Controlling Styrene Maleic Acid Lipid Particles through RAFT

Membrane Proteins in Nanodiscs: Methods and Applications

Membrane proteins, a principal class of drug targets, play indispensable roles in various biological processes and are closely associated with essential life functions. Their study, however, is complicated by their low solubility in aqueous environments and distinctive structural characteristics, necessitating a suitable native-like environment for molecular analysis. Nanodisc technology has revolutionized this field, providing biochemists with a powerful tool to stabilize membrane proteins and significantly enhance their research possibilities. This review outlines the substantial advancements in nanodisc methodologies and applications from 2018 to 2024. We cover the development of various nanodisc models, as well as structural and functional studies of membrane proteins that utilize nanodiscs, highlighting their medical applications.

Tethering Efficiency of Reversible Addition-Fragmentation Chain Transfer-Synthesized Styrene Maleic Acid Polymers and Associated Styrene Maleic Acid Lipid Nanoparticles on Gold Surfaces

Styrene maleic acid lipid nanoparticles (SMALPs) arise from amphipathic styrene maleic acid (SMA) copolymer encapsulation of membranes into polymer-lipid nanodiscs, structures applied in the native extraction of membrane proteins (MPs). Strategies to immobilize SMALPs via their polymer belt onto surfaces allow the biophysical study of MPs without direct protein-surface anchoring. In this work, reversible addition-fragmentation chain transfer (RAFT) polymerization is used to synthesize a library of diblock SMA copolymers to determine the optimal sequence for SMALP assembly. The further ability of trithiocarbonates (T) and attached (Z)-end-groups, generated by RAFT polymerization, to tether SMALPs to gold surfaces via sulfur-gold bonds is evaluated. Improved DMPC liposome solubilization is achieved with a hydrophilic (Z)-end-group, shorter polystyrene block and lower molecular weight for diblock R-(Sty)-b-(Sty-alt-MA)-T-Z polymers. Quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D) and atomic force microscopy (AFM) revealed that diblock SMA polymers bound to gold as a micellular film, irrespective of the presence of the trithiocarbonate group. SMALPs, however, showed an enhanced gold affinity when terminated by a trithiocarbonate and hydrophilic RAFT (Z)-end-group compared to end-group removed SMALPs, the latter exhibiting nonspecific gold adhesion. These findings offer a new approach in utilizing RAFT end-groups of nanodisc assembling polymers for label-free analysis of MPs.

Bioderived copolymer alternatives to poly(styrene-co-maleic anhydride) via RAFT-mediated copolymerization

Poly(styrene-co-maleic anhydride) (SMAnh) is a petroleum-based copolymer with desirable properties that afford utility in both industrial and academic fields. The reversible addition-fragmentation chain transfer (RAFT)-mediated polymerization of the bioderived comonomers, indene and itaconic anhydride, was explored using three chain transfer agents with varying activity, and generally well-controlled (Đ < 1.40) polymerizations were observed.

An Exploration of the Universal and Switchable RAFT-Mediated Synthesis of Poly(styrene-alt-maleic acid)-b-poly(N-vinylpyrrolidone) Block Copolymers

The synthesis of poly(styrene-alt-maleic anhydride) (SMAnh) and poly(4-tert-butylstyrene-alt-maleic anhydride) (tBuSMAnh) macro-RAFT agents was investigated using universal 3,5-dimethylpyrazole dithiocarbamate and stimuli-responsive N-(4-pyridinyl)-N-methyldithiocarbamate RAFT agents. SMAnh/tBuSMAnh macro-RAFT agents of targeted molecular weight and narrow molecular weight distribution could be synthesized with intentional variation of the terminal monomer unit, allowing for the assessment of two distinctive macro-R-groups. SMAnh macro-RAFT agents were utilized to mediate the thermally initiated polymerization of N-vinylpyrrolidone (NVP), yielding SMAnh-b-PVP, but with significant thermolysis and hydrolysis of dithiocarbamate ω-chain ends. Alternatively, the redox-initiated RAFT-mediated polymerization of NVP at ambient temperatures using hydrolyzed macro-RAFT agents, i.e., poly(styrene-alt-maleic acid) (SMA) and poly(4-tert-butylstyrene-alt-maleic acid) (tBuSMA), was explored. Double hydrophilic SMA-b-PVP and tBuSMA-b-PVP block copolymers could be synthesized but with significant broadening of the molecular weight distribution. This is a result of the formation of dead chains derived from the alkaline hydrolysis of macro-RAFT agents prepolymerization and hydrolysis of dithiocarbamate chain ends throughout the polymerization. The latter is exacerbated by the insertion of NVP at the ω-chain end, which was subsequently investigated via the kinetic analysis of the xanthate- and dithiocarbamate-mediated aqueous homopolymerization of NVP.

Tunable Terpolymer Series for the Systematic Investigation of Membrane Proteins

Membrane proteins (MPs) are critical to cellular processes and serve as essential therapeutic targets. However, their isolation and characterization are often impeded by traditional detergent-based methods, which can compromise their native states, and retention of their native lipid environment. Amphiphilic polymers have emerged as effective alternatives, enabling the formation of nanoscale discs that preserve MPs' structural and functional integrity. We introduce a novel series of poly(styrene-co-maleic acid-co-(N-benzyl)maleimide) (BzAM) terpolymers with tunable amphiphilicity, synthesized through controlled polymerization. Designed to mimic and improve upon industry-standard poly(styrene-co-maleic acid), these well-defined terpolymers offer enhanced control over molecular weight and distribution, allowing for systematic evaluation of polymer properties and their effect on membrane solubilization. The BzAM series effectively solubilized membranes and demonstrated a direct correlation between polymer hydrophobicity and solubilization efficiency of bacterial ABC transporter, Sav1866. This research highlights the importance of rational polymer design in MP research and provides a foundation for future developments.

Vinyl Ether Maleic Acid Polymers: Tunable Polymers for Self-Assembled Lipid Nanodiscs and Environments for Membrane Proteins

Native lipid bilayer mimetics, including those that use amphiphilic polymers, are important for the effective study of membrane-bound peptides and proteins. Copolymers of vinyl ether monomers and maleic anhydride were developed with controlled molecular weights and hydrophobicity through reversible addition-fragmentation chain-transfer polymerization. After polymerization, the maleic anhydride units can be hydrolyzed, giving dicarboxylates. The vinyl ether and maleic anhydride copolymerized in a close to alternating manner, giving essentially alternating hydrophilic maleic acid units and hydrophobic vinyl ether units along the backbone after hydrolysis. The vinyl ether monomers and maleic acid polymers self-assembled with lipids, giving vinyl ether maleic acid lipid particles (VEMALPs) with tunable sizes controlled by either the vinyl ether hydrophobicity or the polymer molecular weight. These VEMALPs were able to support membrane-bound proteins and peptides, creating a new class of lipid bilayer mimetics.

Sulfonated polystyrenes: pH and Mg2+-insensitive amphiphilic copolymers for detergent-free membrane protein isolation

Amphiphilic polymers are increasingly applied in the detergent-free isolation and functional studies of membrane proteins. However, the carboxylate group present in the structure of many popular variants, such as styrene-maleic acid (SMA) copolymers, brings limitations in terms of polymer sensitivity to precipitation at acidic pH or in the presence of divalent metal cations. Herein, we addressed this problem by replacing carboxylate with the more acidic sulfonate groups. To this end, we synthesized a library of amphiphilic poly[styrene-co-(sodium 4-styrene sulfonate)] copolymers (termed SSS), differing in their molecular weight and overall polarity. Using model cell membranes (Jurkat), we identified two copolymer compositions (SSS-L30 and SSS-L36) that solubilized membranes to an extent similar to SMA. Interestingly, the density gradient ultracentrifugation/SDS-PAGE/Western blotting analysis of cell lysates revealed a distribution of studied membrane proteins in the gradient fractions that was different than for SMA-solubilized membranes. Importantly, unlike SMA, the SSS copolymers remained soluble at low pH and in the presence of Mg2+ ions. Additionally, the solubilization of DMPC liposomes by the lead materials was studied by turbidimetry, DLS, SEC, and high-resolution NMR, revealing, for SSS-L36, the formation of stable particles (nanodiscs), facilitated by the direct hydrophobic interaction of the copolymer phenyls with lipid acyl chains.

pH-tunable membrane-active polymers, NCMNP2a-x, and their potential membrane protein applications

Accurate 3D structures of membrane proteins are essential for comprehending their mechanisms of action and designing specific ligands to modulate their activities. However, these structures are still uncommon due to the involvement of detergents in the sample preparation. Recently, membrane-active polymers have emerged as an alternative to detergents, but their incompatibility with low pH and divalent cations has hindered their efficacy. Herein, we describe the design, synthesis, characterization, and application of a new class of pH-tunable membrane-active polymers, NCMNP2a-x. The results demonstrated that NCMNP2a-x could be used for high-resolution single-particle cryo-EM structural analysis of AcrB in various pH conditions and can effectively solubilize BcTSPO with the function preserved. Molecular dynamic simulation is consistent with experimental data that shed great insights into the working mechanism of this class of polymers. These results demonstrated that NCMNP2a-x might have broad applications in membrane protein research.

SMALPs Are Not Simply Nanodiscs: The Polymer-to-Lipid Ratios of Fractionated SMALPs Underline Their Heterogeneous Nature

Amphipathic styrene-maleic acid (SMA) copolymers directly solubilize biomembranes into SMA-lipid particles, or SMALPs, that are often regarded as nanodiscs and hailed as a native membrane platform. The promising outlook of SMALPs inspires the discovery of many SMA-like copolymers that also solubilize biomembranes into putative nanodiscs, but a fundamental question remains on how much the SMALPs or SMALP analogues truly resemble the bilayer structure of nanodiscs. This unfortunate ambiguity undermines the utility of SMA or SMA-like copolymers in membrane biology because the structure and function of many membrane proteins depend critically on their surrounding matrices. Here, we report the structural heterogeneity of SMALPs revealed through fractionating SMALPs comprised of lipids and well-defined SMAs via size-exclusion chromatography followed by quantitative determination of the polymer-to-lipid (P/L) stoichiometric ratios in individual fractions. Through the lens of P/L stoichiometric ratios, different self-assembled polymer-lipid nanostructures are inferred, such as polymer-remodeled liposomes, polymer-encased nanodiscs, polymer-lipid mixed micelles, and lipid-doped polymer micellar aggregates. We attribute the structural heterogeneity of SMALPs to the microstructure variations amongst individual polymer chains that give rise to their polydisperse detergency. As an example, we demonstrate that SMAs with a similar S/MA ratio but different chain sizes participate preferentially in different polymer-lipid nanostructures. We further demonstrate that proteorhodopsin, a light-driven proton pump solubilized within the same SMALPs is distributed amongst different self-assembled nanostructures to display different photocycle kinetics. Our discovery challenges the native nanodisc notion of SMALPs or SMALP analogues and highlights the necessity to separate and identify the structurally dissimilar polymer-lipid particles in membrane biology studies.

Emergent Sequence Biasing in Step-Growth Copolymerization: Influence of Non-Bonded Interactions and Comonomer Reactivities

The phase behavior and material properties of copolymers are intrinsically dependent on their primary comonomer sequences. Achieving precise control over monomer sequence in synthetic copolymerizations is challenging, as sequence determination is influenced not only by the reaction conditions and the properties of the reactants but also by the statistical nature of the copolymerization process itself. Mayo-Lewis reactivity ratios are often used to predict copolymer composition and sequence and are based on ratios of static reactivity constants. However, prior results have demonstrated that in a generic, solution-based step-growth A,B-copolymerization, relatively weak non-bonded attractions between certain monomer pairs induce emergent microphase separations. Such polymerization-driven separations lead to deviations from standard kinetics due to the emergent heterogeneities in reactant concentrations, which can also cause significant shifts in the resulting copolymer sequences. Previously, these effects were observed in systems where the activation energies were equal for all reaction pathways, that is, between all monomer pair combinations. In this work, we explore the combined effects on copolymerization kinetics of differences in both activation energies and non-bonded attractions between monomers and examine the sequences produced within this same step-growth copolymerization model. Our results indicate that altering activation energies influences the kinetics and sequences in a manner that also depends on the non-bonded attractions, showing that these effects may work in concert or in opposition to one another to bias the sequences formed. Non-standard kinetic behaviors and long-range sequence biasing are observed under certain conditions, and the extent of each clearly shifts as the reaction proceeds. These findings provide insight into the complex interplay between sequence and nascent oligomer phase behavior, highlighting the potential for exploiting emergent phase properties in the informed design of advanced sequence-biased materials.

Tailoring Butyl Methacrylate/Methacrylic Acid Copolymers for the Solubilization of Membrane Proteins: The Influence of Composition and Molecular Weight

Low-molecular weight (MW) amphiphilic copolymers have been recently introduced as a powerful tool for the detergent-free isolation of cell membrane proteins. Herein, we use a screening approach to identify a new copolymer type for this application. Via a two-step ATRP/acidolysis procedure, we prepare a 3×3 matrix of well-defined poly[(butyl methacrylate)-co-(methacrylic acid)] copolymers (denoted BMAA) differing in their MW and ratio of hydrophobic (BMA) and hydrophilic (MAA) units. Subsequently, using the biologically relevant model (T-cell line Jurkat), we identify two compositions of BMAA copolymers that solubilize cell membranes to an extent comparable to the industry standard, styrene-maleic acid copolymer (SMA), while avoiding the potentially problematic phenyl groups. Surprisingly, while only the lowest-MW variant of the BMA/MAA 2:1 composition is effective, all the copolymers of the BMA/MAA 1:1 composition are found to solubilize the model membranes, including the high-MW variant (MW of 14 000). Importantly, the density gradient ultracentrifugation/SDS PAGE/Western blotting experiments reveal that the BMA/MAA 1:1 copolymers disintegrate the Jurkat membranes differently than SMA, as demonstrated by the different distribution patterns of two tested membrane protein markers. This makes the BMAA copolymers a useful tool for studies on membrane microdomains differing in their composition and resistance to membrane-disintegrating polymers. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

Fluorescent styrene maleic acid copolymers to facilitate membrane protein studies in lipid nanodiscs

Fluorescently-labelled variants of poly(styrene-co-maleic acid), SMA, have been synthesised by RAFT copolymerisation. We show that low ratios of vinyl fluorophores, analogous to styrene, can be successfully incorporated during polymerisation without detriment to nanodisc formation upon interaction with lipids. These novel copolymers are capable of encapuslating lipids and the model membrane protein, gramicidin, and hence have the potential to be applied in fluorescence-based biological studies. To demonstrate this, energy transfer is used to probe polymer-protein interactions in nanodiscs. The copolymers may also be used to monitor nanodisc self assembly by exploiting aggregation-caused-quenching (ACQ).

The interaction of styrene maleic acid copolymers with phospholipids in Langmuir monolayers, vesicles and nanodiscs; a structural study

HYPOTHESIS

Self-assembly of amphipathic styrene maleic acid copolymers with phospholipids in aqueous solution results in the formation of 'nanodiscs' containing a planar segment of phospholipid bilayer encapsulated by a polymer belt. Recently, studies have reported that lipids rapidly exchange between both nanodiscs in solution and external sources of lipids. Outstanding questions remain regarding details of polymer-lipid interactions, factors influencing lipid exchange and structural effects of such exchange processes. Here, the dynamic behaviour of nanodiscs is investigated, specifically the role of membrane charge and polymer chemistry.

EXPERIMENTS

Two model systems are investigated: fluorescently labelled phospholipid vesicles, and Langmuir monolayers of phospholipids. Using fluorescence spectroscopy and time-resolved neutron reflectometry, the membrane potential, monolayer structure and composition are monitored with respect to time upon polymer and nanodisc interactions.

FINDINGS

In the presence of external lipids, polymer chains embed throughout lipid membranes, the extent of which is governed by the net membrane charge. Nanodiscs stabilised by three different polymers will all exchange lipids and polymer with monolayers to differing extents, related to the properties of the stabilising polymer belt. These results demonstrate the dynamic nature of nanodiscs which interact with the local environment and are likely to deposit both lipids and polymer at all stages of use.

Synthesis and Evaluation of a Library of Alternating Amphipathic Copolymers to Solubilize and Study Membrane Proteins

Amphipathic copolymers such as poly(styrene-maleic acid) (SMA) are promising tools for the facile extraction of membrane proteins (MPs) into native nanodiscs. Here, we designed and synthesized a library of well-defined alternating copolymers of SMA analogues in order to elucidate polymer properties that are important for MP solubilization and stability. MP extraction efficiency was determined using KcsA from E. coli membranes, and general solubilization efficiency was investigated via turbidimetry experiments on membranes of E. coli, yeast mitochondria, and synthetic lipids. Remarkably, halogenation of SMA copolymers dramatically improved solubilization efficiency in all systems, while substituents on the copolymer backbone improved resistance to Ca²⁺. Relevant polymer properties were found to include hydrophobic balance, size and positioning of substituents, rigidity, and electronic effects. The library thus contributes to the rational design of copolymers for the study of MPs.

Drug Delivery Systems and Strategies to Overcome the Barriers of Brain

The transport of drugs to the central nervous system is the most challenging task for conventional drug delivery systems. Reduced permeability of drugs through the blood-brain barrier is a major hurdle in delivering drugs to the brain. Hence, various strategies for improving drug delivery through the blood-brain barrier are currently being explored. Novel drug delivery systems (NDDS) offer several advantages, including high chemical and biological stability, suitability for both hydrophobic and hydrophilic drugs, and can be administered through different routes. Furthermore, the conjugation of suitable ligands with these carriers tend to potentiate targeting to the endothelium of the brain and could facilitate the internalization of drugs through endocytosis. Further, the intranasal route has also shown potential, as a promising alternate route, for the delivery of drugs to the brain. This can deliver the drugs directly to the brain through the olfactory pathway. In recent years, several advancements have been made to target and overcome the barriers of the brain. This article deals with a detailed overview of the diverse strategies and delivery systems to overcome the barriers of the brain for effective delivery of drugs.

Artificial stabilization of the fusion pore by intra-organelle styrene-maleic acid copolymers

Styrene-maleic acid copolymers have become an advantageous detergent-free alternative for membrane protein isolation. Since their discovery, experimental membrane protein extraction and purification by keeping intact their lipid environment has become significantly easier. With the aim of identifying new applications of these interesting copolymers, their molecular binding and functioning mechanisms have recently become intense objects of study. In this work, we describe the use of styrene-maleic acid copolymers as an artificial tool to stabilize the fusion pore. We show that when these copolymers circumscribe the water channel that defines the fusion pore, they keep it from shrinking and closing. We describe how only intra-organelle copolymers have stabilizing capabilities while extra-organelle ones have negligible or even contrary effects on the fusion pore life-time.

Polymer Nanodiscs and Their Bioanalytical Potential

Membrane proteins (MPs) play a pivotal role in cellular function and are therefore predominant pharmaceutical targets. Although detailed understanding of MP structure and mechanistic activity is invaluable for rational drug design, challenges are associated with the purification and study of MPs. This review delves into the historical developments that became the prelude to currently available membrane mimetic technologies before shining a spotlight on polymer nanodiscs. These are soluble nanosized particles capable of encompassing MPs embedded in a phospholipid ring. The expanding range of reported amphipathic polymer nanodisc materials is presented and discussed in terms of their tolerance to different solution conditions and their nanodisc properties. Finally, the analytical scope of polymer nanodiscs is considered in both the demonstration of basic nanodisc parameters as well as in the elucidation of structures, lipid-protein interactions, and the functional mechanisms of reconstituted membrane proteins. The final emphasis is given to the unique benefits and applications demonstrated for native nanodiscs accessed through a detergent free process.

Benchmarks of SMA-Copolymer Derivatives and Nanodisc Integrity

Poly(styrene-co-maleic acid) or SMA and its derivatives, a family of synthetic amphipathic copolymers, are increasingly used to directly solubilize cell membranes to functionally reconstitute membrane proteins in native-like copolymer-lipid nanodiscs. Although these copolymers act, de facto, like a "macromolecular detergent", the polymer-based lipid-nanodiscs has been demonstrated to be an excellent membrane mimetic for structural and functional studies of membrane proteins and their complexes by a variety of biophysical and biochemical approaches. In many studies reported in the literature, the choice of the right SMA formulation can depend on a number of factors, and the experimental conditions are typically developed according to a trial-and-error process since each studied system requires adapted protocols. While increasing number of nanodisc-forming copolymers are reported to be useful and they provide flexibilities in optimizing the sample preparation conditions, it is important to develop a systematic protocol that can be used for various applications. In this context, there is a vital necessity of benchmarking the performances of existing copolymer formulations, assessing crucial parameters for the successful extraction, isolation, and stabilization of membrane proteins. In this study, we compare both copolymers and copolymer-lipid nanodiscs obtained by SMA-EA with a set of anionic XIRAN copolymer formulations commercially available under the names of SL25010 P, SL30010 P, and SL40005 P. The reported results show how the critical micellar concentration (c.m.c.) of each copolymer is significantly altered in the presence of lipids and confirms the existence of an equilibrium between nanodisc-bound and "free" or "micellar" copolymer chains in the solution. We believe that these findings can be exploited to optimize studies that involve the necessity of special copolymers, which would not only simplify the applications but also broaden the scope of polymer-based nanodiscs.

Polymer-Encased Nanodiscs and Polymer Nanodiscs: New Platforms for Membrane Protein Research and Applications

Membrane proteins (MPs) are essential to many organisms’ major functions. They are notorious for being difficult to isolate and study, and mimicking native conditions for studies in vitro has proved to be a challenge. Lipid nanodiscs are among the most promising platforms for MP reconstitution, but they contain a relatively labile lipid bilayer and their use requires previous protein solubilization in detergent. These limitations have led to the testing of copolymers in new types of nanodisc platforms. Polymer-encased nanodiscs and polymer nanodiscs support functional MPs and address some of the limitations present in other MP reconstitution platforms. In this review, we provide a summary of recent developments in the use of polymers in nanodiscs.

Homogeneous nanodiscs of native membranes formed by stilbene-maleic-acid copolymers

Methylstilbene-alt-maleic acid copolymers spontaneously convert biological membranes into bilayer discs with ∼20 nm diameters. This readily functionalizable class of copolymers has the compositional homogeneity, hydrophobicity, dynamics, and charge that may help to achieve optimal structural resolution, membrane dissolution, stability, and broad utility.

Extraction and reconstitution of membrane proteins into lipid nanodiscs encased by zwitterionic styrene-maleic amide copolymers

Membrane proteins can be reconstituted in polymer-encased nanodiscs for studies under near-physiological conditions and in the absence of detergents, but traditional styrene-maleic acid copolymers used for this purpose suffer severely from buffer incompatibilities. We have recently introduced zwitterionic styrene-maleic amide copolymers (zSMAs) to overcome this limitation. Here, we compared the extraction and reconstitution of membrane proteins into lipid nanodiscs by a series of zSMAs with different styrene:maleic amide molar ratios, chain sizes, and molecular weight distributions. These copolymers solubilize, stabilize, and support membrane proteins in nanodiscs with different efficiencies depending on both the structure of the copolymers and the membrane proteins.

Adsorption of a styrene maleic acid (SMA) copolymer-stabilized phospholipid nanodisc on a solid-supported planar lipid bilayer

Over recent years, there has been a rapid development of membrane-mimetic systems to encapsulate and stabilize planar segments of phospholipid bilayers in solution. One such system has been the use of amphipathic copolymers to solubilize lipid bilayers into nanodiscs. The attractiveness of this system, in part, stems from the capability of these polymers to solubilize membrane proteins directly from the host cell membrane. The assumption has been that the native lipid annulus remains intact, with nanodiscs providing a snapshot of the lipid environment. Recent studies have provided evidence that phospholipids can exchange from the nanodiscs with either lipids at interfaces, or with other nanodiscs in bulk solution. Here we investigate kinetics of lipid exchange between three recently studied polymer-stabilized nanodiscs and supported lipid bilayers at the silicon-water interface. We show that lipid and polymer exchange occurs in all nanodiscs tested, although the rate and extent differs between different nanodisc types. Furthermore, we observe adsorption of nanodiscs to the supported lipid bilayer for one nanodisc system which used a polymer made using reversible addition-fragmentation chain transfer polymerization. These results have important implications in applications of polymer-stabilized nanodiscs, such as in the fabrication of solid-supported films containing membrane proteins.

Membrane mimetic systems in CryoEM: keeping membrane proteins in their native environment

Advances in electron microscopes, detectors and data processing algorithms have greatly facilitated the structural determination of many challenging integral membrane proteins that have been evasive to crystallization. These breakthroughs facilitate the application and development of various membrane protein solubilization approaches for structural studies, including reconstitution into lipid nanoparticles. In this review, we discuss various approaches for preparing transmembrane proteins for structural determination with single-particle electron cryo microscopy (cryoEM).

Structures and Interactions of Transmembrane Targets in Native Nanodiscs

Transmembrane proteins function within a continuous layer of biologically relevant lipid molecules that stabilizes their structures and modulates their activities. Structures and interactions of biological membrane-protein complexes or "memteins" can now be elucidated using native nanodiscs made by poly(styrene co-maleic anhydride) derivatives. These linear polymers contain a series of hydrophobic and polar subunits that gently fragment membranes into water-soluble discs with diameters of 5-50 nm known as styrene maleic acid lipid particles (SMALPs). High-resolution structures of memteins that include endogenous lipid ligands and posttranslational modifications can be resolved without resorting to synthetic detergents or artificial lipids. The resulting ex situ structures better recapitulate the in vivo situation and can be visualized by methods including cryo-electron microscopy (cryoEM), electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR), mass spectrometry (MS), nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, small angle x-ray scattering (SAXS), and x-ray diffraction (XRD). Recent progress including 3D structures of biological bilayers illustrates how polymers and native nanodiscs expose previously inaccessible membrane assemblies at atomic resolution and suggest ways in which the SMALP system could be exploited for drug discovery.

Single-particle cryo-EM studies of transmembrane proteins in SMA copolymer nanodiscs

Styrene-maleic acid (SMA) copolymers can extract membrane proteins from native membranes along with lipids as nanodiscs. Preparation with SMA is fast, cost-effective, and captures the native protein-lipid interactions. On the other hand, cryo-EM has become increasingly successful and efficient for structural determinations of membrane proteins, with biochemical sample preparation often the bottleneck. Three recent cryo-EM studies on the efflux transporter AcrB and the alternative complex III: cyt c oxidase supercomplex have demonstrated the potential of SMA nanodisc samples to yield high-resolution structure information of membrane proteins.

Structural characterization of styrene-maleic acid copolymer-lipid nanoparticles (SMALPs) using EPR spectroscopy

Spectroscopic studies of membrane proteins (MPs) are challenging due to difficulties in preparing homogenous and functional lipid membrane mimetic systems into which membrane proteins can properly fold and function. It has recently been shown that styrene-maleic acid (SMA) copolymers act as a macromolecular surfactant and therefore facilitate the formation of disk-shaped lipid bilayer nanoparticles (styrene-maleic acid copolymer-lipid nanoparticles (SMALPs)) that retain structural characteristics of native lipid membranes. We have previously reported controlled synthesis of SMA block copolymers using reversible addition-fragmentation chain transfer (RAFT) polymerization, and that alteration of the weight ratio of styrene to maleic acid affects nanoparticle size. RAFT-synthesis offers superior control over SMA polymer architecture compared to conventional radical polymerization techniques used for commercially available SMA. However, the interactions between the lipid bilayer and the solubilized RAFT-synthesized SMA polymer are currently not fully understood. In this study, EPR spectroscopy was used to detect the perturbation on the acyl chain upon introduction of the RAFT-synthesized SMA polymer by attaching PC-based nitroxide spin labels to the 5^th, 12^th, and 16^th positions along the acyl chain of the lipid bilayer. EPR spectra showed high rigidity at the 12^th position compared to the other two regions, displaying similar qualities to commercially available polymers synthesized via conventional methods. In addition, central EPR linewidths and correlation time data were obtained that are consistent with previous findings.

Molecular snapshots of dynamic membrane-bound metabolons

Numerous biosynthetic pathways have been shown to assemble at the surface of cellular membranes into efficient dynamic supramolecular assemblies termed metabolons. In response to environmental stimuli, metabolons assemble on-demand making them highly dynamic and fragile. This transient nature has previously hampered isolation and molecular characterization of dynamic metabolons. In contrast to conventional detergents, which tend to disrupt weak protein-protein interactions and remove lipids, the competence of a styrene maleic acid copolymer to carve out discrete lipid nanodisc from membranes offers immense potential for isolation of intact protein assemblies. Here, we present a method to extract the entire membrane-bound dhurrin pathway directly from microsomal fractions of the cereal Sorghum bicolor. This detergent-free nanodisc approach may be generally transposed for isolation of entire plant biosynthetic metabolons. This method provides a simple practical toolkit for the study of membrane protein complexes.

Practical Prediction of Heteropolymer Composition and Drift

Composition drift in batch polymerizations is a well-known phenomenon and can lead to composition gradients in polymers synthesized using controlled polymerization methodologies. With known reactivity ratios of monomers, the drift, and thus resultant gradient copolymer, can be designed by adjusting reagent ratios and targeted conversions. Although such prediction is straightforward, it is seldom done, likely due to the perceived difficulty and unfamiliarity for nonspecialists. We seek to remedy this by providing the communities using copolymers with an easy-to-use program called Compositional Drift which is based on the Mayo-Lewis model and the penultimate model of monomer addition, using Monte Carlo methodology. This tool can also be applied to predict composition in nondrifting polymerizations. Herein we supply this tool to the community, showcasing two recent examples of use to guide experimental design and understanding of heteropolymers (RHP).

Characterizing the structure of styrene-maleic acid copolymer-lipid nanoparticles (SMALPs) using RAFT polymerization for membrane protein spectroscopic studies

Membrane proteins play an important role in maintaining the structure and physiology of an organism. Despite their significance, spectroscopic studies involving membrane proteins remain challenging due to the difficulties in mimicking their native lipid bilayer environment. Membrane mimetic systems such as detergent micelles, liposomes, bicelles, nanodiscs, lipodisqs have improved the solubility and folding properties of the membrane proteins for structural studies, however, each mimetic system suffers from its own limitations. In this study, using three different lipid environments, vesicles were titrated with styrene-maleic acid (StMA) copolymer leading to a homogeneous SMALP system (∼10 nm) at a weight ratio of 1:1.5 (vesicle: StMA solution). A combination of Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS) and Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) was used to characterize these SMALPs. We used a controlled synthesis mechanism to synthesize StMA based block copolymers called reversible addition-fragmentation chain transfer polymerization (RAFT) SMALPs. Incorporation of the Voltage Sensor Domain of KCNQ1 (Q1-VSD) into RAFT SMALPs indicates that this is a promising application of this system to study membrane proteins using different biophysical techniques. V165C in Q1-VSD corresponding to the hydrophobic region was incorporated into the SMALP system. Continuous Wave-Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (CW-EPR) line shape analysis showed line shape broadening, exposing a lower rigid component and a faster component of the spin label.

The Peptidisc, a simple method for stabilizing membrane proteins in detergent-free solution

Membrane proteins are difficult to work with due to their insolubility in aqueous solution and quite often their poor stability in detergent micelles. Here, we present the peptidisc for their facile capture into water-soluble particles. Unlike the nanodisc, which requires scaffold proteins of different lengths and precise amounts of matching lipids, reconstitution of detergent solubilized proteins in peptidisc only requires a short amphipathic bi-helical peptide (NSP_r) and no extra lipids. Multiple copies of the peptide wrap around to shield the membrane-exposed part of the target protein. We demonstrate the effectiveness of this ‘one size fits all’ method using five different membrane protein assemblies (MalFGK₂, FhuA, SecYEG, OmpF, BRC) during ‘on-column’, ‘in-gel’, and ‘on-bead’ reconstitution embedded within the membrane protein purification protocol. The peptidisc method is rapid and cost-effective, and it may emerge as a universal tool for high-throughput stabilization of membrane proteins to advance modern biological studies.

Surrounding every living cell is a biological membrane that is largely impermeable to water-soluble molecules. This hydrophobic (or “water-hating”) barrier preserves the contents of the cell and also regulates how the cell interacts with its environment. This latter function is critical and relies on a class of proteins that are embedded within the membrane and are also hydrophobic.

The hydrophobic nature of membrane proteins is however inconvenient for biochemical studies which usually take place in water-based solutions. Therefore, membrane proteins are under-represented in biological research compared to the water-soluble ones, even though roughly one quarter of a cell’s proteins are membrane proteins. Researchers have developed a few tricks to keep membrane proteins soluble after they have been extracted from the membrane. An old but popular technique makes use of detergents, which are chemicals with opposing hydrophobic and hydrophilic properties (hydrophilic literally means “water-loving”). However, even mild detergents can damage membrane proteins and will sometimes lead to experimental artifacts. More recent tricks to stabilize membrane proteins without detergents have been described but remain laborious, costly or difficult to perform.

To overcome these limitations, Carlson et al. developed a simple method to stabilize membrane proteins without detergent. Called the “peptidisc”, the method uses multiple copies of a unique peptide – a short sequence of the building blocks of protein – that had been redesigned to have optimal hydrophobic and hydrophilic properties. The idea was that the peptides would wrap around the hydrophobic parts of the membrane protein, and shield them from the watery solution. Indeed, when Carlson et al. mixed this peptide with five different membrane proteins from bacteria, all were perfectly soluble and functional without detergent. The ideal ratio of peptide needed to form a peptidisc around each membrane protein was reached automatically, without having to test many different conditions. This indicates that the peptidisc acts like a “one size fits all” scaffold.

The peptidisc is a new tool that will allow more researchers, including those who are not expert biochemists, to study membrane proteins. This will yield a better understanding of the structure of a cell’s membrane and how it interacts with the environment. Since the approach is both simple and easy to apply, more membrane proteins can now also be included in high-throughput searches for potential new drugs for various medical conditions.

Macrodiscs Comprising SMALPs for Oriented Sample Solid-State NMR Spectroscopy of Membrane Proteins

Macrodiscs, which are magnetically alignable lipid bilayer discs with diameters of >30 nm, were obtained by solubilizing protein-containing liposomes with styrene-maleic acid copolymers. Macrodiscs provide a detergent-free phospholipid bilayer environment for biophysical and functional studies of membrane proteins under physiological conditions. The narrow resonance linewidths observed from membrane proteins in styrene-maleic acid macrodiscs advance structure determination by oriented sample solid-state NMR spectroscopy.

Purification of membrane proteins free from conventional detergents: SMA, new polymers, new opportunities and new insights

Membrane proteins remain a somewhat enigmatic group of biomolecules. On the one hand they mediate some of the most important processes in biology with molecular mechanisms that are often elegantly complex. On the other hand they are exceptionally challenging to produce, making studies of membrane protein structure and function among the most difficult projects undertaken by biochemists. The central issue with studies of a membrane protein has been the need to extract them from their native lipid environment before purification and production of a homogenous sample. Historical approaches have utilized detergent solubilisation but these often lead to a sample with low activity and stability. In the past 15 years a new approach that focuses on preserving the local lipid environment surrounding the membrane proteins has been developed. The latest, and perhaps most complete, incarnation of this method has been the use of polymers based on styrene maleic acid (SMA) to stabilise nanoscale discs of lipid that contain membrane proteins. In this review we examine the range of SMA-related polymers that have now been shown to have utility in the production of membrane proteins. We discuss the differences between the polymers and attempt to discover rules and trends that explain their behavior.

Membrane biology visualized in nanometer-sized discs formed by styrene maleic acid polymers

Discovering how membrane proteins recognize signals and passage molecules remains challenging. Life depends on compartmentalizing these processes into dynamic lipid bilayers that are technically difficult to work with. Several polymers have proven adept at separating the responsible machines intact for detailed analysis of their structures and interactions. Styrene maleic acid (SMA) co-polymers efficiently solubilize membranes into native nanodiscs and, unlike amphipols and membrane scaffold proteins, require no potentially destabilizing detergents. Here we review progress with the SMA lipid particle (SMALP) system and its impacts including three dimensional structures and biochemical functions of peripheral and transmembrane proteins. Polymers systems are emerging to tackle the remaining challenges for wider use and future applications including in membrane proteomics, structural biology of transient or unstable states, and discovery of ligand and drug-like molecules specific for native lipid-bound states.