Elucidating the medium-resolution structure of ribosomal particles: an interplay between electron cryo-microscopy and X-ray crystallograhy

The linkage between ribosomal crystallography, metal ions, heteropolytungstates and functional flexibility

Crystallography of ribosomes, the universal cell nucleoprotein assemblies facilitating the translation of the genetic-code into proteins, met with severe problems owing to their large size, complex structure, inherent flexibility and high conformational variability. For the case of the small ribosomal subunit, which caused extreme difficulties, post crystallization treatment by minute amounts of a heteropolytungstate cluster allowed structure determination at atomic resolution. This cluster played a dual role in ribosomal crystallography: providing anomalous phasing power and dramatically increased the resolution, by stabilization of a selected functional conformation. Thus, four out of the fourteen clusters that bind to each of the crystallized small subunits are attached to a specific ribosomal protein in a fashion that may control a significant component of the subunit internal flexibility, by "gluing" symmetrical related subunits. Here we highlight basic issues in the relationship between metal ions and macromolecules and present common traits controlling in the interactions between polymetalates and various macromolecules, which may be extended towards the exploitation of polymetalates for therapeutical treatment.

Three-dimensional analysis of single particles by electron microscopy: sample preparation and data acquisition

Electron microscopy of single particles has recently become a very popular field in both biological and material sciences. It might be difficult for a novice researcher new to this field to know how to start tackling a new project. This chapter is designed to serve as a guideline for anyone starting a new project to determine a three-dimensional structure using single-particle techniques. The chapter describes the basic techniques necessary to prepare the samples and acquire the data to calculate a three-dimensional reconstruction in easy-to-understand, step-by-step instructions. It starts with the basic preparation of support films and the usage of a variety of staining techniques needed to assess the quality of the sample and the viability of the project. It ends with a detailed description of vitreous ice preparations designed to acquire high-resolution structural information. Guidelines and tips are given on how to record the best images with an electron microscope. Although this chapter is geared to researchers new to the field, experts might find it not only useful as a reference but also valuable because of the number of practical tips included.

Morphological variation of individual Escherichia coli 30S ribosomal subunits in vitro and in situ, as revealed by cryo-electron tomography

Cryo-electron tomography has been used to reconstruct the structures of individual ribosomal 30S subunits in Escherichia coli cells treated with rifampicin. Rifampicin inhibits transcription initiation, thus giving depletion of mRNA and accumulation of free 30S and 50S subunits in the cell. Here, we present the 3D morphologies of reconstructed individual 30S ribosomal subunits both in vitro and in situ from E. coli. The head, the platform, and the body of the structures show large conformational movements relative to each other. The particles were grouped into three conformational groups according to the ratio between width and height in the subunit solvent side view. Also, an S15 fusion protein derivative has been used as a physical reporter to localize S15 in the 30S subunit. The results demonstrate a considerable morphological heterogeneity and structural variability among 30S ribosomal subunits.

The structural basis of large ribosomal subunit function

The ribosome crystal structures published in the past two years have revolutionized our understanding of ribonucleoprotein structure, and more specifically, the structural basis of the peptide bonding forming activity of the ribosome. This review concentrates on the crystallographic developments that made it possible to solve these structures. It also discusses the information obtained from these structures about the three-dimensional architecture of the large ribosomal subunit, the mechanism by which it facilitates peptide bond formation, and the way antibiotics inhibit large subunit function. The work reviewed, taken as a whole, proves beyond doubt that the ribosome is an RNA enzyme, as had long been surmised on the basis of less conclusive evidence.

Ribosomal crystallography: peptide bond formation and its inhibition

Ribosomes, the universal cellular organelles catalyzing the translation of genetic code into proteins, are protein/RNA assemblies, of a molecular weight 2.5 mega Daltons or higher. They are built of two subunits that associate for performing protein biosynthesis. The large subunit creates the peptide bond and provides the path for emerging proteins. The small has key roles in initiating the process and controlling its fidelity. Crystallographic studies on complexes of the small and the large eubacterial ribosomal subunits with substrate analogs, antibiotics, and inhibitors confirmed that the ribosomal RNA governs most of its activities, and indicated that the main catalytic contribution of the ribosome is the precise positioning and alignment of its substrates, the tRNA molecules. A symmetry-related region of a significant size, containing about two hundred nucleotides, was revealed in all known structures of the large ribosomal subunit, despite the asymmetric nature of the ribosome. The symmetry rotation axis, identified in the middle of the peptide-bond formation site, coincides with the bond connecting the tRNA double-helical features with its single-stranded 3' end, which is the moiety carrying the amino acids. This thus implies sovereign movements of tRNA features and suggests that tRNA translocation involves a rotatory motion within the ribosomal active site. This motion is guided and anchored by ribosomal nucleotides belonging to the active site walls, and results in geometry suitable for peptide-bond formation with no significant rearrangements. The sole geometrical requirement for this proposed mechanism is that the initial P-site tRNA adopts the flipped orientation. The rotatory motion is the major component of unified machinery for peptide-bond formation, translocation, and nascent protein progression, since its spiral nature ensures the entrance of the nascent peptide into the ribosomal exit tunnel. This tunnel, assumed to be a passive path for the growing chains, was found to be involved dynamically in gating and discrimination.

The search and its outcome: high-resolution structures of ribosomal particles from mesophilic, thermophilic, and halophilic bacteria at various functional states

We determined the high-resolution structures of large and small ribosomal subunits from mesophilic and thermophilic bacteria and compared them with those of the thermophilic ribosome and the halophilic large subunit. We confirmed that the elements involved in intersubunit contacts and in substrate binding are inherently flexible and that a common ribosomal strategy is to utilize this conformational variability for optimizing its functional efficiency and minimizing nonproductive interactions. Under close-to-physiological conditions, these elements maintain well-ordered characteristic conformations. In unbound subunits, the features creating intersubunit bridges within associated ribosomes lie on the interface surface, and the features that bind factors and substrates reach toward the binding site only when conditions are ripe.

Ribosomal crystallography: from poorly diffracting microcrystals to high-resolution structures

The cellular organelles translating the genetic code into proteins, the ribosomes, are large, asymmetric, flexible, and unstable ribonucleoprotein assemblies, hence they are difficult to crystallize. Despite two decades of intensive effort and thorough searches for suitable sources, so far only three crystal types have yielded high-resolution structures: two large subunits (from an archaean and from a mesophilic eubacterium) and one thermophilic small subunit. These structures have added to our understanding of decoding, have revealed dynamic aspects of the biosynthetic process, and have indicated the strategies adopted by ribosomes for interacting between themselves as well as with inhibitors, factors and substrates.

Crystal structure of the 30 S ribosomal subunit from Thermus thermophilus: purification, crystallization and structure determination

We describe the crystallization and structure determination of the 30 S ribosomal subunit from Thermus thermophilus. Previous reports of crystals that diffracted to 10 A resolution were used as a starting point to improve the quality of the diffraction. Eventually, ideas such as the addition of substrates or factors to eliminate conformational heterogeneity proved less important than attention to detail in yielding crystals that diffracted beyond 3 A resolution. Despite improvements in technology and methodology in the last decade, the structure determination of the 30 S subunit presented some very challenging technical problems because of the size of the asymmetric unit, crystal variability and sensitivity to radiation damage. Some steps that were useful for determination of the atomic structure were: the use of anomalous scattering from the LIII edges of osmium and lutetium to obtain the necessary phasing signal; the use of tunable, third-generation synchrotron sources to obtain data of reasonable quality at high resolution; collection of derivative data precisely about a mirror plane to preserve small anomalous differences between Bijvoet mates despite extensive radiation damage and multi-crystal scaling; the pre-screening of crystals to ensure quality, isomorphism and the efficient use of scarce third-generation synchrotron time; pre-incubation of crystals in cobalt hexaammine to ensure isomorphism with other derivatives; and finally, the placement of proteins whose structures had been previously solved in isolation, in conjunction with biochemical data on protein-RNA interactions, to map out the architecture of the 30 S subunit prior to the construction of a detailed atomic-resolution model.

Cryo-electron microscopic localization of protein L7/L12 within the Escherichia coli 70 S ribosome by difference mapping and Nanogold labeling

The Escherichia coli ribosomal protein L7/L12 is central to the translocation step of translation, and it is known to be flexible under some conditions. The assignment of electron density to L7/L12 was not possible in the recent 2.4 A resolution x-ray crystallographic structure (Ban, N., Nissen, P., Hansen, J., Moore, P. B., and Steitz, T. A. (2000) Science 289, 905-920). We have localized the two dimers of L7/L12 within the structure of the 70 S ribosome using two reconstitution approaches together with cryo-electron microscopy and single particle reconstruction. First, the structures were determined for ribosomal cores from which protein L7/L12 had been removed by treatment with NH(4)Cl and ethanol and for reconstituted ribosomes in which purified L7/L12 had been restored to core particles. Difference mapping revealed that the reconstituted ribosomes had additional density within the L7/L12 shoulder next to protein L11. Second, ribosomes were reconstituted using an L7/L12 variant in which a single cysteine at position 89 in the C-terminal domain was modified with Nanogold (Nanoprobes, Inc.), a 14 A gold derivative. The reconstruction from cryo-electron microscopy images and difference mapping placed the gold at four interfacial positions. The finding of multiple sites for the C-terminal domain of L7/L12 suggests that the conformation of this protein may change during the steps of elongation and translocation.

Atomic structures at last: the ribosome in 2000

Last year, atomic structures of the 50S ribosomal subunit from Haloarcula marismortui and of the 30S ribosomal subunit from Thermus thermophilus were published. A year before that, a 7.8 A resolution electron density map of the 70S ribosome from T. thermophilus appeared. This information is revolutionizing our understanding of protein synthesis.

Determining the structure of biological macromolecules by transmission electron microscopy, single particle analysis and 3D reconstruction

Single particle analysis and 3D reconstruction of molecules imaged by transmission electron microscopy have provided a wealth of medium to low resolution structures of biological molecules and macromolecular complexes, such as the ribosome, viruses, molecular chaperones and photosystem II. In this review, the principles of these techniques are introduced in a non-mathematical way, and single particle analysis is compared to other methods used for structural studies. In particular, the recent X-ray structures of the ribosome and of ribosomal subunits allow a critical comparison of single particle analysis and X-ray crystallography. This has emphasised the rapidity with which single particle analysis can produce medium resolution structures of complexes that are difficult to crystallise. Once crystals are available, X-ray crystallography can produce structures at a much higher resolution. The great similarities now seen between the structures obtained by the two techniques reinforce confidence in the use of single particle analysis and 3D reconstruction, and show that for electron cryo-microscopy structure distortion during sample preparation and imaging has not been a significant problem. The ability to analyse conformational flexibility and the ease with which time-resolved studies can be performed are significant advantages for single particle analysis. Future improvements in single particle analysis and electron microscopy should increase the attainable resolution. Combining single particle analysis of macromolecular complexes and electron tomography of subcellular structures with high-resolution X-ray structures may enable us to realise the ultimate dream of structural biology-a complete description of the macromolecular complexes of the cell in their different functional states.

The bacterial ribosome at atomic resolution

X-ray crystallographic structures have just been published for the 30S ribosomal subunit of Thermus thermophilus at 3.4 A resolution and for the 50S subunit of Haloarcula marismortui at 2.4 A. These eagerly awaited structures will provide an enormous boost to research into the mechanisms involved in protein biosynthesis.

Structure of functionally activated small ribosomal subunit at 3.3 angstroms resolution

The small ribosomal subunit performs the decoding of genetic information during translation. The structure of that from Thermus thermophilus shows that the decoding center, which positions mRNA and three tRNAs, is constructed entirely of RNA. The entrance to the mRNA channel will encircle the message when a latch-like contact closes and contributes to processivity and fidelity. Extended RNA helical elements that run longitudinally through the body transmit structural changes, correlating events at the particle's far end with the cycle of mRNA translocation at the decoding region. 96% of the nucleotides were traced and the main fold of all proteins was determined. The latter are either peripheral or appear to serve as linkers. Some may assist the directionality of translocation.

The 3D arrangement of the 23 S and 5 S rRNA in the Escherichia coli 50 S ribosomal subunit based on a cryo-electron microscopic reconstruction at 7.5 A resolution

The Escherichia coli 23 S and 5 S rRNA molecules have been fitted helix by helix to a cryo-electron microscopic (EM) reconstruction of the 50 S ribosomal subunit, using an unfiltered version of the recently published 50 S reconstruction at 7.5 A resolution. At this resolution, the EM density shows a well-defined network of fine structural elements, in which the major and minor grooves of the rRNA helices can be discerned at many locations. The 3D folding of the rRNA molecules within this EM density is constrained by their well-established secondary structures, and further constraints are provided by intra and inter-rRNA crosslinking data, as well as by tertiary interactions and pseudoknots. RNA-protein cross-link and foot-print sites on the 23 S and 5 S rRNA were used to position the rRNA elements concerned in relation to the known arrangement of the ribosomal proteins as determined by immuno-electron microscopy. The published X-ray or NMR structures of seven 50 S ribosomal proteins or RNA-protein complexes were incorporated into the EM density. The 3D locations of cross-link and foot-print sites to the 23 S rRNA from tRNA bound to the ribosomal A, P or E sites were correlated with the positions of the tRNA molecules directly observed in earlier reconstructions of the 70 S ribosome at 13 A or 20 A. Similarly, the positions of cross-link sites within the peptidyl transferase ring of the 23 S rRNA from the aminoacyl residue of tRNA were correlated with the locations of the CCA ends of the A and P site tRNA. Sites on the 23 S rRNA that are cross-linked to the N termini of peptides of different lengths were all found to lie within or close to the internal tunnel connecting the peptidyl transferase region with the presumed peptide exit site on the solvent side of the 50 S subunit. The post-transcriptionally modified bases in the 23 S rRNA form a cluster close to the peptidyl transferase area. The minimum conserved core elements of the secondary structure of the 23 S rRNA form a compact block within the 3D structure and, conversely, the points corresponding to the locations of expansion segments in 28 S rRNA all lie on the outside of the structure.

Electrons and X-rays gang up on the ribosome

In all cells, protein synthesis is coordinated by the ribosome, and a number of pivotal structural studies on this complex have been completed during 1999. The combined results of the X-ray crystallography and electron microscopy studies have shed new light on the mechanism of this molecular machine.

Solution structure of the E. coli 70S ribosome at 11.5 A resolution

Over 73,000 projections of the E. coli ribosome bound with formyl-methionyl initiator tRNAf(Met) were used to obtain an 11.5 A cryo-electron microscopy map of the complex. This map allows identification of RNA helices, peripheral proteins, and intersubunit bridges. Comparison of double-stranded RNA regions and positions of proteins identified in both cryo-EM and X-ray maps indicates good overall agreement but points to rearrangements of ribosomal components required for the subunit association. Fitting of known components of the 50S stalk base region into the map defines the architecture of the GTPase-associated center and reveals a major change in the orientation of the alpha-sarcin-ricin loop. Analysis of the bridging connections between the subunits provides insight into the dynamic signaling mechanism between the ribosomal subunits.

Genetic and biochemical manipulations of the small ribosomal subunit from Thermus thermophilus HB8

Crystals of the small ribosomal subunit from Thermus thermophilus diffract to 3A and exhibit reasonable isomorphism and moderate resistance to irradiation. A 5A MIR map of this particle shows a similar shape to the part assigned to this particle within the cryo-EM reconstructions of the whole ribosome and contains regions interpretable either as RNA chains or as protein motifs. To assist phasing at higher resolution we introduced recombinant methods aimed at extensive selenation for MAD phasing. We are focusing on several ribosomal proteins that can be quantitatively detached by chemical means. These proteins can be modified and subsequently reconstituted into depleted ribosomal cores. They also can be used for binding heavy atoms, by incorporating chemically reactive binding sites, such as -SH groups, into them. In parallel we are co-crystallizing the ribosomal particles with tailor made ligands, such as antibiotics or cDNA to which heavy-atoms have been attached or diffuse the latter compounds into already formed crystals.

Direct three-dimensional localization and positive identification of RNA helices within the ribosome by means of genetic tagging and cryo-electron microscopy

BACKGROUND

Ribosomes are complex macromolecular machines that perform the translation of the genetic message. Cryo-electron microscopic (cryo-EM) maps of the Escherichia coli 70S ribosome are approaching a resolution of 10 A and X-ray maps of the 30S and 50S subunits are now available at 5 A. These maps show a lot of details about the inner architecture of the ribosome and ribosomal RNA helices are clearly visible. However, in the absence of further biological information, even at the higher resolution of the X-ray maps many rRNA helices can be placed only tentatively. Here we show that genetic tagging in combination with cryo-EM can place and orient double-stranded RNA helices with high accuracy.

RESULTS

A tRNA sequence inserted into the E. coli 23S ribosomal RNA gene, at one of the points of sequence expansion in eukaryotic ribosomes, is visible in the cryo-EM map as a peripheral 'foot' structure. By tracing its acceptor-stem end, the location of helix 63 in domain IV and helix 98 in domain VI of the 50S subunit could be precisely determined.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study demonstrates for the first time that features of a three-dimensional cryo-EM map of an asymmetric macromolecular complex can be interpreted in terms of secondary and primary structure. Using the identified helices as a starting point, it is possible to model and interpret, in molecular terms, a larger portion of the ribosome. Our results might be also useful in interpreting and refining the current X-ray maps.

The Escherichia coli large ribosomal subunit at 7.5 A resolution

BACKGROUND

In recent years, the three-dimensional structure of the ribosome has been visualised in different functional states by single-particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) at 13-25 A resolution. Even more recently, X-ray crystallography has achieved resolution levels better than 10 A for the ribosomal structures of thermophilic and halophilic organisms. We present here the 7.5 A solution structure of the 50S large subunit of the Escherichia coli ribosome, as determined by cryo-EM and angular reconstitution.

RESULTS

The reconstruction reveals a host of new details including the long alpha helix connecting the N- and C-terminal domains of the L9 protein, which is found wrapped like a collar around the base of the L1 stalk. A second L7/L12 dimer is now visible below the classical L7/L12 'stalk', thus revealing the position of the entire L8 complex. Extensive conformational changes occur in the 50S subunit upon 30S binding; for example, the L9 protein moves by some 50 A. Various rRNA stem-loops are found to be involved in subunit binding: helix h38, located in the A-site finger; h69, on the rim of the peptidyl transferase centre cleft; and h34, in the principal interface protrusion.

CONCLUSIONS

Single-particle cryo-EM is rapidly evolving towards the resolution levels required for the direct atomic interpretation of the structure of the ribosome. Structural details such as the minor and major grooves in rRNA double helices and alpha helices of the ribosomal proteins can already be visualised directly in cryo-EM reconstructions of ribosomes frozen in different functional states.

The small ribosomal subunit from Thermus thermophilus at 4.5 A resolution: pattern fittings and the identification of a functional site

The electron density map of the small ribosomal subunit from Thermus thermophilus, constructed at 4.5 A resolution, shows the recognizable morphology of this particle, as well as structural features that were interpreted as ribosomal RNA and proteins. Unbiased assignments, carried out by quantitative covalent binding of heavy atom compounds at predetermined sites, led to the localization of the surface of the ribosomal protein S13 at a position compatible with previous assignments, whereas the surface of S11 was localized at a distance of about twice its diameter from the site suggested for its center by neutron scattering. Proteins S5 and S7, whose structures have been determined crystallographically, were visually placed in the map with no alterations in their conformations. Regions suitable to host the fold of protein S15 were detected in several positions, all at a significant distance from the location of this protein in the neutron scattering map. Targeting the 16S RNA region, where mRNA docks to allow the formation of the initiation complex by a mercurated mRNA analog, led to the characterization of its vicinity.

Identification of 23S rRNA nucleotides neighboring the P-loop in the Escherichia coli 50S subunit

We report the synthesis of a radioactive, photolabile 2'-O-methyloligoRNA probe, 2258-53/52(SAz)-48, PHONT1, and its exploitation in identifying 23S rRNA nucleotides neighboring the so-called 'P-loop'. The probe is complementary to nt 2248-2258 in Escherichia coli 50S subunits. PHONT1 contains a p-azidophenacyl group attached to a phosphorothioate bridge between the nucleotides complementary to the positions 2252-2253, such that the photogenerated nitrene is maximally 17-19 A from 23S RNA nucleotides G2252 and G2253. PHONT1 binds to the 50S subunit, and photoincorporates within or immediately adjacent to its target site, as well as into several nucleotides falling between G2357 and A2430. The significance of these results for the structure of the peptidyl transferase center is considered. The PHONT approach is generally applicable to studies of complex RNA-containing molecules.

Metal compounds as tools for the construction and the interpretation of medium-resolution maps of ribosomal particles

Procedures were developed exploiting organometallic clusters and coordination compounds in combination with heavy metal salts for derivatization of ribosomal crystals. These enabled the construction of multiple isomorphous replacement (MIR) and multiple isomorphous replacement combined with anomalous scattering medium-resolution electron density maps for the ribosomal particles that yield the crystals diffracting to the highest resolution, 3 A, of the large subunit from Haloarcula marismortui and the small subunit from Thermus thermophilus. The first steps in the interpretation of the 7. 3-A MIR map of the small subunit were made with the aid of a tetrairidium cluster that was covalently attached to exposed sulfhydryls on the particle's surface prior to crystallization. The positions of these sulfhydryls were localized in difference Fourier maps that were constructed with the MIR phases.