Membrane Dynamics of γ-Secretase Provides a Molecular Basis for β-Amyloid Binding and Processing

Emerging structures and dynamic mechanisms of γ-secretase for Alzheimer's disease

γ-Secretase, called "the proteasome of the membrane," is a membrane-embedded protease complex that cleaves 150+ peptide substrates with central roles in biology and medicine, including amyloid precursor protein and the Notch family of cell-surface receptors. Mutations in γ-secretase and amyloid precursor protein lead to early-onset familial Alzheimer's disease. γ-Secretase has thus served as a critical drug target for treating familial Alzheimer's disease and the more common late-onset Alzheimer's disease as well. However, critical gaps remain in understanding the mechanisms of processive proteolysis of substrates, the effects of familial Alzheimer's disease mutations, and allosteric modulation of substrate cleavage by γ-secretase. In this review, we focus on recent studies of structural dynamic mechanisms of γ-secretase. Different mechanisms, including the "Fit-Stay-Trim," "Sliding-Unwinding," and "Tilting-Unwinding," have been proposed for substrate proteolysis of amyloid precursor protein by γ-secretase based on all-atom molecular dynamics simulations. While an incorrect registry of the Notch1 substrate was identified in the cryo-electron microscopy structure of Notch1-bound γ-secretase, molecular dynamics simulations on a resolved model of Notch1-bound γ-secretase that was reconstructed using the amyloid precursor protein-bound γ-secretase as a template successfully captured γ-secretase activation for proper cleavages of both wildtype and mutant Notch, being consistent with biochemical experimental findings. The approach could be potentially applied to decipher the processing mechanisms of various substrates by γ-secretase. In addition, controversy over the effects of familial Alzheimer's disease mutations, particularly the issue of whether they stabilize or destabilize γ-secretase-substrate complexes, is discussed. Finally, an outlook is provided for future studies of γ-secretase, including pathways of substrate binding and product release, effects of modulators on familial Alzheimer's disease mutations of the γ-secretase-substrate complexes. Comprehensive understanding of the functional mechanisms of γ-secretase will greatly facilitate the rational design of effective drug molecules for treating familial Alzheimer's disease and perhaps Alzheimer's disease in general.

The amyloid cascade hypothesis: an updated critical review

Results from recent clinical trials of antibodies that target amyloid-β (Aβ) for Alzheimer's disease have created excitement and have been heralded as corroboration of the amyloid cascade hypothesis. However, while Aβ may contribute to disease, genetic, clinical, imaging and biochemical data suggest a more complex aetiology. Here we review the history and weaknesses of the amyloid cascade hypothesis in view of the new evidence obtained from clinical trials of anti-amyloid antibodies. These trials indicate that the treatments have either no or uncertain clinical effect on cognition. Despite the importance of amyloid in the definition of Alzheimer's disease, we argue that the data point to Aβ playing a minor aetiological role. We also discuss data suggesting that the concerted activity of many pathogenic factors contribute to Alzheimer's disease and propose that evolving multi-factor disease models will better underpin the search for more effective strategies to treat the disease.

Effects of presenilin-1 familial Alzheimer's disease mutations on γ-secretase activation for cleavage of amyloid precursor protein

Presenilin-1 (PS1) is the catalytic subunit of γ-secretase which cleaves within the transmembrane domain of over 150 peptide substrates. Dominant missense mutations in PS1 cause early-onset familial Alzheimer's disease (FAD); however, the exact pathogenic mechanism remains unknown. Here we combined Gaussian accelerated molecular dynamics (GaMD) simulations and biochemical experiments to determine the effects of six representative PS1 FAD mutations (P117L, I143T, L166P, G384A, L435F, and L286V) on the enzyme-substrate interactions between γ-secretase and amyloid precursor protein (APP). Biochemical experiments showed that all six PS1 FAD mutations rendered γ-secretase less active for the endoproteolytic (ε) cleavage of APP. Distinct low-energy conformational states were identified from the free energy profiles of wildtype and PS1 FAD-mutant γ-secretase. The P117L and L286V FAD mutants could still sample the "Active" state for substrate cleavage, but with noticeably reduced conformational space compared with the wildtype. The other mutants hardly visited the "Active" state. The PS1 FAD mutants were found to reduce γ-secretase proteolytic activity by hindering APP residue L49 from proper orientation in the active site and/or disrupting the distance between the catalytic aspartates. Therefore, our findings provide mechanistic insights into how PS1 FAD mutations affect structural dynamics and enzyme-substrate interactions of γ-secretase and APP.

The Anti-Amyloid Monoclonal Antibody Lecanemab: 16 Cautionary Notes

After the CLARITY-AD clinical trial results of lecanemab were interpreted as positive, and supporting the amyloid hypothesis, the drug received accelerated Food and Drug Administration approval. However, we argue that benefits of lecanemab treatment are uncertain and may yield net harm for some patients, and that the data do not support the amyloid hypothesis. We note potential biases from inclusion, unblinding, dropouts, and other issues. Given substantial adverse effects and subgroup heterogeneity, we conclude that lecanemab's efficacy is not clinically meaningful, consistent with numerous analyses suggesting that amyloid-β and its derivatives are not the main causative agents of Alzheimer's disease dementia.

Genetics, Functions, and Clinical Impact of Presenilin-1 (PSEN1) Gene

Presenilin-1 (PSEN1) has been verified as an important causative factor for early onset Alzheimer's disease (EOAD). PSEN1 is a part of γ-secretase, and in addition to amyloid precursor protein (APP) cleavage, it can also affect other processes, such as Notch signaling, β-cadherin processing, and calcium metabolism. Several motifs and residues have been identified in PSEN1, which may play a significant role in γ-secretase mechanisms, such as the WNF, GxGD, and PALP motifs. More than 300 mutations have been described in PSEN1; however, the clinical phenotypes related to these mutations may be diverse. In addition to classical EOAD, patients with PSEN1 mutations regularly present with atypical phenotypic symptoms, such as spasticity, seizures, and visual impairment. In vivo and in vitro studies were performed to verify the effect of PSEN1 mutations on EOAD. The pathogenic nature of PSEN1 mutations can be categorized according to the ACMG-AMP guidelines; however, some mutations could not be categorized because they were detected only in a single case, and their presence could not be confirmed in family members. Genetic modifiers, therefore, may play a critical role in the age of disease onset and clinical phenotypes of PSEN1 mutations. This review introduces the role of PSEN1 in γ-secretase, the clinical phenotypes related to its mutations, and possible significant residues of the protein.

Structure and mechanism of the γ-secretase intramembrane protease complex

γ-Secretase is a membrane protein complex that proteolyzes within the transmembrane domain of >100 substrates, including those derived from the amyloid precursor protein and the Notch family of cell surface receptors. The nine-transmembrane presenilin is the catalytic component of this aspartyl protease complex that carries out hydrolysis in the lipid bilayer. Advances in cryoelectron microscopy have led to the elucidation of the structure of the γ-secretase complex at atomic resolution. Recently, structures of the enzyme have been determined with bound APP- or Notch-derived substrates, providing insight into the nature of substrate recognition and processing. Molecular dynamics simulations of substrate-bound enzymes suggest dynamic mechanisms of intramembrane proteolysis. Structures of the enzyme bound to small-molecule inhibitors and modulators have also been solved, setting the stage for rational structure-based drug discovery targeting γ-secretase.

Mechanism of Tripeptide Trimming of Amyloid β-Peptide 49 by γ-Secretase

The membrane-embedded γ-secretase complex processively cleaves within the transmembrane domain of amyloid precursor protein (APP) to produce 37-to-43-residue amyloid β-peptides (Aβ) of Alzheimer's disease (AD). Despite its importance in pathogenesis, the mechanism of processive proteolysis by γ-secretase remains poorly understood. Here, mass spectrometry and Western blotting were used to quantify the efficiency of tripeptide trimming of wild-type (WT) and familial AD (FAD) mutant Aβ49. In comparison to WT Aβ49, the efficiency of tripeptide trimming was similar for the I45F, A42T, and V46F Aβ49 FAD mutants but substantially diminished for the I45T and T48P mutants. In parallel with biochemical experiments, all-atom simulations using a novel peptide Gaussian accelerated molecular dynamics (Pep-GaMD) method were applied to investigate the tripeptide trimming of Aβ49 by γ-secretase. The starting structure was the active γ-secretase bound to Aβ49 and APP intracellular domain (AICD), as generated from our previous study that captured the activation of γ-secretase for the initial endoproteolytic cleavage of APP (Bhattarai, A., ACS Cent. Sci. 2020, 6, 969-983). Pep-GaMD simulations captured remarkable structural rearrangements of both the enzyme and substrate, in which hydrogen-bonded catalytic aspartates and water became poised for tripeptide trimming of Aβ49 to Aβ46. These structural changes required a positively charged N-terminus of endoproteolytic coproduct AICD, which could dissociate during conformational rearrangements of the protease and Aβ49. The simulation findings were highly consistent with biochemical experimental data. Taken together, our complementary biochemical experiments and Pep-GaMD simulations have enabled elucidation of the mechanism of tripeptide trimming of Aβ49 by γ-secretase.

Mechanistic regulation of γ-secretase by their substrates

γ-Secretase (GS) is a transmembrane (TM) enzyme that plays important roles in the processing of approximately 90 substrates.

Characterizing the Chemical Space of γ-Secretase Inhibitors and Modulators

γ-Secretase (GS) is one of the most attractive molecular targets for the treatment of Alzheimer's disease (AD). Its key role in the final step of amyloid-β peptides generation and its relationship in the cascade of events for disease development have caught the attention of many pharmaceutical groups. Over the past years, different inhibitors and modulators have been evaluated as promising therapeutics against AD. However, despite the great chemical diversity of the reported compounds, a global classification and visual representation of the chemical space for GS inhibitors and modulators remain unavailable. In the present work, we carried out a two-dimensional (2D) chemical space analysis from different classes and subclasses of GS inhibitors and modulators based on their structural similarity. Along with the novel structural information available for GS complexes, our analysis opens the possibility to identify compounds with high molecular similarity, critical to finding new chemical structures through the optimization of existing compounds and relating them with a potential binding site.

Sequential conformational changes in transmembrane domains of presenilin 1 in Aβ42 downregulation

Alzheimer disease (AD) is the most common neurodegenerative disease worldwide. AD is pathologically characterized by the deposition of senile plaques in the brain, which are composed of an amyloid-β peptide (Aβ) that is produced through the multistep cleavage of amyloid precursor protein (APP) by γ-secretase. γ-Secretase is a membrane protein complex, which includes its catalytic subunit presenilin 1 (PS1). However, much about the structural dynamics of this enzyme remain unclear. We have previously demonstrated that movements of the transmembrane domain (TMD) 1 and TMD3 of PS1 are strongly associated with decreased production of the Aβ peptide ending at the 42nd residue (i.e., Aβ42), which is the aggregation-prone, toxic species. However, the association between these movements as well as the sequence of these TMDs remains unclear. In this study, we raised the possibility that the vertical movement of TMD1 is a prerequisite for expansion of the catalytic cavity around TMD3 of PS1, resulting in reduced Aβ42 production. Our results shed light on the association between the conformational changes of TMDs and the regulation of γ-secretase activity.

Is It the Twilight of BACE1 Inhibitors?

β-secretase (BACE1) has been regarded as a prime target for the development of amyloid beta (Aβ) lowering drugs in the therapy of Alzheimer´s disease (AD). Although the enzyme was discovered in 1991 and helped to formulate the Aβ hypothesis as one of the very important features of AD etiopathogenesis, progress in AD treatment utilizing BACE1 inhibitors has remained limited. Moreover, in the last years, major pharmaceutical companies have discontinued clinical trials of five BACE1 inhibitors that had been strongly perceived as prospective. In our review, the Aβ hypothesis, the enzyme, its functions, and selected substrates are described. BACE1 inhibitors are classified into four generations. Those that underwent clinical trials displayed adverse effects, including weight loss, skin rashes, worsening of neuropsychiatric symptoms, etc. Some inhibitors could not establish a statistically significant risk-benefit ratio, or even scored worse than placebo. We still believe that drugs targeting BACE1 may still hide some potential, but a different approach to BACE1 inhibition or a shift of focus to modulation of its trafficking and/or post-translational modification should now be followed.

How Mutations Perturb γ-Secretase Active Site Studied by Free Energy Simulations

γ-Secretase is involved in processing of the amyloid precursor protein (APP) and generation of short Aβ peptides that may play a key role in neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer's disease (AD). Several mutations in γ-secretase influence its activity, resulting in early AD onset (Familial AD or FAD mutations). The molecular details of how mutations, not located close to the active site, can affect enzyme activity is not understood. In molecular dynamics simulations of γ-secretase in the absence of substrate (apo), we identified two active site conformational states characterized by a direct contact between catalytic Asp residues (closed state) and an open water-bridged state. In the presence of substrate, only conformations compatible with the open active site geometry are accessible. Systematic free energy simulations on wild type and FAD mutations indicate a free energy difference between closed and open states that is significantly modulated by FAD mutations and correlates with the corresponding experimental activity. For mutations with reduced activity, an increased penalty for open-state transitions was found. Only for two mutations located at the active site a direct perturbation of the open-state geometry was observed that could directly explain the drop of enzyme activity. The simulations suggest that modulation of the closed/open equilibrium and perturbation of the open (active) catalytic geometry are possible mechanisms of how FAD mutations affect γ-secretase activity. The results also offer an explanation for the experimental finding that FAD mutations, although not located at the interface to the substrate, mainly destabilize the enzyme-substrate complex.

Membrane dynamics of γ-secretase with the anterior pharynx-defective 1B subunit

The four-subunit protease complex γ-secretase cleaves many single-pass transmembrane (TM) substrates, including Notch and β-amyloid precursor protein to generate amyloid-β (Aβ), central to Alzheimer's disease. Two of the subunits anterior pharynx-defective 1 (APH-1) and presenilin (PS) exist in two homologous forms APH1-A and APH1-B, and PS1 and PS2. The consequences of these variations are poorly understood and could affect Aβ production and γ-secretase medicine. Here, we developed the first complete structural model of the APH-1B subunit using the published cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) structures of APH1-A (Protein Data Bank: 5FN2, 5A63, and 6IYC). We then performed all-atom molecular dynamics simulations at 303 K in a realistic bilayer system to understand both APH-1B alone and in γ-secretase without and with substrate C83-bound. We show that APH-1B adopts a 7TM topology with a water channel topology similar to APH-1A. We demonstrate direct transport of water through this channel, mainly via Glu84, Arg87, His170, and His196. The apo and holo states closely resemble the experimental cryo-EM structures with APH-1A, however with subtle differences: The substrate-bound APH-1B γ-secretase was quite stable, but some TM helices of PS1 and APH-1B rearranged in the membrane consistent with the disorder seen in the cryo-EM data. This produces different accessibility of water molecules for the catalytic aspartates of PS1, critical for Aβ production. In particular, we find that the typical distance between the catalytic aspartates of PS1 and the C83 cleavage sites are shorter in APH-1B, that is, it represents a more closed state, due to interactions with the C-terminal fragment of PS1. Our structural-dynamic model of APH-1B alone and in γ-secretase suggests generally similar topology but some notable differences in water accessibility which may be relevant to the protein's existence in two forms and their specific function and location.

Side-by-side comparison of Notch- and C83 binding to γ-secretase in a complete membrane model at physiological temperature

γ-Secretase cleaves the C99 fragment of the amyloid precursor protein, leading to formation of aggregated β-amyloid peptide central to Alzheimer's disease, and Notch, essential for cell regulation. Recent cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) structures indicate major changes upon substrate binding, a β-sheet recognition motif, and a possible helix unwinding to expose peptide bonds towards nucleophilic attack. Here we report side-by-side comparison of the 303 K dynamics of the two proteins in realistic membranes using molecular dynamics simulations. Our ensembles agree with the cryo-EM data (full-protein Cα-RMSD = 1.62–2.19 Å) but reveal distinct presenilin helix conformation states and thermal β-strand to coil transitions of C83 and Notch100. We identify distinct 303 K hydrogen bond dynamics and water accessibility of the catalytic sites. The RKRR motif (1758–1761) contributes significantly to Notch binding and serves as a “membrane anchor” that prevents Notch displacement. Water that transiently hydrogen bonds to G1753 and V1754 probably represents the catalytic nucleophile. At 303 K, Notch and C83 binding induce different conformation states, with Notch mostly present in a closed state with shorter Asp–Asp distance. This may explain the different outcome of Notch and C99 cleavage, as the latter is more imprecise with many products. Our identified conformation states may aid efforts to develop conformation-selective drugs that target C99 and Notch cleavage differently, e.g. Notch-sparing γ-secretase modulators.

Distinct membrane dynamics and conformations of C83- and Notch-bound γ-secretase may aid the development of Notch-sparing treatments of Alzheimer's disease.

Mechanisms of γ-Secretase Activation and Substrate Processing

Amyloid β-peptide, the principal component of characteristic cerebral plaques of Alzheimer's disease (AD), is produced through intramembrane proteolysis of the amyloid precursor protein (APP) by γ-secretase. Despite the importance in the pathogenesis of AD, the mechanisms of intramembrane proteolysis and substrate processing by γ-secretase remain poorly understood. Here, complementary all-atom simulations using a robust Gaussian accelerated molecular dynamics (GaMD) method and biochemical experiments were combined to investigate substrate processing of wildtype and mutant APP by γ-secretase. The GaMD simulations captured spontaneous activation of γ-secretase, with hydrogen bonded catalytic aspartates and water poised for proteolysis of APP at the ε cleavage site. Furthermore, GaMD simulations revealed that familial AD mutations I45F and T48P enhanced the initial ε cleavage between residues Leu49-Val50, while M51F mutation shifted the ε cleavage site to the amide bond between Thr48-Leu49. Detailed analysis of the GaMD simulations allowed us to identify distinct low-energy conformational states of γ-secretase, different secondary structures of the wildtype and mutant APP substrate, and important active-site subpockets for catalytic function of the enzyme. The simulation findings were highly consistent with experimental analyses of APP proteolytic products using mass spectrometry and Western blotting. Taken together, the GaMD simulations and biochemical experiments have enabled us to elucidate the mechanisms of γ-secretase activation and substrate processing, which should facilitate rational computer-aided drug design targeting this functionally important enzyme.

Identification of Structural Calcium Binding Sites in Membrane-Bound Presenilin 1 and 2

Variants of presenilin (PS1 and PS2) are the main genetic risk factors of familial Alzheimer's disease and thus central to the disease etiology. Although mostly studied as catalytic units of γ-secretase controlling Aβ production, presenilins also affect calcium levels, which are disturbed in Alzheimer's disease. We investigated the interaction of calcium with both PS1 and PS2 using all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations in realistic membrane models, with the specific aim to identify any Ca²⁺ sites. We did not observe any complete Ca²⁺ leak event, but we identified four persistent Ca²⁺ sites in membrane-bound PS1 and PS2: One in HL2 near the C-terminal of TM6, one in HL2 toward the N-terminal of TM7, a site at the catalytic aspartate on TM7, and a site at the PALP motif on TM9. The sites feature negatively charged glutamates and aspartates typical of calcium binding. Structural homology to diaspartate calcium transport proteins and mutation studies of calcium efflux support our identified calcium sites. Calcium consistently dampens HL2 motions in all comparisons (PS1, protonated PS1, PS2, protonated PS2). Due to their location in HL2 and the active site, we propose that the calcium sites control autoproteolytic maturation of presenilin by a pH-dependent conformational restriction of the HL2 recognition loop, which also regulates calcium transport proteins such as inositol 1,4,5-triphosphate receptor and ryanodine receptor. Our structural dynamics could provide a possible molecular basis for the need of both calcium and presenilin for lysosome proteolytic function, perhaps relevant also to other protein misfolding diseases.

Structure-activity relationship of presenilin in γ-secretase-mediated intramembrane cleavage

Genetic research on familial cases of Alzheimer disease have identified presenilin (PS) as an important membrane protein in the pathomechanism of this disease. PS is the catalytic subunit of γ-secretase, which is responsible for the generation of amyloid-β peptide deposited in the brains of Alzheimer disease patients. γ-Secretase is an atypical protease composed of four membrane proteins (i.e., presenilin, nicastrin, anterior pharynx defective-1 (Aph-1), and presenilin enhancer-2 (Pen-2)) and mediates intramembrane proteolysis. Numerous investigations have been conducted toward understanding the structural features of γ-secretase components as well as the cleavage mechanism of γ-secretase. In this review, we summarize our current understanding of the structure and activity relationship of the γ-secretase complex.

Pathogenic PSEN1 Glu184Gly Mutation in a Family from Thailand with Probable Autosomal Dominant Early Onset Alzheimer's Disease

A pathogenic mutation in PSEN1 p.Glu184Gly was discovered in a Thai family with early onset Alzheimer's disease (EOAD) as the first case in Asia. Proband patient presented memory impairment and anxiety at the age of 41 years. Family history was positive, since several family members were also diagnosed with dementia (father and grandfather). MRI in the patient revealed global cortical atrophy without specific lesions or lacuna infarctions. Extensive genetic profiling for 50 neurodegenerative disease related genes was performed by next generation sequencing (NGS) on the patient. PSEN1 Glu184Gly was previously reported in French families with frontal variant Alzheimer's disease (AD). Interestingly, this mutation is located near the splicing site and could possibly result in abnormal cleavage of PSEN1 transcript. Furthermore, 3D models from protein structural predictions revealed significant structural changes, since glycine may result in increased flexibility of TM-III helix. Inter/intra-helical interactions could also be altered. In the future, functional studies should be performed to verify the probable role PSEN1 Glu184Gly in amyloid beta processing and pathogenicity.

Computer-Aided Drug Design of β-Secretase, γ-Secretase and Anti-Tau Inhibitors for the Discovery of Novel Alzheimer's Therapeutics

Aging-associated neurodegenerative diseases, which are characterized by progressive neuronal death and synapses loss in human brain, are rapidly growing affecting millions of people globally. Alzheimer's is the most common neurodegenerative disease and it can be caused by genetic and environmental risk factors. This review describes the amyloid-β and Tau hypotheses leading to amyloid plaques and neurofibrillary tangles, respectively which are the predominant pathways for the development of anti-Alzheimer's small molecule inhibitors. The function and structure of the druggable targets of these two pathways including β-secretase, γ-secretase, and Tau are discussed in this review article. Computer-Aided Drug Design including computational structure-based design and ligand-based design have been employed successfully to develop inhibitors for biomolecular targets involved in Alzheimer's. The application of computational molecular modeling for the discovery of small molecule inhibitors and modulators for β-secretase and γ-secretase is summarized. Examples of computational approaches employed for the development of anti-amyloid aggregation and anti-Tau phosphorylation, proteolysis and aggregation inhibitors are also reported.

Cryo-temperature effects on membrane protein structure and dynamics

Cryo-electron structures revolutionize biology, yet cooling effects are unclear. Using a simulation protocol of hot, cold, and rapidly cooled γ-secretase we identify cryo-contraction and modes relevant to Aβ production and cryo-analysis in general.

Conformational Dynamics of Transmembrane Domain 3 of Presenilin 1 Is Associated with the Trimming Activity of γ-Secretase

γ-Secretase is an intramembrane-cleaving protease that generates the toxic species of the amyloid-β peptide (Aβ) that is responsible for the pathology of Alzheimer disease. The catalytic subunit of γ-secretase is presenilin 1 (PS1), which is a polytopic membrane protein with a hydrophilic catalytic pore. The length of the C terminus of Aβ is proteolytically determined by its processive trimming by γ-secretase, although the precise mechanism still remains largely unknown. Here, we identified that transmembrane domain (TMD) 3 of human PS1 is involved in the formation of the intramembranous hydrophilic pore. Notably, the water accessibility of TMD3 was greatly altered by point mutations and compounds, which modify γ-secretase activity. The changes in the water accessibility of TMD3 was also correlated with Aβ42 production. Moreover, crosslinking between TMD3 and TMD7 resulted in a loss of sensitivity to a γ-secretase modulator that reduces Aβ42 production. Therefore, our findings indicate that the conformational dynamics of TMD3 is a prerequisite for regulation of the Aβ trimming activity of γ-secretase.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT Modulation of γ-secretase activity to reduce the level of toxic amyloid-β species is thought to be a therapeutic strategy for Alzheimer disease. However, the detailed mechanism of the regulation of amyloid-β production, as well as the structure-and-activity relationship of γ-secretase remains unclear. Here we identified that the water accessibility around transmembrane domain 3 in presenilin 1 was increased along with a reduction in toxic amyloid-β production. Our findings demonstrate how the structure of presenilin 1 dynamically changes during amyloid-β production, and provides insights toward the development of treatments against Alzheimer disease.

Insights into membrane-bound presenilin 2 from all-atom molecular dynamics simulations

Presenilins 1 and 2 (PS1 or PS2) are main genetic risk factors of familial Alzheimer's disease (AD) that produce the β-amyloid (Aβ) peptides and also have important stand-alone functions related to, e.g. calcium signaling. Most work so far has focused on PS1, but humans carry both PS1 and PS2, and mutations in both cause AD. Here, we develop a computational model of PS2 in the membrane to address the question how pathogenic PS2 mutations affect the membrane-embedded protein. The models are based on cryo-electron microscopy structures of PS1 translated to PS2, augmented with missing residues and a complete all-atom membrane-water system, and equilibrated using three independent 500-ns simulations of molecular dynamics with a structure-balanced force field. We show that the nine-transmembrane channel structure is substantially controlled by major dynamics in the hydrophilic loop bridging TM6 and TM7, which functions as a 'plug' in the PS2 membrane channel. TM2, TM6, TM7 and TM9 flexibility controls the size of this channel. We find that most pathogenic PS2 mutations significantly reduce stability relative to random mutations, using a statistical ANOVA test with all possible mutations in the affected sites as a control. The associated loss of compactness may also impair calcium affinity. Remarkably, similar properties of the open state are known to impair the binding of substrates to γ-secretase, and we thus argue that the two mechanisms could be functionally related.Communicated by Ramaswamy H. Sarma.

Uncovering the Binding Mode of γ -Secretase Inhibitors

Knowledge of how transition state inhibitors bind to γ-secretase is of major importance for the design of new Alzheimer's disease therapies. On the basis of the known structure of γ-secretase in complex with a fragment of the amyloid precursor protein, we generated a structural model of γ-secretase in complex with the effective L-685,458 transition state inhibitor. The predicted binding mode is in excellent agreement with experimental data, mimicking all enzyme-substrate interactions at the active site and forming the relevant transition state geometry with the active site aspartate residues. The model also indicates the possible location and nature of the amino acid residues forming the proposed binding pockets S1', S2', and S3' near the active site that are occupied by chemical groups of the inhibitor. In addition, we found that the stability of the complex is very likely sensitive to the pH value. Comparative simulations on the binding of L-685,458 and the epimer L682,679 allowed us to explain the strongly reduced affinity of the epimer for γ-secretase. The structural model could form a valuable basis for the design of new or modified γ-secretase inhibitors.

Structure and dynamics of γ-secretase with presenilin 2 compared to presenilin 1

Severe early-onset familial Alzheimer's disease (FAD) is caused by more than 200 different mutations in the genes coding for presenilin, the catalytic subunit of the 4-subunit protease complex γ-secretase, which cleaves the C99 fragment of the amyloid precursor protein (APP) to produce Aβ peptides. γ-Secretase exists with either of two homologues, PS1 and PS2. All cryo-electron microscopic structures and computational work has so far focused on γ-secretase with PS1, yet PS2 mutations also cause FAD. A central question is thus whether there are structural and dynamic differences between PS1 and PS2. To address this question, we use the cryo-electron microscopic data for PS1 to develop the first structural and dynamic model of PS2-γ-secretase in the catalytically relevant mature membrane-bound state at ambient temperature, equilibrated by three independent 500 ns molecular dynamics simulations. We find that the characteristic nicastrin extra-cellular domain breathing mode and major movements in the cytosolic loop between TM6 and TM7 occur in both PS2- and PS1-γ-secretase. The overall structures and conformational states are similar, suggesting similar catalytic activities. However, at the sequence level, charge-controlled membrane-anchoring is extracellular for PS1 and intracellular for PS2, which suggests different subcellular locations. The tilt angles of the TM2, TM6, TM7 and TM9 helices differ in the two forms of γ-secretase, suggesting that the two proteins have somewhat different substrate processing and channel sizes. Our MD simulations consistently indicated that PS2 retains several water molecules near the catalytic site at the bilayer, as required for catalysis. The possible reasons for the differences of PS1 and PS2 are discussed in relation to their location and function.

The interactions of an Aβ protofibril with a cholesterol-enriched membrane and involvement of neuroprotective carbazolium-based substances

Recent studies have shown that the aggregation of the amyloid-beta peptide (Aβ) in the brain cell membrane is responsible for the emergence of Alzheimer's disease (AD); the exploration of effective factors involved in the extension of the aggregation process and alternatively the examination of an effective inhibitor via theoretical and experimental tools are among the main research topics in the field of AD treatment. Therefore, in this study, we used all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to clarify the impact of cell membrane cholesterol on the interaction of Aβ with 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) as a membrane model. Moreover, the effect of the P7C3-S243 molecule on the abovementioned process was investigated. The simulation results disclosed the neuroprotective property of the P7C3-S243 molecule. The MD simulation results indicate that the interaction of cholesterol molecules with the Aβ oligomer is negligible and cannot enhance membrane rupture. However, strong hydrogen bonding between the POPC molecules and the oligomers led to membrane perturbation. According to our modellings, the P7C3-S243 molecular layer can protect the cell membrane by inhibiting the direct interaction between the bilayer and Aβ. In addition, free-energy calculations were conducted to determine the possible penetration of Aβ fibrils into the cholesterol-enriched membrane.

Molecular dynamics of C99-bound γ-secretase reveal two binding modes with distinct compactness, stability, and active-site retention: implications for Aβ production

The membrane protease γ-secretase cleaves the C99 fragment of the amyloid precursor protein, thus producing the Aβ peptides central to Alzheimer's disease. Cryo-electron microscopy has provided the topology but misses the membrane and loop parts that contribute to substrate binding. We report here an essentially complete atomic model of C99 within wild-type γ-secretase that respects all the experimental constraints and additionally describes loop, helix, and C99 substrate dynamics in a realistic all-atom membrane. Our model represents the matured auto-cleaved state required for catalysis. From two independent 500-ns molecular dynamic simulations, we identify two conformation states of C99 in equilibrium, a compact and a loose state. Our simulations provide a basis for C99 processing and Aβ formation and explain the production of longer and shorter Aβ, as the compact state retains C99 for longer and thus probably trims to shorter Aβ peptides. We expect pathogenic presenilin mutations to stabilize the loose over the compact state. The simulations detail the role of the Lys53-Lys54-Lys55 anchor for C99 binding, a loss of helicity of bound C99, and positioning of Thr48 and Leu49 leading to alternative trimming pathways on opposite sides of the C99 helix in three amino acid steps. The C99 binding topology resembles that of C83-bound γ-secretase without membrane but lacks a presenilin 1-C99 β-sheet, which could be induced by C83's stronger binding. The loose state should be selectively disfavored by γ-secretase modulators to increase C99 trimming and reduce the formation of longer Aβ, a strategy that is currently much explored but has lacked a structural basis.

Structural Modeling of γ-Secretase Aβ n Complex Formation and Substrate Processing

The intramembrane aspartyl protease γ-secretase (GSEC) cleaves single-span transmembrane helices including the C-terminal fragment of the amyloid precursor protein (APP). This substrate is initially cleaved at the ϵ-site followed by successive processing (trimming) events mostly in steps of three amino acids. GSEC is responsible for the formation of N-terminal APP amyloid-β (Aβ) peptides of different length (e.g., Aβ₄₂) that can form aggregates involved in Alzheimer's disease pathogenesis. The molecular mechanism of GSEC-APP substrate recognition is key for understanding how different peptide products are formed and could help in designing APP-selective modulators. Based on the known structure of apo GSEC and the APP-C99 fragment we have generated putative structural models of the initial binding in three different possible modes using extensive molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. The binding mode with the substrate helix located in a cleft between the transmembrane helices 2 and 3 of the presenilin subunit was identified as a most likely binding mode. Based on this arrangement, the processing steps were investigated using restraint MD simulations to pull the scissile bond (for each processing step) into a transition like (cleavable) state. This allowed us to analyze in detail the motions and energetic contributions of participating residues. The structural model agrees qualitatively well with the influence of many mutations in GSEC and C99. It also explains the effects of inhibitors, cross-linking, as well as spectroscopic data on GSEC substrate binding and can serve as working model for the future planning of structural and biochemical studies.

γ-Secretase Studied by Atomistic Molecular Dynamics Simulations: Global Dynamics, Enzyme Activation, Water Distribution and Lipid Binding

γ-secretase, an intramembrane-cleaving aspartyl protease is involved in the cleavage of a large number of intramembrane proteins. The most prominent substrate is the amyloid precursor protein, whose proteolytic processing leads to the production of different amyloid Aβ peptides. These peptides are known to form toxic aggregates and may play a key role in Alzheimer's disease (AD). Recently, the three-dimensional structure of γ-secretase has been determined via Cryo-EM, elucidating the spatial geometry of this enzyme complex in different functional states. We have used molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to study the global dynamics and conformational transitions of γ-secretase, as well as the water and lipid distributions in and around the transmembrane domains in atomic detail. Simulations were performed on the full enzyme complex and on the membrane embedded parts alone. The simulations revealed global motions compatible with the experimental enzyme structures and indicated little dependence of the dynamics of the transmembrane domains on the soluble extracellular subunits. During the simulation on the membrane spanning part a transition between an inactive conformation (with catalytic residues far apart) toward a putatively active form (with catalytic residues in close proximity) has been observed. This conformational change is associated with a distinct rearrangement of transmembrane helices, a global compaction of the catalytically active presenilin subunit a change in the water structure near the active site and a rigidification of the protein fold. The observed conformational rearrangement allows the interpretation of the effect of several mutations on the activity of γ-secretase. A number of long-lived lipid binding sites could be identified on the membrane spanning surface of γ-secretase which may coincide with association regions of hydrophobic membrane helices to form putative substrate binding exosites.

Influence of membrane lipid composition on the structure and activity of γ-secretase

γ-Secretase (GS) is a multi-subunit membrane-embedded aspartyl protease that cleaves more than 80 integral membrane proteins, including the amyloid precursor protein (APP) to produce the amyloid-β (Aβ) peptide. Oligomerization and aggregation of the 42-amino acid length Aβ isoform in the brain has been associated with the development and progression of Alzheimer's disease (AD). Based on recent experimental structural studies and using multiscale computational modeling approaches, the conformational states and protein-membrane interactions of the GS complex embedded in six homogeneous and six heterogeneous lipid bilayers were characterized. In order to identify potential lipid and cholesterol binding sites, GS regions with high lipid/cholesterol occupancy values were analyzed using atomistic and coarse-grained simulations. Long lipid residence times were observed to be correlated with a large number of hydrogen bonds between the charged headgroups and key GS amino acids. This observation provides a plausible explanation for the inhibition of GS by charged lipids observed in previous experimental studies. Computed lateral pressure profiles suggest that higher transmembrane pressures favor active state conformations of the catalytic subunit. A probable mechanism for the regulation of the local stress response in cholesterol-rich multicomponent lipid bilayers is identified. Finally, it is demonstrated that interactions between the nicastrin extracellular domain and lipid headgroups leads to a compact structural conformation of the GS complex. Overall, this study provides valuable insight into the effect of bilayer lipid composition on the GS structural ensemble and its function.

Dissecting conformational changes in APP's transmembrane domain linked to ε-efficiency in familial Alzheimer's disease

The mechanism by which familial Alzheimer's disease (FAD) mutations within the transmembrane domain (TMD) of the Amyloid Precursor Protein (APP) affect ε-endoproteolysis is only poorly understood. Thereby, mutations in the cleavage domain reduce ε-efficiency of γ-secretase cleavage and some even shift entry into production lines. Since cleavage occurs within the TMD, a relationship between processing and TMD structure and dynamics seems obvious. Using molecular dynamic simulations, we dissect the dynamic features of wild-type and seven FAD-mutants into local and global components. Mutations consistently enhance hydrogen-bond fluctuations upstream of the ε-cleavage sites but maintain strong helicity there. Dynamic perturbation-response scanning reveals that FAD-mutants target backbone motions utilized in the bound state. Those motions, obscured by large-scale motions in the pre-bound state, provide (i) a dynamic mechanism underlying the proposed coupling between binding and ε-cleavage, (ii) key sites consistent with experimentally determined docking sites, and (iii) the distinction between mutants and wild-type.