The treatment of Zenker's diverticula: a review

Swallowing improvement surgeries

PURPOSE

To discuss the different swallowing improvement surgeries that address one or more dysfunctional pharyngolaryngeal structures causing dysphagia. These surgeries reduce the risk of aspiration without sacrificing vocal function.

METHODS

We searched the PubMed database and used Google Scholar search engine to find studies discussing the different swallowing improvement surgeries. A manual search of references in selected articles and reviews was done as well. No chronologic limitation was set for the studies; however, only articles written in English and Japanese were considered. Due to the nature of this article, no particular inclusion or exclusion criteria were set when searching for studies to be used as references; however, all relevant studies were reviewed and agreed upon by the authors for inclusion in this review article.

RESULTS/DISCUSSION

Surgeries to improve swallowing function can be categorized into those that reinforce nasopharyngeal closure or pharyngeal contraction, improve laryngeal elevation or pharyngoesophageal segment opening, and those that improve vocal fold closure to protect the airway during swallowing. They are an effective alternative treatment that may significantly improve these patients' quality of life. Swallowing rehabilitation with the altered pharyngolaryngeal structures is required post-operatively to significantly improve patients' dysphagia.

CONCLUSIONS

Surgeries to improve swallowing function address specific dysfunctional sites involved in the swallowing mechanism. Choosing the most appropriate surgery for each patient requires knowledge of the pathophysiology for their dysphagia and detailed pre-operative work-up.

Transoral endoscopic repair of Zenker diverticulum by a thoracic surgical service

OBJECTIVE

Zenker diverticulum (ZD), a pulsion diverticulum of the esophagus, has been traditionally managed with an open surgical approach, but endoscopic transoral stapling has been reported with increasing frequency. The objective of this study was to evaluate the results of endoscopic repair of ZD by a thoracic surgery service.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective review of patients who underwent transoral stapling repair of ZD at our institution by the thoracic surgery service. We evaluated perioperative outcomes including dysphagia (1, no dysphagia to 5, unable to swallow saliva) and failure of repair requiring surgical intervention.

RESULTS

A total of 151 patients (median age, 78 years; 75 men, 76 women) underwent evaluation for endoscopic repair of ZD. Endoscopic stapled repair of the ZD was completed in 135. Sixteen patients underwent conversion to open repair. The perioperative mortality was 0.6% (1 patient). The median hospital stay was 2 days (range, 0-18 days). Complications occurred in 5 patients who underwent endoscopic repair. The mean preoperative dysphagia score was 2.8 and improved to 1.2 during follow-up (median, 16 months; P < .001). During further follow-up (median, 52 months), 8 patients (5.3%) had failure of the endoscopic repair requiring open surgery (n = 5) or redo transoral stapling (n = 3).

CONCLUSIONS

Endoscopic stapling repair of ZD can be performed safely with good results in experienced centers by thoracic surgeons with significant esophageal experience. Long-term follow-up is required to evaluate the durability of endoscopic repair of ZD.

[Diverticulopexy for the treatment of Zenker's diverticulum]

Zenker's diverticulum is a pseudodiverticulum through a muscular defect in the posterior pharyngeal wall at the area between the inferior pharyngeal constrictor muscles of the pharynx and the cricopharyngeus muscle. Although endoscopic techniques have made significant progress, the surgical treatment remains the gold standard. There are two main techniques: diverticulectomy (resection of the diverticulum) and diverticulopexy. The main advantages of diverticulopexy are mostly linked to the absence of an esophageal anatomosis and its possible complications: cervical fistulae, mediastinitis, esophageal stenosis and wound infection, which allows a rapid recover with satisfactory oral intake. The purpose of this article is to describe in details the technique for diverticulopexy to the prevertebral ligament in association with a miotomy of the cricopharyngeus muscle.

Zenker's and epiphrenic diverticula in a patient with cutis laxa: should the surgical technique be modified?

Currently, most of esophageal diverticula arise as the result of a pulsion effect. Some esophageal motor disorders increase the intraluminal pressure and after some time, the diverticula grow through a weak point of esophageal wall. In these cases, the surgical treatment of choice is the myotomy associated with diverticulopexy or diverticulectomy. Adding a fundoplication is accepted to avoid the consequences of gastroesophageal reflux after myotomy in the epiphrenic diverticula surgery. There are other causes of esophageal diverticula that change the resistance of esophageal wall. Cutis laxa, a congenital or acquired connective disease, is a strange one. In our patient, a good result was reached modifying the standard technique accord to its ethiopathogenic mechanism.

Endoscopic treatment of pharyngo-esophageal diverticulum in child

Pharyngo-esophageal diverticula are extremely rare among children. Treatment in adults usually consists of endoscopic resection of the crico-pharyngeal muscle but application of this surgical procedure in children has not been reported before. We report the case of a 5-year-old boy whose recurrent pulmonary infection and chronic low weight led to diagnosis of a pharyngeal diverticulum. The diverticulum was removed by endoscopic CO(2) laser surgery. No relapse occurred during the 4-year follow-up period after surgery.

[Suspension diverticulopexy for Zenker's diverticulum]

INTRODUCTION

Zenker's diverticulum is an unusual condition. Its treatment requires surgery but there is no consensus regarding the various operative techniques. Through an open cervical approach, the diverticulum can be either resected or suspended with or without a concurrent myotomy of the cricopharyngeus muscle. An innovative option is endoscopic trans-oral stapled esophago-diverticulostomy.

PATIENTS

and method: We retrospectively reviewed a consecutive series of 36 patients operated on between 1988 and 2006. Median age was 77.5 years and M/F sex ratio was 1.4. Through an open neck approach, diverticulectomy without cricopharyngeal myotomy was performed in 7 patients, diverticulectomy with myotomy in 11, and diverticulopexy with myotomy in 18.

RESULTS

Morbidity rate was 13.8%. One fistula and one recurrence occurred in both diverticulectomy groups with and without myotomy. There was no morbidity after suspension diverticulopexy which also allowed earlier oral feeding (1 vs. 6 days) and shortened hospitalization (6 vs. 13.5 days).

CONCLUSION

Diverticulopexy with cricopharyngeus myotomy is an effective, reliable, and reproducible technique for the correction of Zenker's diverticula smaller than 5 cm. Diverticulectomy should be reserved for larger diverticula. Technical improvements of transoral stapled diverticulostomy are still required before it can be promoted as an alternative therapy.

Risk factors in patients undergoing cricopharyngeal myotomy

Background

Cricopharyngeal myotomy for oropharyngeal dysphagia is designed to improve symptoms, but the operation can result in significant morbidity and even death.

Methods

A retrospective analysis was carried out of all complications and deaths among 253 patients who had cricopharyngeal myotomy performed by a single surgeon.

Results

A single wound infection developed among 15 patients with neurological dysphagia. The same patient subsequently required laryngeal exclusion and tracheostomy. Of 139 patients treated for dysphagia secondary to muscular dystrophy, haematoma formation or infection occurred in four, and eight patients developed postoperative pulmonary complications, four of whom died from respiratory distress syndrome. Two patients with myogenic dysphagia required laryngeal exclusion with a permanent tracheostomy. Infection of the wound or retropharyngeal space was the main problem in 90 patients with a pharyngo-oesophageal diverticulum, affecting 9 per cent of the patients. Fistula was documented in three patients overall (1·2 per cent). Systemic morbidity unrelated to the technique occurred in 26 patients (10·3 per cent).

Conclusion

Pulmonary aspiration and lethal respiratory distress occurred only in patients with myogenic dysphagia. Local infection was the main complication in those with pharyngo-oesophageal diverticulum. Persistent aspiration can lead to laryngeal exclusion or resection with permanent tracheostomy.

Transcervical video-assisted resection of Zenker's diverticulum

We report a novel technique for resection of symptomatic Zenker's diverticulum. Two consecutive patients underwent a transcervical video-assisted dissection and resection of Zenker's diverticular pouch. Both patients exhibited good anatomical and functional results at 10 months follow-up.

Evolution of surgical treatment for pharyngeal pouch

BACKGROUND

The development of endoscopic techniques, particularly endoscopic stapling, has led to a re-evaluation of the treatment of pharyngeal pouch. The pathophysiology and treatment of the condition is reviewed.

METHODS

An electronic literature search was undertaken on the pathophysiology, history and surgery of pharyngeal pouch (Zenker's diverticulum). These last two terms were used to the search the Cochrane, Medline and Embase databases (from 1966 to date) and the bibliographies of extracted articles.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSION

With recognition of the central role of the cricopharyngeus muscle in the pathogenesis of pouch formation, the emphasis on treatment has shifted from diverticulectomy to cricopharyngeal myotomy. Minimally invasive techniques have become established since the advent of endoscopic stapling devices. Although randomized controlled data are lacking, the endoscopic approach appears to offer advantages in terms of a shorter duration of anaesthesia, more rapid resumption of oral intake, shorter hospital stay and quicker recovery. It is associated with excellent success rates and minimal morbidity.

Oesophageal diverticula

Oesophageal diverticula are rare. They are most commonly seen at the pharyngo-oesophageal junction (Zenker's diverticula) or at the distal oesophagus (epiphrenic diverticula). In both cases they are caused by altered motility which results in abnormal intraluminal pressure and the pushing of the oesophageal mucosa through focal weaknesses of the muscular wall (pulsion diverticula). The established surgical treatment for these diverticula therefore consists of eliminating the functional obstruction causing the disease (myotomy), associated with resection of the diverticulum (diverticulectomy) or its suspension (diverticulopexy). Recently, the spread of minimally invasive surgery has also led the application of such techniques to the treatment of oesophageal diverticula. Endoscopic diverticulostomy with stapler, laser or coagulation, through a rigid or flexible endoscope, has been demonstrated to be a valid treatment for Zenker's diverticula-as an alternative to surgery-especially in high-risk patients. On the other hand, laparoscopic treatment of epiphrenic diverticula has recently been introduced with encouraging results. However, because the disease is rare, more experience is required in order to allow definitive conclusions.

Management of pharyngoesophageal (Zenker's) diverticulum: which technique?

BACKGROUND

Incomplete symptomatic relief of pharyngoesophageal (Zenker's) diverticulum after endoscopic stapling or laser division has been reported by some authors. The clinical relevance of cricomyotomy, although supported by experimental data, remains controversial.

METHODS

Operative procedures consisted of transcervical resection (n = 34, group I), transcervical resection plus cricomyotomy (n = 12, group II), transcervical cricomyotomy (n = 8, group III), transcervical cricomyotomy plus diverticulopexy (n = 47, group IV), endoscopic stapling division (n = 31, group V), and endoscopic laser division (n = 55; group VI).

RESULTS

The percentage of totally asymptomatic patients was significantly (p < 0.004) higher after open procedures (combined groups I to IV) than after endoscopic treatment (combined groups V and VI) regardless of the size of the pouch (< 3 cm, 85% versus 25%; > or = 3 cm, 86% versus 50%). The percentage of patients with no or occasional (ie, fewer than twice a week) symptoms was significantly (p < 0.001) higher after open procedures (98%) than after endoscopic treatment (57%) for less than 3-cm diverticula whereas it was not higher (p = 0.409) for 3-cm or greater pouches (open, 97%; endoscopic, 88%). Furthermore, this percentage was similar (p > 0.286) after endoscopic stapling division and after endoscopic laser division (< 3 cm, 50% versus 58%; > or = 3 cm, 96% versus 80%). It was also similar (p > 0.197) after resection alone (group I) and after open operations including myotomy (combined groups II to IV) (< 3 cm, 100% versus 98%; > or = 3 cm, 92% versus 100%). Unlike endoscopic stapling and division, laser division was complicated by mediastinitis (2 patients), and 1 patient was referred because of cervical esophageal disruption during laser division. Five of six postoperative fistulas after resection occurred in patients who did not have myotomy, and 4 patients were referred 12 to 49 years after resection without myotomy for true recurrence of the pouch.

CONCLUSIONS

Open techniques afford better symptomatic relief than endoscopic techniques, especially in patients with small diverticula. Endoscopic stapling and division is safer than laser division. Although very effective at midterm, resection without myotomy predisposes to the development of postoperative fistula and to recurrence of the pouch after many years.

Perioperative care of the patient with Zenker's diverticulum

There are a variety of surgical approaches to treat the symptomatic patient with a Zenker's diverticulum. Approaches to treat Zenker's diverticula include external excision (i.e., diverticulectomy) with or without myotomy; diverticulopexy, an endoscopic approach; or cricopharyngeal myotomy alone. This article discusses esophageal diverticula, treatment modalities, and the perioperative care of patients with Zenker's diverticula.

Esophageal motor disorders

Motor dysfunction is responsible for symptomatic illnesses both in the proximal skeletal muscle region and in the distal smooth muscle esophagus. Practical methods for diagnosing and treating oropharyngeal dysphagia continue to reach consensus. Achalasia, the most significant of the distal motor disorders, is of investigative interest because of the expanded armamentarium of treatment options. Minimally invasive surgical methods have taken an important foothold as a primary treatment of this disorder. Appreciation is growing for sensory dysfunction that accompanies distal motor disorders. Such dysfunction may help explain the observed discrepancies between symptoms and measurable motility abnormality.