Kinetic and thermodynamic characterization of the reaction catalyzed by a polynucleotide kinase ribozyme

Nucleobase modification by an RNA enzyme

Ribozymes can catalyze phosphoryl or nucleotidyl transfer onto ribose hydroxyls of RNA chains. We report a single ribozyme that performs both reactions, with a nucleobase serving as initial acceptor moiety. This unprecedented combined reaction was revealed while investigating potential contributions of ribose hydroxyls to catalysis by kinase ribozyme K28. For a 58nt, cis-acting form of K28, each nucleotide could be replaced with the corresponding 2΄F analog without loss of activity, indicating that no particular 2΄OH is specifically required. Reactivities of two-stranded K28 variants with oligodeoxynucleotide acceptor strands devoid of any 2΄OH moieties implicate modification on an internal guanosine N-2, rather than a ribose hydroxyl. Product mass suggests formation of a GDP(S) adduct along with a second thiophosphorylation, implying that the ribozyme catalyzes both phosphoryl and nucleotidyl transfers. This is further supported by transfer of radiolabels into product from both α and γ phosphates of donor molecules. Furthermore, periodate reactivity of the final product signifies acquisition of a ribose sugar with an intact 2΄-3΄ vicinal diol. Neither nucleobase modification nor nucleotidyl transfer has previously been reported for a kinase ribozyme, making this a first-in-class ribozyme. Base-modifying ribozymes may have played important roles in early RNA world evolution by enhancing nucleic acid functions.

DNA Oligonucleotide 3'-Phosphorylation by a DNA Enzyme

T4 polynucleotide kinase is widely used for 5'-phosphorylation of DNA and RNA oligonucleotide termini, but no natural protein enzyme is capable of 3'-phosphorylation. Here, we report the in vitro selection of deoxyribozymes (DNA enzymes) capable of DNA oligonucleotide 3'-phosphorylation, using a 5'-triphosphorylated RNA transcript (pppRNA) as the phosphoryl donor. The basis of selection was the capture, during each selection round, of the 3'-phosphorylated DNA substrate terminus by 2-methylimidazole activation of the 3'-phosphate (forming 3'-MeImp) and subsequent splint ligation with a 5'-amino DNA oligonucleotide. Competing and precedented DNA-catalyzed reactions were DNA phosphodiester hydrolysis or deglycosylation, each also leading to a 3'-phosphate but at a different nucleotide position within the DNA substrate. One oligonucleotide 3'-kinase deoxyribozyme, obtained from an N40 random pool and named 3'Kin1, can 3'-phosphorylate nearly any DNA oligonucleotide substrate for which the 3'-terminus has the sequence motif 5'-NKR-3', where N denotes any oligonucleotide sequence, K = T or G, and R = A or G. These results establish the viabilty of in vitro selection for identifying DNA enzymes that 3'-phosphorylate DNA oligonucleotides.

A modular tyrosine kinase deoxyribozyme with discrete aptamer and catalyst domains

We assess the utility of integrating a predetermined aptamer DNA module adjacent to a random catalytic DNA region for identifying new deoxyribozymes by in vitro selection. By placing a known ATP aptamer next to an N40 random region, an explicitly modular DNA catalyst for tyrosine side chain phosphorylation is identified. The results have implications for broader identification of deoxyribozymes that function with small-molecule substrates.

Lewis acid catalysis of phosphoryl transfer from a copper(II)-NTP complex in a kinase ribozyme

The chemical strategies used by ribozymes to enhance reaction rates are revealed in part from their metal ion and pH requirements. We find that kinase ribozyme K28(1-77)C, in contrast with previously characterized kinase ribozymes, requires Cu²⁺ for optimal catalysis of thiophosphoryl transfer from GTPγS. Phosphoryl transfer from GTP is greatly reduced in the absence of Cu²⁺, indicating a specific catalytic role independent of any potential interactions with the GTPγS thiophosphoryl group. In-line probing and ATPγS competition both argue against direct Cu²⁺ binding by RNA; rather, these data establish that Cu²⁺ enters the active site within a Cu²⁺•GTPγS or Cu²⁺•GTP chelation complex, and that Cu²⁺•nucleobase interactions further enforce Cu²⁺ selectivity and position the metal ion for Lewis acid catalysis. Replacing Mg²⁺ with [Co(NH₃)₆]³⁺ significantly reduced product yield, but not k_obs, indicating that the role of inner-sphere Mg²⁺ coordination is structural rather than catalytic. Replacing Mg²⁺ with alkaline earths of increasing ionic radii (Ca²⁺, Sr²⁺ and Ba²⁺) gave lower yields and approximately linear rates of product accumulation. Finally, we observe that reaction rates increased with pH in log-linear fashion with an apparent pKa = 8.0 ± 0.1, indicating deprotonation in the rate-limiting step.

A small ribozyme with dual-site kinase activity

Phosphoryl transfer onto backbone hydroxyls is a recognized catalytic activity of nucleic acids. We find that kinase ribozyme K28 possesses an unusually complex active site that promotes (thio)phosphorylation of two residues widely separated in primary sequence. After allowing the ribozyme to radiolabel itself by phosphoryl transfer from [γ-³²P]GTP, DNAzyme-mediated cleavage yielded two radiolabeled cleavage fragments, indicating phosphorylation sites within each of the two cleavage fragments. These sites were mapped by alkaline digestion and primer extension pausing. Enzymatic digestion and mutational analysis identified nucleotides important for activity and established the active structure as being a constrained pseudoknot with unusual connectivity that may juxtapose the two reactive sites. Nuclease sensitivities for nucleotides near the pseudoknot core were altered in the presence of GTPγS, indicating donor-induced folding. The 5′ target site was more strongly favored in full-length ribozyme K28 (128 nt) than in truncated RNAs (58 nt). Electrophoretic mobilities of self-thiophosphorylated products on organomercurial gels are distinct from the 5′ mono-thiophosphorylated product produced by reaction with polynucleotide kinase, potentially indicating simultaneous labeling of both sites within individual RNA strands. Our evidence supports a single, compact structure with local dynamics, rather than global rearrangement, as being responsible for dual-site phosphorylation.

Assembly and activation of a kinase ribozyme

RNA activities can be regulated by modulating the relative energies of all conformations in a folding landscape; however, it is often unknown precisely how peripheral elements perturb the overall landscape in the absence of discrete alternative folds (inactive ensemble). This work explores the effects of sequence and secondary structure in governing kinase ribozyme activity. Kin.46 catalyzes thiophosphoryl transfer from ATPγS onto the 5' hydroxyl of polynucleotide substrates, and is regulated 10,000-fold by annealing an effector oligonucleotide to form activator helix P4. Transfer kinetics for an extensive series of ribozyme variants identified several dispensable internal single-stranded segments, in addition to a potential pseudoknot at the active site between segments J1/4 and J3/2 that is partially supported by compensatory rescue. Standard allosteric mechanisms were ruled out, such as formation of discrete repressive structures or docking P4 into the rest of the ribozyme via backbone 2' hydroxyls. Instead, P4 serves both to complete an important structural element (100-fold contribution to the reaction relative to a P4-deleted variant) and to mitigate nonspecific, inhibitory effects of the single-stranded tail (an additional 100-fold contribution to the apparent rate constant, k(obs)). Thermodynamic activation parameters ΔH(‡) and ΔS(‡), calculated from the temperature dependence of k(obs), varied with tail length and sequence. Inhibitory effects of the unpaired tail are largely enthalpic for short tails and are both enthalpic and entropic for longer tails. These results refine the structural view of this kinase ribozyme and highlight the importance of nonspecific ensemble effects in conformational regulation by peripheral elements.

Template-directed ligation of tethered mononucleotides by t4 DNA ligase for kinase ribozyme selection

BACKGROUND

In vitro selection of kinase ribozymes for small molecule metabolites, such as free nucleosides, will require partition systems that discriminate active from inactive RNA species. While nucleic acid catalysis of phosphoryl transfer is well established for phosphorylation of 5' or 2' OH of oligonucleotide substrates, phosphorylation of diffusible small molecules has not been demonstrated.

METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS

This study demonstrates the ability of T4 DNA ligase to capture RNA strands in which a tethered monodeoxynucleoside has acquired a 5' phosphate. The ligation reaction therefore mimics the partition step of a selection for nucleoside kinase (deoxy)ribozymes. Ligation with tethered substrates was considerably slower than with nicked, fully duplex DNA, even though the deoxynucleotides at the ligation junction were Watson-Crick base paired in the tethered substrate. Ligation increased markedly when the bridging template strand contained unpaired spacer nucleotides across from the flexible tether, according to the trends: A(2)>A(1)>A(3)>A(4)>A(0)>A(6)>A(8)>A(10) and T(2)>T(3)>T(4)>T(6) approximately T(1)>T(8)>T(10). Bridging T's generally gave higher yield of ligated product than bridging A's. ATP concentrations above 33 microM accumulated adenylated intermediate and decreased yields of the gap-sealed product, likely due to re-adenylation of dissociated enzyme. Under optimized conditions, T4 DNA ligase efficiently (>90%) joined a correctly paired, or TratioG wobble-paired, substrate on the 3' side of the ligation junction while discriminating approximately 100-fold against most mispaired substrates. Tethered dC and dG gave the highest ligation rates and yields, followed by tethered deoxyinosine (dI) and dT, with the slowest reactions for tethered dA. The same kinetic trends were observed in ligase-mediated capture in complex reaction mixtures with multiple substrates. The "universal" analog 5-nitroindole (dNI) did not support ligation when used as the tethered nucleotide.

CONCLUSIONS/SIGNIFICANCE

Our results reveal a novel activity for T4 DNA ligase (template-directed ligation of a tethered mononucleotide) and establish this partition scheme as being suitable for the selection of ribozymes that phosphorylate mononucleoside substrates.

Convergent donor and acceptor substrate utilization among kinase ribozymes

Accommodation of donor and acceptor substrates is critical to the catalysis of (thio)phosphoryl group transfer, but there has been no systematic study of donor nucleotide recognition by kinase ribozymes, and there is relatively little known about the structural requirements for phosphorylating internal 2′OH. To address these questions, new self-phosphorylating ribozymes were selected that utilize ATP(gammaS) or GTP(gammaS) for 2′OH (thio)phosphorylation. Eight independent sequence families were identified among 57 sequenced isolates. Kinetics, donor nucleotide recognition and secondary structures were analyzed for representatives from each family. Each ribozyme was highly specific for its cognate donor. Competition assays with nucleotide analogs showed a remarkable convergence of donor recognition requirements, with critical contributions to recognition provided by the Watson–Crick face of the nucleobase, lesser contributions from donor nucleotide ribose hydroxyls, and little or no contribution from the Hoogsteen face. Importantly, most ribozymes showed evidence of significant interaction with one or more donor phosphates, suggesting that—unlike most aptamers—these ribozymes use phosphate interactions to orient the gamma phosphate within the active site for in-line displacement. All but one of the mapped (thio)phosphorylation sites are on unpaired guanosines within internal bulges. Comparative structural analysis identified three loosely-defined consensus structural motifs for kinase ribozyme active sites.

In vitro selection of a 5'-purine ribonucleotide transferase ribozyme

Here we report in vitro selection of a novel ribozyme that catalyzes the 5′-nucleotidyl transfer reaction forming the 2′–5′ phosphodiester bond. This ribozyme was retrieved as a sole sequence in the pool enriched for the 5′-triphosphate-dependent activities in incorporating ATP-γS. The originally selected ribozyme consisting of 109-nucleotide (nt) was miniaturized to 45-nt M4 ribozyme via a series of mutation studies, and based on this mini-ribozyme a trans-acting system was constructed. One of the most challenging tasks in our study was to determine the chemistry occurring at the 5′-ppp site. We utilized various analytical methods including MALDI-TOF analysis of the product generated by the trans-acting system and elucidated the chemistry to be 3′→5′ mononucleotide extension forming the 2′–5′ phosphodiester bond. Interestingly, M4 ribozyme promiscuously accepts a variety of purine nucleotides bearing 5′-mono-, di- and triphosphates as substrates. This remarkable ability of M4 ribozyme would lead us to the development of a new tool for the 5′-modification of RNAs with unique chemical groups.

Topological rearrangement yields structural stabilization and interhelical distance constraints in the Kin.46 self-phosphorylating ribozyme

The Kin.46 ribozyme catalyzes transfer of the gamma (thio)phosphoryl group of ATP (or ATPgammaS) to the ribozyme's 5' hydroxyl. Single-turnover catalytic activities of topologically rearranged versions of Kin.46 were studied to gain insight into its overall tertiary architecture. The distal ends of stems P3 and P4 were tethered through a single-stranded connection domain that altered the interhelical connectivity. The shortest linkers interfered with catalysis, while seven or more nucleotides (nt) in the linker allowed near-normal catalytic rates, suggesting that a distance of roughly 25-35 A optimally separates the termini of these helices. Activity was maximal when the tether contained 15 nt, at which point the k(cat) (0.016 min(-1)) and Km (1.2 mM) values were identical to those of a nontethered control. The presence of the tether alters Mg(2+) dependence, in that Mg2+ binding appears to be more cooperative in the tethered ribozyme (Hill coefficient 1.4-1.8 versus 0.8 for the nontethered ribozyme). Binding affinity for the ATPgammaS substrate increases at elevated concentrations of Mg2+, particularly for the tethered ribozyme. The tethered ribozyme displays significantly enhanced thermal stability, with a maximum initial velocity (0.126 min(-1)) at 60 degrees C, whereas the nontethered ribozyme has a lower maximum initial velocity (0.051 min(-1)) at 50 degrees C. The tether also significantly reduces the apparent entropy of activation. Both of these effects can be understood in terms of stabilization of the ribozyme in a conformation that is on-path with respect to catalysis, and in terms of facilitating formation of the allosteric activation helix P4.

Multiple-turnover thio-ATP hydrolase and phospho-enzyme intermediate formation activities catalyzed by an RNA enzyme

Ribozymes that phosphorylate internal 2′-OH positions mimic the first mechanistic step of P-type ATPase enzymes by forming a phospho-enzyme intermediate. We previously described 2′-autophosphorylation and autothiophosphorylation by the 2PTmin3.2 ribozyme. In the present work we demonstrate that the thiophosphorylated form of this ribozyme can de-thiophosphorylate in the absence of ATPγS. Identical ionic conditions yield a thiophosphorylated strand when ATPγS is included, thus effecting a net ATPγS hydrolysis. The de-thiophosphorylation step is nearly independent of pH over the range of 6.3–8.5 and does not require a specifically folded RNA structure, but this step is greatly stimulated by transition metal ions. By monitoring thiophosphate release, we observe 29–46 ATPγS hydrolyzed per ribozyme strand in 24 h, corresponding to a turnover rate of 1.2–2.0 h⁻¹. The existence of an ATP- (or thio-ATP-)powered catalytic cycle raises the possibility of using ribozymes to transduce chemical energy into mechanical work for nucleic acid nanodevices.

Tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine stabilization of RNA: comparison with dithiothreitol for use with nucleic acid and thiophosphoryl chemistry

We assessed the utility of the sulfhydryl reductant Tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine (TCEP) for both nucleic acid and thiophosphate chemistry, including its effects on organomercurial gel electrophoresis, RNA catalysis, RNA backbone stability, and the intrinsic stability of TCEP. The sulfhydryls of dithiothreitol (DTT) compete with thiophosphates for binding to the mercury within [(N-acryloylamino)phenyl] mercuric chloride (APM) polyacrylamide gels, whereas millimolar concentrations of TCEP gave no difference in the fraction of thiophosphorylated RNA retained on the APM interface relative to samples containing no reductant. Ribozyme activity in TCEP, assessed by the self-thiophosphorylating Kin.46 ribozyme, was unaffected by the presence of DTT or TCEP or by the absence of reductant, as measured on APM gels and evaluated by Michaelis-Menten kinetics. Unexpectedly, TCEP more than doubled the half-life of full-length RNA at 50 and 70 degrees C, whether in 5 or 50mM MgCl(2), relative to DTT and the absence of reductant. Under these same conditions, the 5(')-thiophosphate showed negligible decay, and TCEP was more stable than DTT. TCEP thermostability was equivalent in the presence of 5 or 50mM MgCl(2) and 10mM adenosine or ATP.

Zeptomole detection of a viral nucleic acid using a target-activated ribozyme

We describe a strategy for the ultra-sensitive detection of nucleic acids using "half" ribozymes that are devoid of catalytic activity unless completed by a trans-acting target nucleic acid. The half-ribozyme concept was initially demonstrated using a construct derived from a multiple turnover Class I ligase. Iterative RNA selection was carried out to evolve this half-ribozyme into one activated by a conserved sequence present in the hepatitis C virus (HCV) genome. Following sequence optimization of substrate RNAs, this HCV-activated half-ribozyme displayed a maximal turnover rate of 69 min(-1) (pH 8.3) and was induced in rate by approximately 2.6 x 10(9)-fold by the HCV target. It detected the HCV target oligonucleotide in the zeptomole range (6700 molecules), a sensitivity of detection roughly 2.6 x 10(6)-fold greater than that previously demonstrated by oligonucleotide-activated ribozymes, and one that is sufficient for molecular diagnostic applications.

In vitro selection of kinase and ligase deoxyribozymes

Exploration of the limits of biocatalysis has led to the discovery that DNA has significant potential for enzymatic function. This makes possible the construction of DNA enzymes or "deoxyribozymes" for catalyzing various chemical reactions that could be used to address fundamental questions in biocatalysis or that could find unique applications in biotechnology. Of significant interest are self-modification reactions, given the fundamental role that DNA serves in modern living systems. Recently, in vitro selection strategies have been used to isolate prototypical ATP-dependent deoxyribozymes from random-sequence populations of DNA that catalyze DNA phosphorylation and others that catalyze DNA adenylation. In nature, protein enzymes such as T4 DNA kinase and T4 DNA ligase catalyze identical chemical reactions. These findings suggest that DNA constructs could be engineered to efficiently catalyze other self-modifying reactions, including ATP-dependent DNA ligation. This article provides a detailed overview of the methods used to isolate deoxyribozymes that promote ATP-dependent DNA ligation.

In vitro selection of functional nucleic acids

In vitro selection allows rare functional RNA or DNA molecules to be isolated from pools of over 10(15) different sequences. This approach has been used to identify RNA and DNA ligands for numerous small molecules, and recent three-dimensional structure solutions have revealed the basis for ligand recognition in several cases. By selecting high-affinity and -specificity nucleic acid ligands for proteins, promising new therapeutic and diagnostic reagents have been identified. Selection experiments have also been carried out to identify ribozymes that catalyze a variety of chemical transformations, including RNA cleavage, ligation, and synthesis, as well as alkylation and acyl-transfer reactions and N-glycosidic and peptide bond formation. The existence of such RNA enzymes supports the notion that ribozymes could have directed a primitive metabolism before the evolution of protein synthesis. New in vitro protein selection techniques should allow for a direct comparison of the frequency of ligand binding and catalytic structures in pools of random sequence polynucleotides versus polypeptides.

Phosphorylating DNA with DNA

Nearly 50 individual DNAs with polynucleotide kinase-like activity were isolated from a random-sequence pool by using in vitro selection. Each self-phosphorylating deoxyribozyme makes use of one or more of the eight standard NTPs or dNTPs as a source of activated phosphate. Although most prototypic deoxyribozymes poorly differentiate between the ribose and deoxyribose moieties, further optimization by in vitro selection produced variants that display up to 100-fold discrimination between related NTP and dNTP substrates. An optimized ATP-dependent deoxyribozyme uses ATP >40,000-fold more efficiently than CTP, GTP, or UTP. This enzyme operates with a rate enhancement of nearly one billion-fold over the uncatalyzed rate of ATP hydrolysis. A bimolecular version of the ATP-dependent deoxyribozyme was further engineered to phosphorylate specific target DNAs with multiple turnover. The substrate-recognition patterns and rate enhancements intrinsic to these DNAs are characteristic of naturally occurring RNA and protein enzymes, supporting the hypothesis that DNA has sufficient catalytic potential to function as an enzyme in biological systems.

Kinetics at a multifunctional RNA active site

Kinetics of a self-capping RNA, Iso6, have been investigated to constrain the catalytic mechanism. The role of phosphates has been examined by varying the number of phosphates on the nucleophilic attacking group or on the RNA. While the number of phosphates in the nucleophile affects capping kinetics, only KM but not kcat is altered. The KM values for GMP, GDP, GTP and ppppG are 200, 11, 13 and 31 microM, respectively. A reaction product, pyrophosphate, is also found to strongly inhibit RNA activities through a competitive exchange mechanism with an apparent Ki of 200 nM. Uniquely strong binding of pyrophosphate supports the idea that capping originated by utilization of the initial pyrophosphate leaving group site for capping nucleophiles. In contrast to the nucleophile phosphate, change of 5' RNA terminus from triphosphate to tetraphosphate enhances the overall rate and kcat by 40%, with little effect on KM. Thus, only the leaving group appears to affect the rate of the chemical transformation. We propose two possible mechanisms that explain this apparent rate-limiting chemical step, either dissociation of pyrophosphate to form a metaphosphate monoester intermediate or formation of a circular phosphoramidate intermediate, using an internal RNA nitrogenous group. A single essential Ca ion is required for all activities.

Isolation of novel ribozymes that ligate AMP-activated RNA substrates

BACKGROUND

The protein enzymes RNA ligase and DNA ligase catalyze the ligation of nucleic acids via an adenosine-5'-5'-pyrophosphate 'capped' RNA or DNA intermediate. The activation of nucleic acid substrates by adenosine 5'-monophosphate (AMP) may be a vestige of 'RNA world' catalysis. AMP-activated ligation seems ideally suited for catalysis by ribozymes (RNA enzymes), because an RNA motif capable of tightly and specifically binding AMP has previously been isolated.

RESULTS

We used in vitro selection and directed evolution to explore the ability of ribozymes to catalyze the template-directed ligation of AMP-activated RNAs. We subjected a pool of 10(15) RNA molecules, each consisting of long random sequences flanking a mutagenized adenosine triphosphate (ATP) aptamer, to ten rounds of in vitro selection, including three rounds involving mutagenic polymerase chain reaction. Selection was for the ligation of an oligonucleotide to the 5'-capped active pool RNA species. Many different ligase ribozymes were isolated; these ribozymes had rates of reaction up to 0.4 ligations per hour, corresponding to rate accelerations of approximately 5 x10(5) over the templated, but otherwise uncatalyzed, background reaction rate. Three characterized ribozymes catalyzed the formation of 3'-5'-phosphodiester bonds and were highly specific for activation by AMP at the ligation site.

CONCLUSIONS

The existence of a new class of ligase ribozymes is consistent with the hypothesis that the unusual mechanism of the biological ligases resulted from a conservation of mechanism during an evolutionary replacement of a primordial ribozyme ligase by a more modern protein enzyme. The newly isolated ligase ribozymes may also provide a starting point for the isolation of ribozymes that catalyze the polymerization of AMP-activated oligonucleotides or mononucleotides, which might have been the prebiotic analogs of nucleoside triphosphates.

Principles and methods of evolutionary biotechnology

Evolutionary biotechnology applies the principles of molecular evolution to biotechnology, leading to novel techniques for the creation of biomolecules with a great variety of functions for technical and medical purposes. Several basic principles for the application of evolutionary strategies can be derived from a comprehensive theory of molecular evolution. Prerequisites for evolutionary biotechnology are summarized with respect to the different classes of biomolecules and a few, selected applications are described in detail. Concepts for the technical implementation of evolutionary strategies are presented which allow automatized, high throughput processes.

The New World of ribozymes

The number of RNA molecules that have novel catalytic activities has dramatically increased during the past two years. This ribozymic boom is not due to the discovery of additional examples of natural ribozymes but rather to the development of artificial ribozymes isolated by in vitro selection and evolution techniques. The structural and functional complexities of these artificial ribozymes, however, do not match those of the larger natural ribozymes. The understanding of both RNA structure and catalysis performed by natural and artificial ribozymes paves the way for the creation of RNA molecules that are able to efficiently catalyze more complex reactions.

Mechanistic aspects of enzymatic catalysis: lessons from comparison of RNA and protein enzymes

A classic approach in biology, both organismal and cellular, is to compare morphologies in order to glean structural and functional commonalities. The comparative approach has also proven valuable on a molecular level. For example, phylogenetic comparisons of RNA sequences have led to determination of conserved secondary and even tertiary structures, and comparisons of protein structures have led to classifications of families of protein folds. Here we take this approach in a mechanistic direction, comparing protein and RNA enzymes. The aim of comparing RNA and protein enzymes is to learn about fundamental physical and chemical principles of biological catalysis. The more recently discovered RNA enzymes, or ribozymes, provide a distinct perspective on long-standing questions of biological catalysis. The differences described in this review have taught us about the aspects of RNA and proteins that are distinct, whereas the common features have helped us to understand the aspects that are fundamental to biological catalysis. This has allowed the framework that was put forth by Jencks for protein catalysts over 20 years ago (1) to be extended to RNA enzymes, generalized, and strengthened.

Are engineered proteins getting competition from RNA?

Progress in several areas of research is pushing back the supposed limitations of nucleic acid structure and function. New ligand-binding and catalytic RNAs are being created at a rapid pace. Some engineered RNAs offer potential as therapeutic agents whereas others can be used as model systems to study the principles that direct structure formation, molecular recognition and catalytic function by nucleic acids.

Chance and necessity in the selection of nucleic acid catalysts

In Tom Stoppard's famous play [Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead], the ill-fated heroes toss a coin 101 times. The first 100 times they do so the coin lands heads up. The chance of this happening is approximately 1 in 10(30), a sequence of events so rare that one might argue that it could only happen in such a delightful fiction. Similarly rare events, however, may underlie the origins of biological catalysis. What is the probability that an RNA, DNA, or protein molecule of a given random sequence will display a particular catalytic activity? The answer to this question determines whether a collection of such sequences, such as might result from prebiotic chemistry on the early earth, is extremely likely or unlikely to contain catalytically active molecules, and hence whether the origin of life itself is a virtually inevitable consequence of chemical laws or merely a bizarre fluke. The fact that a priori estimates of this probability, given by otherwise informed chemists and biologists, ranged from 10(-5) to 10(-50), inspired us to begin to address the question experimentally. As it turns out, the chance that a given random sequence RNA molecule will be able to catalyze an RNA polymerase-like phosphoryl transfer reaction is close to 1 in 10(13), rare enough, to be sure, but nevertheless in a range that is comfortably accessible by experiment. It is the purpose of this Account to describe the recent advances in combinatorial biochemistry that have made it possible for us to explore the abundance and diversity of catalysts existing in nucleic acid sequence space.