Evidence for the existence of three or more slow phases in the refolding of ribonuclease A and some characteristics of the phases

The measurement of volume change by capillary dilatometry

Capillary dilatometry enables direct measurement of changes in volume, an extensive thermodynamic property. The results provide insight into the changes in hydration that occur upon protein folding, ligand binding, and the interactions of proteins with nucleic acids and other cellular components. Often the entropy change arising from release of hydrating solvent provides the main driving force of a binding reaction. For technical reasons, though, capillary dilatometry has not been as widely used in protein biochemistry and biophysics as other methods such as calorimetry. Described here are simple apparatus and simple methods, which bring the technique within the capacity of any laboratory. Even very simple results are shown to have implications for macromolecular‐based phenomena. Protein examples are described.

Folding pathway of guanidine-denatured disulfide-intact wild-type and mutant bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A

The refolding kinetics of guanidine-denatured disulfide-intact bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) and its proline-42-to-alanine mutant (Pro42Ala) have been studied by monitoring tyrosine burial and 2'-cytidine monophosphate (2'CMP) inhibitor binding. The folding rate for wild-type RNase A is faster in the presence of the inhibitor 2'CMP than in its absence, indicating that the transition-state structure in the rate-determining step is stabilized by 2'CMP. The folding rate monitored by 2'CMP binding to the major slow-folding species of Pro42Ala RNase A is faster than the folding rate monitored by tyrosine burial; however, the folding rate monitored by inhibitor binding to the minor slow-folding species is decreased significantly over the folding rate monitored by tyrosine burial, indicating that the major and minor slow-folding species of Pro42Ala fold to the native state with different transition-state conformations in the rate-determining step.

Slow-folding kinetics of ribonuclease-A by volume change and circular dichroism: evidence for two independent reactions

The slow refolding of guanidine-HCl-denatured ribonuclease-A was studied by volume change and by kinetic CD at 222 and 276 nm. Dilatometric measurements revealed that on refolding there is a fast volume change of +232 mL/mol of protein. This is followed by a very slow nonexponential change that takes about 25 min to reach equilibrium. By adding varying amounts of (NH4)2SO4, the slow volume change curve was resolved into 2 concurrent reactions. The faster of the 2 slow events entails a negative volume change of -64 mL/mol of protein and appears to arise from proline isomerization. The slower process, attended by a positive change of +53 mL/mol of protein, has properties consistent with the "XY" reaction of Lin and Brands (1983, Biochemistry 22:563-573). This reaction is so named because the conformational nature of neither its initial (Y) nor its final state (X) is known; the transition is characterized solely by its absorbance and fluorescence kinetics. These are the first direct physical measures attributable to the "XY" process. The early formation of a compact structure in the event responsible for the rapid +232-mL/mol volume change, however, is consistent with the sequential model of folding (Cook KH, Schmid FX, Baldwin RL, 1979, Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 76:6157-6161; Kim PS, Baldwin RL, 1980, Biochemistry 19:6124-6129). The usefulness of volume change measurements as a method of detecting structural rearrangements was confirmed by finding agreement between time constants obtained from parallel volume change and kinetic CD experiments. The measured volume changes arise from both changes in hydration and changes in the packing of atoms in the interior of the protein.

Purification and properties of multiple molecular forms of yeast peptidyl prolyl cis-trans isomerase

By hydrophobic chromatography on a butyl-Toyopearl 650 M column, yeast peptidyl prolyl cis-trans isomerase (PPIase) was separated into at least three molecular components (PPI-I, PPI-II and PPI-III) in their native forms. On the basis of the result of SDS-PAGE, PPI-II and PPI-III were highly purified and their molecular masses were estimated to be 16.5 and 17.2 kDa, respectively. However, PPI-I was still a mixture of two components with molecular masses of 23.3 and 24.1 kDa. The UV absorption spectrum of PPI-II was slightly different from that of PPI-III. In contrast, the CD spectra of the two proteins were essentially identical in the far-UV region. Upon addition of an immunosuppressant, cyclosporine A (CsA), the absorption spectra of the two highly purified proteins were subtly changed, which was indicative of some alterations in the microenvironments of the aromatic amino-acid residues. The two proteins exhibited subtle but clear differences in the kinetic parameters (kc/Km) for the PPIase-catalyzed cis-trans isomerization and in the inhibition constants of CsA for the PPIase activity. These results lead to the conclusions that (1), a family of PPIases exists in one organism and that (2), one member of the family has multiple molecular forms with different substrate specificities and different affinities for the drugs (inhibitors).

Cis proline mutants of ribonuclease A. II. Elimination of the slow-folding forms by mutation

Ribonuclease A is known to form an equilibrium mixture of fast-folding (UF) and slow-folding (US) species. Rapid unfolding to UF is then followed by a reaction in the unfolded state, which produces a mixture of UF, USII, USI, and possibly also minor populations of other US species. The two cis proline residues, P93 and P114, are logical candidates for producing the major US species after unfolding, by slow cis <==> trans isomerization. Much work has been done in the past on testing this proposal, but the results have been controversial. Site-directed mutagenesis is used here. Four single mutants, P93A, P93S, P114A, and P114G, and also the double mutant P93A, P114G have been made and tested for the formation of US species after unfolding. The single mutants P114G and P114A still show slow isomerization reactions after unfolding that produce US species; thus, Pro 114 is not required for the formation of at least one of the major US species of ribonuclease A. Both the refolding kinetics and the isomerization kinetics after unfolding of the Pro 93 single mutants are unexpectedly complex, possibly because the substituted amino acid forms a cis peptide bond, which should undergo cis --> trans isomerization after unfolding. The kinetics of peptide bond isomerization are not understood at present and the Pro 93 single mutants cannot be used yet to investigate the role of Pro 93 in forming the US species of ribonuclease A. The double mutant P93A, P114G shows single exponential kinetics measured by CD, and it shows no evidence of isomerization after unfolding.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Identification of a new site of conformational heterogeneity in unfolded ribonuclease A

The results presented here indicate that there are two slowly exchanging conformational isomers in unfolded bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) in the vicinity of Lys-41. The conformational heterogeneity is not observed in the fully folded protein. Therefore, one of the isomers may correspond to one of the slow-folding forms of the protein observed when refolding is initiated. These results were obtained from a chemically modified form of the protein, CL(7-41) RNase A, that has a dinitrophenyl cross-link between the epsilon-amino groups of Lys-7 and Lys-41. Extensive physical studies have shown that the cross-link does not significantly perturb the structure or the folding pathways of the protein. Therefore, the results obtained from this modified form of the protein are relevant to intact RNase A. The one-dimensional (1D) NMR spectrum of heat-unfolded CL(7-41) RNase A reveals that the singlet resonance for the C3H ring proton of the dinitrophenyl cross-link has been split into two unequal peaks in a 3:1 ratio, indicating that there are two distinct environments for the dinitrophenyl group. Variations in temperature, and the addition of urea, do not affect the relative peak intensities. The two peaks collapse into one after the protein is refolded. The observed splitting must originate from a slow reversible isomerization (greater than 100 msec) in a neighboring bond. The two most likely candidates are either the cis/trans isomerization of the Lys-41-Pro-42 peptide bond or hindered rotation about the disulfide bond between Cys-40 and Cys-95.

Dynamic Monte Carlo simulations of globular protein folding. Model studies of in vivo assembly of four helix bundles and four member beta-barrels

As part of an ongoing series of dynamic Monte Carlo simulations of globular protein folding, the nature of the folding pathway, of model four-member beta-barrels and four-helix bundles, under highly idealized conditions in vivo, has been examined. The ribosome is crudely modeled as an inert hard wall on to which the model protein chain is attached. Three cases are considered in detail. The first corresponds to post-translational assembly in which the fully synthesized chain is tethered to the wall and starts out under strongly denaturing conditions. The system is cooled down, and the chain is allowed to fold. Interestingly, the helical motif prefers to assemble parallel to the wall, whereas the beta-barrel, predominantly assembles with its principal axis perpendicular to the wall. In the former case, the dominant intermediate, the helical hairpin, is different from that in free solution, a three-helix bundle. The wall acts to reduce the expanse of configuration space that must be searched and aids in folding. Two situations that might lead to co-translational folding are also simulated. In the first case, to eliminate wall effects, the chain is slowly synthesized in free solution, and in the second case, it is slowly synthesized from the wall. In all cases, the chains are observed to fold post-translationally. While partially folded intermediates are observed during synthesis, they lack the stability to survive until chain synthesis is complete. The implications of these results for the folding in vivo of real protein chains is discussed, and a model of multiple domain protein folding is proposed.

Peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerase does not affect the Pro-43 cis-trans isomerization rate in folded calbindin D9k

The calcium-binding protein calbindin D9k has previously been shown to exist in two folded forms only differing in the proline cis-trans isomerism of the Gly-42-Pro-43 amide bond. This bond is located in a flexible loop connecting the two EF-hand Ca2+ sites. Calbindin D9k therefore constitutes a unique test case for investigating if the recently discovered enzyme peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerase (PPIase) can affect the cis-trans exchange rate in a folded protein. The 1H NMR saturation transfer technique has been used to measure the rate of interconversion between the cis and trans forms of calbindin in the presence of PPIase (PPIase:calbindin concentration ratio 1:10) at 35 degrees C. No rate enhancement could be detected.

Structural characterization of folding intermediates in cytochrome c by H-exchange labelling and proton NMR

To understand the process of protein folding, it will be necessary to obtain detailed structural information on folding intermediates. This difficult problem is being studied by using hydrogen exchange and rapid mixing to label transient structural intermediates, with subsequent analysis of the proton-labelling pattern by two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Results for cytochrome c show that the method provides the spatial and temporal resolution necessary to monitor structure formation at many defined sites along the polypeptide chain on a timescale ranging from milliseconds to minutes.

Catalysis of proline isomerization during protein-folding reactions

The enzyme peptidylprolyl cis-trans isomerase (PPI) is known to catalyze proline isomerization in short proline-containing peptides. If PPI can be shown to generally catalyze isomerization of proline residues in proteins, then it would be a valuable diagnostic reagent for recognition of isomerization, which has proven to be extremely difficult to characterize by other methods. In this study, the catalytic effect of PPI on the slow refolding reactions of seven different proteins has been studied, and in only two cases (RNase T1 and cytochrome c) could significant catalysis be seen. PPI also caused no enhancement in the rate for the 'subtle' conformational changes of native concanavalin A or native Fragment I of prothrombin, which have been suggested to be rate-limited by proline isomerization. There was a small effect of PPI observed for the generation of native RNAase A from the fully-reduced form when the glutathione concentration was low. The conclusion from these studies is that PPI can weakly catalyze some protein processes which are rate-limited by proline isomerization, but probably exhibits no measureable catalysis toward others. This somewhat limits the usefulness of PPI as a diagnostic reagent for proline isomerization.

The effect of methanol and temperature on the kinetics of refolding of ribonuclease A

Unfolded ribonuclease A consists of 20% fast refolding (Uf) and 80% slow refolding material (Us). The latter consists of at least two different forms which refold at different rates. We have used absorbance and fluorescence spectrophotometry to compare the kinetics of refolding in aqueous and aqueous-methanol solutions. At 1 degree C and pH 3.0, the addition of increasing concentrations of methanol (to 50%, v/v) had negligible effect on the rates and amplitudes of the slow refolding Us states. The effect of temperature on the two slow phases of refolding was determined in 35 and 50% methanol. From Arrhenius plots the energies of activation were found to be in the vicinity of 20 kcal/mol for both processes. The results suggest that both slow phases correspond to proline isomerization, and that the presence of methanol does not significantly perturb the overall refolding process. It is possible that the faster of the slow refolding phases corresponds to the isomerization of a proline residue which is trans in the folded native state but which undergoes extensive isomerization to the cis conformation in the unfolded state.

Folding of the nascent peptide chain into a biologically active protein

The refolding of denatured proteins with complete sequences may not be fast enough to account for the in vivo folding of growing peptide chains during biosynthesis. As some peptide fragments have secondary structures not unlike those of the corresponding segments in the intact molecules and native disulfide bonds of some proteins can form cotranslationally, it is suggested that the folding of the nascent chain begins early during synthesis. However, further adjustments may be necessary during chain elongation and after posttranslational modifications of the completed peptide chain to generate the native conformation of a biologically active protein.