[Trapeziectomy in rhizarthrosis]

Isolated Osseous Excision in the Adult Carpus: A Narrative Review

Various pathologies of the adult carpus result in clinical scenarios where excision can be considered and even recommended. In the appropriate patient population, isolated carpal excision can alleviate pain and improve mobility. Excisions of the pisiform, trapezium, and trapezoid have abundant literature evidence to support positive long-term functional outcomes. In contrast, isolated excision of the capitate, hamate, and triquetrum has limited support in the literature secondary to compromise of carpal mechanics and lead to recurrent pain. Additionally, isolated scaphoid and lunate excision are best avoided secondary to carpal collapse and should be paired with concomitant stabilizing procedures in the carpus. This article provides a comprehensive literature review of isolated excision of each osseous carpal bone, their indications, and previously assessed outcomes.

TREATMENT OF BASAL JOINT ARTHRITIS OF THE THUMB: TRAPEZIECTOMY WITH OR WITHOUT TENDON INTERPOSITION/LIGAMENT RECONSTRUCTION

This prospective study compared the outcome — subjective, objective and radiographic — of two surgical techniques for treating basal joint arthritis of the thumb: a "simple" trapeziectomy (group I) and a ligament reconstruction/tendon (group II) interposition technique. There were respectively 22 patients in group I and 34 in group II, all women with primary osteoarthritis.

Both techniques gave favourable results and there were no significant differences for pain relief, patient satisfaction, mobility, DASH-score, key pinch force and gripping force. However in group II, the trapezial height was better preserved indicating that the proximal migration of the thumb was prevented or limited. There was also a significant correlation between the remaining trapezial space and key pinch force.

Adverse effect of porcine collagen interposition after trapeziectomy: a comparative study

Twenty-six hands in 26 adults with osteoarthrosis of the thumb trapeziometacarpal joint were randomised to undergo either trapeziectomy alone (control) or with the interposition of porcine dermal collagen xenograft (Permacol). The study was terminated prematurely because of apparent reactions to the implants in six of 13 patients. The collagen interposition group required more frequent review on clinical grounds and were discharged later after surgery. Three of the implants have been removed and histology revealed foreign body reactions in all. There was no difference in thumb movement or power after surgery between the two groups. However, improved grip strength was observed and improved function were reported only in the control group. Permacol patients reported greater pain and were less satisfied with their operations than control patients. We conclude that interposition of Permacol is detrimental to the results of trapeziectomy.

A comparison of trapeziectomy with and without ligament reconstruction and tendon interposition

Forty-three patients were randomly allocated to undergo either trapeziectomy alone (control) or with a ligament reconstruction and tendon interposition (LRTI) using an abductor pollicis longus tendon slip. The patients were reviewed at a median 13 (range, 7-29) months after surgery. The demographic characteristics, severity of disease and pre-operative clinical measurements of the two study groups were indistinguishable but LRTI lengthened the operation by approximately 15 minutes. Both groups expressed equal satisfaction with the operation and there were no significant differences between the two treatment groups. Simple trapeziectomy is an effective operation for osteoarthrosis at the base of the thumb and the addition of a ligament reconstruction was not shown to confer any additional benefit.

Simple trapezectomy for treatment of trapeziometacarpal osteoarthritis of the thumb

This is a review of 20 patients (22 operations) with symptomatic osteoarthritis of the first carpometacarpal joint who were treated by simple trapezectomy without interposition material. They were all women with a mean age of 60 years (46-77). The average follow-up was 2 years, ranging from 8 months to 3 years. Pain relief is the main contributor to the good clinical results of this procedure. Sixteen patients professed to be very satisfied, two had a fair result and four cases claimed to be unsatisfied. Range of motion (opposition and counter opposition) and first web space were very well preserved. Mean values of grip strength showed reduction of grip power on the operated side though not statistically. However, we did find a statistically significant difference in pinch strength between operated and non-operated side. In general, simple trapezectomy is our preferred surgical therapy in the treatment of carpometacarpal osteoarthritis in the elderly population.

[Stabilization-interposition arthroplasty in peri-trapezial arthritic lesions. Apropos of a prospective series of 200 cases]

A group of 200 arthroplasties (180 patients) for basal thumb arthrosis is reported. The used technique is similar to that described by Burton and Pelegrini in 1986. At the last follow up (2 years minimum), 90% patients were without pain, 95% were very satisfied, the grip strength was improved in 70%, and the shortening of the thumb was between 2 and 9 mm (mean 6 m). The mobility of the first metacarpal is improved in only 47%. Complications were limited to two NAD for patients operated of carpal tunnel syndrome in the same time.