Au22Ir3(PET)18: An Unusual Alloy Cluster through Intercluster Reaction

Chemical Flexibility of Atomically Precise Metal Clusters

Ligand-protected metal clusters possess hybrid properties that seamlessly combine an inorganic core with an organic ligand shell, imparting them exceptional chemical flexibility and unlocking remarkable application potential in diverse fields. Leveraging chemical flexibility to expand the library of available materials and stimulate the development of new functionalities is becoming an increasingly pressing requirement. This Review focuses on the origin of chemical flexibility from the structural analysis, including intra-cluster bonding, inter-cluster interactions, cluster-environments interactions, metal-to-ligand ratios, and thermodynamic effects. In the introduction, we briefly outline the development of metal clusters and explain the differences and commonalities of M(I)/M(I/0) coinage metal clusters. Additionally, we distinguish the bonding characteristics of metal atoms in the inorganic core, which give rise to their distinct chemical flexibility. Section 2 delves into the structural analysis, bonding categories, and thermodynamic theories related to metal clusters. In the following sections 3 to 7, we primarily elucidate the mechanisms that trigger chemical flexibility, the dynamic processes in transformation, the resultant alterations in structure, and the ensuing modifications in physical-chemical properties. Section 8 presents the notable applications that have emerged from utilizing metal clusters and their assemblies. Finally, in section 9, we discuss future challenges and opportunities within this area.

Synthesis of RhH-doped Au-Ag alloy nanoclusters and dopant evolution

Doping atomically precise metal nanoclusters (NCs) with heterometals is a powerful method for tuning the physicochemical properties of the original NCs at the atomic level. While the heterometals incorporated into metal NCs are limited to group 10-12 metals with closed d-shells, the doping of open d-shell metals remains largely unexplored. Herein, we report the synthesis of Rh-doped Au-Ag alloy NCs by a metal-exchange reaction of [RhHAg24(SPhMe2)18]2- NCs with an Au-thiolate complex. Combined experimental and theoretical structural studies revealed that the synthesized product is a dianionic [RhHAuxAg24-x(SPhMe2)18]2- NC (x = 8-12), consisting of RhH dopant, Au-rich kernel, and Ag-thiolate staple motifs, with the superatomic 8-electron configuration (1S21P6). Under aerobic conditions, the synthesized NCs underwent kernel evolution to generate a 6-electron [RhAuxAg24-x(SPhMe2)18]1- NC (1S21P4), which was initiated by the desorption of hydride from the kernel. Structural analysis of the [RhHAuxAg24-x(SPhMe2)18]2- NC suggests that the kernel evolution is induced by the change in chemical bonds surrounding the hydride in the Au-rich kernel.

Intermediate Silver Doping of Au25(SR)18: Variation of Electronic, Optical, and Chiroptical Properties along Au25-xAgx(SH)18- (x = 0-12) Stoichiometry from DFT Calculations

The silver analogue of the prominent Au₂₅(SR)₁₈ nanocluster reveals the possibility of finding "gold"-like behavior despite their different nature, in addition to the common features among molecular AgNP. Herein, we explore the effect of successive additions of silver atoms reaching an intermediate Ag/Au doping ratio where the parent gold cluster exhibits properties from both elements. Our results show a more favorable situation as the Ag/Au ratio increases along the Au_25-xAg_x(SH)₁₈^- (x = 0-12) clusters, with structural distortions mainly centered at the ligand-protected shell. The calculated optical spectrum shows that from the Au₁₉Ag₆ species, a plasmon-like peak appears along species with a doping ratio above 25%, where all the silver atoms are located within the M₁₂ icosahedron. In addition, the chiral properties were explored, showing mild optical activity from the calculated circular dichroism spectra due to the distorted ligand-shell avoiding a centrosymmetric structure. Thus, an intermediate doping ratio ascribed to a specific structural layer can recover inherent properties to both elements in the binary Au_25-xAg_x(SH)₁₈^- series, suggesting the possibility of having clusters with dual properties at a certain degree of element exchange. This can be useful for further exploration theoretically and synthetically toward different and larger-nuclearity clusters.

Promoting Photocatalytic Carbon Dioxide Reduction by Tuning the Properties of Cocatalysts

Suppressing the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere is an essential measure toward addressing global warming. Specifically, the photocatalytic CO₂ reduction reaction (CRR) is an effective strategy because it affords the conversion of CO₂ into useful carbon feedstocks by using sunlight and water. However, the practical application of photocatalyst-promoting CRR (CRR photocatalysts) requires significant improvement of their conversion efficiency. Accordingly, extensive research is being conducted toward improving semiconductor photocatalysts, as well as cocatalysts that are loaded as active sites on the photocatalysts. In this review, we summarize recent research and development trends in the improvement of cocatalysts, which have a significant impact on the catalytic activity and selectivity of photocatalytic CRR. We expect that the advanced knowledge provided on the improvement of cocatalysts for CRR in this review will serve as a general guideline to accelerate the development of highly efficient CRR photocatalysts.

Analytical separation techniques: toward achieving atomic precision in nanomaterials science

The size- and shape-dependence of the properties are the most characteristic features of nanoscale matter. In many types of nanomaterials, there is a size regime wherein every atom counts. In order to fully realize the idea of 'maneuvering things atom by atom' envisioned by Richard Feynman, synthesis and separation of nanoscale matter with atomic precision are essential. It is therefore not surprising that analytical separation techniques have contributed tremendously toward understanding the size- as well as shape-dependent properties of nanomaterials. Fascinating properties of nanomaterials would not have been explored without the use of these techniques. Here we discuss the pivotal role of analytical separation techniques in the progress of nanomaterials science. We begin with a brief overview of some of the key analytical separation techniques that are of tremendous importance in nanomaterials research. Then we describe how each of these techniques has contributed to the advancements in nanomaterials science taking some of the nanosystems as examples. We discuss the limitations and challenges of these techniques and future perspectives.

Revealing the composition-dependent structural evolution fundamentals of bimetallic nanoparticles through an inter-particle alloying reaction

Alloy nanoparticles represent one of the most important metal materials, finding increasing applications in diverse fields of catalysis, biomedicine, and nano-optics. However, the structural evolution of bimetallic nanoparticles in their full composition spectrum has been rarely explored at the molecular and atomic levels, imparting inherent difficulties to establish a reliable structure-property relationship in practical applications. Here, through an inter-particle reaction between [Au₄₄(SR)₂₆]^2- and [Ag₄₄(SR)₃₀]^4- nanoparticles or nanoclusters (NCs), which possess the same number of metal atoms, but different atomic packing structures, we reveal the composition-dependent structural evolution of alloy NCs in the alloying process at the molecular and atomic levels. In particular, an inter-cluster reaction can produce three sets of Au _x Ag_44-x NCs in a wide composition range, and the structure of Au _x Ag_44-x NCs evolves from Ag-rich [Au _x Ag_44-x (SR)₃₀]^4- (x = 1-12), to evenly mixed [Au _x Ag_44-x (SR)₂₇]^3- (x = 19-24), and finally to Au-rich [Au _x Ag_44-x (SR)₂₆]^2- (x = 40-43) NCs, with the increase of the Au/Ag atomic ratio in the NC composition. In addition, leveraging on real-time electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS), we reveal the different inter-cluster reaction mechanisms for the alloying process in the sub-3-nm regime, including partial decomposition-reconstruction and metal exchange reactions. The molecular-level inter-cluster reaction demonstrated in this study provides a fine chemistry to customize the composition and structure of bimetallic NCs in their full alloy composition spectrum, which will greatly increase the acceptance of bimetallic NCs in both basic and applied research.

Cu Doping-Induced Transformation from [Ag62 S12 (SBut )32 ]2+ to [Ag62-x Cux S12 (SBut )32 ]4+ Nanocluster

The change in the valence state of nanocluster can induce remarkable changes in the properties and structure. However, achieving the valence state changes in nanoclusters is still a challenge. In this work, we use Cu²⁺ as dopant to "oxidize" [Ag₆₂ S₁₂ (SBu^t )₃₂ ]²⁺ (4 free electrons) to obtain the new nanocluster: [Ag_62-x Cu_x S₁₂ (SBu^t )₃₂ ]⁴⁺ with 2 free electrons. As revealed by its structure, the [Ag_62-x Cu_x S₁₂ (SBu^t )₃₂ ]⁴⁺ (x=10∼21) has a similar structure to that of [Ag₆₂ S₁₂ (SBu^t )₃₂ ]²⁺ precursor and all the Cu atoms occupy the surface site of nanocluster. It's worth noting that with the Cu atoms doping, the [Ag_62-x Cu_x S₁₂ (SBu^t )₃₂ ]⁴⁺ nanocluster is more stable than [Ag₆₂ S₁₂ (SBu^t )₃₂ ]²⁺ at higher temperature and in electrochemical cycle. This result has laid a foundation for the subsequent application and exploration. Overall, this work reveals crystals structure of a new Ag-Cu nanocluster and offers a new insight into the electron reduction/oxidation of nanocluster.

Superatom-in-Superatom [RhH@Ag24 (SPhMe2 )18 ]2- Nanocluster

Heterometal doping is a powerful method for tuning the physicochemical properties of metal nanoclusters. While the heterometals doped into such nanoclusters predominantly include transition metals with closed d-shells, the doping of open d-shell metals remains largely unexplored. Herein, we report the first synthesis of a [RhHAg₂₄ (SPhMe₂ )₁₈ ]^2- nanocluster, in which a Rh atom with open d-shells ([Kr]4d⁸ 5s¹ ) is incorporated into the Ag₂₄ framework by forming a RhH superatom with closed d-shells ([Kr]4d¹⁰ ). Combined experimental and theoretical investigations showed that the Ag₂₄ framework was co-doped with Rh and hydride and that the RhH dopant was a superatomic construct of a Pd atom. Additional studies demonstrated that the [RhHAg₂₄ (SPhMe₂ )₁₈ ]^2- nanocluster was isoelectronic to the [PdAg₂₄ (SPhMe₂ )₁₈ ]^2- nanocluster with the superatomic 8-electron configuration (1S² 1P⁶ ). This study demonstrated for the first time that a superatom could be incorporated into a cluster superatom to generate a stable superatom-in-superatom nanocluster.

Self-Assembly of Precision Noble Metal Nanoclusters: Hierarchical Structural Complexity, Colloidal Superstructures, and Applications

Ligand protected noble metal nanoparticles are excellent building blocks for colloidal self-assembly. Metal nanoparticle self-assembly offers routes for a wide range of multifunctional nanomaterials with enhanced optoelectronic properties. The emergence of atomically precise monolayer thiol-protected noble metal nanoclusters has overcome numerous challenges such as uncontrolled aggregation, polydispersity, and directionalities faced in plasmonic nanoparticle self-assemblies. Because of their well-defined molecular compositions, enhanced stability, and diverse surface functionalities, nanoclusters offer an excellent platform for developing colloidal superstructures via the self-assembly driven by surface ligands and metal cores. More importantly, recent reports have also revealed the hierarchical structural complexity of several nanoclusters. In this review, the formulation and periodic self-assembly of different noble metal nanoclusters are focused upon. Further, self-assembly induced amplification of physicochemical properties, and their potential applications in molecular recognition, sensing, gas storage, device fabrication, bioimaging, therapeutics, and catalysis are discussed. The topics covered in this review are extensively associated with state-of-the-art achievements in the field of precision noble metal nanoclusters.

Thiolate-Protected Metal Nanoclusters: Recent Development in Synthesis, Understanding of Reaction, and Application in Energy and Environmental Field

Metal nanoclusters (NCs), which are composed of about 250 or fewer metal atoms, possess great potential as novel functional materials. Fundamental research on metal NCs gradually started in the 1960s, and since 2000, thiolate (SR)-protected metal NCs have been the main metal NCs actively studied. The precise and systematic isolation of SR-protected metal NCs has been achieved in 2005. Since then, research on SR-protected metal NCs for both basic science and practical application has rapidly expanded. This review describes this recent progress in the field of SR-protected metal NCs in three areas: synthesis, understanding, and application. Specifically, the recent study of alloy NCs and connected structures composed of NCs is highlighted in the "synthesis" section, recent knowledge on the reactivity of NCs in solution is highlighted in the "understanding" section, and the applications of NCs in the energy and environmental field are highlighted in the "application" section. This review provides insight on the current state of research on SR-protected metal NCs and discusses the challenges to be overcome for further development in this field as well as the possibilities that these materials can contribute to solving the problems facing modern society.

Observable but Not Isolable: The RhAu24 (PET)181+ Nanocluster

The synthesis and characterization of RhAu₂₄ (PET)₁₈ (PET = 2-phenylethanethiol) is described. The cluster is cosynthesized with Au₂₅ (PET)₁₈ and rhodium thiolates in a coreduction of RhCl₃ , HAuCl₄ , and PET. Rapid decomposition of RhAu₂₄ (PET)₁₈ occurs when purified from the other reaction products, precluding the study of isolated cluster. Mixtures containing RhAu₂₄ (PET)₁₈ , Au₂₅ (PET)₁₈ , and rhodium thiolates are therefore characterized. Mass spectrometry, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, and chromatography methods suggest a combination of charge-charge and metallophilic interactions among Au₂₅ (PET)₁₈^1- , rhodium thiolates and RhAu₂₄ (PET)₁₈ resulting in stabilization of RhAu₂₄ (PET)₁₈ . The charge of RhAu₂₄ (PET)₁₈ is assigned as 1+ on the basis of its stoichiometric 1:1 presence with anionic Au₂₅ (PET)₁₈ , and its stability is contextualized within the superatom electron counting rules. This analysis concludes that the Rh atom absorbs one superatomic electron to close its d-shell, giving RhAu₂₄ (PET)₁₈¹⁺ a superatomic electron configuration of 1S² 1P⁴ . Overall, an updated framework for rationalizing open d-shell heterometal dopant electronics in thiolated gold nanoclusters emerges.

Toward the creation of high-performance heterogeneous catalysts by controlled ligand desorption from atomically precise metal nanoclusters

Ligand-protected metal nanoclusters controlled by atomic accuracy (i. e. atomically precise metal NCs) have recently attracted considerable attention as active sites in heterogeneous catalysts. Using these atomically precise metal NCs, it becomes possible to create novel heterogeneous catalysts based on a size-specific electronic/geometrical structure of metal NCs and understand the mechanism of the catalytic reaction easily. However, to create high-performance heterogeneous catalysts using atomically precise metal NCs, it is often necessary to remove the ligands from the metal NCs. This review summarizes previous studies on the creation of heterogeneous catalysts using atomically precise metal NCs while focusing on the calcination as a ligand-elimination method. Through this summary, we intend to share state-of-art techniques and knowledge on (1) experimental conditions suitable for creating high-performance heterogeneous catalysts (e.g., support type, metal NC type, ligand type, and calcination temperature), (2) the mechanism of calcination, and (3) the mechanism of catalytic reaction over the created heterogeneous catalyst. We also discuss (4) issues that should be addressed in the future toward the creation of high-performance heterogeneous catalysts using atomically precise metal NCs. The knowledge and issues described in this review are expected to lead to clear design guidelines for the creation of novel heterogeneous catalysts.

Kinetics of Intercluster Reactions between Atomically Precise Noble Metal Clusters [Ag25(DMBT)18]- and [Au25(PET)18]- in Room Temperature Solutions

The kinetics of intercluster metal atom exchange reactions between solvated [Ag₂₅(DMBT)₁₈]^- and [Au₂₅(PET)₁₈]^- (DMBT and PET are 2,4-dimethylbenzenethiol and 2-phenylethanethiol, respectively, both C₈H₁₀S) were probed by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry and computer-based modeling. Anion mass spectra and collision induced dissociation (CID) measurements show that both cluster monomers and dimers are involved in the reactions. We have modeled the corresponding kinetics assuming a reaction mechanism in which metal atom exchange occurs through transient dimers. Our kinetic model contains three types of generic reactions: dimerization of monomers, metal atom exchange in the transient dimers, and dissociation of the dimers to monomers. There are correspondingly 377 discrete species connected by in total 1302 reactions (i.e., dimerization, dissociation and atom exchange reactions) leading to the entire series of monomeric and dimeric products [Ag_mAu_25-m]^- (m = 1-24) and [Ag_mAu_50-m]^2- (m = 0-50), respectively. The rate constants of the corresponding reactions were fitted to the experimental data, and good agreement was obtained with exchange rate constants which scale with the probability of finding a silver or gold atom in the respective monomeric subunit of the dimer, i.e., reflecting an entropic driving force for alloying. Allowing the dimerization rate constant to scale with increasing gold composition of the respective reactants improves the agreement further. The rate constants obtained are physically plausible, thus strongly supporting dimer-mediated metal atom exchange in this intercluster reaction system.

Intercluster exchanges leading to hydride-centered bimetallic clusters: a multi-NMR, X-ray crystallographic, and DFT study

Encouraged by the successful syntheses of alloy nanoclusters (or nanoparticles) via intercluster (or interparticle) reactions, herein we apply this methodology to prepare a series of bimetallic hydride clusters. Mixing of two clusters, [Ag₇(H){E₂P(OⁱPr)₂}₆] (E = S, 1; Se, 3) and [Cu₇(H){E₂P(OⁱPr)₂}₆] (E = S, 2; Se, 4), yields two series of hydride-centered bimetallic clusters, [Cu_xAg_7-x(H){E₂P(OⁱPr)₂}₆] (x = 0-7; E = S, 5; Se, 6). Their compositions are fully characterized by positive-mode ESI-MS spectrometry, multi-NMR spectroscopy, and the structures of [Cu₆Ag(H){S₂P(OⁱPr)₂}₆] (5a) and [CuAg₆(H){Se₂P(OⁱPr)₂}₆] (6a) by single crystal X-ray diffraction. The presence of individual compounds in solution is the result of a (dynamic) chemical equilibrium primarily driven by metal exchanges. In fact, the process of inter-cluster exchange of 1 and 2 leading to hydride-centered bimetallic clusters 5 can be monitored by concentration-dependent ³¹P NMR spectroscopy of which the higher concentration of 1 in the reaction, the closer to its resonance will be the distribution, in accord with Le Chatelier's principle. The dynamic equilibrium is further confirmed by 2D exchange spectroscopy that reveals a stepwise process involving one metal exchange at a time. DFT calculations on a model series of clusters 6 show that silver prefers occupying the inner tetrahedral positions, while copper favors capping positions, in full agreement with the crystal structure of 5a and 6a.

Unconventional Approaches in Coordination Chemistry and Organometallic Reactivity

This contribution highlights a number of approaches developed by coordination and organometallic chemists that go beyond mainstream inorganic reactivity. A few of these strategies have been known for decades and are fundamental tools in synthesis and catalysis, while others are more recent and still belong to a niche. Through selected examples, we show herein how transmetalation, metal exchange, metal cooperativity, and catalytic transformation of metal complexes provide unique new opportunities to expand the reactivity arsenal of inorganic systems for synthetic and technological applications.

New Routes for Multicomponent Atomically Precise Metal Nanoclusters

Atomically precise metal nanoclusters (NCs), protected by a monolayer of ligands, are regarded as potential building blocks for advanced technologies. They are considered as intermediates between the atomic/molecular regime and the bulk. Incorporation of foreign metals in NCs enhances several of their properties such as catalytic activity, luminescence, and so on; hence, it is of high importance for tuning their properties and broadening the scope of applications. In most of the cases, enhancement in specific properties was observed upon alloying due to the synergistic effect. In the past several years, many alloy clusters have been synthesized, which show a tremendous change in the properties than their monometallic analogs. However, controlling the synthesis and tuning the structures of alloy NCs with atomic precision are major challenges. Various synthetic methodologies have been developed so far for the controlled synthesis of alloy NCs. In this perspective, we have highlighted those diverse synthetic routes to prepare alloys, which include co-reduction, galvanic reduction, antigalvanic reduction, metal deposition, ligand exchange, intercluster reaction, and reaction of NCs with bulk metals. Advancement in synthetic procedures will help in the preparation of alloy NCs with the desired structure and composition. Future perceptions concerning the progress of alloy nanocluster science are also provided.

Creation of active water-splitting photocatalysts by controlling cocatalysts using atomically precise metal nanoclusters

With global warming and the depletion of fossil resources, our fossil-fuel-dependent society is expected to shift to one that instead uses hydrogen (H₂) as clean and renewable energy. Water-splitting photocatalysts can produce H₂ from water using sunlight, which are almost infinite on the earth. However, further improvements are indispensable to enable their practical application. To improve the efficiency of the photocatalytic water-splitting reaction, in addition to improving the semiconductor photocatalyst, it is extremely effective to improve the cocatalysts (loaded metal nanoclusters, NCs) that enable the reaction to proceed on the photocatalysts. We have thus attempted to strictly control metal NCs on photocatalysts by introducing the precise-control techniques of metal NCs established in the metal NC field into research on water-splitting photocatalysts. Specifically, the cocatalysts on the photocatalysts were controlled by adsorbing atomically precise metal NCs on the photocatalysts and then removing the protective ligands by calcination. This work has led to several findings on the electronic/geometrical structures of the loaded metal NCs, the correlation between the types of loaded metal NCs and the water-splitting activity, and the methods for producing high water-splitting activity. We expect that the obtained knowledge will lead to clear design guidelines for the creation of practical water-splitting photocatalysts and thereby contribute to the construction of a hydrogen-energy society.

Linear Size Contraction of Ligand Protected Ag29 Clusters by Substituting Ag with Cu

There are only a few examples of atomically precise, ligand protected, bimetallic coinage metal clusters in which molecular structure remains essentially unchanged over a wide composition range starting from the corresponding homometallic species. Such model systems are particularly useful to study the dynamics of alloy formation on the nanoscale. Here we demonstrate the unusual reactivity of solvated metalloid-superatom Ag₂₉(BDT)₁₂(PPh₃)₄ (BDT = 1,3 benzenedithiol) clusters toward semiconducting Cu₁₂S₆(DPPPT)₄ (DPPPT = bis(diphenylphosphino)pentane) clusters as an efficient way to exchange multiple copper atoms into the atomically precise silver clusters without changing overall the structure type. Concentration-dependent UV-vis absorption and online mass spectrometry shows that 14 Cu atoms can be exchanged into the silver cluster. Beyond the 14 Cu atom exchange, the cluster degrades to smaller thiolates. Information on cluster structures is obtained from high-resolution ion mobility mass spectrometry, which shows a linear decrease in collision cross section (CCS) with each Ag/Cu exchanged. Several isomeric structures are calculated by density functional theory (DFT), and their calculated collision cross sections are used to identify the most stable isomers for each Ag/Cu exchange product. Ag/Cu exchange is essentially limited to the cluster surface/shell. The core appears not to be involved.

Atom transfer between precision nanoclusters and polydispersed nanoparticles: a facile route for monodisperse alloy nanoparticles and their superstructures

Reactions between atomically precise noble metal nanoclusters (NCs) have been studied widely in the recent past, but such processes between NCs and plasmonic nanoparticles (NPs) have not been explored earlier. For the first time, we demonstrate spontaneous reactions between an atomically precise NC, Au25(PET)18 (PET = 2-phenylethanethiol), and polydispersed silver NPs with an average diameter of 4 nm and protected with PET, resulting in alloy NPs under ambient conditions. These reactions were specific to the nature of the protecting ligands as no reaction was observed between the Au25(SBB)18 NC (SBB = 4-(tert-butyl)benzyl mercaptan) and the very same silver NPs. The mechanism involves an interparticle exchange of the metal and ligand species where the metal-ligand interface plays a vital role in controlling the reaction. The reaction proceeds through transient Au25-xAgx(PET)n alloy cluster intermediates as observed in time-dependent electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI MS). High-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) analysis of the resulting dispersion showed the transformation of polydispersed silver NPs into highly monodisperse gold-silver alloy NPs which assembled to form 2-dimensional superlattices. Using NPs of other average sizes (3 and 8 nm), we demonstrated that size plays an important role in the reactivity as observed in ESI MS and HRTEM.

Atomically precise alloy nanoclusters: syntheses, structures, and properties

Metal nanoclusters fill the gap between discrete atoms and plasmonic nanoparticles, providing unique opportunities for investigating the quantum effects and precise structure-property correlations at the atomic level. As a versatile strategy, alloying can largely improve the physicochemical performances compared to the corresponding homo-metal nanoclusters, and thus benefit the applications of such nanomaterials. In this review, we highlight the achievements of atomically precise alloy nanoclusters, and summarize the alloying principles and fundamentals, including the synthetic methods, site-preferences for different heteroatoms in the templates, and alloying-induced structure and property changes. First, based on various Au or Ag nanocluster templates, heteroatom doping modes are presented. The templates with electronic shell-closing configurations tend to maintain their structures during doping, while the others may undergo transformation and give rise to alloy nanoclusters with new structures. Second, alloy nanoclusters of specific magic sizes are reviewed. The arrangement of different atoms is related to the symmetry of the structures; that is, different atoms are symmetrically located in the nanoclusters of smaller sizes, and evolve into shell-by-shell structures at larger sizes. Then, we elaborate on the alloying effects in terms of optical, electrochemical, electroluminescent, magnetic and chiral properties, as well as the stability and reactivity via comparisons between the doped nanoclusters and their homo-metal counterparts. For example, central heteroatom-induced photoluminescence enhancement is emphasized. The applications of alloy nanoclusters in catalysis, chemical sensing, bio-labeling, and other fields are further discussed. Finally, we provide perspectives on existing issues and future efforts. Overall, this review provides a comprehensive synthetic toolbox and controllable doping modes so as to achieve more alloy nanoclusters with customized compositions, structures, and properties for applications. This review is based on publications available up to February 2020.

An overview on the current understanding of the photophysical properties of metal nanoclusters and their potential applications

Photophysics of atomically precise metal nanoclusters (MNCs) is an emerging area of research due to their potential applications in optoelectronics, photovoltaics, sensing, bio-imaging and catalysis. An overview of the recent advances in the photophysical properties of MNCs is presented in this review. To begin with, we illustrate general synthesis methodologies of MNCs using direct reduction, chemical etching, ligand exchange, metal exchange and intercluster reaction. Due to strong quantum confinement, the NCs possess unique electronic properties such as discrete optical absorption, intense photoluminescence (PL), molecular-like electron dynamics and non-linear optical behavior. Discussions have also been carried out to unveil the influence of the core size, nature of ligands, heteroatom doping, and surrounding environments on the optical absorption and photophysical properties of metal clusters. Recent findings reveal that the excited-state dynamics, nonlinear optical properties and aggregation induced emission of metal clusters offer exciting opportunities for potential applications. We discuss briefly about their versatile applications in optoelectronics, sensing, catalysis and bio-imaging. Finally, the future perspective of this research field is given.

Interparticle Reactions between Silver Nanoclusters Leading to Product Cocrystals by Selective Cocrystallization

We present an example of an interparticle reaction between atomically precise nanoclusters (NCs) of the same metal, resulting in entirely different clusters. In detail, the clusters [Ag₁₂(TBT)₈(TFA)₅(CH₃CN)]⁺ (TBT = tert-butylthiolate, TFA = trifluoroacetate, CH₃CN = acetonitrile) and [Ag₁₈(TPP)₁₀H₁₆]²⁺ (TPP = triphenylphosphine) abbreviated as Ag₁₂ and Ag₁₈, respectively, react leading to [Ag₁₆(TBT)₈(TFA)₇(CH₃CN)₃Cl]⁺ and [Ag₁₇(TBT)₈(TFA)₇(CH₃CN)₃Cl]⁺, abbreviated as Ag₁₆ and Ag₁₇, respectively. The two product NCs crystallize together as both possess the same metal chalcogenolate shell, composed of Ag₁₆S₈, making them indistinguishable. The occupancies of Ag₁₆ and Ag₁₇ are 66.66 and 33.33%, respectively, in a single crystal. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI MS) of the reaction product and a dissolved crystal show the population of Ag₁₆ and Ag₁₇ NCs to be in a 1:1 and 2:1 ratio, respectively. This suggests selective crystallization in the cocrystal. Time-dependent ESI MS was employed to understand the formation of product clusters by monitoring the reaction intermediates formed in the course of the reaction. We present an unprecedented growth mechanism for the formation of silver NCs mediated by silver thiolate intermediates.

Formation of an NIR-emitting Ag34S3SBB20(CF3COO)62+ cluster from a hydride-protected silver cluster

Formation of an NIR emitting Ag₃₄S₃SBB₂₀(CF₃COO)₆²⁺ cluster.

Atomic-Level Doping of Metal Clusters

Atomically precise noble metal (mainly silver and gold) nanoclusters are an emerging category of promising functional materials for future applications in energy, sensing, catalysis, and nanoelectronics. These nanoclusters are protected by ligands such as thiols, phosphines, and hydride and have sizes between those of atoms and plasmonic nanoparticles. In metallurgy, the properties of a pure metal are modified by the addition of other metals, which often offers augmented characteristics, making them more utilizable for real-life applications. In this Account, we discuss how the incorporation of various metal atoms into existing protected nanoclusters tunes their structure and properties. The process of incorporating metals into an existing cluster is known as doping; the product is known as a doped cluster, and the incorporated metal atom is called a dopant/foreign atom. We first present a brief historical overview of protected clusters and the need for doping and explain (with examples) the difference between an "alloy" and a "doped" cluster, which are two frequently confused terms. We then discuss several commonly observed challenges in the synthesis of doped clusters: (i) doping produces a mixture of compositions that prevents the growth of single crystals; (ii) doping with foreign atoms sometimes changes the overall composition and structure of the parent cluster; and (iii) doping beyond a certain number of foreign atoms decomposes the doped cluster. After delineating the challenges, we review a few potential synthetic methods for doped clusters: (i) the co-reduction method, (ii) the galvanic exchange method, (iii) ligand-induced conversion of bimetallic clusters to doped clusters, and (iv) intercluster reactions. As a foreign atom is able to occupy different positions within the structure of the parent cluster, we examine the structural relationship between the parent clusters and their different foreign-atom-doped clusters. We then show how doping enhances the stability, luminescence, and catalytic properties of clusters. The enhancement factor highly depends on the number and nature of the foreign atoms, which can also alter the charge state of the parent cluster. Atomic-level doping of foreign atoms in the parent cluster is confirmed by high-resolution electrospray ionization and matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry techniques and single-crystal X-ray diffraction methods. The photophysical properties of the doped clusters are investigated using both time-dependent and steady-state luminescence and optical absorption spectroscopies. After presenting an overview of atomic-level doping in metal clusters and demonstrating its importance for enriching the chemistry and photophysics of clusters and extending their applications, we conclude this Account with a brief perspective on the field's future.

Alloy Clusters: Precise Synthesis and Mixing Effects

Metal alloys exhibit functionalities unlike those of single metals. Such alloying has drawn considerable research interest, particularly for nanoscale particles (metal clusters/nanoparticles), from the viewpoint of creating new functional nanomaterials. In gas phase cluster research, generated alloy clusters can be spatially separated with atomic precision in vacuum. Thus, the influences of increases or decreases in each element on the overall electronic structure of the cluster can be elucidated. However, to further understand the related mixing and synergistic effects, alloy clusters need to be produced on a large scale and characterized by various techniques. Because alloy clusters protected by thiolate (SR) can be synthesized by chemical methods and are stable in both solution and the solid state, these clusters are ideal study materials to better understand the mixing and synergistic effects. Moreover, the alloy clusters thus created have potential applications as functional materials. Therefore, since 2008, we have been working on establishing a precise synthesis method for SR-protected alloy clusters and elucidating their mixing and synergistic effects. Early research focused on the precise synthesis of alloy clusters wherein some of the Au in the stable SR-protected gold clusters ([Au₂₅(SR)₁₈]^- and [Au₃₈(SR)₂₄]⁰) is replaced by Pd, Ag, or Cu. These studies have shown that Pd, Ag, or Cu substitute at different metal sites. We also have examined the as-synthesized alloy clusters to clarify the effect of substitution by each element on the physical and chemical properties of the clusters. However, in early studies, the number of substitutions could not be controlled with atomic accuracy for [Au_{25- x}M _x(SR)₁₈]^- (M = Ag or Cu). Then, in following research, methods have been established to obtain alloy clusters with control over the composition. We have succeeded in developing a method for controlling the number of Ag substitutions with atomic precision and thereby elucidating the effect of Ag substitution on the electronic structure of clusters with atomic precision. Concurrently, we also studied alloy clusters containing multiple heteroelements with different preferential substitution sites. These results revealed that the effects of substitution of each element can be superimposed on the cluster by combining multiple elemental substitutions at different sites. In addition, we successfully developed methods to synthesize alloy clusters with heterometal core. These findings are expected to lead to clear design guidelines for developing new functional nanomaterials.

Customizing the Structure, Composition, and Properties of Alloy Nanoclusters by Metal Exchange

The properties of metal materials can be greatly enriched by including various elements to generate alloys. The galvanic replacement represents a classical method for the preparation of both bulk- and nanoalloy materials. The difference of the electrochemical potential between the two metals acts as the driving force for the galvanic replacement reaction. However, this classical rule partially fails at the ultrasmall size scale, for that novel chemistry emerges by the decrease of the size of materials down to less than 3 nm due to the strong quantum effect. In this Account, we discuss an emerging topic of nanochemistry, the metal exchange in atomically precise ultrasmall (<3 nm) metal nanoparticles (or nanoclusters). The metal exchange method uses different types of metal sources (e.g., AuBrPPh₃ or AgSR complexes) to react with templating metal nanoclusters (e.g., Au₂₅(SR)₁₈^-), and finally alloy nanoclusters are produced. We demonstrate that the metal exchange reaction between metal nanoclusters and metal complexes does not follow the classical metal activity sequence (i.e., Fe > Cd > Co > Ni > Pb > Cu > Hg > Ag > Pd > Pt > Au) and such metal exchange reactions in the nanocluster range is, to a large extent, related with the electron shell closing and the structural stability of nanoclusters. In the subsequent sections, we present effective control over the number, position, and distribution of the dopants. The shape and structure of the final alloy products can be tailored by recently developed metal exchange methods. More importantly, modulation and enhancement of the properties of NCs through metal exchange are realized. For example, the largely increased quantum yield and the significantly improved catalytic activity. In addition, we shall also discuss the real-time characterization of the metal exchange reaction by the combination of UV-vis absorption spectroscopy, high resolution electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS), matrix assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF-MS), and single crystal X-ray diffraction (SC-XRD). By controlling the charge of the templating metal nanoclusters and the different types of metal complexes, the driving force of metal exchange has been studied, which is considered to be the thermodynamics rather than the electrochemical potential. In summary, the metal exchange reactions in the ultrasmall nanocluster range are totally different compared with the case of larger-sized metal nanoparticles. Depending on this novel method, atomically precise alloy nanoclusters can be prepared by reacting the nanocluster composed of inert metal (such as Au) with complexes of high-activity metals (e.g., Cd/Hg/Cu/Ag). We anticipate that future research on the metal exchange will contribute to the fundamental understanding of reaction behavior of metal atoms in ultrasmall nanoclusters and to the design of alloy nanoclusters with enhanced properties.

Au25(SR)18: the captain of the great nanocluster ship

Noble metal nanoclusters are in the intermediate state between discrete atoms and plasmonic nanoparticles and are of significance due to their atomically accurate structures, intriguing properties, and great potential for applications in various fields. In addition, the size-dependent properties of nanoclusters construct a platform for thoroughly researching the structure (composition)-property correlations, which is favorable for obtaining novel nanomaterials with enhanced physicochemical properties. Thus far, more than 100 species of nanoclusters (mono-metallic Au or Ag nanoclusters, and bi- or tri-metallic alloy nanoclusters) with crystal structures have been reported. Among these nanoclusters, Au25(SR)18-the brightest molecular star in the nanocluster field-is capable of revealing the past developments and prospecting the future of the nanoclusters. Since being successfully synthesized (in 1998, with a 20-year history) and structurally determined (in 2008, with a 10-year history), Au25(SR)18 has stimulated the interest of chemists as well as material scientists, due to the early discovery, easy preparation, high stability, and easy functionalization and application of this molecular star. In this review, the preparation methods, crystal structures, physicochemical properties, and practical applications of Au25(SR)18 are summarized. The properties of Au25(SR)18 range from optics and chirality to magnetism and electrochemistry, and the property-oriented applications include catalysis, chemical imaging, sensing, biological labeling, biomedicine and beyond. Furthermore, the research progress on the Ag-based M25(SR)18 counterpart (i.e., Ag25(SR)18) is included in this review due to its homologous composition, construction and optical absorption to its gold-counterpart Au25(SR)18. Moreover, the alloying methods, metal-exchange sites and property alternations based on the templated Au25(SR)18 are highlighted. Finally, some perspectives and challenges for the future research of the Au25(SR)18 nanocluster are proposed (also holding true for all members in the nanocluster field). This review is directed toward the broader scientific community interested in the metal nanocluster field, and hopefully opens up new horizons for scientists studying nanomaterials. This review is based on the publications available up to March 2018.

Dopant-Dependent Electronic Structures Observed for M2Au36(SC6H13)24 Clusters (M = Pt, Pd)

Heteroatom doping is a powerful means to tune the optical and electronic properties of gold clusters at the atomic level. We herein report that doping a Au₃₈ cluster with Pt and Pd atoms leads to core-doped [Pt₂Au₃₆(SC₆H₁₃)₂₄]^2- and [Pd₂Au₃₆(SC₆H₁₃)₂₄]⁰, respectively. Voltammetric investigations show that these clusters exhibit drastically different electronic structures; whereas the HOMO-LUMO gap of [Pt₂Au₃₆(SC₆H₁₃)₂₄]^2- is found to be 0.95 V, that of [Pd₂Au₃₆(SC₆H₁₃)₂₄]⁰ is drastically decreased to 0.26 V, suggesting Jahn-Teller distortion of the 12-electron cluster. Density functional investigations confirm that the HOMO-LUMO gap of the Pd-doped cluster is indeed reduced. Analysis of the optimized geometry for the 12-electron [Pd₂Au₃₆(SC₆H₁₃)₂₄]⁰ reveals that the rod-like M₂Au₂₁ core becomes more flattened upon Pd-doping. Reversible geometrical interconversion between [Pt₂Au₃₆(SC₆H₁₃)₂₄]⁰ and [Pt₂Au₃₆(SC₆H₁₃)₂₄]^2- is clearly demonstrated by manipulating the oxidation state of the cluster.

Surface Single-Atom Tailoring of a Gold Nanoparticle

Surface single-atom tailoring of a gold nanoparticle, that is, adding, removing, or replacing one surface atom on a structure-resolved nanoparticle in a controlled manner, is very exciting yet challenging and has not been hitherto achieved. Herein we report the first realization of the introduction of a single sulfur atom onto the surface of the structure-unraveled Au₆₀S₆(SCH₂Ph)₃₆ nanoparticle. Single-crystal X-ray crystallography reveals that the as-obtained nanoparticle consists of one Au₁₇ kernel protected by one Au₂₀S₃(SCH₂Ph)₁₈ and one unprecedented Au₂₃S₄(SCH₂Ph)₁₈ motif with the introduced sulfur atom included as a tetrahedral-coordinated μ₄-S. The introduced sulfur leads to the changes of both internal structure and crystallographic arrangement. Unlike the case of 6HLH arrangement in Au₆₀S₆(SCH₂Ph)₃₆ crystals, the "ABAB" arrangement in Au₆₀S₇(SCH₂Ph)₃₆ crystals enhances the solid photoluminescence of amorphous Au₆₀S₇(SCH₂Ph)₃₆ and brings a slight redshift of the maximum emission. The extensive near-infrared emission provides Au₆₀S₇(SCH₂Ph)₃₆ potential applications in some fields such as anticounterfeiting, imaging, etc.

Relativistic DFT investigation of electronic structure effects arising from doping the Au25 nanocluster with transition metals

We perform a theoretical investigation using density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependent DFT (TDDFT) on the doping of the Au₂₅(SR)₁₈^-1 nanocluster with group IX transition metals (M = cobalt, rhodium and iridium). Different doping motifs, charge states and spin multiplicities were considered for the single-atom doped nanoclusters. Our results show that the interaction (or the lack of interaction) between the d-type energy levels that mainly originate from the dopant atom and the super-atomic levels plays an important role in the energetics, the electronic structure and the optical properties of the doped systems. The evaluated MAu₂₄(SR)₁₈^q (q = -1, -3) systems favor an endohedral disposition of the doping atom typically in a singlet ground state, with either a 6- or 8-valence electron icosahedral core. For the sake of comparison, the role of the d energy levels in the electronic structure of a variety of doped Au₂₅(SR)₁₈^-1 nanoclusters was investigated for dopant atoms from other families such as Cd, Ag and Pd. Finally, the effect of spin-orbit coupling (SOC) on the electronic structure and absorption spectra was determined. The information in this study regarding the relative energetics of the d-based and super-atom energy levels can be useful to extend our understanding of the preferred doping modes of different transition metals in protected gold nanoclusters.

Interparticle Reactions: An Emerging Direction in Nanomaterials Chemistry

Nanoparticles exhibit a rich variety in terms of structure, composition, and properties. However, reactions between them remain largely unexplored. In this Account, we discuss an emerging aspect of nanomaterials chemistry, namely, interparticle reactions in solution phase, similar to reactions between molecules, involving atomically precise noble metal clusters. A brief historical account of the developments, starting from the bare, gas phase clusters, which led to the synthesis of atomically precise monolayer protected clusters in solution, is presented first. Then a reaction between two thiolate-protected, atomically precise noble metal clusters, [Au₂₅(PET)₁₈]^- and [Ag₄₄(FTP)₃₀]^4- (PET = 2-phenylethanethiol, FTP = 4-fluorothiophenol), is presented wherein these clusters spontaneously exchange metal atoms, ligands, and metal-ligand fragments between them under ambient conditions. The number of exchanged species could be controlled by varying the initial compositions of the reactant clusters. Next, a reaction of [Au₂₅(PET)₁₈]^- with its structural analogue [Ag₂₅(DMBT)₁₈]^- (DMBT = 2,4-dimethylbenzenethiol) is presented, which shows that atom-exchange reactions happen with structures conserved. We detected a transient dianionic adduct, [Ag₂₅Au₂₅(DMBT)₁₈(PET)₁₈]^2-, formed between the two clusters indicating that this adduct could be a possible intermediate of the reaction. A reaction involving a dithiolate-protected cluster, [Ag₂₉(BDT)₁₂]^3- (BDT = 1,3-benzenedithiol), is also presented wherein metal atom exchange alone occurs, but with no ligand and fragment exchanges. These examples demonstrate that the nature of the metal-thiolate interface, that is, its bonding network and dynamics, play crucial roles in dictating the type of exchange processes and overall rates. We also discuss a recently proposed structural model of these clusters, namely, the Borromean ring model, to understand the dynamics of the metal-ligand interfaces and to address the site specificity and selectivity in these reactions. In the subsequent sections, reactions involving atomically precise noble metal clusters and one- and two-dimensional nanosystems are presented. We show that highly protected, stable clusters such as [Au₂₅(PET)₁₈]^- undergo chemical transformation on graphenic surfaces to form a bigger cluster, Au₁₃₅(PET)₅₇. Finally, we present the transformation of tellurium nanowires (Te NWs) to Ag-Te-Ag dumbbell nanostructures through a reaction with an atomically precise silver cluster, Ag₃₂(SG)₁₉ (SG = glutathione thiolate). The starting materials and the products were characterized using high resolution electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, matrix assisted laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry, UV/vis absorption, luminescence spectroscopies, etc. We have analyzed principally mass spectrometric data to understand these reactions. In summary, we present the emergence of a new branch of chemistry involving the reactions of atomically precise cluster systems, which are prototypical nanoparticles. We demonstrate that such interparticle chemistry is not limited to metal clusters; it occurs across zero-, one-, and two-dimensional nanosystems leading to specific transformations. We conclude this Account with a discussion of the limitations in understanding of these reactions and future directions in this area of nanomaterials chemistry.