Paracellular Gatekeeping: What Does It Take for an Ion to Pass Through a Tight Junction Pore?

Effect of claudin-1 or -3 expression on cation and water channel properties of claudin-2

Claudin-2 (Cldn2) is a typical tight junction protein of leaky epithelia that forms paracellular channels for small cations and water. Claudin-3 (Cldn3) and claudin-1 (Cldn1) are barrier formers and may interact with Cldn2. We aimed to investigate whether this interaction affects the permeability of Cldn2 channels to ions and/or water. To achieve this, two knockout kidney cell lines (MDCK C7/Cldn3KO and MDCK II/quinKO) were used to express Cldn2 and Cldn2/Cldn3. Furthermore, MDCK II/quinKO/Cldn2/Cldn1 cells were generated for comparison. Electrophysiological assays were performed to evaluate the function and properties of Cldn2 channels in these cell models. Cis- and trans-interaction of Cldn2 with Cldn1 or Cldn3 was assessed in MDCK II/quinKO cells by FRET and enrichment assays, respectively. At the tight junction, Cldn2 had a closer cis-proximity to Cldn1 than to Cldn3, but a stronger trans-interaction with the latter. In comparison to cells expressing Cldn2 alone, co-expression with Cldn3 (in both cell models) or Cldn1 (in MDCK II/quinKO cells) resulted in lower cation permeabilities without altering the Eisenman sequences. Other than ion permeability, water flux showed no differences between MDCK C7/Cldn3KO cells expressing Cldn2 and those co-expressing Cldn2/Cldn3. Based on these results, we propose a model in which Cldn2-Cldn1 cis- and Cldn2-Cldn3 trans-interaction leads to a mixture of homo-oligomeric Cldn2 and hetero-oligomeric Cldn2/Cldn1 or Cldn2/Cldn3 channels. The latter would have a pore center where charges are neutralized, by this impairing cation permeability while still allowing water to pass.

A claudin5-binding peptide enhances the permeability of the blood-brain barrier in vitro

The blood-brain barrier (BBB) maintains brain homeostasis but also prevents most drugs from entering the brain. No paracellular diffusion of solutes is allowed because of tight junctions that are made impermeable by the expression of claudin5 (CLDN5) by brain endothelial cells. The possibility of regulating the BBB permeability in a transient and reversible fashion is in strong demand for the pharmacological treatment of brain diseases. Here, we designed and tested short BBB-active peptides, derived from the CLDN5 extracellular domains and the CLDN5-binding domain of Clostridium perfringens enterotoxin, using a robust workflow of structural modeling and in vitro validation techniques. Computational analysis at the atom level based on solubility and affinity to CLDN5 identified a CLDN5-derived peptide not reported previously called f1-C5C2, which was soluble in biological media, displayed efficient binding to CLDN5, and transiently increased BBB permeability. The peptidomimetic strategy described here may have potential applications in the pharmacological treatment of brain diseases.

Ion and water permeation through claudin-10b and claudin-15 paracellular channels

The structural scaffold of epithelial and endothelial tight junctions (TJs) comprises multimeric strands of claudin (Cldn) proteins that anchor adjacent cells and control the paracellular flux of water and solutes. Based on the permeability properties they confer to the TJs, Cldns are classified as channel- or barrier-forming. For instance, Cldn10b, expressed in kidneys, lungs, and other tissues, displays high permeability for cations and low permeability for water. Along with its high sequence similarity to the cation- and water-permeable TJ protein Cldn15, this makes Cldn10b a valuable test case for investigating the molecular determinants of paracellular transport. In lack of high-resolution experimental information on TJ architectures, here we use molecular dynamics simulations to determine whether atomistic models recapitulate the differences in ion and water transport between of Cldn10b and Cldn15. Our data, based on extensive standard simulations and free energy calculations, reveal that Cldn10b models form cation-permeable pores narrower than Cldn15, which, together with the stable coordination of Na+ ions to acidic pore-lining residues (E153, D36, D56), limit the passage of water molecules. By providing a mechanism driving a peculiar case of paracellular transport, these results provide a structural basis for the specific permeability properties of Cldn subtypes that define their physiological role.

Biophysics of claudin proteins in tight junction architecture: Three decades of progress

Tight junctions are cell-cell adhesion complexes that act as gatekeepers of the paracellular space. Formed by several transmembrane proteins, the claudin family performs the primary gate-keeping function. The claudin proteins form charge and size-selective diffusion barriers to maintain homeostasis across endothelial and epithelial tissue. Of the 27 known claudins in mammals, some are known to seal the paracellular space, while others provide selective permeability. The differences in permeability arise due to the varying expression levels of claudins in each tissue. The tight junctions are observed as strands in freeze-fracture electron monographs; however, at the molecular level, tight junction strands form when multiple claudin proteins assemble laterally (cis assembly) within a cell and head-on (trans assembly) with claudins of the adjacent cell in a zipper-like architecture, closing the gap between the neighboring cells. The disruption of tight junctions caused by changing claudin expression levels or mutations can lead to diseases. Therefore, knowledge of the molecular architecture of the tight junctions and how that is tied to tissue-specific function is critical for fighting diseases. Here, we review the current understanding of the tight junctions accrued over the last three decades from experimental and computational biophysics perspectives.

An Affordable Topography-Based Protocol for Assigning a Residue's Character on a Hydropathy (PARCH) Scale

The hydropathy of proteins or quantitative assessment of protein-water interactions has been a topic of interest for decades. Most hydropathy scales use a residue-based or atom-based approach to assign fixed numerical values to the 20 amino acids and categorize them as hydrophilic, hydroneutral, or hydrophobic. These scales overlook the protein's nanoscale topography, such as bumps, crevices, cavities, clefts, pockets, and channels, in calculating the hydropathy of the residues. Some recent studies have included protein topography in determining hydrophobic patches on protein surfaces, but these methods do not provide a hydropathy scale. To overcome the limitations in the existing methods, we have developed a Protocol for Assigning a Residue's Character on the Hydropathy (PARCH) scale that adopts a holistic approach to assigning the hydropathy of a residue. The parch scale evaluates the collective response of the water molecules in the protein's first hydration shell to increasing temperatures. We performed the parch analysis of a set of well-studied proteins that include the following─enzymes, immune proteins, and integral membrane proteins, as well as fungal and virus capsid proteins. Since the parch scale evaluates every residue based on its location, a residue may have very different parch values inside a crevice versus a surface bump. Thus, a residue can have a range of parch values (or hydropathies) dictated by the local geometry. The parch scale calculations are computationally inexpensive and can compare hydropathies of different proteins. The parch analysis can affordably and reliably aid in designing nanostructured surfaces, identifying hydrophilic and hydrophobic patches, and drug discovery.

The impact of pathogenic and artificial mutations on Claudin-5 selectivity from molecular dynamics simulations

Tight-junctions (TJs) are multi-protein complexes between adjacent endothelial or epithelial cells. In the blood-brain-barrier (BBB), they seal the paracellular space and the Claudin-5 (Cldn5) protein forms their backbone. Despite the fundamental role in brain homeostasis, little is known on Cldn5-based TJ assemblies. Different structural models were suggested, with Cldn5 protomers generating paracellular pores that restrict the passage of ions and small molecules. Recently, the first Cldn5 pathogenic mutation, G60R, was identified and shown to induce Cl^--selective channels and Na⁺ barriers in BBB TJs, providing an excellent opportunity to validate the structural models. Here, we used molecular dynamics to study the permeation of ions and water through two distinct G60R-Cldn5 paracellular architectures. Only the so-called Pore I reproduces the functional modification observed in experiments, displaying a free energy (FE) minimum for Cl^- and a barrier for Na⁺ consistent with anionic selectivity. We also studied the artificial Q57D and Q63D mutations in the constriction region, Q57 being conserved in Cldns except for cation permeable homologs. In both cases, we obtain FE profiles consistent with facilitated passage of cations. Our calculations provide the first in-silico description of a Cldn5 pathogenic mutation, further assessing the TJ Pore I model and yielding new insight on BBB's paracellular selectivity.

Computational study of ion permeation through claudin-4 paracellular channels

Claudins (Cldns) form a large family of protein homologs that are essential for the assembly of paracellular tight junctions (TJs), where they form channels or barriers with tissue-specific selectivity for permeants. In contrast to several family members whose physiological role has been identified, the function of claudin 4 (Cldn4) remains elusive, despite experimental evidence suggesting that it can form anion-selective TJ channels in the renal epithelium. Computational approaches have recently been employed to elucidate the molecular basis of Cldns' function, and hence could help in clarifying the role of Cldn4. In this work, we use structural modeling and all-atom molecular dynamics simulations to transfer two previously introduced structural models of Cldn-based paracellular complexes to Cldn4 to reproduce a paracellular anion channel. Free energy calculations for ionic transport through the pores allow us to establish the thermodynamic properties driving the ion-selectivity of the structures. While one model shows a cavity permeable to chloride and repulsive to cations, the other forms barrier to the passage of all the major physiological ions. Furthermore, our results confirm the charge selectivity role of the residue Lys65 in the first extracellular loop of the protein, rationalizing Cldn4 control of paracellular permeability.

Computational Assessment of Different Structural Models for Claudin-5 Complexes in Blood-Brain Barrier Tight Junctions

The blood-brain barrier (BBB) strictly regulates the exchange of ions and molecules between the blood and the central nervous system. Tight junctions (TJs) are multimeric structures that control the transport through the paracellular spaces between the adjacent brain endothelial cells of the BBB. Claudin-5 (Cldn5) proteins are essential for TJ formation and assemble into multiprotein complexes via cis-interactions within the same cell membrane and trans-interactions across two contiguous cells. Despite the relevant biological function of Cldn5 proteins and their role as targets of brain drug delivery strategies, the molecular details of their assembly within TJs are still unclear. Two different structural models have been recently introduced, in which Cldn5 dimers belonging to opposite cells join to generate paracellular pores. However, a comparison of these models in terms of ionic transport features is still lacking. In this work, we used molecular dynamics simulations and free energy (FE) calculations to assess the two Cldn5 pore models and investigate the thermodynamic properties of water and physiological ions permeating through them. Despite different FE profiles, both structures present single/multiple FE barriers to ionic permeation, while being permissive to water flux. These results reveal that both models are compatible with the physiological role of Cldn5 TJ strands. By identifying the protein-protein surface at the core of TJ Cldn5 assemblies, our computational investigation provides a basis for the rational design of synthetic peptides and other molecules capable of opening paracellular pores in the BBB.