Synthesis, Characterization, and Photocatalytic H2-Evolving Activity of a Family of [Co(N4Py)(X)](n+) Complexes in Aqueous Solution

Co(III) complexes of the pentadentate NHC ligand PY4Im: carbene-induced trans influences and the non-disappearing 13C NMR peak

Co(III) complexes of the N-heterocyclic carbene ligand PY4Im (PY4Im = (1,3-bis(bis(2-pyridyl)methyl)imidazol-2-ylidene)) having the general formula [(PY4Im)Co(X)](ClO4)n (X = NCMe; n = 3: OH-, N3-, NCS-, ONO-, F-; n = 2: O2CO2-, n = 1; (N3-)3, n = 0) were prepared and structurally characterised. X-ray structural data are consistent with the presence of a trans influence due to the coordinated carbene carbon, and this is also supported by computational results. 13C NMR spectra of the complexes did not display peaks corresponding to the carbene carbon, except in the case of the [(PY4Im)Co(O2CO)]+ cation, where a peak at δ = 170.21 ppm was observed. However, HMBC spectra allowed indirect determination of the chemical shifts of the carbene carbon in the remaining complexes, owing to the geometry of the PY4Im ligand. Calculated 13C chemical shifts for the complexes showed very good agreement with the experimental values for all but the carbene carbon atoms in all cases.

Electrochemical Properties of a Rhodium(III) Mono-Terpyridyl Complex and Use as a Catalyst for Light-Driven Hydrogen Evolution in Water

Molecular hydrogen (H₂) is considered one of the most promising fuels to decarbonize the industrial and transportation sectors, and its photocatalytic production from molecular catalysts is a research field that is still abounding. The search for new molecular catalysts for H₂ production with simple and easily synthesized ligands is still ongoing, and the terpyridine ligand with its particular electronic and coordination properties, is a good candidate to design new catalysts meeting these requirements. Herein, we have isolated the new mono-terpyridyl rhodium complex, [Rh^III(tpy)(CH₃CN)Cl₂](CF₃SO₃) (Rh-tpy), and shown that it can act as a catalyst for the light-induced proton reduction into H₂ in water in the presence of the [Ru(bpy)₃]Cl₂ (Ru) photosensitizer and ascorbate as sacrificial electron donor. Under photocatalytic conditions, in acetate buffer at pH 4.5 with 0.1 M of ascorbate and 530 μM of Ru, the Rh-tpy catalyst produces H₂ with turnover number versus catalyst (TON_Cat*) of 300 at a Rh concentration of 10 μM, and up to 1000 at a concentration of 1 μM. The photocatalytic performance of Ru/Rh-tpy/HA^-/H₂A has been also compared with that obtained with the bis-dimethyl-bipyridyl complex [Rh^III(dmbpy)₂Cl₂]⁺ (Rh2) as a catalyst in the same experimental conditions. The investigation of the electrochemical properties of Rh-tpy in DMF solvent reveals that the two-electrons reduced state of the complex, the square-planar [Rh^I(tpy)Cl] (Rh^I-tpy), is quantitatively electrogenerated by bulk electrolysis. This complex is stable for hours under an inert atmosphere owing to the π-acceptor property of the terpyridine ligand that stabilizes the low oxidation states of the rhodium, making this catalyst less prone to degrade during photocatalysis. The π-acceptor property of terpyridine also confers to the Rh-tpy catalyst a moderately negative reduction potential (Ep_c(Rh^III/Rh^I) = -0.83 V vs. SCE in DMF), making possible its reduction by the reduced state of Ru, [Ru^II(bpy)(bpy^•-)]⁺ (Ru^-) (E_1/2(Ru^II/Ru^-) = -1.50 V vs. SCE) generated by a reductive quenching of the Ru excited state (*Ru) by ascorbate during photocatalysis. A Stern-Volmer plot and transient absorption spectroscopy confirmed that the first step of the photocatalytic process is the reductive quenching of *Ru by ascorbate. The resulting reduced Ru species (Ru^-) were then able to activate the Rh^III-tpy H₂-evolving catalyst by reduction generating Rh^I-tpy, which can react with a proton on a sub-nanosecond time scale to form a Rh^III(H)-tpy hydride, the key intermediate for H₂ evolution.

Recent findings and future directions in photosynthetic hydrogen evolution using polypyridine cobalt complexes

The production of hydrogen gas using water as the molecular substrate currently represents one of the most challenging and appealing reaction schemes in the field of artificial photosynthesis (AP), i.e., the conversion of solar energy into fuels. In order to be efficient, this process requires a suitable combination of a light-harvesting sensitizer, an electron donor, and a hydrogen-evolving catalyst (HEC). In the last few years, cobalt polypyridine complexes have been discovered to be competent molecular catalysts for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER), showing enhanced efficiency and stability with respect to previously reported molecular species. This perspective collects information about all relevant cobalt polypyridine complexes employed for the HER in aqueous solution under light-driven conditions in the presence of Ru(bpy)32+ (where bpy = 2,2'-bipyridine) as the photosensitizer and ascorbate as the electron donor, trying to highlight promising chemical motifs and aiming towards efficient catalytic activity in order to stimulate further efforts to design molecular catalysts for hydrogen generation and allow their profitable implementation in devices. As a final step, a few suggestions for the benchmarking of HECs employed under light-driven conditions are introduced.

Can you break the oxo-wall? A multiconfigurational perspective

The concept of the "oxo-wall" was conceived about 60 years ago by Harry B. Gray, and has been found to be related to the non-existence of high-valent M-oxo species in the +IV oxidation state in a tetragonal geometry beyond group 8 in the periodic table. Several efforts have been made in the past decades to test and find examples that violate this theory. Several claims of violation in the past were attributed to the difference in the geometries/coordination number and, therefore, these are not examples of true violation. In recent years, substantial efforts have been undertaken to synthesise a true Co^IVO species with various ligand architectures. Co^IVO and Co^III-O˙ are electromers and, while they are interchangeably used in the literature; the former violates the oxo-wall while the latter does not. The possibility that these two species could exist in various proportions similar to resonating structures has not been considered in detail in this area. Furthermore, there have been no attempts to quantify such mixing. In this direction, we have employed density functional theory (DFT) and ab initio CASSCF/NEVPT2 methods to quantify the co-existence of Co^IVO and Co^III-O˙ isomeric species. By thoroughly studying six different metal-oxo species, we affirm that the nature of such electromeric mixing is minimal/negligible for Fe^IVO and Mn^IVO species - both are pre-oxo-wall examples. By studying four different ligand architectures with Co-oxo species, our results unveil that the mixing of Co^IVO ↔ Co^III-O˙ is substantial in all geometries, with dominant Co^IVO species favourable for the S = 3/2 intermediate spin state. The percentage of the Co^III-O˙ species is enhanced substantially for the S = 1/2 low-spin state. We have attempted to develop a tool to estimate the percentage of the Co^III-O˙ species using various structural parameters. Among those tested, a linear relationship between % of Co^III-O˙ and a bond length based ratio is found (, where d_(Co-O) and d_(Co-Nax) are the axial Co-O and Co-N_ax bond lengths in Å, respectively). It is found that the higher the R_d, the greater the Co^III-O˙ character will be and the geometrically portable correlation developed offers a way to qualitatively compute the % of Co^III-O˙ character for unknown geometries.

Electronic effects on polypyridyl Co complex-based water reduction catalysts

Three new isomeric cobalt complexes of TPA (tris(2-pyridylmethyl)amine) based on methoxy substitution at the ortho, meta and para positions, respectively, were constructed and their photocatalytic proton reduction efficiencies were compared. It was found that there are good linear correlations with the Hammett constants of the substituents for the computed Co–N bond lengths, redox potentials of Co^II/I and Co^I/0 events, and the photocatalytic activities of the complexes. The ortho-substituted Co complex distinguished itself from the others remarkably in all these comparisons, demonstrating the presence of a steric effect besides the electronic effect. For other examined complexes, a stronger electron-donating substituent may lead to a higher hydrogen evolution efficiency, suggesting that the formation of a Co(iii) hydride intermediate is the rate-limiting step.

Three isomeric Co complexes showed a significant substituent electronic effect in photocatalytic hydrogen production.

Electrocatalytic Proton Reduction by a Cobalt(III) Hydride Complex with Phosphinopyridine PN Ligands

Cobalt complexes with 2-(diisopropylphosphinomethyl)pyridine (PN) ligands have been synthesized with the aim of demonstrating electrocatalytic proton reduction to dihydrogen with a well-defined hydride complex of an Earth-abundant metal. Reactions of simple cobalt precursors with 2-(diisopropylphosphino-methyl)pyridine (PN) yield [Co^II(PN)₂(MeCN)][BF₄]₂ 1, [Co^III(PN)₂(H)(MeCN)][PF₆]₂ 2, and [Co^III(PN)₂(H)(Cl)][PF₆] 3. Complexes 1 and 3 have been characterized crystallographically. Unusually for a bidentate PN ligand, all three exhibit geometries with mutually trans phosphorus and nitrogen ligands. Complex 1 exhibits a distorted square-pyramidal geometry with an axial MeCN ligand in a low-spin electronic state. In complexes 2 and 3, the PN ligands lie in a plane leaving the hydride trans to MeCN or chloride, respectively. The redox behavior of the three complexes has been studied by cyclic voltammetry at variable scan rates and by spectroelectrochemistry. A catalytic wave is observed in the presence of trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) at an applied potential close to the Co(II/I) couple of 1. Bulk electrolysis of 1, 2, or 3 at a potential of ca. -1.4 V vs E(Fc⁺/Fc) in the presence of TFA yields H₂ with Faradaic yields close to 100%. A catalytic mechanism is proposed in which the pyridine moiety of a PN ligand acts as a pendant proton donor following opening of the chelate ring. Additional mechanisms may also operate, especially in the presence of high acid concentration where speciation changes.

The role of the capping agent and nanocrystal size in photoinduced hydrogen evolution using CdTe/CdS quantum dot sensitizers

Hydrogen production via light-driven water splitting is a key process in the context of solar energy conversion. In this respect, the choice of suitable light-harvesting units appears as a major challenge, particularly as far as stability issues are concerned. In this work, we report on the use of CdTe/CdS QDs as photosensitizers for light-assisted hydrogen evolution in combination with a nickel bis(diphosphine) catalyst (1) and ascorbate as the sacrificial electron donor. QDs of different sizes (1.7-3.4 nm) and with different capping agents (MPA, MAA, and MSA) have been prepared and their performance assessed in the above-mentioned photocatalytic reaction. Detailed photophysical studies have been also accomplished to highlight the charge transfer processes relevant to the photocatalytic reaction. Hydrogen evolution is observed with remarkable efficiencies when compared to common coordination compounds like Ru(bpy)₃²⁺ (where bpy = 2,2'-bipyridine) as light-harvesting units. Furthermore, the hydrogen evolution performance under irradiation is strongly determined by the nature of the capping agent and the QD size and can be related to the concentration of the surface defects within the semiconducting nanocrystal. Overall, the present results outline how QDs featuring large quantum yields and long lifetimes are desirable to achieve sustained hydrogen evolution upon irradiation and that a precise control of the structural and photophysical properties thus appears as a major requirement towards profitable photocatalytic applications.

Photosensitizers for H2 Evolution Based on Charged or Neutral Zn and Sn Porphyrins

We report a comparison between a series of zinc and tin porphyrins as photosensitizers for photochemical hydrogen evolution using cobaloxime complexes as molecular catalysts. Among all the chromophores tested, only the positively charged zinc porphyrin, [ZnTMePyP⁴⁺]Cl₄, and the neutral tin porphyrin derivatives, Sn(OH)₂TPyP, Sn(Cl₂)TPP-[COOMe]₄, and Sn(Cl₂)TPP-[PO(OEt)₂]₄, were photocatalytically active. Hydrogen evolution was strongly affected by the pH value as well as the different concentrations of both the sensitizer and the catalyst. A comprehensive photophysical and electrochemical investigation was conducted in order to examine the mechanism of photocatalysis. The results derived from this study establish fundamental criteria with respect to the design and synthesis of porphyrin derivatives for their application as photosensitizers in photoinduced hydrogen evolution.

Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution with a Cobalt Complex Bearing Pendant Proton Relays: Acid Strength and Applied Potential Govern Mechanism and Stability

[Co(bapbpy)Cl]⁺ (bapbpy: 6,6'-bis(2-aminopyridyl)-2,2'-bipyridine) is a polypyridyl cobalt(II) complex bearing both a redox-active bipyridine ligand and pendant proton relays. This compound catalyzes electro-assisted H₂ evolution in DMF with distinct mechanisms depending on the strength of the acid used as the proton source (pK_a values ranging from 3.4 to 13.5 in DMF) and the applied potential. Electrochemical studies combining cyclic voltammetry and bulk electrolysis measurements enabled one to bring out four distinct catalytic processes. Where applicable, relevant kinetic information were obtained using either foot-of-the-wave analysis (FOWA) or analytical treatment of bulk electrolysis experiments. Among the different catalytic pathways identified in this study, a clear relationship between the catalyst performances and stability was evidenced. These results draw attention to a number of interesting considerations and may help in the development of future adequately designed catalysts.

Efficient Light-Driven Hydrogen Evolution Using a Thiosemicarbazone-Nickel (II) Complex

In the following work, we carried out a systematic study investigating the behavior of a thiosemicarbazone-nickel (II) complex (NiTSC-OMe) as a molecular catalyst for photo-induced hydrogen production. A comprehensive comparison regarding the combination of three different chromophores with this catalyst has been performed, using [Ir(ppy)₂(bpy)]PF₆, [Ru(bpy)₃]Cl₂ and [ZnTMePy]PCl₄ as photosensitizers. Thorough evaluation of the parameters affecting the hydrogen evolution experiments (i.e., concentration, pH, solvent nature, and ratio), has been performed in order to probe the most efficient photocatalytic system, which was comprised by NiTSC-OMe and [Ir(ppy)₂(bpy)]PF₆ as catalyst and chromophore, respectively. The electrochemical together with the photophysical investigation clarified the properties of this photocatalytic system and allowed us to propose a possible reaction mechanism for hydrogen production.

Design and photophysical studies of iridium(iii)–cobalt(iii) dyads and their application for dihydrogen photo-evolution

We report several new dyads constituted of cationic iridium(iii) photosensitizers and cobalt(iii) catalyst connected via free pendant pyridine on the photosensitizers.

Role of Anation on the Mechanism of Proton Reduction Involving a Pentapyridine Cobalt Complex: A Theoretical Study

Kinetic and thermodynamic aspects of proton reduction involving pentapyridine cobalt(II) complex were investigated with the help of quantum chemical calculations. Free energy profile of all possible mechanistic routes for proton reduction was constructed with the consideration of both anation and solvent bound pathways. The computed free energy profile shows that acetate ion plays a significant role in modulating the kinetic aspects of Co(III)-hydride formation which is found to be the key intermediate for proton reduction. Upon replacing solvent by acetate ion, one electron reduction and protonation of Co^I species become more rapid along with slow displacement reaction. Most favorable pathways for hydrogen evolution from Co(III)-hydride species is also investigated. Among the four possible pathways, reduction followed by protonation of Co(III)-hydride (RPP) is found to be the most feasible pathway. On the basis of QTAIM and NBO analyses, the electronic origin of most favorable pathway is explained. The basicity of cobalt center along with thermodynamic stability of putative Co^III/II-H species is essentially a prime factor in deciding the most favorable pathway for hydrogen evolution. Our computed results are in good agreement with experimental observations and also provided adequate information to design cobalt-based molecular electrocatalysts for proton reduction in future.

Enhancement and control of the selectivity in light-driven ketone versus water reduction using aminopyridine cobalt complexes

A highly selective light-driven reduction of aromatic ketones versus water reduction could be achieved by ligand design.

Understanding light-driven H2 evolution through the electronic tuning of aminopyridine cobalt complexes

Electronic effects provide a general mechanistic scenario for rationalizing photocatalytic water reduction activity with aminopyridine cobalt complexes.

A new family of cobalt complexes with the general formula [Co^II(OTf)₂(^Y,XPy^Metacn)] (1^R, ^Y,XPy^Metacn = 1-[(4-X-3,5-Y-2-pyridyl)methyl]-4,7-dimethyl-1,4,7-triazacyclononane, (X = CN (1^CN), CO₂Et (1^CO2Et), Cl (1^Cl), H (1^H), NMe₂ (1^NMe2)) where (Y = H, and X = OMe when Y = Me (1^DMM)) is reported. We found that the electronic tuning of the ^Y,XPy^Metacn ligand not only has an impact on the electronic and structural properties of the metal center, but also allows for a systematic water-reduction-catalytic control. In particular, the increase of the electron-withdrawing character of the pyridine moiety promotes a 20-fold enhancement of the catalytic outcome. By UV-Vis spectroscopy, luminescence quenching studies and Transient Absorption Spectroscopy (TAS), we have studied the direct reaction of the photogenerated [Ir^III(ppy)₂(bpy˙^–)] (PS_Ir) species to form the elusive Co^I intermediates. In particular, our attention is focused on the effect of the ligand architecture in this elemental step of the catalytic mechanism. Finally, kinetic isotopic experiments together with DFT calculations provide complementary information about the rate-determining step of the catalytic cycle.

Structure-Activity and Stability Relationships for Cobalt Polypyridyl-Based Hydrogen-Evolving Catalysts in Water

A series of eight new and three known cobalt polypyridyl-based hydrogen-evolving catalysts (HECs) with distinct electronic and structural differences are benchmarked in photocatalytic runs in water. Methylene-bridged bis-bipyridyl is the preferred scaffold, both in terms of stability and rate. For a cobalt complex of the tetradentate methanol-bridged bispyridyl-bipyridyl complex [Co^II Br(tpy)]Br, a detailed mechanistic picture is obtained by combining electrochemistry, spectroscopy, and photocatalysis. In the acidic branch, a proton-coupled electron transfer, assigned to formation of Co^III -H, is found upon reduction of Co^II , in line with a pK_a (Co^III -H) of approximately 7.25. Subsequent reduction (-0.94 V vs. NHE) and protonation close the catalytic cycle. Methoxy substitution on the bipyridyl scaffold results in the expected cathodic shift of the reduction, but fails to change the pK_a (Co^III -H). An analysis of the outcome of the benchmarking in view of this postulated mechanism is given along with an outlook for design criteria for new generations of catalysts.

Dual cobalt-copper light-driven catalytic reduction of aldehydes and aromatic ketones in aqueous media

A dual catalytic system based on earth-abundant elements reduces aromatic ketones and aldehydes to alcohols in aqueous media under visible light. An unprecedented selectivity for the reduction of aromatic ketones versus aliphatic aldehydes is reported.

We present an efficient, general, fast, and robust light-driven methodology based on earth-abundant elements to reduce aryl ketones, and both aryl and aliphatic aldehydes (up to 1400 TON). The catalytic system consists of a robust and well-defined aminopyridyl cobalt complex active for photocatalytic water reduction and the [Cu(bathocuproine)(Xantphos)](PF₆) photoredox catalyst. The dual cobalt–copper system uses visible light as the driving-force and H₂O and an electron donor (Et₃N or ⁱPr₂EtN) as the hydride source. The catalytic system operates in aqueous mixtures (80–60% water) with high selectivity towards the reduction of organic substrates (>2000) vs. water reduction, and tolerates O₂. High selectivity towards the hydrogenation of aryl ketones is observed in the presence of terminal olefins, aliphatic ketones, and alkynes. Remarkably, the catalytic system also shows unique selectivity for the reduction of acetophenone in the presence of aliphatic aldehydes. The catalytic system provides a simple and convenient method to obtain α,β-deuterated alcohols. Both the observed reactivity and the DFT modelling support a common cobalt hydride intermediate. The DFT modelled energy profile for the [Co–H] nucleophilic attack to acetophenone and water rationalises the competence of [Co^II–H] to reduce acetophenone in the presence of water. Mechanistic studies suggest alternative mechanisms depending on the redox potential of the substrate. These results show the potential of the water reduction catalyst [Co(OTf)(Py₂^Tstacn)](OTf) (1), (Py₂^Tstacn = 1,4-di(picolyl)-7-(p-toluenesulfonyl)-1,4,7-triazacyclononane, OTf = trifluoromethanesulfonate anion) to develop light-driven selective organic transformations and fine solar chemicals.

Cobalt, nickel, and iron complexes of 8-hydroxyquinoline-di(2-picolyl)amine for light-driven hydrogen evolution

Novel first-row transition metal complexes based on the 8-hydroxyquinoline-di(2-picolyl)amine ligand were prepared and tested as potential HECs in light-driven experiments.

Photoinduced hydrogen evolution with new tetradentate cobalt(ii) complexes based on the TPMA ligand

New cobalt(ii) complexes based on the TPMA ligand have been synthesized and characterized as molecular catalysts for photoinduced hydrogen evolution.