Mechanistic Basis of the Fast Dark Recovery of the Short LOV Protein DsLOV from Dinoroseobacter shibae

Reduction midpoint potential of a paradigm light-oxygen-voltage receptor and its modulation by methionine residues

Light-dependent adaptations of organismal physiology, development, and behavior abound in nature and depend on sensory photoreceptors. As one class, light-oxygen-voltage (LOV) photoreceptors harness flavin-nucleotide chromophores to sense blue light. Photon absorption drives the LOV receptor to its signaling state, characterized by a metastable thioadduct between the flavin and a conserved cysteine residue. With this cysteine absent, LOV receptors instead undergo photoreduction to the flavin semiquinone which however can still elicit downstream physiological responses. Irrespective of the cysteine presence, the LOV photochemical response thus entails a formal reduction of the flavin. Against this backdrop, we here investigate the reduction midpoint potential E 0 in the paradigmatic LOV2 domain from Avena sativa phototropin 1 (AsLOV2), and how it can be deliberately varied. Replacements of residues at different sites near the flavin by methionine consistently increase E 0 from its value of around -280 mV by up to 40 mV. Moreover, methionine introduction invariably impairs photoactivation efficiency and thus renders the resultant AsLOV2 variants less light-sensitive. Although individual methionine substitutions also affect the stability of the signaling state and downstream allosteric responses, no clear-cut correlation with the redox properties emerges. With a reduction midpoint potential near -280 mV, AsLOV2 and, by inference, other LOV receptors may be partially reduced inside cells which directly affects their light responsiveness. The targeted modification of the chromophore environment, as presently demonstrated, may mitigate this effect and enables the design of LOV receptors with stratified redox sensitivities.

Conserved Signal Transduction Mechanisms and Dark Recovery Kinetic Tuning in the Pseudomonadaceae Short Light, Oxygen, Voltage (LOV) Protein Family

Light-Oxygen-Voltage (LOV) flavoproteins transduce a light signal into variable signaling outputs via a structural rearrangement in the sensory core domain, which is then relayed to fused effector domains via α-helical linker elements. Short LOV proteins from Pseudomonadaceae consist of a LOV sensory core and N- and C-terminal α-helices of variable length, providing a simple model system to study the molecular mechanism of allosteric activation. Here we report the crystal structures of two LOV proteins from Pseudomonas fluorescens - SBW25-LOV in the fully light-adapted state and Pf5-LOV in the dark-state. In a comparative analysis of the Pseudomonadaceae short LOVs, the structures demonstrate light-induced rotation of the core domains and splaying of the proximal A'α and Jα helices in the N and C-termini, highlighting evidence for a conserved signal transduction mechanism. Another distinguishing feature of the Pseudomonadaceae short LOV protein family is their highly variable dark recovery, ranging from seconds to days. Understanding this variability is crucial for tuning the signaling behavior of LOV-based optogenetic tools. At 37 °C, SBW25-LOV and Pf5-LOV exhibit adduct state lifetimes of 1470 min and 3.6 min, respectively. To investigate this remarkable difference in dark recovery rates, we targeted three residues lining the solvent channel entrance to the chromophore pocket where we introduced mutations by exchanging the non-conserved amino acids from SBW25-LOV into Pf5-LOV and vice versa. Dark recovery kinetics of the resulting mutants, as well as MD simulations and solvent cavity calculations on the crystal structures suggest a correlation between solvent accessibility and adduct lifetime.

Machine Learning-Assisted Engineering of Light, Oxygen, Voltage Photoreceptor Adduct Lifetime

Naturally occurring and engineered flavin-binding, blue-light-sensing, light, oxygen, voltage (LOV) photoreceptor domains have been used widely to design fluorescent reporters, optogenetic tools, and photosensitizers for the visualization and control of biological processes. In addition, natural LOV photoreceptors with engineered properties were recently employed for optimizing plant biomass production in the framework of a plant-based bioeconomy. Here, the understanding and fine-tuning of LOV photoreceptor (kinetic) properties is instrumental for application. In response to blue-light illumination, LOV domains undergo a cascade of photophysical and photochemical events that yield a transient covalent FMN-cysteine adduct, allowing for signaling. The rate-limiting step of the LOV photocycle is the dark-recovery process, which involves adduct scission and can take between seconds and days. Rational engineering of LOV domains with fine-tuned dark recovery has been challenging due to the lack of a mechanistic model, the long time scale of the process, which hampers atomistic simulations, and a gigantic protein sequence space covering known mutations (combinatorial challenge). To address these issues, we used machine learning (ML) trained on scarce literature data and iteratively generated and implemented experimental data to design LOV variants with faster and slower dark recovery. Over the three prediction-validation cycles, LOV domain variants were successfully predicted, whose adduct-state lifetimes spanned 7 orders of magnitude, yielding optimized tools for synthetic (opto)biology. In summary, our results demonstrate ML as a viable method to guide the design of proteins even with limited experimental data and when no mechanistic model of the underlying physical principles is available.

Light-Controlled Biocatalysis by Unspecific Peroxygenases with Genetically Encoded Photosensitizers

Fungal unspecific peroxygenases (UPOs) have gained substantial attention for their versatile oxyfunctionalization chemistry paired with impressive catalytic capabilities. A major drawback, however, remains their sensitivity towards their co-substrate hydrogen peroxide, necessitating the use of smart in situ hydrogen peroxide generation methods to enable efficient catalysis setups. Herein, we introduce flavin-containing protein photosensitizers as a new general tool for light-controlled in situ hydrogen peroxide production. By genetically fusing flavin binding fluorescent proteins and UPOs, we have created two virtually self-sufficient photo-enzymes (PhotUPO). Subsequent testing of a versatile substrate panel with the two divergent PhotUPOs revealed two stereoselective conversions. The catalytic performance of the fusion protein was optimized through enzyme and substrate loading variation, enabling up to 24300 turnover numbers (TONs) for the sulfoxidation of methyl phenyl sulfide. The PhotUPO concept was upscaled to a 100 mg substrate preparative scale, enabling the extraction of enantiomerically pure alcohol products.

Residue alterations within a conserved hydrophobic pocket influence light, oxygen, voltage photoreceptor dark recovery

Light, oxygen, voltage (LOV) photoreceptors are widely distributed throughout all kingdoms of life, and have in recent years, due to their modular nature, been broadly used as sensor domains for the construction of optogenetic tools. For understanding photoreceptor function as well as for optogenetic tool design and fine-tuning, a detailed knowledge of the photophysics, photochemistry, and structural changes underlying the LOV signaling paradigm is instrumental. Mutations that alter the lifetime of the photo-adduct signaling state represent a convenient handle to tune LOV sensor on/off kinetics and, thus, steady-state on/off equilibria of the photoreceptor (or optogenetic switch). Such mutations, however, should ideally only influence sensor kinetics, while being benign with regard to the nature of the structural changes that are induced by illumination, i.e., they should not result in a disruption of signal transduction. In the present study, we identify a conserved hydrophobic pocket for which mutations have a strong impact on the adduct-state lifetime across different LOV photoreceptor families. Using the slow cycling bacterial short LOV photoreceptor PpSB1-LOV, we show that the I48T mutation within this pocket, which accelerates adduct rupture, is otherwise structurally and mechanistically benign, i.e., light-induced structural changes, as probed by NMR spectroscopy and X-ray crystallography, are not altered in the variant. Additional mutations within the pocket of PpSB1-LOV and the introduction of homologous mutations in the LOV photoreceptor YtvA of Bacillus subtilis and the Avena sativa LOV2 domain result in similarly altered kinetics. Given the conserved nature of the corresponding structural region, the here identified mutations should find application in dark-recovery tuning of optogenetic tools and LOV photoreceptors, alike.

Graphical abstract

Selective Photoinduced Dimerization and Slow Recovery of a BLUF Domain of EB1

The EAL-BLUF fragment from Magnetococcus marinus BldP1 (EB1) light-dependently hydrolyzes c-di-GMP. Herein, the photoreaction of the BLUF domain of EB1 (eBLUF) is studied. It is found for the first time that a monomeric BLUF domain forms a dimer upon illumination and its dark recovery is very slow. The dimer of light- and dark-state protomers (LD-dimer) is much more stable than that of two light-state protomers (LL-dimer), and the dark recovery of the LD-dimer is approximately 20 times slower than that of the LL-dimer, which is suitable for optogenetic tools. The secondary structure of the L-monomer is different from those of the D-monomer and the LD-dimer. The transient grating measurements reveal that this conformational change occurs simultaneously with dimerization. Although the W91A mutant exhibits a spectral red shift, it forms a heterodimer with the L-monomer of wild-type eBLUF with similar stability to the LD-dimer. This suggests that the conformation of the dimerization site of W91A is similar to that of the dark state (dark-mimic mutant); that is, the light-induced structural changes in the chromophore cavity are not transferred to the other part of the protein. The selective photoinduced dimerization of eBLUF is potentially useful to control interprotein interactions between two different effector domains bound to these proteins.

Phylogenetic Analysis with Prediction of Cofactor or Ligand Binding for Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAS and Cache Domains

PAS domains are omnipresent building blocks of multidomain proteins in all domains of life. Bacteria possess a variety of PAS domains in intracellular proteins and the related Cache domains in periplasmic or extracellular proteins. PAS and Cache domains are predominant in sensory systems, often carry cofactors or bind ligands, and serve as dimerization domains in protein association. To aid our understanding of the wide distribution of these domains, we analyzed the proteome of the opportunistic human pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1 in silico. The ability of this bacterium to survive under different environmental conditions, to switch between planktonic and sessile/biofilm lifestyle, or to evade stresses, notably involves c-di-GMP regulatory proteins or depends on sensory pathways involving multidomain proteins that possess PAS or Cache domains. Maximum likelihood phylogeny was used to group PAS and Cache domains on the basis of amino acid sequence. Conservation of cofactor- or ligand-coordinating amino acids aided by structure-based comparison was used to inform function. The resulting classification presented here includes PAS domains that are candidate binders of carboxylic acids, amino acids, fatty acids, flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD), 4-hydroxycinnamic acid, and heme. These predictions are put in context to previously described phenotypic data, often generated from deletion mutants. The analysis predicts novel functions for sensory proteins and sheds light on functional diversification in a large set of proteins with similar architecture. IMPORTANCE To adjust to a variety of life conditions, bacteria typically use multidomain proteins, where the modular structure allows functional differentiation. Proteins responding to environmental cues and regulating physiological responses are found in chemotaxis pathways that respond to a wide range of stimuli to affect movement. Environmental cues also regulate intracellular levels of cyclic-di-GMP, a universal bacterial secondary messenger that is a key determinant of bacterial lifestyle and virulence. We study Pseudomonas aeruginosa, an organism known to colonize a broad range of environments that can switch lifestyle between the sessile biofilm and the planktonic swimming form. We have investigated the PAS and Cache domains, of which we identified 101 in 70 Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1 proteins, and have grouped these by phylogeny with domains of known structure. The resulting data set integrates sequence analysis and structure prediction to infer ligand or cofactor binding. With this data set, functional predictions for PAS and Cache domain-containing proteins are made.

Real-Time Tracking of Proton Transfer from the Reactive Cysteine to the Flavin Chromophore of a Photosensing Light Oxygen Voltage Protein

LOV (light oxygen voltage) proteins are photosensors ubiquitous to all domains of life. A variant of the short LOV protein from Dinoroseobacter shibae (DsLOV) exhibits an exceptionally fast photocycle. We performed time-resolved molecular spectroscopy on DsLOV-M49S and characterized the formation of the thio-adduct state with a covalent bond between the reactive cysteine (C72) and C_4a of the FMN. By use of a tunable quantum cascade laser, the weak absorption change of the vibrational band of S-H stretching vibration of C57 was resolved with a time resolution of 10 ns. Deprotonation of C72 proceeded with a time constant of 12 μs which tallies the rise of the thio-adduct state. These results provide valuable information for the mechanistic interpretation of light-induced structural changes in LOV domains, which involves the choreographed sequence of proton transfers, changes in electron density distributions, spin alterations of the latter, and transient bond formation and breakage. Such molecular insight will help develop new optogenetic tools based on flavin photoreceptors.

Insights into the mechanisms of light-oxygen-voltage domain color tuning from a set of high-resolution X-ray structures

Light-oxygen-voltage (LOV) domains are widespread photosensory modules that can be used in fluorescence microscopy, optogenetics and controlled production of reactive oxygen species. All of the currently known LOV domains have absorption maxima in the range of ~440 to ~450 nm, and it is not clear whether they can be shifted significantly using mutations. Here, we have generated a panel of LOV domain variants by mutating the key chromophore-proximal glutamine aminoacid of a thermostable flavin based fluorescent protein CagFbFP (Gln148) to asparagine, aspartate, glutamate, histidine, lysine and arginine. Absorption spectra of all of the mutants are blue-shifted, with the maximal shift of 8 nm observed for the Q148H variant. While CagFbFP and its Q148N/D/E variants are not sensitive to pH, Q148H/K/R reveal a moderate red shift induced byacidic pH. To gain further insight, we determined high resolution crystal structures of all of the mutants studied at the resolutions from 1.07 Å for Q148D to 1.63 Å for Q148R. Whereas in some of the variants, the aminoacid 148 remains in the vicinity of the flavin, in Q148K, Q148R and partially Q148D, the C-terminus of the protein unlatches and the side chain of the residue 148 is reoriented away from the chromophore. Our results explain the absence of color shifts from replacing Gln148 with charged aminoacids and pave the way for rational design of color-shifted flavin based fluorescent proteins.

Effects of Proline Substitutions on the Thermostable LOV Domain from Chloroflexus aggregans

Light-oxygen-voltage (LOV) domains are ubiquitous photosensory modules found in proteins from bacteria, archaea and eukaryotes. Engineered versions of LOV domains have found widespread use in fluorescence microscopy and optogenetics, with improved versions being continuously developed. Many of the engineering efforts focused on the thermal stabilization of LOV domains. Recently, we described a naturally thermostable LOV domain from Chloroflexus aggregans. Here we show that the discovered protein can be further stabilized using proline substitution. We tested the effects of three mutations, and found that the melting temperature of the A95P mutant is raised by approximately 2 °C, whereas mutations A56P and A58P are neutral. To further evaluate the effects of mutations, we crystallized the variants A56P and A95P, while the variant A58P did not crystallize. The obtained crystal structures do not reveal any alterations in the proteins other than the introduced mutations. Molecular dynamics simulations showed that mutation A58P alters the structure of the respective loop (Aβ-Bβ), but does not change the general structure of the protein. We conclude that proline substitution is a viable strategy for the stabilization of the Chloroflexus aggregans LOV domain. Since the sequences and structures of the LOV domains are overall well-conserved, the effects of the reported mutations may be transferable to other proteins belonging to this family.

Dimerization of LOV domains of Rhodobacter sphaeroides (RsLOV) studied with FRET and stopped-flow experiments

LOV (light-oxygen-voltage) proteins function as light sensors in plants, fungi, and bacteria. RsLOV is unique as the light state is a monomer but the dark state is a dimer. These dimers exchange their monomer units on a time-scale of seconds.

Interplay among the “flipping” glutamine, a conserved phenylalanine, water and hydrogen bonds within a blue-light sensing LOV domain

A combined photoacoustics and molecular dynamics approach highlights the crucial role of a conserved phenyalanine in photosensing LOV domains.

Helical Contributions Mediate Light-Activated Conformational Change in the LOV2 Domain of Avena sativa Phototropin 1

Algae, plants, bacteria, and fungi contain flavin-binding light-oxygen-voltage (LOV) domains that function as blue light sensors to control cellular responses to light. In the second LOV domain of phototropins, called LOV2 domains, blue light illumination leads to covalent bond formation between protein and flavin that induces the dissociation and unfolding of a C-terminally attached α helix (Jα) and the N-terminal helix (A'α). To date, the majority of studies on these domains have focused on versions that contain truncations in the termini, which creates difficulties when extrapolating to the much larger proteins that contain these domains. Here, we study the influence of deletions and extensions of the A'α helix of the LOV2 domain of Avena sativa phototropin 1 (AsLOV2) on the light-triggered structural response of the protein by Fourier-transform infrared difference spectroscopy. Deletion of the A'α helix abolishes the light-induced unfolding of Jα, whereas extensions of the A'α helix lead to an attenuated structural change of Jα. These results are different from shorter constructs, indicating that the conformational changes in full-length phototropin LOV domains might not be as large as previously assumed, and that the well-characterized full unfolding of the Jα helix in AsLOV2 with short A'α helices may be considered a truncation artifact. It also suggests that the N- and C-terminal helices of phot-LOV2 domains are necessary for allosteric regulation of the phototropin kinase domain and may provide a basis for signal integration of LOV1 and LOV2 domains in phototropins.

A thermostable flavin-based fluorescent protein from Chloroflexus aggregans: a framework for ultra-high resolution structural studies

A new thermostable fluorescent protein is shown to be a promising model for ultra-high resolution structural studies of LOV domains and for application as a fluorescent reporter.