High-energy phosphates in the frontal lobe correlate with Wisconsin Card Sort Test performance in controls, not in schizophrenics: a 31phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopic and neuropsychological investigation

Neurocognitive correlates of cerebral mitochondrial function and energy metabolism using phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy in older adults

The goal of the current study was to learn about the role of cerebral mitochondrial function on cognition. Based on established cognitive neuroscience, clinical neuropsychology, and cognitive aging literature, we hypothesized mitochondrial function within a focal brain region would map onto cognitive behaviors linked to that brain region. To test this hypothesis, we used phosphorous (31P) magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) to derive indirect markers of mitochondrial function and energy metabolism across two regions of the brain (bifrontal, left temporal). We administered cognitive tasks sensitive to frontal-executive or temporal-hippocampal systems to a sample of 70 cognitively unimpaired older adults with subjective memory complaints and a first-degree family history of Alzheimer's disease and predicted better executive function and recent memory performance would be related to greater frontal and temporal 31P MRS indirect markers, respectively. Results of separate hierarchical linear regressions indicated better recent memory scores were related to 31P MRS indirect markers of lower static energy and higher energy reserve within the left temporal voxel; these findings were associated with moderate effect sizes. Contrary to predictions, executive function performance was unrelated to 31P MRS indirect markers within the bilateral frontal voxel, which may reflect a combination of theoretical and/or methodological issues. Findings represent a snapshot of the relationship between cognition and 31P MRS indirect markers of mitochondrial function, providing potential avenues for future work investigating mitochondrial underpinnings of cognition. 31P MRS may provide a sensitive neuroimaging marker for differences in aspects of memory among persons at-risk for mild cognitive impairment or dementia.

Active Women Across the Lifespan: Nutritional Ingredients to Support Health and Wellness

Women are the largest consumers of dietary supplements. Dietary supplements can play a role in health and performance, particularly for women. Growing evidence and innovations support the unique physiological and nutrient timing needs for women. Despite the need for more nutrition and exercise-specific research in women, initial data and known physiological differences between sexes related to the brain, respiration, bone, and muscle support new product development and evidence-based education for active women regarding the use of dietary supplements. In this narrative review, we discuss hormonal and metabolic considerations with the potential to impact nutritional recommendations for active women. We propose four potential areas of opportunity for ingredients to help support the health and well-being of active women, including: (1) body composition, (2) energy/fatigue, (3) mental health, and (4) physical health.

Regionally Distinct Alterations in Membrane Phospholipid Metabolism in Schizophrenia: A Meta-analysis of Phosphorus Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy Studies

BACKGROUND

Existing data on altered membrane phospholipid metabolism in schizophrenia are diverse. We conducted a meta-analysis of studies of phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy, a noninvasive imaging approach that can assess molecular biochemistry of cortex by measuring phosphomonoester (PME) and phosphodiester (PDE) levels, which can provide evidence of altered biochemical processes involved in neuropil membrane expansion and contraction in schizophrenia.

METHODS

We analyzed PME and PDE data in the frontal and temporal lobes in subjects with schizophrenia from 24 peer-reviewed publications using the MAVIS package in R by building random- and fixed-effects models. Heterogeneity of effect sizes, effects of publication bias, and file drawer analysis were also assessed.

RESULTS

Subjects with schizophrenia showed lower PME levels in the frontal regions (p = .008) and elevated PDE levels in the temporal regions (p < .001) with significant heterogeneity. We noted significant publication bias and file drawer effect for frontal PME and PDE and temporal PDE levels, but not for temporal PME levels. Fail-safe analysis estimated that a high number of negative studies were required to provide nonsignificant results.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite methodological differences, these phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy studies demonstrate regionally specific imbalance in membrane phospholipid metabolism related to neuropil in subjects with schizophrenia compared with control subjects reflecting neuropil contraction. Specifically, decreased PME levels in the frontal regions and elevated PDE levels in the temporal regions provide evidence of decreased synthesis and increased degradation of neuropil membrane, respectively. Notwithstanding significant heterogeneity and publication bias, a large number of negative studies are required to render the results of this meta-analysis nonsignificant. These findings warrant further postmortem and animal studies.

Brain bioenergetics and redox state measured by 31P magnetic resonance spectroscopy in unaffected siblings of patients with psychotic disorders

BACKGROUND

Brain bioenergetic anomalies and redox dysregulation have been implicated in the pathophysiology of psychotic disorders. The present study examined brain energy-related metabolites and the balance between nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide metabolites (oxidized NAD+ and reduced NADH) using ³¹P-magnetic resonance spectroscopy (³¹P-MRS) in unaffected siblings, compared to first episode psychosis (FEP) patients and healthy controls.

METHODS

21 unaffected siblings, 32 FEP patients (including schizophrenia spectrum and affective psychoses), and 21 controls underwent ³¹P-MRS in the frontal lobe (6×6×4cm³) on a 4T MR scanner, using custom-designed dual-tuned surface coil with outer volume suppression. Brain parenchymal pH and steady-state metabolite ratios of high energy phosphate compounds were measured. NAD+ and NADH levels were determined using a ³¹P-MRS fitting algorithm. 13 unaffected sibling-patient pairs were related; other patients and siblings were unrelated. ANCOVA analyses were used to examine ³¹P-MRS measures, with age and gender as covariates.

RESULTS

The phosphocreatine/adenosine triphosphate ratio was significantly reduced in both unaffected siblings and FEP patients, compared to controls. NAD+/NADH ratio was significantly reduced in patients compared to siblings and controls, with siblings showing a reduction in NAD+/NADH compared to controls that was not statistically significant. Compared to patients and controls, siblings showed significantly reduced levels of NAD+. Siblings did not differ from patients or controls on brain pH.

DISCUSSION

Our results indicate that unaffected siblings show some, but not all the same abnormalities in brain energy metabolites and redox state as FEP patients. Thus, ³¹P-MRS studies may identify factors related both to risk and expression of psychosis.

Neuropil pruning in Early-Course Schizophrenia: Immunological, Clinical, and Neurocognitive Correlates

INTRODUCTION

Neuropathological studies suggest neuropil reduction in schizophrenia. Altered synaptic pruning is proposed to underlie neuropil reduction. Underlying factors and clinical correlates of synaptic pruning are poorly understood. Using phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy (31P MRS), it is feasible to assess membrane phospholipid (MPL) metabolites in the brain that specifically and sensitively reflect neuropil expansion (elevated MPL precursors) or contraction (elevated MPL catabolites).

METHODS

We examined MPL metabolites and their cognitive, clinical and immunologic correlates among 28 early-course schizophrenia individuals (illness duration 1.99±1.33 years; antipsychotic-naïve=18) and 21 controls. We acquired whole-brain multi-voxel 31P MRS data from 12 unique brain regions. Interleukin-6 and C-reactive protein (CRP) were assayed in the serum. Generalized linear mixed models examined case-control differences in MPL metabolites in these regions correcting for multiple testing. Partial correlations accounting for multiple tests examined the relationship of Interleukin-6 and CRP levels with MPL metabolite levels.

RESULTS

MPL catabolite levels were increased in the thalamus in schizophrenia compared to controls. Interleukin-6 and CRP levels did not show case-control differences. Interleukin-6 levels positively correlated with MPL catabolite levels in the thalamus after correcting for multiple tests. The left thalamus MPL catabolite levels correlated negatively with sustained attention (corrected p=0.039).

DISCUSSION

Elevated MPL catabolites in the thalamus suggest increased neuropil contraction that may be related to excessive synaptic pruning. The thalamic neuropil contraction is associated with Interleukin-6 levels suggesting central pathogenic mechanisms for the inflammatory mediators. Correlation of increased thalamic MPL catabolite levels with cognitive impairments suggests clinical correlates of neuropil contraction.

Glutamatergic dysfunction linked to energy and membrane lipid metabolism in frontal and anterior cingulate cortices of never treated first-episode schizophrenia patients

BACKGROUND

Glutamatergic dysfunction and altered membrane lipid and energy metabolism have been repeatedly demonstrated in the frontal/prefrontal and anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) in schizophrenia. Though having been already studied in animals, the presumed link between glutamatergic function and structural plasticity has not been investigated directly in the human brain yet. We measured glutamate (Glu), focal energy metabolism, and membrane phospholipid turnover to investigate main pathologies in those key brain regions of schizophrenia.

METHODS

(1)H- and (31)P-Chemical Shift Imaging (CSI) was combined in a single session to assess Glu and markers of energy (PCr, ATP) and membrane lipid (PME, PDE) metabolism in 31 neuroleptic-naïve first acute onset psychosis patients and 31 matched healthy controls. Multivariate analyses of covariance were used to assess disease effects on Glu and to investigate the impact of Glu alterations on phospholipid and energy metabolites.

RESULTS

Glu levels of patients were increased in the frontal and prefrontal cortex bilaterally and in the ACC. Higher Glu was associated with increased left frontal/prefrontal PME and right frontal/prefrontal PDE in patients, which was not observed in healthy controls. In contrast, higher Glu levels were associated with lower PCr or ATP values in the frontal/prefrontal cortex bilaterally and in the right ACC of controls. This was not observed in the right ACC and left frontal/prefrontal cortex of patients.

CONCLUSION

Frontal glutamatergic hyperactivity is disconnected from physiologically regulated energy metabolism and is associated with increased membrane breakdown in right and increased membrane restoration in left frontal and prefrontal cortical regions. As indicated by previous findings, this pathology is likely dynamic during the course of first acute illness and possibly associated with negative symptoms and cognitive impairment. Our findings underline the importance of further research on neuroprotective treatment options during the early acute or even better for the ultra-high risk state of psychotic illness.

Phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy studies in schizophrenia

Phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy ((31)P MRS) allows in vivo quantification of phosphorus metabolites that are considered to be related to membrane turnover and energy metabolism. In schizophrenia (SZ), (31)P MRS studies found several abnormalities in different brain regions suggesting that alterations in these pathways may be contributing to the pathophysiology. In this paper, we systematically reviewed the (31)P MRS studies in SZ published to date by taking patient characteristics, medication status and brain regions into account. Publications written in English were searched on http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/, by using the keywords 'phosphomonoester', 'phosphodiester', 'ATP', 'phosphocreatine', 'phosphocholine', 'phosphoethanolamine','glycerophosphocholine', 'glycerophosphoethanolamine', 'pH', 'schizophrenia', and 'MRS'. Studies that measured (31)P metabolites in SZ patients were included. This search identified 52 studies. Reduced PME and elevated PDE reported in earlier studies were not replicated in several subsequent studies. One relatively consistent pattern was a decrease in PDE in chronic patients in the subcortical structures. There were no consistent patterns for the comparison of energy related phosphorus metabolites between patients and controls. Also, no consistent pattern emerged in studies seeking relationship between (31)P metabolites and antipsychotic use and other clinical variables. Despite emerging patterns, methodological heterogeneities and shortcomings in this literature likely obscure consistent patterns among studies. We conclude with recommendations to improve study designs and (31)P MRS methods in future studies. We also stress the significance of probing into the dynamic changes in energy metabolism, as this approach reveals abnormalities that are not visible to steady-state measurements.

Contributions of magnetic resonance spectroscopy to understanding development: potential applications in the study of adolescent alcohol use and abuse

A growing body of research has documented structural and functional brain development during adolescence, yet little is known about neurochemical changes that occur during this important developmental period. Magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) is a well-developed technology that permits the in vivo quantification of multiple brain neurochemicals relevant to neuronal health and functioning. However, MRS technology has been underused in exploring normative developmental changes during adolescence and the onset of alcohol and drug use and abuse during this developmental period. This review begins with a brief overview of normative cognitive and neurobiological development during adolescence, followed by an introduction to MRS principles. The subsequent sections provide a comprehensive review of the existing MRS studies of development and cognitive functioning in healthy children and adolescents. The final sections of this article address the potential application of MRS in identifying neurochemical predictors and consequences of alcohol use and abuse in adolescence. MRS studies of adolescent populations hold promise for advancing our understanding of neurobiological risk factors for psychopathology by identifying the biochemical signatures associated with healthy brain development, as well as neurobiological and cognitive correlates of alcohol and substance use and abuse.

Anodal transcranial direct current stimulation increases brain intracellular pH and modulates bioenergetics

Transcranial direct current stimulation is an emerging treatment for brain disorders but its mode of action is not well understood. We applied 10 min 1 mA anodal transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) inside the bore of a 3 T MRI scanner to the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex of 13 healthy volunteers (aged 19-28 yr) in a blinded, sham-controlled, cross-over design. Brain bioenergetics were measured from the left temporo-frontal region using 31P magnetic resonance spectroscopy before, during and for 20 min following tDCS. Brain pH rose during tDCS and remained elevated afterwards. Phosphomonoesters were significantly decreased while inorganic phosphate (Pi) also fell. Partial-least squares discriminant analysis of the data revealed two significantly different subject groups: one where phosphocreatine (PCr), ATP and Pi fell along with a larger increase in pH and one where PCr and ATP increased along with a smaller increase in pH and a slower and more sustained decrease in Pi. Group membership was predicted by baseline pH and ATP. We interpreted the effects of tDCS as driving two biochemical processes: cellular consumption of ATP causing hydrolysis of PCr via the creatine kinase reaction driving the increase in pH; synthesis of ATP and PCr by mitochondria with concomitant drop in Pi and phosphomonoester levels.

Creatine metabolism and psychiatric disorders: Does creatine supplementation have therapeutic value?

Athletes, body builders, and military personnel use dietary creatine as an ergogenic aid to boost physical performance in sports involving short bursts of high-intensity muscle activity. Lesser known is the essential role creatine, a natural regulator of energy homeostasis, plays in brain function and development. Creatine supplementation has shown promise as a safe, effective, and tolerable adjunct to medication for the treatment of brain-related disorders linked with dysfunctional energy metabolism, such as Huntington's Disease and Parkinson's Disease. Impairments in creatine metabolism have also been implicated in the pathogenesis of psychiatric disorders, leaving clinicians, researchers and patients alike wondering if dietary creatine has therapeutic value for treating mental illness. The present review summarizes the neurobiology of the creatine-phosphocreatine circuit and its relation to psychological stress, schizophrenia, mood and anxiety disorders. While present knowledge of the role of creatine in cognitive and emotional processing is in its infancy, further research on this endogenous metabolite has the potential to advance our understanding of the biological bases of psychopathology and improve current therapeutic strategies.

Metabolic mapping using 2D 31P-MR spectroscopy reveals frontal and thalamic metabolic abnormalities in schizophrenia

(31)Phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy ((31)P-MRS) allows in vivo investigation of cerebral phospholipid and energy metabolism. Using 2D chemical shift imaging, this method can be applied to study multiple brain areas and to assess concentrations of both phospholipids and high-energy phosphates. The purpose of our study was to assess multiregional metabolic profiles in schizophrenia using a 2D-resolved MRS technique, and to assess the intercorrelation of findings. We applied (31)P-MRS chemical shift imaging in 31 schizophrenia patients (12 antipsychotic-naïve first-episode and 19 antipsychotic-free multi-episode patients) and 31 healthy age- and sex-matched controls. Spatially resolved maps were compared for the main metabolites of the (31)P spectrum. Metabolites of phospholipid (PME and PDE) and energy (PCr and Pi) metabolism were significantly reduced in bilateral prefrontal and medial temporal (including hippocampal) brain regions, caudate nucleus, thalamus and anterior cerebellum as compared to controls. Moreover, factor analysis of these changes showed a characteristic spatial pattern of changes, which demonstrates significant associations between alterations of phospholipid and energy metabolism, and between metabolic alterations and severity of symptoms (BPRS total score, but not SANS or SAPS scores). This suggests a pattern of intercorrelated changes of these metabolic markers. Results support the notion of disturbed phospholipid turnover in schizophrenia, probably unrelated to prior pharmacological treatment, and associated with increased energy demand.

Magnetic resonance spectroscopy in cognitive research

The neurophysiological basis of cognition is relatively unexplained, with most studies reporting weak relationships between cognition and measures of brain function, such as event-related potentials, brain size and cerebral blood flow. Magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) is an in vivo method used to detect neurochemicals within the brain that are relevant to certain brain processes. The most widely used methods are 1H-MRS and 31P-MRS, which detect compounds that contain hydrogen and phosphorus, respectively. Recent studies have shown that the absolute concentrations or ratios of these neurochemicals, in particular N-acetyl aspartate (NAA), which is associated with neuronal viability, correlate with performance on neuropsychological tests or other measures of cognitive function in normal subjects. Many studies in adults and children have shown a relationship between neurometabolite values and cognitive status or extent of cognitive dysfunction in various neurological and neuropsychiatric disorders. We review these studies and conclude that MRS has potential applications for the study of cognitive processes in health and disease and may be used clinically for differential diagnosis, the early detection of pathology and the examination of longitudinal change.

Implications of lipid biology for the pathogenesis of schizophrenia

OBJECTIVE

Preclinical and clinical data suggest that lipid biology is integral to brain development and neurodegeneration. Both aspects are proposed as being important in the pathogenesis of schizophrenia. The purpose of this paper is to examine the implications of lipid biology, in particular the role of essential fatty acids (EFA), for schizophrenia.

METHODS

Medline databases were searched from 1966 to 2001 followed by the cross-checking of references.

RESULTS

Most studies investigating lipids in schizophrenia described reduced EFA, altered glycerophospholipids and an increased activity of a calcium-independent phospholipase A2 in blood cells and in post-mortem brain tissue. Additionally, in vivo brain phosphorus-31 Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy (31P-MRS) demonstrated lower phosphomonoesters (implying reduced membrane precursors) in first- and multi-episode patients. In contrast, phosphodiesters were elevated mainly in first-episode patients (implying increased membrane breakdown products), whereas inconclusive results were found in chronic patients. EFA supplementation trials in chronic patient populations with residual symptoms have demonstrated conflicting results. More consistent results were observed in the early and symptomatic stages of illness, especially if EFA with a high proportion of eicosapentaenoic acid was used.

CONCLUSION

Peripheral blood cell, brain necropsy and 31P-MRS analysis reveal a disturbed lipid biology, suggesting generalized membrane alterations in schizophrenia. 31P-MRS data suggest increased membrane turnover at illness onset and persisting membrane abnormalities in established schizophrenia. Cellular processes regulating membrane lipid metabolism are potential new targets for antipsychotic drugs and might explain the mechanism of action of treatments such as eicosapentaenoic acid.

Neurochemical investigation of the schizophrenic brain by in vivo phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy

Abnormal phospholipid metabolisms may play important roles in the pathophysiology of schizophrenia. Phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy (31P-MRS) offers a new method for studying phosphorus-related metabolism in vivo. A decrease in the level of phosphomonoesters (PME) and an increase in the level of phosphodiesters (PDE) has been demonstrated in the prefrontal lobe of neuroleptic-naive schizophrenic patients. Most of the studies in medicated schizophrenic patients have shown decreased PME and/or increased PDE. The decreased PME in the frontal lobe appears to be associated with negative symptoms and poor working memory performance. 1H-decoupled 31P-MRS revealed a reduction in the phosphocholine element of PME and an elevation in the mobile phospholipids of PDE in the prefrontal region of medicated schizophrenic patients. PDE were elevated in the temporal lobes of neuroleptic-naive schizophrenic patients, and this increase was partially normalized by haloperidol administration. Data about the temporal lobes of medicated schizophrenic patients have not been consistent. Except for the reduction in the adenosine triphosphate (ATP) in the basal ganglia and the correlation between the increase in the frontal lobe phosphocreatine (PCr) and negative symptomatology, data related to changes in high-energy phosphates are contradictory. No consensus on the effect of neuroleptics on phosphorus metabolites has been achieved. Methodological problems inherent in 31P-MRS may have contributed to the confusion in understanding available data. Future directions of MRS studies are suggested in the last section of the paper.

Dual voxel proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy in the healthy elderly: subcortical-frontal axonal N-acetylaspartate levels are correlated with fluid cognitive abilities independent of structural brain changes

The published literature suggests that degeneration of the subcorticofrontal networks may underlie cognitive ageing, but appropriate methods to examine this in vivo have been lacking. Proton Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy ((1)H-MRS) has now been used in a number of clinical studies to assess cerebral pathophysicochemistry and recently has been utilized to examine the relationship between neurochemical markers and cognitive functioning in normal individuals. Results have been somewhat conflicting and difficult to interpret. To further clarify the role of the cognitive spectroscopy technique, we measured N-acetylaspartate (NAA) levels in the frontal subcortical white matter and the occipitoparietal grey matter and correlated them with performance in different cognitive domains in a group of twenty healthy elderly individuals. Subjects underwent whole brain T(1)- and T(2)-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), dual voxel short echo-time (1)H-MRS, and a comprehensive neuropsychological assessment. Individual tests of executive and attentional abilities, and a principal components composite score reflecting these skills, but not measures of memory or verbal abilities, were correlated with NAA concentration in the frontal white matter only. These relationships were independent of other neurocognitive predictors of executive impairment such as age, midventricular dilation, frontal white matter disease, and presenescent verbal proficiency. This study suggests the ability of (1)H-MRS to differentiate anatomically distinct neurochemical markers related to specific cognitive abilities. In particular, neurometabolic fitness of the frontal subcortical-cortical axonal fibers may be important in mediating fluid intellectual processing. Longitudinal MRS studies are required to determine if the present results reflect different rates of neurocellular degeneration or preexisting individual differences in neuronal density.

Chemical heterogeneity of the living human brain: a proton MR spectroscopy study on the effects of sex, age, and brain region

Brain chemistry was compared between 19 male and female normal volunteers in the age group 19-31 years, across six brain regions and nine metabolites using in vivo proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy. The relative concentrations of N-acetyl aspartate, choline, glutamate, glutamine, GABA, inositol, glucose, and lactate were measured relative to creatine within 8-cm(3) brain voxels. These measurements were performed in six brain regions: thalamus and cingulate, insula, sensorimotor, dorsolateral prefrontal, and orbital frontal cortices in the left hemisphere. Total metabolite concentration was highest in prefrontal regions (28% higher in orbital frontal cortex and 18.7% higher in dorsolateral prefrontal cortex compared with insula and thalamus, P < 10(-7)). Subjects 25-31 years of age demonstrated a significant increase in total metabolite concentration in the orbital frontal cortex (35%, P < 10(-7)) and sensorimotor cortex (16.7%, P < 10(-5)) compared to those 19-20 years of age. These two brain regions also showed gender dependence, with women demonstrating increased metabolite concentrations compared to men (9% increase in sensorimotor cortex, P < 0.002, and 2.1% in orbital frontal cortex). Most other brain regions showed no gender- or age-dependent differences. The results indicate that the living human brain is chemically heterogeneous. The chemical heterogeneity is sex and age dependent and specific for brain region.

Magnetic resonance spectroscopy and schizophrenia: what have we learnt?

OBJECTIVE

Magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) has been increasingly used to investigate the in vivo biochemistry of particular regions of the brain in patients with schizophrenia. We review the literature and discuss the theoretical constructs that form the presumed impetus for these studies in light of the current methodological limitations. Future directions are noted.

METHOD

The available published literature in English formed the basis for this review.

RESULTS

The results of 31P-MRS have been interpreted as reflecting a relative increase in cell membrane degradation in prefrontal cortical regions at certain phases of schizophrenia. 1H-MRS studies, though less consistent, provide evidence suggestive of a decrease in neuronal cell mass in the hippocampal region, which supports the findings of volumetric studies. Both groups of MRS studies support a neuro-developmental hypothesis of brain dysfunction in schizophrenia. However, current methodological problems limit the reliable interpretation of MRS data. A clear understanding of the methodology and its reliable interpretation is yet to emerge.

CONCLUSIONS

MRS remains a research instrument that is yet to be fully utilised in schizophrenia research. A few replicated findings are emerging, although the interpretation of these spectroscopic findings needs to be validated.

A meta-analytic review of Wisconsin Card Sort studies in schizophrenia: general intellectual deficit in disguise?

A majority of studies show that schizophrenics perform poorly on so-called tests of executive or frontal lobe function--the paradigmatic case being the Wisconsin Card Sort Test (WCST). Nevertheless, the specific character of this deficit in schizophrenia remains underspecified. In particular, it seems premature to assume that schizophrenia is characterised by an executive dysfunction and/or a disorder of frontal lobe function before determining whether any deficit is: selective; disproportionate to the general level of intellectual functioning; or qualitatively comparable with that of frontal lobe patients. A meta-analysis was conducted on 29 studies comparing the performance of schizophrenics and normal controls on the WCST. This showed that the mean weighted effect size was large for categories achieved (d = 0.91), medium for absolute level of perseveration (d = 0.53), but only small for the proportion of perseverative errors (d = 0.18). By contrast, the effect size for Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale Intelligence Quotient (WAIS IQ) in a subset of these studies (d = 1.23) was significantly larger than for any WCST measures. This pattern of findings challenges notions that schizophrenia is characterised by an executive dysfunction that is: selective; disproportionate to IQ level; and analogous to that found in frontal lobe patients. Rather, the poor WCST performance of schizophrenics appears to reflect a generalised intellectual deficit.