Conformational Dynamics of the GdmHCl-Induced Molten Globule State of Creatine Kinase Monitored by Hydrogen Exchange and Mass Spectrometry

Probing Aromatic Side Chains Reveals the Site-Specific Melting in the SUMO1 Molten Globule

The conventional idea that a well-defined protein structure governs its functions is being challenged by the evolving significance of conformational flexibility and disorder in influencing protein activity. Here, we focus on the Small Ubiquitin-like MOdifier 1 (SUMO1) protein, a post-translational modifier, which binds various target proteins during the process of SUMOylation. We present evidence supporting the presence of both folded and "ordered" molten globule (MG) states in SUMO1 under physiological conditions. We investigate the MG state using a combination of near-UV and far-UV circular dichroism (CD) experiments. Moreover, we dissect the information from the near-UV CD data to gain specific insights about the MG intermediate. This is achieved by mutating specific aromatic amino acids, particularly creating a single-tyrosine mutant S1Y51 (by introducing Y21F and Y91F mutations) and a tryptophan mutant S1F66W. Spectroscopic studies of the mutants as a function of temperature revealed multiple insights. The transition from the folded to the MG state involves a site-specific loss of tertiary packing near Y51 but the region surrounding F66 retained most of its tertiary contacts, suggesting an ordered MG structure. We further demonstrate the increased solvent exposure of Y51 in the MG state by using time-resolved fluorescence and steady-state quenching experiments. The observed conformational flexibility and solvent accessibility, particularly around Y51 that is known to be involved in binding the cognate ligands such as PIASX and its peptide analogues, have biological and functional implications in mediating protein-protein interactions during the SUMOylation process.

DMSO-Quenched H/D-Exchange 2D NMR Spectroscopy and Its Applications in Protein Science

Hydrogen/deuterium (H/D) exchange combined with two-dimensional (2D) NMR spectroscopy has been widely used for studying the structure, stability, and dynamics of proteins. When we apply the H/D-exchange method to investigate non-native states of proteins such as equilibrium and kinetic folding intermediates, H/D-exchange quenching techniques are indispensable, because the exchange reaction is usually too fast to follow by 2D NMR. In this article, we will describe the dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO)-quenched H/D-exchange method and its applications in protein science. In this method, the H/D-exchange buffer is replaced by an aprotic DMSO solution, which quenches the exchange reaction. We have improved the DMSO-quenched method by using spin desalting columns, which are used for medium exchange from the H/D-exchange buffer to the DMSO solution. This improvement has allowed us to monitor the H/D exchange of proteins at a high concentration of salts or denaturants. We describe methodological details of the improved DMSO-quenched method and present a case study using the improved method on the H/D-exchange behavior of unfolded human ubiquitin in 6 M guanidinium chloride.

Long-range stabilization of anthrax protective antigen upon binding to CMG2

Protective antigen (PA) mediates entry of edema factor (EF) and lethal factor (LF) into the cytoplasmic space of the cells through the formation of a membrane-spanning pore. To do this, PA must initially bind to a host cellular receptor. Recent mass spectrometry analysis of PA using histidine hydrogen–deuterium exchange (His-HDX) has shown that binding of the von Willebrand factor A (vWA) domain of the receptor capillary morphogenesis protein-2 (CMG2) lowers the exchange rates of the imidazole C₂ hydrogen of several histidines, suggesting that receptor binding decreases the structural flexibility of PA. Here, using His-HDX and fluorescence as a function of denaturant, and protease susceptibility, we show that binding of the vWA domain of CMG2 largely increases the stability of PA and the effect reaches up to 70 Å from the receptor binding interface. We also show that the pK_a values and HDX rates of histidines located in separate domains change upon receptor binding. These results indicate that when one end of the protein is anchored, the structure of PA is tightened, noncovalent interactions are strengthened, and the global stability of the protein increases. These findings suggest that CMG2 may be used to stabilize PA in future anthrax vaccines.

Analyzing protein dynamics using hydrogen exchange mass spectrometry

All cellular processes depend on the functionality of proteins. Although the functionality of a given protein is the direct consequence of its unique amino acid sequence, it is only realized by the folding of the polypeptide chain into a single defined three-dimensional arrangement or more commonly into an ensemble of interconverting conformations. Investigating the connection between protein conformation and its function is therefore essential for a complete understanding of how proteins are able to fulfill their great variety of tasks. One possibility to study conformational changes a protein undergoes while progressing through its functional cycle is hydrogen-(1)H/(2)H-exchange in combination with high-resolution mass spectrometry (HX-MS). HX-MS is a versatile and robust method that adds a new dimension to structural information obtained by e.g. crystallography. It is used to study protein folding and unfolding, binding of small molecule ligands, protein-protein interactions, conformational changes linked to enzyme catalysis, and allostery. In addition, HX-MS is often used when the amount of protein is very limited or crystallization of the protein is not feasible. Here we provide a general protocol for studying protein dynamics with HX-MS and describe as an example how to reveal the interaction interface of two proteins in a complex.

Dissecting the key residues crucial for the species-specific thermostability of muscle-type creatine kinase

Species-specific protein thermal stability is closely correlated to the living conditions of the organism, especially to its body temperature. In this research, human and zebrafish muscle-type creatine kinases (MMCKs) were taken as model proteins to investigate the molecular adaptation of proteins in poikilothermal and homoiothermal animals. Both the optimal temperature for catalysis and the thermal stability of human MMCK was much higher than those of zebrafish MMCK. Sequence alignment identified 9 amino acid variations conserved in either the teleost MMCKs or the mammal and electric ray MMCKs. Bidirectional mutations were performed to find the residues with beneficial mutations. The results showed that two residues close to the dimer interface of MMCK, the 46th and 146th residue, were crucial for species-specific thermal stability.

Sequential events in the irreversible thermal denaturation of human brain-type creatine kinase by spectroscopic methods

The non-cooperative or sequential events which occur during protein thermal denaturation are closely correlated with protein folding, stability, and physiological functions. In this research, the sequential events of human brain-type creatine kinase (hBBCK) thermal denaturation were studied by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), CD, and intrinsic fluorescence spectroscopy. DSC experiments revealed that the thermal denaturation of hBBCK was calorimetrically irreversible. The existence of several endothermic peaks suggested that the denaturation involved stepwise conformational changes, which were further verified by the discrepancy in the transition curves obtained from various spectroscopic probes. During heating, the disruption of the active site structure occurred prior to the secondary and tertiary structural changes. The thermal unfolding and aggregation of hBBCK was found to occur through sequential events. This is quite different from that of muscle-type CK (MMCK). The results herein suggest that BBCK and MMCK undergo quite dissimilar thermal unfolding pathways, although they are highly conserved in the primary and tertiary structures. A minor difference in structure might endow the isoenzymes dissimilar local stabilities in structure, which further contribute to isoenzyme-specific thermal stabilities.

Investigating solution-phase protein structure and dynamics by hydrogen exchange mass spectrometry

By taking advantage of labeling methods such as hydrogen exchange (HX), many details about protein conformation, dynamics, and interactions can be revealed by mass spectrometry. In this unit, hydrogen exchange theory is discussed as it applies to HX-MS protocols, the practice of HX-MS including data analysis and interpretation is explained in detail, and recent advancements in technology which greatly increase the depth of information gained from the technique are highlighted.

Intrinsic domain and loop dynamics commensurate with catalytic turnover in an induced-fit enzyme

Arginine kinase catalyzes reversible phosphoryl transfer between ATP and arginine, buffering cellular ATP concentrations. Structures of substrate-free and -bound enzyme have highlighted a range of conformational changes thought to occur during the catalytic cycle. Here, NMR is used to characterize the intrinsic backbone dynamics over multiple timescales. Relaxation dispersion indicates rigid-body motion of the N-terminal domain and flexible dynamics in the I182-G209 loop, both at millisecond rates commensurate with k(cat), implying that either might be rate limiting upon catalysis. Lipari-Szabo analysis indicates backbone flexibility on the nanosecond timescale in the V308-V322 loop, while the rest of the enzyme is more rigid in this timescale. Thus, intrinsic dynamics are most prominent in regions that have been independently implicated in conformational changes. Substrate-free enzyme may sample an ensemble of different conformations, of which a subset is selected upon substrate binding, with critical active site residues appropriately configured for binding and catalysis.

Accessibility changes within diphtheria toxin T domain when in the functional molten globule state, as determined using hydrogen/deuterium exchange measurements

The translocation domain (T domain) of diphtheria toxin adopts a partially folded state, the so-called molten globule state, to become functional at acidic pH. We compared, using hydrogen/deuterium exchange experiments associated with MS, the structures of the T domain in its soluble folded state at neutral pH and in its functional molten globule state at acidic pH. In the native state, the alpha-helices TH5 and TH8 are identified as the core of the domain. Based on the high-resolution structure of the T domain, we propose that TH8 is highly protected because it is buried within the native structure. According to the same structure, TH5 is partly accessible at the surface of the T domain. We propose that its high protection is caused by the formation of dimers. Within the molten globule state, high protection is still observed within the helical hairpin TH8-TH9, which is responsible for the insertion of the T domain into the membrane. In the absence of the lipid bilayer, this hydrophobic part of the domain self-assembles, leading to the formation of oligomers. Overall, hydrogen/deuterium-exchange measurements allow the analysis of interaction contacts within small oligomers made of partially folded proteins. Such information, together with crystal structure data, are particularly valuable for using to analyze the self-assembly of proteins.

Cooperative Unfolding of a Metastable Serpin to a Molten Globule Suggests a Link Between Functional and Folding Energy Landscapes

Alpha-1 antitrypsin (alpha(1)-AT) is a member of the serpin class of protease inhibitors, and folds to a metastable state rather than its thermodynamically most stable native state. Upon cleavage by a target protease, alpha(1)-AT undergoes a dramatic conformational change to a stable form, translocating the bound protease more than 70 A to form an inhibitory protease-serpin complex. Numerous mutagenesis studies on serpins have demonstrated the trade-off between the stability of the metastable state on the one hand and the inhibitory efficiency on the other. Studies of the equilibrium unfolding of serpins provide insight into this connection between structural plasticity and metastability. We studied equilibrium unfolding of wild-type alpha(1)-AT using hydrogen-deuterium/exchange mass spectrometry to characterize the structure and the stability of an equilibrium intermediate that was observed in low concentrations of denaturant in earlier studies. Our results show that the intermediate observed at low concentrations of denaturant has no protection from hydrogen-deuterium exchange, indicating a lack of stable structure. Further, differential scanning calorimetry of alpha(1)-AT at low concentrations of denaturant shows no heat capacity peak during thermal denaturation, indicating that the transition from the intermediate to the unfolded state is not a cooperative first-order-like phase transition.. Our results show that the unfolding of alpha(1)-AT involves a cooperative transition to a molten globule form, followed by a non-cooperative transition to a random-coil form as more guanidine is added. Thus, the entire alpha(1)-AT molecule consists of one cooperative structural unit rather than multiple structural domains with different stabilities. Furthermore, our results together with previous mutagenesis studies suggest a possible link between an equilibrium molten globule and a functional intermediate that may be populated during the protease inhibition.

Effects of Solutes on Empirical Phase Diagrams of Human Fibroblast Growth Factor 1

A variety of solutes are commonly used to increase the stability of protein in therapeutic formulations. An empirical phase diagram approach is used to evaluate the effects of different types of additives on the solution behavior of a protein of pharmaceutical interest, human fibroblast growth factor 1 (FGF-1). A specific stabilizer, heparin, and a nonspecific stabilizer, sucrose, were used in this work. The protein was characterized as a function of pH (3-8) and temperature (10-85 degrees C) using Far-UV circular dichroism (Far-UV CD), intrinsic and extrinsic fluorescence as well as second derivative UV absorption spectroscopy. Empirical phase diagrams were constructed to summarize the biophysical characterization data obtained with FGF-1 alone, in the presence of a threefold weight excess of heparin (3x heparin) or 10% sucrose (w/v). Three phases are observed in the low temperature regions at pH 3, 4, and 5-8. Phase boundaries corresponding to major heat-induced transitions are detected in the physiological temperature range. The highest thermal stabilities are observed near neutral pH (pH 6 and 7). Both heparin and sucrose appear to enhance the thermal stability of FGF-1, although their effects on the phase diagram are quite distinct. The greatest stabilization is observed at pH 8. Only heparin appears to protect FGF-1 from acid-induced unfolding to any extent.

Despite its high similarity with monomeric arginine kinase, muscle creatine kinase is only enzymatically active as a dimer

Although having highly similar primary to tertiary structures, the different guanidino kinases exhibit distinct quaternary structures: monomer, dimer or octamer. However, no evidence for communication between subunits has yet been provided, and reasons for these different levels of quaternary complexity that can be observed from invertebrate to mammalian guanidino kinases remain elusive. Muscle creatine kinase is a dimer and disruption of the interface between subunits has been shown to give rise to destabilized monomers with slight residual activity; this low activity could, however, be due to a fraction of protein molecules present as dimer. CK monomer/monomer interface involves electrostatic interactions and increasing salt concentrations unfold and inactivate this enzyme. NaCl and guanidine hydrochloride show a synergistic unfolding effect and, whatever the respective concentrations of these compounds, inactivation is associated with a dissociation of the dimer. Using an interface mutant (W210Y), protein concentration dependence of the NaCl-induced unfolding profile indicates that the active dimer is in equilibrium with an inactive monomeric state. Although highly similar to muscle CK, horse shoe crab (Limulus polyphemus) arginine kinase (AK) is enzymatically active as a monomer. Indeed, high ionic strengths that can monomerize and inactivate CK, have no effect on AK enzymatic activity or on its structure as judged from intrinsic fluorescence data. Our results indicate that expression of muscle creatine kinase catalytic activity is dependent on its dimeric state which is required for a proper stabilization of the monomers.

Hydrogen/Deuterium Scrambling during Quadrupole Time-of-Flight MS/MS Analysis of a Zinc-Binding Protein Domain

It remains an open question as to whether experiments involving collision-induced dissociation (CID) can provide a viable approach for monitoring spatially resolved deuteration levels in electrosprayed polypeptide ions. A number of laboratories reported the successful application of CID following solution-phase H/D exchange (HDX), whereas others found that H/D scrambling precluded site-specific measurements. The aim of the current work is to help clarify the general feasibility of HDX-CID methods, using a 22-residue zinc-bound protein domain (Zn-ZBD) as model system. Metal binding in Zn-ZBD should confer structural rigidity, and the presence of several basic residues should sequester mobile charge carriers in the gas phase. Both of these factors were expected to suppress the extent of scrambling. HDX was carried out by employing rapid on-line mixing, thereby mimicking conditions typically encountered in kinetic pulse-labeling studies. Quadrupole time-of-flight MS/MS of pulse-labeled Zn-ZBD provides high sequence coverage. However, the measured fragment deuteration levels do not correlate with the known H-bonding pattern of Zn-ZBD, suggesting the occurrence of extensive scrambling. Instead of showing a uniform distribution, the fragment ions reveal a distinct nonrandom pattern of deuteration levels. In the absence of prior information, these data could erroneously be ascribed to the presence of protected sites. However, the observed patterns clearly originate from other factors; possibly they are caused by modulations of the amide CID efficiency by kinetic isotope effects. It is concluded that scrambling does not represent the only conceptual problem in HDX-CID studies and that control experiments on uniformly labeled samples are essential for ruling out interpretation artifacts.

Interfacial behavior of cytoplasmic and mitochondrial creatine kinase oligomeric states

Adsorption to the air/water interface of isoenzymes of creatine kinase was investigated using surface pressure-area isotherms and Brewster angle microscopy (BAM) observations. Octameric mitochondrial creatine kinase (mtCK) exhibits a significant affinity for the air/water interface. Whatever the mode of formation of the interfacial film, i.e., injection of the protein in the subphase or spreading onto the buffer surface, the final arrangement and conformation adopted by mtCK molecules lead to a similar result. In contrast, the dimeric isoenzymes mtCK and cytosolic MMCK do not induce any surface pressure variation. However, when the subphase contains 0.3M NaCl, both isoenzymes adsorb to the interface. When treated with 0.8 or 3M GdnHCl, muscle creatine kinase (MMCK) becomes surface active and occupies a greater surface than mtCK. This result contrasts with previous observations, often derived from monomeric proteins, that their surface activity is increased upon unfolding. It underlines the possible influence exerted by the protein oligomeric state on its interfacial activity. At a subphase pH of 8.8, which corresponds to the pI of octameric mtCK, the profiles of the isotherms obtained with dimeric and octameric states and the resistance to compression of the protein monolayers are significantly affected when compared to those recorded at pH 7.4. These data suggest that the octamer is more hydrophobic than the dimer and may contribute to explaining why octamers bind to the inner mitochondrial membrane while dimers do not.

Anthrax vaccine powder formulations for nasal mucosal delivery

Anthrax remains a serious threat worldwide as a bioterror agent. A second-generation anthrax vaccine currently under clinical evaluation consists of a recombinant Protective Antigen (rPA) of Bacillus anthracis. We have previously demonstrated that complete protection against inhalational anthrax can be achieved in a rabbit model, by intranasal delivery of a powder rPA formulation. Here we describe the preformulation and formulation development of such powder formulations. The physical stability of rPA was studied in solution as a function of pH and temperature using circular dichroism (CD), and UV-visible absorption and fluorescence spectroscopies. Extensive aggregation of rPA was observed at physiological temperatures. An empirical phase diagram, constructed using a combination of CD and fluorescence data, suggests that rPA is most thermally stable within the pH range of 6-8. To identify potential stabilizers, a library of GRAS excipients was screened using an aggregation sensitive turbidity assay, CD, and fluorescence. Based on these stability profiles, spray freeze-dried (SFD) formulations were prepared at pH 7-8 using trehalose as stabilizer and a CpG-containing oligonucleotide adjuvant. SFD formulations displayed substantial improvement in storage stability over liquid formulations. In combination with noninvasive intranasal delivery, such powder formulations may offer an attractive approach for mass biodefense immunization.

Hydrogen exchange mass spectrometry for the analysis of protein dynamics

Hydrogen exchange coupled to mass spectrometry (MS) has become a valuable analytical tool for the study of protein dynamics. By combining information about protein dynamics with more classical functional data, a more thorough understanding of protein function can be obtained. In many cases, protein dynamics are directly related to specific protein functions such as conformational changes during enzyme activation or protein movements during binding. The method is made possible because labile backbone hydrogens in a protein will exchange with deuterium atoms when the protein is placed in a D2O solution. The subsequent increase in protein mass over time is measured with high-resolution MS. The location of the deuterium incorporation is determined by monitoring deuterium incorporation in peptic fragments that are produced after the labeling reaction. In this review, we will summarize the general principles of the method, discuss the latest variations on the experimental protocol that probe different types of protein movements, and review other recent work and improvements in the field.

Structural and dynamic characteristics of a partially folded state of ubiquitin revealed by hydrogen exchange mass spectrometry

Structural and dynamic properties of a partially folded conformation (A-state) of ubiquitin are studied using amide hydrogen exchange in solution (HDX) and mass spectrometric detection. A clear distinction between the native state of the protein and the A-state can be made when HDX is carried out in a semicorrelated regime. Convoluted exchange patterns are interpreted with the aid of HDX simulations in a three-state system (highly structured, partially unstructured, and fully unstructured states). The data clearly indicate a highly dynamic character of the non-native state. Furthermore, combination of HDX and protein ion fragmentation in the gas phase [by means of collision-induced dissociation (CAD)] is used to evaluate the conformational stability of various protein segments specifically in the molten globular state. Chain flexibility appears to be distributed very unevenly in this non-native conformation. The highest degree of structural disorder is displayed by the C-terminal segment (Gly(53)-Gly(76)), which was previously suggested to form a transient alpha-helix. The least dynamic segment of ubiquitin in the A-state is Thr(9)-Glu(18) (which was previously suggested to form a stable nativelike beta-strand), with the adjacent segments exhibiting somewhat diminished conformational stability. The study also demonstrates the power of mass spectrometry as a tool in providing conformer-specific information about the structure and dynamics of both native and non-native protein states coexisting in solution under equilibrium.

Local dynamics measured by hydrogen/deuterium exchange and mass spectrometry of creatine kinase digested by two proteases

Hydrogen/deuterium exchange coupled to mass spectrometry has been used to investigate the structure and dynamics of native dimeric cytosolic muscle creatine kinase. The protein was incubated in D2O for various time. After H/D exchange and rapid quenching of the reaction, the partially deuterated protein was cleaved in parallel by two different proteases (pepsin or type XIII protease from Aspergillus saitoi) to increase the sequence coverage and spatial resolution of deuterium incorporation. The resulting peptides were analyzed by liquid chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry. In comparison with the 3D structure of MM-CK, the analysis of the two independent proteolysis deuteration patterns allowed us to get new insights into CK local dynamics as compared to a previous study using pepsin [Mazon et al. Protein Science 13 (2004) 476-486]. In particular, we obtained more information on the kinetics and extent of deuterium exchange in the N- and C-terminal extremities represented by the 1-22 and 362-380 pepsin peptides. Indeed, we observed a very different behaviour of the 1-12 and 13-22 type XIII protease peptides, and similarly for the 362-373 and 374-380 peptides. Moreover, comparison of the deuteration patterns of type XIII protease segments of the large 90-126 pepsin peptide led us to identify a small relatively dynamic region (108-114).

Denaturant sensitive regions in creatine kinase identified by hydrogen/deuterium exchange

The GdmHCl-induced unfolding of creatine kinase (CK) has been studied by hydrogen/deuterium (H/D) exchange combined with mass spectrometry. MM-CK unfolded for various periods in different denaturant concentrations was pulsed-labeled with deuterium to identify different conformational intermediate states. For all denaturation times or GdmHCl concentrations, we observed variable proportions of only two species. The low-mass envelope of isotope peaks corresponds to a species that has gained about 10 deuteriums more than native CK, and the high-mass envelope to a completely deuterated species. To localize precisely the unfolded regions in the states highly populated during denaturation, the protein was digested with two proteases (pepsin and type XIII protease) after H/D exchange and rapid quenching of the reaction. The two sets of fragments obtained were analyzed by liquid chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry to determine the deuterium level in each fragment. Bimodal distributions of deuterium were found for most peptides, indicating that these regions were either folded or unfolded. This behavior is consistent with cooperative, localized unfolding. However, we observed a monomodal distribution of deuterium in two regions (1-12 and 162-186). We conclude that the increment of mass observed in the low-mass species of the intact protein (+10 Da) has its origin in these two segments. These regions, which are very sensitive to low GdmHCl concentrations, are involved in the monomer-monomer interface of CK and their perturbation is likely to weaken the dimeric structure. At higher denaturant concentration, this would induce dissociation of the dimer.

Using mass spectrometry to probe the subtle differences in conformations of several cytochromes c in aqueous and methanol solutions

We have detected, using electrospray mass spectrometry, minor changes in the H/D exchange rates in various solvents for cytochromes c obtained from five different species. We compared the exchange rates exhibited by these proteins by mixing horse cytochrome c with each of the other four species and monitoring their exchanges simultaneously by mass spectrometry. The use of horse cytochrome c as a reference allowed us to make very accurate comparisons of the small differences in hydrogen exchange rates among the various species. The exchange experiments were performed in water and methanol at several concentrations in an effort to determine whether the cytochromes c of these five species have different conformations in specific solvents, which would cause their exchange rates to differ. Therefore, monitoring the level of exchange as a function of time in both water and water-methanol mixtures is a method for detecting subtle structural changes of proteins in their native or unfolded intermediate states.