Approaches to determining membrane protein structures to high resolution: do selections of subpopulations occur?

Challenges of Protein-Protein Docking of the Membrane Proteins

Despite the recent advances in the determination of high-resolution membrane protein (MP) structures, the structural and functional characterization of MPs remains extremely challenging, mainly due to the hydrophobic nature, low abundance, poor expression, purification, and crystallization difficulties associated with MPs. Whereby the major challenges/hurdles for MP structure determination are associated with the expression, purification, and crystallization procedures. Although there have been significant advances in the experimental determination of MP structures, only a limited number of MP structures (approximately less than 1% of all) are available in the Protein Data Bank (PDB). Therefore, the structures of a large number of MPs still remain unresolved, which leads to the availability of widely unplumbed structural and functional information related to MPs. As a result, recent developments in the drug discovery realm and the significant biological contemplation have led to the development of several novel, low-cost, and time-efficient computational methods that overcome the limitations of experimental approaches, supplement experiments, and provide alternatives for the characterization of MPs. Whereby the fine tuning and optimizations of these computational approaches remains an ongoing endeavor.Computational methods offer a potential way for the elucidation of structural features and the augmentation of currently available MP information. However, the use of computational modeling can be extremely challenging for MPs mainly due to insufficient knowledge of (or gaps in) atomic structures of MPs. Despite the availability of numerous in silico methods for 3D structure determination the applicability of these methods to MPs remains relatively low since all methods are not well-suited or adequate for MPs. However, sophisticated methods for MP structure predictions are constantly being developed and updated to integrate the modifications required for MPs. Currently, different computational methods for (1) MP structure prediction, (2) stability analysis of MPs through molecular dynamics simulations, (3) modeling of MP complexes through docking, (4) prediction of interactions between MPs, and (5) MP interactions with its soluble partner are extensively used. Towards this end, MP docking is widely used. It is notable that the MP docking methods yet few in number might show greater potential in terms of filling the knowledge gap. In this chapter, MP docking methods and associated challenges have been reviewed to improve the applicability, accuracy, and the ability to model macromolecular complexes.

Variation of the detergent-binding capacity and phospholipid content of membrane proteins when purified in different detergents

Purified membrane proteins are ternary complexes consisting of protein, lipid, and detergent. Information about the amounts of detergent and endogenous phospholipid molecules bound to purified membrane proteins is largely lacking. In this systematic study, three model membrane proteins of different oligomeric states were purified in nine different detergents at commonly used concentrations and characterized biochemically and biophysically. Detergent-binding capacities and phospholipid contents of the model proteins were determined and compared. The insights on ternary complexes obtained from the experimental results, when put into a general context, are summarized as follows. 1), The amount of detergent and 2) the amount of endogenous phospholipids bound to purified membrane proteins are dependent on the size of the hydrophobic lipid-accessible protein surface areas and the physicochemical properties of the detergents used. 3), The size of the detergent and lipid belt surrounding the hydrophobic lipid-accessible surface of purified membrane proteins can be tuned by the appropriate choice of detergent. 4), The detergents n-nonyl-β-D-glucopyranoside and Cymal-5 have exceptional delipidating effects on ternary complexes. 5), The types of endogenous phospholipids bound to membrane proteins can vary depending on the detergent used for solubilization and purification. 6), Furthermore, we demonstrate that size-exclusion chromatography can be a suitable method for estimating the molecular mass of ternary complexes. The findings presented suggest a strategy to control and tune the numbers of detergent and endogenous phospholipid molecules bound to membrane proteins. These two parameters are potentially important for the successul crystallization of membrane proteins for structure determination by crystallographic approaches.

Simple screening method for improving membrane protein thermostability

Biochemical and biophysical analysis on integral membrane proteins often requires monodisperse and stable protein samples. Here we describe a method to characterize protein thermostability by measuring its melting temperature in detergent using analytical size-exclusion chromatography. This quantitative method can be used to screen for compounds and conditions that stabilize the protein. With this technique we were able to assess and improve the thermostability of several membrane proteins. These conditions were in turn used to assist purification, to identify protein ligand and to improve crystal quality.

Overcoming the challenges of membrane protein crystallography

Membrane protein structural biology is still a largely unconquered area, given that approximately 25% of all proteins are membrane proteins and yet less than 150 unique structures are available. Membrane proteins have proven to be difficult to study owing to their partially hydrophobic surfaces, flexibility and lack of stability. The field is now taking advantage of the high-throughput revolution in structural biology and methods are emerging for effective expression, solubilisation, purification and crystallisation of membrane proteins. These technical advances will lead to a rapid increase in the rate at which membrane protein structures are solved in the near future.

Controlled 2D crystallization of membrane proteins using methyl-β-cyclodextrin

High-resolution structural data of membrane proteins can be obtained by studying 2D crystals by electron crystallography. Finding the right conditions to produce these crystals is one of the major bottlenecks encountered in 2D crystallography. Many reviews address 2D crystallization techniques in attempts to provide guidelines for crystallographers. Several techniques including new approaches to remove detergent like the biobeads technique and the development of dedicated devices have been described (dialysis and dilution machines). In addition, 2D crystallization at interfaces has been studied, the most prominent method being the 2D crystallization at the lipid monolayer. A new approach based on detergent complexation by cyclodextrins is presented in this paper. To prove the ability of cyclodextrins to remove detergent from ternary mixtures (lipid, detergent and protein) in order to get 2D crystals, this method has been tested with OmpF, a typical beta-barrel protein, and with SoPIP2;1, a typical alpha-helical protein. Experiments over different time ranges were performed to analyze the kinetic effects of detergent removal with cyclodextrins on the formation of 2D crystals. The quality of the produced crystals was assessed with negative stain electron microscopy, cryo-electron microscopy and diffraction. Both proteins yielded crystals comparable in quality to previous crystallization reports.

Crystallization of bacteriorhodopsin solubilized by a tripod amphiphile

Bacteriorhodopsin (bR) is solubilized efficiently as a monomer by a novel surfactant, a tripod amphiphile (TPA), which permits the formation of purple hexagonal bR crystals under several conditions. The crystals, although small, diffract to 2.5 A resolution using synchrotron radiation. TPA may be useful for the solubilization, purification, and crystallization of other membrane proteins.

Role of glycosylation and membrane environment in nicotinic acetylcholine receptor stability

The effects of glycosylation and membrane environment on the structural stability of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) from Torpedo have been investigated to improve our understanding of factors that influence eukaryotic membrane protein crystallization. Gel shift assays and carbohydrate-specific staining show that the deglycosylation enzyme, Endo F1, removes at least 50% of membrane-reconstituted nAChR glycosylation. The extent of deglycosylation with Endo F1 increases upon detergent solubilization. Removal of between 60-100% of high mannose moieties from the nAChR has no effect on nAChR secondary structure, stability, or flexibility. Deglycosylation does not influence either agonist binding or the ability of the nAChR to undergo agonist-induced conformational change. In contrast, nAChR structural stability, flexibility, and function are all negatively influenced by simple changes in reconstituted membrane lipid composition. Our results suggest that deglycosylation may represent a feasible approach for enhancing the crystallizability of the nAChR. Our data also demonstrate that the dependence of nAChR structural stability on lipid environment may represent a significant obstacle to nAChR crystallization. Some membrane proteins may have evolved complex interactions with their lipid environments. Understanding the complexity of these interactions may be essential for devising an appropriate strategy for the crystallization of some membrane proteins.

Myelin basic protein-diverse conformational states of an intrinsically unstructured protein and its roles in myelin assembly and multiple sclerosis

The 18.5 kDa isoform of myelin basic protein (MBP) is a major component of the myelin sheath in the central nervous system of higher vertebrates, and a member of a larger family of proteins with a multiplicity of forms and post-translational modifications (PTMs). The 18.5 kDa protein is the exemplar of the family, being most abundant in adult myelin, and thus the most-studied. It is peripherally membrane-associated, but has generally been investigated in isolated form. MBP is an 'intrinsically unstructured' protein with a high proportion (approximately 75%) of random coil, but postulated to have core elements of beta-sheet and alpha-helix. We review here the properties of the MBP family, especially of the 18.5 kDa isoform, and discuss how its three-dimensional (3D) structure may be resolved by direct techniques available to us, viz., X-ray and electron crystallography, and solution and solid-state NMR spectrometry. In particular, we emphasise that creating an appropriate environment in which the protein can adopt a physiologically relevant fold is crucial to such endeavours. By solving the 3D structure of 18.5 kDa MBP and the effects of PTMs, we will attain a better understanding of myelin architecture, and of the molecular mechanisms that transpire in demyelinating diseases such as multiple sclerosis.

Solid-State NMR Spin Diffusion for Measurement of Membrane-Bound Peptide Structure: Gramicidin A

A recently developed solid-state NMR method for measurement of depths in membrane systems is applied to gramicidin A, a membrane-bound peptide of known structure, to investigate the potential of this method. (15)N-detected, (1)H spin diffusion experiments demonstrate the resolution of the technique by measuring the 4-5 A depth differences between three (15)N-labeled backbone sites (Trp13, Val7, Gly2) in gramicidin A. We also show that (13)C-detected, (1)H spin diffusion experiments on unlabeled gramicidin A are sufficient to discriminate between the end-to-end dimer and double-helix structures of gramicidin A. Thus, spin diffusion solid-state NMR experiments can provide a simple approach, which does not require labeled samples, for testing structural models of membrane-bound peptides.

The monotopic membrane protein human oxidosqualene cyclase is active as monomer

The monotopic integral membrane protein 2,3-oxidosqualene cyclase (OSC) catalyzes the formation of lanosterol the first sterol precursor of cholesterol in mammals. Therefore, it is an important target for the development of new hypocholesterolemic drugs. Here, we report the overexpression and purification of functional human OSC (hOSC) in Pichia pastoris. The obtained IC(50) for the reference inhibitor Ro 48-8071 is nearly identical for the recombinant hOSC compared to OSC from human liver microsomes. The correlation of analytical ultracentrifugation data and activity measurements showed the highest enzymatic activity for the monomeric hOSC indicating that this would be the natural form. Furthermore, these data helped us to identify the detergent for a successful crystallization of the protein. The availability of this active recombinant human membrane protein is a very important step on the way to a more detailed functional and structural characterization of OSCs.

Membrane protein crystallization

The need for high-resolution structure information on membrane proteins is immediate and growing. Currently, the only reliable way to get it is crystallographically. The rate-limiting step from protein to structure is crystal production. An overview of the current ideas and experimental approaches prevailing in the area of membrane protein crystallization is presented. The long-established surfactant-based method has been reviewed extensively and is not examined in detail here. The focus instead is on the latest methods, all of which exploit the spontaneous self-assembling properties of lipids and detergent as vesicles (vesicle-fusion method), discoidal micelles (bicelle method), and liquid crystals or mesophases (in meso or cubic-phase method). In the belief that a knowledge of the underlying phase science is integral to understanding the molecular basis of these assorted crystallization strategies, the article begins with a brief primer on lipids, mesophases, and phase science, and the related issue of form and function as applied to lipids is addressed. The experimental challenges associated with and the solutions for procuring adequate amounts of homogeneous membrane proteins, or parts thereof, are examined. The cubic-phase method is described from the following perspectives: how it is done in practice, its general applicability and successes to date, and the nature of the mesophases integral to the process. Practical aspects of the method are examined with regard to salt, detergent, and screen solution effects; crystallization at low temperatures; tailoring the cubic phase to suit the target protein; different cubic-phase types; dealing with low-protein samples, colorless proteins, microcrystals, and radiation damage; transport within the cubic phase for drug design, cofactor retention, and phasing; using spectroscopy for quality control; harvesting crystals; and miniaturization and robotization for high-throughput screening. The section ends with a hypothesis for nucleation and growth of membrane protein crystals in meso. Thus far, the bicelle and vesicle-fusion methods have produced crystals of one membrane protein, bacteriorhodopsin. The experimental details of both methods are reviewed and their general applicability in the future is commented on. The three new methods are rationalized by analogy to crystallization in microgravity and with respect to epitaxy. A list of Web resources in the area of membrane protein crystallogenesis is included.

Three-dimensional crystallization of the Escherichia coli glycerol-3-phosphate transporter: a member of the major facilitator superfamily

Here we report the successful three-dimensional crystallization of GlpT, the glycerol-3-phosphate transporter from Escherichia coli inner membrane. GlpT possesses 12 transmembrane alpha-helices and is a member of the major facilitator superfamily. It mediates the exchange of glycerol-3-phosphate for inorganic phosphate across the membrane. Approximately 20 phospholipid molecules per protein, identified as negatively charged phosphatidylethanolamine, phosphatidylglycerol, and cardiolipin, were required for the monodispersity of purified GlpT. Analytical size-exclusion chromatography proved to be efficient in identifying detergents for GlpT monodispersity. Nine such detergents were later used for GlpT crystallization. Screening for crystal nucleation was carried out with a variety of polyethylene glycols as the precipitant over a wide pH range. Subsequent identification of a rigid protein core by limited proteolysis and mass spectroscopy resulted in better-ordered crystals. These crystals exhibited order to 3.7 A resolution in two dimensions. However, the stacking in the third dimension was partially disordered. This stacking problem was overcome by using a detergent mixture and manipulating the ionic interactions in the crystallization solution. The resulting GlpT crystals diffracted isotropically to 3.3 A resolution and were suitable for structure determination by X-ray crystallography.

Practical aspects of overexpressing bacterial secondary membrane transporters for structural studies

Membrane transporter proteins play critical physiological roles in the cell and constitute 5-10% of prokaryotic and eukaryotic genomes. High-resolution structural information is essential for understanding the functional mechanism of these proteins. A prerequisite for structural study is to overexpress such proteins in large quantities. In the last few years, over 20 bacterial membrane transporters were overexpressed at a level of 1 mg/l of culture or higher, most often in Escherichia coli. In this review, we analyzed those factors that affect the quantity and quality of the protein produced, and summarized recent progress in overexpression of membrane transporters from bacterial inner membrane. Rapid progress in genome sequencing provides opportunities for expressing several homologues and orthologues of the target protein simultaneously, while the availability of various expression vectors allows flexible experimental design. Careful optimization of cell culture conditions can drastically improve the expression level and homogeneity of the target protein. New sample preparation techniques for mass spectrometry of membrane proteins have enabled one to identity the rigid protein core, which can be subsequently overexpressed. Size-exclusion chromatography on HPLC has proven to be an efficient method in screening detergent, pH an other conditions required for maintaining the stability and monodispersity of the protein. Such high-quality preparations of membrane transporter proteins will probably lead to successful crystallization and structure determination of these proteins in the next few years.

Integral membrane protein biosynthesis: why topology is hard to predict

Integral membrane protein biogenesis requires the coordination of several events: accurate targeting of the nascent chain to the membrane; recognition,orientation and integration of transmembrane (TM) domains; and proper formation of tertiary and quaternary structure. Initially unanticipated inter-and intra-protein interactions probably mediate each stage of biogenesis for single spanning, polytopic and C-terminally anchored membrane proteins. The importance of these regulated interactions is illustrated by analysis of topology prediction algorithm failures. Misassigned or misoriented TM domains occur because the primary sequence and overall hydrophobicity of a single TM domain are not the only determinants of membrane integration.

Stability of membrane proteins: relevance for the selection of appropriate methods for high-resolution structure determinations

High stability is a prominent characteristic of integral membrane proteins of known atomic structure. But rather than being an intrinsic property, it may be due to a selection exerted by biochemical procedures prior to structure determination, since solubilization results in the transient exposure of membrane proteins to solution conditions. This may cause structural perturbations that interfere with 3D crystallization and hence with X-ray analysis. This problem also affects the preparation of samples for electron crystallography and NMR studies and may account for the fact that high-resolution structures of representatives of whole groups, such as transport proteins and signal transducers, have not been elucidated so far by any method. A knowledge of the proportion of labile proteins among membrane proteins, and of the kinetics of their denaturation, is therefore necessary. Establishing stability profiles, developing methods to maintain lateral pressure, or preventing contact with water (or both) should prove significant in establishing the structures of conformationally flexible proteins.

Sarcolipin, the shorter homologue of phospholamban, forms oligomeric structures in detergent micelles and in liposomes

The human 31-amino acid integral membrane protein sarcolipin (SLN), which regulates the sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca-ATPase in fast-twitch skeletal muscle, was chemically synthesized. Appropriate synthesis and purification strategies were used to achieve high purity and satisfactory yields of this hydrophobic and poorly soluble protein. Structural and functional properties of SLN were analyzed and compared with the homologous region of human phospholamban (PLB) comprising residues Ala(24)-Leu(52) (PLB-(24-52)), the regulatory protein of the cardiac sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca-ATPase. Circular dichroism spectroscopy showed that SLN is a predominantly alpha-helical protein and that the secondary structure is highly resistant to SDS and thermal denaturation. In this respect SLN is remarkably similar to PLB-(24-52). However, SLN is monomeric in SDS gels, whereas PLB-(24-52) shows a monomer-pentamer equilibrium typical for native PLB. Analytical ultracentrifugation experiments revealed that SLN oligomerizes in the presence of the nonionic detergents octylpolyoxyethylene and octyl glucoside in a concentration-dependent manner. No plateau was observed, and a pentameric state was only reached at much higher protein concentrations compared with PLB-(24-52). Chemical cross-linking showed that also in liposomes SLN has the ability to self-associate to oligomers. PLB-(24-52) specifically oligomerized to pentamers in the presence of octylpolyoxyethylene as well as in liposomes at low protein concentrations. In the presence of octylpolyoxyethylene pentamers were the main oligomeric species, whereas in liposomes monomers and dimers were predominant. Increasing the protein concentration led to self-association of PLB-(24-52) pentamers in the presence of octylpolyoxyethylene. Functional reconstitution of Ca-ATPase with PLB-(24-52) and SLN in liposomes showed that both proteins regulate the Ca-ATPase in a similar manner.

Purification and characterization of human erythrocyte glucose transporter in decylmaltoside detergent solution

The facilitative glucose transporter from human erythrocyte membrane, Glut1, was purified by a novel method. The nonionic detergent decylmaltoside was selected for solubilization on the basis of its efficiency to extract Glut1 from the erythrocyte membrane and its ability to maintain the protein in a monodisperse state. A positive, anion-exchange chromatography protocol produced a Glut1 preparation of 95% purity with little copurified lipid. This protein preparation exhibited cytochalasin B binding in detergent solution, as measured by tryptophan fluorescence quenching. The transporter existed as a monomer in decylmaltoside, with a Stokes radius of 50 A and a molecular mass of 147 kDa for the protein-detergent complex. We screened detergent, pH, additive, and lipid and have found conditions to maintain Glut1 monodispersity for 8 days at 25 degrees C or over 5 weeks at 4 degrees C. This Glut1 preparation represents the best available material for two- and three-dimensional crystallization trials of the human glucose transporter protein.