Benefits of Iterative Searches of Large Databases to Interpret Large Human Gut Metaproteomic Data Sets

Insights on Wet and Dry Workflows for Human Gut Metaproteomics

The human gut microbiota (GM) is a community of microorganisms that resides in the gastrointestinal (GI) tract. Recognized as a critical element of human health, the functions of the GM extend beyond GI well-being to influence overall systemic health and susceptibility to disease. Among the other omic sciences, metaproteomics highlights additional facets that make it a highly valuable discipline in the study of GM. Indeed, it allows the protein inventory of complex microbial communities. Proteins with associated taxonomic membership and function are identified and quantified from their constituent peptides by liquid chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry analyses and by querying specific databases (DBs). The aim of this review was to compile comprehensive information on metaproteomic studies of the human GM, with a focus on the bacterial component, to assist newcomers in understanding the methods and types of research conducted in this field. The review outlines key steps in a metaproteomic-based study, such as protein extraction, DB selection, and bioinformatic workflow. The importance of standardization is emphasized. In addition, a list of previously published studies is provided as hints for researchers interested in investigating the role of GM in health and disease states.

Construction of Protein Sequence Databases for Metaproteomics: A Review of the Current Tools and Databases

In metaproteomics studies, constructing a reference protein sequence database that is both comprehensive and not overly large is critical for the peptide identification step. Therefore, the availability of well-curated reference databases and tools for custom database construction is essential to enhance the performance of metaproteomics analyses. In this review, we first provide an overview of metaproteomics by presenting a concise historical background, outlining a typical experimental and bioinformatics workflow, emphasizing the crucial step of constructing a protein sequence database for metaproteomics. We then delve into the current tools available for building such databases, highlighting their individual approaches, utility, and advantages and limitations. Next, we examine existing protein sequence databases, detailing their scope and relevance in metaproteomics research. Then, we provide practical recommendations for constructing protein sequence databases for metaproteomics, along with an overview of the current challenges in this area. We conclude with a discussion of anticipated advancements, emerging trends, and future directions in the construction of protein sequence databases for metaproteomics.

Full Native timsTOF PASEF-Enabled Quantitative Proteomics with the i2MassChroQ Software Package

Ion mobility mass spectrometry has become popular in proteomics lately, in particular because the Bruker timsTOF instruments have found significant adoption in proteomics facilities. The Bruker's implementation of the ion mobility dimension generates massive amounts of mass spectrometric data that require carefully designed software both to extract meaningful information and to perform processing tasks at reasonable speed. In a historical move, the Bruker company decided to harness the skills of the scientific software development community by releasing to the public the timsTOF data file format specification. As a proteomics facility that has been developing Free Open Source Software (FOSS) solutions since decades, we took advantage of this opportunity to implement the very first FOSS proteomics complete solution to natively read the timsTOF data, low-level process them, and explore them in an integrated quantitative proteomics software environment. We dubbed our software i2MassChroQ because it implements a (peptide)identification-(protein)inference-mass-chromatogram-quantification processing workflow. The software benchmarking results reported in this paper show that i2MassChroQ performed better than competing software on two critical characteristics: (1) feature extraction capability and (2) protein quantitative dynamic range. Altogether, i2MassChroQ yielded better quantified protein numbers, both in a technical replicate MS runs setting and in a differential protein abundance analysis setting.

Data-independent acquisition in metaproteomics

INTRODUCTION

Metaproteomics offers insights into the function of complex microbial communities, while it is also capable of revealing microbe-microbe and host-microbe interactions. Data-independent acquisition (DIA) mass spectrometry is an emerging technology, which holds great potential to achieve deep and accurate metaproteomics with higher reproducibility yet still facing a series of challenges due to the inherent complexity of metaproteomics and DIA data.

AREAS COVERED

This review offers an overview of the DIA metaproteomics approaches, covering aspects such as database construction, search strategy, and data analysis tools. Several cases of current DIA metaproteomics studies are presented to illustrate the procedures. Important ongoing challenges are also highlighted. Future perspectives of DIA methods for metaproteomics analysis are further discussed. Cited references are searched through and collected from Google Scholar and PubMed.

EXPERT OPINION

Considering the inherent complexity of DIA metaproteomics data, data analysis strategies specifically designed for interpretation are imperative. From this point of view, we anticipate that deep learning methods and de novo sequencing methods will become more prevalent in the future, potentially improving protein coverage in metaproteomics. Moreover, the advancement of metaproteomics also depends on the development of sample preparation methods, data analysis strategies, etc. These factors are key to unlocking the full potential of metaproteomics.

Contigs directed gene annotation (ConDiGA) for accurate protein sequence database construction in metaproteomics

BACKGROUND

Microbiota are closely associated with human health and disease. Metaproteomics can provide a direct means to identify microbial proteins in microbiota for compositional and functional characterization. However, in-depth and accurate metaproteomics is still limited due to the extreme complexity and high diversity of microbiota samples. It is generally recommended to use metagenomic data from the same samples to construct the protein sequence database for metaproteomic data analysis. Although different metagenomics-based database construction strategies have been developed, an optimization of gene taxonomic annotation has not been reported, which, however, is extremely important for accurate metaproteomic analysis.

RESULTS

Herein, we proposed an accurate taxonomic annotation pipeline for genes from metagenomic data, namely contigs directed gene annotation (ConDiGA), and used the method to build a protein sequence database for metaproteomic analysis. We compared our pipeline (ConDiGA or MD3) with two other popular annotation pipelines (MD1 and MD2). In MD1, genes were directly annotated against the whole bacterial genome database; in MD2, contigs were annotated against the whole bacterial genome database and the taxonomic information of contigs was assigned to the genes; in MD3, the most confident species from the contigs annotation results were taken as reference to annotate genes. Annotation tools, including BLAST, Kaiju, and Kraken2, were compared. Based on a synthetic microbial community of 12 species, it was found that Kaiju with the MD3 pipeline outperformed the others in the construction of protein sequence database from metagenomic data. Similar performance was also observed with a fecal sample, as well as in silico mixed datasets of the simulated microbial community and the fecal sample.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, we developed an optimized pipeline for gene taxonomic annotation to construct protein sequence databases. Our study can tackle the current taxonomic annotation reliability problem in metagenomics-derived protein sequence database and can promote the in-depth metaproteomic analysis of microbiome. The unique metagenomic and metaproteomic datasets of the 12 bacterial species are publicly available as a standard benchmarking sample for evaluating various analysis pipelines. The code of ConDiGA is open access at GitHub for the analysis of microbiota samples. Video Abstract.

The astounding exhaustiveness and speed of the Astral mass analyzer for highly complex samples is a quantum leap in the functional analysis of microbiomes

BACKGROUND

By analyzing the proteins which are the workhorses of biological systems, metaproteomics allows us to list the taxa present in any microbiota, monitor their relative biomass, and characterize the functioning of complex biological systems.

RESULTS

Here, we present a new strategy for rapidly determining the microbial community structure of a given sample and designing a customized protein sequence database to optimally exploit extensive tandem mass spectrometry data. This approach leverages the capabilities of the first generation of Quadrupole Orbitrap mass spectrometer incorporating an asymmetric track lossless (Astral) analyzer, offering rapid MS/MS scan speed and sensitivity. We took advantage of data-dependent acquisition and data-independent acquisition strategies using a peptide extract from a human fecal sample spiked with precise amounts of peptides from two reference bacteria.

CONCLUSIONS

Our approach, which combines both acquisition methods, proves to be time-efficient while processing extensive generic databases and massive datasets, achieving a coverage of more than 122,000 unique peptides and 38,000 protein groups within a 30-min DIA run. This marks a significant departure from current state-of-the-art metaproteomics methodologies, resulting in broader coverage of the metabolic pathways governing the biological system. In combination, our strategy and the Astral mass analyzer represent a quantum leap in the functional analysis of microbiomes. Video Abstract.

High-Abundance Protein-Guided Hybrid Spectral Library for Data-Independent Acquisition Metaproteomics

Metaproteomics offers a direct avenue to identify microbial proteins in microbiota, enabling the compositional and functional characterization of microbiota. Due to the complexity and heterogeneity of microbial communities, in-depth and accurate metaproteomics faces tremendous limitations. One challenge in metaproteomics is the construction of a suitable protein sequence database to interpret the highly complex metaproteomic data, especially in the absence of metagenomic sequencing data. Herein, we present a high-abundance protein-guided hybrid spectral library strategy for in-depth data independent acquisition (DIA) metaproteomic analysis (HAPs-hyblibDIA). A dedicated high-abundance protein database of gut microbial species is constructed and used to mine the taxonomic information on microbiota samples. Then, a sample-specific protein sequence database is built based on the taxonomic information using Uniprot protein sequence for subsequent analysis of the DIA data using hybrid spectral library-based DIA analysis. We evaluated the accuracy and sensitivity of the method using synthetic microbial community samples and human gut microbiome samples. It was demonstrated that the strategy can successfully identify taxonomic compositions of microbiota samples and that the peptides identified by HAPs-hyblibDIA overlapped greatly with the peptides identified using a metagenomic sequencing-derived database. At the peptide and species level, our results can serve as a complement to the results obtained using a metagenomic sequencing-derived database. Furthermore, we validated the applicability of the HAPs-hyblibDIA strategy in a cohort of human gut microbiota samples of colorectal cancer patients and controls, highlighting its usability in biomedical research.

NovoLign: metaproteomics by sequence alignment

Tremendous advances in mass spectrometric and bioinformatic approaches have expanded proteomics into the field of microbial ecology. The commonly used spectral annotation method for metaproteomics data relies on database searching, which requires sample-specific databases obtained from whole metagenome sequencing experiments. However, creating these databases is complex, time-consuming, and prone to errors, potentially biasing experimental outcomes and conclusions. This asks for alternative approaches that can provide rapid and orthogonal insights into metaproteomics data. Here, we present NovoLign, a de novo metaproteomics pipeline that performs sequence alignment of de novo sequences from complete metaproteomics experiments. The pipeline enables rapid taxonomic profiling of complex communities and evaluates the taxonomic coverage of metaproteomics outcomes obtained from database searches. Furthermore, the NovoLign pipeline supports the creation of reference sequence databases for database searching to ensure comprehensive coverage. We assessed the NovoLign pipeline for taxonomic coverage and false positive annotations using a wide range of in silico and experimental data, including pure reference strains, laboratory enrichment cultures, synthetic communities, and environmental microbial communities. In summary, we present NovoLign, a de novo metaproteomics pipeline that employs large-scale sequence alignment to enable rapid taxonomic profiling, evaluation of database searching outcomes, and the creation of reference sequence databases. The NovoLign pipeline is publicly available via: https://github.com/hbckleikamp/NovoLign.

GroEL-Proteotyping of Bacterial Communities Using Tandem Mass Spectrometry

Profiling bacterial populations in mixed communities is a common task in microbiology. Sequencing of 16S small subunit ribosomal-RNA (16S rRNA) gene amplicons is a widely accepted and functional approach but relies on amplification primers and cannot quantify isotope incorporation. Tandem mass spectrometry proteotyping is an effective alternative for taxonomically profiling microorganisms. We suggest that targeted proteotyping approaches can complement traditional population analyses. Therefore, we describe an approach to assess bacterial community compositions at the family level using the taxonomic marker protein GroEL, which is ubiquitously found in bacteria, except a few obligate intracellular species. We refer to our method as GroEL-proteotyping. GroEL-proteotyping is based on high-resolution tandem mass spectrometry of GroEL peptides and identification of GroEL-derived taxa via a Galaxy workflow and a subsequent Python-based analysis script. Its advantage is that it can be performed with a curated and extendable sample-independent database and that GroEL can be pre-separated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) to reduce sample complexity, improving GroEL identification while simultaneously decreasing the instrument time. GroEL-proteotyping was validated by employing it on a comprehensive raw dataset obtained through a metaproteome approach from synthetic microbial communities as well as real human gut samples. Our data show that GroEL-proteotyping enables fast and straightforward profiling of highly abundant taxa in bacterial communities at reasonable taxonomic resolution.

Current progress and critical challenges to overcome in the bioinformatics of mass spectrometry-based metaproteomics

Metaproteomics is a relatively young field that has only been studied for approximately 15 years. Nevertheless, it has the potential to play a key role in disease research by elucidating the mechanisms of communication between the human host and the microbiome. Although it has been useful in developing an understanding of various diseases, its analytical strategies remain limited to the extended application of proteomics. The sequence databases in metaproteomics must be large because of the presence of thousands of species in a typical sample, which causes problems unique to large databases. In this review, we demonstrate the usefulness of metaproteomics in disease research through examples from several studies. Additionally, we discuss the challenges of applying metaproteomics to conventional proteomics analysis methods and introduce studies that may provide clues to the solutions. We also discuss the need for a standard false discovery rate control method for metaproteomics to replace common target-decoy search approaches in proteomics and a method to ensure the reliability of peptide spectrum match.

Metaproteomics to understand how microbiota function: The crystal ball predicts a promising future

In the medical, environmental, and biotechnological fields, microbial communities have attracted much attention due to their roles and numerous possible applications. The study of these communities is challenging due to their diversity and complexity. Innovative methods are needed to identify the taxonomic components of individual microbiota, their changes over time, and to determine how microoorganisms interact and function. Metaproteomics is based on the identification and quantification of proteins, and can potentially provide this full picture. Due to the wide molecular panorama and functional insights it provides, metaproteomics is gaining momentum in microbiome and holobiont research. Its full potential should be unleashed in the coming years with progress in speed and cost of analyses. In this exploratory crystal ball exercise, I discuss the technical and conceptual advances in metaproteomics that I expect to drive innovative research over the next few years in microbiology. I also debate the concepts of 'microbial dark matter' and 'Metaproteomics-Assembled Proteomes (MAPs)' and present some long-term prospects for metaproteomics in clinical diagnostics and personalized medicine, environmental monitoring, agriculture, and biotechnology.

Quick and wide-range taxonomical repertoire establishment of the cystic fibrosis lung microbiota by tandem mass spectrometry on sputum samples

Microorganisms proteotyping by tandem mass spectrometry has been recently shown as a powerful methodology to identify the wide-range taxonomy and biomass of microbiota. Sputum is the recommended specimen for routine microbiological monitoring of Cystic Fibrosis (CF) patients but has been rarely submitted to tandem mass spectrometry-based proteotyping. In this study, we compared the microbial components of spontaneous and induced sputum samples from three cystic fibrosis patients. Although the presence of microbial proteins is much lower than host proteins, we report that the microbiota’s components present in the samples can be identified, as well as host biomarkers and functional insights into the microbiota. No significant difference was found in microorganism abundance between paired spontaneous and induced sputum samples. Microbial proteins linked to resistance, iron uptake, and biofilm-forming ability were observed in sputa independently of the sampling method. This unbiased and enlarged view of the CF microbiome could be highly complementary to culture and relevant for the clinical management of CF patients by improving knowledge about the host-pathogen dynamics and CF pathophysiology.

Microbial Proteins in Stomach Biopsies Associated with Gastritis, Ulcer, and Gastric Cancer

(1) Background: Gastric cancer (GC) is the fourth leading cause of cancer-related deaths worldwide. Helicobacter pylori infection is a major risk factor, but other microbial species may also be involved. In the context of an earlier proteomics study of serum and biopsies of patients with gastroduodenal diseases, we explored here a simplified microbiome in these biopsies (H. pylori, Acinetobacter baumannii, Escherichia coli, Fusobacterium nucleatum, Bacteroides fragilis) on the protein level. (2) Methods: A cohort of 75 patients was divided into groups with respect to the findings of the normal gastric mucosa (NGM) and gastroduodenal disorders such as gastritis, ulcer, and gastric cancer (GC). The H. pylori infection status was determined. The protein expression analysis of the biopsy samples was carried out using high-definition mass spectrometry of the tryptic digest (label-free data-independent quantification and statistical analysis). (3) Results: The total of 304 bacterial protein matches were detected based on two or more peptide hits. Significantly regulated microbial proteins like virulence factor type IV secretion system protein CagE from H. pylori were found with more abundance in gastritis than in GC or NGM. This finding could reflect the increased microbial involvement in mucosa inflammation in line with current hypotheses. Abundant proteins across species were heat shock proteins and elongation factors. (4) Conclusions: Next to the bulk of human proteins, a number of species-specific bacterial proteins were detected in stomach biopsies of patients with gastroduodenal diseases, some of which, like those expressed by the cag pathogenicity island, may provide gateways to disease prevention without antibacterial intervention in order to reduce antibiotic resistance.

A combined test for feature selection on sparse metaproteomics data-an alternative to missing value imputation

One of the difficulties encountered in the statistical analysis of metaproteomics data is the high proportion of missing values, which are usually treated by imputation. Nevertheless, imputation methods are based on restrictive assumptions regarding missingness mechanisms, namely "at random" or "not at random". To circumvent these limitations in the context of feature selection in a multi-class comparison, we propose a univariate selection method that combines a test of association between missingness and classes, and a test for difference of observed intensities between classes. This approach implicitly handles both missingness mechanisms. We performed a quantitative and qualitative comparison of our procedure with imputation-based feature selection methods on two experimental data sets, as well as simulated data with various scenarios regarding the missingness mechanisms and the nature of the difference of expression (differential intensity or differential presence). Whereas we observed similar performances in terms of prediction on the experimental data set, the feature ranking and selection from various imputation-based methods were strongly divergent. We showed that the combined test reaches a compromise by correlating reasonably with other methods, and remains efficient in all simulated scenarios unlike imputation-based feature selection methods.

Modern Metaproteomics: A Unique Tool to Characterize the Active Microbiome in Health and Diseases, and Pave the Road towards New Biomarkers—Example of Crohn’s Disease and Ulcerative Colitis Flare-Ups

Thanks to the latest developments in mass spectrometry, software and standards, metaproteomics is emerging as the vital complement of metagenomics, to make headway in understanding the actual functioning of living and active microbial communities. Modern metaproteomics offers new possibilities in the area of clinical diagnosis. This is illustrated here, for the still highly challenging diagnosis of intestinal bowel diseases (IBDs). Using bottom-up proteomics, we analyzed the gut metaproteomes of the same twenty faecal specimens processed either fresh or after a two-month freezing period. We focused on metaproteomes of microbial cell envelopes since it is an outstanding way of capturing host and host–microbe interaction signals. The protein profiles of pairs of fresh and frozen-thawed samples were closely related, making feasible deferred analysis in a distant diagnosis centre. The taxonomic and functional landscape of microbes in diverse IBD phenotypes—active ulcerative colitis, or active Crohn’s disease either with ileo-colonic or exclusive colonic localization—differed from each other and from the controls. Based on their specific peptides, we could identify proteins that were either strictly overrepresented or underrepresented in all samples of one clinical group compared to all samples of another group, paving the road for promising additional diagnostic tool for IBDs.

An integrated workflow for enhanced taxonomic and functional coverage of the mouse fecal metaproteome

Intestinal microbiota plays a key role in shaping host homeostasis by regulating metabolism, immune responses and behavior. Its dysregulation has been associated with metabolic, immune and neuropsychiatric disorders and is accompanied by changes in bacterial metabolic regulation. Although proteomics is well suited for analysis of individual microbes, metaproteomics of fecal samples is challenging due to the physical structure of the sample, presence of contaminating host proteins and coexistence of hundreds of taxa. Furthermore, there is a lack of consensus regarding preparation of fecal samples, as well as downstream bioinformatic analyses following metaproteomics data acquisition. Here we assess sample preparation and data analysis strategies applied to mouse feces in a typical mass spectrometry-based metaproteomic experiment. We show that subtle changes in sample preparation protocols may influence interpretation of biological findings. Two-step database search strategies led to significant underestimation of false positive protein identifications. Unipept software provided the highest sensitivity and specificity in taxonomic annotation of the identified peptides of unknown origin. Comparison of matching metaproteome and metagenome data revealed a positive correlation between protein and gene abundances. Notably, nearly all functional categories of detected protein groups were differentially abundant in the metaproteome compared to what would be expected from the metagenome, highlighting the need to perform metaproteomics when studying complex microbiome samples.

Inferring early-life host and microbiome functions by mass spectrometry-based metaproteomics and metabolomics

Humans have a long-standing coexistence with microorganisms. In particular, the microbial community that populates the human gastrointestinal tract has emerged as a critical player in governing human health and disease. DNA and RNA sequencing techniques that map taxonomical composition and genomic potential of the gut community have become invaluable for microbiome research. However, deriving a biochemical understanding of how activities of the gut microbiome shape host development and physiology requires an expanded experimental design that goes beyond these approaches. In this review, we explore advances in high-throughput techniques based on liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. These omics methods for the identification of proteins and metabolites have enabled direct characterisation of gut microbiome functions and the crosstalk with the host. We discuss current metaproteomics and metabolomics workflows for producing functional profiles, the existing methodological challenges and limitations, and recent studies utilising these techniques with a special focus on early life gut microbiome.