Measurement errors stemming from nonrespondents present at in-person interviews

Completing Self-Administered Questionnaires: Hmong Older Adults and Their Family Helpers

This study describes a method for collecting data from non-literate, non-English speaking populations. Our Audio computer-assisted self-interview instrument with color-labeled response categories was designed for use with a helper assistance. The study included 30 dyads of non-literate older Hmong respondents and family helpers answering questions about health. Analysis of video recordings identified respondents' problems and helpers' strategies to address these problems. Seven dyads displayed the paradigmatic question-answer sequence for all items, while 23 departed from the paradigmatic sequence at least once. Reports and pauses were the most common signs of problems displayed by respondents. Paraphrasing questions or response categories and providing examples were the most common helper strategies. Future research could assess the impact of helpers' strategies on data quality.

Sources of Error in Substance Use Prevalence Surveys

Population-based estimates of substance use patterns have been regularly reported now for several decades. Concerns with the quality of the survey methodologies employed to produce those estimates date back almost as far. Those concerns have led to a considerable body of research specifically focused on understanding the nature and consequences of survey-based errors in substance use epidemiology. This paper reviews and summarizes that empirical research by organizing it within a total survey error model framework that considers multiple types of representation and measurement errors. Gaps in our knowledge of error sources in substance use surveys and areas needing future research are also identified.

Alcohol consumption and rectal tumor mutations and epigenetic changes

PURPOSE

An association between alcohol and rectal cancer has been reported in the epidemiological literature. In this study we further explore the association by examining specific tumor markers with alcohol consumption as well as types of alcoholic beverages consumed.

METHODS

We assessed alcohol consumption with CpG Island Methylator Phenotype, TP53, and KRAS2 mutations in incident rectal cancer cases and compared them with population-based controls. We evaluated type, long-term, and recent alcohol consumption.

RESULTS

We observed a trend toward increasing risk of CpG Island Methylator Phenotype positive tumors and long-term alcohol consumption. In contrast, after adjusting for total alcohol intake, recent high beer consumption significantly increased the odds of having a TP53 mutation compared with those who did not drink beer (odds ratio, 1.97; 95% CI 1.24, 3.12). We observed a nonstatistically significant reduced risk of a TP53 mutation among those who drank wine (in particular, red wine) vs nonconsumers of wine. The association between TP53 mutations and recent beer consumption was strongest for transversion mutations.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that both alcohol and specific constituents of alcoholic beverages contribute to rectal cancer risk among unique disease pathways.

Association between different alcoholic beverages and leukoplakia among non- to moderate-drinking adults: A matched case–control study

While heavy drinking is a risk factor for oral leukoplakia, the effects of moderate drinking and of different alcoholic beverages are unclear and were investigated in this case-control study. 187 leukoplakia patients, aged 40-65 years, who were not heavy drinkers and did not change their drinking/smoking habits over the last decade, were age/gender matched to 187 controls. The effect of regular, moderate, overall alcohol, beer, wine, spirit drinking, adjusted for the effects of heavy smoking and other important co-variables, were assessed using conditional logistic regression analysis. Overall alcohol (OR, 0.22), wine (OR, 0.20), spirits (OR, 2.93) were significantly associated to leukoplakia. A statistically significant interaction wine/heavy smoking was also found. Such different effects could be explained by the ethanol antagonising potential of other drink components, such as polyphenols, abundant in red wine and scarce in spirits. Among heavy smokers, the preventive effect of wine was more than multiplicative.

Effect of environment and research participant characteristics on data quality

The purpose of this study, a component of a randomized clinical trial, was to assess the influence of the emergency department environment and participant characteristics on the accuracy of self-reported health care utilization. Interviews of 612 seniors aged 65 to 93 were conducted in two emergency departments. The research assistant, upon completion of each interview, rated characteristics of the emergency department and compared participants' self-reports of emergency department use and hospitalization during the previous 4 weeks with data from hospital records: 3.6% overreported and 2.2% underreported visits to the emergency department. Regarding hospitalizations, 2.6% overreported and 1.2% underreported. Discrepancies were associated with male gender, cognitive deficits, and risk status. Inconsistencies were not related to any of the environmental variables. These findings suggest that seniors without cognitive decline report reliable data even in a potentially challenging environment.