Color-flow Doppler-assisted duplex imaging fails to detect ulceration in high-grade internal carotid artery stenosis

Advances in Noninvasive Carotid Wall Imaging with Ultrasound: A Narrative Review

Carotid atherosclerosis is a major cause for stroke, with significant associated disease burden morbidity and mortality in Western societies. Diagnosis, grading and follow-up of carotid atherosclerotic disease relies on imaging, specifically ultrasound (US) as the initial modality of choice. Traditionally, the degree of carotid lumen stenosis was considered the sole risk factor to predict brain ischemia. However, modern research has shown that a variety of other imaging biomarkers, such as plaque echogenicity, surface morphology, intraplaque neovascularization and vasa vasorum contribute to the risk for rupture of carotid atheromas with subsequent cerebrovascular events. Furthermore, the majority of embolic strokes of undetermined origin are probably arteriogenic and are associated with nonstenosing atheromas. Therefore, a state-of-the-art US scan of the carotid arteries should take advantage of recent technical developments and should provide detailed information about potential thrombogenic (/) and emboligenic arterial wall features. This manuscript reviews recent advances in ultrasonographic assessment of vulnerable carotid atherosclerotic plaques and highlights the fields of future development in multiparametric arterial wall imaging, in an attempt to convey the most important take-home messages for clinicians performing carotid ultrasound.

Imaging of the ulcerated carotid atherosclerotic plaque: a review of the literature

Abstract

Carotid atherosclerotic disease constitutes a major modern health problem whose diagnosis primarily relies on imaging. Grading of stenosis has been long used as the main factor for risk stratification and guiding of management. Nevertheless, increasing evidence has shown that additional plaque characteristics such as plaque composition and surface morphology play an important role in the occurrence of symptoms, justifying the term “vulnerable plaque”. Carotid plaque surface characteristics either in the form of surface irregularities or ulceration represent an important factor of vulnerability and are associated with the occurrence of neurologic symptoms. The delineation of the carotid plaque surface can be performed with virtually all imaging modalities including ultrasound, contrast-enhanced ultrasound, multi-detector computed tomography angiography, magnetic resonance angiography and the traditional reference method of angiography. These techniques have shown varying levels of diagnostic accuracy for the identification of ulcerated carotid plaques or plaque surface irregularities. As a consequence and given its high clinical significance, radiologists should be familiar with the various aspects of this entity, including its definition, classification, imaging findings on different imaging modalities and associations. The purpose of this review is to present the current literature regarding carotid plaque ulcerations and present illustrative images of ulcerated carotid plaques.

Teaching Points

• Plaque surface and ulceration represent risk factors for stroke in carotid disease.

• Characterisation of the plaque surface and ulcerations can be performed with every modality.

• US is the first-line modality for carotid disease and identification of ulcerations.

• The administration of microbubbles increases US accuracy for diagnosis of carotid ulceration.

• MDCTA and MRA are valuable for diagnosing ulceration and evaluating plaque composition.

Imaging Carotid Atherosclerosis Plaque Ulceration: Comparison of Advanced Imaging Modalities and Recent Developments

Atherosclerosis remains the leading cause of long-term mortality and morbidity worldwide, despite remarkable advancement in its management. Vulnerable atherosclerotic plaques are principally responsible for thromboembolic events in various arterial territories such as carotid, coronary, and lower limb vessels. Carotid plaque ulceration is one of the key features associated with plaque vulnerability and is considered a notable indicator of previous plaque rupture and possible future cerebrovascular events. Multiple imaging modalities have been used to assess the degree of carotid plaque ulceration for diagnostic and research purposes. Early diagnosis and management of carotid artery disease could prevent further cerebrovascular events. In this review, we highlight the merits and limitations of various imaging techniques for identifying plaque ulceration.

Molecular imaging of carotid plaque vulnerability

BACKGROUND

Carotid endarterectomy (CEA) has been shown to be beneficial in patients with high-grade symptomatic carotid artery stenosis. Patients with high-grade asymptomatic stenosis may only exceptionally benefit from CEA during periods of increased plaque vulnerability. Imaging modalities to characterize unstable, vulnerable plaques are strongly needed for better risk stratification in these patients.

SUMMARY

Contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS) is a novel and noninvasive technique capable to identify several surrogate markers of vulnerable carotid plaques. The use of specific ultrasound microbubbles allows a reliable detection of microulcerations due to an optimized visualization of the plaque-lumen border. As microbubbles are strictly intravascular tracers, the detection of individual microbubbles within the plaque corresponds to intraplaque neovessels. The accuracy of CEUS in the visualization of newly formed microvessels has been confirmed in histological studies on carotid endarterectomy specimens. Together with the formation of adventitial vasa vasorum, intraplaque neovascularization is a strong predictor for symptomatic disease. The phenomenon of late phase contrast enhancement is based on the adherence of microbubble-containing monocytes on inflamed endothelium. Recent studies suggest that late phase contrast enhancement may reflect endothelial inflammation or activation within carotid plaques. The development of conjugated microbubbles that bind to specific ligands such as thrombotic material or neovessels has led to the term 'molecular imaging'. CEUS with microbubbles targeted to P-selectin and VCAM-1, key molecules in leukocyte trafficking, was used to detect an inflammatory plaque phenotype, whereas microbubbles coupled to the VEGF-receptor may allow for a detection of neovascularization. Even though imaging with targeted microbubbles is yet in an experimental stage, this technique can visualize active plaque reorganization with increased vulnerability leading to generation of arterio-arterial embolism. Key Messages: The use of contrast-enhanced ultrasound can be recommended to assess atherosclerotic carotid lesions at risk for rupture. Prospective clinical studies are needed to validate the use of CEUS in patients with high risks of recurrent large artery strokes. In particular, this applies to the detection of intraplaque neovascularization, a well-established marker in preclinical and observational studies, while the clinical significance of late phase contrast enhancement still needs to be determined..

Quantitative assessment of carotid plaque surface irregularities and correlation to cerebrovascular symptoms

Background

The purpose of this study was to determine whether surface irregularities measured from ultrasound images of carotid artery plaques and quantified using a novel method, correlate with the presence of ipsilateral hemispheric cerebrovascular symptoms.

Methods

A plaque surface irregularity index (SII) was measured in 47 carotid artery plaques (32 subjects, stenosis range 10% -95%, 49% symptomatic) using ultrasound image sequences spanning several cardiac cycles. The differences in the distribution of SII in plaques with ipsilateral hemispheric symptoms versus those without symptoms and the correlation between the SII of plaques and the degrees of stenosis of the corresponding arteries were assessed. Diagnostic performance of plaque SII was evaluated on its own and in combination with the degree of stenosis.

Results

The mean SII was significantly greater for plaques with ipsilateral hemispheric symptoms (1.89 radians/mm) than for asymptomatic plaques (1.67 radians/mm, p = 0.03). There was no statistically significant association between the SII and the degree of stenosis (p = 0.30). SII predicted the presence of cerebrovascular symptoms with an accuracy of 66% (sensitivity 65%, specificity 67%) on its own and with an accuracy of 83% (sensitivity 96%, specificity 71%) in combination with the degree of stenosis.

Conclusions

Quantitative assessment of carotid plaque surface irregularities using a novel SII parameter correlates with the presence ipsilateral hemispheric cerebrovascular symptoms and may increase diagnostic performance beyond that provided by the degree of stenosis.

Ultrasonography of carotid plaque for the prevention of stroke

A carotid ultrasonography is a non-invasive technique that provides an accurate and reliable characterization of the broad spectrum of carotid arteriosclerosis, from the intima-media thickness to the atherosclerotic plaque. Carotid ultrasonography has become a useful tool for identifying patients at high risk of stroke and selecting those who can benefit most from revascularization therapies such as carotid endarterectomy and stenting. In addition to the degree of stenosis, plaque echomorphology has emerged in recent years as an important contributory factor to stroke risk. Changes in plaque echogenicity, as measured by the quantitative computer-assisted ultrasonography index, could be a marker of plaque instability as well as an indicator of plaque remodeling, thereby providing the means for monitoring anti-atherosclerosis drugs such as statins.

Usefulness of contrast-enhanced ultrasound for detection of carotid plaque ulceration in patients with symptomatic carotid atherosclerosis

Previous data have indicated that carotid plaque ulceration is a strong predictor of cerebrovascular events. Standard ultrasound and color Doppler ultrasound (CDUS) scans have poor diagnostic accuracy for the detection of carotid plaque ulceration. The aim of the present prospective study was to assess the value of contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS) scans for the detection of carotid plaque ulceration. The Institutional Ethics Committee approved the study protocol, and all patients provided informed consent. The patients had symptomatic stenosis of the internal carotid artery and underwent carotid computed tomographic angiography as part of their clinical evaluation. All patients underwent a CDUS examination in conjunction with CEUS. Carotid plaque ulceration was defined as the presence of ≥1 disruptions in the plaque-lumen border ≥1 × 1 mm. Carotid computed tomographic angiography was used as reference technique. The study population consisted of 20 patients (mean age 64 ± 9 years, 80% men), and 39 carotid arteries were included in the present analysis. Computed tomographic angiography demonstrated that the plaque surface was smooth in 15 (38%), irregular in 7 (18%) and ulcerated in 17 (44%) carotid arteries. The sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value of CDUS for the detection of ulceration was 29%, 73%, 54%, 46%, and 57%, respectively. The sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value of CEUS for the detection of ulceration was 88%, 59%, 72%, 63%, and 87%, respectively. CEUS had superior sensitivity and diagnostic accuracy for the assessment of carotid plaque ulceration compared with CDUS. CEUS improved the intrareader and inter-reader variability for the assessment of carotid plaque ulceration compared with CDUS. In conclusion, CEUS could be an additional method for the detection of carotid plaque ulceration. The role of CDUS for the assessment of carotid plaque ulceration seems limited.

New criteria for the sonographic diagnosis of a plaque ulcer in the extracranial carotid artery

OBJECTIVE

The diagnostic power of carotid sonography in detecting plaque ulcers may be inadequate when using the conventional criteria. We aimed to evaluate the usefulness of new criteria that we devised through a preliminary analysis of 50 endarterectomy cases before the present series.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Thirty carotid arteries of 30 consecutive patients who underwent endarterectomy (28 men; age range, 46-83 years) were studied. In the long- and short-axis B-mode images of carotid arteries, the concavity of the plaque surface and the surface echo intensity were carefully investigated. The conventional criteria stipulate a concavity larger than 2 × 2 mm with a well-defined back wall and flow reversal within the recess. Our new criteria specify a concavity in the plaque with the basal border echo weaker than that of the adjacent plaque surface, regardless of size. The final diagnosis was based on surgical and histologic findings.

RESULTS

Among the 30 carotid arteries, 14 arteries had 14 ulcers at surgery. Seventeen concavities were detected by sonography, and 12 of them, including six smaller than 2 × 2 mm, were truly ulcers. Two concavities with an echo intensity of the basal border equal to or greater than that of the adjacent surface were not true ulcers. Only two of 14 ulcers were not detected by sonography. The sensitivity and specificity of the conventional criteria were 35.7% and 75.0%, respectively, and those of our new criteria were 85.7% and 81.3%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Our new criteria for the sonographic diagnosis of plaque ulcer are more useful than the conventional ones.

Accuracy of a Novel Risk Index Combining Degree of Stenosis of the Carotid Artery and Plaque Surface Echogenicity

Background and Purpose—

The purpose of this study was to determine the accuracy of a risk index in symptomatic or asymptomatic carotid stenoses.

Methods—

Consecutive patients presenting 50% to 99% carotid stenoses were included. A semiautomated gray scale-based color mapping (red, yellow, and green) of the whole plaque and of its surface was achieved. Surface was defined as the region located between the lumen (Level 0) and, respectively, 0.5, 1, 1.5, and 2 mm. Risk index was based on a combination of degree of stenosis and the proportion of the red color (reflecting low echogenicity) on the surface or on the whole plaque.

Results—

There were 67 (36%) symptomatic and 117 (64%) asymptomatic carotid stenoses. Risk index values were higher among symptomatic stenoses (0.46 mean versus 0.29; P <0.0001); on receiver operating characteristic curves, risk index presented a stronger predictive power compared with degree of stenosis or surface echogenicity alone. Also, in a regression model including age, gender, degree of stenosis, surface echogenicity, gray median scale of the whole plaque, and risk index, risk index measured within the surface region located at 0.5 mm from the lumen was the only parameter significantly associated with the presence of symptoms (OR, 4.89; 95% CI, 2.7–8.7; P =0.0000002). The best criterion to differentiate between symptomatic and asymptomatic stenoses was a risk index value >0.36 (sensitivity and specificity of 78% and 65%, respectively).

Conclusions—

Risk index was significantly higher in the presence of symptoms and could therefore be a valuable tool to assess the clinical risk of a carotid plaque.

Stratifying risk: asymptomatic carotid disease

Stroke generates significant healthcare expenses and it is also a social and economic burden. The carotid artery atherosclerotic plaque instability is responsible for a third of all embolic strokes. The degree of stenosis has been deliberately used to justify carotid artery interventions in thousands of patients worldwide. However, the annual risk of stroke in asymptomatic carotid artery disease is low. Plaque morphology and its kinetics have gained ground to explain cerebrovascular and retinal embolic events. This review provides the readers with an insightful and critical analysis of the risk stratification of asymptomatic carotid artery disease in order to assist in selecting potential candidates for a carotid intervention.

Noninvasive imaging of the vulnerable atherosclerotic plaque

Atherosclerosis is an inflammatory disease, complicated by progressively increasing atherosclerotic plaques that eventually may rupture. Plaque rupture is a major cause of cardiovascular events, such as unstable angina, myocardial infarction, and stroke. A number of noninvasive imaging techniques have been developed to evaluate the vascular wall in an attempt to identify so-called vulnerable atherosclerotic plaques that are prone to rupture. The purpose of the present review is to systematically investigate the accuracy of noninvasive imaging techniques in the identification of plaque components and morphologic characteristics associated with plaque vulnerability, assessing their clinical and diagnostic value.

Asymptomatic carotid artery plaques: use of magnetic resonance imaging to characterize vulnerable plaques in 6 cases

BACKGROUND

Echography is a convenient and noninvasive method of characterizing carotid artery plaques. However, recent reports suggest that multisequential MR imaging may yield better data regarding the instability of asymptomatic carotid artery plaques. Therefore, the goal of the present study was to show the useful information for asymptomatic carotid artery plaque.

METHODS

A total of 6 patients (5 men, 1 woman; age range, 62-76 years; mean age, 69.2 years) with carotid artery plaques, which were detected during medical check-up using carotid MR angiography and/or echography, underwent MR imaging. Two-dimensional TOF MR angiography, T1WI, and fat-suppressed, cardiac-gated, black-blood proton density image, and T2WI were obtained with a 1.5-T MR imager. All plaques underwent carotid endarterectomy and histological examination.

RESULTS

The MR imaging demonstrated high signals in at least one modality in 4 of 7 plaques. In the remaining 3 patients, MR imaging detected partial-high signals, which corresponded to histologically confirmed partial lipid core or hemorrhagic components in the fibrous tissues The TOF MR imaging showed 2 cases of thin fibrous caps, and MR imaging also showed a large mural thrombus in 1 patient.

CONCLUSIONS

Magnetic resonance imaging was useful in characterizing factors associated with plaque instability in patients with asymptomatic carotid artery plaques and may help guide therapeutic strategies for asymptomatic carotid artery plaques.

High-resolution magnetic resonance imaging for detection of carotid plaques

OBJECTIVE

We report our experience using high-resolution magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to identify carotid plaques and also discuss these MRI findings while comparing them with carotid endarterectomy specimens.

METHODS

Eighteen carotid plaques from 17 different patients were observed using plaque MRI. The patients included 14 men and 3 women, aged 53 to 75 years (mean, 68.6 yr). Eight patients experienced a stroke and four patients experienced transient ischemic attack. The remaining five patients did not experience any neurological symptoms. Two-dimensional time-of-flight (TOF) MR angiography; T1-weighted imaging; fat-suppressed, cardiac gated, black-blood proton density imaging; and T2-weighted imaging were obtained with a 1.5-T MRI.

RESULTS

Symptomatic plaques showed either vast or partially dotted high signals for each contrast. The high signal intensity on time-of-flight and T2-weighted imaging predicted the instability of the plaques (100% sensitivity and specificity). In particular, time-of-flight imaging predicted intraplaque hemorrhaging with 100% sensitivity and 80% specificity. MRI revealed that three of four asymptomatic lesions were unstable plaques.

CONCLUSION

High-resolution MRI was able to detect various signal patterns related to the plaque components, and it was thus considered to be very useful for evaluating plaque instability. The application of plaque MRI therefore may positively affect the decision-making process when selecting optimal therapeutic strategies to treat with carotid plaques.

A Critical Appraisal of the Performance, Reporting, and Interpretation of Studies Comparing Carotid Plaque Imaging With Histology

Background and Purpose— Carotid plaque instability is an important determinant of stroke risk. There are now a number of different imaging techniques that provide information on carotid plaque morphology. However, it is unclear how they compare with one another or whether they can reliably assess plaque instability. Studies comparing imaging with pathology have shown highly variable results, even for similar imaging techniques. This may be because of variable pathology techniques rather than differences in imaging.

Methods— We performed a systematic review of studies that compared carotid imaging with histology of the excised plaque published between January 1995 and September 2004. We assessed the quality and comparability of these studies. In particular, we determined which histology methods were used and whether observer reproducibility of the histology assessment was reported.

Results— Among 73 eligible studies, histological methods were poorly reported and highly variable; 23% reported reproducibility data for imaging and only 12% reported reproducibility data for histology. Of 29 studies that reported quantitative results of blinded comparisons, there were methodological deficiencies and the results were highly variable. No study considered the extent to which the lack of reproducibility influenced the imaging-pathological correlations reported.

Conclusions— Pathological correlation in studies of carotid plaque imaging cannot be reliably interpreted or compared because of incomparable and poorly reported histology methods. We make recommendations for the performance, reporting, and interpretation of imaging–pathological correlation studies and highlight the need for consensus guidelines.

Noninvasive Evaluation of Carotid Artery Stenosis: Indications, Strategies, and Accuracy

Carotid artery occlusive disease is an important stroke risk factor and accounts for a significant proportion of stroke morbidity and mortality. In this article we survey the major clinical trials related to stroke risk in symptomatic and asymptomatic patients who have internal carotid artery (ICA) stenosis; techniques for noninvasive screening of ICA stenosis including ultrasound, MR angiography, and CT angiography; and evolving algorithms for ICA evaluation. We comment on current interest in plaque morphology as a risk factor for stroke.

Reproducibility of histological assessment of carotid plaque: implications for studies of carotid imaging

BACKGROUND

Thromboembolism from carotid plaque is an important cause of stroke. Identification of unstable plaque would therefore be clinically useful. Unfortunately, studies of carotid plaque imaging have shown poor agreement with histology. However, this may be due to inconsistent methods and the variability of assessments of carotid plaque histology, rather than inadequate imaging.

METHODS

We assessed the reproducibility of histological assessment in 60 plaques, and section-to-section variability along the length of 26 plaques.

RESULTS

Kappa values ranged from 0.35 to 0.89 and from 0.44 to 0.68, respectively, for intra- and inter-observer reproducibility. There was considerable section-to-section variability within plaques.

CONCLUSIONS

The accuracy of imaging of carotid plaque morphology will be underestimated unless variability in the histology assessment is taken into account.

Ultrasonographic analysis of arteriosclerotic plaques in the internal carotid artery

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to investigate whether ultrasonography can characterise plaque morphology and surfaces independent of the observer.

METHODS

Computer-assisted image analysis of the grey scales of B-mode scans from 15 patients with stenoses of the internal carotid artery was performed and compared with the histopathological reports. In vitro angioscopy, was used to visualise the plaque surfaces of the thromboendarterectomy specimens.

RESULT

Assessment of the internal plaque structure by ultrasound showed close agreement between the two observers (P<0.01) without correlation with the histopathological results. Ultrasonography was able to characterise the plaque surfaces in 93% of cases.

CONCLUSION

This investigation showed that standardised computer-assisted analysis of the internal plaque structure correlates less closely than histological investigation, but agrees closely with the surface structure of the plaque. The exclusive use of digital image processing and standardisation of the investigative technique are expected to provide even better results.

Major carotid plaque surface irregularities correlate with neurologic symptoms

PURPOSE

Many studies have linked carotid plaque surface irregularities with stroke risk, but this relationship has been obscured by the limited ability of available imaging modalities to resolve plaque surface morphology. To address this issue, we performed a prospective study correlating the presenting neurologic symptoms of patients with high-resolution magnetic resonance imaging (MRI; 200 microm) studies of ipsilateral plaque surface invaginations and ledges, lumen shape, and the location of the plaque bulk creating the stenosis.

METHODS

One hundred patients, 17 women and 83 men, 45 to 81 years old (mean, 68 years) underwent surgery. Forty-five patients had a transient ischemic attack (TIA) or stroke as the indication for surgery, and 55 patients had no symptoms. Angiograms were obtained in 50 patients. Carotid plaques were removed "en bloc" and placed in gadolinium doped saline for imaging in a Siemens Symphony, 1.5T scanner with a custom-built transmit-receive radiofrequency coil. The resulting slice thickness was 200 microm, with 200 microm by 200 microm in plane resolution. The MRI data and angiograms were reviewed by using National Institutes of Health Image software and read by consensus. A surface irregularity was categorized as a ledge or ulcer and measured by using electronic calipers. Luminal shape was determined at the point of maximal stenosis with a "slice" set at 90 degrees to the lumen axis. The location of the maximal stenosis was recorded. In the internal carotid artery, plaque bulk was designated to be on the flow divider wall or non-flow divider wall.

RESULTS

The mean maximal stenosis was 81.5% +/- 12.0%. Surface contour irregularities were found in 80 plaques. Thirty-five plaques were graded as having major surface contour irregularities, and 45 plaques were graded as having minor irregularities. There was a significant correlation between major surface irregularity and TIA or stroke (P <.01). Irregular plaques were identified with angiography, but the irregularity in size was underestimated (P <.01). Only 28% of plaques had circular lumens; 50% had elliptical lumens, and 22% had either crescentic or multi-lobular lumens. The maximal stenosis was located in the internal carotid artery in 82 plaques, the bifurcation in 17 plaques, and the common carotid artery in one plaque.

CONCLUSION

Surface irregularities were revealed by means of submillimeter resolution of the carotid plaques with MRI to be common, but only the presence of major irregularities correlated with the patient having TIA or stroke. Lumen shape and plaque location did not appear to predict stroke risk, but may effect imaging accuracy in determining the degree of stenosis. These data further define the relationship of plaque irregularity and cerebrovascular symptoms caused by atheroemboli.

Computer-assisted carotid plaque analysis: characteristics of plaques associated with cerebrovascular symptoms and cerebral infarction

OBJECTIVE

to correlate the echostructural characteristics of carotid plaques with neurological symptoms and cerebral infarcts.

MATERIALS

one hundred and five plaques were studied in 74 patients by colour-flow duplex ultrasound: 39 were symptomatic and 37 were associated with brain infarction on CT scanning.

METHODS

the images were digitalised for computer-assisted image standardisation and divided in homogenous (n=67) and heterogenous (n=38) groups. Parameters of the plaque image were analysed.

RESULTS

global echogenicity was significantly lower in symptomatic and in CT(+)plaques (p<0.05). For homogenous plaques, an echogenic cap (EC) was visualised in 8.3% of symptomatic vs. 33.9% of asymptomatic (p<0. 05) and in 7.7% for plaques that were CT(+)vs. 37.7% for CT(-)(p<0. 05). Surface disruption was visualised in 50% of symptomatic vs. 8. 5% of asymptomatic (p=0.002) and in 46% of CT(+)vs. 9.4% of CT(-)plaques (p=0.002). For heterogenous plaques, the echolucent region was juxtaluminal in 67% of symptomatic and CT(+)plaques vs. 33% in asymptomatic and CT(-)(p<0.01).

CONCLUSION

echolucent plaques are associated with a higher neurological risk. In homogenous plaques the absence of an echogenic cap and disruption of the plaque surface also correlates with symptoms. In heterogenous plaques, juxtaluminal location of the echolucent region is an additional marker of increased risk.

Interrater reliability of plaque morphology classification in patients with severe carotid artery stenosis

OBJECTIVE

Ultrasonographic assessment of carotid artery plaque morphology is widely used to identify patients at high risk for stroke. However, the reliability of plaque analysis in high-grade stenosis is uncertain. We determined the interrater reliability of sonographic plaque morphology analysis in patients with severe carotid artery stenosis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Duplex Doppler was performed on 114 patients with 80-99% stenosis of the internal carotid artery using a Siemens Quantum 2000 D with a handheld 7.5 MHz transducer. B-mode pictures with and without color coding were printed on a Sony color video printer UP-5000 W. Three raters independently evaluated plaque echolucency, heterogeneity, calcification, and surface structure. Interrater agreement was calculated by a jackknife procedure generating kappa values and two-sided 95% confidence intervals.

RESULTS

Kappa values and 95% confidence intervals were 0.05 (-0.07 to 0.16) for plaque surface structure, 0.15 (0.02 to 0.28) for plaque heterogeneity, 0.18 (0.09 to 0.29) for plaque echogenicity, and 0.29 (0.19 to 0.39) for plaque calcification. The upper bounds of all of the confidence intervals were below the 0.40 level suggested for minimal reliability.

CONCLUSION

The low interrater agreement indicated that unaided visual assessment of static B-mode pictures to assess plaque morphology in patients with severe carotid artery stenosis is not reliable. Other evaluation procedures and standardized criteria, as yet undeveloped, are needed to improve reliability.

Complete MR angiography and Doppler ultrasound as the sole imaging modalities prior to carotid endarterectomy

OBJECTIVE

To assess the combination of duplex Doppler ultrasound (DUS) and complete carotid magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) for the non-invasive imaging of carotid disease and their effect on outcomes. Determine inter-reader agreement of carotid MRA.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

One-hundred and ten carotid bifurcations were evaluated using DUS, 2D and 3D time-of-flight MRA from the aortic arch to the Circle of Willis in 55 patients. Percentage stenoses were determined by two blinded readers using standardized criteria. Clinical follow-up was by chart review.

RESULTS

Correlation of Doppler and MRA was excellent (r=0.903, P<0.001). Inter-reader agreement (K) for MRA was good: internal carotid artery (ICA) (0.750), external carotid artery (ECA) (0.674) and common carotid artery (CCA) (0.410). Differences in CCA readings were due to minor differences in categorizing lesions as CCA versus ICA or ECA. MRA and Doppler detected nine occluded ICAs. Two DUS occlusions had ICA flow by MRA; one due to a reconstituted precavernous ICA, one a near occluded vessel. Five patients (9%) had surgical management modified by MRA with four not having surgery: three distal ICA/Siphon occlusions and one less severe stenosis by MRA. One tandem lesion not visualized by DUS was surgically significant. Nine aortic arch abnormalities had no surgical impact, possibly due to small sample size. Of 41 endarterectomies, there were no complications from errors of diagnosis.

CONCLUSION

Carotid MRA correlates well with DUS with good inter-reader agreement. MRA confirms Doppler findings, expands anatomical information and identifies tandem lesions from the aortic arch to the Circle of Willis which can affect surgical management. This approach to carotid artery imaging appears to have no negative effect on surgical outcome.