Controversies in adolescent hormonal contraception

Adolescent and young adult women's use of emergency contraception

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To determine differences in the use of emergency contraception (EC) between adolescent (11-17 years old) and young adult women (18-24 years old) in an insured, population based cohort.

DESIGN AND PARTICIPANTS

Females 11-24 years old were divided into two groups: adolescents (11-17) and young adults (18-24) at their first captured EC prescription fill. A medical record review followed.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The main outcomes of our study were reason for EC use, timing of EC use, and repeat use. Chi-square tests were used to compare dichotomous variables between groups by age and for ever vs repeat use. An independent t-test was used to compare continuous variables. A person-time analysis was used to compare rates of repeat use.

RESULTS

344 women were identified as having filled at least one prescription for an EC drug. Among ever users, adolescents were more likely than young adults to cite no contraception as their reason for seeking EC (30% for 11-17 and 24% for 18-24 year olds; P = 0.38). For both ever and repeat users, young adults reported condom failure as their main reason for seeking EC. We calculated t-tests on the hours since unprotected sex. For adolescents the mean was 42 hours and for young adults the mean was 34 hours (P = 0.13). Both are within the recommended 72-hour window for administration and were not significantly different. The rate of repeat use was essentially the same for both age groups.

CONCLUSIONS

We found that adolescent use of EC was similar to young adult use and support the recommendation that 17-year-olds have behind-the-counter access to EC.

Adolescent use of the monthly contraceptive injection

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To compare weight and continuation among adolescents using monthly medroxyprogesterone acetate (MPA)/ethinyl estradiol cypionate (E2C), tri-monthly depot MPA (DMPA), and daily oral contraceptive pills (OCP).

DESIGN

Medical records were reviewed for body mass index, demographics, and sexual history at baseline; and weight and continuation at 3, 6, 9, and 12 months. Bivariate analyses were performed by method, and continuation functions were compared by the log-rank and Wilcoxon tests. The effect of method on use duration was assessed by Cox regression.

SETTING

Hospital adolescent clinic.

PARTICIPANTS

12- to 21-year-old patients who initiated MPA/E2C, DMPA, or OCPs in 2001.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Weight gain and method continuation.

RESULTS

MPA/E2C was initiated by 40 (18%) patients, DMPA by 63 (28%), and OCPs by 119 (54%, P < 0.001). OCP users were younger (P = 0.005) and more likely to be white, privately insured, and in school (P < 0.004) than MPA/E2C or DMPA users. Previous DMPA and OCP use, pregnancy, and sexually transmitted infections (STI) were more common among MPA/E2C than DMPA or OCP users (P < or = 0.001). Baseline BMI was lowest (P = 0.06) among DMPA users, and MPA/E2C users were most likely to be overweight (P = 0.03). There were non-significant differences in weight change. Continuation functions differed by the method only in the first three months of use (P = 0.03). Leading reasons for discontinuation were unavailability of MPA/E2C (20%), bleeding with DMPA (22%), and forgetting OCPs (17%). Duration of use was independently associated with white race (P < 0.005) and STI-never (P < 0.0001) but not with method type.

CONCLUSIONS

Although MPA/E2C use was associated with overweight status and early discontinuation, it also was associated with previous use of other methods. For all methods, poor continuation at one year supports the ongoing search for effective contraceptive alternatives.