A Comparison of Implicit Memory Tests in Schizophrenic Patients and Normal Controls

Implicit memory in schizophrenia: a meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

Previous studies examining implicit memory in schizophrenia yielded inconsistent results. The present meta-analysis aimed at determining whether, compared to healthy controls, schizophrenic patients: (a) exhibited reduced priming in the whole set of studies; (b) were differentially impaired in conceptual/perceptual and production/identification tests; and (c) were less efficient in the use of semantic encoding processes.

METHOD

A systematic search in PsycINFO and PubMed led to the selection of 22 critical studies (31 effect sizes), comparing repetition priming in 836 schizophrenic patients and 760 healthy controls. Moderators were assessed by classifying implicit tasks into the perceptual/conceptual and identification/production categories, and by distinguishing between perceptual and conceptual encoding instructions.

RESULTS

Overall, implicit memory was slightly, but significantly, impaired in schizophrenia (d=0.179). Patients exhibited reduced priming in conceptually-driven tasks (d=0.447), but intact priming in perceptually-driven tasks (d=0.080). No significant difference was observed between identification and production priming (d=0.064 vs. d=0.243). Finally, priming in schizophrenic patients was significantly lower than that of controls when the encoding task required the analysis of the conceptual properties of the stimuli (d=0.261).

CONCLUSION

Results suggest that schizophrenia is associated with a specific deficit in the use of conceptual processes, both at encoding and at retrieval. In contrast with theoretical expectations, high levels of response competition did not disproportionately impair the patients' performance.

Emotional effect on cognitive control in implicit memory tasks in patients with schizophrenia

The aim of this study was to reveal a potential effect of emotion on cognitive control in the implicit memory task with emotionally neutral and unpleasant words in healthy controls and patients with schizophrenia using a 3.0 T functional MRI (fMRI). A total of 15 patients with schizophrenia and 15 healthy controls underwent the fMRI. fMRI data were obtained while the participants performed the implicit memory tasks with emotionally neutral and unpleasant words. During the implicit memory retrieval with emotionally neutral words, the predominant activation areas observed in patients in contrast to healthy controls included the precuneus, superior parietal gyrus, and dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (dlPFC). In the implicit memory retrieval with unpleasant words, patients with schizophrenia showed dominant activities in the superior and middle temporal gyri, fusiform gyrus, supramarginal gyrus, postcentral gyrus, occipital gyrus, lingual gyrus, parahippocampal gyrus, amygdala, and insula as well as precuneus, superior parietal gyrus, and dlPFC. Blood-oxygen-level-dependent signal changes in the dlPFC were correlated positively with the scores of the negative symptoms under the PANSS during implicit memory retrieval with unpleasant words in patients with schizophrenia. These findings would be useful to understand the neural mechanisms related to general impairment of cognitive and emotional functions commonly observed in schizophrenia.

Is conceptual implicit memory impaired in schizophrenia? Evidence from lexical decision and category verification

INTRODUCTION

Implicit memory tasks differ along two orthogonal dimensions, tapping the relative involvement of perceptual/conceptual and identification/production processes. Previous studies have documented a dissociation between perceptual (spared) and conceptual (impaired) implicit memory, using in the latter case a production task (category exemplar generation), in which there is high response competition during the retrieval phase. The present study sought to determine whether the perceptual/conceptual dissociation held when comparing two identification tasks, in which there is no response competition at retrieval.

METHODS

In two experiments, repetition priming was assessed in 44 schizophrenic patients and 46 healthy controls in lexical decision (a test based on perceptual identification processes) and category verification (a test based on conceptual identification processes).

RESULTS

Schizophrenic patients achieved a priming as high as that of controls in the lexical decision task. In contrast, only controls exhibited significant priming in the category verification task.

CONCLUSIONS

It is concluded that schizophrenia is associated with a specific deficit in conceptual implicit memory, irrespective of the degree of response competition in the test phase.

Nonconscious processing and a novel target for schizophrenia research

Analysis of the pattern of altered cognition observed in schizophrenia provides better insight into neurocognitive deficits. It reveals a potential novel target for schizophrenia research. To understand this target we reviewed the findings of neuroimaging studies on implicit [nonconscious] memory. These studies have consistently reported attenuated activity in the area V3A of the extrastriate cortex during retrieval of studied items. It was suggested that the attenuation limits the pool of information available for further cognitive processing. Therefore, if V3A is functionally damaged, individuals will have access to a larger pool of information for cognitive processing. Since cognitive tasks that are not dependent on attention [attention independent] process a larger pool of information more efficiently, performance in these tasks is likely to improve after V3A is damaged. Conversely, tasks that are dependent on attentional resources are more efficient in processing smaller pool of information. Performance in these tasks therefore is expected to deteriorate if a large pool of information is made available following V3A damage. A review of cognitive performance in schizophrenia suggests that patients perform at above normal level in attention independent priming tasks and perform at subnormal level in attention dependent episodic and working memory tasks. These findings indicate possible impairment of V3A activity. It could therefore be a potentially important unstudied target for schizophrenia research, particularly because a number of investigators have reported that the activity in this area is altered in schizophrenia.

Memory blocking in schizophrenia reflects deficient retrieval control mechanisms

Retrieval interference and orthographic processing were evaluated in schizophrenia, schizotypal personality disorder, and non-psychiatric control participants using a word fragment completion paradigm. Participants studied solutions and later completed corresponding fragments preceded by solutions, orthographically similar blocking words, or ampersands. Although schizophrenia patients completed fewest fragments, they showed equivalent repetition priming and blocking magnitude, supporting intact orthographic processing. Schizophrenia patients were more likely to commit intrusions in the blocking condition, whereas control participants displayed better mental control because they were more likely to withhold the response. These results suggest schizophrenia patients show abnormal functioning of control mechanisms responsible for selection and inhibition of competitors.

Conceptual implicit memory impaired in amnestic mild cognitive impairment patient

Explicit memory has been well proven to be impaired in amnestic mild cognitive impairment (aMCI), and conceptual implicit memory is impaired in Alzheimer's disease. However, it is unclear whether implicit memory is affected in aMCI. In the present study, 35 patients with aMCI and 35 healthy elderly subjects were administered a neuropsychological battery of tests including conceptual and perceptual implicit memory tasks (category exemplar generation, image identification) as well as explicit memory tasks. Patients with aMCI exhibited impairment in explicit memory tasks and selective impairment in conceptual priming tasks, while the effect of perceptual priming was preserved. More importantly, category exemplar generation task priming, but not perceptual priming, was positively correlated with verbal fluency test performance in the aMCI group. The dissociation between the 2 components of implicit priming suggests that conceptual priming impairment in aMCI patients may be related to frontal lobe dysfunction.

Declarative and nondeclarative memory in schizophrenia: What is impaired? What is spared?

The study's aim was to assess a broad range of declarative and nondeclarative memory functions in schizophrenia to identify areas of impairment versus relative preservation. Participants included 40 schizophrenia outpatients and 30 demographically comparable community residents. All participants were administered a battery assessing declarative memory (verbal learning, working memory, semantic memory, remote memory, verbal retention) and nondeclarative memory (procedural learning, priming). To control for order effects, the battery was divided into three parts of approximately equal length with order of administration counterbalanced across study participants. The results showed persons with schizophrenia to be significantly impaired relative to community residents in verbal learning, working memory, semantic memory, remote memory, and priming. In contrast, the two groups were comparable in verbal retention and procedural learning. In the schizophrenia group, priming ability best discriminated past year's vocational status. In sum, the findings indicate a specific pattern of impairment and preservation of memory functioning in schizophrenia. Skill (procedural) learning and retention of learned, declarative verbal information across a delay appear intact, while all other areas measured appear impaired.