Comment on “Arresting an Unusual Amide Tautomer Using Divalent Cations”

Local Electric Fields in Aqueous Electrolytes

Vibrational Stark shifts were explored in aqueous solutions of organic molecules with carbonyl- and nitrile-containing constituents. In many cases, the vibrational resonances from these moieties shifted toward lower frequency as salt was introduced into solution. This is in contrast to the blue-shift that would be expected based upon Onsager's reaction field theory. Salts containing well-hydrated cations like Mg²⁺ or Li⁺ led to the most pronounced Stark shift for the carbonyl group, while poorly hydrated cations like Cs⁺ had the greatest impact on nitriles. Moreover, salts containing I^- gave rise to larger Stark shifts than those containing Cl^-. Molecular dynamics simulations indicated that cations and anions both accumulate around the probe in an ion- and probe-dependent manner. An electric field was generated by the ion pair, which pointed from the cation to the anion through the vibrational chromophore. This resulted from solvent-shared binding of the ions to the probes, consistent with their positions in the Hofmeister series. The "anti-Onsager" Stark shifts occur in both vibrational spectroscopy and fluorescence measurements.