Revealing the Influence of Doping and Surface Treatment on the Surface Carrier Dynamics in Hematite Nanorod Photoanodes

Quantitative Analysis of the Synergy of Doping and Nanostructuring of Oxide Photocatalysts

In this paper, the effect of doping and nanostructuring on the electrostatic potential across the electrochemical interface between a transition metal oxide and a water electrolyte is investigated by means of the Poisson-Boltzmann model. For spherical nanoparticles and nanorods, compact expressions for the limiting potentials at which the space charge layer includes the whole semiconductor are reported. We provide a quantitative analysis of the distribution of the potential drop between the solid and the liquid and show that the relative importance changes with doping. It is usually assumed that high doping improves charge dynamics in the semiconductor but reduces the width of the space charge layer. However, nanostructuring counterbalances the latter negative effect; we show quantitatively that in highly doped nanoparticles the space charge layer can occupy a similar volume fraction as in low-doped microparticles. Moreover, as shown by some recent experiments, under conditions of high doping the electric fields in the Helmholtz layer can be as high as 100 mV/Å, comparable to electric fields inducing freezing in water. This work provides a systematic quantitative framework for understanding the effects of doping and nanostructuring on electrochemical interfaces, and suggests that it is necessary to better characterize the interface at the atomistic level.

Low Catalyst Loading Enhances Charge Accumulation for Photoelectrochemical Water Splitting

Solar water oxidation is a critical step in artificial photosynthesis. Successful completion of the process requires four holes and releases four protons. It depends on the consecutive accumulation of charges at the active site. While recent research has shown an obvious dependence of the reaction kinetics on the hole concentrations on the surface of heterogeneous (photo)electrodes, little is known about how the catalyst density impacts the reaction rate. Using atomically dispersed Ir catalysts on hematite, we report a study on how the interplay between the catalyst density and the surface hole concentration influences the reaction kinetics. At low photon flux, where surface hole concentrations are low, faster charge transfer was observed on photoelectrodes with low catalyst density compared to high catalyst density; at high photon flux and high applied potentials, where surface hole concentrations are moderate or high, slower surface charge recombination was afforded by low-density catalysts. The results support that charge transfer between the light absorber and the catalyst is reversible; they reveal the unexpected benefits of low-density catalyst loading in facilitating forward charge transfer for desired chemical reactions. It is implied that for practical solar water splitting devices, a suitable catalyst loading is important for maximized performance.

Insight into the Light-Driven Hydrogen Production over Pure and Rh-Doped Rutile in the Presence of Ascorbic Acid: Impact of Interfacial Chemistry on Photocatalysts

The surface states of a semiconductor photocatalyst are essential for interfacial charge transfer in heterogeneous photocatalytic reactions. Here, we report that the light-driven hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) activity of 0.5 mol % Rh-doped rutile increases by more than 30 times compared with that of rutile when ascorbic acid is used as a sacrificial agent. Intensity-modulated photocurrent spectroscopy and surface photovoltage spectroscopy are employed to reveal the impact of surface states on the photo-oxidation reactions. It is found that the adsorption of ascorbic acid molecules dramatically reduces the activity of rutile due to coverage of the HER-active Ti sites. Nevertheless, for Rh-doped rutile, ascorbic acid neutralizes the Rh(IV) sites that would otherwise cause severe recombination of electron-hole pairs and resurrects its photocatalytic performance. This work demonstrates the key role of interfacial chemistry in photocatalytic reactions and provides a strategy for excavating the potential of various photocatalysts.

Photophysical and photoelectrochemical properties of CsPbBr3 films grown by an electrochemically assisted deposition

Perovskite have had a great impact on the solid-state physics world in the last decade not only achieving great success in photovoltaics but, more recently, also in the implementation of other optoelectronic devices. One of the main obstacles for the adoption of Pb-based perovskite technologies are the high amounts of Pb needed in the conventional preparation methods. Here we present for the first time a detailed analysis of the photophysical and photoelectrochemical properties of CsPbBr3 films directly grown on FTO coated glass through a novel technique based in the electrodeposition of PbO2 as CsPbBr3 precursor. This technique allows to save up to 90 % of the Pb used compared to traditional methods and can be scalable compared with the commonly used spin-coating process. The low temperature analysis of their photoluminescence spectra, performed in both steady state and time dependence, revealed a strong interaction between electrons and longitudinal optical phonons dominant at high temperatures. On the other hand, the electrochemical and photoelectrochemical analysis proves that CsPbBr3 prepared using this new method has state-of-the-art features, showing a p-type behavior under depletion regime. This is also confirmed by photoelectrochemical measurements using p-benzoquinone as target molecule. These results prove that the proposed method can be used to produce excellent CsPbBr3 films, saving much of the lead waste.

Identifying Water Oxidation Mechanisms at Pure and Titanium-Doped Hematite-Based Photoanodes with Spectroelectrochemistry

Investigation of the mechanism of the water oxidation reaction for hematite photoanodes has been one of the most persistently pursued topics in the course of understanding photoelectrochemical water splitting by transition metal oxides. Unfortunately, existing experimental techniques often require over-simplified models and theories that assume only one reaction path. In this work, however, it is proposed that water oxidation on hematite can proceed via mixed reaction paths according to spectroelectrochemical results without a priori assumptions. The true absorption signals of surface states responsible for water oxidation are isolated from subsidiary signals for undoped and Ti-doped hematite and contrasted with those of inactive species. The evolution of absorption signals as a function of applied potential and illumination intensity highlights the non-negligible contribution of direct hole transfer, especially for highly doped hematite.

Promoting superoxide generation in Bi2WO6 by less electronegative substitution for enhanced photocatalytic performance: an example of Te doping

Doping with elements with lower electronegativity, like Te, shifts the band potentials of Bi2WO6 to the point that superoxide radical generation is feasible. As a result, an optimum of 2.5 at% Te doping improves the activity of Bi2WO6 by 48 times.

Photosensitive Thin Films Based on Drop Cast and Langmuir-Blodgett Hydrophilic and Hydrophobic CdS Nanoparticles

Comparative photoelectrochemical studies of cadmium sulfide (CdS) nanoparticles with either hydrophilic or hydrophobic surface properties are presented. Oleylamine organic shells provided CdS nanoparticles with hydrophobic behavior, affecting the photoelectrochemical properties of such nanostructured semiconductor. Hydrophilic CdS nanoparticles were drop-cast on the electrode, whereas the hydrophobic ones were transferred in a controlled manner with Langmuir-Blodgett technique. The substantial hindrance of photopotential and photocurrent was observed for L-B CdS films as compared to the hydrophilic, uncoated nanoparticles that were drop-cast directly on the electrode surface. The electron lifetime in both hydrophilic and hydrophobic nanocrystalline CdS was determined, revealing longer carrier lifetime for oleylamine coated CdS nanoparticles, ascribed to the trapping of charge at the interface of the organic shell/CdS nanoparticle and to the dominant influence of the resistance of the organic shell against the flux of charges. The “on” transients of the photocurrent responses, observed only for the oleylamine-coated nanoparticles, were resolved, yielding the potential-dependent rate constants of the redox processes occurring at the interface.

The role of carbon dots - derived underlayer in hematite photoanodes

Hematite is a promising candidate as photoanode for solar-driven water splitting, with a theoretically predicted maximum solar-to-hydrogen conversion efficiency of ∼16%. However, the interfacial charge transfer and recombination greatly limits its activity for photoelectrochemical water splitting. Carbon dots exhibit great potential in photoelectrochemical water splitting for solar to hydrogen conversion as photosensitisers and co-catalysts. Here we developed a novel carbon underlayer from low-cost and environmental-friendly carbon dots through a facile hydrothermal process, introduced between the fluorine-doped tin oxide conducting substrate and hematite photoanodes. This led to a remarkable enhancement in the photocurrent density. Owing to the triple functional role of carbon dots underlayer in improving the interfacial properties of FTO/hematite and providing carbon source for the overlayer as well as the change in the iron oxidation state, the bulk and interfacial charge transfer dynamics of hematite are significantly enhanced, and consequently led to a remarkable enhancement in the photocurrent density. The results revealed a substantial improvement in the charge transfer rate, yielding a charge transfer efficiency of up to 80% at 1.25 V vs. RHE. In addition, a significant enhancement in the lifetime of photogenerated electrons and an increased carrier density were observed for the hematite photoanodes modified with a carbon underlayer, confirming that the use of sustainable carbon nanomaterials is an effective strategy to boost the photoelectrochemical performance of semiconductors for energy conversion.

Impact of the Synthesis Route on the Water Oxidation Kinetics of Hematite Photoanodes

Operando spectroelectrochemical analysis is used to determine the water oxidation reaction kinetics for hematite photoanodes prepared using four different synthetic procedures. While these photoanodes exhibit very different current/voltage performance, their underlying water oxidation kinetics are found to be almost invariant. Higher temperature thermal annealing was found to correlate with a shift in the photocurrent onset potential toward less positive potentials, assigned to a suppression of both back electron-hole recombination and of charge accumulation in intra-bandgap states, indicating these intra-bandgap states do not contribute directly to water oxidation.

Highly active deficient ternary sulfide photoanode for photoelectrochemical water splitting

The exploration of photoanode materials with high efficiency and stability is the eternal pursuit for the realization of practically solar-driven photoelectrochemical (PEC) water splitting. Here we develop a deficient ternary metal sulfide (CdIn2S4) photoanode, and its PEC performance is significantly enhanced by introducing surface sulfur vacancies, achieving a photocurrent density of 5.73 mA cm-2 at 1.23 V vs. RHE and 1 Sun with an applied bias photon-to-current efficiency of 2.49% at 0.477 V vs. RHE. The experimental characterizations and theoretical calculations highlight the enhanced effect of surface sulfur vacancies on the interfacial charge separation and transfer kinetics, which also demonstrate the restrained surface states distribution and the transformation of active sites after introducing surface sulfur vacancies. This work may inspire more excellent work on developing sulfide-based photoanodes.

Understanding the enhanced photoelectrochemical water oxidation over Ti-doped α-Fe2O3 electrodes by electrochemical reduction pretreatment

Water splitting using semiconductor photoelectrodes is a promising approach to solar hydrogen production. Previous studies have well-demonstrated that electrochemical reduction (ER) pretreatment of bare and Ti-doped α-Fe2O3 electrodes enhances water photooxidation efficiencies, however, the mechanism underlying this improvement remains poorly understood. In this study, this was quantitatively investigated by multiple photoelectrochemical techniques and transient absorption spectroscopy, using the doped electrodes as examples. The results reveal that the kinetics of photoholes after moving to the electrode surface can be well described by a model of surface-state mediated charge transfer and recombination. The reason for the photocurrent enhancement is attributed to a significantly increased charge transfer rate constant (kct) and a decreased surface recombination rate constant (ksr) by ER. The reason for the accelerated kct is that a new type of surface state, with a favorable energy position for water oxidation, is produced. The decreased ksr is due to the reduced electron density at the surface of the semiconductor, resulted predominately from the negatively shifted flat band potential. These findings provide new insights into the mechanism of water photooxidation and enlighten a simple way to develop more efficient electrodes.

Self-improvement of solar water oxidation for the continuously-irradiated hematite photoanode

Improving bulk- or surface-properties has been found as an effective route to regulate and enhance the photoelectrochemical (PEC) performances of some metal-oxide photoelectrodes. However, both bulk and surface self-improvement resulting from the photocharging (PC) effect is rarely reported and as a result the underlying mechanism of the PC effect is not fully understood. Here, we demonstrate that the hematite photoanode integrated with Sn doping and a TiO2 underlayer shows a substantial increase in the photocurrent density (i.e., from 0.69 to 1.12 mA cm-2 at 1.23 V relative to the standard hydrogen electrode) and a cathodic shift of the onset potential after being irradiated by a one-sun simulator for 12 h. The primary reasons for these can be categorized into two fundamental factors: (1) the enhanced bulk conductivity and the resulting decrease in carrier bulk recombination from the gradually increasing ratio of Fe2+ and Fe3+; (2) the reduced carrier surface recombination from the photogenerated passivation layer. Ultimately, both the bulk and surface electrical properties of the hematite photoanode are substantially self-improved under continuous irradiation. This work deepens the understanding of the PC effect and proves that it is a promising technique for the PEC-performance enhancement of the hematite photoanode.

Regulating the Silicon/Hematite Microwire Photoanode by the Conformal Al2O3 Intermediate Layer for Water Splitting

Dual-absorber photoelectrodes have been proved to possess greater potential than the single-absorber systems in the applications of photoelectrochemical (PEC) cells (e.g., solar-driven water splitting); however, the mismatching of the energy bands and substantial carrier recombinations at the two absorber interfaces are normally subsistent. Here, we introduce an intermediate layer of conformal Al₂O₃ into the silicon/hematite (Si/α-Fe₂O₃) microwire photoanode for enriching the understanding of the interaction among the interlayer, inner absorber, and outer absorber. Our results show that the Si/Al₂O₃/α-Fe₂O₃ microwire photoanode with the thickness-optimized Al₂O₃ can lead to a substantial increase in the photocurrent from 0.83 to 2.08 mA/cm² at 1.23 V_RHE (under 1 sun irradiation) and an obvious decrease in the onset potential relative to the counterpart without Al₂O₃. By analyzing the PEC responses under various monochromatic lights, PEC impedance spectroscopy, and intensity-modulated photocurrent spectroscopy, we ascribe the improvements to the fact that the suitable-thickness Al₂O₃ can passivate the Si microwire surfaces and the bottom surfaces of the α-Fe₂O₃ film and give rise to Al doping into the post-synthesized α-Fe₂O₃. These essential causes promote the carrier separation in α-Fe₂O₃, diminish the photoanode surface recombination rate, and then increase the surface charge-transfer efficiency.

Effect of Surface Ionization of Doped MnO2 on Capacitive Deionization Efficiency

Associating MnO₂ with carbonaceous supports profoundly enhances capacitive deionization (CDI) efficiency. A fundamental question of how the surface chemistry of MnO₂ itself influences CDI efficiency is not yet fully understood. In this study, the effect of surface ionization on the CDI efficiencies of Fe-, Co-, and Ni-doped α-MnO₂ (<0.1 mol %) as a model cathode material was studied. A pattern that CDI efficiency decreased with increasing negative surface charge density resulting from surface deprotonation was noted. This is likely attributed to the appreciable co-ion expulsion occurring at a highly ionized surface in the mesopores of MnO₂. It is thus concluded that the combination of surface charge modification and a microporous environment would be important for CDI efficiency enhancement by minimizing co-ion exclusion effect. In the former case, structural stress adjustment by doping elements would be a practical route to regulate the p K_a1 and p K_a2 values and consequently the degree of surface ionization of MnO₂.

2D Porous TiO2 Single-Crystalline Nanostructure Demonstrating High Photo-Electrochemical Water Splitting Performance

Porous single crystals are promising candidates for solar fuel production owing to their long range charge diffusion length, structural coherence, and sufficient reactive sites. Here, a simple template-free method of growing a selectively branched, 2D anatase TiO₂ porous single crystalline nanostructure (PSN) on fluorine-doped tin oxide substrate is demonstrated. An innovative ion exchange-induced pore-forming process is designed to successfully create high porosity in the single-crystalline nanostructure with retention of excellent charge mobility and no detriment to crystal structure. PSN TiO₂ film delivers a photocurrent of 1.02 mA cm^-2 at a very low potential of 0.4 V versus reversible hydrogen electrode (RHE) for photo-electrochemical water splitting, closing to the theoretical value of TiO₂ (1.12 mA cm^-2 ). Moreover, the current-potential curve featuring a small potential window from 0.1 to 0.4 V versus RHE under one-sun illumination has a near-ideal shape predicted by the Gartner Model, revealing that the charge separation and surface reaction on the PSN TiO₂ photoanode are very efficient. The photo-electrochemical water splitting performance of the films indicates that the ion exchange-assisted synthesis strategy is effective in creating large surface area and single-crystalline porous photoelectrodes for efficient solar energy conversion.