A 21st Century View of Allowed and Forbidden Electrocyclic Reactions

Self-Sensitized Fulgimides with Selective Multiplicity-Based Three-State Photoswitching

Precise control over excited-state multiplicity is a powerful strategy for controlling photochemical reactivity, particularly in multimodal systems where different multiplicities lead to distinct reaction products. Here, we present a multiplicity-sensitive, multimodal, fulgimide-based system capable of three-state photoswitching both in solution and in the solid state. With the aim of suppressing singlet-state sensitization, we rationally designed an intramolecularly sensitized system that enables triplet-exclusive energy transfer-a crucial feature for selective multiplicity-dependent reactivity. Our findings provide insights into the underlying principles of intramolecular triplet-exclusive sensitization and its application in controlling three-state photoswitching in unimolecular systems.

The fellowship of the Grignard: 21st century computational tools for hundred-year-old chemistry

This perspective begins with the discovery of the Grignard reaction by a graduate student in the last years of the 19th century, followed by describing why it has remained largely unexplained for more than a century. From the summary of what has been achieved, focusing on the computational aspects, it is now clear that further studies of the chemistry of any chemical species that is highly sensitive to solvents, such as Group I and II elements, require a holistic approach that includes the solute and the solvent together. Ab initio molecular dynamics, which meets these requirements, has produced some results but has hit hard limits due to its relatively high computational costs. In these days, it is becoming clear that data-driven methods, including machine learning potentials and simulations driven by quantitative on-the-fly calculation of relevant observables, have the potential to better and more completely explore the very large chemical space associated with the presence of a large number of species in solution. These methodologies have the chance to give the keys to enter the challenging and still poorly explored world of chemical species whose behaviour and reactivity are strongly influenced by the solvent and the experimental conditions.

An argument for abandoning the "allowed" and "forbidden" classification of electrocyclic reactions

The division of electrocyclic reactions into "allowed" and "forbidden" classes carries the implication that reactions of the latter class are so energetically penalised that they will occur only if their "allowed" alternatives are rendered effectively impossible. The present work tests that assumption, using NEVPT2 and DFT calculations on a variety of cyclobutene ring openings and (Z)-1,3,5-hexatriene ring closures, and their benzannelated congeners. The results show the assumption to be incorrect. The potential energy differences between "forbidden" and "allowed" transition states are found to cover a wide range of values, with the smallest being less than half the classical barrier to internal rotation of ethane. It follows that planning a total synthesis on the presumption that electrocyclic reactions will always follow the "allowed" stereochemical course is an unreliable strategy because other commonly occurring factors, such as routine steric and electronic substituent effects, can easily outweigh the electronic penalty for following the nominally forbidden mechansim. A particular case involving a proposed synthetic route to a class of anticancer compounds is highlighted as an example.

Converting Second-Order Saddle Points to Transition States: New Principles for the Design of 4π Photoswitches

Molecular photoswitches have demonstrated potential for storing solar energy at the molecular level, with power densities comparable to commercial batteries and hydroelectric energy storage. However, development of efficient photoswitches is hindered by limitations in cyclability and optical properties of existing materials. We here demonstrate that certain limitations in photoswitches based on electrocyclizations stem from the issue of controlling competition between Woodward-Hoffmann allowed and forbidden pathways. Our approach moves beyond the traditional view of activation barriers and reveals that second-order saddle points are crucial in dictating the competition between disrotatory and conrotatory pathways. These insights suggest new opportunities to manipulate the competition between these pathways through geometric constraints, fundamentally altering the connectivity of the potential energy surface. Our study also emphasizes the necessity of multi-reference methods and the need to conduct higher-dimensional explorations for competing pathways beyond photoswitch design.

Going Beyond Woodward and Hoffmann's Electrocyclizations and Cycloadditions: Sigmatropic Rearrangements

On June 1, 1965, R. B. Woodward and Roald Hoffmann published their third communication in the Journal of the American Chemical Society in which they applied orbital symmetry control to explain the mechanism of a wide variety of valence isomerizations that they termed "sigmatropic reactions." This publication reveals the research trajectory taken by Hoffmann from which this portion of the no-mechanism problem was solved. Hoffmann used five different quantum chemical tools, all based on either extended Hückel theoretical calculations or frontier molecular orbital theory, in his research. Hoffmann's laboratory notebooks and his three draft manuscripts along with Woodward's four subsequent drafts have survived the past 59 years and provide an excellent window into the thinking and manuscript-writing processes used by these Nobel laureates in February-April 1965.

Woodward-Hoffmann or Hoffmann-Woodward? Cycloadditions and the Transformation of Roald Hoffmann from a "Calculator" to an "Explainer"

On May 1, 1965, Roald Hoffmann and R. B. Woodward published their second joint communication, Selection Rules for Concerted Cycloaddition Reactions, in the Journal of the American Chemical Society. Herein is presented a historical analysis of Woodward and Hoffmann's determination of the mechanism of cycloadditions. This analysis is based on thorough analyses with Roald Hoffmann of his 1964 and 1965 laboratory notebooks and his archived documents and on numerous in-person, video, and email interviews. This historical research pinpoints several seminal moments in chemistry and in the professional career of Hoffmann. For example, now documented is the fact that Woodward and Hoffmann had no anticipation that their collaboration would continue after the publication of their first 1965 communication on electrocyclizations. Also pinpointed is the moment in Hoffmann's professional and intellectual trajectories that he became a full-fledged, equal collaborator with Woodward and Hoffmann's transition from a "calculator" to an "explainer."

Application of Sublimation in the Synthesis and Crystal Growth of Organosulfones

The solvent-free elimination of sulfinic acid and aromatization of 1,6-trans-substituted bis(arylsulfone) trienes is reported. It is shown that sublimation can be used as a 'green' method to combine the thermal transformation of six trienes and the crystal growth of the resulting 4-(phenylsulfonyl)biphenyls. When the sublimation conditions are carefully controlled, high quality single crystals of the 4-(phenylsulfonyl)biphenyls are obtained. Theoretical modelling of the reaction using the simplified triene Ph-(CH)6-SO2H showed that the cyclization is energetically feasible and that the complete conversion is possible during the timescale of the sublimation. At temperatures slightly higher than the optimum sublimation temperature two of the trienes transformed into 1,4-cyclohexadienes that did not eliminate phenylsulfinic acid. A reaction mechanism involving a 1,3-hydrogen shift induced by free PhS• radicals is proposed for the formation of the 1,4-cyclohexadienes.

Quantum Tunneling Instability in Pericyclic Reactions

Several cycloreversion reactions of the retro-Diels-Alder type were computationally assessed to understand their quantum tunneling (QT) reactivity. N2, CO, and other leaving groups were considered based on their strong exothermicity, as it reduces their thermodynamic and kinetic stabilities. Our results indicate that for many of these reactions, it is essential to take into account their QT decomposition rate, which can massively weaken their molecular stability and shorten their half-lives even at deep cryogenic temperatures. In practical terms, this indicates that many supposedly stable molecules will actually be unsynthesizable or unisolable, and therefore trying to prepare or detect them would be a futile attempt. In addition, we discuss the importance of tunneling to correctly understand the enthalpy of activation and the collective atomic effect on the tunneling kinetic isotope effects to test if third-row atoms can tunnel in a chemical reaction. This project raises the question of the importance of in silico chemistry to guide in vitro chemistry, especially in cases where the latter cannot solve its own uncertainties.