Polarization-Dependent Heterodyne-Detected Sum-Frequency Generation Spectroscopy as a Tool to Explore Surface Molecular Orientation and Ångström-Scale Depth Profiling

Measuring complex SFG: Characterizing a phase reference

Reactions and interactions at interfaces play pivotal roles in processes ranging from atmospheric aerosols influencing climate to battery electrodes determining charge-discharge rates to defects in catalysts controlling the fate of reactants to the outcome of biological processes at membrane interfaces. Tools to probe these surfaces at the atomic-molecular level are thus critical. Chief among non-invasive probes is the vibrational spectroscopy sum frequency generation (SFG). The complex signal amplitude generated by SFG requires techniques to interfere the unknown amplitude with a well-characterized one. An interferometric method is described to characterize the signal from any nonresonant reference material. The technique is demonstrated by measuring the phase of polycrystalline GaAs, chosen due to the strong signal and insensitivity to surface contamination. With a 515 nm visible field, the phase of GaAs is 54.5° ± 0.5°. The capability of choosing a reference based solely on its signal intensity enables probing a wide range of interfaces.

Flipping Water Orientation at the Surface of Water-in-Salt and Salt-in-Water Solutions

Salt-in-water and water-in-salt mixtures are promising for battery applications and fine-tuning of room-temperature ionic liquid (RTIL) properties. Although critical processes take place at interfaces of these systems, including charge transfer and heterogeneous catalytic reactions, the microscopic interfacial structures remain unclear. Here, we apply heterodyne-detected sum-frequency generation spectroscopy to aqueous solutions of imidazolium-based RTILs to unveil the microscopic structure of the interfaces of these solutions with air. Our results show that, under salt-in-water conditions, the orientation of the OH group hydrogen-bonded to the other water molecules flips from the OH group pointing down into the liquid for pure water to up due to the accumulation of anions in the cation-rich interfacial region. However, under the water-in-salt condition, the interfacial water molecules are confined by RTIL, and their orientation is down. Details of the water organization depend critically on the alkyl chain length of the imidazolium cation. Our results demonstrate that the surface structure can be tuned by altering the molecular structure and concentration of the RTIL.

Experimental and simulation-based characterization of surfactant adsorption layers at fluid interfaces

Adsorption of surfactants to fluid interfaces occurs in numerous technological and daily-life contexts. The coverage at the interface and other properties of the formed adsorption layers determine the performance of a surfactant with regard to the desired application. Given the importance of these applications, there is a great demand for the comprehensive characterization and understanding of surfactant adsorption layers. In this review, we provide an overview of suitable experimental and simulation-based techniques and review the literature in which they were used for the investigation of surfactant adsorption layers. We come to the conclusion that, while these techniques have been successfully applied to investigate Langmuir monolayers of water-insoluble surfactants, their application to the study of Gibbs adsorption layers of water-soluble surfactants has not been fully exploited. Finally, we emphasize the great potential of these methods in providing a deeper understanding of the behavior of soluble surfactants at interfaces, which is crucial for optimizing their performance in various applications.

Surface populations as a model for the distance-dependence of the interfacial refractive index

Vibrational sum frequency spectra provide information about interfaces that is sensitive to the orientation of molecules, their electronic environment, and the local electric fields. Here, we use molecular dynamics simulations in order to study a surfactant, para-cyanophenol, at the air-water interface. The volume fractions of water and the organic surfactant are considered at various points over the nanometer-scale region in a Lorentz-Lorenz model. We find that the calculated ratios of nonlinear susceptibility tensor elements are in agreement with experimental data only when this depth profile was considered. We also use these data to evaluate the ratio of the C-N hyperpolarizability tensor elements in the interfacial region.

Effect of Carboxyl Group Position on Assembly Behavior and Structure of Hydrocarbon Oil-Carboxylic Acid Compound Collector on Low-Rank Coal Surface: Sum-Frequency Vibration Spectroscopy and Coarse-Grained Molecular Dynamics Simulation Study

In this work, the assembly behavior and structure of a compound collector with different carboxyl group positions at the low-rank coal (LRC)-water interface were investigated through coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulation (CGMD) combined with sum-frequency vibration spectroscopy (SFG). The choice of compound collector was dodecane +decanoic acid (D-DA) and dodecane +2-butyl octanoic acid (D-BA). CGMD results showed that the carboxyl group at the carbon chain's middle can better control the assembly process between carboxylic acid and D molecules. SFG research found that the carboxyl group at the carbon chain's termination had a greater impact on the displacement of the methyl/methylene symmetric stretching vibration peak, while the carboxyl group at the carbon chain's middle had a greater impact on the displacement of the methyl/methylene asymmetric stretching vibration peak. The spatial angle calculation results revealed that the methyl group's orientation angle in the D-BA molecule was smaller and the carboxyl group's orientation angle in the BA molecule was bigger, indicating that D-BA spread more flatly on the LRC surface than D-DA. This meant that the assembled structure had a larger effective adsorption area on the LRC surface. The flotation studies also verified that the assembly behavior and structure of D-BA with the carboxyl group at the carbon chain's middle at the LRC-water interface were more conducive to the improvement of flotation efficiency. The study of interface assembly behavior and structure by CGMD combined with SFG is crucial for the creation of effective compound collectors.

Spiers Memorial Lecture: Water at interfaces

In this article we discuss current issues in the context of the four chosen subtopics for the meeting: dynamics and nano-rheology of interfacial water, electrified/charged aqueous interfaces, ice interfaces, and soft matter/water interfaces. We emphasize current advances in both theory and experiment, as well as important practical manifestations and areas of unresolved controversy.

Determination of the Thickness of Interfacial Water by Time-Resolved Sum-Frequency Generation Vibrational Spectroscopy

The physics and chemistry of a charged interface are governed by the structure of the electrical double layer (EDL). Determination of the interfacial water thickness (diw) of the charged interface is crucial to quantitatively describe the EDL structure, but it can be utilized with very scarce experimental methods. Here, we propose and verify that the vibrational relaxation time (T1) of the OH stretching mode at 3200 cm-1, obtained by time-resolved sum frequency generation vibrational spectroscopy with ssp polarizations, provides an effective tool to determine diw. By investigating the T1 values at the SiO2/NaCl solution interface, we established a time-space (T1-diw) relationship. We find that water has a T1 lifetime of ≥0.5 ps for diw ≤ 3 Å, while it displays bulk-like dynamics with T1 ≤ 0.2 ps for diw ≥ 9 Å. T1 decreases as diw increases from ∼3 Å to 9 Å. The hydration water at the DPPG lipid bilayer and LK15β protein interfaces has a thickness of ≥9 Å and shows a bulk-like feature. The time-space relationship will provide a novel tool to pattern the interfacial topography and heterogeneity in Ångstrom-depth resolution by imaging the T1 values.

Revealing the Effects of Weak Surfactants on the Dynamics of Surface Fluctuations by Surface Light Scattering

Surfactant monolayers at liquid interfaces induce a viscoelastic behavior that influences the dynamics of surface fluctuations probed by surface light scattering (SLS). Recent thermophysical property research on viscosity and interfacial tension of liquid organic hydrogen carrier (LOHC) systems based on diphenylmethane suggested that such viscoelastic effects may also be present here, although not being expected a priori. To prove the hypothesis that the LOHC intermediate cyclohexylphenylmethane (H6-DPM) can induce a surfactant-like behavior, binary mixtures of diphenylmethane (H0-DPM) or dicyclohexylmethane (H12-DPM) with small amounts of H6-DPM were studied by SLS in combination with conventional viscometry and tensiometry and molecular dynamics simulations between (303 and 473) K. Only in mixtures with H0-DPM which has a slightly larger surface tension than H6-DPM, the presence of the latter compound causes a significant effect on the dynamics of surface fluctuations, especially on their damping. In analogy to the concentration-dependent behavior observed for a monolayer of a highly amphiphilic ionic surfactant on the surface of water at ambient temperature, the orientation of H6-DPM molecules with respect to the surface appears to change from a preferentially perpendicular to a parallel alignment with increasing temperature. This demonstrates that viscoelastic effects including accompanied surface orientation effects can be resolved by SLS even for weakly asymmetric surface-active molecules such as H6-DPM in its diluted mixtures with very similar species.

High phase resolution: Probing interactions in complex interfaces with sum frequency generation

An often-quoted statement attributed to Wolfgang Pauli is that God made the bulk, but the surface was invented by the devil. Although humorous, the statement really reflects frustration in developing a detailed picture of a surface. In the last several decades, that frustration has begun to abate with numerous techniques providing clues to interactions and reactions at surfaces. Often these techniques require considerable prior knowledge. Complex mixtures on irregular or soft surfaces-complex interfaces-thus represent the last frontier. Two optical techniques: sum frequency generation (SFG) and second harmonic generation (SHG) are beginning to lift the veil on complex interfaces. Of these techniques, SFG with one excitation in the infrared has the potential to provide exquisite molecular- and moiety-specific vibrational data. This Perspective is intended both to aid newcomers in gaining traction in this field and to demonstrate the impact of high-phase resolution. It starts with a basic description of light-induced surface polarization that is at the heart of SFG. The sum frequency is generated when the input fields are sufficiently intense that the interaction is nonlinear. This nonlinearity represents a challenge for disentangling data to reveal the molecular-level picture. Three, high-phase-resolution methods that reveal interactions at the surface are described.

Second-Order Nonlinear Optics as an Orientation-Independent Probe of Molecular Environments at Interfaces

Measurement techniques that probe the second-order susceptibility, such as second-harmonic and sum-frequency generation, are recognized for their ability to study environments with broken centrosymmetry. As a result, they serve as reporters of molecules at surfaces because the second-order susceptibility is often zero in the adjacent bulk media. Although the signals measured in such experiments carry unique information about the interfacial environment, the challenge is to disentangle properties related to the electronic structure as they are wrapped up in the orientation distribution. Over the past 30 years, this challenge has been turned into an opportunity, as many studies have sought to learn about the arrangement of molecules at surfaces. Here we demonstrate that the flipped case is possible, where fundamental properties of the interfacial environment can be extracted in a manner that is completely independent of, and therefore oblivious to, the orientation distribution. Using p-cyanophenol adsorbed at the air-water interface as an example, we illustrate that the cyano group polarizability varies less along the direction of the C-N bond when at the surface than when the same molecules are in the bulk aqueous phase.

Ions Speciation at the Water-Air Interface

In typical aqueous systems, including naturally occurring sweet and salt water and tap water, multiple ion species are co-solvated. At the water-air interface, these ions are known to affect the chemical reactivity, aerosol formation, climate, and water odor. Yet, the composition of ions at the water interface has remained enigmatic. Here, using surface-specific heterodyne-detected sum-frequency generation spectroscopy, we quantify the relative surface activity of two co-solvated ions in solution. We find that more hydrophobic ions are speciated to the interface due to the hydrophilic ions. Quantitative analysis shows that the interfacial hydrophobic ion population increases with decreasing interfacial hydrophilic ion population at the interface. Simulations show that the solvation energy difference between the ions and the intrinsic surface propensity of ions determine the extent of an ion's speciation by other ions. This mechanism provides a unified view of the speciation of monatomic and polyatomic ions at electrolyte solution interfaces.

On the Fresnel factor correction of sum-frequency generation spectra of interfacial water

Insights into the microscopic structure of aqueous interfaces are essential for understanding the chemical and physical processes on the water surface, including chemical synthesis, atmospheric chemistry, and events in biomolecular systems. These aqueous interfaces have been probed by heterodyne-detected sum-frequency generation (HD-SFG) spectroscopy. To obtain the molecular response from the measured HD-SFG spectra, one needs to correct the measured ssp spectra for local electromagnetic field effects at the interface due to a spatially varying dielectric function. This so-called Fresnel factor correction can change the inferred response substantially, and different ways of performing this correction lead to different conclusions about the interfacial water response. Here, we compare the simulated and experimental spectra at the air/water interface. We use three previously developed models to compare the experiment with theory: an advanced approach taking into account the detailed inhomogeneous interfacial dielectric profile and the Lorentz and slab models to approximate the interfacial dielectric function. Using the advanced model, we obtain an excellent quantitative agreement between theory and experiment, in both spectral shape and amplitude. Remarkably, we find that for the Fresnel factor correction of the ssp spectra, the Lorentz model for the interfacial dielectric function is equally accurate in the hydrogen (H)-bonded region of the response, while the slab model underestimates this response significantly. The Lorentz model, thus, provides a straightforward method to obtain the molecular response from the measured spectra of aqueous interfaces in the H-bonded region.