Aldol Condensation Versus Superbase-Catalyzed Addition of Ketones to Acetylenes: A Quantum-Chemical and Experimental Study

Polyaniline-Supported Tungsten-Catalyzed α-H Alkylation Reaction of Ketone with Alcohol

α-H alkylation of carbonyls is a significant reaction in the pharmaceutical industry because it can directly form a C-C bond in an environmentally benign manner. Thus, developing a novel catalyst for this reaction is a hot and practical topic in catalysis, organic synthesis, and materials science. In this paper, we found that polyaniline-supported tungsten could catalyze the α-H alkylation reaction of ketone with alcohol generating water as the only byproduct. Polyaniline support is the key for promoting the catalytic activity of tungsten, which is relatively cheaper than the traditionally employed noble metals. The reaction occurred under mild conditions with a wide substrate scope. The substrate initial concentration was enhanced to 1 mol/L, while the reaction speed was accelerated to reduce the reaction time to only 6 h; these improvements could significantly enhance the production capacity. The advantages make this reaction practical for synthesis with industrial purposes.

DFT calculations in solution systems: solvation energy, dispersion energy and entropy

DFT calculations of reaction mechanisms in solution have always been a hot topic, especially for transition-metal-catalyzed reactions. The calculation of solvation energy is performed using either the polarizable continuum model (PCM) or the universal solvation model SMD. The PCM calculation is very sensitive to the choice of atomic radii to form a cavity, where the self-consistent isodensity PCM (SCI-PCM) has been recognized as the best choice and our IDSCRF radii can provide a similar cavity. Moving from a gas-phase case to a solution case, dispersion energy and entropy should be carefully treated. The solvent-solute dispersion is also important in solution systems, and it should be calculated together with the solute dispersion. Only half of the solvent-solute dispersion energy from the PCM calculation belongs to the solute molecules to maintain a thermal equilibrium between a solute molecule and its cavity, similar to the treatment of electrostatic energy. Relative solute dispersion energy should also be shared equally with the newly formed cavity. The entropy change from a gas phase to a liquid phase is quite large, but the modern quantum chemistry programs can only calculate the gas-phase translational entropy based on the idea-gas equation. In this review, we will provide an operable method to calculate the solution translational entropy, which has been coded in our THERMO program.

Reply to the 'Comment on "Topography of the Free Energy Landscape on the Claisen-Schmidt Condensation: Solvent and Temperature Effect in the Rate-Controlling Step"' by N. D. Coutinho, H. G. Machado, V. H. Carvalho-Silva and W. A. da Silva, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2021, , 6738

In the Comment on our paper on the description of the Gibbs Free energy profile of Claisen-Schmidt condensation, it is claimed that our calculations are flawed due to inconsistencies with experimental isotope effects in aqueous acetonitrile. In this Reply, we presented rigorous arguments, ambiguities in the Comment and new calculations confirming the consistency of our results: (i) small differences in the relative energetic barriers in both experimental and theoretical curves make the assignment of the rate-limiting step debatable, making the concept of RCS questionable; (ii) it is shown how the misinterpretation of the elementary steps and of the overall processes rate constants led the Comment to incorrect conclusions about the behavior of the inverse isotopic effect; (iii) neglect in the Comment of the inverse kinetic isotope effect in step R2 due to the hybridization conversion, and of the inverse equilibrium isotopic effect for step R1 to describe an overall iKIE > 1, (iv) an erroneous suggestion in the Comment that the disagreement between experimental kinetic parameters is due to the fact that acetonitrile is not used in previous experimental works, when contradictorily the literature recommends it as being indispensable to allow kinetic accuracy; and (v) new calculations improved by explicit-implicit hybrid treatment again ensure that step R4, and not step R5, can assume the role of RCS in protic solvents. Recognizing that questioning is an excellent path for promoting understanding, we hope that the answers provided here will help to clarify and expand the pertinent topics under discussion.