0.335, and for patients with acute MI it was 0.63 [0.29-1.39]; P= 0.257.

CONCLUSIONS

In patients with CAD, the coronary collateralization has a relevant protective effect. Patients with a high collateralization have a 36% reduced mortality risk compared with patients with low collateralization.

Coronary collateral circulation

The occurrence and influence of coronary collateral circulation and obstruction of the supplying coronary arteries on left ventricular contractility, prevalence of myocardial infarction, and bicycle exercise ergometer test were studied in a random sample of 286 patients with angiographically documented coronary artery disease. Collaterals appeared increasingly in all three main coronary arteries with grade of obstruction. The highest prevalence of collaterals occurred in stenosis of the right coronary artery (60%), followed by the left descending artery (45%); they occurred least in the left circumflex artery (21%) (p less than 0.001). The frequency of intra-arterial collateral circulation was 42%, 11%, and 12%, respectively (p less than 0.001). With total occlusion of the left anterior descending coronary artery, 22% of the patients had normokinetic anterior and apical left ventricular wall when collaterals were present. More often, the inferior wall showed normal contraction with total occlusion of the right coronary artery and collaterals [52%, p less than 0.001 compared with left anterior descending artery (LAD)]. The prevalence of inferior myocardial infarction was 39%, with collateral circulation to the totally occluded right coronary artery. The respective prevalence of anterior infarction and total occlusion in the left coronary artery was 58% (p less than 0.02). The presence or absence of collaterals had no obvious influence on ST-segment response during bicycle ergometer test. In triple-vessel disease, peak work capacity was better when collaterals to LAD were not jeopardized (427 kpm) than when jeopardized (321 kpm) (p less than 0.02).

Computerized tabulation of cine coronary angiograms. Its implication for results of randomized trials

The quality of cine angiography is excellent in our days, and as a consequence some of the pitfalls encountered in previous randomized trials are not currently present. An example can be found in the CASS analysis of the reproducibility of coronary arteriographic reading by the Quality Control Committee Sessions: "There is an indication that different clinics" involved in the CASS trial "can reduce the variability between their readings by concerted effort to improve both the quality and the completeness of the angiographic examination." The introduction of electronic calipers to judge the severity of the obstruction can eliminate human errors. The computerized protocol has the disadvantage that it takes longer to tabulate cine coronary angiography and it will depend on its pattern, but it certainly will not be as long as filling in the CASS protocol. However, this effort is justified because it will enrich our knowledge of coronary arteriosclerosis. As a result, patients will be divided into proximal (1, 2, 12, 13, and 19), middle (mainly, 3, 14, and 20), and distal (remainder) segments. Sometimes midsegments can be important. For example, in the report from CASS related to the left main equivalent lesions, the 5-year survival rate was 48% if the obstruction on the left anterior descending was proximal and increased to 71% if it was more distal. Several randomized studies to compare PTCA with CABG as suggested by Gruentzig et al in 1979 are underway, and it is hoped that the data will be properly analyzed. However, if cine coronary angiography and the status of the left ventricle are not carefully tabulated (classification of patients into left main trunk or one-, two-, or three-vessel disease is not sufficient), the results of the randomized trials comparing PTCA with CABG will add more confusion instead of clarifying proper therapeutic implications.

Protective effect of collateral vessels during coronary angioplasty

To assess the potential protective role of collateral vessels 27 patients undergoing angioplasty of the left anterior descending coronary artery were studied by intravenous digital subtraction left ventriculography. Fifteen patients had no collateral vessels (group 1) and 12 had some degree of collateral supply (group 2). During balloon inflation ST segment elevation in group 1 (4.9 mm) was significantly greater than that in group 2 (0.9 mm). Similarly the reduction in left ventricular ejection fraction was significantly greater in group 1 (24%) than in group 2 (12%). Both the size of ST segment elevation and the fall in ejection fraction correlated inversely with the extent of the collateral supply (r = -0.680 and r = -0.446 respectively). During balloon occlusion of the anterior descending coronary artery the percentage shortening of the anterior and apical segments fell in both groups but apical shortening fell to a lesser extent in group 2. An additional reduction in anterobasal contraction was confined to group 1. Electrocardiographic and ventriculographic manifestations of ischaemia produced by balloon inflation during angioplasty are less pronounced when collateral vessels are present. This suggests that the collateral circulation can protect myocardium at risk of ischaemia after coronary occlusion.

Coronary wedge pressure in relation to spontaneously visible and recruitable collaterals

Coronary angiography demonstrates only collateral arteries that are already in use (spontaneously visible collaterals). Percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) provides an opportunity to uncover collaterals ready to become functional in case of occlusion of the recipient artery (recruitable collaterals). The incidence of recruitable collaterals and their relation to the distal pressure in the occluded artery (coronary wedge pressure) during a 30 sec or longer balloon occlusion was assessed in 57 coronary arteries of 49 patients undergoing PTCA for a proximal coronary stenosis or occlusion. Collateral to 75% of the arteries were present. Spontaneously visible collaterals were four times as frequent as recruitable collaterals. Coronary wedge pressure was significantly higher in arteries with spontaneously visible and recruitable collaterals (41 +/- 12 and 36 +/- 12 mm Hg, respectively) than in arteries without collaterals (18 +/- 4 mm Hg). A coronary wedge pressure of 30 mm Hg or higher was found exclusively in the presence of collaterals. Electrocardiographic changes during balloon occlusion were found more frequently with arteries without collaterals than with arteries with spontaneously visible or recruitable collaterals. Chest pain was more frequent in patients without collaterals or with recruitable collaterals than in those with spontaneously visible collaterals. Major in-hospital events occurred in three patients with collaterals, with a salutary influence of the collaterals in two. The coronary wedge pressure allows prediction of recruitable collaterals. Their clinical impact remains to be investigated in long-term studies on large patient populations.