Combinatorial Synthesis and High-Throughput Screening of Alkyl Amines for Nonviral Gene Delivery

Multiple Routes to Bicontinuous Cubic Liquid Crystal Phases Discovered by High-Throughput Self-Assembly Screening of Multi-Tail Lipidoids

Bicontinuous cubic phases offer advantageous routes to a broad range of applied materials ranging from drug delivery devices to membranes. However, a priori design of molecules that assemble into these phases remains a technological challenge. In this article, a high-throughput synthesis of lipidoids that undergo protonation-driven self-assembly (PrSA) into liquid crystalline (LC) phases is conducted. With this screening approach, 12 different multi-tail lipidoid structures capable of assembling into the bicontinuous double gyroid phase are discovered. The large volume of small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) data uncovers unexpected design criteria that enable phase selection as a function of lipidoid headgroup size and architecture, tail length and architecture, and counterion identity. Surprisingly, combining branched headgroups with bulky tails forces lipidoids to adopt unconventional pseudo-disc conformations that pack into double gyroid networks, entirely distinct from other synthetic or biological amphiphiles within bicontinuous cubic phases. From a multitude of possible applications, two examples of functional materials from lipidoid liquid crystals are demonstrated. First, the fabrication of gyroid nanostructured films by interfacial PrSA, which are rapidly responsive to the external medium. Second, it is shown that colloidally-dispersed lipidoid cubosomes, for example, for drug delivery, are easily assembled using top-down solvent evaporation methods.

Biodegradable Cationic and Ionizable Cationic Lipids: A Roadmap for Safer Pharmaceutical Excipients

Cationic and ionizable cationic lipids are broadly applied as auxiliary agents, but their use is associated with adverse effects. If these excipients are rapidly degraded to endogenously occurring metabolites such as amino acids and fatty acids, their toxic potential can be minimized. So far, synthesized and evaluated biodegradable cationic and ionizable cationic lipids already showed promising results in terms of functionality and safety. Within this review, an overview about the different types of such biodegradable lipids, the available building blocks, their synthesis and cleavage by endogenous enzymes is provided. Moreover, the relationship between the structure of the lipids and their toxicity is described. Their application in drug delivery systems is critically discussed and placed in context with the lead compounds used in mRNA vaccines. Moreover, their use as preservatives is reviewed, guidance for their design is provided, and an outlook on future developments is given.

High-throughput screening of nanoparticles in drug delivery

The use of pharmacologically active compounds to manage and treat diseases is of utmost relevance in clinical practice. It is well recognized that spatial-temporal control over the delivery of these biomolecules will greatly impact their pharmacokinetic profile and ultimately their therapeutic effect. Nanoparticles (NPs) prepared from different materials have been tested successfully in the clinic for the delivery of several biomolecules including non-coding RNAs (siRNA and miRNA) and mRNAs. Indeed, the recent success of mRNA vaccines is in part due to progress in the delivery systems (NP based) that have been developed for many years. In most cases, the identification of the best formulation was done by testing a small number of novel formulations or by modification of pre-existing ones. Unfortunately, this is a low throughput and time-consuming process that hinders the identification of formulations with the highest potential. Alternatively, high-throughput combinatorial design of NP libraries may allow the rapid identification of formulations with the required release and cell/tissue targeting profile for a given application. Combinatorial approaches offer several advantages over conventional methods since they allow the incorporation of multiple components with varied chemical properties into materials, such as polymers or lipid-like materials, that will subsequently form NPs by self-assembly or chemical conjugation processes. The current review highlights the impact of high-throughput in the development of more efficient drug delivery systems with enhanced targeting and release kinetics. It also describes the current challenges in this research area as well as future directions.

Multifunctional Neomycin-Triazine-Based Cationic Lipids for Gene Delivery with Antibacterial Properties

Cationic lipids (CLs) have gained significant attention among nonviral gene delivery vectors due to their ease of synthesis and functionalization with multivalent moieties. In particular, there is an increasing request for multifunctional CLs having gene delivery capacity and antibacterial activity. Herein, we describe the design and synthesis of a novel class of aminoglycoside (AG)-based multifunctional vectors with high transfection efficiency and noticeable antibacterial properties. Specifically, cationic amphiphiles were built on a triazine scaffold, allowing for an easy derivatization with up to three potentially different substituents, such as neomycin (Neo) that serves as the polar head and one or two lipophilic tails, namely stearyl (ST) and oleyl (OL) alkyl chains and cholesteryl (Chol) tail. With the aim to shed more light on the effect of different types and numbers of lipophilic moieties on the ability of CLs to condense and transfect cells, the performance of Neo–triazine-based derivatives as gene delivery vectors was evaluated and compared. The ability of Neo–triazine-based derivatives to act as antimicrobial agents was evaluated as well. Neo–triazine-based CLs invariably exhibited excellent DNA condensation ability, even at a low charge ratio (CR, +/−). Besides, each derivative showed very good transfection performance at its optimal CR on two different cell lines, along with negligible cytotoxicity. CLs bearing symmetric two-tailed OL proved to be the most effective in transfection. Interestingly, Neo–triazine-based derivatives, used as either free lipids or lipoplexes, exhibited strong antibacterial activity against Gram-negative bacteria, especially in the case of CLs bearing one or two aliphatic chains. Altogether, these results highlight the potential of Neo–triazine-based derivatives as effective multifunctional nonviral gene delivery vectors.

Cationic lipids for gene delivery: many players, one goal

Lipid-based carriers represent the most widely used alternative to viral vectors for gene expression and gene silencing purposes. This class of non-viral vectors is particularly attractive for their ease of synthesis and chemical modifications to endow them with desirable properties. Despite combinatorial approaches have led to the generation of a large number of cationic lipids displaying different supramolecular structures and improved behavior, additional effort is needed towards the development of more and more effective cationic lipids for transfection purposes. With this review, we seek to highlight the great progress made in the design of each and every constituent domain of cationic lipids, that is, the chemical structure of the headgroup, linker and hydrophobic moieties, and on the specific effect on the assembly with nucleic acids. Since the complexity of such systems is known to affect their performances, the role of formulation, stability and phase behavior on the transfection efficiency of such assemblies will be thoroughly discussed. Our objective is to provide a conceptual framework for the development of ever more performing lipid gene delivery vectors.

Cell-based high-throughput screening of cationic polymers for efficient DNA and siRNA delivery

Development of non-viral gene vectors which can efficiently and safely transfect plasmid DNA and siRNA into cells is of great importance for gene therapy. Despite lots of efforts spent, it is still imperative to develop suitable gene vectors with better transfection efficiency and low cytotoxicity. To this end, we successfully designed, synthesized and screened a library of 120 polymers (via nucleophilic substitution reaction between dihalides and amines). With cell-based transfection screening assays, 120 polymers were tested to evaluate their transfection efficiency of transporting DNA and siRNA into cells. Our results indicated that hydrophobic modification could greatly enhance cationic polymers' transfection efficiency, and polymers with long linkers usually showed better transfection performance, especially for polymers with the linker of 1, 12-dibromododecane (L3 linker). Besides, polyalkylamines exhibited better transfection efficiency with the polymer particle size around 200 nm and the zeta potential in the range of + 40 mV to +50 mV. Interestingly, polymer particles made from N15HL3 not only exhibited better DNA transfection efficiency in HEK 293T cells but also showed higher siRNA transfection efficiency in U87 Luc-GFP cells together with low cell toxicity than Lipofectamine 2000 (one of commercial transfection reagents). Therefore, it is hoped that our study here not only provides promising gene vector candidates for further evaluation in gene therapy, but also provides valuable insights for better understanding of the relationship between the chemical structures and gene transfection efficiency to rationally design better non-viral gene vectors for gene therapy in the future.

[12]aneN3-Based Gemini-Type Amphiphiles with Two-Photon Absorption Properties for Enhanced Nonviral Gene Delivery and Bioimaging

Although a plethora of nonviral gene vectors have been developed for potential gene therapy, imageable gemini surfactants with stimuli-responsiveness and high transfection efficiency are still scarce for gene delivery. Herein, three gemini amphiphiles (DEDPP-4/8/12) consisting of an aggregation-induced emission (AIE) central fluorophore: 5,6-diphenylpyrazine-2,3-diester (DEDPP), decorated with triazole-[12]aneN₃ as the hydrophilic moiety and alkyl chains of various lengths as the hydrophobic moiety, were designed and synthesized for trackable gene delivery via optical imaging. All three amphiphiles exhibited ultralow critical micelle concentrations (CMCs) (up to 3.40 × 10^-6 M), prominent two-photon absorption properties, and solvatochromic fluorescence. Gel electrophoresis assays demonstrated that the migration of plasmid DNA was completely retarded after condensation with these gemini amphiphiles at low concentrations (up to 10 μM). In addition, the ester bond in these amphiphiles may facilitate vector degradation and DNA release, in response to esterase and the acidic environment inside cells. Upon self-assembly with DOPE to form liposomes, DEDPP-8/DOPE achieved the best transfection efficiency in four cell lines, and the transfection efficiency of DEDPP-8/DOPE in HeLa cell lines was 23.5-fold higher than that of Lipo2000, which is unusually high for small organic molecule-based nonviral vectors. Furthermore, excellent transfection efficiency of DEDPP-8/DOPE was obtained in the presence of serum, and the red fluorescence protein (RFP) gene was successfully transfected in zebrafish embryos. Both one- and two-photon fluorescence imaging clearly demonstrated the delivery process of plasmid DNA. This study demonstrated that gemini-type amphiphiles composed of a two-photon fluorophore core conjugated with triazole-[12]aneN₃ via an ester bond afforded an unprecedentedly high transfection efficiency with excellent biocompatibility, which may provide new insights for the design and development of multifunctional nonviral gene vectors for imageable gene delivery.

Combinatorial Synthesis of a Lipidoid Library by Thiolactone Chemistry: In Vitro Screening and In Vivo Validation for siRNA Delivery

Transcriptional inhibition by small interfering RNA (siRNA) delivery using synthetic transfection agents eliminates the subsequent risk of introducing mutations in relevant genes, as opposed to viral vectors. However, synthetic vectors with comparable transfection efficiency to that of viral vectors are yet to be developed. Hence, synthesizing new transfection vehicles with low toxicity is important. In this study, a library of lipid-like molecules (lipidoids) was synthesized by thiolactone chemistry. This library facilitated nonviral delivery of siRNA to mammalian cells, inducing sequence-specific knockdown of a target gene. The liposomal nanoparticles complexed with anti-green fluorescent protein (GFP) siRNA were successfully screened for transfection efficiency using a HeLa-GFP cell line. The five best-performing lipidoids identified in the screening were found to exhibit superior GFP-knockdown efficiency compared with commercially available transfection reagents. The efficiency of siRNA delivery by one of these lipidoids with minimal toxicity was further successfully evaluated in vivo using Kdrl:EGFP zebrafish embryos as a model system. Our study would be important as a facile synthetic route of efficient nonviral nucleic acid delivery to live cells and organisms.

Lipid-Based DNA Therapeutics: Hallmarks of Non-Viral Gene Delivery

Gene therapy is a promising strategy for the treatment of monogenic disorders. Non-viral gene delivery systems including lipid-based DNA therapeutics offer the opportunity to deliver an encoding gene sequence specifically to the target tissue and thus enable the expression of therapeutic proteins in diseased cells. Currently, available gene delivery approaches based on DNA are inefficient and require improvements to achieve clinical utility. In this Review, we discuss state-of-the-art lipid-based DNA delivery systems that have been investigated in a preclinical setting. We emphasize factors influencing the delivery and subsequent gene expression in vitro, ex vivo, and in vivo. In addition, we cover aspects of nanoparticle engineering and optimization for DNA therapeutics. Finally, we highlight achievements of lipid-based DNA therapies in clinical trials.

One-Pot Parallel Synthesis of Lipid Library via Thiolactone Ring Opening and Screening for Gene Delivery

Efficient delivery of nucleic acids into cells is of great interest in the field of cell biology and gene therapy. Despite a lot of research, transfection efficiency and structural diversity of gene-delivery vectors are still limited. A better understanding of the structure-function relationship of gene delivery vectors is also essential for the design of novel and intelligent delivery vectors, efficient in "difficult-to-transfect" cells and in vivo clinical applications. Most of the existing strategies for the synthesis of gene-delivery vectors require multiple steps and lengthy procedures. Here, we demonstrate a facile, three-component one-pot synthesis of a combinatorial library of 288 structurally diverse lipid-like molecules termed "lipidoids" via a thiolactone ring opening reaction. This strategy introduces the possibility to synthesize lipidoids with hydrophobic tails containing both unsaturated bonds and reducible disulfide groups. The whole synthesis and purification are convenient, extremely fast, and can be accomplished within a few hours. Screening of the produced lipidoids using HEK293T cells without addition of helper lipids resulted in identification of highly stable liposomes demonstrating ∼95% transfection efficiency with low toxicity.

Polymer synthesis by mimicking nature's strategy: the combination of ultra-fast RAFT and the Biginelli reaction

A two-stage method has been developed by mimicking nature's protein synthesis strategy to prepare plenty of polymers using limited monomers.

Superhydrophilic-Superhydrophobic Patterned Surfaces as High-Density Cell Microarrays: Optimization of Reverse Transfection

High-density microarrays can screen thousands of genetic and chemical probes at once in a miniaturized and parallelized manner, and thus are a cost-effective alternative to microwell plates. Here, high-density cell microarrays are fabricated by creating superhydrophilic-superhydrophobic micropatterns in thin, nanoporous polymer substrates such that the superhydrophobic barriers confine both aqueous solutions and adherent cells within each superhydrophilic microspot. The superhydrophobic barriers confine and prevent the mixing of larger droplet volumes, and also control the spreading of droplets independent of the volume, minimizing the variability that arises due to different liquid and surface properties. Using a novel liposomal transfection reagent, ScreenFect A, the method of reverse cell transfection is optimized on the patterned substrates and several factors that affect transfection efficiency and cytotoxicity are identified. Higher levels of transfection are achieved on HOOC- versus NH₂ -functionalized superhydrophilic spots, as well as when gelatin and fibronectin are added to the transfection mixture, while minimizing the amount of transfection reagent improves cell viability. Almost no diffusion of the printed transfection mixtures to the neighboring microspots is detected. Thus, superhydrophilic-superhydrophobic patterned surfaces can be used as cell microarrays and for optimizing reverse cell transfection conditions before performing further cell screenings.

Combinatorial Approach to Nanoarchitectonics for Nonviral Delivery of Nucleic Acids

Nanoparticles based on cationic polymers, lipids or lipidoids are of great interest in the field of gene delivery applications. The research on these nanosystems is rapidly growing as they hold promise to treat wide variety of human diseases ranging from viral infections to genetic disorders and cancer. Recently, combinatorial design principles have been adopted for rapid generation of large numbers of chemically diverse polymers and lipids capable of forming multifunctional nanocarriers for the use in gene delivery applications. At the same time, current high-throughput screening systems as well as convenient cell assays and readout techniques allow for fast evaluation of cell transfection efficiencies and toxicities of libraries of novel gene delivery agents. This allows for a rapid evaluation of structure-function relationship as well as identification of novel efficient nanocarriers for cell transfection and gene therapy. Here, the recent contribution of high-throughput synthesis to the development of novel nanocarriers for gene delivery applications is described.

Single-Tailed Lipidoids Enhance the Transfection Activity of Their Double-Tailed Counterparts

Cationic lipid-like molecules (lipidoids) are widely used for in vitro and in vivo gene delivery. Nearly all lipidoids developed to date employ double-tail or multiple-tail structures for transfection. Single-tail lipidoids are seldom considered for transfection as they have low efficiency in gene delivery. So far, there is no detailed study on the contribution to transfection efficiency of single-tail lipidoids when combined with standard double-tail lipidoids. Here, we use combinatorial chemistry to synthesize 17 double-tail and 17 single-tail lipidoids using thiol-yne and thiol-ene click chemistry, respectively. HEK 293T cells were used to analyze transfection efficiency by fluorescence microscopy and calculated based on the percentage of cells transfected. The size and zeta potential of liposomes and lipoplexes were characterized by dynamic light scattering (DLS). Intracellular DNA delivery and trafficking was further examined using confocal microscopy. Our study shows that combining single with double-tail lipidoids increases uptake of lipoplexes, as well as cellular transfection efficiency.

Combinatorial library strategies for synthesis of cationic lipid-like nanoparticles and their potential medical applications

The past two decades have witnessed the high efficiency and efficacy of cationic lipids and liposomal formations for drug delivery. The tedious synthesis of conventional lipids and the inefficiency in studying structure-activity relationships, however, have hindered the clinical translation of lipid nanoparticle delivery systems. Combinatorial synthesis of lipid-like nanoparticles ('lipidoids') has recently emerged as an approach to accelerate the development of these delivery platforms. Utilizing a high-throughput screening strategy, the libraries of lipidoids are sorted and prime candidates for the delivery in the intended application can be identified and optimized for the next generation. In this review, we outline methods used for combinatorial lipidoid synthesis, the application of high-throughput screening, and the current medical applications of candidate lipidoids.

Exploring the role of polymer structure on intracellular nucleic acid delivery via polymeric nanoparticles

Intracellular nucleic acid delivery has the potential to treat many genetically-based diseases, however, gene delivery safety and efficacy remains a challenging obstacle. One promising approach is the use of polymers to form polymeric nanoparticles with nucleic acids that have led to exciting advances in non-viral gene delivery. Understanding the successes and failures of gene delivery polymers and structures is the key to engineering optimal polymers for gene delivery in the future. This article discusses the polymer structural features that enable effective intracellular delivery of DNA and RNA, including protection of nucleic acid cargo, cellular uptake, endosomal escape, vector unpacking, and delivery to the intracellular site of activity. The chemical properties that aid in each step of intracellular nucleic acid delivery are described and specific structures of note are highlighted. Understanding the chemical design parameters of polymeric nucleic acid delivery nanoparticles is important to achieving the goal of safe and effective non-viral genetic nanomedicine.

Identification of siRNA delivery enhancers by a chemical library screen

Most delivery systems for small interfering RNA therapeutics depend on endocytosis and release from endo-lysosomal compartments. One approach to improve delivery is to identify small molecules enhancing these steps. It is unclear to what extent such enhancers can be universally applied to different delivery systems and cell types. Here, we performed a compound library screen on two well-established siRNA delivery systems, lipid nanoparticles and cholesterol conjugated-siRNAs. We identified fifty-one enhancers improving gene silencing 2–5 fold. Strikingly, most enhancers displayed specificity for one delivery system only. By a combination of quantitative fluorescence and electron microscopy we found that the enhancers substantially differed in their mechanism of action, increasing either endocytic uptake or release of siRNAs from endosomes. Furthermore, they acted either on the delivery system itself or the cell, by modulating the endocytic system via distinct mechanisms. Interestingly, several compounds displayed activity on different cell types. As proof of principle, we showed that one compound enhanced siRNA delivery in primary endothelial cells in vitro and in the endocardium in the mouse heart. This study suggests that a pharmacological approach can improve the delivery of siRNAs in a system-specific fashion, by exploiting distinct mechanisms and acting upon multiple cell types.

Multifunctional poly(methacrylate) polyplex libraries: A platform for gene delivery inspired by nature

Polymer-based gene delivery systems have enormous potential in biomedicine, but their efficiency is often limited by poor biocompatibility. Poly(methacrylate)s (PMAs) are an interesting class of polymers which allow to explore structure-activity relationships of polymer functionalities for polyplex formation in oligonucleotide delivery. Here, we synthesized and tested a library of PMA polymers, containing functional groups contributing to the different steps of gene delivery, from oligonucleotide complexation to cellular internalization and endosomal escape. By variation of the molar ratios of the individual building blocks, the physicochemical properties of the polymers and polyplexes were fine-tuned to reduce toxicity as well as to increase activity of the polyplexes. To further enhance transfection efficiency, a cell-penetrating peptide (CPP)-like functionality was introduced on the polymeric backbone. With the ability to synthesize large libraries of polymers in parallel we also developed a workflow for a mid-to-high throughput screening, focusing first on safety parameters that are accessible by high-throughput approaches such as blood compatibility and toxicity towards host cells and only at a later stage on more laborious tests for the ability to deliver oligonucleotides. To arrive at a better understanding of the molecular basis of activity, furthermore, the effect of the presence of heparan sulfates on the surface of host cells was assessed and the mechanism of cell entry and intracellular trafficking investigated for those polymers that showed a suitable pharmacological profile. Following endocytic uptake, rapid endosomal release occurred. Interestingly, the presence of heparan sulfates on the cell surface had a negative impact on the activity of those polyplexes that were sensitive to decomplexation by heparin in solution. In summary, the screening approach identified two polymers, which form polyplexes with high stability and transfection capacity exceeding the one of poly(ethylene imine) also in the presence of serum.