Assessing the impact of a consensus conference on long-term therapy for schizophrenia

The current state of adult mental health care in France

Since the 1960s, French public mental health services are organised in "sectors", each sector catering for a mean population of 54,000 inhabitants. Although this organisation was aimed at insuring equal access to care whatever the place of residence, there are still huge disparities in number of staff and bed resources from one sector to another. The reduction in the number of hospital beds started later in France than in most other European countries, and was really effective in the 1990s. In 2000, there were 9.4 beds for 10,000 inhabitants aged over 20 years. Hospital-based care has still an overwhelming importance, and is associated with a marked under-development of community services and lack of sheltered housing for the most disabled patients. With more than 13,000 registered psychiatrists in France, the density of psychiatrists is one of the highest in the world. However, French psychiatry has currently to face a structural crisis due to the reduction in public health budgets, as well as to the reduction of 30% in the number of French psychiatrists over the next two decades. The numerous national programmes aimed at renovating French mental health services, published over the last decade, have not yet kept their promises.

Impact of CEDIT recommendations: An example of health technology assessment in a hospital network

Objectives: The objective of this study is to assess the impact of CEDIT (French Committee for the Assessment and Dissemination of Technological Innovations) recommendations on the introduction of technological innovations within the AP-HP (Assistance Publique–Hôpitaux de Paris), the French hospital network to which this body is attached.

Methods: In 2002, a study based on semidirective interviews of fourteen people affected by these recommendations and a case study relating to thirteen recommendations issued between 1995 and 1998 were conducted.

Results: The CEDIT is very scientifically reputable among interviewees. There is generally widespread interest for the recommendations. They are used as decision-making tools by administrative staff and as negotiating instruments by doctors in their dealings with management. Based on the case study, ten of thirteen recommendations had an impact on the introduction of the technology in health establishments. One recommendation appears not to have had an impact. Furthermore, the impact of two technologies was impossible to assess.

Conclusions: This study highlights the significant impact of recommendations arising from a structure that is attached to a hospital network and the good match between CEDIT's objectives and its assignments.

[Management of erysipelas in French hospitals: a post-consensus conference study]

INTRODUCTION

A prospective hospital-based survey on the management of bacterial dermal-hypodermal infections was conducted before the consensus conference "How should Erysipelas-Necrotic Fasciitis be managed?". The results of the survey were circulated early in 2001. To assess the eventual impact of the guidelines from the conference on hospital practices with regard to erysipelas, we conducted a new prospective survey at the end of 2002.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The questionnaire used was identical to that of the 2001 survey. It collected, anonymously, data on the clinical characteristics, supplementary examinations conducted (bacteriology, imaging), initial treatment and outcome. The questionnaire was mailed to the departments of dermatology, internal and/or infectious diseases and intensive care that had replied to the first survey (n = 124). The patients eligible for inclusion were those hospitalized between 09/01/2002 and 11/30/2002. Statistical analysis compared the results with those of the preceding survey.

RESULTS

The files of 245 patients were collected that came from 41 departments (15 from university hospitals, 23 from general hospitals and 3 from military hospitals) and 235 of whom had erysipelas. For those with erysipelas, the mean age was of 65 +/- 2.5 years, the M/F sex ratio was of 0.66 and the localization was the leg in 89.5 p. 100 of cases. A Doppler of the legs was performed in 33 p. 100 of cases. The initial antibiotherapy was penicillin G in 38 p. 100 of cases and pristinamycine in 18 p. 100 (others: 44 p. 100). The route of administration was initially intravenous in 73 p. 100 of cases. An anti-coagulant was associated in 60 p. 100. The outcome was favorable in 94 p. 100 of cases, with a mean duration of hospitalization of 11.2 +/- 1.2 days and antibiotics of 17.7 +/- 1.3 days. Dopplers and the blood cultures were performed more frequently than before the consensus conference, but no difference was found in the antibiotics or adjuvant therapies.

DISCUSSION

The follow-up survey showed the stability of hospital practices concerning erysipelas, notably with regard to treatment. In contrast, the clear tendency in limiting the supplementary examinations is in agreement with the consensus conference.

Overview of health technology assessment in France

Health technology assessment (HTA) in France covers a variety of activities performed for different customers (e.g., health professionals in the field and policy makers in government) for the benefit of patients. To promote the improvement of quality in health care, France has set up a series of distinct agencies that report to the Ministry of Health but are also accountable to their other customers. We place particular emphasis on ANAES (National Agency for Accreditation and Evaluation in Health) whose main remit is HTA. We show how the diversity of HTA activities and their decentralization suggests tight collaboration among all the different bodies which perform HTA or are closely involved with HTA, and we provide examples of such collaboration.

Do integrated mental healthcare organisations facilitate process quality in the treatment of people with schizophrenia and related psychoses?

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study is to investigate the influence of mergers of ambulatory and mental healthcare organisations on the process quality of care for persons suffering from schizophrenia or related psychoses.

THEORY

On the basis of the theory of Donabedian we assume the relationships between three types of quality in healthcare: structure quality, process quality and outcome quality. This study focuses on the influences of structure quality, i.e. years since merger and catchment area size upon process quality.

METHODS

Criteria according to Tugwell for evaluating healthcare were used to describe the process quality of schizophrenia care, resulting in a process quality questionnaire with 6 subscales and 21 items. Leading psychiatrists of 31 Dutch mental healthcare organisations, covering 89% of the country, answered the questionnaire. Both programmes and documents from the responding institutions and schizophrenia projects were analysed. Correlations of two determinants, age of the merged organisation and catchment area size, were made with total scale scores and the sub scores of the questionnaire.

RESULTS

The response rate was 97% (31/32). Twenty-two organisations (71%) had a score of more than 50% on the used scale, 8 (29%) scored less. Two evidence-based interventions were implemented in more than 50% of the organisations, three in less than 50%. A low degree of implementation occurs in establishing care for people with schizophrenia from ethnic minorities, standardising diagnostic procedures and continuity of care. No significant relationship between the age of the merged organisation ('age') and the total process quality of schizophrenia care was found, however, the relationships between age and the subscales availability of interventions and integrated treatment were significant. No association was found between the size of the MHO's catchment area and any of the used subscales.

CONCLUSIONS

The age of integration of residential and ambulatory mental health institutions correlates significantly with two subscales of process quality of schizophrenia care, i.e. availability of interventions and treatment. Catchment area size is not significantly associated with process quality or any of the subscales. Despite the mentioned positive effects, the overall picture of schizophrenia care is not very positive. Additional forces other than merely integration of ambulatory and residential services are needed for the further implementation of evidence-based interventions, diagnostic standards and continuity of care. The development of a national 'schizophrenia standard' (like in other countries) in relation with implementation plans and strategies to evaluate care on a regional level is recommended as well as further research on patient outcomes in relation to mergers of mental healthcare organisations.