Synthesis of Cysteine-Rich Peptides by Native Chemical Ligation without Use of Exogenous Thiols

Advances in the chemical synthesis of human proteoforms

Access to structurally-defined human proteoforms is essential to the biochemical studies on human health and medicine. Chemical protein synthesis provides a bottom-up and atomic-resolution approach for the preparation of homogeneous proteoforms bearing any number of post-translational modifications of any structure, at any position, and in any combination. In this review, we summarize the development of chemical protein synthesis, focusing on the recent advances in synthetic methods, product characterizations, and biomedical applications. By analyzing the chemical protein synthesis studies on human proteoforms reported to date, this review demonstrates the significant methodological improvements that have taken place in the field of human proteoform synthesis, especially in the last decade. Our analysis shows that although further method development is needed, all the human proteoforms could be within reach in a cost-effective manner through a divide-and-conquer chemical protein synthesis strategy. The synthetic proteoforms have been increasingly used to support biomedical research, including spatial-temporal studies and interaction network analysis, activity quantification and mechanism elucidation, and the development and evaluation of diagnostics and therapeutics.

Design, Synthesis and Catalytic Activity of Protein Containing Thiotyrosine as an Active Site Residue

Native chemical ligation is a key reaction in the toolbox of chemical methods for the synthesis of native and modified proteins. The catalysis of ligation is commonly performed by using small aryl-thiol molecules added at high concentrations. In this work, we incorporated thiotyrosine, a non-canonical amino acid containing an aryl-thiol moiety, into a designed cyclic protein « sans queue ni tête ». Importantly, the protein environment reduced the pKa of the thiol group to 5.8-5.9, which is significantly lower than the previously reported value for thiotyrosine in a short peptide (pKa 6.4). Furthermore, we demonstrated the catalytic activity of this protein both as hydrolase and in native chemical ligation of peptides. These results will be useful for the development of efficient protein catalysts (enzymes) for protein synthesis and modification.

Deciphering the Synthetic and Refolding Strategy of a Cysteine-Rich Domain in the Tumor Necrosis Factor Receptor (TNF-R) for Racemic Crystallography Analysis and d-Peptide Ligand Discovery

Many cell-surface receptors are promising targets for chemical synthesis because of their critical roles in disease development. This synthetic approach enables investigations by racemic protein crystallography and ligand discovery by mirror-image methodologies. However, due to their complex nature, the chemical synthesis of a receptor can be a significant challenge. Here, we describe the chemical synthesis and folding of a central, cysteine-rich domain of the cell-surface receptor tumor necrosis factor 1 which is integral to binding of the cytokine TNF-α, namely, TNFR-1 CRD2. Racemic protein crystallography at 1.4 Å confirmed that the native binding conformation was preserved, and TNFR-1 CRD2 maintained its capacity to bind to TNF-α (KD ≈ 7 nM). Encouraged by this discovery, we carried out mirror-image phage display using the enantiomeric receptor mimic and identified a d-peptide ligand for TNFR-1 CRD2 (KD = 1 μM). This work demonstrated that cysteine-rich domains, including the central domains, can be chemically synthesized and used as mimics for investigations.

Förster Resonance Energy Transfer Assay for Investigating the Reactivity of Thioesters in Biochemistry and Native Chemical Ligation

Thioesters are considered to be "energy-rich" functional groups that are susceptible to attack by thiolate and amine nucleophiles while remaining hydrolytically stable at neutral pH, which enables thioester chemistry to take place in an aqueous medium. Thus, the inherent reactivity of thioesters enables their fundamental roles in biology and unique applications in chemical synthesis. Here, we investigate the reactivity of thioesters that mimic acyl-coenzyme A (CoA) species and S-acylcysteine modifications as well as aryl thioesters applied in chemical protein synthesis by native chemical ligation (NCL). We developed a fluorogenic assay format for the direct and continuous investigation of the rate of reaction between thioesters and nucleophiles (hydroxide, thiolate, and amines) under various conditions and were able to recapitulate previously reported reactivity of thioesters. Further, chromatography-based analyses of acetyl- and succinyl-CoA mimics revealed striking differences in their ability to acylate lysine side chains, providing insight into nonenzymatic protein acylation. Finally, we investigated key aspects of native chemical ligation reaction conditions. Our data revealed a profound effect of the tris-(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine (TCEP) commonly used in systems where thiol-thioester exchange occurs, including a potentially harmful hydrolysis side reaction. These data provide insight into the potential optimization of native chemical ligation chemistry.

Pedal to the Metal: The Homogeneous Catalysis of the Native Chemical Ligation Reaction

The native chemical ligation reaction of peptide thioesters with cysteinyl peptides is a pivotal chemical process in the production of native or modified peptides and proteins, and well beyond in the preparation of various biomolecule analogs and materials. To benefit from this reaction at its fullest and to access all the possible applications, the experimentalist needs to know the factors affecting its rate and how to control it. This concept article presents the fundamental principles underlying the rate of the native chemical ligation and its homogeneous catalysis by nucleophiles. It has been prepared to serve as a quick guide in the search for an appropriate catalyst.

Late-stage macrolactonisation enabled by tandem acyl transfers followed by desulphurisation

Intramolecular S-acylation of a thiol-installed threonine with a thioester unit, followed by S-O acyl transfer and subsequent desulphurisation, allows the synthesis of lactone peptides. A protocol has been developed enabling the cyclisation of a linear peptide, a reaction which has not been achieved by conventional methods.

Cysteine protecting groups: applications in peptide and protein science

Protecting group chemistry for the cysteine thiol group has enabled a vast array of peptide and protein chemistry over the last several decades. Increasingly sophisticated strategies for the protection, and subsequent deprotection, of cysteine have been developed, facilitating synthesis of complex disulfide-rich peptides, semisynthesis of proteins, and peptide/protein labelling in vitro and in vivo. In this review, we analyse and discuss the 60+ individual protecting groups reported for cysteine, highlighting their applications in peptide synthesis and protein science.

Toward Activatable Collagen Mimics: Combining DEPSI "Switch" Defects and Template-Guided Self-Organization to Control Collagen Mimetic Peptides

Collagen mimetic peptides (CMPs), which imitate various structural or functional features of natural collagen, constitute advanced models illuminating the folding aspects of the collagen triple helix (CTH) motif. In this study, the CMPs of repeating Gly-Pro-Pro (GPP) triplets are tethered to an organic scaffold based on a tris(2-aminoethyl) amine (TREN) derivative (TREN(sucOH)₃ ). These three templated peptide strands are further expanded via native chemical ligation to increase the number of GPP triplets and lead to a TREN(sucGPPGPPG(Ψ)SPGPPCPP[GPP]₄ )₃ construct. The incorporation of an ester switch segment, G(Ψ)S, as a positional O-acyl isopeptide (DEPSI) defect into the peptide strands allows the pH-controlled acceleration of CTH formation. The strand assembly process is monitored by circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy. The results of pH jump experiments and thermal denaturation studies provide new insights into the contributions of structural DEPSI defects to the template-guided self-assembly of the CTH motif. While the organic scaffold drives the CTH formation, the switch defects act as temporary opponents and slow down the folding. CD spectroscopy data confirm that the switch defects contribute to the formation of a more stable CTH motif by enhancing the structural dynamics at the early stage of the folding process.

Synthetic peptides to produce antivenoms against the Cys-rich toxins of arachnids

Scorpion and spider envenomation is treated with the appropriate antivenoms, prepared as described by Césaire Auguste Phisalix and Albert Calmette in 1894. Such treatment requires the acquisition and manipulation of arachnid venoms, both very complicated procedures. Most of the toxins in the venoms of spiders and scorpions are extremely stable cysteine-rich peptide neurotoxins. Many strategies have been developed to obtain synthetic immunogens to facilitate the production of antivenoms against these toxins. For example, whole peptide toxins can be synthesized by solid-phase peptide synthesis (SPPS). Also, epitopes of the toxins can be identified and after the chemical synthesis of these peptide epitopes by SPPS, they can be coupled to protein carriers to develop efficient immunogens. Moreover, multiple antigenic peptides with a polylysine core can be designed and synthesized. This review focuses on the strategies developed to obtain synthetic immunogens for the production of antivenoms against the toxic Cys-rich peptides of scorpions and spiders.

Transformation of Thioester-Initiated Star Polymers into Linear Arms via Native Chemical Ligation

The synthesis of a new class of Cu-mediated polymerization initiators with thioester functionality is demonstrated and their polymerization kinetics via single-electron transfer living radical polymerization is reported. From periodic sampling, it is found that thioester- or ester-based initiators can be employed interchangeably, resulting in very similar polymerization rates. Furthermore, a multifunctional thioester initiator is employed for the preparation of a well-defined four-arm star-shaped polymer. It is further shown that the full dissociation of the star polymer into linear arms via native chemical ligation can easily be followed via size exclusion chromatography, as a result of the change in hydrodynamic volume. Finally, the obtained linear polymers are characterized via matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight mass spectrometry and found to be in good agreement with the expected molecular weight distribution that confirms the successful transformation.

Identification of autoinducing thiodepsipeptides from staphylococci enabled by native chemical ligation

Staphylococci secrete autoinducing peptides (AIPs) as signalling molecules to regulate population-wide behaviour. AIPs from non-Staphylococcus aureus staphylococci have received attention as potential antivirulence agents to inhibit quorum sensing and virulence gene expression in the human pathogen Staphylococcus aureus. However, only a limited number of AIP structures from non-S. aureus staphylococci have been identified to date, as the minute amounts secreted in complex media render it difficult. Here, we report a method for the identification of AIPs by exploiting their thiolactone functionality for chemoselective trapping and enrichment of the compounds from the bacterial supernatant. Standard liquid chromatography mass spectrometry analysis, guided by genome sequencing data, then readily provides the AIP identities. Using this approach, we confirm the identity of five known AIPs and identify the AIPs of eleven non-S. aureus species, and we expect that the method should be extendable to AIP-expressing Gram-positive bacteria beyond the Staphylococcus genus.

Traceless β-mercaptan-assisted activation of valinyl benzimidazolinones in peptide ligations

Peptidyl thioesters or their surrogates with C-terminal β-branched hydrophobic amino acid residues usually exhibit poor reactivities in ligation reactions. Thus, activation using exogenous additives is required to ensure an acceptable reaction efficiency. Herein, we report a traceless ligation at Val-Xaa sites under mild thiol additive-free reaction conditions, whereby the introduction of β-mercaptan on the C-terminal valine residue effectively activates the otherwise unreactive N-acyl-benzimidazolinone (Nbz), and enables the use of a one-pot ligation-desulfurization strategy to generate the desired peptide products. The orthogonality between β-thiovaline-Nbz and a conventional alkyl thioester, as well as the convenient access to the former from readily available penicillamine, also allowed expedited assembly of the peptidic hormone β-LPH and hPTH analogues, based on a kinetically controlled one-pot three-segment ligation and desulfurization strategy.

Coupling of sterically demanding peptides by β-thiolactone-mediated native chemical ligation

The ligation of sterically demanding peptidyl sites such as those involving Val-Val and Val-Pro linkages has proven to be extremely challenging with conventional NCL methods that rely on exogenous thiol additives. Herein, we report an efficient β-thiolactone-mediated additive-free NCL protocol that enables the establishment of these connections in good yield. The rapid NCL was followed by in situ desulfurization. Reaction rates between β-thiolactones and conventional thioesters towards NCL were also investigated, and direct aminolysis was ruled out as a possible pathway. Finally, the potent cytotoxic cyclic-peptide axinastatin 1 has been prepared using the developed methodology.

New potent and selective αvβ3 integrin ligands: Macrocyclic peptides containing RGD motif synthesized by sortase A-mediated ligation

Three 14-mer macrocyclic peptides 1-3 containing mono-, di- and tri-RGD structure motif were designed and synthesized by sortase A-mediated ligation in good yields. The results of in intro cell-based biological assays indicated that linear peptide 5 and macrocyclic peptide 1, containing di-RGD and mono-RGD motif respectively, showed remarkable potency and selectivity to α_vβ₃ integrin.

1,2,4-Triazole-aided native chemical ligation between peptide-N-acyl-N′-methyl-benzimidazolinone and cysteinyl peptide

Novel thiol-additive-free NCL using easy-to-prepare peptide-MeNbz and 1,2,4-triazole can be readily combined with one-pot desulfurization and Cys-modification.

N-Sulfanylethylaminooxybutyramide (SEAoxy): A Crypto-Thioester Compatible with Fmoc Solid-Phase Peptide Synthesis

An N-sulfanylethylaminooxybutyramide (SEAoxy) has been developed as a novel thioester equivalent for native chemical ligation. SEAoxy peptide was straightforwardly synthesized by conventional Fmoc solid-phase peptide synthesis without a problem. Moreover, SEAoxy peptide could be directly applied to native chemical ligation owing to the intramolecular N-to-S acyl shift that releases the peptide-thioester in situ. This methodology was successfully applied to the synthesis of two bioactive peptides.

Nonclassical Routes for Amide Bond Formation

The present review offers an overview of nonclassical (e.g., with no pre- or in situ activation of a carboxylic acid partner) approaches for the construction of amide bonds. The review aims to comprehensively discuss relevant work, which was mainly done in the field in the last 20 years. Organization of the data follows a subdivision according to substrate classes: catalytic direct formation of amides from carboxylic and amines ( section 2 ); the use of carboxylic acid surrogates ( section 3 ); and the use of amine surrogates ( section 4 ). The ligation strategies (NCL, Staudinger, KAHA, KATs, etc.) that could involve both carboxylic acid and amine surrogates are treated separately in section 5 .

Removal of the 5-nitro-2-pyridine-sulfenyl protecting group from selenocysteine and cysteine by ascorbolysis

We previously reported on a method for the facile removal of 4-methoxybenzyl and acetamidomethyl protecting groups from cysteine (Cys) and selenocysteine (Sec) using 2,2'-dithiobis-5-nitropyridine dissolved in trifluoroacetic acid, with or without thioanisole. The use of this reaction mixture removes the protecting group and replaces it with a 2-thio(5-nitropyridyl) (5-Npys) group. This results in either a mixed selenosulfide bond or disulfide bond (depending on the use of Sec or Cys), which can subsequently be reduced by thiolysis. A major disadvantage of thiolysis is that excess thiol must be used to drive the reaction to completion and then removed before using the Cys-containing or Sec-containing peptide in further applications. Here, we report a further advancement of this method as we have found that ascorbate at pH 4.5 and 25 °C will reduce the selenosulfide to the selenol. Ascorbolysis of the mixed disulfide between Cys and 5-Npys is much less efficient but can be accomplished at higher concentrations of ascorbate at pH 7 and 37 °C with extended reaction times. We envision that our improved method will allow for in situ reactions with alkylating agents and electrophiles without the need for further purification, as well as a number of other applications. Copyright © 2016 European Peptide Society and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.