The evolution of an allosteric site in phosphorylase

Structural basis of glycogen metabolism in bacteria

The evolution of metabolic pathways is a major force behind natural selection. In the spotlight of such process lies the structural evolution of the enzymatic machinery responsible for the central energy metabolism. Specifically, glycogen metabolism has emerged to allow organisms to save available environmental surplus of carbon and energy, using dedicated glucose polymers as a storage compartment that can be mobilized at future demand. The origins of such adaptive advantage rely on the acquisition of an enzymatic system for the biosynthesis and degradation of glycogen, along with mechanisms to balance the assembly and disassembly rate of this polysaccharide, in order to store and recover glucose according to cell energy needs. The first step in the classical bacterial glycogen biosynthetic pathway is carried out by the adenosine 5'-diphosphate (ADP)-glucose pyrophosphorylase. This allosteric enzyme synthesizes ADP-glucose and acts as a point of regulation. The second step is carried out by the glycogen synthase, an enzyme that generates linear α-(1→4)-linked glucose chains, whereas the third step catalyzed by the branching enzyme produces α-(1→6)-linked glucan branches in the polymer. Two enzymes facilitate glycogen degradation: glycogen phosphorylase, which functions as an α-(1→4)-depolymerizing enzyme, and the debranching enzyme that catalyzes the removal of α-(1→6)-linked ramifications. In this work, we rationalize the structural basis of glycogen metabolism in bacteria to the light of the current knowledge. We describe and discuss the remarkable progress made in the understanding of the molecular mechanisms of substrate recognition and product release, allosteric regulation and catalysis of all those enzymes.

Rational engineering of enzyme allosteric regulation through sequence evolution analysis

Control of enzyme allosteric regulation is required to drive metabolic flux toward desired levels. Although the three-dimensional (3D) structures of many enzyme-ligand complexes are available, it is still difficult to rationally engineer an allosterically regulatable enzyme without decreasing its catalytic activity. Here, we describe an effective strategy to deregulate the allosteric inhibition of enzymes based on the molecular evolution and physicochemical characteristics of allosteric ligand-binding sites. We found that allosteric sites are evolutionarily variable and comprised of more hydrophobic residues than catalytic sites. We applied our findings to design mutations in selected target residues that deregulate the allosteric activity of fructose-1,6-bisphosphatase (FBPase). Specifically, charged amino acids at less conserved positions were substituted with hydrophobic or neutral amino acids with similar sizes. The engineered proteins successfully diminished the allosteric inhibition of E. coli FBPase without affecting its catalytic efficiency. We expect that our method will aid the rational design of enzyme allosteric regulation strategies and facilitate the control of metabolic flux.

Design of allosterically regulatable enzyme is essential to develop a highly efficient metabolite production. However, mutations on allosteric ligand binding sites often disrupt the catalytic activity of enzyme. To aid the design process of allosterically controllable enzymes, we develop an effective computational strategy to deregulate the allosteric inhibition of enzymes based on sequence evolution analysis of allosteric ligand-binding sites. We analyzed the molecular evolution and amino acid composition of catalytic and allosteric sites of enzymes, and discovered that allosteric sites are evolutionarily variable and comprised of more hydrophobic residues than catalytic sites. We then experimentally tested our strategy of enzyme allosteric regulation and found that the designed mutations effectively deregulated allosteric inhibition of FBPase. We believe that our method will aid the rational design of enzyme allosteric regulation and help to facilitate control of metabolic flux.

Maize Phosphoenolpyruvate Carboxylase

Phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylases (PEPC, EC 4.1.1.31) from higher plants are regulated by both allosteric effects and reversible phosphorylation. Previous x-ray crystallographic analysis of Zea mays PEPC has revealed a binding site for sulfate ion, speculated to be the site for an allosteric activator, glucose 6-phosphate (Glc-6-P) (Matsumura, H., Xie, Y., Shirakata, S., Inoue, T., Yoshinaga, T., Ueno, Y., Izui, K., and Kai, Y. (2002) Structure (Lond.) 10, 1721-1730). Because kinetic experiments have also supported this notion, each of the four basic residues (Arg-183, -184, -231, and -372' on the adjacent subunit) located at or near the binding site was replaced by Gln, and the kinetic properties of recombinant mutant enzymes were investigated. Complete desensitization to Glc-6-P was observed for R183Q, R184Q, R183Q/R184Q (double mutant), and R372Q, as was a marked decrease in the sensitivity for R231Q. The heterotropic effect of Glc-6-P on an allosteric inhibitor, l-malate, was also abolished, but sensitivity to Gly, another allosteric activator of monocot PEPC, was essentially not affected, suggesting the distinctness of their binding sites. Considering the kinetic and structural data, Arg-183 and Arg-231 were suggested to be involved directly in the binding with phosphate group of Glc-6-P, and the residues Arg-184 and Arg-372 were thought to be involved in making up the site for Glc-6-P and/or in the transmission of an allosteric regulatory signal. Most unexpectedly, the mutant enzymes had almost lost responsiveness to regulatory phosphorylation at Ser-15. An apparent lack of kinetic competition between the phosphate groups of Glc-6-P and of phospho-Ser at 15 suggested the distinctness of their binding sites. The possible roles of these Arg residues are discussed.

Multidimensional NMR Identifies the Conformational Shift Essential for Catalytic Competence in the 60-kDa Drosophila melanogaster dUTPase Trimer

The catalytic mechanism of dUTP pyrophosphatase (dUTPase), responsible for the prevention of uracil incorporation into DNA, involves ordering of the flexible C terminus of the enzyme. This conformational shift is investigated by multidimensional NMR on the Drosophila enzyme. Flexible segments of the homotrimer give rise to sharp resonances in the (1)H-(15)N heteronuclear single-quantum coherence (HSQC) spectra, which are clearly distinguishable from the background resonances of the well folded protein globule. Binding of the product dUMP or the analogues dUDP and alpha,beta-imino-dUTP to the enzyme induces a conformational change reflected in the disappearance of eight sharp resonances. This phenomenon is interpreted as nucleotide binding-induced ordering of some residues upon the folded protein globule. Three-dimensional (15)N-edited (1)H-(15)N HSQC total correlation spectroscopy (TOCSY) and (1)H-(15)N HSQC nuclear Overhauser effect spectroscopy measurements allowed clear assignment of these eight specific resonance peaks. The residues identified correspond to the conserved C-terminal sequence motif, indicating that (i) this conformational shift is amenable to NMR studies in solution even in the large trimeric molecule and (ii) formation of the closed enzyme conformer in the case of the Drosophila enzyme does not require the complete triphosphate chain of the substrate. NMR titration of the enzyme with the nucleotide ligands as well as kinetic data indicated significant deviation from the model of independent active sites within the homotrimer. The results suggest allosterism in the eukaryotic dUTPase.

Transplanting allosteric control of enzyme activity by protein-protein interactions: coupling a regulatory site to the conserved catalytic core

Glycerol kinase from Escherichia coli, but not Haemophilus influenzae, is inhibited allosterically by phosphotransferase system protein IIA(Glc). The primary structures of these related kinases contain 501 amino acids, differing at 117. IIA(Glc) inhibition is transplanted from E. coli glycerol kinase into H. influenzae glycerol kinase by interconverting only 11 of the differences: 8 residues that interact with IIA(Glc) at the allosteric binding site and 3 residues in the conserved ATPase catalytic core that do not interact with IIA(Glc) but the solvent accessible surface of which decreases when it binds. The three core residues are crucial for coupling the allosteric site to the conserved catalytic core of the enzyme. The site of the coupling residues identifies a regulatory locus in the sugar kinase/heat shock protein 70/actin superfamily and suggests relations between allosteric regulation and the active site closure that characterizes the family. The location of the coupling residues provides empirical validation of a computational model that predicts a coupling pathway between the IIA(Glc)-binding site and the active site [Luque, I. & Freire, E. (2000) Proteins Struct. Funct. Genet. Suppl. 4, 63-71]. The requirement for changes in core residues to couple the allosteric and active sites and switching from inhibition to activation by a single amino acid change are consistent with a postulated mechanism for molecular evolution of allosteric regulation.

Structural relationships among regulated and unregulated phosphorylases

Species and tissue-specific isozymes of phosphorylase display differences in regulatory properties consistent with their distinct roles in particular organisms and tissues. In this review, we compare crystallographic structures of regulated and unregulated phosphorylases, including maltodextrin phosphorylase (MalP) from Escherichia coli, glycogen phosphorylase from yeast, and mammalian isozymes from muscle and liver tissues. Mutagenesis and functional studies supplement the structural work and provide insights into the structural basis for allosteric control mechanisms. MalP, a simple, unregulated enzyme, is contrasted with the more complicated yeast and mammalian phosphorylases that have evolved regulatory sites onto the basic catalytic architecture. The human liver and muscle isozymes show differences structurally in their means of invoking allosteric activation. Phosphorylation, though common to both the yeast and mammalian enzymes, occurs at different sites and activates the enzymes by surprisingly different mechanisms.

Altered subunit communication in subfamilies of trimeric dUTPases

The enzyme dUTPase is essential in preventing uracil incorporation into DNA. Design of antagonists against this novel chemotherapeutic target requires identification of species-specific differences in the structure and mechanism of the enzyme. This task is now approached via comparisons of available crystallographic structures of dUTPases from Homo sapiens, Escherichia coli, and retroviruses. The eukaryotic protein uniquely displays polar and charged amino acid residues participating in threefold intersubunit interactions. In bacterial and retroviral dUTPases, threefold interactions are mainly hydrophobic. The residues responsible for this contrast are mapped in multiple sequence alignment to positions differently and characteristically conserved in distinct evolutionary branches. The general feature of this contrast is further strengthened by a second eukaryotic model structure constructed using comparative modeling. The dUTPase cDNA from Drosophila melanogaster was identified, sequenced, and the model structure of the encoded polypeptide displayed a polar hydrogen-bonding network of threefold interactions, identically to the human structure. Results allow clear distinction between two subfamilies of trimeric dUTPases where altered subunit communication may account for a functional difference in the catalytic cycle.

Thermal denaturation pathway of starch phosphorylase from Corynebacterium callunae: oxyanion binding provides the glue that efficiently stabilizes the dimer structure of the protein

Starch phosphorylase from Corynebacterium callunae is a dimeric protein in which each mol of 90 kDa subunit contains 1 mol pyridoxal 5'-phosphate as an active-site cofactor. To determine the mechanism by which phosphate or sulfate ions bring about a greater than 500-fold stabilization against irreversible inactivation at elevated temperatures (> or = 50 degrees C), enzyme/oxyanion interactions and their role during thermal denaturation of phosphorylase have been studied. By binding to a protein site distinguishable from the catalytic site with dissociation constants of Ksulfate = 4.5 mM and Kphosphate approximately 16 mM, dianionic oxyanions induce formation of a more compact structure of phosphorylase, manifested by (a) an increase by about 5% in the relative composition of the alpha-helical secondary structure, (b) reduced 1H/2H exchange, and (c) protection of a cofactor fluorescence against quenching by iodide. Irreversible loss of enzyme activity is triggered by the release into solution of pyridoxal 5'-phosphate, and results from subsequent intermolecular aggregation driven by hydrophobic interactions between phosphorylase subunits that display a temperature-dependent degree of melting of secondary structure. By specifically increasing the stability of the dimer structure of phosphorylase (probably due to tightened intersubunit contacts), phosphate, and sulfate, this indirectly (1) preserves a functional active site up to approximately 50 degrees C, and (2) stabilizes the covalent protein cofactor linkage up to approximately 70 degrees C. The effect on thermostability shows a sigmoidal and saturatable dependence on the concentration of phosphate, with an apparent binding constant at 50 degrees C of approximately 25 mM. The extra stability conferred by oxyanion-ligand binding to starch phosphorylase is expressed as a dramatic shift of the entire denaturation pathway to a approximately 20 degrees C higher value on the temperature scale.

Distinct phosphorylation signals converge at the catalytic center in glycogen phosphorylases

BACKGROUND

Glycogen phosphorylases (GPs) catalyze the conversion of the storage form of carbohydrate (glycogen) to the readily usable form (glucose-1-phosphate) to provide cellular energy. Members of this enzyme family have evolved diverse regulatory mechanisms that control a conserved catalytic function. The mammalian and yeast GPs are expressed as inactive forms requiring phosphorylation for activation. Phosphorylation of yeast GP occurs at a distinct site from that of mammalian GP. This work addresses the structural basis by which distinct activation signals relay to the conserved catalytic site in yeast and mammalian GPs. Such knowledge may help understand the principles by which diverse biological regulation evolves.

RESULTS

We have compared the crystal structures of the unphosphorylated and phosphorylated forms of yeast GP and propose a relay which links phosphorylation to enzyme activation. Structural components along the activation relay becomes more conserved within the GP family downstream along the relay, towards the catalytic center. Despite distinct upstream activation signals, a response element downstream of the relay leading to the catalytic center is conserved in all GPs. The response element consists of ten hydrophobic residues dispersed over two subunits of the homodimer. Phosphorylation induces hydrophobic condensation of these residues via structural rearrangement, which triggers conformation change of the active site GATE loop, leading to enzyme activation.

CONCLUSIONS

Members of the GP family with diverse activation mechanisms have evolved from a constitutively active ancestral enzyme which has the TOWER hydrophobic response element in the active position. Diverse regulation evolved as a result of evolutionary constraint on the downstream response element in the active state, coupled with flexibility and variability in elements of the upstream relays.

The crystal structure of Escherichia coli maltodextrin phosphorylase provides an explanation for the activity without control in this basic archetype of a phosphorylase

In animals, glycogen phosphorylase (GP) exists in an inactive (T state) and an active (R state) equilibrium that can be altered by allosteric effectors or covalent modification. In Escherichia coli, the activity of maltodextrin phosphorylase (MalP) is controlled by induction at the level of gene expression, and the enzyme exhibits no regulatory properties. We report the crystal structure of E. coli maltodextrin phosphorylase refined to 2.4 A resolution. The molecule consists of a dimer with 796 amino acids per monomer, with 46% sequence identity to the mammalian enzyme. The overall structure of MalP shows a similar fold to GP and the catalytic sites are highly conserved. However, the relative orientation of the two subunits in E. coli MalP is different from both the T and R state GP structures, and there are significant changes at the subunit-subunit interfaces. The sequence changes result in loss of each of the control sites present in rabbit muscle GP. As a result of the changes at the subunit interface, the 280s loop, which in T state GP acts as a gate to control access to the catalytic site, is held in an open conformation in MalP. The open access to the conserved catalytic site provides an explanation for the activity without control in this basic archetype of a phosphorylase.

Control by phosphorylation

The two examples of phospho and dephospho proteins for which structural data were previously available (glycogen phosphorylase and isocitrate dehydrogenase) demonstrated two different mechanisms for control. In glycogen phosphorylase, activation by phosphorylation results in long-range allosteric changes. In isocitrate dehydrogenase, inhibition by phosphorylation is achieved by an electrostatic blocking mechanism with no conformational changes. During the past year, the structures of the phospho and dephospho forms of two more proteins, the cell cycle protein kinase CDK2 and yeast glycogen phosphorylase, have been determined. The new results highlight the importance of the phosphoamino acids both in the organization of local regions of protein structure through phosphate-arginine interactions and in the promotion of long-range conformational responses.