Conservation in evolution for a small monomeric phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase of the tRNA(Phe) recognition nucleotides and initial aminoacylation site

The tRNA identity landscape for aminoacylation and beyond

tRNAs are key partners in ribosome-dependent protein synthesis. This process is highly dependent on the fidelity of tRNA aminoacylation by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases and relies primarily on sets of identities within tRNA molecules composed of determinants and antideterminants preventing mischarging by non-cognate synthetases. Such identity sets were discovered in the tRNAs of a few model organisms, and their properties were generalized as universal identity rules. Since then, the panel of identity elements governing the accuracy of tRNA aminoacylation has expanded considerably, but the increasing number of reported functional idiosyncrasies has led to some confusion. In parallel, the description of other processes involving tRNAs, often well beyond aminoacylation, has progressed considerably, greatly expanding their interactome and uncovering multiple novel identities on the same tRNA molecule. This review highlights key findings on the mechanistics and evolution of tRNA and tRNA-like identities. In addition, new methods and their results for searching sets of multiple identities on a single tRNA are discussed. Taken together, this knowledge shows that a comprehensive understanding of the functional role of individual and collective nucleotide identity sets in tRNA molecules is needed for medical, biotechnological and other applications.

tRNA biology in mitochondria

Mitochondria are the powerhouses of eukaryotic cells. They are considered as semi-autonomous because they have retained genomes inherited from their prokaryotic ancestor and host fully functional gene expression machineries. These organelles have attracted considerable attention because they combine bacterial-like traits with novel features that evolved in the host cell. Among them, mitochondria use many specific pathways to obtain complete and functional sets of tRNAs as required for translation. In some instances, tRNA genes have been partially or entirely transferred to the nucleus and mitochondria require precise import systems to attain their pool of tRNAs. Still, tRNA genes have also often been maintained in mitochondria. Their genetic arrangement is more diverse than previously envisaged. The expression and maturation of mitochondrial tRNAs often use specific enzymes that evolved during eukaryote history. For instance many mitochondria use a eukaryote-specific RNase P enzyme devoid of RNA. The structure itself of mitochondrial encoded tRNAs is also very diverse, as e.g., in Metazoan, where tRNAs often show non canonical or truncated structures. As a result, the translational machinery in mitochondria evolved adapted strategies to accommodate the peculiarities of these tRNAs, in particular simplified identity rules for their aminoacylation. Here, we review the specific features of tRNA biology in mitochondria from model species representing the major eukaryotic groups, with an emphasis on recent research on tRNA import, maturation and aminoacylation.

The mechanistic and evolutionary aspects of the 2'- and 3'-OH paradigm in biosynthetic machinery

BACKGROUND

The translation machinery underlies a multitude of biological processes within the cell. The design and implementation of the modern translation apparatus on even the simplest course of action is extremely complex, and involves different RNA and protein factors. According to the "RNA world" idea, the critical link in the translation machinery may be assigned to an adaptor tRNA molecule. Its exceptional functional and structural characteristics are of primary importance in understanding the evolutionary relationships among all these macromolecular components.

PRESENTATION OF THE HYPOTHESIS

The 2'-3' hydroxyls of the tRNA A76 constitute chemical groups of critical functional importance, as they are implicated in almost all phases of protein biosynthesis. They contribute to: a) each step of the tRNA aminoacylation reaction catalyzed by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs); b) the isomerase activity of EF-Tu, involving a mixture of the 2'(3')- aminoacyl tRNA isomers as substrates, thereby producing the required combination of amino acid and tRNA; and c) peptide bond formation at the peptidyl transferase center (PTC) of the ribosome. We hypothesize that specific functions assigned to the 2'-3' hydroxyls during peptide bond formation co-evolved, together with two modes of attack on the aminoacyl-adenylate carbonyl typical for two classes of aaRSs, and alongside the isomerase activity of EF-Tu. Protein components of the translational apparatus are universally recognized as being of ancient origin, possibly replacing RNA-based enzymes that may have existed before the last universal common ancestor (LUCA). We believe that a remnant of these processes is still imprinted on the organization of modern-day translation.

TESTING AND IMPLICATIONS OF THE HYPOTHESIS

Earlier publications indicate that it is possible to select ribozymes capable of attaching the aa-AMP moiety to RNA molecules. The scenario described herein would gain general acceptance, if a ribozyme able to activate the amino acid and transfer it onto the terminal ribose of the tRNA, would be found in any life form, or generated in vitro. Interestingly, recent studies have demonstrated the plausibility of using metals, likely abandoned under primordial conditions, as biomimetic catalysts of the aminoacylation reaction.

Crystal structure of human mitochondrial PheRS complexed with tRNA(Phe) in the active "open" state

Monomeric human mitochondrial phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (PheRS), or hmPheRS, is the smallest known enzyme exhibiting aminoacylation activity. HmPheRS consists of only two structural domains and differs markedly from heterodimeric eukaryotic cytosolic and bacterial analogs both in the domain organization and in the mode of tRNA binding. Here, we describe the first crystal structure of mitochondrial aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase (aaRS) complexed with tRNA at a resolution of 3.0 Å. Unlike bacterial PheRSs, the hmPheRS recognizes C74, the G1-C72 base pair, and the "discriminator" base A73, proposed to contribute to tRNA(Phe) identity in the yeast mitochondrial enzyme. An interaction of the tRNA acceptor stem with the signature motif 2 residues of hmPheRS is of critical importance for the stabilization of the CCA-extended conformation and its correct placement in the synthetic site of the enzyme. The crystal structure of hmPheRS-tRNA(Phe) provides direct evidence that the formation of the complex with tRNA requires a significant rearrangement of the anticodon-binding domain from the "closed" to the productive "open" state. Global repositioning of the domain is tRNA modulated and governed by long-range electrostatic interactions.

Cell-specific differences in the requirements for translation quality control

Protein synthesis has an overall error rate of approximately 10(-4) for each mRNA codon translated. The fidelity of translation is mainly determined by two events: synthesis of cognate amino acid:tRNA pairs by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs) and accurate selection of aminoacyl-tRNAs (aa-tRNAs) by the ribosome. To ensure faithful aa-tRNA synthesis, many aaRSs employ a proofreading ("editing") activity, such as phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetases (PheRS) that hydrolyze mischarged Tyr-tRNA(Phe). Eukaryotes maintain two distinct PheRS enzymes, a cytoplasmic (ctPheRS) and an organellar form. CtPheRS is similar to bacterial enzymes in that it consists of a heterotetramer in which the alpha-subunits contain the active site and the beta-subunits harbor the editing site. In contrast, mitochondrial PheRS (mtPheRS) is an alpha-subunit monomer that does not edit Tyr-tRNA(Phe), and a comparable transacting activity does not exist in organelles. Although mtPheRS does not edit, it is extremely specific as only one Tyr-tRNA(Phe) is synthesized for every approximately 7,300 Phe-tRNA(Phe), compatible with an error rate in translation of approximately 10(-4). When the error rate of mtPheRS was increased 17-fold, the corresponding strain could not grow on respiratory media and the mitochondrial genome was rapidly lost. In contrast, error-prone mtPheRS, editing-deficient ctPheRS, and their wild-type counterparts all supported cytoplasmic protein synthesis and cell growth. These striking differences reveal unexpectedly divergent requirements for quality control in different cell compartments and suggest that the limits of translational accuracy may be largely determined by cellular physiology.

A mechanism for functional segregation of mitochondrial and cytosolic genetic codes

The coexistence of multiple gene translation machineries is a feature of eukaryotic cells and a result of the endosymbiotic events that gave rise to mitochondria, plastids, and other organelles. The conditions required for the integration of these apparatuses within a single cell are not understood, but current evidence indicates that complete ablation of the mitochondrial protein synthesis apparatus and its substitution by its cytosolic equivalent is not possible. Why certain mitochondrial components and not others can be substituted by cytosolic equivalents is not known. In trypanosomatids this situation reaches a limit, because certain aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are mitochondrial specific despite the fact that all tRNAs in these organisms are shared between cytosol and mitochondria. Here we report that a mitochondria-specific lysyl-tRNA synthetase in Trypanosoma has evolved a mechanism to block the activity of the enzyme during its synthesis and translocation. Only when the enzyme reaches the mitochondria is it activated through the cleavage of a C-terminal structural extension, preventing the possibility of the enzyme being active in the cytosol.

Intra-protein compensatory mutations analysis highlights the tRNA recognition regions in aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases

The aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs) covalently attach amino acids to their corresponding nucleic acid adapter molecules, tRNAs. The interactions in the tRNA-aaRSs complexes are mostly non-specific, and largely electrostatic. Tracing a way of aaRS-tRNA mutual adaptation throughout evolution offers a clearer view of understanding how aaRS-tRNA systems preserve patterns of tRNA recognition and binding. In this study, we used the compensatory mutations analysis to explore adaptation of aaRSs in respond to random mutations that can occur in the tRNA-recognition area. We showed that the frequency of compensatory mutations among residues that belong to the recognition region is 1.75-fold higher than that of the exposed residues. The highest frequencies of compensatory mutations are observed for pairs of charged residues, wherein one residue is located within the tRNA-recognition area, while the second is placed outside of the area, and contributes to the formation of the aaRS electrostatic landscape. Given charged residues are compensated by buried charge residues in more than 60% of the analyzed mutations. The cytoplasmatic and mitochondrial aaRSs preserve similar patterns of compensatory mutations in the tRNA recognition areas. Moreover, we found that mitochondrial aaRSs demonstrate a significant increase in the frequency of compensatory mutations in the area. Our findings shed light on the physical nature of compensatory mutations in aaRSs, thereby keeping unchanged tRNA-recognition patterns.

The tRNA-induced conformational activation of human mitochondrial phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase

All class II aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs) are known to be active as functional homodimers, homotetramers, or heterotetramers. However, multimeric organization is not a prerequisite for phenylalanylation activity, as monomeric mitochondrial phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (PheRS) is also active. We herein report the structure, at 2.2 A resolution, of a human monomeric mitPheRS complexed with Phe-AMP. The smallest known aaRS, which is, in fact, 1/5 of a cytoplasmic analog, is a chimera of the catalytic module of the alpha and anticodon binding domain (ABD) of the bacterial beta subunit of (alphabeta)2 PheRS. We demonstrate that the ABD located at the C terminus of mitPheRS overlaps with the acceptor stem of phenylalanine transfer RNA (tRNAPhe) if the substrate is positioned in a manner similar to that seen in the binary Thermus thermophilus complex. Thus, formation of the PheRS-tRNAPhe complex in human mitochondria must be accompanied by considerable rearrangement (hinge-type rotation through approximately 160 degrees) of the ABD upon tRNA binding.

tRNA discrimination by T. thermophilus phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase at the binding step

The extent of tRNA recognition at the level of binding by Thermus thermophilus phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (PheRS), one of the most complex class II synthetases, has been studied by independent measurements of the enzyme association with wild-type and mutant tRNA(Phe)s as well as with non-cognate tRNAs. The data obtained, combined with kinetic data on aminoacylation, clearly show that PheRS exhibits more tRNA selectivity at the level of binding than at the level of catalysis. The anticodon nucleotides involved in base-specific interactions with the enzyme prevail both in the initial binding recognition and in favouring aminoacylation catalysis. Tertiary nucleotides of base pair G19-C56 and base triple U45-G10-C25 contribute primarily to stabilization of the correctly folded tRNA(Phe) structure, which is important for binding. Other nucleotides of the central core (U20, U16 and of the A26-G44 tertiary base pair) are involved in conformational adjustment of the tRNA upon its interaction with the enzyme. The specificity of nucleotide A73, mutation of which slightly reduces the catalytic rate of aminoacylation, is not displayed at the binding step. A few backbone-mediated contacts of PheRS with the acceptor and anticodon stems revealed in the crystal structure do not contribute to tRNA(Phe) discrimination, their role being limited to stabilization of the complex. The highest affinity of T. thermophilus PheRS for cognate tRNA, observed for synthetase-tRNA complexes, results in 100-3000-fold binding discrimination against non-cognate tRNAs.

Determination of tRNA(Phe) nucleotides contacting the subunits of Thermus thermophilus phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase by photoaffinity crosslinking

The nucleotides of tRNA(Phe) interacting with the subunits of Thermus thermophilus phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (the alpha(2)beta(2) heterotetramer) have been determined by photoaffinity crosslinking of randomly s(4)U-monosubstituted tRNA(Phe) transcripts which retain aminoacylation parameters closely similar to those of the native tRNA(Phe). The thiolated transcripts have been fractionated by affinity electrophoresis and separately crosslinked to the enzyme. Sites of crosslinking to the beta subunit have been identified at positions 33 and 39 and crosslinking sites to the alpha subunit have been localized at positions 20, 45 and 47, using alkaline hydrolysis analysis of the crosslinked proteinase K-treated tRNAs. An additional crosslink to the beta subunit, not identified in the full-length crosslinked tRNAs, has been deduced to occur at position 12, based on the analysis of an unusual (fast migrating) crosslinked product. Nucleotide s(4)U8 of native tRNA(Phe) has been shown to form a minor crosslink to the alpha subunit. Four of the seven crosslinking sites, namely nucleotides 8, 12, 20 and 39, are among those shown to be protected against cleavage by iodine in footprinting experiments; in contrast, only nucleotide 12 is among the contact sites defined in the crystal structure. The data of independent biochemical approaches strongly suggest conformational flexibility of the complex under functional conditions, thus reflecting the importance of macromolecular dynamics for the interaction.

Unique recognition style of tRNA(Leu) by Haloferax volcanii leucyl-tRNA synthetase

The recognition manner of tRNA(Leu), a class II tRNA characterized by a long variable arm, by leucyl-tRNA synthetase from an extreme halophilic archaea, Haloferax volcanii, was studied using the in vitro transcription system. It was found that the discriminator base (A73) and the long variable arm, especially the specific loop sequence A47CG47D and U47H at the base of this helix, are significant for recognition by LeuRS. An appropriate stem length of the variable arm was also required. Base substitutions in the anticodon arm did not affect the leucylation activity. Transplantation of both the discriminator base and the variable arm of tRNA(Leu) was not sufficient to introduce leucylation activity to tRNA(Ser). Insertion of an additional nucleotide into the D-loop, which is not involved in the direct interaction with LeuRS, converted tRNA(Ser) to an efficient leucine acceptor. This suggests that differences in the tertiary structure play a key role in eliminating tRNA(Ser). The sequence-specific recognition of the long variable arm of tRNA(Leu) has not been observed in any of other organisms reported, such as Escherichia coli, yeast or human. On the other hand, the mode of discrimination from non-cognate tRNAs is similar to that in E. coli in that differences in the tertiary structure play a key role. Similarity extends to the substrate stringency, exemplified by a cross-species aminoacylation study showing that no class II tRNAs from E. coli or yeast can be leucylated by H. volcanii LeuRS. Our results have implications for the understanding of the evolution of the recognition system of class II tRNA.

Expression and characterization of a human mitochondrial phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase

Human mitochondrial phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (mtPheRS) has been identified from the human EST database. Using consensus sequences derived from conserved regions of the alpha and beta-subunits from bacterial PheRS, two partially sequenced cDNA clones were identified. Unexpectedly, sequence analysis indicated that one of these clones was a truncated form of the other. Detailed analysis indicates that unlike the (alphabeta)2 structure of the prokaryotic and eukaryotic cytoplasmic forms of PheRS, the human mtPheRS consists of a single polypeptide chain. This protein has been cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli. Gel filtration and analytical velocity sedimentation centrifugation indicate that the human mtPheRS is active in a monomeric form. The N-terminal 314 amino acid residues appear to be analogous to the alpha-subunit of the prokaryotic PheRS, while the C-terminal 100 amino acid residues correspond to a region of the beta-subunit known to interact with the anticodon of tRNAPhe. Comparisons with the sequences of PheRS from yeast and Drosophila mitochondria indicate they are 42 % and 51 % identical with the human mtPheRS, respectively. Sequence analysis confirms the presence of motifs characteristic of class II aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. KM and kcat values for ATP:PPi exchange and for the aminoacylation reaction carried out by human mtPheRS have been determined. Evolutionary origins of this small monomeric human mtPheRS are unknown, however, implications are that this enzyme is a result of the simplification of the more complex (alphabeta)2 bacterial PheRS in which specific functional regions were retained.

Cloning and characterization of the phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase beta subunit gene from Candida albicans

A Candida albicans expression library was constructed from RNA isolated from regenerating protoplasts. A 1.4-kb cDNA clone was used to isolate a genomic fragment. Sequence analysis revealed an open reading frame of 593 amino acids with an overall identity of 63.6% with the phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase beta subunit (FRS1) of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. We named it CaFRS1. It is located in a single copy in chromosome R, SfiI fragment M. Its expression showed a decrease during the cell wall regeneration process in protoplasts of both yeast and mycelial cells of C. albicans, suggesting its requirement thereof in initial steps of the cell wall synthesis.

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases

Crystallographic studies of a number of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases and their complexes with ATP, amino acid and cognate tRNA are leading to an increasingly detailed picture of how these sophisticated enzymes function. Within the two distinct structural classes of ten synthetases, many common features are apparent, although evolution has led to many interesting idiosyncrasies in certain enzymes. Recent advances, specifically concerning class II enzymes, have increased our knowledge of both the role of electrophiles in the mechanism of amino acid activation and cross-subunit tRNA recognition and help solve the evolutionary puzzles that have emerged from the extension of the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase database to include Archae.

Transfer RNA(Phe) isoacceptors possess non-identical set of identity elements at high and low Mg2+ concentration

Primary structures of phage T5- and Escherichia coli-encoded tRNA(Phe) are distinct at four out of 11 positions known as identity elements for E. coli phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (FRS). In order to reveal structural requirements for FRS recognition, aminoacylation of wild-type phage T5 tRNA(Phe) gene transcript and mutants containing substitutions of the identity elements at positions 20, 34, 35 and 36 was compared with E. coli tRNA(Phe) gene transcript. The wild-type phage T5 transcript can be aminoacylated with the same catalytic efficiency as the E. coli counterpart. However, the maximal aminoacylation rate for T5 and E. coli transcripts was reached at different Mg2+ concentrations: 4 and 15 mM, respectively. Aminoacylation assays with tRNA(Phe) mutants revealed that (i) phage transcripts with the substituted anticodon bases at positions 35 and 36 were efficient substrates for aminoacylation at 15 mM Mg2+ but not at optimal 4 mM Mg2+; (ii) any change of G34 in phage transcripts dramatically decreased the aminoacylation efficiency at both 4 and 15 mM Mg2+ whereas G34A mutation in the E. coli transcript exhibits virtually no influence on aminoacylation rate at 15 mM Mg2+; (iii) substitution of A20 with U in the phage transcript caused no significant change in the aminoacylation rate at both Mg2+ concentrations; (iv) phage transcripts with double substitutions A20U+A35C and A20U+A36C were very poor substrates for FRS. Collectively, the results indicate the non-identical mode of tRNA(Phe) recognition by E. coli FRS at low and high Mg2+ concentrations. Probably, along with identity elements, the local tRNA conformation is essential for recognition by FRS.