Extraction and Quantitative Analysis of Goat Milk Oligosaccharides: Composition, Variation, Associations, and 2'-FL Variability

Comparative study of the oligosaccharide profile in goat, bovine, sheep, and human milk whey

Milk oligosaccharides are high added value compounds that could be obtained by exploiting cheese whey, a byproduct of dairy industry. The objective was to compare the abundance and diversity of oligosaccharides in whey samples from domestic animals and humans. During fresh cheese making, whey samples were collected and analyzed by untargeted and targeted small molecule analysis using high-resolution mass-spectrometry. A great similarity in the metabolite profile between goat and sheep was observed. Up to 11 oligosaccharides were observed in the sheep whey from those typically found in humans. The concentration of 2'-Fucosyllactose (0.136 ± 0.055 g/L) and 3-Fucosyllactose (0.079 ± 0.009 g/L) were significantly higher (p-value <0.01) in sheep whey, while the concentration of 3'-Sialyllactose (0.826 ± 0.638 g/L) was higher in goat whey. No significant differences were observed between goat and sheep whey for the other oligosaccharides (p-value >0.05). Therefore, sheep and goat whey could become an important source of oligosaccharides through their revalorization.

Human Milk Oligosaccharides: Decoding Their Structural Variability, Health Benefits, and the Evolution of Infant Nutrition

Human milk oligosaccharides (HMOs), the third most abundant solid component in human milk, vary significantly among women due to factors such as secretor status, race, geography, season, maternal nutrition and weight, gestational age, and delivery method. In recent studies, HMOs have been shown to have a variety of functional roles in the development of infants. Because HMOs are not digested by infants, they act as metabolic substrates for certain bacteria, helping to establish the infant's gut microbiota. By encouraging the growth of advantageous intestinal bacteria, these sugars function as prebiotics and produce short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs), which are essential for gut health. HMOs can also specifically reduce harmful microbes and viruses binding to the gut epithelium, preventing illness. HMO addition to infant formula is safe and promotes healthy development, infection prevention, and microbiota. Current infant formulas frequently contain oligosaccharides (OSs) that differ structurally from those found in human milk, making it unlikely that they would reproduce the unique effects of HMOs. However, there is a growing trend in producing OSs resembling HMOs, but limited data make it unclear whether HMOs offer additional therapeutic benefits compared to non-human OSs. Better knowledge of how the human mammary gland synthesizes HMOs could direct the development of technologies that yield a broad variety of complex HMOs with OS compositions that closely mimic human milk. This review explores HMOs' complex nature and vital role in infant health, examining maternal variation in HMO composition and its contributing factors. It highlights recent technological advances enabling large-scale studies on HMO composition and its effects on infant health. Furthermore, HMOs' multifunctional roles in biological processes such as infection prevention, brain development, and gut microbiota and immune response regulation are investigated. The structural distinctions between HMOs and other mammalian OSs in infant formulas are discussed, with a focus on the trend toward producing more precise replicas of HMOs found in human milk.

Is it possible to obtain substitutes for human milk oligosaccharides from bovine milk, goat milk, or other mammal milks?

Considering the current level of chemical and biological synthesis technology, it was a sensible selection to obtain milk oligosaccharides (MOs) from other mammals as the potential substitute for human MOs (HMOs) that possessed various structural features in the infant formula. Through a comprehensive analysis of the content, structure, and function of MOs in six distinct varieties of mammal milk, it has been shown that goat milk was the most suitable material for the preparation as a human milk substitute. Goat MOs (GMOs) had a relatively high content and diverse structural features compared to those found in other mammalian milks. The concentration of GMOs in colostrum ranged from 60 to 350 mg/L, whereas in mature milk, it ranged from 200 to 24,00 mg/L. The acidic oligosaccharides in goat milk have attracted considerable attention due to their closeness in acidic content and structural diversity with HMOs. Simultaneously, it was discovered that some structures, like N-glycolylneuraminic acid, were found to have a certain content in GMOs and served essential functional properties. Moreover, studies focused on the extraction of MOs from goat milk indicated that the production of GMOs on an industrial scale was viable. Furthermore, it is imperative to do further study on GMOs to enhance the preparation process, discover of new MOs structures and bioactivity evaluation, which will contribute to the development of both the commercial production of MOs and the goat milk industry.

Genetic and environmental factors shaping goat milk oligosaccharide composition

Oligosaccharides (OS) in milk have been suggested to influence the health and development of the newborn by promoting growth of beneficial gut bacteria, stimulating brain development, and enhancing immune functions. Goat milk is a natural source of specific OS, which could be a potential beneficial ingredient for infant formula. In this study, goat milk oligosaccharide (gMOS) content from approximately 1,000 dairy goats across 18 commercial farms was studied. A genomic relationship matrix was used to unravel genetic and environmental factors shaping gMOS content. The most abundant gMOS identified was 3'-NGL, with a concentration of 32.05 mg/kg, while 3-FL exhibited the lowest concentration at 1.85 mg/kg. Acidic OS had a notably higher content (81.67 mg/kg) than neutral OS (24.88 mg/kg). High variability in gMOS content was observed among individual goats, which could for a large extent be attributed to genetic differences. Heritability estimates ranged from 31% for 3'-GL to 85% for 3-FL. High positive genetic correlations (>0.57) were estimated between 3'-SL and 6'-SL, and between 6'-GL and 3'-GL. The contribution of differences between farms to variation in milk OS content varied from 3% for 3'-NGL to 45% for 6'-SL. While gMOS like 3'-GL, 6'-GL, and 6'-NGL, were significantly influenced by systematic environmental factors such as the lactation stage, the impact of these factors was relatively minor compared with the importance of genetic and farm effects. This research, which stands out due to its relatively large sample size, underscores the pivotal role of genetics, and to a smaller extent farm practices like feed ration, in determining gMOS composition.

Unlocking the mysteries of milk oligosaccharides: Structure, metabolism, and function

Milk oligosaccharides (MOs), complex carbohydrates prevalent in human breast milk, play a vital role in infant nutrition. Serving as prebiotics, they inhibit pathogen adherence, modulate the immune system, and support newborn brain development. Notably, MOs demonstrate significant variations in concentration and composition, both across different species and within the same species. These characteristics of MOs lead to several compelling questions: (i) What distinct beneficial functions do MOs offer and how do the functions vary along with their structural differences? (ii) In what ways do MOs in human milk differ from those in other mammals, and what factors drive these unique profiles? (iii) What are the emerging applications of MOs, particularly in the context of their incorporation into infant formula? This review delves into the structural characteristics, quantification methods, and species-specific concentration differences of MOs. It highlights the critical role of human MOs in infant growth and their potential applications, providing substantial evidence to enhance infant health and development.

Innovative direct introduction-ion mobility-mass spectrometry (DI-IM-MS) approach for fast and robust isomer-specific quantification in a complex matrix: Application to 2'-fucosyllactose (2'-FL) in breast milk

Identification and specific quantification of isomers in a complex biological matrix by mass spectrometry alone is not an easy task due to their identical chemical formula and therefore their same mass-to-charge ratio (m/z). Here, the potential of direct introduction combined with ion mobility-mass spectrometry (DI-IM-MS) for rapid quantification of isomers as human milk oligosaccharides (HMOs) was investigated. Differences in HMO profiles between various analyzed breast milk samples were highlighted using the single ion mobility monitoring (SIM2) acquisition for high ion mobility resolution detection. Furthermore, the Se+ (secretor) or Se- (non-secretor) phenotype could be assigned to breast milk samples studied based on their HMO contents, especially on the response of 2'-fucosyllactose (2'-FL) and lacto-N-fucopentaose I (LNFP I). The possibility of quantifying a specific isomer in breast milk by DI-IM-MS was also investigated. The standard addition method allowed the determination of the 2'-FL despite the presence of other oligosaccharides, including 3-fucosyllactose (3-FL) isomer in breast milk. This proof-of-concept study demonstrated the high potential of such an approach for the rapid and convenient quantification of isomers in complex mixtures.

Comparative Analysis of Free and Glycoconjugates Oligosaccharide Content in Milk from Different Species

Human milk is important for infant growth, and oligosaccharides are one of its main functional nutrients. To enable a systematic comparison of free oligosaccharide and glycoconjugate content in milk from different species, the phenol-sulfuric acid and resorcinol assays were combined to determine the content. Using real samples, the method revealed that human milk contained the highest amount of total, neutral (9.84 ± 0.31 g/L), and sialylated (3.21 ± 0.11 g/L) free oligosaccharides, followed by goat milk, with neutral (0.135 ± 0.015 g/L) and sialylated (0.192 ± 0.016 g/L) free oligosaccharides and at a distance by bovine and yak milk. The highest total glycoconjugate content was detected in yak milk (0.798 ± 0.011 g/L), followed by human, bovine, and goat milk. These findings suggest that goat milk is the best source of free oligosaccharides in infant formula and functional dairy products and yak milk is the best source of glycoconjugates.

Quantitation of bioactive components in infant formulas: Milk oligosaccharides, sialic acids and corticosteroids

Human milk is considered the optimal food for infants with abundant nutrients and bioactive components, which play key roles in infant health and development. Infant formulas represent appropriate substitutes for human milk. There are many brands of infant formula with different ingredient sources and functions on the market. The present study aims to quantify important bioactive components, i.e., milk oligosaccharides (MOS), sialic acids (Sia) and corticosteroids, in different infant formulas and compare these to human milk. In total, 12 different infant formulas available on the Dutch market were analyzed in this study. The concentrations of MOS and Sia were characterized by UHPLC-FLD and LC-MS, while corticosteroids were determined using established UHPLC-MS/MS methods. Among infant formulas, 15 structures of oligosaccharides were identified, of which 2'-Fucosyllactose (2'FL), 3'-Galactosyllactose (3'GL) and 6'-Galactosyllactose (6́'GL) were found in all infant formulas. The oligosaccharide concentrations differed between milk source and brands and were 3-5 times lower than in human milk. All infant formulas contained Sia, N-acetylneuraminic acid (Neu5Ac) was dominant in bovine milk-based formulas, while N-glycolylneuraminic acid (Neu5Gc) was major in goat milk-based formula. All infant formulas contained corticosteroids, yet, at lower concentrations than human milk. Insight in concentrations of bioactive components in infant formula compared to human milk may give direction to dietary advices and/or novel formula design.

Development and validation of a versatile analytical method for absolute quantification of seven oligosaccharides in human, bovine, and goat milk

Oligosaccharides are significant in mammalian milk, where they serve as prebiotics that promote the growth of beneficial gut bacteria in infants. Comprehensive research of milk oligosaccharides requires precise and validated analytical methods for compositional studies. To address this need, the focus of our study was to develop and validate an analytical method using UPLC-MS/MS to quantify seven specific oligosaccharides found in mammalian milk. The developed and optimized method has adequate linearity, accuracy, and precision parameters. The detection (LOD) and quantification (LOQ) limits for the seven compounds ranged from 0.0018 to 0.0030 μg/mL and 0.0054-0.0063 μg/mL, respectively. The sample preparation method yielded recovery rates above 90.5 %. Furthermore, no significant matrix effect was observed. The validated method was successfully applied to human, goat, and bovine milk samples, demonstrating its proficiency in identifying variances in the concentration of oligosaccharides across different mammals. This versatile method will allow future research about factors affecting oligosaccharide composition.

Qualitative and Quantitative Changes of Oligosaccharides in Human and Animal Milk over Lactation

The aim of this study was to investigate the changes in human and animal milk oligosaccharides over lactation. In total, 89, 97, 115, and 71 oligosaccharides were identified in human, bovine, goat, and camel milk. The number of common oligosaccharides between camel and human milk was the highest (16 and 17 in transitional and mature milk). With respect to the absolute concentration of eight oligosaccharides (2'-FL, 3-FL, α3'-GL, LNT, LNnT, 3'-SL, 6'-SL, and DSL), 2'-FL, 3'-FL, LNT, and LNnT were much higher in human than three animal species. 3'-SL had a similar concentration in bovine colostrum (322.2 μg/mL) and human colostrum (321.0 μg/mL), followed by goat colostrum (105.1 μg/mL); however, it had the highest concentration in camel mature milk (304.5 μg/mL). The ratio of 6'-SL and 3'-SL (1.77) in goat colostrum was similar to that in human colostrum (1.68), followed by bovine colostrum (0.13). In terms of changes of eight oligosaccharides over lactation, they all decreased with the increase of lactation in bovine and goat milk; however, α3'-GL, 2'-FL, and 3-FL increased in camel species, and LNT increased first and then decreased over lactation in human milk. This study provides a better understanding of the variation of milk oligosaccharides related to lactation and species.

Comprehensive investigation of milk oligosaccharides in different mammalian species and the effect of breed and lactation period on sheep milk oligosaccharides

Milk oligosaccharides (MOs) have unique health benefits for newborns, and MOs are important components in mammalian milk. The present study was conducted to provide a comprehensive analysis of MOs in important domestic animals, including goats, cows, camels and sheep. The comparison with human MOs was conducted simultaneously. Furthermore, analysis of the relative abundance of sheep MOs among different breeds (Hu sheep, East Friesen sheep, East Friesen-Hu crossbred sheep) and lactation periods (colostrum, mature milk) was performed. In general, 35, 24 19, 26, and 16 MOs were identified in human, goat, bovine, camel and sheep milk, respectively. The type of sheep MOs was not greatly influenced by the breeds and lactation period. Hu sheep colostrum had the highest abundance of MOs among six sheep milks, followed by East Friesen sheep colostrum, while East Friesen-Hu crossbred sheep mature milk had the lowest abundance of MOs. These findings provide evidence for the potential value of MOs from domestic animal milk for the commercial applications.

Biological Relevance of Goat Milk Oligosaccharides to Infant Health

Milk is often regarded as the gold standard for the nourishment of all mammalian offspring. The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends exclusive breastfeeding for the first 6 months of the life of the infant, followed by a slow introduction of complementary foods to the breastfeeding routine for a period of approximately 2 years, whenever this is possible ( Global Strategy for Infant and Young Child Feeding; WHO, 2003). One of the most abundant components in all mammals' milk, which is associated with important health benefits, is the oligosaccharides. The milk oligosaccharides (MOS) of humans and other mammals differ in terms of their concentration and diversity. Among those, goat milk contains more oligosaccharides (gMOS) than other domesticated dairy animals, as well as a greater range of structures. This review summarizes the biological functions of MOS found in both human and goat milk to identify the possible biological relevance of gMOS in human health and development. Based on the existing literature, seven biological functions of gMOS were identified, namely, MOS action as prebiotics, immune modulators, and pathogen traps; their modulation of intestinal cells; protective effect against necrotizing enterocolitis; improved brain development; and positive effects on stressor exposure. Overall, goat milk is a viable alternate supply of functional MOS that could be employed in a newborn formula.

The Choice of Product for Mixed or Formula Feeding of Infant: Beneficial Properties of Goat’s Milk Formula

This review summarizes the benefits of goat’s milk as the basis to produce adapted milk formulas according to relevant infants feeding issues. The characteristics of main nutrients of modern goat’s milk formulas are presented. A balanced protein composition enriched with β-palmitate, presence of prebiotics-oligosaccharides, natural nucleotides and probiotics advances these formulas closer to breast milk and provide their multipotent sanogenetic effects. The unique composition of goat’s milk formulas allows to ensure normal physical growth of a baby, induces tissue and systemic immunity via adequate intestinal microbiota formation, maintains normal functioning of gut-brain axis, that promotes vegetative and visceral disorders (due to functional digestive disorders) correction. Thus, it is possible to recommend goat’s milk formulas in cases of forced mixed or formula feeding of healthy infants and children with functional digestive disorders.

Characterization of Bioactive Sialyl Oligosaccharides Separated from Colostrum of Indonesia Dairy Goat

The bioactive functions of oligosaccharides from human milk have been reported by many studies. Many of oligosaccharides isolated from colostrum and/or milk of dairy animals have been reported to have similar chemical structures with those in human colostrum and/or milk. It has been proved by several studies that the oligosaccharides with similar chemical structure shared common bioactivities. Among domesticated dairy animals, bovine/cattle, caprine/goat, and ovine/sheep are the most commonly used species to isolate oligosaccharides from their colostrum and/or milk. Several studies on the oligosaccharides from goat colostrum and milk have revealed similar properties to that of human milk and possess the highest content of sialyl oligosaccharides (SOS) as compared to other ruminants. Indonesia ranks first in Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) for goat milk production. Therefore, goat milk is the second most consumed milk in the country. The most reared dairy goat breed in Indonesia is Etawah Grade. However, oligosaccharides from Indonesia dairy animals including goat, have not been characterized. This is the first study to characterize oligosaccharides from Indonesia dairy animals. The present study was aimed to isolate and characterize oligosaccharides, specifically SOS from the colostrum of Etawah Grade goats by using proton/1H-nuclear magnetic resonance. The SOS successfully characterized in this study were: Neu5Ac(α2-3)Gal(β1-4)Glc (3'-N-acetylneuraminyllactose), Neu5Ac(α2-6)Gal(β1-4)Glc (6'-N-acetylneuraminyllactose), Neu5Gc(α2-3)Gal(β1-4)Glc (3'-N-glycolylneuraminyllactose), Neu5Gc(α2-6)Gal(β1-4)Glc (6'-N-glycolylneuraminyllactose), Neu5Ac(α2-6)Gal(β1-4) GlcNAc (6'-N-acetylneuraminyllactosamine) and Neu5Gc(α2-6)Gal(β1-4)GlcNAc (6'-N-glycolylneuraminyllactosamine). This finding shows that Etawah Grade, as a local dairy goat breed in Indonesia, is having significant potential to be natural source of oligosaccharides that can be utilized in the future food and pharmaceutical industries.