Probing Energy Landscapes of Cytochrome b6f with Spectral Hole Burning: Effects of Deuterated Solvent and Detergent

Identification of Residues Potentially Involved in Optical Shifts in the Water-Soluble Chlorophyll a-Binding Protein through Molecular Dynamics Simulations

Reversible light and thermally induced spectral shifts are universally observed in a wide variety of pigment-protein complexes at temperatures ranging from cryogenic to ambient. In this paper, we employed large-scale molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of a prototypical pigment-protein complex to better understand these shifts at a molecular scale. Although multiple mechanisms have been proposed over the years, no verification of these proposals via MD simulations has thus far been performed; our work represents the first step in this direction. From simulations of the water-soluble chlorophyll-binding protein complex, we determined that rearrangements of long hydrogen bonds were unlikely to be the origin of the multiwell landscape features necessary to explain observed spectral shifts. We also assessed small motions of amino acid residues and identified side chain rotations of some of these residues as likely candidates for the origin of relevant multiwell landscape features. The protein free-energy landscapes associated with side chain rotations feature energy barriers of around 1100-1600 cm-1, in agreement with optical spectroscopy results, with the most promising residue type associated with experimental signatures being serine, which possesses a symmetric triple-well landscape and moment of inertia of a relevant magnitude.

Effects of Chlorophyll Triplet States on the Kinetics of Spectral Hole Growth

Spectral hole burning has been employed for decades to study various amorphous solids and proteins. Triplet states and respective transient holes were incorporated into theoretical models and software simulating nonphotochemical spectral hole burning (NPHB) and including all relevant distributions, in particular the distribution of the angle between the electric field of light E and transient dipole moment of the chromophore μ. The presence of a chlorophyll a triplet state with a lifetime of several milliseconds explains the slowdown of NPHB (on the depth vs illumination dose scale) with the increase of the light intensity, as well as larger hole depths observed in weak probe beam experiments, compared to those deduced from the hole growth kinetics (HGK) measurements (signal collected at a fixed wavelength while a stronger burning beam is on) in cytochrome b₆f and chemically modified LH2. We also considered the solvent deuteration effects on triplet lifetime and concluded that both triplet states and local heating likely play a role in slowing down the HGK with increasing burn intensity.

Evidence of Simultaneous Spectral Hole Burning Involving Two Tiers of the Protein Energy Landscape in Cytochrome b6f

Cytochrome b₆f, with one chlorophyll molecule per protein monomer, is a simple model system whose studies can help achieve a better understanding of nonphotochemical spectral hole burning (NPHB) and single-complex spectroscopy results obtained in more complicated photosynthetic chlorophyll-protein complexes. We are reporting new data and proposing an alternative explanation for spectral dynamics that was recently observed in cytochrome b₆f using NPHB. The relevant distribution of the tunneling parameter λ is a superposition of two components that are nearly degenerate in terms of the resultant NPHB yield and represent two tiers of the energy landscape responsible for NPHB. These two components likely burn competitively; we present the first demonstration of modeling a competitive NPHB process. Similar values of the NPHB yield result from distinctly different combinations of barrier heights, shifts along the generalized coordinate d, and/or masses of the entities involved in conformational changes m, with md² parameter different by a factor of 2.7. Consequently, in cytochrome b₆f, the first (at least) 10 h of fixed-temperature recovery preferentially probe different components of the barrier- and λ-distributions encoded into the spectral holes than thermocycling experiments. Both components most likely represent dynamics of the protein and not of the surrounding buffer/glycerol glass.

How Well Does the Hole-Burning Action Spectrum Represent the Site-Distribution Function of the Lowest-Energy State in Photosynthetic Pigment-Protein Complexes?

For the first time, we combined Monte Carlo and nonphotochemical hole burning (NPHB) master equation approaches to allow for ultrahigh-resolution (<0.005 cm^-1, smaller than the typical homogeneous line widths at 5 K) simulations of the NPHB spectra of dimers and trimers of interacting pigments. These simulations reveal significant differences between the zero-phonon hole (ZPH) action spectrum and the site-distribution function (SDF) of the lowest-energy state. The NPHB of the lowest-energy pigment, following the excitation energy transfer (EET) from the higher-energy pigments which are excited directly, results in the shifts of all excited states. These shifts affect the ZPH action spectra and EET times derived from the widths of the spectral holes burned in the donor-dominated regions. The effect is present for a broad variety of realistic antihole functions, and it is maximal at relatively low values of interpigment coupling (V ≤ 5 cm^-1) where the use of the Förster approximation is justified. These findings need to be considered in interpreting various optical spectra of photosynthetic pigment-protein complexes for which SDFs (describing the inhomogeneous broadening) are often obtained directly from the ZPH action spectra. Water-soluble chlorophyll-binding protein (WSCP) was considered as an example.