Single-Molecule Studies of the Linker Histone H1 Binding to DNA and the Nucleosome

Linker histone H1.0 loads onto nucleosomes through multiple pathways that are facilitated by histone chaperones

Linker histone H1 is an essential chromatin architectural protein that compacts chromatin into transcriptionally silent regions by interacting with nucleosomal and linker DNA, while rapidly exchanging in vivo. How H1 targets nucleosomes while being dynamic remains unanswered. Using a single-molecule strategy, we investigated human H1.0 interactions with DNA and nucleosomes. H1.0 directly binds nucleosomes and naked DNA with a preference toward nucleosomes. DNA-bound H1.0 exhibited a range of bound lifetimes with both mobile and immobile states, where the mobile H1.0 did not load onto nucleosomes. The histone chaperone Nap1 facilitated H1.0-nucleosome loading by enabling H1.0 loading through DNA sliding, reducing DNA resident times without impacting nucleosome resident times, increasing mobility along DNA, and targeting H1.0 loading onto the nucleosome dyad. These findings reveal linker histones load onto nucleosomes through multiple distinct mechanisms that are facilitated by chaperones to regulate chromatin accessibility.

Histone H3 Tail Modifications Alter Structure and Dynamics of the H1 C-Terminal Domain Within Nucleosomes

The highly positively charged and intrinsically disordered H1 C-terminal domain (CTD) undergoes extensive condensation upon binding to nucleosomes, and stabilizes nucleosomes and higher-order chromatin structures but its interactions in chromatin are not well defined. Using single-molecule FRET we found that about half of the H1 CTDs in H1-nucleosome complexes exhibit well-defined FRET values indicative of distinct, static conformations, while the remainder of the population exhibits exchange between multiple defined FRET structures. Moreover, crosslinking studies indicate that the first 30 residues of the H1 CTD participate in relatively localized contacts with the first ∼25 bp of linker DNA, and that two separate regions in the CTD contribute to H1-dependent organization of linker DNA. Finally, we show that acetylation mimetics within the histone H3 tail markedly reduce the overall extent of H1 CTD condensation and significantly increase the fraction of H1 CTDs undergoing dynamic exchange between FRET states. Our results indicate the nucleosome-bound H1 CTD adopts loosely defined structures that exhibit significantly enhanced dynamics and decondensation upon epigenetic acetylation within the H3 tail.

Spontaneous histone exchange between nucleosomes

The nucleosome is the fundamental gene-packing unit in eukaryotes. Nucleosomes comprise ∼147 bp DNA wrapped around an octameric histone protein core composed of two H2A-H2B dimers and one (H3-H4)2 tetramer. The strong yet flexible DNA-histone interactions are the physical basis of the dynamic regulation of genes packaged in chromatin. The dynamic nature of DNA-histone interactions also implies that nucleosomes dissociate DNA-histone contacts both transiently and repeatedly. This kinetic instability may lead to spontaneous nucleosome disassembly or histone exchange between nucleosomes. At high nucleosome concentrations, nucleosome-nucleosome collisions and subsequent histone exchange would be a more likely event, where nucleosomes could act as their own histone chaperone. This spontaneous histone exchange could serve as a mechanism for maintaining overall chromatin stability, although it has never been reported. Here we employed three-color single-molecule FRET (smFRET) to demonstrate that histone H2A-H2B dimers are exchanged spontaneously between nucleosomes on a time scale of a few tens of seconds at a physiological nucleosome concentration. We show that the rate of histone exchange increases at a higher monovalent salt concentration, with histone-acetylated nucleosomes, and in the presence of histone chaperone Nap1, while it remains unchanged at a higher temperature, and decreases upon DNA methylation. These results support the notion of histone exchange via transient and repetitive partial disassembly of the nucleosome and corroborate spontaneous histone diffusion in a compact chromatin context, modulating the local concentrations of histone modifications and variants.

Methods to investigate nucleosome structure and dynamics with single-molecule FRET

The nucleosome is the fundamental building block of chromatin. Changes taking place at the nucleosome level are the molecular basis of chromatin transactions with various enzymes and factors. These changes are directly and indirectly regulated by chromatin modifications such as DNA methylation and histone post-translational modifications including acetylation, methylation, and ubiquitylation. Nucleosomal changes are often stochastic, unsynchronized, and heterogeneous, making it very difficult to monitor with traditional ensemble averaging methods. Diverse single-molecule fluorescence approaches have been employed to investigate the structure and structural changes of the nucleosome in the context of its interactions with various enzymes such as RNA Polymerase II, histone chaperones, transcription factors, and chromatin remodelers. We utilize diverse single-molecule fluorescence methods to study the nucleosomal changes accompanying these processes, elucidate the kinetics of these processes, and eventually learn the implications of various chromatin modifications in directly regulating these processes. The methods include two- and three-color single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET), single-molecule fluorescence correlation spectroscopy, and fluorescence (co-)localization. Here we report the details of the two- and three-color single-molecule FRET methods we currently use. This report will help researchers design their single-molecule FRET approaches to investigating chromatin regulation at the nucleosome level.

Development of Convergent Hybrid Phase Ligation for Efficient and Convenient Total Synthesis of Proteins

Simple and efficient total synthesis of homogeneous and chemically modified protein samples remains a significant challenge. Here, we report development of a convergent hybrid phase native chemical ligation (CHP-NCL) strategy for facile preparation of proteins. In this strategy, proteins are split into ~100-residue blocks, and each block is assembled on solid support from synthetically accessible peptide fragments before ligated together into full-length protein in solution. With the new method, we increase the yield of CENP-A synthesis by 2.5-fold compared to the previous hybrid phase ligation approach. We further extend the new strategy to the total chemical synthesis of 212-residue linker histone H1.2 in unmodified, phosphorylated, and citrullinated forms, each from eight peptide segments with only one single purification. We demonstrate that fully synthetic H1.2 replicates the binding interactions of linker histones to intact mononucleosomes, as a proxy for the essential function of linker histones in the formation and regulation of higher order chromatin structure.

Histone H3 tail modifications regulate structure and dynamics of the H1 C-terminal domain within nucleosomes

Despite their importance, how linker histone H1s interact in chromatin and especially how the highly positively charged and intrinsically disordered H1 C-terminal domain (CTD) binds and stabilizes nucleosomes and higher-order chromatin structures remains unclear. Using single-molecule FRET we found that about half of the H1 CTDs in H1-nucleosome complexes exhibit well-defined FRET values indicative of distinct, static conformations, while the remainder of the population exhibits dynamically changing values, similar to that observed for H1 in the absence of nucleosomes. We also find that the first 30 residues of the CTD participate in relatively localized interactions with the first ∼20 bp of linker DNA, and that two separate regions in the CTD contribute to H1-dependent organization of linker DNA, consistent with some non-random CTD-linker DNA interactions. Finally, our data show that acetylation mimetics within the histone H3 tail induce decondensation and enhanced dynamics of the nucleosome-bound H1 CTD. (148 words).

Spontaneous Histone Exchange Between Nucleosomes

The nucleosome is the fundamental gene-packing unit in eukaryotes. Nucleosomes comprise ∼147 bp DNA wrapped around an octameric histone protein core composed of two H2A-H2B dimers and one (H3-H4) ₂ tetramer. The strong yet flexible DNA-histone interactions are a physical basis of the dynamic regulation of genes packaged in chromatin. The dynamic nature of DNA-histone interactions implies that nucleosomes dissociate DNA-histone contacts transiently and repeatedly. This kinetic instability may lead to spontaneous nucleosome disassembly or histone exchange between nucleosomes. At a high nucleosome concentration, nucleosome-nucleosome collisions and subsequent histone exchange would be a more likely pathway, where nucleosomes act as their own histone chaperone. The spontaneous histone exchange would serve as a mechanism for maintaining the overall chromatin stability although it has never been reported. We employed three-color single-molecule FRET (smFRET) to demonstrate that histone H2A-H2B dimers are exchanged spontaneously between nucleosomes and that the time scale is on a few tens of seconds at a physiological nucleosome concentration. The rate of histone exchange increases at a higher monovalent salt concentration, with histone acetylated nucleosomes, and in the presence of histone chaperone Nap1, while it remains unchanged at a higher temperature, and decreases upon DNA methylation. These results support histone exchange via transient and repetitive partial disassembly of the nucleosome and corroborate spontaneous histone diffusion in a compact chromatin context, modulating the local concentrations of histone modifications and variants.

DNA Sequence-Dependent Binding of Linker Histone gH1 Regulates Nucleosome Conformations

Sequence-dependent binding between DNA and proteins in chromatin is an essential part of gene expression. Linker histone H1 is an important protein in the regulation of chromatin compartmentalization and compaction, and its binding with the nucleosome is sensitive to the DNA sequence. Although the interactions of H1 and DNA have been widely investigated, the mechanism of nucleosome conformation changes induced by the DNA-sequence-dependent binding with gH1 (globular H1.0) remains largely unclear at the atomic level. In the present molecular dynamics simulations, both linker and dyad DNAs were mutated to investigate the conformational changes of the nucleosome induced by the sequence-dependent binding of gH1 based on the on-dyad binding mode. Our results indicate that gH1 is insensitive to the DNA sequence of the dyad DNA but presents an apparent preference to linker DNA with an AT-rich sequence. Moreover, this specific binding induces the entry/exit region of a nucleosome to a tight conformation and regulates the accessibility of core histones. Considering that the entry/exit region of the nucleosome is a crucial binding site for many functional proteins related to gene expression, the conformational change at this region could represent an important gene regulation signal.

Loop extrusion driven volume phase transition of entangled chromosomes

Experiments on reconstituted chromosomes have revealed that mitotic chromosomes are assembled even without nucleosomes. When topoisomerase II (topo II) is depleted from such reconstituted chromosomes, these chromosomes are not disentangled and form "sparklers," where DNA and linker histone are condensed in the core and condensin is localized at the periphery. To understand the mechanism of the assembly of sparklers, we here take into account the loop extrusion by condensin in an extension of the theory of entangled polymer gels. The loop extrusion stiffens an entangled DNA network because DNA segments in the elastically effective chains are translocated to loops, which are elastically ineffective. Our theory predicts that the loop extrusion by condensin drives the volume phase transition that collapses a swollen entangled DNA gel because the stiffening of the network destabilizes the swollen phase. This may be an important piece to understand the mechanism of the assembly of mitotic chromosomes.

DOT1L activity in leukemia cells requires interaction with ubiquitylated H2B that promotes productive nucleosome binding

DOT1L methylates histone H3 lysine 79 during transcriptional elongation and is stimulated by ubiquitylation of histone H2B lysine 120 (H2BK120ub) in a classical trans-histone crosstalk pathway. Aberrant genomic localization of DOT1L is implicated in mixed lineage leukemia (MLL)-rearranged leukemias, an aggressive subset of leukemias that lacks effective targeted treatments. Despite recent atomic structures of DOT1L in complex with H2BK120ub nucleosomes, fundamental questions remain as to how DOT1L-ubiquitin and DOT1L-nucleosome acidic patch interactions observed in these structures contribute to nucleosome binding and methylation by DOT1L. Here, we combine bulk and single-molecule biophysical measurements with cancer cell biology to show that ubiquitin and cofactor binding drive conformational changes to stimulate DOT1L activity. Using structure-guided mutations, we demonstrate that ubiquitin and nucleosome acidic patch binding by DOT1L are required for cell proliferation in the MV4; 11 leukemia model, providing proof of principle for MLL targeted therapeutic strategies.

Epigenetic-Mediated Regulation of Gene Expression for Biological Control and Cancer: Cell and Tissue Structure, Function, and Phenotype

Epigenetic gene regulatory mechanisms play a central role in the biological control of cell and tissue structure, function, and phenotype. Identification of epigenetic dysregulation in cancer provides mechanistic into tumor initiation and progression and may prove valuable for a variety of clinical applications. We present an overview of epigenetically driven mechanisms that are obligatory for physiological regulation and parameters of epigenetic control that are modified in tumor cells. The interrelationship between nuclear structure and function is not mutually exclusive but synergistic. We explore concepts influencing the maintenance of chromatin structures, including phase separation, recognition signals, factors that mediate enhancer-promoter looping, and insulation and how these are altered during the cell cycle and in cancer. Understanding how these processes are altered in cancer provides a potential for advancing capabilities for the diagnosis and identification of novel therapeutic targets.

Physical Chemistry of Epigenetics: Single-Molecule Investigations

The nucleosome is the fundamental building block of the eukaryotic genome, composed of an ∼147 base-pair DNA fragment wrapping around an octameric histone protein core. DNA and histone proteins are targets of enzymatic chemical modifications that serve as signals for gene regulation. These modifications are often referred to as epigenetic modifications that govern gene activities without altering the DNA sequence. Although the term epigenetics initially required inheritability, it now frequently includes noninherited histone modifications associated with gene regulation. Important epigenetic modifications for healthy cell growth and proliferation include DNA methylation, histone acetylation, methylation, phosphorylation, ubiquitination, and SUMOylation (SUMO = Small Ubiquitin-like Modifier). Our research focuses on the biophysical roles of these modifications in altering the structure and structural dynamics of the nucleosome and their implications in gene regulation mechanisms. As the changes are subtle and complex, we employ various single-molecule fluorescence approaches for their investigations. Our investigations revealed that these modifications induce changes in the structure and structural dynamics of the nucleosome and their thermodynamic and kinetic stabilities. We also suggested the implications of these changes in gene regulation mechanisms that are the foci of our current and future research.

Single-molecule FRET method to investigate the dynamics of transcription elongation through the nucleosome by RNA polymerase II

Transcription elongation through the nucleosome is a precisely coordinated activity to ensure timely production of RNA and accurate regulation of co-transcriptional histone modifications. Nucleosomes actively participate in transcription regulation at various levels and impose physical barriers to RNA polymerase II (RNAPII) during transcription elongation. Despite its high significance, the detailed dynamics of how RNAPII translocates along nucleosomal DNA during transcription elongation and how the nucleosome structure dynamically conforms to the changes necessary for RNAPII progression remain poorly understood. Transcription elongation through the nucleosome is a complex process and investigating the changes of the nucleosome structure during this process by ensemble measurements is daunting. This is because it is nearly impossible to synchronize elongation complexes within a nucleosome or a sub-nucleosome to a designated location at a high enough efficiency for desired sample homogeneity. Here we review our recently developed single-molecule FRET experimental system and method that has fulfilled this deficiency. With our method, one can follow the changes in the structure of individual nucleosomes during transcription elongation. We demonstrated that this method enables the detailed measurements of the kinetics of transcription elongation through the nucleosome and its regulation by a transcription factor, which can be easily extended to investigations of the roles of environmental variables and histone post-translational modifications in regulating transcription elongation.

How Protein Binding Sensitizes the Nucleosome to Histone H3K56 Acetylation

The nucleosome, the fundamental gene-packing unit comprising an octameric histone protein core wrapped with DNA, has a flexible structure that enables dynamic gene regulation mechanisms. Histone lysine acetylation at H3K56 removes a positive charge from the histone core where it interacts with the termini of the nucleosomal DNA and acts as a critical gene regulatory signal that is implicated in transcription initiation and elongation. The predominant proposal for the biophysical role of H3K56 acetylation (H3K56ac) is that weakened electrostatic interaction between DNA termini and the histone core results in facilitated opening and subsequent disassembly of the nucleosome. However, this effect alone is too weak to account for the strong coupling between H3K56ac and its regulatory outcomes. Here we utilized a semisynthetically modified nucleosome with H3K56ac in order to address this discrepancy. Based on the results, we propose an innovative mechanism by which the charge neutralization effect of H3K56ac is significantly amplified via protein binding. We employed three-color single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer (smFRET) to monitor the opening rate of nucleosomal DNA termini induced by binding of histone chaperone Nap1. We observed an elevated opening rate upon H3K56ac by 5.9-fold, which is far larger than the 1.5-fold previously reported for the spontaneous opening dynamics in the absence of Nap1. Our proposed mechanism successfully reconciles this discrepancy because DNA opening for Nap1 binding must be larger than the average spontaneous opening. This is a novel mechanism that can explain how a small biophysical effect of histone acetylation results in a significant change in protein binding rate.

Tetratricopeptide repeat domain 7A is a nuclear factor that modulates transcription and chromatin structure

A loss-of-function mutation in tetratricopeptide repeat domain 7A (TTC7A) is a recently identified cause of human intestinal and immune disorders. However, clues to related underlying molecular dysfunctions remain elusive. It is now shown based on the study of TTC7A-deficient and wild-type cells that TTC7A is an essential nuclear protein. It binds to chromatin, preferentially at actively transcribed regions. Its depletion results in broad range of epigenomic changes at proximal and distal transcriptional regulatory elements and in altered control of the transcriptional program. Loss of WT_TTC7A induces general decrease in chromatin compaction, unbalanced cellular distribution of histones, higher nucleosome accessibility to nuclease digestion along with genome instability, and reduced cell viability. Our observations characterize for the first time unreported functions for TTC7A in the nucleus that exert a critical role in chromatin organization and gene regulation to safeguard healthy immune and intestinal status.

Single-molecule kinetic analysis of HP1-chromatin binding reveals a dynamic network of histone modification and DNA interactions

Chromatin recruitment of effector proteins involved in gene regulation depends on multivalent interaction with histone post-translational modifications (PTMs) and structural features of the chromatin fiber. Due to the complex interactions involved, it is currently not understood how effectors dynamically sample the chromatin landscape. Here, we dissect the dynamic chromatin interactions of a family of multivalent effectors, heterochromatin protein 1 (HP1) proteins, using single-molecule fluorescence imaging and computational modeling. We show that the three human HP1 isoforms are recruited and retained on chromatin by a dynamic exchange between histone PTM and DNA bound states. These interactions depend on local chromatin structure, the HP1 isoforms as well as on PTMs on HP1 itself. Of the HP1 isoforms, HP1α exhibits the longest residence times and fastest binding rates due to DNA interactions in addition to PTM binding. HP1α phosphorylation further increases chromatin retention through strengthening of multivalency while reducing DNA binding. As DNA binding in combination with specific PTM recognition is found in many chromatin effectors, we propose a general dynamic capture mechanism for effector recruitment. Multiple weak protein and DNA interactions result in a multivalent interaction network that targets effectors to a specific chromatin modification state, where their activity is required.

Single-Molecule Investigations on Histone H2A-H2B Dynamics in the Nucleosome

Nucleosomes impose physical barriers to DNA-templated processes, playing important roles in eukaryotic gene regulation. DNA is packaged into nucleosomes by histone proteins mainly through strong electrostatic interactions that can be modulated by various post-translational histone modifications. Investigating the dynamics of histone dissociation from the nucleosome and how it is altered upon histone modifications is important for understanding eukaryotic gene regulation mechanisms. In particular, histone H2A-H2B dimer displacement in the nucleosome is one of the most important and earliest steps of histone dissociation. Two conflicting hypotheses on the requirement for dimer displacement are that nucleosomal DNA needs to be unwrapped before a dimer can displace and that a dimer can displace without DNA unwrapping. In order to test the hypotheses, we employed three-color single-molecule FRET and monitored in a time-resolved manner the early kinetics of H2A-H2B dimer dissociation triggered by high salt concentration and by histone chaperone Nap1. The results reveal that dimer displacement requires DNA unwrapping in the vast majority of the nucleosomes in the salt-induced case, while dimer displacement precedes DNA unwrapping in >60% of the nucleosomes in the Nap1-mediated case. We also found that acetylation at histone H4K16 or H3K56 affects the kinetics of Nap1-mediated dimer dissociation and facilitates the process both kinetically and thermodynamically. On the basis of these results, we suggest a mechanism by which histone chaperone facilitates H2A-H2B dimer displacement from the histone core without requiring another factor to unwrap the nucleosomal DNA.

Chromatin structure-dependent conformations of the H1 CTD

Linker histones are an integral component of chromatin but how these proteins promote assembly of chromatin fibers and higher order structures and regulate gene expression remains an open question. Using Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) approaches we find that association of a linker histone with oligonucleosomal arrays induces condensation of the intrinsically disordered H1 CTD in a manner consistent with adoption of a defined fold or ensemble of folds in the bound state. However, H1 CTD structure when bound to nucleosomes in arrays is distinct from that induced upon H1 association with mononucleosomes or bare double stranded DNA. Moreover, the H1 CTD becomes more condensed upon condensation of extended nucleosome arrays to the contacting zig-zag form found in moderate salts, but does not detectably change during folding to fully compacted chromatin fibers. We provide evidence that linker DNA conformation is a key determinant of H1 CTD structure and that constraints imposed by neighboring nucleosomes cause linker DNAs to adopt distinct trajectories in oligonucleosomes compared to H1-bound mononucleosomes. Finally, inter-molecular FRET between H1s within fully condensed nucleosome arrays suggests a regular spatial arrangement for the H1 CTD within the 30 nm chromatin fiber.