Incremental programming of atrial anti-tachycardia pacing therapies in bradycardia-indicated patients: effects on therapy efficacy and atrial tachyarrhythmia burden

EHRA White Paper: knowledge gaps in arrhythmia management—status 2019

Clinicians accept that there are many unknowns when we make diagnostic and therapeutic decisions. Acceptance of uncertainty is essential for the pursuit of the profession: bedside decisions must often be made on the basis of incomplete evidence. Over the years, physicians sometimes even do not realize anymore which the fundamental gaps in our knowledge are. As clinical scientists, however, we have to halt and consider what we do not know yet, and how we can move forward addressing those unknowns. The European Heart Rhythm Association (EHRA) believes that scanning the field of arrhythmia / cardiac electrophysiology to identify knowledge gaps which are not yet the subject of organized research, should be undertaken on a regular basis. Such a review (White Paper) should concentrate on research which is feasible, realistic, and clinically relevant, and should not deal with futuristic aspirations. It fits with the EHRA mission that these White Papers should be shared on a global basis in order to foster collaborative and needed research which will ultimately lead to better care for our patients. The present EHRA White Paper summarizes knowledge gaps in the management of atrial fibrillation, ventricular tachycardia/sudden death and heart failure.

New Insights into Long-Term Follow-Up of Atrial Fibrillation Ablation: Full Disclosure by an Implantable Pacemaker Device

INTRODUCTION

Long-term outcome of radiofrequency ablation (RFA) for atrial fibrillation (AF) is difficult to assess. This study sought to evaluate various aspects of very long-term follow-up (FU) by the properties of an implantable device.

METHODS

Fourteen patients with an implanted pacemaker device (Medtronic AT500) were selected for RFA, due to drug-refractory and highly symptomatic AF despite antibradycardic pacing.

RESULTS

With a mean FU of 41.4 +/- 15.1 months, we could achieve continuous monitoring for more than 400,000 hours after RFA. Based on symptomatic episodes, simulated 24-hour, 48-hour, or 7-day Holter, 57% to 71% of the patients were classified as RFA responders. With permanent FU provided by the implanted device, 43% of the patients exhibited a positive treatment effect and only 21% had no tachyarrhythmic episode at all in long-term FU. With a mean of 1.7 +/- 0.7 RFA per subject, atrial tachyarrhythmia burden (ATB) was significantly reduced from a median of 3.6 to 0.3 hours per day (P < 0.001). Two out of 14 patients developed AF recurrences after a tachyarrhythmia-free period of more than 12 months.

CONCLUSION

Continuous monitoring provided by an implantable device is able to detect significantly more AF episodes than routine FU. ATB is decreased significantly by (repeated) RFA over a very long-term FU. AF may reoccur very late after long-lasting (>1 year) episode-free intervals. A subgroup of patients with drug-aggravated bradycardia in brady-tachy syndrome might be considered for PV isolation rather than pacemaker implantation.

Role of High Frequency Atrial Pacing for the Termination of Acute Atrial Fibrillation and Atypical Atrial Flutter

BACKGROUND

The aim of this study was to assess the efficacy of high-frequency (HF) pacing from the right atrial appendage (RAA) or coronary sinus ostium (CS-Os) for the termination of acute atrial fibrillation (AF) and atypical atrial flutter (AAFL) during an electrophysiological (EP) study.

METHODS

128 episodes of acute fast atrial arrhythmias (FAAs; 93 AF and 35 AAFL) were analyzed in 110 patients. Patients were initially observed for 60s leading to spontaneous termination of 28 FAAs. The remaining 100 FAAs (70 AF) episodes were randomized to the following strategies: (A) pacing at RAA using up to 10 consecutive 20-Hz trains followed by the same stimulation protocol at CS-Os if RAA pacing failed, (B) pacing at CS-Os using the same stimulation protocol followed by HF pacing at RAA, or (C) observation up to 6 minutes ("no pacing").

RESULTS

The 20-Hz pacing at both RAA and CS-Os was associated with higher conversion of AAFL, as compared to strategy C (60% and 77% vs 11%; P < 0.05). Only HF pacing at CS-Os was superior to observation strategy for the conversion of AF (21% vs 4%; P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The 20-Hz pacing protocol is superior to observation strategy for interruption of either acute AF or acute AAFL episodes; however, its efficacy is higher in AAFLs. These results can be helpful for the termination of acute atrial tachyarrhythmias during EPstudy and should be further evaluated in patients with implantable devices capable of antitachycardia pacing.

Randomized comparison between Ramp and Burst+ atrial antitachycardia pacing therapies in patients suffering from sinus node disease and atrial fibrillation and implanted with a DDDRP device

AIMS

Atrial tachycardia and flutter frequently occur in association with atrial fibrillation and may be treated by overdrive pacing in patients who receive pacemakers with antitachycardia pacing (ATP) capabilities. The PITAGORA trial was a multi-centre, randomized, cross-over study aimed at comparing two different ATP modes for atrial tachyarrhythmia (AT) termination in patients suffering from sinus node disease (SND).

METHODS AND RESULTS

One hundred and seventy-six patients (72 M, age 71+/-9 years) received a Medtronic AT500 pacemaker. All patients were on class IC or III antiarrhythmic drugs. After a 5-month observation period, 170 patients were randomized to either Ramp or Burst+ ATP therapy; 4 months later they crossed over. One hundred and fifty-seven patients completed the 13 months of follow-up; 114 (72.6%) suffered 6088 AT episodes. In 75 patients, 1904 AT episodes were treated and 934 (49.1%) successfully terminated. The median value of individual patients' ATP efficacy was 60%. Burst+ terminated 387 out of 873 AT episodes (44%) in 58 patients. Ramp terminated 547 out of 1031 AT episodes (53%, P<0.001) in 56 patients. Ramp efficacy was significantly (P<0.01) and directly correlated with AT cycle length (ATCL), whereas Burst+ efficacy was not. Ramp showed higher (P<0.001) termination efficacy than Burst+ for ATCL >240 ms. Quality of life, as measured by the EuroQoL questionnaire, and number of symptoms significantly improved in the overall population. This improvement was significantly higher in patients with ATP efficacy >60%.

CONCLUSION

In patients suffering from SND and AT, Ramp therapy shows higher termination efficacy than Burst+ therapy in AT episodes with ATCL >240 ms. Further studies are required to show the impact of ATP on clinical outcomes.

Predictors of atrial antitachycardia pacing efficacy in patients affected by brady-tachy form of sick sinus syndrome and implanted with a DDDRP device

Predictors of ATP efficacy in brady/tachy patients.

BACKGROUND

Recent options to treat atrial tachyarrhythmias (ATA) include implantable devices delivering antitachycardia pacing therapies (ATP). No prospective study selected patients with higher chances of episode termination by ATP or indicated the most effective ATP use. Our aim was to study ATP efficacy in patients with brady-tachy form of sinus node disease (SND), identifying clinical factors, ATA characteristics, and device features predicting ATP efficacy.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Three hundred and sixteen patients (105 M, aged 71.1+/-8.8 years) received a DDDRP pacemaker and were prospectively followed. Median follow-up was 18 months: 37,125 ATA episodes occurred in 217 patients; ATP treated 5,536 of them. Overall, ATP efficacy was 50.0%. A multivariate analysis identified longer arrhythmia cycle lengths (OR=1.25; CI=1.07-1.47) and shorter delays to ATP delivery (OR=0.15; CI=0.10-0.22) as independent predictors of ATP efficacy for episodes preceded by >or=5 minutes of sinus rhythm. Additionally, ATP efficacy for all treated episodes was predicted by lower New York Heart Association (NYHA) class (OR=0.64; CI=0.42-0.98), episode classification as nonimmediate recurrence of ATA (non-IRAT) (OR=0.07; CI=0.02-0.33), absence of overlap in the device detection windows (OR=0.54; CI=0.32-0.91), and flecainide treatment (OR=2.22; CI=1.04-4.71).

CONCLUSIONS

In patients paced for SND, multivariate analysis shows that ATP efficacy is associated to longer arrhythmia cycle lengths, shorter ATP delivery delays, NYHA class I, episode classification as non-IRAT, absence of overlap in the atrial arrhythmia device detection windows, and flecainide treatment.

Device treatment of atrial tachycardia—minor additional effect of repeating pacing sequences

PURPOSE

Ramp and burst pacing as treatment for atrial tachycardia (AT), one known trigger mechanism of atrial fibrillation (AF) are available in permanent pacemakers to reduce the burden of AF. An analysis of the success rate of three consecutive antitachycardia pacing sequences is presented.

METHOD

The AT 500 (Medtronic) pacemaker was implanted in 36 patients (18 female, mean age 77+/-11 years) with pacemaker indication due to tachybrady arrhythmias (n=34), and other indications (n=2). A standardized AT treatment of 8 sequences of ramp followed by six and four sequences burst pacing was programmed on after 1 month of tachycardia detection only. 5 consecutive sinus beats or 3 min with atrial rhythm not classified as AF or AT defined treatment success and was registered at 3 months follow-up.

RESULTS

2979 episodes (mean 85+/-316) in 17 patients (7 female) were treated and analyzed. The overall treatment success increased from 42+/-27% to 44+/-31% and 45+/-31% during the consecutive ATP sequences (ns). The average ATP success of the first ramp pacing sequences was 95+/-10%, the second ramp ATP sequence was successful in 3+/-6%, and the last ramp ATP sequence in 2+/-5%.

CONCLUSION

95% of the 45% treatment success of a standard AT treatment was achieved by the first ramp pacing sequence. Further antitachycardia pacing sequences did not increase the success rate significantly.

Comparison of Induced and Spontaneous Atrial Tachyarrhythmias in Patients with a History of Spontaneous Atrial Tachyarrhythmias

INTRODUCTION

This retrospective study investigated whether induced episodes could be used to predict the morphology of future spontaneous atrial episodes.

METHODS

Eighty-two patients (64 +/- 12 years; 77% male; CAD in 60%; left ventricular ejection fraction 45 +/- 16%) with a history of atrial tachycardia or atrial fibrillation (AT/AF) were implanted with a dual-chamber implantable cardioverter defibrillator (ICD) and followed for 6 months. A total of 224 episodes of induced and spontaneous AT/AF were classified into type I, II, and III according to the method of Israel et al. and then compared based on average cycle length (CL) and atrial amplitude. Episodes were also grouped as "pace-terminable" or "nonpace-terminable" based on the CL definition of Gillis et al.

RESULTS

The analysis of 121 induced episodes (from 80 patients) and 103 spontaneous episodes (from 43 patients) showed that within each arrhythmia type, there were no significant differences in CL or mean amplitude between induced and spontaneous episodes. Additional analysis of patients that had both induced and spontaneous episodes (n = 41) showed 78% had at least one spontaneous episode that matched the induced episode. Fifty-seven percent of spontaneous episodes were considered to be pace-terminable based on CL.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data suggest that there is no significant difference between induced and spontaneous episodes of AT/AF of the same type. The majority of patients had at least one spontaneous episode of the same type as the induced episode, showing that induced atrial arrhythmias may be useful in predicting the morphology of future spontaneous episodes and in identifying patients potentially benefiting from atrial antitachycardia pacing.

Accuracy of Atrial Tachyarrhythmia Detection in Implantable Devices with Arrhythmia Therapies

The clinical application of atrial tachyarrhythmia (AT) episode data stored by implantable devices is presently limited by the high proportion of inappropriate detection. We quantified the percentage of inappropriate AT detection in two implantable devices with AT diagnostics and therapies via meta-analysis of stored AT episodes from a number of clinical trials. The AT500 and GEM III AT, contain dual chamber logic to discriminate AT from ventricular tachycardia and far-field R wave (FFRW) oversensing using dual chamber bipolar electrograms. A subset of data from four clinical trials of 1,142 patients was considered. Manual analysis was performed on 21,553 stored episodes with atrial EGM and marker channel from 409 patients with stored episodes and the market-released device detection configuration. The percentage of episodes with inappropriate detection and termination was evaluated and compared between septal and nonseptal lead locations. The percentage of inappropriately detected episodes receiving ATP therapy was also determined. The percentage of episodes appropriately detected and the percentage of net episode duration (i.e., burden) recorded by the device were also determined from a separate analysis of 24-hour Holter recordings from a subset of 40 patients from one trial. Adjusted estimates of the percentage of appropriate [corrected] detection were 95.3% (93.5-96.7; 95% CI) for AT500 and 95.7% (84.3-98.9) for GEM III AT. Inappropriate detection was primarily due to FFRW oversensing or brief runs of premature atrial contractions (PACs). The device detected 100% of the sustained atrial arrhythmia episodes and 95.3% (range 76.1-99.9) of the net AT duration observed on the Holter recordings. AT detection was not influenced by atrial lead location. Appropriate detection of normal sinus rhythm at episode termination was 83.7% (80.7-86.3) for AT500 and 92.1% (84.5-96.2) for GEM III AT. Accurate detection and discrimination of FFRWs validates the reliability of AT diagnostic data and decreases the risk of inappropriate device therapy.