Detection of intermediates in the oxidative half-reaction of the FAD-dependent thymidylate synthase from Thermotoga maritima: carbon transfer without covalent pyrimidine activation

Insights into the Mechanism of Installation of 5-Carboxymethylaminomethyl Uridine Hypermodification by tRNA-Modifying Enzymes MnmE and MnmG

The evolutionarily conserved bacterial proteins MnmE and MnmG (and their homologues in Eukarya) install a 5-carboxymethylaminomethyl (cmnm5) or a 5-taurinomethyl (τm5) group onto wobble uridines of several tRNA species. The Escherichia coli MnmE binds guanosine-5'-triphosphate (GTP) and methylenetetrahydrofolate (CH2THF), while MnmG binds flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) and a reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH). Together with glycine, MnmEG catalyzes the installation of cmnm5 in a reaction that also requires hydrolysis of GTP. In this letter, we investigated key steps of the MnmEG reaction using a combination of biochemical techniques. We show multiple lines of evidence supporting flavin-iminium FADH[N5═CH2]+ as a central intermediate in the MnmEG reaction. Using a synthetic FADH[N5═CD2]+ analogue, the intermediacy of the FAD in the transfer of the methylene group from CH2THF to the C5 position of U34 was unambiguously demonstrated. Further, MnmEG reactions containing the deuterated flavin-iminium intermediate and alternate nucleophiles such as taurine and ammonia also led to the formation of the anticipated U34-modified tRNAs, showing FAD[N5═CH2]+ as the universal intermediate for all MnmEG homologues. Additionally, an RNA-protein complex stable to urea-denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis was identified. Studies involving a series of nuclease (RNase T1) and protease (trypsin) digestions along with reverse transcription experiments suggest that the complex may be noncovalent. While the conserved MnmG cysteine C47 and C277 mutant variants were shown to reduce FAD, they were unable to promote the modified tRNA formation. Overall, this study provides critical insights into the biochemical mechanism underlying tRNA modification by the MnmEG.

Integrative Approach to Probe Alternative Redox Mechanisms in RNA Modifications

ConspectusRNA modifications found in most RNAs, particularly in tRNAs and rRNAs, reveal an abundance of chemical alterations of nucleotides. Over 150 distinct RNA modifications are known, emphasizing a remarkable diversity of chemical moieties in RNA molecules. These modifications play pivotal roles in RNA maturation, structural integrity, and the fidelity and efficiency of translation processes. The catalysts responsible for these modifications are RNA-modifying enzymes that use a striking array of chemistries to directly influence the chemical landscape of RNA. This diversity is further underscored by instances where the same modification is introduced by distinct enzymes that use unique catalytic mechanisms and cofactors across different domains of life. This phenomenon of convergent evolution highlights the biological importance of RNA modification and the vast potential within the chemical repertoire for nucleotide alteration. While shared RNA modifications can hint at conserved enzymatic pathways, a major bottleneck is to identify alternative routes within species that possess a modified RNA but are devoid of known RNA-modifying enzymes. To address this challenge, a combination of bioinformatic and experimental strategies proves invaluable in pinpointing new genes responsible for RNA modifications. This integrative approach not only unveils new chemical insights but also serves as a wellspring of inspiration for biocatalytic applications and drug design. In this Account, we present how comparative genomics and genome mining, combined with biomimetic synthetic chemistry, biochemistry, and anaerobic crystallography, can be judiciously implemented to address unprecedented and alternative chemical mechanisms in the world of RNA modification. We illustrate these integrative methodologies through the study of tRNA and rRNA modifications, dihydrouridine, 5-methyluridine, queuosine, 8-methyladenosine, 5-carboxymethylamino-methyluridine, or 5-taurinomethyluridine, each dependent on a diverse array of redox chemistries, often involving organic compounds, organometallic complexes, and metal coenzymes. We explore how vast genome and tRNA databases empower comparative genomic analyses and enable the identification of novel genes that govern RNA modification. Subsequently, we describe how the isolation of a stable reaction intermediate can guide the synthesis of a biomimetic to unveil new enzymatic pathways. We then discuss the usefulness of a biochemical "shunt" strategy to study catalytic mechanisms and to directly visualize reactive intermediates bound within active sites. While we primarily focus on various RNA-modifying enzymes studied in our laboratory, with a particular emphasis on the discovery of a SAM-independent methylation mechanism, the strategies and rationale presented herein are broadly applicable for the identification of new enzymes and the elucidation of their intricate chemistries. This Account offers a comprehensive glimpse into the evolving landscape of RNA modification research and highlights the pivotal role of integrated approaches to identify novel enzymatic pathways.

Multimodal Reactivity of N-H Bonds in Triazanes and Isolation of a Triazinyl Radical

The employment of nitrogen Lewis acids based on nitrenium cations has been increasingly featured in the fields of main group chemistry and catalysis. A formally reduced form of nitrenium D─cyclic triazanes E─are intriguing chemical compounds, the chemistry of which is completely unexplored. In this work, we reveal that N-H-triazanes exhibit unusual N-H bond properties; namely, they can serve as protons, hydrides, or hydrogen atom donors. This unique multimodal reactivity provides an N-cation, N-anion, or N-radical from the same species. It allowed us to isolate, for the first time, a stable naphto[1,2,3]triazinyl radical, which was fully characterized both computationally and experimentally, including its monomeric X-ray structure. Moreover, this radical can be prepared directly from the nitrenium cation by a single electron reduction (E = -0.46 V), and this process is reversible. We envision versatile uses of this radical in synthetic and materials chemistry.

Ultrafast dynamics of fully reduced flavin in catalytic structures of thymidylate synthase ThyX

Thymidylate is a vital DNA precursor synthesized by thymidylate synthases. ThyX is a flavin-dependent thymidylate synthase found in several human pathogens and absent in humans, which makes it a potential target for antimicrobial drugs. This enzyme methylates the 2'-deoxyuridine 5'-monophosphate (dUMP) to 2'-deoxythymidine 5'-monophosphate (dTMP) using a reduced flavin adenine dinucleotide (FADH^-) as prosthetic group and (6R)-N₅,N₁₀-methylene-5,6,7,8-tetrahydrofolate (CH₂THF) as a methylene donor. Recently, it was shown that ThyX-catalyzed reaction is a complex process wherein FADH^- promotes both methylene transfer and reduction of the transferred methylene into a methyl group. Here, we studied the dynamic and photophysics of FADH^- bound to ThyX, in several substrate-binding states (no substrate, in the presence of dUMP or folate or both) by femtosecond transient absorption spectroscopy. This methodology provides valuable information about the ground-state configuration of the isoalloxazine moiety of FADH^- and the rigidity of its local environment, through spectra shape and excited-state lifetime parameters. In the absence of substrate, the environment of FADH^- in ThyX is only mildly more constrained than that of free FADH^- in solution. The addition of dUMP however narrows the distribution of ground-state configurations and increases the constraints on the butterfly bending motion in the excited state. Folate binding results in the selection of new ground-state configurations, presumably located at a greater distance from the conical intersection where excited-state decay occurs. When both substrates are present, the ground-state configuration appears on the contrary rather limited to a geometry close to the conical intersection, which explains the relatively fast excited-state decay (100 ps on the average), even if the environment of the isoalloxazine is densely packed. Hence, although the environment of the flavin is dramatically constrained, FADH^- retains a dynamic necessary to shuttle carbon from folate to dUMP. Our study demonstrates the high sensitivity of FADH^- photophysics to the constraints exerted by its immediate surroundings.

An enzymatic activation of formaldehyde for nucleotide methylation

Folate enzyme cofactors and their derivatives have the unique ability to provide a single carbon unit at different oxidation levels for the de novo synthesis of amino-acids, purines, or thymidylate, an essential DNA nucleotide. How these cofactors mediate methylene transfer is not fully settled yet, particularly with regard to how the methylene is transferred to the methylene acceptor. Here, we uncovered that the bacterial thymidylate synthase ThyX, which relies on both folate and flavin for activity, can also use a formaldehyde-shunt to directly synthesize thymidylate. Combining biochemical, spectroscopic and anaerobic crystallographic analyses, we showed that formaldehyde reacts with the reduced flavin coenzyme to form a carbinolamine intermediate used by ThyX for dUMP methylation. The crystallographic structure of this intermediate reveals how ThyX activates formaldehyde and uses it, with the assistance of active site residues, to methylate dUMP. Our results reveal that carbinolamine species promote methylene transfer and suggest that the use of a CH₂O-shunt may be relevant in several other important folate-dependent reactions.

Reductive Evolution and Diversification of C5-Uracil Methylation in the Nucleic Acids of Mollicutes

The C5-methylation of uracil to form 5-methyluracil (m5U) is a ubiquitous base modification of nucleic acids. Four enzyme families have converged to catalyze this methylation using different chemical solutions. Here, we investigate the evolution of 5-methyluracil synthase families in Mollicutes, a class of bacteria that has undergone extensive genome erosion. Many mollicutes have lost some of the m5U methyltransferases present in their common ancestor. Cases of duplication and subsequent shift of function are also described. For example, most members of the Spiroplasma subgroup use the ancestral tetrahydrofolate-dependent TrmFO enzyme to catalyze the formation of m5U54 in tRNA, while a TrmFO paralog (termed RlmFO) is responsible for m5U1939 formation in 23S rRNA. RlmFO has replaced the S-adenosyl-L-methionine (SAM)-enzyme RlmD that adds the same modification in the ancestor and which is still present in mollicutes from the Hominis subgroup. Another paralog of this family, the TrmFO-like protein, has a yet unidentified function that differs from the TrmFO and RlmFO homologs. Despite having evolved towards minimal genomes, the mollicutes possess a repertoire of m5U-modifying enzymes that is highly dynamic and has undergone horizontal transfer.

Chemo-enzymatic synthesis of the exocyclic olefin isomer of thymidine monophosphate

Exocyclic olefin variants of thymidylate (dTMP) recently have been proposed as reaction intermediates for the thymidyl biosynthesis enzymes found in many pathogenic organisms, yet synthetic reports on these materials are lacking. Here we report two strategies to prepare the exocyclic olefin isomer of dTMP, which is a putative reaction intermediate in pathogenic thymidylate biosynthesis and a novel nucleotide analog. Our most effective strategy involves preserving the existing glyosidic bond of thymidine and manipulating the base to generate the exocyclic methylene moiety. We also report a successful enzymatic deoxyribosylation of a non-aromatic nucleobase isomer of thymine, which provides an additional strategy to access nucleotide analogs with disrupted ring conjugation or with reduced heterocyclic bases. The strategies reported here are straightforward and extendable towards the synthesis of various pyrimidine nucleotide analogs, which could lead to compounds of value in studies of enzyme reaction mechanisms or serve as templates for rational drug design.

Flavin-dependent thymidylate synthase: N5 of flavin as a Methylene carrier

Thymidylate is synthesized de novo in all living organisms for replication of genomes. The chemical transformation is reductive methylation of deoxyuridylate at C5 to form deoxythymidylate. All eukaryotes including humans complete this well-understood transformation with thymidylate synthase utilizing 6R-N⁵-N¹⁰-methylene-5,6,7,8-tetrahydrofolate as both a source of methylene and a reducing hydride. In 2002, flavin-dependent thymidylate synthase was discovered as a new pathway for de novo thymidylate synthesis. The flavin-dependent catalytic mechanism is different than thymidylate synthase because it requires flavin as a reducing agent and methylene transporter. This catalytic mechanism is not well-understood, but since it is known to be very different from thymidylate synthase, there is potential for mechanism-based inhibitors that can selectively inhibit the flavin-dependent enzyme to target many human pathogens with low host toxicity.

Discovery of a new Mycobacterium tuberculosis thymidylate synthase X inhibitor with a unique inhibition profile

Tuberculosis (TB), mainly caused by Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb), is an infection that is responsible for roughly 1.5 million deaths per year. The situation is further complicated by the wide-spread resistance to the existing first- and second-line drugs. As a result of this, it is urgent to develop new drugs to combat the resistant bacteria as well as have lower side effects, which can promote adherence to the treatment regimens. Targeting the de novo synthesis of thymidylate (dTMP) is an important pathway to develop drugs for TB. Although Mtb carries genes for two families of thymidylate synthases (TS), ThyA and ThyX, only ThyX is essential for its normal growth. Both enzymes catalyze the conversion of uridylate (dUMP) to dTMP but employ a different catalytic approach and have different structures. Also, ThyA is the only TS found in humans. This is the rationale for identifying selective inhibitors against ThyX. We exploited the NADPH oxidation to NADP⁺ step, catalyzed by ThyX, to develop a spectrophotometric biochemical assay. Success of the assay was demonstrated by its effectiveness (average Z'=0.77) and identification of selective ThyX inhibitors. The most potent compound is a tight-binding inhibitor with an IC₅₀ of 710nM. Its mechanism of inhibition is analyzed in relation to the latest findings of ThyX mechanism and substrate and cofactor binding order.

Deprotonations in the Reaction of Flavin-Dependent Thymidylate Synthase

Many microorganisms use flavin-dependent thymidylate synthase (FDTS) to synthesize the essential nucleotide 2'-deoxythymidine 5'-monophosphate (dTMP) from 2'-deoxyuridine 5'-monophosphate (dUMP), 5,10-methylenetetrahydrofolate (CH2THF), and NADPH. FDTSs have a structure that is unrelated to the thymidylate synthase used by humans and a very different mechanism. Here we report nuclear magnetic resonance evidence that FDTS ionizes N3 of dUMP using an active-site arginine. The ionized form of dUMP is largely responsible for the changes in the flavin absorbance spectrum of FDTS upon dUMP binding. dUMP analogues also suggest that the phosphate of dUMP acts as the base that removes the proton from C5 of the dUMP-methylene intermediate in the FDTS-catalyzed reaction. These findings establish additional differences between the mechanisms of FDTS and human thymidylate synthase.

Flavin-Dependent Thymidylate Synthase as a New Antibiotic Target

In humans de novo synthesis of 2'-deoxythymidine-5'-monophosphate (dTMP), an essential building block of DNA, utilizes an enzymatic pathway requiring thymidylate synthase (TSase) and dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR). The enzyme flavin-dependent thymidylate synthase (FDTS) represents an alternative enzymatic pathway to synthesize dTMP, which is not present in human cells. A number of pathogenic bacteria, however, depend on this enzyme in lieu of or in conjunction with the analogous human pathway. Thus, inhibitors of this enzyme may serve as antibiotics. Here, we review the similarities and differences of FDTS vs. TSase including aspects of their structure and chemical mechanism. In addition, we review current progress in the search for inhibitors of flavin dependent thymidylate synthase as potential novel therapeutics.

An unprecedented mechanism of nucleotide methylation in organisms containing thyX

In several human pathogens, thyX-encoded flavin-dependent thymidylate synthase (FDTS) catalyzes the last step in the biosynthesis of thymidylate, one of the four DNA nucleotides. ThyX is absent in humans, rendering FDTS an attractive antibiotic target; however, the lack of mechanistic understanding prohibits mechanism-based drug design. Here, we report trapping and characterization of two consecutive intermediates, which together with previous crystal structures indicate that the enzyme's reduced flavin relays a methylene from the folate carrier to the nucleotide acceptor. Furthermore, these results corroborate an unprecedented activation of the nucleotide that involves no covalent modification but only electrostatic polarization by the enzyme's active site. These findings indicate a mechanism that is very different from thymidylate biosynthesis in humans, underscoring the promise of FDTS as an antibiotic target.

Thymidylate synthase inspired biomodel reagent for the conversion of uracil to thymine

Inspired by TSase catalysis for dUMP conversion to dTMP, a biomodel reagent is developed. The presence of NH2, Gly-(S)-Cys and (S)-oxiran methyl, at C5, C4 and N-10 of acridine, respectively, in addition to the pH of the reaction mixture, allows for good complementary inter- and intra-molecular interactions and chiral discrimination for the reagent to achieve conversion of uracil to thymine.