Insights into Rational Design of a New Class of Allosteric Effectors with Molecular Dynamics Markov State Models and Network Theory

MD Multi-Sector Selector: Recursive Extraction and Refinement of Molecular Dynamics Based Sectors Yields Two Sectors in p53 Tumor Suppressor Protein

Allosteric signaling in proteins allows perturbations at one locale to modulate activity at an orthosteric distant site. This may explain how distal mutations disrupt protein activity and offer pathways for the development of allosteric therapeutics, a novel class of restorative compounds to reactivate native function. Despite the ubiquitous presence of allosteric control in nature and the promises that it holds for treating currently untreatable diseases, quantitative theory of the mechanism of allostery is lacking. Working to fill this critical gap, we have developed a novel method to identify groups of covarying residues which the sector hypothesis suggests are capable of transmitting allosteric signals in proteins. A major problem with sectors computed from covariance measures is the selection relies upon a full covariance matrix rather than on the covariance among the residues posited to be in the sector. We demonstrate a novel method which constructs sectors on the basis of cohesion within the residues in the sector to eliminate the incongruity between the sector idea and the way it is calculated. Furthermore, the refinement can be iteratively applied, enabling the extraction of more than one sector in a well-defined, systematic manner. In this study, we report on the development of MD multi-sector selector and its application to allosteric signaling in the tumor suppressor protein p53. We consider the implications of our findings on our long-term goal of allosterically reactivating mutant p53 as a means of curing cancer, and critically assess the broader applicability of MD multi-sector selector across diverse fields.

Navigating the complexity of p53-DNA binding: implications for cancer therapy

Abstract

The tumor suppressor protein p53, a transcription factor playing a key role in cancer prevention, interacts with DNA as its primary means of determining cell fate in the event of DNA damage. When it becomes mutated, it opens damaged cells to the possibility of reproducing unchecked, which can lead to formation of cancerous tumors. Despite its critical role, therapies at the molecular level to restore p53 native function remain elusive, due to its complex nature. Nevertheless, considerable information has been amassed, and new means of investigating the problem have become available.

Objectives

We consider structural, biophysical, and bioinformatic insights and their implications for the role of direct and indirect readout and how they contribute to binding site recognition, particularly those of low consensus. We then pivot to consider advances in computational approaches to drug discovery.

Materials and methods

We have conducted a review of recent literature pertinent to the p53 protein.

Results

Considerable literature corroborates the idea that p53 is a complex allosteric protein that discriminates its binding sites not only via consensus sequence through direct H-bond contacts, but also a complex combination of factors involving the flexibility of the binding site. New computational methods have emerged capable of capturing such information, which can then be utilized as input to machine learning algorithms towards the goal of more intelligent and efficient de novo allosteric drug design.

Conclusions

Recent improvements in machine learning coupled with graph theory and sector analysis hold promise for advances to more intelligently design allosteric effectors that may be able to restore native p53-DNA binding activity to mutant proteins.

Clinical relevance

The ideas brought to light by this review constitute a significant advance that can be applied to ongoing biophysical studies of drugs for p53, paving the way for the continued development of new methodologies for allosteric drugs. Our discoveries hold promise to provide molecular therapeutics which restore p53 native activity, thereby offering new insights for cancer therapies.

Graphical Abstract

Structural representation of the p53 DBD (PDBID 1TUP). DNA consensus sequence is shown in gray, and the protein is shown in blue. Red beads indicate hotspot residue mutations, green beads represent DNA interacting residues, and yellow beads represent both.

Leveraging Bidirectional Nature of Allostery To Inhibit Protein-Protein Interactions (PPIs): A Case Study of PCSK9-LDLR Interaction

The protein PCSK9 (proprotein convertase subtilisin/Kexin type 9) negatively regulates the recycling of LDLR (low-density lipoprotein receptor), leading to an elevated plasma level of LDL. Inhibition of PCSK9-LDLR interaction has emerged as a promising therapeutic strategy to manage hypercholesterolemia. However, the large interaction surface area between PCSK9 and LDLR makes it challenging to identify a small molecule competitive inhibitor. An alternative strategy would be to identify distal cryptic sites as targets for allosteric inhibitors that can remotely modulate PCSK9-LDLR interaction. Using several microseconds long molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, we demonstrate that on binding with LDLR, there is a significant conformational change (population shift) in a distal loop (residues 211-222) region of PCSK9. Consistent with the bidirectional nature of allostery, we establish a clear correlation between the loop conformation and the binding affinity with LDLR. Using a thermodynamic argument, we establish that the loop conformations predominantly present in the apo state of PCSK9 would have lower LDLR binding affinity, and they would be potential targets for designing allosteric inhibitors. We elucidate the molecular origin of the allosteric coupling between this loop and the LDLR binding interface in terms of the population shift in a set of salt bridges and hydrogen bonds. Overall, our work provides a general strategy toward identifying allosteric hotspots: compare the conformational ensemble of the receptor between the apo and bound states of the protein and identify distal conformational changes, if any. The inhibitors should be designed to bind and stabilize the apo-specific conformations.

Reconnaissance of Allostery via the Restoration of Native p53 DNA-Binding Domain Dynamics in Y220C Mutant p53 Tumor Suppressor Protein

Allosteric regulation of protein dynamics infers a long-range deliberate propagation of information via micro- and macroscale interactions. The Y220C structural mutant is one of the most frequent cancerous p53 mutants. The mutation is distally located from the DNA-binding site of the p53 DNA-binding domain yet causes changes in DNA recognition. This system presents a unique opportunity to examine the allosteric control of mutated proteins under a drug design paradigm. We focus on the key case study of p53 Y220C mutation restoration by a series of new compounds suggested to have Y220C reactivation properties in comparison to our previous findings on the restorative potential of PK11000, a compound studied extensively for reactivation in vitro and in vivo. Previously, we implemented all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and our lab's techniques of MD-Sectors and MD-Markov state models on the wild type, the Y220C mutant, and Y220C with PK11000 to characterize the effector's restorative properties in terms of conformational dynamics and hydrogen bonding. In this study, we turn to probing the effects made by docking the battery of a new but less well-tested set of aminobenzothiazole derivative compounds reported by Baud et al., which show promise of Y220C rescue. We find that while complete and precise reconstitution of p53 WT molecular dynamics may not be observed as was the case with PK11000, dispersed local reconstitution of loop dynamics provides evidence of rescuing effects by aminobenzothiazole derivative N,2-dihydroxy-3,5-diiodo-4-(1H-pyrrol-1-yl)benzamide, Effector 22, like what we observed for PK11000. Generalizable insights into the mutation and allosteric reactivation of p53 by various effectors by reconstitution of WT dynamics observed in statistical conformational ensemble analysis and network inference are discussed, considering the development of allosteric drug design rooted in first principles.

Allosteric Signaling in PDZ Energetic Networks: Embedding Error Analysis

Allosteric signaling in proteins has been known for some half a century, yet how the signal traverses the protein remains an active area of research. Recently, the importance of electrostatics to achieve long-range signaling has become increasingly appreciated. Our laboratory has been working on developing network approaches to capture such interactions. In this study, we turn our attention to the well-studied allosteric model protein, PDZ. We study the allosteric dynamics on a per-residue basis in key constructs involving the PDZ domain, its allosteric effector, and its peptide ligand. We utilize molecular dynamics trajectories to create the networks for the constructs to explore the allosteric effect by plotting the heat kernel results onto axes defined by principal components. We introduce a new metric to quantitate the volume sampled by a residue in the latent space. We relate our findings to PDZ and the greater field of allostery.

Network Analysis of Molecular Dynamics Sectors in the p53 Protein

Design of allosteric regulators is an emergent field in the area of drug discovery holding promise for currently untreated diseases. Allosteric regulators bind to a protein in one location and affect a distant site. The ubiquitous presence of allosteric effectors in biology and the success of serendipitously identified allosteric compounds point to the potential they hold. Although the mechanism of transmission of an allosteric signal is not unequivocally determined, one hypothesis suggests that groups of evolutionarily covarying residues within a protein, termed sectors, are conduits. A long-term goal of our lab is to allosterically modulate the activity of proteins by binding small molecules at points of allosteric control. However, methods to consistently identify such points remain unclear. Sector residues on the surfaces of proteins are a promising source of allosteric targets. Recently, we introduced molecular dynamics (MD)-based sectors; MD sectors capitalize on covariance of motion, in place of evolutionary covariance. By focusing on motional covariance, MD sectors tap into the framework of statistical mechanics afforded by the Boltzmann ensemble of structural conformations comprising the underlying data set. We hypothesized that the method of MD sectors can be used to identify a cohesive network of motionally covarying residues capable of transmitting an allosteric signal in a protein. While our initial qualitative results showed promise for the method to predict sectors, that a network of cohesively covarying residues had been produced remained an untested assumption. In this work, we apply network theory to rigorously analyze MD sectors, allowing us to quantitatively assess the biologically relevant property of network cohesiveness of sectors in the context of the tumor suppressor protein, p53. We revised the methodology for assessing and improving MD sectors. Specifically, we introduce a metric to calculate the cohesive properties of the network. Our new approach separates residues into two categories: sector residues and non-sector residues. The relatedness within each respective group is computed with a distance metric. Cohesive sector networks are identified as those that have high relatedness among the sector residues which exceeds the relatedness of the residues to the non-sector residues in terms of the correlation of motions. Our major finding was that the revised means of obtaining sectors was more efficacious than previous iterations, as evidenced by the greater cohesion of the networks. These results are discussed in the context of the development of allosteric regulators of p53 in particular and the expected applicability of the method to the drug design field in general.

Variable Regions of p53 Isoforms Allosterically Hard Code DNA Interaction

Allosteric regulation of protein activity pervades biology as the "second secret of life." We have been examining the allosteric regulation and mutant reactivation of the tumor suppressor protein p53. We have found that generalizing the definition of allosteric effector to include entire proteins and expanding the meaning of binding site to include the interface of a transcription factor with its DNA to be useful in understanding the modulation of protein activity. Here, we cast the variable regions of p53 isoforms as allosteric regulators of p53 interactions with its consensus DNA. We implemented molecular dynamics simulations and our lab's new techniques of molecular dynamics (MD) sectors and MD-Markov state models to investigate the effects of nine naturally occurring splice variant isoforms of p53. We find that all of the isoforms differ from wild type in their dynamic properties and how they interact with the DNA. We consider the implications of these findings on allostery and cancer treatment.