Variable-Temperature NMR Analysis of the Thermodynamics of Polymer Partitioning between Aqueous and Drug-Rich Phases and Its Significance for Amorphous Formulations

Quantitative Analysis of Drug Supersaturation Region by Temperature-Variable Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Measurements, Part 2: Effects of Solubilizer

This study utilized temperature-variable nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy to investigate the effects of a solubilizing agent on the ketoprofen (KTP) supersaturation region. Quantitative NMR analysis showed that the solubilizing agent cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) increased both the crystalline and amorphous solubilities of KTP, shifting the KTP supersaturation region to a higher KTP concentration range. The amorphous solubility of KTP was found to be independent of the enantiomeric composition of KTP, even in the presence of CTAB. However, the supersaturation region of the S-enantiomer of KTP (s-KTP) in CTAB solutions was smaller than that of the racemic form of KTP (rac-KTP), likely because of the higher crystalline solubility of s-KTP. When KTP formed a KTP-rich phase via liquid-liquid phase separation from KTP-supersaturated solutions, CTAB was observed to be distributed into the KTP-rich phase, decreasing the chemical potential of KTP and the maximum thermodynamic activity of KTP in the aqueous phase. Additionally, the incorporation of CTAB into the KTP-rich phase diminished the solubilization effect of CTAB micelles in the aqueous phase, narrowing the KTP supersaturation region to a greater extent at higher KTP dose concentrations. Furthermore, the upper-temperature limit of the supersaturated dissolvable region of KTP was lowered in the presence of CTAB, which was rationalized by the melting point depression of the KTP crystal upon mixing with CTAB. The findings of this study highlight the importance of considering the molecular-level impact of solubilizing agents on the drug supersaturation region to fully exploit the potential benefits of supersaturated formulations.

Quantitative Analysis of Drug Supersaturation Region by Temperature-Variable Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Measurements, Part 1: Effects of Polymer and Drug Chiralities

We examined the effects of the polymer-additive and drug chiralities on the ketoprofen (KTP) supersaturation region using temperature-variable nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). Quantitative NMR analysis revealed that the racemic KTP and corresponding S-enantiomer (rac- and s-KTP) exhibited similar amorphous solubilities in a buffer, while the crystalline solubility of s-KTP was higher than that of rac-KTP. Therefore, rac-KTP exhibited a larger supersaturation region than s-KTP. In contrast, polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) reduced the amorphous solubility of both rac- and s-KTP, whereas the crystalline solubility of KTP remained unchanged. Partitioning PVP into the KTP-rich phase reduced the chemical potential of KTP in the KTP-rich phase and the amorphous solubility of KTP. At higher temperatures, the distribution of PVP into the KTP-rich phase became more significant, which considerably reduced the amorphous solubility. Because the upper limit of the KTP supersaturation decreased, PVP narrowed the KTP supersaturation region. The maximum KTP supersaturation ratio decreased with increasing temperature, and the supersaturated dissolvable area of KTP finally disappeared. The maximum temperature at which KTP can form the supersaturation was lowered by replacing rac- with s-KTP and the addition of PVP. The maximum supersaturation temperature was dominated by the melting behavior of crystalline KTP in an aqueous solution. The present study highlighted that a quantitative understanding of the supersaturation region is essential to determine whether supersaturated formulations are beneficial for improving the oral absorption of poorly water-soluble drugs.

Dissolution Mechanisms of Amorphous Solid Dispersions: Role of Drug Load and Molecular Interactions

High drug load amorphous solid dispersions (ASDs) have been a challenge to formulate partially because drug release is inhibited at high drug loads. The maximum drug load prior to inhibition of release has been termed the limit of congruency (LoC) and has been most widely studied for copovidone (PVPVA)-based ASDs. The terminology was derived from the observation that below LoC, the polymer controlled the kinetics and the drug and the polymer released congruently, while above LoC, the release rates diverged and were impaired. Recent studies show a correlation between the LoC value and drug-polymer interaction strength, where a lower LoC was observed for systems with stronger interactions. The aim of this study was to investigate the causality between drug-PVPVA interaction strength and LoC. Four chemical analogues with diverse abilities to interact with PVPVA were used as model drugs. The distribution of the polymer between the dilute aqueous phase and the insoluble nanoparticles containing drug was studied with solution nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and traditional separation techniques to understand the thermodynamics of the systems in a dilute environment. Polymer diffusion to and from ASD particles suspended in aqueous solution was monitored for drug loads above the LoC to investigate the thermodynamic driving force for polymer release. The surface composition of ASD compacts before and after exposure to buffer was studied with Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy to capture potential kinetic barriers to release. It was found that ASD compacts with drug loads above the LoC formed an insoluble barrier on the surface that was in pseudo-equilibrium with the aqueous phase and prevented further release of drugs and polymers during dissolution. The insoluble barrier contained a substantial amount of the polymer for the strongly interacting drug-polymer systems. In contrast, a negligible amount was found for the weakly interacting systems. This observation provides an explanation for the ability of strongly interacting systems to form an insoluble barrier at lower drug loads. The study highlights the importance of thermodynamic and kinetic factors on the dissolution behavior of ASDs and provides a potential framework for maximizing the drug load in ASDs.

Unusual Correlation between the Apparent Amorphous Solubility of a Drug and Solubilizer Concentration Revealed by NMR Analysis

Herein, we investigated the effect of the solubilizers, cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) and amino methacrylate copolymer (Eudragit E PO, EUD-E), on the apparent amorphous solubility of ketoprofen (KTP) and free KTP concentrations in an aqueous phase when a KTP-rich phase was generated by liquid-liquid phase separation. Quantitative analysis by solution nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) revealed that the apparent amorphous solubility of KTP increased with increasing EUD-E concentrations by the solubilization of KTP into the EUD-E micelles; this was reminiscent of the improvement in the apparent crystalline solubility of KTP observed when EUD-E was added. In contrast, the apparent amorphous solubility of KTP decreased with increasing CTAB concentrations, although the solubilizing ability of CTAB was stronger than that of EUD-E when the KTP-rich phase was absent. NMR analysis revealed that CTAB was distributed into the KTP-rich phase to a relatively large extent. This resulted in a significant reduction of the chemical potential of KTP in the KTP-rich phase in the CTAB solution. Thus, the maximum free KTP concentration in the aqueous phase was reduced more significantly in the CTAB solution than in the EUD-E solution. Moreover, the solubilization effect of KTP by the CTAB micelles in the aqueous phase was drastically diminished due to the distribution of CTAB into the KTP-rich phase. As a result, the apparent amorphous solubility of KTP reached a minimum at a CTAB concentration of 200 μg/mL. A further increase in the CTAB concentration resulted in an improvement in the apparent amorphous solubility of KTP due to the solubilization effect of CTAB remaining in the aqueous phase. The present study highlights the impact of solubilizer selection on the apparent amorphous solubility and attainable supersaturation of the drug, which should be considered during the development of supersaturating formulations to obtain preferable oral absorption.