Accurate evaluation of charge asymmetry in aqueous solvation

Inclusion of Water Multipoles into the Implicit Solvation Framework Leads to Accuracy Gains

The current practical "workhorses" of the atomistic implicit solvation─the Poisson-Boltzmann (PB) and generalized Born (GB) models─face fundamental accuracy limitations. Here, we propose a computationally efficient implicit solvation framework, the Implicit Water Multipole GB (IWM-GB) model, that systematically incorporates the effects of multipole moments of water molecules in the first hydration shell of a solute, beyond the dipole water polarization already present at the PB/GB level. The framework explicitly accounts for coupling between polar and nonpolar contributions to the total solvation energy, which is missing from many implicit solvation models. An implementation of the framework, utilizing the GAFF force field and AM1-BCC atomic partial charges model, is parametrized and tested against the experimental hydration free energies of small molecules from the FreeSolv database. The resulting accuracy on the test set (RMSE ∼ 0.9 kcal/mol) is 12% better than that of the explicit solvation (TIP3P) treatment, which is orders of magnitude slower. We also find that the coupling between polar and nonpolar parts of the solvation free energy is essential to ensuring that several features of the IWM-GB model are physically meaningful, including the sign of the nonpolar contributions.

Improving the Accuracy of Physics-Based Hydration-Free Energy Predictions by Machine Learning the Remaining Error Relative to the Experiment

The accuracy of computational models of water is key to atomistic simulations of biomolecules. We propose a computationally efficient way to improve the accuracy of the prediction of hydration-free energies (HFEs) of small molecules: the remaining errors of the physics-based models relative to the experiment are predicted and mitigated by machine learning (ML) as a postprocessing step. Specifically, the trained graph convolutional neural network attempts to identify the "blind spots" in the physics-based model predictions, where the complex physics of aqueous solvation is poorly accounted for, and partially corrects for them. The strategy is explored for five classical solvent models representing various accuracy/speed trade-offs, from the fast analytical generalized Born (GB) to the popular TIP3P explicit solvent model; experimental HFEs of small neutral molecules from the FreeSolv set are used for the training and testing. For all of the models, the ML correction reduces the resulting root-mean-square error relative to the experiment for HFEs of small molecules, without significant overfitting and with negligible computational overhead. For example, on the test set, the relative accuracy improvement is 47% for the fast analytical GB, making it, after the ML correction, almost as accurate as uncorrected TIP3P. For the TIP3P model, the accuracy improvement is about 39%, bringing the ML-corrected model's accuracy below the 1 kcal/mol threshold. In general, the relative benefit of the ML corrections is smaller for more accurate physics-based models, reaching the lower limit of about 20% relative accuracy gain compared with that of the physics-based treatment alone. The proposed strategy of using ML to learn the remaining error of physics-based models offers a distinct advantage over training ML alone directly on reference HFEs: it preserves the correct overall trend, even well outside of the training set.

Assessment of an Electrostatic Energy-Based Charge Model for Modeling the Electrostatic Interactions in Water Solvent

The protein force field based on the restrained electrostatic potential (RESP) charges has limitations in accurately describing hydrogen bonding interactions in proteins. To address this issue, we propose an alternative approach called the electrostatic energy-based charges (EEC) model, which shows improved performance in describing electrostatic interactions (EIs) of hydrogen bonds in proteins. In this study, we further investigate the performance of the EEC model in modeling EIs in water solvent. Our findings demonstrate that the fixed EEC model can effectively reproduce the quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM)-calculated EIs between a water molecule and various water solvent environments. However, to achieve the same level of computational accuracy, the electrostatic potential (ESP) charge model needs to fluctuate according to the electrostatic environment. Our analysis indicates that the requirement for charge adjustments depends on the specific mathematical and physical representation of EIs as a function of the environment for deriving charges. By comparing with widely used empirical water models calibrated to reproduce experimental properties, we confirm that the performance of the EEC model in reproducing QM/MM EIs is similar to that of general purpose TIP4P-like water models such as TIP4P-Ew and TIP4P/2005. When comparing the computed 10,000 distinct EI values within the range of -40 to 0 kcal/mol with the QM/MM results calculated at the MP2/aug-cc-pVQZ/TIP3P level, we noticed that the mean unsigned error (MUE) for the EEC model is merely 0.487 kcal/mol, which is remarkably similar to the MUE values of the TIP4P-Ew (0.63 kcal/mol) and TIP4P/2005 (0.579 kcal/mol) models. However, both the RESP method and the TIP3P model exhibit a tendency to overestimate the EIs, as evidenced by their higher MUE values of 1.761 and 1.293 kcal/mol, respectively. EEC-based molecular dynamics simulations have demonstrated that, when combined with appropriate van der Waals parameters, the EEC model can closely reproduce oxygen-oxygen radial distribution function and density of water, showing a remarkable similarity to the well-established TIP4P-like empirical water models. Our results demonstrate that the EEC model has the potential to build force fields with comparable accuracy to more sophisticated empirical TIP4P-like water models.

Specific Ion Effects in Different Media: Current Status and Future Challenges

We discuss the current state of research as well as the future challenges for a deeper understanding of specific ion effects in protic and aprotic solvents as well as various additional media. Despite recent interest in solute or interfacial effects, we focus exclusively on the specific properties of ions in bulk electrolyte solutions. Corresponding results show that many mechanisms remain unknown for these simple media, although theoretical, computational, and experimental studies have provided some insights into explaining individual observations. In particular, the importance of local interactions and electronic properties is emphasized, which enabled a more consistent interpretation of specific ion effects over the past years. Despite current insufficient knowledge, we also discuss future challenges in relation to dynamic properties as well as the influence of different concentrations, different solvents, and solute contributions to gain a deeper understanding of specific ion effects for technological applications.

Generalized Born Implicit Solvent Models for Biomolecules

It would often be useful in computer simulations to use an implicit description of solvation effects, instead of explicitly representing the individual solvent molecules. Continuum dielectric models often work well in describing the thermodynamic aspects of aqueous solvation and can be very efficient compared to the explicit treatment of the solvent. Here, we review a particular class of so-called fast implicit solvent models, generalized Born (GB) models, which are widely used for molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of proteins and nucleic acids. These approaches model hydration effects and provide solvent-dependent forces with efficiencies comparable to molecular-mechanics calculations on the solute alone; as such, they can be incorporated into MD or other conformational searching strategies in a straightforward manner. The foundations of the GB model are reviewed, followed by examples of newer, emerging models and examples of important applications. We discuss their strengths and weaknesses, both for fidelity to the underlying continuum model and for the ability to replace explicit consideration of solvent molecules in macromolecular simulations.

Why Computed Protein Folding Landscapes Are Sensitive to the Water Model

We investigate the effect of solvent models on the computed thermodynamics of protein folding. Atomistic folding simulations of a fast-folding mini-protein, CLN025, were employed to compare two commonly used explicit solvent water models, TIP3P and TIP4P/Ew, and one implicit solvent (AMBER generalized Born) model. Although all three solvent models correctly identify the same native folded state (RMSD = 1.5 ± 0.1 Å relative to the experimental structure), the corresponding free energy landscapes vary drastically between water models: almost an order-of-magnitude difference is seen in the predicted fraction of the unfolded state between the two explicit solvent models, with even larger differences between the implicit and the explicit models. Quantitative arguments are presented for why the sensitivity is expected to hold for other proteins, as well as for other conformational transitions involving large changes in solvent exposed areas such as protein-ligand binding. Comparing protein-solvent and solvent-solvent contributions to the folding energy between different water models, water-water electrostatic interactions are identified as the largest contributor to the differences in the predicted folding energy, which helps explain the strong sensitivity of the folding landscape to subtle details of the water model. For the two explicit solvent models, differences in water model parameters also result in the average number of water molecules surrounding the protein being noticeably different. Water models that poorly reproduce certain bulk properties of liquid water such as self-diffusion are likely to misrepresent water-water interactions; we argue that within a pairwise additive energy function this error cannot, in general, be compensated by an adjustment to the solute-solute and solute-solvent parts of the energy.

Molecular Insights into the Unusual Structure of an Antifreeze Protein with a Hydrated Core

The primary driving force for protein folding is the formation of a well-packed, anhydrous core. However, recently, the crystal structure of an antifreeze protein, maxi, has been resolved where the core of the protein is filled with water, which apparently contradicts the existing notion of protein folding. Here, we have performed standard molecular dynamics (MD) simulation, replica exchange MD (REMD) simulation, and umbrella sampling using TIP4P water at various temperatures (300, 260, and 240 K) to explore the origin of this unusual structural feature. It is evident from standard MD and REMD simulations that the protein is found to be stable at 240 K in its unusual state. The core of protein has two layers of semi-clathrate water separating the methyl groups of alanine residues from different helical strands. However, with increasing temperature (260 and 300 K), the stability decreases as the core becomes dehydrated, and methyl groups of alanine are tightly packed driven by hydrophobic interactions. Calculation of the potential of mean force by an umbrella sampling technique between a pair of model hydrophobes resembling maxi protein at 240 K shows the stabilization of second solvent-separated minima (SSM), which provides a thermodynamic rationale of the unusual structural feature in terms of weakening of the hydrophobic interaction. Because the stabilization of SSMs is implicated for cold denaturation, it suggests that the maxi protein is so designed by nature where the cold denatured-like state becomes the biologically active form as it works near or below the freezing point of water.

Understanding the scale of the single ion free energy: A critical test of the tetra-phenyl arsonium and tetra-phenyl borate assumption

The tetra-phenyl arsonium and tetra-phenyl borate (TATB) assumption is a commonly used extra-thermodynamic assumption that allows single ion free energies to be split into cationic and anionic contributions. The assumption is that the values for the TATB salt can be divided equally. This is justified by arguing that these large hydrophobic ions will cause a symmetric response in water. Experimental and classical simulation work has raised potential flaws with this assumption, indicating that hydrogen bonding with the phenyl ring may favor the solvation of the TB^- anion. Here, we perform ab initio molecular dynamics simulations of these ions in bulk water demonstrating that there are significant structural differences. We quantify our findings by reproducing the experimentally observed vibrational shift for the TB^- anion and confirm that this is associated with hydrogen bonding with the phenyl rings. Finally, we demonstrate that this results in a substantial energetic preference of the water to solvate the anion. Our results suggest that the validity of the TATB assumption, which is still widely used today, should be reconsidered experimentally in order to properly reference single ion solvation free energy, enthalpy, and entropy.

Accuracy limit of rigid 3-point water models

Classical 3-point rigid water models are most widely used due to their computational efficiency. Recently, we introduced a new approach to constructing classical rigid water models [S. Izadi et al., J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 5, 3863 (2014)], which permits a virtually exhaustive search for globally optimal model parameters in the sub-space that is most relevant to the electrostatic properties of the water molecule in liquid phase. Here we apply the approach to develop a 3-point Optimal Point Charge (OPC3) water model. OPC3 is significantly more accurate than the commonly used water models of same class (TIP3P and SPCE) in reproducing a comprehensive set of liquid bulk properties, over a wide range of temperatures. Beyond bulk properties, we show that OPC3 predicts the intrinsic charge hydration asymmetry (CHA) of water - a characteristic dependence of hydration free energy on the sign of the solute charge - in very close agreement with experiment. Two other recent 3-point rigid water models, TIP3PFB and H2ODC, each developed by its own, completely different optimization method, approach the global accuracy optimum represented by OPC3 in both the parameter space and accuracy of bulk properties. Thus, we argue that an accuracy limit of practical 3-point rigid non-polarizable models has effectively been reached; remaining accuracy issues are discussed.

Origin of Asymmetric Solvation Effects for Ions in Water and Organic Solvents Investigated Using Molecular Dynamics Simulations: The Swain Acity-Basity Scale Revisited

The asymmetric solvation of ions can be defined as the tendency of a solvent to preferentially solvate anions over cations or cations over anions, at identical ionic charge magnitudes and effective sizes. Taking water as a reference, these effects are quantified experimentally for many solvents by the relative acity (A) and basity (B) parameters of the Swain scale. The goal of the present study is to investigate the asymmetric solvation of ions using molecular dynamics simulations, and to connect the results to this empirical scale. To this purpose, the charging free energies of alkali and halide ions, and of their hypothetical oppositely charged counterparts, are calculated in a variety of solvents. In a first set of calculations, artificial solvent models are considered that present either a charge or a shape asymmetry at the molecular level. The solvation asymmetry, probed by the difference in charging free energy between the two oppositely charged ions, is found to encompass a term quadratic in the ion charge, related to the different solvation structures around the anion and cation, and a term linear in the ion charge, related to the solvation structure around the uncharged ion-sized cavity. For these simple solvent models, the two terms are systematically counteracting each other, and it is argued that only the quadratic term should be retained when comparing the results of simulations involving physical solvents to experimental data. In a second set of calculations, 16 physical solvents are considered. The theoretical estimates for the acity A are found to correlate very well with the Swain parameters, whereas the correlation for B is very poor. Based on this observation, the Swain scale is reformulated into a new scale involving an asymmetry parameter Σ, positive for acitic solvents and negative for basitic ones, and a polarity parameter Π. This revised scale has the same predictive power as the original scale, but it characterizes asymmetry in an absolute sense, the atomistic simulations playing the role of an extra-thermodynamic assumption, and is optimally compatible with the simulation results. Considering the 55 solvents in the Swain set, it is observed that a moderate basity (Σ between -0.9 and -0.3, related to electronic polarization) represents the baseline for most solvents, while a highly variable acity (Σ between 0.0 and 3.0, related to hydrogen-bond donor capacity modulated by inductive effects) represents a landmark of protic solvents.