Screening for hemochromatosis. A public health perspective

Hemochromatosis genotypes and risk of iron overload--a meta-analysis

PURPOSE

The incomplete phenotypic penetrance of high iron Fe genotypes in relation to hemochromatosis poses a practical problem in the interpretation of the genotyping results by clinicians. We carried out meta-analyses of the associations between hemochromatosis genotypes C282Y/C282Y, C282Y/H63D, C282Y/wild-type, H63D/H63D, H63D/wild-type, versus wild-type/wild-type and iron overload, both provisional (elevated serum iron markers) and documented (elevated serum iron markers associated with evidence of iron excess based on liver biopsy and/or quantitative phlebotomy).

METHODS

After reviewing 3572 article titles and evaluating 92 articles in detail, odds ratios were pooled from 43 study populations (9986 cases and 25,492 controls) using a random-effects model.

RESULTS

Homozygosity for either variant or compound heterozygosity was associated with both provisional and documented iron overload. Single heterozygosity conferred no risk for elevated hepatic iron index and/or mobilizable iron by quantitative phlebotomy. In patients with clinical hereditary hemochromatosis, no evidence of provisional and documented iron overload with transferrin saturation (TS) values greater than 55% was evidenced for C282Y and H63D single heterozygotes whereas documented iron overload including TS of 45% to 50% was weakly associated with C282Y/wild-type genotype; H63D/H63D genotype was not associated with documented iron overload in patients with TS values of 45% to 50%.

CONCLUSIONS

The results, mainly from case-control studies, cannot necessarily be extrapolated to the general population.

HFE gene mutations increase the risk of coronary heart disease in women

The purpose of the present study is to examine HFE gene mutations in relation to newly diagnosed (incident) coronary heart disease (CHD). In a population-based follow-up study of 7,983 individuals aged 55 years and older, we compared the risk of incident CHD between HFE carriers and non-carriers, overall and stratified by sex and smoking status. HFE mutations were significantly associated with an increased risk of incident CHD in women but not in men (hazard ratio [HR] for women = 1.7, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.2–2.4 versus HR for men = 0.9, 95% CI 0.7–1.2). This increased CHD risk associated with HFE mutations in women was statistically significant in never smokers (HR = 1.8, 95% CI 1.1–2.8) and current smokers (HR = 3.1, 95% CI 1.4–7.1), but not in former smokers (HR = 1.3, 95% CI 0.7–2.4). HFE mutations are associated with increased risk of incident CHD in women.

HFE gene mutation, chronic liver disease, and iron overload In Turkey

We aimed to determine the relationships between iron overload and HFE gene mutation in chronic liver disease in Turkey. One hundred thirteen chronic liver disease patients and 138 healthy controls were evaluated regarding their clinical, biochemical, and genetic parameters. Each group was divided into two subgroups according to transferrin saturation (TS) (45% and >45%). HFE gene mutation was analyzed by the PCR-RFLP method. C282Y homozygote, heterozygote, and wild-type mutation rates were 1.7%, 0%, and 98.3% in patients and 0%, 1.4%, and 98.6% in controls, respectively. H63D homozygote, heterozygote, and wild-type mutation rates were 1.8%, 24.7%, and 73.5% in patients and 1.4%, 24%, and 74.6% in controls, respectively. Mutation rates were not statistically different in patients with high and normal TS. Iron overload was positively correlated with biochemical activity and Child-Pugh score (P < 0.05). In multivariate analysis, H63D homozygotic mutation was an independent factor for the development of hepatocellular carcinoma (P = 0.004). We conclude that C282Y mutation is very rare in Turkey. Iron overload is not related to H63D mutation but is positively correlated with biochemical activity and Child-Pugh score in chronic liver diseases.

Review article: the genetic basis of haemochromatosis

BACKGROUND

Since the seminal discovery of the HFE gene a decade ago, considerable further progress in unravelling the genetic basis of haemochromatosis has been made. Novel genes and iron overload phenotypes have been described with potential insights into the molecular pathophysiology of human iron metabolism.

AIM

To review recent key advances in the field of inherited iron overload and assess their impact on clinical practice and on our understanding of iron regulation.

METHODS

A PubMed search was undertaken predominantly using 'haemochromatosis', 'HFE', 'hepcidin' and 'ferroportin'. Illustrative cases were sought.

RESULTS

The impact of HFE mutation analysis on the management of haemochromatosis is significant and allows early accurate diagnosis. HFE is also implicated in the siderosis associated with other liver pathologies. Non-HFE genes underpinning other forms of haemochromatosis are now recognized and genotype-phenotype interactions result in a spectrum of disease. These novel gene products interact with HFE in a common pathway for iron homeostasis.

CONCLUSIONS

Further identification of non-HFE genes associated with iron homeostasis will enhance our diagnostic certainty of primary haemochromatosis and may explain the variable expression seen in HFE-related disease. Improving our understanding of the mechanisms of iron regulation may lead to novel therapeutic strategies for the management of iron overload.

Psychological adjustment and knowledge about hereditary hemochromatosis in a clinic-based sample: a prospective study

This study assessed psychological adjustment and quality of life relative to population-based norms and knowledge about hereditary hemochromatosis in a sample of 101 patients who attended a hemochromatosis clinic. Participants were assessed prior to their clinic visit, and two weeks and 12 months after attendance, using self-administered questionnaires. Mean Mental Health Component Scores from the Medical Outcomes Study 36-Item Short-Form Health Survey (SF-36) (45.3, 95% CI 43.2, 47.4) were as compromised as those found amongst stroke victims (45.9, 95% CI 42.8, 49.0) who had participated in a national health survey. Recall of the genetic testing result was less than optimal, in that only 69.3% of those with genetic testing results knew whether they carried one or two mutations. This study demonstrates that patients would benefit from routine assessment of psychological distress and referral to mental health professionals of those whose levels of distress suggest a need for clinical intervention. Results also show that patients may benefit from strategies aimed at improving recall of genetic testing results.

Comparison of genotypic and phenotypic strategies for population screening in hemochromatosis: assessment of anxiety, depression, and perception of health

PURPOSE

Hemochromatosis is a treatable disorder with a major genetic predisposition. It provides an example in which genotypic and phenotypic strategies for screening may be compared. We previously showed noninferiority of uptake of a genotypic population screening strategy for hemochromatosis compared with a phenotypic strategy. In this article we present the psychologic effects of each strategy.

METHODS

A sample of 3000 individuals from primary care were randomly allocated to a phenotypic or genotypic screening strategy for hemochromatosis, and the 939 individuals who accepted screening provide the sample for this article. Standardized assessments of anxiety, general health, and depression were made at invitation, testing, result-giving, and 6 months.

RESULTS

Screening did not lead to significant changes in the self-rated assessments of anxiety, depression, and general health over time, and there were no significant differences between the two screening strategies. The unemployed or permanently disabled had lower ratings of health and higher anxiety and depression.

CONCLUSION

The two screening strategies appeared to cause little adverse psychologic disturbance in the short term, and there was no difference between the two strategies This study provides some empiric data to support arguments against "genetic exceptionalism" and suggests that genetic testing when used for population screening for a treatable disease has few adverse effects.

Factors affecting the uptake of screening: a randomised controlled non-inferiority trial comparing a genotypic and a phenotypic strategy for screening for haemochromatosis

BACKGROUND/AIMS

Haemochromatosis provides an example where a novel pragmatic genotypic screening strategy may be compared with a phenotypic strategy assessing factors affecting uptake, feasibility and cost.

METHODS

A randomised controlled 'non-inferiority' trial testing the hypothesis that the uptake of testing in the genotypic strategy would not be inferior to the uptake in a phenotypic screening strategy. Three thousand individuals aged 30-70 were randomly selected and randomly allocated (stratified by age and sex) to one of two screening strategies. Phenotypic-transferrin saturation on blood sample taken at GP surgery or genotypic-saliva sample taken at home; followed in screen positive individuals with assessment of iron status and genotyping.

RESULTS

The difference in uptake between the two strategies was 3.4% (95% CI=0.5-6.8). Uptake was low (32%) and least in young men from socially deprived areas. Phenotypic screening was least costly.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, investigating the uptake of screening for a treatable disease in primary care, the uptake of screening with the genotypic strategy was not inferior to that in the phenotypic strategy. The poor uptake in younger men would further limit the effectiveness of screening for haemochromatosis and may have implications for other screening programmes targeted to this group.

Public health aspects of genetic screening for hereditary haemochromatosis in Australia

Hereditary haemochromatosis (HH) is an inherited disorder of iron absorption. It meets several of the key public health principles for population-based screening and is considered to be a test-case for public health genetics. However, there has been relatively little debate in the public health or wider community regarding the merits of population-based genetic screening for HH. Genetic susceptibility to HH occurs in about 1:200 people and although mortality is low (age-standardised rate 2.75/million), there are potentially serious clinical manifestations of iron overload. Regular venesection is a simple and effective treatment for early stage iron overload. DNA-based testing is available and iron overload may be identified using serum transferrin saturation and ferritin tests. However, there are important gaps in knowledge relevant to screening for HH. The limited data on penetrance of HFE genotypes, and thus the uncertain probability that genetically susceptible individuals will develop clinically significant disease, is a major impediment to population-based genetic screening. Clinical evidence supports treating early-stage disease but no randomised controlled trials of the effectiveness of screening in reducing the burden of disease have been conducted. In addition, the natural history of early stages of HH and factors that may modify progression are unclear. Two intemational consensus panels on HH concluded that there is insufficient evidence for population-based screening at present. We present recommendations to advance the debate on screening for HH in Australia.

The crucial role of the public health sciences in the postgenomic era

Genomic sequence information and gene and protein expression patterns must be linked with information about diet and metabolism, lifestyle behaviors, diseases and medications, and microbial, chemical, and physical exposures. These linkages depend upon the public health sciences: epidemiology, biostatistics, environmental health sciences, pathobiology, health sciences research, and clinical prevention trials.

Rapid genotyping of single nucleotide polymorphisms using novel minor groove binding DNA oligonucleotides (MGB probes)

Novel fluorescent oligonucleotides that contain a 3' minor groove binding group (MGB) hybridize to single-stranded targets with increased sequence-specificity compared to ordinary DNA probes. This reduces non-specific probe hybridization and results in low background fluorescence during the 5' nuclease PCR assay (TaqMan, Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA). We developed a method for closed-tube genotyping using two allele-specific MGB probes labeled with different fluorophores in one reaction. After PCR, tubes were transported to a fluorescence plate-reader for analysis of fluorescence. Common spreadsheet software was used for automated genotype assignment. As an example, DNA samples from 172 hemochromatosis patients were selected and tested for molecular defects in the HFE gene, i.e., mutations in codon 63 and 282. Tight genotype clusters were observed for both codons and results with MGB probes were identical to conventional genotyping (PCR + restriction-fragment-length-polymorphism). We show that this fast and easy method can be used for large-scale (high-throughput) genetic studies but also for routine molecular diagnostics without post-PCR manipulation of amplicons or the need for real-time quantitative PCR machines. Hum Mutat 19:554-559, 2002.

Screening for hemochromatosis

BACKGROUND

Hereditary hemochromatosis is the most common autosomal recessive disorder in populations of northern European descent.

ISSUES

Many experts consider hemochromatosis to be an almost ideal disease for population screening because it essentially fulfills almost all the criteria for screening proposed by the WHO. However, others disagree and suggest that more data are required particularly with regard to the natural history and penetrance of the disease. There is also disagreement about the best diagnostic/screening test for the disease and the performance of these tests in the context of screening. Other concerns are the variability and lack of standardization in screening test measurements, the selection of screening threshold values and the identification of false positive cases. The advent of a genetic test for the condition has brought other worries with regard to informed consent and the ethical, legal and social implications of screening particularly in relation to medical and general discrimination. Other important issues include compliance, cost effectiveness and the evidence that screening has lessened the burden of disease in the community.

CONCLUSIONS

At the present time, we believe that further data regarding both the exact disease burden and the outcomes of screening studies particularly in the general community are required before widespread population screening is introduced.

Haemochromatosis gene mutations in a clustered Italian population: evidence of high prevalence in people of Celtic ancestry

Hereditary haemochromatosis is an inherited disorder characterised by an excessive iron absorption from the diet and is associated with several HFE gene mutations. One hypothesis is that these genetic mutations originated in the Celtic populations. The aim of this study is to determine the frequency of HFE gene mutations in a clustered Italian population of Celtic ancestry (Cimbri, Asiago plateau). One hundred and forty-nine consecutive unrelated blood donors (31 females and 118 males) were enrolled in this study. A family investigation was performed in each case to identify the ethnic origin of the individuals. The analysis of HFE gene mutations was performed by PCR amplification followed by digestion with RsaI and DpnII restriction enzymes. At least one HFE gene mutation was identified in 49 individuals (32.9%) of the studied population. The allele frequencies of the C282Y and H63D were respectively 0.037 and 0.144. When we considered only the 103 individuals with relatives born in Asiago, the prevalence of the HFE mutations rose from 32.9 to 39.8%; the allele frequencies of the C282Y and H63D were respectively 0.048 and 0.174. The mean serum iron and ferritin levels were significantly higher in individuals with the HFE mutations than in normal cases. This study indicates that the prevalence of the HFE gene mutations is surprisingly high in Italians with Celtic ancestry. This could suggest the need to perform large mass studies in selected areas of the country to detect the affected patients and prevent the disease in homozygous individuals.

A pilot C282Y hemochromatosis screening in Italian newborns by TaqMan technology

Hereditary hemochromatosis (HH) is a disorder of iron metabolism that leads to iron overload in middle age and can be caused by homozygosity for the C282Y mutation in the HFE gene. Preliminary studies have estimated the frequency of this mutation at 0.5-1% in Italy, but this has not been verified on a large sample. We analyzed 1,331 Italian newborns for the C282Y mutation in the HFE gene using dried blood spots (DBS) from the Neonatal Screening Center in Turin, Italy. The mutation was assessed using a semi-automatable 5'-nuclease assay (TaqMan technology). We detected 55 heterozygotes and no homozygotes in our sampling, resulting in an overall frequency of 2.1% +/- 0.6 for the C282Y allele. Differences in allele frequency were observed, and ranged from 2.7% +/- 1.3 in samples from Northern Italy, to 1.7% +/- 0.9 in samples from Central-Southern Italy. The low frequency of the at-risk genotype for iron overload suggests that genetic screening for HFE in Italy would not be cost effective. The present study, in addition to defining C282Y frequency, documents detection of the major HFE mutation on routine DBS samples from neonatal screening programs using a semi-automatable, rapid, reliable, and relatively inexpensive approach.

Inherited iron overload disorders

Iron is an essential nutrient that is highly toxic in excess. Normal iron balance is maintained primarily by regulation of intestinal absorption of the metal from the diet. Iron overload generally results from a chronic increase in intestinal absorption. During the past 5 years, it has become apparent that there are at least eight inherited disorders of iron metabolism characterized by the toxic accumulation of iron. This review provides an update for pediatricians on the clinical features and pathogenesis of these disorders.

Genetic disorders affecting proteins of iron metabolism: clinical implications

Remarkable progress is being made in understanding the molecular basis of disorders of human iron metabolism. Recent work has uncovered unanticipated relationships with the immune and nervous systems, intricate interconnections with copper metabolism, and striking homologies between yeast and human genes involved in the transport of transition metals. This review examines the clinical consequences of new insights into the pathophysiology of genetic abnormalities affecting iron metabolism. The proteins recently found to be involved in the absorption, transport, utilization, and storage of iron are briefly described, and the clinical manifestations of genetic disorders that affect these proteins are discussed. This chapter considers the most common inherited disorder in individuals of European ancestry (hereditary hemochromatosis), a widespread disease in sub-Saharan populations for which the genetic basis is still uncertain (African dietary iron overload), and several less frequent or rare disorders (juvenile hemochromatosis, atransferrinemia, aceruloplasminemia, hyperferritinemia with autosomal dominant congenital cataract, Friedreich's ataxia, and X-linked sideroblastic anemia with ataxia).

Population screening for hemochromatosis: has the time finally come?

Hemochromatosis refers to a group of common heritable disorders among Western Caucasians which increase susceptibility for development of iron overload and its complications. These consequences are preventable by early detection and simple, relatively inexpensive treatment. Screening of appropriate populations to detect hemochromatosis before iron overload occurs is both effective and cost-effective. The primary goal of screening should be the ongoing detection of persons with hemochromatosis, especially healthy individuals whose risk to develop iron overload is great, in a context that provides appropriate preventive treatment, education, and counseling. Although related issues warrant further study, implementation of well-designed screening programs for hemochromatosis should not be delayed.