Polar Effects in Hydrogen Atom Transfer Reactions from a Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer (PCET) Perspective: Abstractions from Toluenes

Disentangling Driving Force Effects, Polar Effects, e-/H+ Imbalance, and Other Influences on H-Atom Transfer Reactions

Hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) reactions and their kinetic barriers ΔGHAT‡ are important in organic and inorganic chemistry. This study examines factors that influence ΔGHAT‡, reporting the kinetics and thermodynamics of HAT from various ruthenium bis(acetylacetonate) pyridine-imidazole complexes to nitroxyl radicals. Across these 36 reactions, the ΔGPT° and ΔGHAT° can be independently varied, with different sets of Ru complexes primarily tuning either their pKas or their E°s. The ΔΔGHAT‡ are analyzed using multiple linear free energy relationships (LFERs), the first largely experimental study of its kind. The barriers vary most strongly with the overall driving force, ΔΔGHAT‡ = 0.28 × ΔΔGHAT°, but are also affected by HAT intrinsic barriers (λ), sterics, and the thermochemical e-/H+ imbalance of the reactions, |ΔGPT° - ΔGET°|. The latter is a small but significant effect, revealed only by comparing LFERs. The imbalance analysis is closely related to traditional explanations of polar effects, but it is quantitative: ΔGHAT‡ shifts by ∼4% with changes in |ΔGPT° - ΔGET°|. This is the same dependence as was observed for purely organic HAT from toluenes─a remarkable result because traditional explanations of organic polar effects, e.g., using X-H bond polarities, do not apply to the Ru complexes in which the e- and H+ are spatially separated. This work demonstrates the strong similarities between different kinds of HAT reactions when viewed through the lens of H+/e- (PCET) free energies. This lens also shows that ΔGHAT‡ are ∼10-fold more sensitive to changes in ΔGHAT° and λ than to the e-/H+ free-energy imbalance.

Engineering mechanisms of proton-coupled electron transfer to a titanium-substituted polyoxovanadate-alkoxide

Metal oxides are promising catalysts for small molecule hydrogen chemistries, mediated by interfacial proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) processes. Engineering the mechanism of PCET has been shown to control the selectivity of reduced products, providing an additional route for improving reductive catalysis with metal oxides. In this work, we present kinetic resolution of the rate determining proton-transfer step of PCET to a titanium-doped POV, TiV5O6(OCH3)13 with 9,10-dihydrophenazine by monitoring the loss of the cationic radical intermediate using stopped-flow analysis. For this reductant, a 5-fold enhanced rate (k PT = 1.2 × 104 M-1 s-1) is accredited to a halved activation barrier in comparison to the homometallic analogue, [V6O7(OCH3)12]1-. By switching to hydrazobenzene as a reductant, a substrate where the electron transfer component of the PCET is thermodynamically unfavorable (ΔG ET = +11 kcal mol-1), the mechanism is found to be altered to a concerted PCET mechanism. Despite the similar mechanisms and driving forces for TiV5O6(OCH3)13 and [V6O7(OCH3)12]1-, the rate of PCET is accellerated by 3-orders of magnitude (k PCET = 0.3 M-1 s-1) by the presence of the Ti(iv) ion. Possible origins of the accelleration are considered, including the possibility of strong electronic coupling interactions between TiV5O6(OCH3)13 with hydrazobenzene. Overall, these results offer insight into the governing factors that control the mechanism of PCET in metal oxide systems.

Visible-Light-Induced Divergent Oxygenation of Methylbenzene Utilizing Aryl Halides

The selective oxidation of methylbenzene to value-added products is of indisputable importance in organic synthesis. Although photocatalytic oxidation reactions of toluene have achieved great success for the preparation of its oxidative products, such as carboxylic acids, benzaldehyde, and benzoate, there remains a lack of a unified photocatalytic system for the selective preparation of these oxidation products. Herein, we report a metal- and additive-free photocatalytic protocol enabled by aryl halides using O2 as a green oxidant for the selective synthesis of the above-mentioned three oxidation products by adjusting the reaction solvent. This strategy features many advantages, including environmentally friendly and mild reaction conditions, broad substrate applicability and functional group tolerance, and potential practical application for the synthesis of aromatic carboxylic drugs and polymer materials and degradation of polystyrene waste. The continuous-flow system was utilized for the oxidation of toluene, which resulted in a reduced reaction time and increased production efficiency. Detailed mechanistic investigation revealed that the hydrogen atom transfer process was facilitated by the bromine radical from aryl halides for further oxidation, and an electron donor-acceptor complex of methylbenzene and aryl halides may exist.

Basicity of MnIII-Hydroxo Complexes Controls the Thermodynamics of Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer Reactions

Several manganese-dependent enzymes utilize MnIII-hydroxo units in concerted proton-electron transfer (CPET) reactions. We recently demonstrated that hydrogen bonding to the hydroxo ligand in the synthetic [MnIII(OH)(PaPy2N)]+ complex increased rates of CPET reactions compared to the [MnIII(OH)(PaPy2Q)]+ complex that lacks a hydrogen bond. In this work, we determine the effect of hydrogen bonding on the basicity of the hydroxo ligand and evaluate the corresponding effect on CPET reactions. Both [MnIII(OH)(PaPy2Q)]+ and [MnIII(OH)(PaPy2N)]+ react with strong acids to yield MnIII-aqua complexes [MnIII(OH2)(PaPy2Q)]2+ and [MnIII(OH2)(PaPy2N)]2+, for which we determined pKa values of 7.6 and 13.1, respectively. Reactions of the MnIII-aqua complexes with one-electron reductants yielded estimates of reduction potentials, which were combined with pKa values to give O-H bond dissociation free energies (BDFEs) of 77 and 85 kcal mol-1 for the MnII-aqua complexes [MnII(OH2)(PaPy2Q)]+ and [MnII(OH2)(PaPy2N)]+. Using these BDFEs, we performed an analysis of the thermodynamic driving force for phenol oxidation by these complexes and observed the unexpected result that slower rates are associated with more asynchronous CPET. In addition, reactions of acidic phenols with the MnIII-hydroxo complexes show rates that deviate from the thermodynamic trends, consistent with a change in mechanism from CPET to proton transfer.

Building Catalytic Reactions One Electron at a Time

ConspectusClassical education in organic chemistry and catalysis, not the least my own, has centered on two-electron transformations, from nucleophilic attack to oxidative addition. The focus on two-electron chemistry is well-founded, as this brand of chemistry has enabled incredible feats of synthesis, from the development of life-saving pharmaceuticals to the production of ubiquitous commodity chemicals. With that said, this approach is in many ways complementary to the approach of nature, where enzymes frequently make use of single-electron "radical" steps to achieve challenging reactions with exceptional selectivity, including light detection and C-H hydroxylation. While the power of radical elementary steps is undeniable, the fundamental understanding of─and ability to apply─these in catalysis remains underdeveloped, constraining the palette with which chemists can make new reactions.Motivation to remedy this traditional underemphasis on radical catalysis has been intensified by the runaway success of outer-sphere photoredox catalysis, not only confirming the versatility of radicals in anthropogenic catalysis but also teaching the value of robust and well-understood catalytic cycles for reaction design. Indeed, I would argue the success of outer-sphere photoredox catalysis has been fueled by strong fundamental understanding of its underlying radical elementary steps, with consideration of single-electron transfer (SET) energetics allowing new reactions to be designed de novo with enviable confidence. However, outer-sphere photoredox catalysis is an outlier in this regard, with other mechanistic approaches remaining underexplored.Our research group is part of a growing movement to expand the vocabulary of synthetic radical catalysis beyond the traditional outer-sphere photoredox SET manifold, assembling new cycles comprised of hydrogen atom transfer (HAT), light-induced homolysis (LIH), and radical ligand transfer (RLT) steps in new combinations to achieve challenging transformations. These efforts have been made possible by the ever-growing understanding of these radical elementary steps and discovery of catalyst systems with significant mechanistic flexibility, most recently iron/thiol (Fe/S) cocatalysis.In this Account, I will focus on our efforts applying HAT and LIH steps in Fe/S cocatalysis, sharing broad guidelines we have found helpful for using these steps and demonstrating how they can be combined to make new reactions using three case studies: radical hydrogenation (HAT + HAT), decarboxylative protonation (LIH + HAT), and alkene hydrofluoroalkylation (LIH + HAT, with an intervening radical alkene addition). These efforts have highlighted the importance of several key parameters, including bond dissociation energy (BDE) and radical polarity, and I hope our findings similarly provide a valuable framework to others designing new radical catalytic reactions.

Tuning Energetics of 2 e-/2H+ PCET Properties with Model Ru-bisamido Complexes

Most redox processes that break/form bonds involve net 2e- changes, and many are coupled to protons. Yet most proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) studies focus on 1e-/1H+ reactions. Reported here is a family of molecular models that undergo tunable 2e-/2H+ redox changes. Complexes [(X2bpy)RuII(en*)2](PF6)2 and [(X2bpy)RuIV(en*-H)2](PF6)2 have been synthesized with bpy=2,2'-bipyridine with 4,4'-subtitutions X=-NMe2, -OMe, -Me, -H, -CF3; and en*=2,3-dimethyl-2,3-butanediamine. They have been characterized by IR, UV-vis, and NMR spectroscopies, XRD, electrochemistry, mass spectrometry, DFT and (TD)DFT computations. The introduction of electron-withdrawing and donating groups at the 4,4'-position of the bpy ligand affects the complexes' redox potentials, pKa's, and Bond Dissociation Free Energies (BDFEs) of the N-H bonds in the en* ligands. The average BDFEs for the overall 2e-/2H+ PCET span over 5 kcal/mol. Notably, these complexes all show marked potential inversion over an extended range, ΔpKa>25 units and ΔE0>1.4 V. Potential inversion remains despite the electronic influence of bpy's substitutions which regulate N-H properties several bonds apart by trans-effect over dπ-molecular orbitals at the Ru center. The experimental and computational results presented in this work support the presence of strong coupling between electrons and protons, for modelling insights of 2e-/2H+ transfer reactivity.

Direct Benzylic C-H Etherification Enabled by Base-Promoted Halogen Transfer

We disclose a benzylic C-H oxidative coupling reaction with alcohols that proceeds through a synergistic deprotonation, halogenation and substitution sequence. The combination of tert-butoxide bases with 2-halothiophene halogen oxidants enables the first general protocol for generating and using benzyl halides through a deprotonative pathway. In contrast to existing radical-based methods for C-H functionalization, this process is guided by C-H acidity trends. This gives rise to new synthetic capabilities, including the ability to functionalize diverse methyl(hetero)arenes, tolerance of oxidizable and nucleophilic functional groups, precision site-selectivity for polyalkylarenes and use of a double C-H etherification process to controllably oxidize methylarenes to benzaldehydes.

Review and Theoretical Analysis of Fluorinated Radicals in Direct CAr-H Functionalization of (Hetero)arenes

We highlight key contributions in the field of direct radical CAr- H (hetero)aromatic functionalization involving fluorinated radicals. A compilation of Functional Group Transfer Reagents and their diverse activation mechanisms leading to the release of radicals are discussed. The substrate scope for each radical is analyzed and classified into three categories according to the electronic properties of the substrates. Density functional theory computational analysis provides insights into the chemical reactivity of several fluorinated radicals through their electrophilicity and nucleophilicity parameters. Theoretical analysis of their reduction potentials also highlights the remarkable correlation between electrophilicity and oxidizing ability. It is also established that highly fluorinated radicals (e.g. ⋅OCF3) are capable of engaging in single-electron transfer (SET) processes rather than radical addition, which is in good agreement with experimental literature data. A reactivity scale, based on activation barrier of addition of these radicals to benzene is also elaborated using the high accuracy DLPNO-(U)CCSD(T) method.