Metabolic Footprinting of a Clear Cell Renal Cell Carcinoma in Vitro Model for Human Kidney Cancer Detection

Untargeted metabolomic profiling of small extracellular vesicles reveals potential new biomarkers for triple negative breast cancer

INTRODUCTION

Breast Cancer (BC) is one of the most diagnosed malignancies among women and the second leading cause of cancer related death in North America. Triple Negative BC (TNBC), one of the most severe subtypes of BC, is extremely aggressive and has a higher chance of occurrence in women under 50 years of age. Due to a lack of regular mammographic testing in women under 50, many individuals with TNBC are diagnosed late which can decrease their survival rate. Currently, liquid biopsy is being investigated as a potentially less-invasive alternative to traditional breast tissue biopsy, but this approach is not completely reliable. Blood contains extracellular vesicles (EVs), which carry biomolecular cargo and play a role in BC progression and metastasis. Examination of small EVs could potentially yield metabolite biomarkers for early BC diagnosis.

OBJECTIVE

We aim to study metabolites in small EVs to find biomarkers for BC diagnosis.

METHODS

In this work, an untargeted nano-LC MS/MS metabolomics approach was used to analyze metabolites from small EVs derived from metastatic MDA-MB-231 and compare it with a non-cancerous MCF10A cell line.

RESULTS

Two metabolites, LysoPC 22:6/0:0 and N-acetyl-L-Phenylalanine, unique to sEVs of MDA-MB-231, were identified, validated, and proposed as potential BC biomarkers.

CONCLUSION

Metabolites from sEVs may be used for BC diagnosis.

Metabolomics for searching validated biomarkers in cancer studies: a decade in review

INTRODUCTION

In the dynamic landscape of modern healthcare, the ability to anticipate and diagnose diseases, particularly in cases where early treatment significantly impacts outcomes, is paramount. Cancer, a complex and heterogeneous disease, underscores the critical importance of early diagnosis for patient survival. The integration of metabolomics information has emerged as a crucial tool, complementing the genotype-phenotype landscape and providing insights into active metabolic mechanisms and disease-induced dysregulated pathways.

AREAS COVERED

This review explores a decade of developments in the search for biomarkers validated within the realm of cancer studies. By critically assessing a diverse array of research articles, clinical trials, and studies, this review aims to present an overview of the methodologies employed and the progress achieved in identifying and validating biomarkers in metabolomics results for various cancer types.

EXPERT OPINION

Through an exploration of more than 800 studies, this review has allowed to establish a general idea about state-of-art in the search of biomarkers in metabolomics studies involving cancer which include certain level of results validation. The potential for metabolites as diagnostic markers to reach the clinic and make a real difference in patient health is substantial, but challenges remain to be explored.

A systematic review of biobanks in Latin America: Strengths and limitations for biomedical research

Biobanks are valuable tools for developing and applying scientific research and international cooperation through the collection of biological materials and their associated data. Systematic research following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis guidelines was conducted in late 2022 in PubMed and Scopus, and generated 17 articles to be reviewed in depth and critically assessed using the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme Checklist due to the limited available data; 12 relevant health organizations and government websites outside of peer-reviewed journals were also included. Our research identified 44 biobanks in Latin America. In general, there is a lack of regulation and legislation guaranteeing the stored materials' quality and institutional collaboration. We believe a consensus needs to be reached regarding the terminology and definitions used for biobanks. The design for informed consent should also be agreed upon to ensure the privacy of the data shared among institutions. In conclusion, in Latin America, there is a clear need for government support in creating specific procedures for biobanks and providing further support for existing biobanks.

Six categories of amino acid derivatives with potential taste contributions: a review of studies on soy sauce

During the fermentation of soy sauce, the metabolism of microorganisms and the Maillard reaction produce a wide variety of metabolites that contribute to the unique and rich flavor characteristics of soy sauce, such as amino acids, organic acids and peptides. Amino acid derivatives, a relatively new taste compounds, formed by the reaction of enzymes or non-enzymes from sugars, amino acids, and organic acids released through metabolism by microorganisms during soy sauce fermentation, have begun to gain more and more attention in recent years. This review focused on our existing knowledge of the sources, taste characteristics and synthesis methods of the 6 categories of amino acid derivatives, including Amadori compounds, γ-glutamyl peptides, pyroglutamyl amino acids, N-lactoyl amino acids, N-acetyl amino acids and N-succinyl amino acids. Sixty-four amino acid derivatives were detected in soy sauce, of which 47 were confirmed to have potential contribution to the taste of soy sauce, especially umami and kokumi, and some of them also have the effect of reducing bitterness. Furthermore, some amino acid derivatives, like γ-glutamyl peptides and N-lactoyl amino acids, were found to be synthesized enzymatically in vitro, which laid the foundation for further study on their formation pathways in the future.

Microbiome and metabolic features of tissues and feces reveal diagnostic biomarkers for colorectal cancer

Microbiome and their metabolites are increasingly being recognized for their role in colorectal cancer (CRC) carcinogenesis. Towards revealing new CRC biomarkers, we compared 16S rRNA gene sequencing and liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) metabolite analyses in 10 CRC (TCRC) and normal paired tissues (THC) along with 10 matched fecal samples (FCRC) and 10 healthy controls (FHC). The highest microbial phyla abundance from THC and TCRC were Firmicutes, while the dominant phyla from FHC and FCRC were Bacteroidetes, with 72 different microbial genera identified among four groups. No changes in Chao1 indices were detected between tissues or between fecal samples whereas non-metric multidimensional scaling (NMDS) analysis showed distinctive clusters among fecal samples but not tissues. LEfSe analyses indicated Caulobacterales and Brevundimonas were higher in THC than in TCRC, while Burkholderialese, Sutterellaceaed, Tannerellaceaea, and Bacteroidaceae were higher in FHC than in FCRC. Microbial association networks indicated some genera had substantially different correlations. Tissue and fecal analyses indicated lipids and lipid-like molecules were the most abundant metabolites detected in fecal samples. Moreover, partial least squares discriminant analysis (PLS-DA) based on metabolic profiles showed distinct clusters for CRC and normal samples with a total of 102 differential metabolites between THC and TCRC groups and 700 metabolites different between FHC and FCRC groups. However, only Myristic acid was detected amongst all four groups. Highly significant positive correlations were recorded between genus-level microbiome and metabolomics data in tissue and feces. And several metabolites were associated with paired microbes, suggesting a strong microbiota-metabolome coupling, indicating also that part of the CRC metabolomic signature was attributable to microbes. Suggesting utility as potential biomarkers, most such microbiome and metabolites showed directionally consistent changes in CRC patients. Nevertheless, further studies are needed to increase sample sizes towards verifying these findings.

Postoperative Metabolic Phenoreversion in Clear Cell Renal Cell Carcinoma

The ultimate goal of surgical treatment in cancer is to remove the tumor mass for restoring a healthy state. A 16-lipid panel that discriminated healthy controls from clear cell renal cell carcinoma (ccRCC) patients in a prior study was evaluated in the present work in paired-serum samples collected from patients (n = 41) before and after nephrectomy. Changes in the lipid and metabolite fingerprints from ccRCC patients were investigated and compared with fingerprints from healthy individuals obtained by means of ultra-performance liquid chromatography-high-resolution mass spectrometry. The lipid panel differentiated phenotypes associated with metabolic restoration after surgery, representing a serum signature of phenoreversion to a healthy metabolic state. In particular, PC 16:0/0:0, PC 18:2/18:2, and linoleic acid allowed discriminating serum samples from ccRCC patients with poor prognosis from those with an improved outcome during the follow-up period. Ratios of PC 16:0/0:0 and PC 18:2/18:2 with linoleic acid levels may contribute as prognostic tools to support decision-making during the patient follow-up care. The preliminary character of these results should be validated with larger cohorts, including subjects with different ethnicities, life style, and diets. MetaboLights study references: MTBLS1839, MTBLS3838, and MTBLS4629.

Exploring Metabolic Signatures of Ex Vivo Tumor Tissue Cultures for Prediction of Chemosensitivity in Ovarian Cancer

Simple Summary

Women diagnosed with ovarian cancer have 5-year survival rates below 45%. Prediction of patient’s outcome and the onset of drug resistance are still major challenges. The patient’s drug response is influenced by the environment that surrounds the tumor cells. We previously showed that patient-derived tumor tissue can be kept in the lab, alive and retaining aspects of that environment. In this study, we exposed tumor tissue derived from ovarian cancer patients to the chemotherapy patients receive and identified metabolites released by the tumor tissue after treatment (metabolic footprint). Using machine learning, we uncovered metabolic signatures that discriminate tumor tissues with higher vs. lower drug sensitivity. We propose potential biomarkers involved in the production of specific building blocks of cells and energy generation processes. Overall, we established a platform to explore metabolic features of the complex environment of each patient’s tumor that can underpin the discovery of biomarkers of drug response.

Abstract

Predicting patient response to treatment and the onset of chemoresistance are still major challenges in oncology. Chemoresistance is deeply influenced by the complex cellular interactions occurring within the tumor microenvironment (TME), including metabolic crosstalk. We have previously shown that ex vivo tumor tissue cultures derived from ovarian carcinoma (OvC) resections retain the TME components for at least four weeks of culture and implemented assays for assessment of drug response. Here, we explored ex vivo patient-derived tumor tissue cultures to uncover metabolic signatures of chemosensitivity and/or resistance. Tissue cultures derived from nine OvC cases were challenged with carboplatin and paclitaxel, the standard-of-care chemotherapeutics, and the metabolic footprints were characterized by LC-MS. Partial least-squares discriminant analysis (PLS-DA) revealed metabolic signatures that discriminated high-responder from low-responder tissue cultures to ex vivo drug exposure. As a proof-of-concept, a set of potential metabolic biomarkers of drug response was identified based on the receiver operating characteristics (ROC) curve, comprising amino acids, fatty acids, pyrimidine, glutathione, and TCA cycle pathways. Overall, this work establishes an analytical and computational platform to explore metabolic features of the TME associated with response to treatment, which can leverage the discovery of biomarkers of drug response and resistance in OvC.

Comparative metabolite fingerprinting of chia, flax and sesame seeds using LC-MS untargeted metabolomics

Chia, flax, and sesame seeds are well known for their nutritional quality and are commonly included in bakery products. So far, the development of methods to verify their presence and authenticity in foods is a requisite and a raised need. In this work we applied untargeted metabolomics to propose authenticity markers. Seeds were analyzed by HPLC-MS/MS and 9938 features in negative mode and 9044 in positive mode were obtained by Mzmine. After isotopes grouping, alignment, gap-filling, filtering adducts, and normalization, PCA was applied to explore the dataset and recognize pre-existent classification patterns. OPLS-DA analysis and S-Plots were used as supervised methods. Twenty-five molecules (12 in negative mode and 13 in positive mode) were selected as discriminant for the three seeds, polyphenols and lignans were identified among them. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first approach using non-target HPLC-MS/MS for the authentication of chia, flax and sesame seeds.

Endogenous formaldehyde scavenges cellular glutathione resulting in redox disruption and cytotoxicity

Formaldehyde (FA) is a ubiquitous endogenous and environmental metabolite that is thought to exert cytotoxicity through DNA and DNA-protein crosslinking, likely contributing to the onset of the human DNA repair condition Fanconi Anaemia. Mutations in the genes coding for FA detoxifying enzymes underlie a human inherited bone marrow failure syndrome (IBMFS), even in the presence of functional DNA repair, raising the question of whether FA causes relevant cellular damage beyond genotoxicity. Here, we report that FA triggers cellular redox imbalance in human cells and in Caenorhabditis elegans. Mechanistically, FA reacts with the redox-active thiol group of glutathione (GSH), altering the GSH:GSSG ratio and causing oxidative stress. FA cytotoxicity is prevented by the enzyme alcohol dehydrogenase 5 (ADH5/GSNOR), which metabolizes FA-GSH products, lastly yielding reduced GSH. Furthermore, we show that GSH synthesis protects human cells from FA, indicating an active role of GSH in preventing FA toxicity. These findings might be relevant for patients carrying mutations in FA-detoxification systems and could suggest therapeutic benefits from thiol-rich antioxidants like N-acetyl-L-cysteine.

Tuning the coordination properties of chiral pseudopeptide bis(2-picolyl)amine and iminodiacetamide ligands in Zn(ii) and Cu(ii) complexes

Modifications of the chiral side chains of bpa and imda ligands lead to different metal ion coordination and hydrogen bonding ability.

Metabolomics Profiling of Cystic Renal Disease towards Biomarker Discovery

Simple Summary

Cystic renal disease (CRD) is a group of diseases characterized by abnormal sacs, or cysts, in the kidneys. CRD can be detected using certain imaging modalities (i.e., ultrasound). Patients with CRD might be symptoms-free, while others can show symptoms long after cysts development. Although these cysts represent structural changes, we hypothesized that they have an underlying biochemical alteration. If so, this would open the floor for potential biomarker discovery, which would aid in CRD diagnosis and, possibly, treatment. On that basis, this study focuses on identifying biomarkers for CRD. To achieve that, we employed a metabolomics-based approach to identify intermediate molecules inside the cells that are byproducts of biochemical reactions. We used dry blood spots and serum samples of CRD patients and healthy controls to study the differences in their metabolomic profile. Our results suggest that certain metabolites, including uridine diphosphate, cystine-5-diphosphate, and morpholine, are potential biomarkers for CRD. The affected biochemical pathways in CRD include aminoacyl-tRNA biosynthesis, purine, pyrimidine, glutathione, TCA cycle, and some amino acid metabolism. These preliminary results could be the starting point for possible diagnostic and therapeutic approaches for CRD in the future.

Abstract

Cystic renal disease (CRD) comprises a heterogeneous group of genetic and acquired disorders. The cystic lesions are detected through imaging, either incidentally or after symptoms develop, due to an underlying disease process. In this study, we aim to study the metabolomic profiles of CRD patients for potential disease-specific biomarkers using unlabeled and labeled metabolomics using low and high-resolution mass spectrometry (MS), respectively. Dried-blood spot (DBS) and serum samples, collected from CRD patients and healthy controls, were analyzed using the unlabeled and labeled method. The metabolomics profiles for both sets of samples and groups were collected, and their data were processed using the lab’s standard protocol. The univariate analysis showed (FDR p < 0.05 and fold change 2) was significant to show a group of potential biomarkers for CRD discovery, including uridine diphosphate, cystine-5-diphosphate, and morpholine. Several pathways were involved in CRD patients based on the metabolic profile, including aminoacyl-tRNA biosynthesis, purine and pyrimidine, glutathione, TCA cycle, and some amino acid metabolism (alanine, aspartate and glutamate, arginine and tryptophan), which have the most impact. In conclusion, early CRD detection and treatment is possible using a metabolomics approach that targets alanine, aspartate, and glutamate pathway metabolites.

Genome-Scale Metabolic Modeling of the Human Microbiome in the Era of Personalized Medicine

The human microbiome plays an important role in human health and disease. Meta-omics analyses provide indispensable data for linking changes in microbiome composition and function to disease etiology. Yet, the lack of a mechanistic understanding of, e.g., microbiome-metabolome links hampers the translation of these findings into effective, novel therapeutics. Here, we propose metabolic modeling of microbial communities through constraint-based reconstruction and analysis (COBRA) as a complementary approach to meta-omics analyses. First, we highlight the importance of microbial metabolism in cardiometabolic diseases, inflammatory bowel disease, colorectal cancer, Alzheimer disease, and Parkinson disease. Next, we demonstrate that microbial community modeling can stratify patients and controls, mechanistically link microbes with fecal metabolites altered in disease, and identify host pathways affected by the microbiome. Finally, we outline our vision for COBRA modeling combined with meta-omics analyses and multivariate statistical analyses to inform and guide clinical trials, yield testable hypotheses, and ultimately propose novel dietary and therapeutic interventions. Expected final online publication date for the Annual Review of Microbiology, Volume 75 is October 2021. Please see http://www.annualreviews.org/page/journal/pubdates for revised estimates.

Development of a prototype device for near real-time surface-enhanced Raman scattering monitoring of biological samples

With the fast growth of bioanalytical surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS), analytical methods have had to adapt to the complex nature of biological samples. In particular, interfering species and protein adsorption onto the SERS substrates have been addressed by sample preparation steps, such as precipitation or extraction, and by smart SERS substrate functionalisation. These additional handling steps however result in irreversible sample alteration, which in turn prevents sample monitoring over time. A new methodology, that enables near real-time, non-invasive and non-destructive SERS monitoring of biological samples, is therefore proposed. It combines solid SERS substrates, benefitting from liquid immersion resistance for extended periods of time, with an original protein filtering device and an on-field detection by means of a handheld Raman analyser. The protein removal device aims at avoiding protein surface fouling on the SERS substrate. It consists of an ultracentrifugation membrane fixed under a cell culture insert for multi-well plates. The inside of the insert is dedicated to containing biological samples. The solid SERS substrate and a simple medium, without any protein, are placed under the insert. By carefully selecting the membrane molecular weight cutoff, selective diffusion of small analytes through the device could be achieved whereas larger proteins were retained inside the insert. Non-invasive SERS spectral acquisition was then carried out through the bottom of the multi-well plate. The diffusion of a SERS probe, 2-mercaptopyridine, and of a neurotransmitter having a less intense SERS signal, serotonin, were first successfully monitored with the device. Then, the latter was applied to distinguish between subclones of cancerous cells through differences in metabolite production. This promising methodology showed a high level of versatility, together with the capability to reduce cellular stress and contamination hazards.

Coupled Mass-Spectrometry-Based Lipidomics Machine Learning Approach for Early Detection of Clear Cell Renal Cell Carcinoma

A discovery-based lipid profiling study of serum samples from a cohort that included patients with clear cell renal cell carcinoma (ccRCC) stages I, II, III, and IV (n = 112) and controls (n = 52) was performed using ultraperformance liquid chromatography coupled to quadrupole-time-of-flight mass spectrometry and machine learning techniques. Multivariate models based on support vector machines and the LASSO variable selection method yielded two discriminant lipid panels for ccRCC detection and early diagnosis. A 16-lipid panel allowed discriminating ccRCC patients from controls with 95.7% accuracy in a training set under cross-validation and 77.1% accuracy in an independent test set. A second model trained to discriminate early (I and II) from late (III and IV) stage ccRCC yielded a panel of 26 compounds that classified stage I patients from an independent test set with 82.1% accuracy. Thirteen species, including cholic acid, undecylenic acid, lauric acid, LPC(16:0/0:0), and PC(18:2/18:2), identified with level 1 exhibited significantly lower levels in samples from ccRCC patients compared to controls. Moreover, 3α-hydroxy-5α-androstan-17-one 3-sulfate, cis-5-dodecenoic acid, arachidonic acid, cis-13-docosenoic acid, PI(16:0/18:1), PC(16:0/18:2), and PC(O-16:0/20:4) contributed to discriminate early from late ccRCC stage patients. The results are auspicious for early ccRCC diagnosis after validation of the panels in larger and different cohorts.

Mass Spectrometry-Based Metabolic Fingerprinting Contributes to Unveil the Role of RSUME in Renal Cell Carcinoma Cell Metabolism

Clear cell renal cell carcinoma (ccRCC) is a heterogeneous disease with 50-80% patients exhibiting mutations in the von Hippel-Lindau (VHL) gene. RSUME (RWD domain (termed after three major RWD-containing proteins: RING finger-containing proteins, WD-repeat-containing proteins, and yeast DEAD (DEXD)-like helicases)-containing protein small ubiquitin-related modifier (SUMO) enhancer) acts as a negative regulator of VHL function in normoxia. A discovery-based metabolomics approach was developed by means of ultraperformance liquid chromatography coupled to quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MS) for fingerprinting the endometabolome of a human ccRCC cell line 786-O and three other transformed cell systems (n = 102) with different expressions of RSUME and VHL. Cross-validated orthogonal projection to latent structures discriminant analysis models were built on positive, negative, and a combination of positive- and negative-ion mode MS data sets. Discriminant feature panels selected by an iterative multivariate classification allowed differentiating cells with different expressions of RSUME and VHL. Fifteen identified discriminant metabolites with level 1, including glutathione, butyrylcarnitine, and acetylcarnitine, contributed to understand the role of RSUME in ccRCC. Altered pathways associated with the RSUME expression were validated by biological and bioinformatics analyses. Combined results showed that in the absence of VHL, RSUME is involved in the downregulation of the antioxidant defense system, whereas in the presence of VHL, it acts in rerouting energy-related pathways, negatively modulating the lipid utilization, and positively modulating the fatty acid synthesis, which may promote deposition in droplets.

Liquid Biopsies in Renal Cell Carcinoma-Recent Advances and Promising New Technologies for the Early Detection of Metastatic Disease

Clear cell renal cell carcinoma (ccRCC) displays a highly varying clinical progression, from slow growing localized tumors to very aggressive metastatic disease (mRCC). Almost a third of all patients with ccRCC show metastatic dissemination at presentation while another third develop metastasis during the course of the disease. Survival rates of mRCC patients remain low despite the development of novel targeted treatment regimens. Biomarkers indicating disease progression could help to define its aggressive potential and thus guide patient management. However, molecular markers that can reliably assess metastatic dissemination and disease recurrence in ccRCC have not been recommended for clinical practice to date. Liquid biopsies could provide an attractive and non-invasive method to determine the risk of recurrence or metastatic dissemination during follow-up and thus assist the search for surveillance biomarkers in ccRCC tumors. A wide spectrum of circulating molecules have already shown considerable potential for ccRCC diagnosis and prognostication. In this review, we outline state of the art of the key circulating analytes such as cfDNA, cfRNA, proteins, and exosomes that may serve as biomarkers for the longitudinal monitoring of ccRCC progression to metastasis. Moreover, we address some of the prevailing limitations in the past approaches and present promising adoptable technologies that could help to pursue the implementation of liquid biopsies as a prognostic tool for mRCC.

Beyond glycolysis: Hypoxia signaling as a master regulator of alternative metabolic pathways and the implications in clear cell renal cell carcinoma

The relationship between kidney cancer, specifically clear cell renal cell carcinoma (ccRCC), and the hypoxia signaling program has been extensively characterized. Its underlying role as the primary driver of the disease has led to the development of the most effective targeted therapies to date. Cellular responses to hypoxia or mutations affecting the von Hippel-Lindau (VHL) tumor suppressor gene stabilize the hypoxia inducible factor (HIF) transcription factors which then orchestrate elaborate downstream signaling events resulting in adaptations to key biological processes, such as reprogramming metabolism. The direct link of hypoxia signaling to glucose uptake and glycolysis has long been appreciated; however, the HIF family of proteins directly regulate many downstream targets, including other transcription factors with their own extensive networks. In this review, we will summarize our current understanding of how hypoxia signaling regulates other metabolic pathways and how this contributes to the development and progression of clear cell renal cell carcinomas.

Evaluation of MDA-MB-468 Cell Culture Media Analysis in Predicting Triple-Negative Breast Cancer Patient Sera Metabolic Profiles

Triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC) is characterized by limited survival, poor prognosis, and high recurrence. Understanding the metabolic adaptations of TNBC could help reveal improved treatment regiments. Here we performed a comprehensive ¹H NMR metabolic characterization of the MDA-MB-468 cell line, a commonly used model of TNBC, followed by an analysis of serum samples obtained from TNBC patients and healthy controls. MDA-MB-468 cells were cultured, and changes in the metabolic composition of the medium were monitored for 72 h. Based on time courses, metabolites were categorized as being consumed, being produced, or showing a mixed behavior. When comparing TNBC and control samples (HC), and by using multivariate and univariate analyses, we identified nine metabolites with differing profiles). The serum of TNBC patients was characterized by higher levels of glucose, glutamine, citrate, and acetoacetate and by lower levels of lactate, alanine, tyrosine, glutamate, and acetone. A comparative analysis between MDA-MB-468 cell culture media and TNBC patients' serum identified a potential systemic response to the carcinogenesis-associated processes, highlighting that MDA-MB-468 cells footprint does not reflect metabolic changes observed in studied TNBC serum fingerprint.

Improving diagnosis of genitourinary cancers: Biomarker discovery strategies through mass spectrometry-based metabolomics

The genitourinary oncology field needs integration of results from basic science, epidemiological studies, clinical and translational research to improve the current methods for diagnosis. MS-based metabolomics can be transformative for disease diagnosis and contribute to global health parity. Metabolite panels are promising to translate metabolomic findings into the clinics, changing the current diagnosis paradigm based on single biomarker analysis. This review article describes capabilities of the MS-based oncometabolomics field for improving kidney, prostate, and bladder cancer detection, early diagnosis, risk stratification, and outcome. Published works are critically discussed based on the study design; type and number of samples analyzed; data quality assessment through quality assurance and quality control practices; data analysis workflows; confidence levels reported for identified metabolites; validation attempts; the overlap of discriminant metabolites for the different genitourinary cancers; and the translation capability of findings into clinical settings. Ongoing challenges are discussed, and future directions are delineated.