Oxidative DNA Damage and Repair in the Radioresistant Archaeon Thermococcus gammatolerans

Tracing the serendipitous genesis of radiation resistance

Free-living organisms frequently encounter unfavorable abiotic environmental factors. Those who adapt and cope with sudden changes in the external environment survive. Desiccation is one of the most common and frequently encountered stresses in nature. On the contrary, ionizing radiations are limited to high local concentrations of naturally occurring radioactive materials and related anthropogenic activities. Yet, resistance to high doses of ionizing radiation is evident across the tree of life. The evolution of desiccation resistance has been linked to the evolution of ionizing radiation resistance, although, evidence to support the idea that the evolution of desiccation tolerance is a necessary precursor to ionizing radiation resistance is lacking. Moreover, the presence of radioresistance in hyperthermophiles suggests multiple paths lead to radiation resistance. In this minireview, we focus on the molecular aspects of damage dynamics and damage response pathways comprising protective and restorative functions with a definitive survival advantage, to explore the serendipitous genesis of ionizing radiation resistance.

Structural and functional determinants of the archaeal 8-oxoguanine-DNA glycosylase AGOG for DNA damage recognition and processing

8-Oxoguanine (GO) is a major purine oxidation product in DNA. Because of its highly mutagenic properties, GO absolutely must be eliminated from DNA. To do this, aerobic and anaerobic organisms from the three kingdoms of life have evolved repair mechanisms to prevent its deleterious effect on genetic integrity. The major way to remove GO is the base excision repair pathway, usually initiated by a GO-DNA glycosylase. First identified in bacteria (Fpg) and eukaryotes (OGG1), GO-DNA glycosylases were more recently identified in archaea (OGG2 and AGOG). AGOG is the less documented enzyme and its mode of damage recognition and removing remains to be clarified at the molecular and atomic levels. This study presents a complete structural characterisation of apo AGOGs from Pyrococcus abyssi (Pab) and Thermococcus gammatolerans (Tga) and the first structure of Pab-AGOG bound to lesion-containing single- or double-stranded DNA. By combining X-ray structure analysis, site directed mutagenesis and biochemistry experiments, we identified key amino acid residues of AGOGs responsible for the specific recognition of the lesion and the base opposite the lesion and for catalysis. Moreover, a unique binding mode of GO, involving double base flipping, never observed for any other DNA glycosylases, is revealed. In addition to unravelling the properties of AGOGs, our study, through comparative biochemical and structural analysis, offers new insights into the evolutionary plasticity of DNA glycosylases across all three kingdoms of life.

A thermophilic 8-oxoguanine DNA glycosylase from Thermococcus barophilus Ch5 is a new member of AGOG DNA glycosylase family

8-Oxoguanine (8oxoG) in DNA is a major oxidized base that poses a severe threat to genome stability. To counteract the mutagenic effect generated by 8oxoG in DNA, cells have evolved 8oxoG DNA glycosylase (OGG) that can excise this oxidized base from DNA. Currently, OGG enzymes have been divided into three families: OGG1, OGG2 and AGOG (archaeal 8oxoG DNA glycosylase). Due to the limited reports, our understanding on AGOG enzymes remains incomplete. Herein, we present evidence that an AGOG from the hyperthermophilic euryarchaeon Ch5 (Tb-AGOG) excises 8oxoG from DNA at high temperature. The enzyme displays maximum efficiency at 75°C-95°C and at pH 9.0. As expected, Tb-AGOG is a bifunctional glycosylase that harbors glycosylase activity and AP (apurinic/apyrimidinic) lyase activity. Importantly, we reveal for the first time that residue D41 in Tb-AGOG is essential for 8oxoG excision and intermediate formation, but not essential for DNA binding or AP cleavage. Furthermore, residue E79 in Tb-AGOG is essential for 8oxoG excision and intermediate formation, and is partially involved in DNA binding and AP cleavage, which has not been described among the reported AGOG members to date. Overall, our work provides new insights into catalytic mechanism of AGOG enzymes.

Biochemical and functional characterization of an endonuclease III from Thermococcus barophilus Ch5

Endonuclease III (EndoIII) is a bifunctional DNA glycosylase that is essential to excise thymine glycol (Tg) from DNA. Although EndoIII is widespread in bacteria, eukarya and Archaea, our understanding on archaeal EndoIII function remains relatively incomplete due to the limited reports. Herein, we characterized an EndoIII from the hyperthermophilic euryarchaeon Thermococcus barophilus Ch5 (Tba-EndoIII) biochemically, demonstrating that the enzyme can excise Tg from dsDNA and display maximum activity at 50 ~ 70 °C and at pH 6.0 ~ 9.0 without the requirement of a divalent metal ion. Importantly, Tba-EndoIII differs from other reported archaeal EndoIII homologues in thermostability and salt requirement. As observed in other EndoIII homologues, the conserved residues D155 and H157 in Helix-hairpin-Helix motif of Tba-EndoIII are essential for Tg excision. Intriguingly, we first dissected that the conserved residues C215 and C221 in the Fe-S cluster loop in Tba-EndoIII are involved in intermediate formation and Tg excision. Additionally, we first revealed that the conserved residue L48 is flexible for intermediate formation and AP cleavage, but plays no detectable role in Tg excision. Overall, our work has revealed additional archaeal EndoIII function and catalytic mechanism.

Biochemical characterization and mutational studies of a thermostable endonuclease III from Sulfolobus islandicus REY15A

Endonuclease III (EndoIII), which is ubiquitous in bacteria, Archaea and eukaryotes, plays an important role in excising thymine glycol (Tg) from DNA. Herein, we present evidence that an EndoIII from the hyperthermophilic crenarchaeon Sulfolobus islandicus REY15A (Sis-EndoIII) is capable of removing Tg from DNA at high temperature. Biochemical data show that the optimal temperature and pH of Sis-EndoIII are ca.70 °C and ca.7.0-8.0, respectively. Furthermore, the recombinant Sis-EndoIII retains relative weak activity without a divalent metal ion, and displays maximum activity in the presence of Mg²⁺ or Ca²⁺. Additionally, we first revealed the activation energy (E_a) of 39.7 ± 4.2 kcal/mol for Sis-EndoIII to remove Tg from dsDNA. As a bifunctional glycosylase, Sis-EndoIII possesses AP lyase activity in addition to glycosylase activity. Additionally, a covalent intermediate is formed between Sis-EndoIII and Tg-containing dsDNA. Mutational studies demonstrate that residues D50, K133 and D151 in Sis-EndoIII are responsible for removal of Tg from dsDNA and K133 and D151 are essential for formation of the covalent intermediate. To our knowledge, it is the first report of Tg excision by crenarchaeal EndoIII, thus augmenting our understanding on archaeal EndoIII function.

Identification of a novel bifunctional uracil DNA glycosylase from Thermococcus barophilus Ch5

Genomes of hyperthermophiles are facing a severe challenge due to increased deamination rates of cytosine induced by high temperature, which could be counteracted by base excision repair mediated by uracil DNA glycosylase (UDG) or other repair pathways. Our previous work has shown that the two UDGs (Tba UDG247 and Tba UDG194) encoded by the genome of the hyperthermophilic euryarchaeon Thermococcus barophilus Ch5 can remove uracil from DNA at high temperature. Herein, we provide evidence that Tba UDG247 is a novel bifunctional glycosylase which can excise uracil from DNA and further cleave the phosphodiester bo nd of the generated apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) site, which has never been described to date. In addition to cleaving uracil-containing DNA, Tba UDG247 can also cleave AP-containing ssDNA although at lower efficiency, thereby suggesting that the enzyme might be involved in repair of AP site in DNA. Kinetic analyses showed that Tba UDG247 displays a faster rate for uracil excision than for AP cleavage, thus suggesting that cleaving AP site by the enzyme is a rate-limiting step for its bifunctionality. Phylogenetic analysis showed that Tba UDG247 is clustered on a separate branch distant from all the reported UDGs. Overall, we designated Tba UDG247 as the prototype of a novel family of bifunctional UDGs. KEY POINTS: We first reported a novel DNA glycosylase with bifunctionality. Tba UDG247 possesses an AP lyase activity.

A Unique B-Family DNA Polymerase Facilitating Error-Prone DNA Damage Tolerance in Crenarchaeota

Sulfolobus islandicus codes for four DNA polymerases: three are of the B-family (Dpo1, Dpo2, and Dpo3), and one is of the Y-family (Dpo4). Western analysis revealed that among the four polymerases, only Dpo2 exhibited DNA damage-inducible expression. To investigate how these DNA polymerases could contribute to DNA damage tolerance in S. islandicus, we conducted genetic analysis of their encoding genes in this archaeon. Plasmid-borne gene expression revealed that Dpo2 increases cell survival upon DNA damage at the expense of mutagenesis. Gene deletion studies showed although dpo1 is essential, the remaining three genes are dispensable. Furthermore, although Dpo4 functions in housekeeping translesion DNA synthesis (TLS), Dpo2, a B-family DNA polymerase once predicted to be inactive, functions as a damage-inducible TLS enzyme solely responsible for targeted mutagenesis, facilitating GC to AT/TA conversions in the process. Together, our data indicate that Dpo2 is the main DNA polymerase responsible for DNA damage tolerance and is the primary source of targeted mutagenesis. Given that crenarchaea encoding a Dpo2 also have a low-GC composition genome, the Dpo2-dependent DNA repair pathway may be conserved in this archaeal lineage.

Genetic Control of Oxidative Mutagenesis in Sulfolobus acidocaldarius

To identify DNA-oxidation defenses of hyperthermophilic archaea, we deleted genes encoding the putative 7,8-dihydro-8-oxoguanine (oxoG)-targeted N-glycosylase of S. acidocaldarius (ogg; Saci_01367), the Y-family DNA polymerase (dbh; Saci_0554), or both, and measured the effects on cellular survival, replication accuracy, and oxoG bypass in vivo Spontaneous G:C to T:A transversions were elevated in all Δogg and Δdbh constructs, and the Δogg Δdbh double mutant lost viability at a faster rate than isogenic WT and ogg strains. The distribution of G:C to T:A transversions within mutation-detector genes suggested that reactivity of G toward oxidation and the effect on translation contribute heavily to the pattern of mutations that are recovered. An impact of the Ogg protein on overall efficiency of bypassing oxoG in transforming DNA was evident only in the absence of Dbh, and Ogg status did not affect the accuracy of bypass. Dbh function, in contrast, dramatically influenced both the efficiency and accuracy of oxoG bypass. Thus, Ogg and Dbh were found to work independently to avoid mutagenesis by oxoG, and inactivating this simple but effective defense system by deleting both genes imposed a severe mutational burden on S. acidocaldarius cells.IMPORTANCE Hyperthermophilic archaea are expected to have effective (and perhaps atypical) mechanisms to limit the genetic consequences of DNA damage, but few gene products have been demonstrated to have genome-preserving functions in vivo This study confirmed by genetic criteria that the S. acidocaldarius Ogg protein avoids the characteristic mutagenesis of G oxidation. This enzyme and the bypass polymerase Dbh have similar impacts on genome stability but work independently, and may comprise most of the DNA-oxidation defense of S. acidocaldarius The critical dependence of accurate oxoG bypass on the accessory DNA polymerase Dbh further argues that some form of polymerase exchange is important for accurate genome replication in Sulfolobus, and perhaps in related hyperthermophilic archaea.

Mutational analysis of Thermococcus kodakarensis Endonuclease III reveals the roles of evolutionarily conserved residues

Endonuclease III (EndoIII) is nearly ubiquitous in all three domains of life. EndoIII family proteins exhibit a bifunctional (glycosylase/lyase) activity on oxidative/saturated pyrimidine bases, such as thymine glycol. Previous studies on EndoIII homologs have reported the presence of important residues involved in substrate binding and catalytic activity. However, a biochemical clarification of the roles of these residues as well as details of their evolutionary conservation is still lacking. This is particularly true for archaeal orthologs. The current study demonstrated the roles of the evolutionarily conserved residues of euryarchaeon Thermococcus kodakarensis EndoIII (TkoEndoIII). We utilized amino acid sequence analysis and homology modeling to identify highly conserved regions with potential key residues in the EndoIII proteins. Using Ala-substituted TkoEndoIII mutant proteins, residues of interest were quantitatively examined via DNA binding, glycosylase/AP lyase/bifunctional activity, and DNA trapping assays. The obtained results allowed us to determine the roles, as well as the significance of these roles in Schiff base formation (Lys140 as a nucleophile and Asp158), Tg recognition (His160), substrate binding (Arg59, Leu101, Trp102, and Gly136), β-elimination activities (Ser57 and Asp62), and [4Fe-4S] cluster formation (Cys208 and Cys215). Interestingly, a critical role played by the highly conserved Lys105 (predicted as being away from the catalytic site) in substrate binding, accompanied by a significant indirect effect on catalytic activity, were detected. Our results suggest that these particular residues play conserved roles among EndoIII orthologs across the domains. In addition to identifying the critical role of the highly conserved Lys105, the study provides a comprehensive understanding of the functions attributable to the evolutionarily conserved residues found in the EndoIII family, from Escherichia coli to humans.

Biochemical reconstitution and genetic characterization of the major oxidative damage base excision DNA repair pathway in Thermococcus kodakarensis

Reactive oxygen species drive the oxidation of guanine to 8-oxoguanine (8oxoG), which threatens genome integrity. The repair of 8oxoG is carried out by base excision repair enzymes in Bacteria and Eukarya, however, little is known about archaeal 8oxoG repair. This study identifies a member of the Ogg-subfamily archaeal GO glycosylase (AGOG) in Thermococcus kodakarensis, an anaerobic, hyperthermophilic archaeon, and delineates its mechanism, kinetics, and substrate specificity. TkoAGOG is the major 8oxoG glycosylase in T. kodakarensis, but is non-essential. In addition to TkoAGOG, the major apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) endonuclease (TkoEndoIV) required for archaeal base excision repair and cell viability was identified and characterized. Enzymes required for the archaeal oxidative damage base excision repair pathway were identified and the complete pathway was reconstituted. This study illustrates the conservation of oxidative damage repair across all Domains of life.

(5'R)-and (5'S)-purine 5',8-cyclo-2'-deoxyribonucleosides: reality or artifactual measurements? A reply to Chatgilialoglu's comments (this issue)

This rebuttal letter is aimed at refuting the poor and false arguments elaborated by Chatgilialoglu (preceding article) in his response to the position article (Cadet et al. Free Radic Res 2019;53:574-577) that focussed on the putative reliability of the HPLC-MS/MS measurements of five radiation-induced damage to cellular DNA, which included 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2'-deoxyadenosine and the (5'R) and (5'S) diastereomers of 5',8-cyclo-2'-deoxyadenosine and 5',8-cyclo-2'-deoxyadenosine (Krokidis et al. Free Radic Res 2017;51:470-482). Unfortunately, none of the main issues we raised on the suitability of the analytical approach and the shortcomings associated with DNA extraction in HPLC based measurement methods of oxidatively generated damage in cells were properly considered in Chatigilialolu's letter. The main questionable issues include the lack of information on the sensitivity of HPLC-MS/MS analysis, the absence of a dose curve that is essential in the formation of damage and the nonconsideration of artifactual oxidation.

Biochemical characterization and mutational studies of the 8-oxoguanine DNA glycosylase from the hyperthermophilic and radioresistant archaeon Thermococcus gammatolerans

8-oxoguanine (GO) is a major lesion found in DNA that arises from guanine oxidation. The hyperthermophilic and radioresistant euryarchaeon Thermococcus gammatolerans encodes an archaeal GO DNA glycosylase (Tg-AGOG). Here, we characterized biochemically Tg-AGOG and probed its GO removal mechanism by mutational studies. Tg-AGOG can remove GO from DNA at high temperature through a β-elimination reaction. The enzyme displays an optimal temperature, ca.85-95 °C, and an optimal pH, ca.7.0-8.5. In addition, Tg-AGOG activity is independent on a divalent metal ion. However, both Co²⁺ and Cu²⁺ inhibit its activity. The enzyme activity is also inhibited by NaCl. Furthermore, Tg-AGOG specifically cleaves GO-containing dsDNA in the order: GO:C, GO:T, GO:A, and GO:G. Moreover, the temperature dependence of cleavage rates of the enzyme was determined, and from this, the activation energy for GO removal from DNA was first estimated to be 16.9 ± 0.9 kcal/mol. In comparison with the wild-type Tg-AGOG, the R197A mutant has a reduced cleavage activity for GO-containing DNA, whereas both the P193A and F167A mutants exhibit similar cleavage activities for GO-containing DNA. While the mutations of P193 and F167 to Ala lead to increased binding, the mutation of R197 to Ala had no significant effect on binding. These observations suggest that residue R197 is involved in catalysis, and residues P193 and F167 are flexible for conformational change.

The interplay at the replisome mitigates the impact of oxidative damage on the genetic integrity of hyperthermophilic Archaea

8-oxodeoxyguanosine (8-oxodG), a major oxidised base modification, has been investigated to study its impact on DNA replication in hyperthermophilic Archaea. Here we show that 8-oxodG is formed in the genome of growing cells, with elevated levels following exposure to oxidative stress. Functional characterisation of cell-free extracts and the DNA polymerisation enzymes, PolB, PolD, and the p41/p46 complex, alone or in the presence of accessory factors (PCNA and RPA) indicates that translesion synthesis occurs under replicative conditions. One of the major polymerisation effects was stalling, but each of the individual proteins could insert and extend past 8-oxodG with differing efficiencies. The introduction of RPA and PCNA influenced PolB and PolD in similar ways, yet provided a cumulative enhancement to the polymerisation performance of p41/p46. Overall, 8-oxodG translesion synthesis was seen to be potentially mutagenic leading to errors that are reminiscent of dA:8-oxodG base pairing.

Formation and repair of oxidatively generated damage in cellular DNA

In this review article, emphasis is placed on the critical survey of available data concerning modified nucleobase and 2-deoxyribose products that have been identified in cellular DNA following exposure to a wide variety of oxidizing species and agents including, hydroxyl radical, one-electron oxidants, singlet oxygen, hypochlorous acid and ten-eleven translocation enzymes. In addition, information is provided about the generation of secondary oxidation products of 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine and nucleobase addition products with reactive aldehydes arising from the decomposition of lipid peroxides. It is worth noting that the different classes of oxidatively generated DNA damage that consist of single lesions, intra- and interstrand cross-links were unambiguously assigned and quantitatively detected on the basis of accurate measurements involving in most cases high performance liquid chromatography coupled to electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry. The reported data clearly show that the frequency of DNA lesions generated upon severe oxidizing conditions, including exposure to ionizing radiation is low, at best a few modifications per 106 normal bases. Application of accurate analytical measurement methods has also allowed the determination of repair kinetics of several well-defined lesions in cellular DNA that however concerns so far only a restricted number of cases.