DSC study of the thermal stability of S-protein and S-peptide/S-protein

Mechanism of 3D domain swapping in bovine seminal ribonuclease

3D domain swapping (3D‐DS) is a complex protein aggregation process for which no unique mechanism exists. We report an analysis of 3D‐DS in bovine seminal ribonuclease, a homodimeric protein whose subunits are linked by two disulfide bridges, based on NMR and biochemical studies. The presence of the covalent bonds between the subunits stabilizes the unswapped dimer, and allows distinct evaluation of the structural and dynamic effects of the swapping with respect to the dimerization process. In comparison with the monomeric subunit, which, in solution has a compact structure without any propensity for local unfolding, both swapped and unswapped dimers show increased flexibility. NMR analysis, together with urea denaturation and hydrogen–deuterium exchange data, indicates that the two dimers have increased conformational fluctuations. Furthermore, we found that the rate‐limiting step of both the swapping and unswapping pathways is the detachment of the N‐terminal helices from the monomers. These results suggest a new general mechanism in which a dimeric intermediate could facilitate 3D‐DS in globular proteins.

Structured digital abstract

http://www.uniprot.org/uniprot/P00669 and http://www.uniprot.org/uniprot/P00669 http://www.ebi.ac.uk/ontology-lookup/?termId=MI:0407 by http://www.ebi.ac.uk/ontology-lookup/?termId=MI:0077 (http://www.ebi.ac.uk/intact/interaction/EBI-8870415)

Back to the future: Ribonuclease A

Pancreatic ribonuclease A (EC 3.1.27.5, RNase) is, perhaps, the best-studied enzyme of the 20th century. It was isolated by René Dubos, crystallized by Moses Kunitz, sequenced by Stanford Moore and William Stein, and synthesized in the laboratory of Bruce Merrifield, all at the Rockefeller Institute/University. It has proven to be an excellent model system for many different types of experiments, both as an enzyme and as a well-characterized protein for biophysical studies. Of major significance was the demonstration by Chris Anfinsen at NIH that the primary sequence of RNase encoded the three-dimensional structure of the enzyme. Many other prominent protein chemists/enzymologists have utilized RNase as a dominant theme in their research. In this review, the history of RNase and its offspring, RNase S (S-protein/S-peptide), will be considered, especially the work in the Merrifield group, as a preface to preliminary data and proposed experiments addressing topics of current interest. These include entropy-enthalpy compensation, entropy of ligand binding, the impact of protein modification on thermal stability, and the role of protein dynamics in enzyme action. In continuing to use RNase as a prototypical enzyme, we stand on the shoulders of the giants of protein chemistry to survey the future.

Control of function of a small peptide by a protein

A peptide that functions only in the presence of a protein has been developed using reaction-based selection from peptide phage libraries. The peptide was not functional in the absence of the protein, but formed enaminones with 1,3-diketone derivatives when bound to the protein.

Differential scanning calorimetry as a tool to estimate binding parameters in multiligand binding proteins

The stability of proteins and their interactions with other molecules is a topic of special interest in biochemistry because many cellular processes depend on that. New methods and approaches are constantly developed to elucidate the energetics of biomolecular recognition. In this sense, the application of the theory of macromolecular unfolding linked to ligand binding to differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) has proved to be a useful tool to simultaneously characterize the energetics of unfolding and binding. Although the general theory is well known, the applicability of DSC to study the interaction of biomolecules is not common. In the current work, we estimated the binding parameters of 8-anilinonaphthalene-1-sulfonic acid to human serum albumin using DSC. This model system was chosen due to both the complex stoichiometry and the moderate binding constants. From DSC curves acquired at different ligand concentrations, we obtained the number of bound ligands, the binding constants, and the binding enthalpy for each independent binding site. Compared with those parameters determined by titration calorimetry, the results highlight the potentiality of DSC to estimate binding parameters in multiligand binding proteins.

Formation, structure, and dissociation of the ribonuclease S three-dimensional domain-swapped dimer

Post-translational events, such as proteolysis, are believed to play essential roles in amyloid formation in vivo. Ribonuclease A forms oligomers by the three-dimensional domain-swapping mechanism. Here, we demonstrate the ability of ribonuclease S, a proteolytically cleaved form of ribonuclease A, to oligomerize efficiently. This unexpected capacity has been investigated to study the effect of proteolysis on oligomerization and amyloid formation. The yield of the RNase S dimer was found to be significantly higher than that of RNase A dimers, which suggests that proteolysis can activate oligomerization via the three-dimensional domain-swapping mechanism. Characterization by chromatography, enzymatic assays, and NMR spectroscopy indicate that the structure of the RNase S dimer is similar to that of the RNase A C-dimer. The RNase S dimer dissociates much more readily than the RNase A C-dimer does. By measuring the dissociation rate as a function of temperature, the activation enthalpy and entropy for RNase S dimer dissociation were found to resemble those for the release of the small fragment (S-peptide) from monomeric RNase S. Excess S-peptide strongly slows RNase S dimer dissociation. These results strongly suggest that S-peptide release is the rate-limiting step of RNase S dimer dissociation.

Minor folding defects trigger local modification of glycoproteins by the ER folding sensor GT

UDP-glucose:glycoprotein glucosyltransferase (GT) is a key component of the glycoprotein-specific folding and quality control system in the endoplasmic reticulum. By exclusively reglucosylating incompletely folded and assembled glycoproteins, it serves as a folding sensor that prolongs the association of newly synthesized glycoproteins with the chaperone-like lectins calnexin and calreticulin. Here, we address the mechanism by which GT recognizes and labels its substrates. Using an improved inhibitor assay based on soluble conformers of pancreatic ribonuclease in its glycosylated (RNase B) and unglycosylated (RNase A) forms, we found that the protein moiety of a misfolded conformer alone is sufficient for specific recognition by GT in vitro. To investigate the relationship between recognition and glucosylation, we tested a variety of glycosylation mutants of RNase S-Protein and an RNase mutant with a local folding defect [RNase C65S, C72S], as well as a series of loop insertion mutants. The results indicated that local folding defects in an otherwise correctly folded domain could be recognized by GT. Only glycans attached to the polypeptide within the misfolded sites were glucosylated.

Study of the ribonuclease-S-protein-peptide complex using a radical probe and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

The interaction between ribonuclease (RNase) S-protein and S-peptide is examined by studying their limited oxidation within the RNase-S complex and free forms using radicals. The limited oxidation of the RNase-S complex and each component is effected through their reaction with a high flux of oxygen-based radicals generated by an electrical discharge within an electrospray ion source. Their exposure to radicals occurs on short millisecond time scales and has been consistently found not to cause any measurable structural damage or conformational change to proteins in a number of published reports. Consistent with these studies, S-peptide is preferentially protected from reactions with radicals under conditions in which it is bound to S-protein. Conversely, a region of S-protein comprising residues 96-100 constitutes the S-peptide binding domain based on its diminished reactivity with radicals within the RNase-S complex over the free S-protein. The results, for the first time, demonstrate the use of radicals generated by an electrical discharge to study protein complexes.

Pretransitional structural changes in the thermal denaturation of ribonuclease S and S protein

Two mechanisms have been proposed for the thermal unfolding of ribonuclease S (RNase S). The first is a sequential partial unfolding of the S peptide/S protein complex followed by dissociation, whereas the second is a concerted denaturation/dissociation. The thermal denaturation of ribonuclease S and its fragment, the S protein, were followed with circular dichroism and infrared spectra. These spectra were analyzed by the principal component method of factor analysis. The use of multiple spectral techniques and of factor analysis monitored different aspects of the denaturation simultaneously. The unfolding pathway was compared with that of the parent enzyme ribonuclease A (RNase A), and a model was devised to assess the importance of the dissociation in the unfolding. The unfolding patterns obtained from the melting curves of each protein imply the existence of multiple intermediate states and/or processes. Our data provide evidence that the pretransition in the unfolding of ribonuclease S is due to partial unfolding of the S protein/S peptide complex and that the dissociation occurs at higher temperature. Our observations are consistent with a sequential denaturation mechanism in which at least one partial unfolding step comes before the main conformational transition, which is instead a concerted, final unfolding/dissociation step.

High affinity RNase S-peptide variants obtained by phage display have a novel "hot-spot" of binding energy

Using phage display mutagenesis, high affinity variants of RNase S-peptide were produced that bind to RNase S-protein over 100-fold more tightly than the wild type S-peptide. The S-peptide: S-protein interface was further characterized using "biased" phage display libraries, where each targeted residue was constrained to be either polar or nonpolar. The use of these tailored libraries placed constraints on the type of interactions present during affinity maturation process and allowed more amino acids to be randomized simultaneously. These results, in conjunction with kinetic association and dissociation constants determined by surface plasmon resonance (SPR), highlight the role of a single mutation (A5W) in increasing S-peptide binding affinity. High affinity S-peptide variants were only identified when tryptophan was present in the phage display library at position 5, suggesting that this residue is a "hot-spot" of binding energy in the high affinity variants. Analysis of SPR data in the presence of denaturant suggests that the increased affinity is a result of increased hydrophobic interactions in the transition state rather than a stabilization of helical structure.

Thermodynamics of the helix-coil transition: Binding of S15 and a hybrid sequence, disulfide stabilized peptide to the S-protein

Pancreatic ribonuclease A may be cleaved to produce two fragments: the S-peptide (residues 1-20) and the S-protein (residues 21-124). The S-peptide, or a truncated version designated as the S15 peptide (residues 1-15), combines with the S-protein to produce catalytically active complexes. The conformation of these peptides and many of their analogues is predominantly random coil at room temperature; however, they populate a significant fraction of helical form at low temperature under certain solution conditions. Moreover, they adopt a helical conformation when bound to the S-protein. A hybrid sequence, disulfide-stabilized peptide (ApaS-25), designed to stabilize the helical structure of the S-peptide in solution, also combines with the S-protein to yield a catalytically active complex. We have performed high-precision titration microcalorimetric measurements to determine the free energy, enthalpy, entropy, and heat capacity changes for the binding of ApaS-25 to S-protein within the temperature range 5-25 degrees C. The thermodynamic parameters for both the complex formation reactions and the helix-to-coil transition also were calculated, using a structure-based approach, by calculating changes in accessible surface area and using published empirical parameters. A simple thermodynamic model is presented in an attempt to account for the differences between the binding of ApaS-25 and the S-peptide. From this model, the thermodynamic parameters of the helix-to-coil transition of S15 can be calculated.

Dimer formation by a "monomeric" protein

Dimeric proteins can arise by the swapping of structural domains between monomers. The prevalence of this occurrence is unknown. Ribonuclease A (RNase A) is assumed to be a monomer near physiological conditions. Here, this hypothesis is tested and found to be imprecise. The two histidine residues (His12 and His119) in the active site of RNase A arise from two domains (S-peptide and S-protein) of the protein. The H12A and H119A variants have 10(5)-fold less ribonucleolytic activity than does the wild-type enzyme. Incubating a 1:1 mixture of the H12A and H119A variants at pH 6.5 and 65 degrees C results in a 10(3)-fold increase in ribonucleolytic activity. A large quantity of active dimer can be produced by lyophilizing a 1:1 mixture of the H12A and H119A variants from acetic acid. At pH 6.5 and 65 degrees C, the ribonucleolytic activity of this dimer converges to that of the dimer formed by simply incubating the monomers, as expected for a monomer-dimer equilibrium. The equilibrium dissociation constant for the dimer is near 2 mM at both 65 and 37 degrees C. This value of Kd is only 20-fold greater than the concentration of RNase A in the cow pancreas, suggesting that RNase A dimers exist in vivo. The intrinsic ability of RNase A to form dimers under physiological conditions is consistent with a detailed model for the evolution of homodimeric proteins. Dimers of "monomeric" proteins could be more prevalent than is usually appreciated.

Thermodynamic stability of the two isoforms of bovine seminal ribonuclease

Bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase) is a dimeric protein with two identical subunits linked by two disulfide bridges, each subunit showing 80% of sequence identity with pancreatic RNase A. BS-RNase exists in two different quaternary conformations in solution: the MxM form, in which each subunit exchanges its alpha-helical N-terminal segment with its partner, and the M=M form with no exchange. By differential scanning microcalorimetry (DSC), the denaturation of the two dimeric forms of BS-RNase was found to be more complex than a simple two-state process. Monomeric derivatives of the dimeric protein follow instead a simple two-state mechanism, but are distinctly less stable than RNase A. The three-state N if I if D denaturation process of the two quaternary isoforms was interpreted by identifying in the dimers a central highly structured core, enclosing the covalently bonded subunit interface, which unfolds only after the periphery (mainly the N-terminal peptide) unfolds. Circular dichroism spectra of the two forms in the far-ultraviolet region show large differences between the secondary structure of the isoforms and that of the native BS-RNase mixture at equilibrium. This has been attributed to the presence in the equilibrium mixture of intermediate forms with displaced and disordered N-terminal alpha-helical segments.

Protein stabilization through phage display

RNase S consists of two proteolytic fragments of RNase A, residues 1-20 (S20) and residues 21-124 (S pro). A 15-mer peptide (S15p) with high affinity for S pro was selected from a phage display library. Peptide residues that are buried in the structure of the wild type complex are conserved in S15p though there are several changes at other positions. Isothermal titration calorimetry studies show that the affinity of S15p is comparable to that of the wild type peptide at 25 degrees C. However, the magnitudes of DeltaH(o) and DeltaC(p) are lower for S15p, suggesting that the thermal stability of the complex is enhanced. In agreement with this prediction, at pH 6, the T(m) of the S15p complex was found to be 10 degrees C higher than that of the wild type complex. This suggests that for proteins where fragment complementation systems exist, phage display can be used to find mutations that increase protein thermal stability.

Peptide and metal ion-dependent association of isolated helix-loop-helix calcium binding domains: studies of thrombic fragments of calmodulin

Calmodulin (CaM), the ubiquitous, eukaryotic, bilobal calcium-binding regulatory protein, has been cleaved by thrombin to create two fragments. TM1 (1-106) and TM2 (107-148). NMR and CD results indicate that TMI and TM2 can associate in the presence of Ca2+ to form a complex similar to native CaM, even though the cleavage site is not in the linker region between two helix-loop-helix domains, but rather within an alpha-helix. Cadmium-113 NMR results show that this complex has enhanced metal-ion binding properties when compared to either TM1 or TM2 alone. This complex can bind several CaM-binding target peptides, as shown by gel bandshift assays, circular dichroism spectra, and 13C NMR spectra of biosynthetically methyl-13C-Met-labeled TM1 and TM2; moreover, gel bandshift assays show that the addition of a target peptide strengthens the interactions between TM1 and TM2 and increases the stability of the complex. Cadmium-113 NMR spectra indicate that the TM1:TM2 complex can also bind the antipsychotic drug trifluoperazine. However, in contrast to CaM:peptide complexes, the TM1:TM2:peptide complexes are disrupted by 4 M urea; moreover, TM1 and TM2 in combination are unable to activate CaM-dependent enzymes. This suggests that TM1:TM2 mixtures cannot bind target molecules as tightly as intact CaM, or perhaps that binding occurs but additional interactions with the target enzymes that are necessary for proper activation are perturbed by the proteolytic cleavage. The results presented here reflect the importance of the existence of helix-loop-helix Ca2+-binding domains in pairs in proteins such as CaM, and extend the understanding of the association of such domains in this class of proteins in general.

Native-state hydrogen-exchange studies of a fragment complex can provide structural information about the isolated fragments

Ordered protein complexes are often formed from partially ordered fragments that are difficult to structurally characterize by conventional NMR and crystallographic techniques. We show that concentration-dependent hydrogen exchange studies of a fragment complex can provide structural information about the solution structures of the isolated fragments. This general methodology can be applied to any bimolecular or multimeric system. The experimental system used here consists of Ribonuclease S, a complex of two fragments of Ribonuclease A. Ribonuclease S and Ribonuclease A have identical three-dimensional structures but exhibit significant differences in their dynamics and stability. We show that the apparent large dynamic differences between Ribonuclease A and Ribonuclease S are caused by small amounts of free fragments in equilibrium with the folded complex, and that amide exchange rates in Ribonuclease S can be used to determine corresponding rates in the isolated fragments. The studies suggest that folded RNase A and the RNase S complex exhibit very similar dynamic behavior. Thus cleavage of a protein chain at a single site need not be accompanied by a large increase in flexibility of the complex relative to that of the uncleaved protein.

Isothermal titration calorimetry and differential scanning calorimetry as complementary tools to investigate the energetics of biomolecular recognition

The principles of isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) are reviewed together with the basic thermodynamic formalism on which the two techniques are based. Although ITC is particularly suitable to follow the energetics of an association reaction between biomolecules, the combination of ITC and DSC provides a more comprehensive description of the thermodynamics of an associating system. The reason is that the parameters DeltaG, DeltaH, DeltaS, and DeltaCp obtained from ITC are global properties of the system under study. They may be composed to varying degrees of contributions from the binding reaction proper, from conformational changes of the component molecules during association, and from changes in molecule/solvent interactions and in the state of protonation.

Circular dichroism study of ribonuclease A mutants containing the minimal structural requirements for dimerization and swapping

Four residues Pro19. Leu28, Cys31 and Cys32 proved to be the minimal structural requirements in determining the dimeric structure and the N-terminal segment swapping of bovine seminal ribonuclease, BS-RNase. We analyzed the content of secondary and tertiary structures in RNase A, P-RNase A, PL-RNase A, MCAM-PLCC-RNase A and MCAM-BS-RNase, performing near and far-UV CD spectra. It results that the five proteins have very similar native conformations. Thermal denaturation at pH 5.0 of the proteins. studied by means of CD measurements. proved reversible and well represented by the two-state N<==>D transition model. Thermodynamic data are discussed in the light of the structural information available for RNase A and BS-RNase.

Discovery of critical Tol A-binding residues in the bactericidal toxin colicin N: a biophysical approach

Colicins translocate across the Escherichia coli outer membrane and periplasm by interacting with several receptors. After first binding to outer membrane surface receptors via their central region, they interact with TolA or TonB proteins via their N-terminal regions. Finally, the toxic C-terminal region is inserted into or across the cytoplasmic membrane. We have measured the binding of colicin N to TolA by isothermal titration microcalorimetry (ITC) and tryptophan fluorescence. The isolated N-terminal domain exhibits a higher affinity for TolA (Kd = 1 microM) than does the whole colicin (18 microM), and similar behaviour has been observed when the N-terminal domain of the g3p protein of the bacteriophage fd, which also binds TolA, is examined in isolation and in situ. This may indicate a similar mechanism in which a cryptic TolA binding site is revealed after primary receptor binding. The isolated colicin N N-terminal domain appears to be unstructured in circular dichroism and fluorescence studies. We have used mutagenesis and ITC to characterize the TolA binding site and have shown it to be of a different sequence and much further from the N-terminus than previously thought.

Kinetic mechanism of a partial folding reaction. 2. Nature of the transition state

The effects of mutations, temperature, and solvent viscosity on the bimolecular association rate constant (kon) and dissociation rate constant (koff) of the complex (RNaseS*) formed by S-peptide analogues and folded S-protein are reported. An important advantage of this system is that both kon and koff may be measured under identical strongly native conditions, and Kd for the complex may be calculated from the ratio koff/kon (preceding article). The side chains of S-peptide residues His-12 and Met-13 contribute a large fraction of the total interface with S-protein. Changing these residues, either singly or in a double mutant, destabilizes RNaseS* by up to 6 orders of magnitude, but causes no more than a 3-fold decrease in kon. Therefore, nativelike side-chain interactions between these residues and S-protein are not present in the transition state for folding. The absence of side-chain interactions in the transition state is surprising, since it has buried 55% of the total surface area that is buried upon forming RNaseS*, as estimated from the denaturant dependences of kon and koff (preceding article). The temperature dependence of the refolding rate suggests that the transition state for complex formation is stabilized by hydrophobic interactions: 66% of the change in heat capacity on forming RNaseS* occurs in the association reaction, consistent with the estimate of surface area burial from the denaturant studies. The solvent viscosity is varied to determine if the folding reaction is diffusion limited. Because kon, koff, and Kd all can be measured under the same native conditions, the viscosity effect on reaction rates can be separated from the effect of sucrose on the stability of RNaseS*. Both kon and koff are found to be inversely proportional to the solvent viscosity, indicating that the association and dissociation kinetics are diffusion controlled. The stabilizing effect of sucrose on RNaseS* appears as a reduction in koff.

Thermodynamic analysis of the effect of selective monodeamidation at asparagine 67 in ribonuclease A

Selective deamidation of proteins and peptides is a reaction of great interest, both because it has a physiological role and because it can cause alteration in the biological activity, local folding, and overall stability of the protein. In order to evaluate the thermodynamic effects of this reaction in proteins, we investigated the temperature-induced denaturation of ribonuclease A derivatives in which asparagine 67 was selectively replaced by an aspartyl residue or an isoaspartyl residue, as a consequence of an in vitro deamidation reaction. Differential scanning calorimetry measurements were performed in the pH range 3.0-6.0, where the unfolding process is reversible, according to the reheating criterion used. It resulted that the monodeamidated forms have a different thermal stability with respect to the parent enzyme. In particular, the replacement of asparagine 67 with an isoaspartyl residue leads to a decrease of 6.3 degrees C of denaturation temperature and 65 kJ mol-1 of denaturation enthalpy at pH 5.0. These results are discussed and correlated to the X-ray three-dimensional structure of this derivative. The analysis leads to the conclusion that the difference in thermal stability between RNase A and (N67isoD)RNase A is due to enthalpic effects arising from the loss of two important hydrogen bonds in the loop containing residue 67, partially counterbalanced by entropic effects. Finally, the influence of cytidine-2'-monophosphate on the stability of the three ribonucleases at pH 5.0 is studied and explained in terms of its binding on the active site of ribonucleases. The analysis makes it possible to estimate the apparent binding constant and binding enthalpy for the three proteins.