Insights into the Structure–Activity Relationship in Aerobic Alcohol Oxidation over a Metal–Organic-Framework-Supported Molybdenum(VI) Catalyst

Recent advances in metal-catalysed oxidation reactions

Oxidation reactions are vital tools in synthetic organic chemistry. Oxidation of organic species such as alcohols, phenols, aldehydes and ketones provides synthetically valuable organic compounds, especially synthetic intermediates for several biologically active compounds. Some of these synthetic intermediates have shown their synthetic utility in the total synthesis of natural products. Several classical and modern synthetic approaches have been used to achieve these oxidation reactions. In this review article, various oxidation reactions achieved by metal catalysis are highlighted.

In Situ Implanting ZrW2O7(OH)2(H2O)2 Nanorods into Hierarchical Functionalized Metal-Organic Framework via Solvent-Free Approach for Upgrading Catalytic Performance

Host-guest catalyst provides new opportunities for targeted applications and the development of new strategies for preparing host-guest catalysts is highly desired. Herein, an in situ solvent-free approach is developed for implanting ZrW2O7(OH)2(H2O)2 nanorods (ZrW-NR) in nitro-functionalized UiO-66(Zr) (UiO-66(Zr)-NO2) with hierarchical porosity, and the encapsulation of ZrW-NR enables the as-prepared host-guest catalyst remarkably enhanced catalytic performance for both for oxidative desulfurization (ODS) and acetalization reactions. ZrW-NR@UiO-66(Zr)-NO2 can eliminate 500 ppm sulfur within 9 min at 40 °C in ODS, and can transform 5.6 mmol benzaldehyde after 3 min at room temperature in acetalization reaction. Its turnover frequencies reach 72.3 h-1 at 40 °C for ODS which is 33.4 times higher than UiO-66(Zr)-NO2, and 28140 h-1 for acetalization which is the highest among previous reports. Density functional theory calculation result indicates that the W sites in ZrW-NR can decompose H2O2 to WVI-peroxo intermediates that contribute to catalytic activity for the ODS reaction. This work opens a new solvent-free approach for preparing MOFs-based host-guest catalysts to upgrade their redox and acid performance.

Metalation of metal-organic frameworks: fundamentals and applications

Metalation of metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) has been developed as a prominent strategy for materials functionalization for pore chemistry modulation and property optimization. By introducing exotic metal ions/complexes/nanoparticles onto/into the parent framework, many metallized MOFs have exhibited significantly improved performance in a wide range of applications. In this review, we focus on the research progress in the metalation of metal-organic frameworks during the last five years, spanning the design principles, synthetic strategies, and potential applications. Based on the crystal engineering principles, a minor change in the MOF composition through metalation would lead to leveraged variation of properties. This review starts from the general strategies established for the incorporation of metal species within MOFs, followed by the design principles to graft the desired functionality while maintaining the porosity of frameworks. Facile metalation has contributed a great number of bespoke materials with excellent performance, and we summarize their applications in gas adsorption and separation, heterogeneous catalysis, detection and sensing, and energy storage and conversion. The underlying mechanisms are also investigated by state-of-the-art techniques and analyzed for gaining insight into the structure-property relationships, which would in turn facilitate the further development of design principles. Finally, the current challenges and opportunities in MOF metalation have been discussed, and the promising future directions for customizing the next-generation advanced materials have been outlined as well.

Bioinspired Photoactive Cu-Halide Coordination Polymers for Reduction Activation and Oxygen Conversion

Natural copper oxygenases provide fundamental principles for catalytic oxidation with kinetically inert molecular oxygen, but it remains a marked challenge to mimic both their structure and function in an entity. Inspired by the CuA enzymatic sites, herein we report two new photoactive binuclear copper-iodine- and bisbenzimidazole-comodified coordination polymers to reproduce the natural oxo-functionalization repertoire in a unique photocatalytic pathway. Under light irradiation, the Cu-halide coordination polymers effectively reduce NHP esters and complete oxygen reduction activation via photoinduced electron transfer for the aerobic oxidative coupling of hydroquinone with terminal alkynes, affording hydroxyl-functionalized ketones with high efficiency and selectivity. This supramolecular approach to developing bioinspired artificial oxygenases that merge transition metal- and photocatalysis supplies a new way to fabricate distinctive photocatalysts with desirable catalytic performances and controllable precise active sites.

Ligand-Mediated Regulation of the Chemical/Thermal Stability and Catalytic Performance of Isostructural Cobalt(II) Coordination Polymers

Regulating the chemical/thermal stability and catalytic activity of coordination polymers (CPs) to achieve high catalytic performance is topical and challenging. The CPs are competent in promoting oxidative cross-coupling, yet they have not received substantial attention. Here, the ligand effect of the secondary ligand of CPs for oxidative cross-coupling reactions was investigated. Specifically, four new isostructural CPs [Co(Fbtx)1.5(4-R-1,2-BDC)]n (denoted as Co-CP-R, Fbtx = 1,4-bis(1,2,4-triazole-1-ylmethyl)-2,3,5,6-tetrafluorobenzene, 4-R-1,2-BDC = 4-R-1,2-benzenedicarboxylate, R = F, Cl, Br, CF3) were prepared. It was found that in the reactions of oxidative amination of benzoxazoles with secondary amines and the oxidative coupling of styrenes with benzaldehydes, both the chemical and thermal stabilities of the four Co-CPs with the R group followed the trend of -CF3 > -Br > -Cl > -F. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations suggested that the difference in reactivity may be ascribed to the effect of substituent groups on the electron transition energy of the cobalt(II) center of these Co-CPs. These findings highlight the secondary ligand effect in regulating the stability and catalytic performance of coordination networks.

Integration of Metal-Organic Frameworks and Metals: Synergy for Electrocatalysis

Electrocatalysis is a highly promising technology widely used in clean energy conversion. There is a continuing need to develop advanced electrocatalysts to catalyze the critical electrochemical reactions. Integrating metal active species, including various metal nanostructures (NSs) and atomically dispersed metal sites (ADMSs), into metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) leads to the formation of promising heterogeneous electrocatalysts that take advantage of both components. Among them, MOFs can provide support and protection for the active sites on guest metals, and the resulting host-guest interactions can synergistically enhance the electrocatalytic performance. In this review, three key concerns on MOF-metal heterogeneous electrocatalysts regarding the catalytic sites, conductivity, and catalytic stability are first presented. Then, rational integration strategies of MOFs and metals, including the integration of metal NSs via surface anchoring, space confining, and MOF coating, as well as the integration of ADMSs either with the metal nodes/linkers or within the pores of MOFs, along with their recent progress on synergistic cooperation for specific electrochemical reactions are summarized. Finally, current challenges and possible solutions in applying these increasingly concerned electrocatalysts are also provided.

Cu-MOFs with Rich Open Metal and F Sites for Separation of C2H2 from CO2 and CH4

Herein, we used the 4-fluoro-[1,1'-biphenyl]-3,4',5-tricarboxylic acid (H₃fbptc) ligand to design and construct a new metal-organic framework (MOF), [Cu₃(fbptc)₂(H₂O)₃]·3NMP (1), which possesses rich accessible metal sites and F functional groups in the porous walls and shows high uptake for C₂H₂ (119.3 cm³ g^-1) and significant adsorption selectivity for C₂H₂ over CH₄ (14.4) and CO₂ (3.6) at 298 K and 100 kPa. In particular, for the gas mixtures of C₂H₂-CH₄ and C₂H₂-CO₂, the MOF reveals large breakthrough time ratios (C₂H₂/CH₄ = 13, C₂H₂/CO₂ = 5.9), which are particularly prominent in dynamic breakthrough experiments, also confirming the excellent potential for the practical separation of C₂H₂ from two-component mixtures (C₂H₂-CH₄ and C₂H₂-CO₂) and even three-component mixtures (C₂H₂-CO₂-CH₄).

Honeycomb reactor: a promising device for streamlining aerobic oxidation under continuous-flow conditions

We report on the high potential of a honeycomb reactor for the use in aerobic oxidation under continuous-flow conditions. The honeycomb reactor is made of porous material with narrow channels separated by porous walls allowing for high density accumulation in the reactor. This structure raised the mixing efficiency of a gas-liquid reaction system, and it effectively accelerated the aerobic oxidation of benzyl alcohols to benzaldehydes under continuous-flow conditions. This reactor is a promising device for streamlining aerobic oxidation with high process safety because it is a closed system.

Classifying and Understanding the Reactivities of Mo-Based Alkyne Metathesis Catalysts from 95Mo NMR Chemical Shift Descriptors

The most active alkyne metathesis catalysts rely on well-defined Mo alkylidynes, X₃Mo≡CR (X = OR), in particular the recently developed canopy catalyst family bearing silanolate ligand sets. Recent efforts to understand catalyst reactivity patterns have shown that NMR chemical shifts are powerful descriptors, though previous studies have mostly focused on ligand-based NMR descriptors. Here, we show in the context of alkyne metathesis that ⁹⁵Mo chemical shift tensors encode detailed information on the electronic structure of these catalysts. Analysis by first-principles calculations of ⁹⁵Mo chemical shift tensors extracted from solid-state ⁹⁵Mo NMR spectra shows a direct link of chemical shift values with the energies of the HOMO and LUMO, two molecular orbitals involved in the key [2 + 2]-cycloaddition step, thus linking ⁹⁵Mo chemical shifts to reactivity. In particular, the ⁹⁵Mo chemical shifts are driven by ligand electronegativity (σ-donation) and electron delocalization through Mo-O π interactions, thus explaining the reactivity patterns of the silanolate canopy catalysts. These results further motivate exploration of transition metal NMR signatures and their relationships to electronic structure and reactivity.

Polyoxometalate-Incorporated Metal-Organic Network as a Heterogeneous Catalyst for Selective Oxidation of Aryl Alkenes

Selective oxidation of aryl alkenes is important for chemical synthesis reactions, in which the key lies in the rational design of efficient catalysts. Herein, four polyoxometalate (POM)-incorporated metal-organic networks, with the formulas of [Co(ttb)(H₂O)₃]₂[SiMo₁₂O₄₀]·2H₂O (1), [Co(ttb)(H₂O)₂]₂[SiW₁₂O₄₀]·8H₂O (2), [Zn(Httb)(H₂ttb)][BW₁₂O₄₀]·9H₂O (3) and {[Zn(H₂O)₃(ttb)]₄[Zn₃(H₂O)₆]}[H₃SiW_10.5Zn_1.5O₄₀]₂·24H₂O (4) (ttb = 1,3,5-tri(1,2,4-triazol-1-ylmethyl)-2,4,6-trimethylbenzene), were hydrothermally synthesized and structurally characterized. Structural analysis showed that compound 1 consists of a POM-encapsulated three-dimensional (3-D) supramolecular framework; compound 2 is composed of a POM-supported 3-D coordination network; and compounds 3-4 show POM-incorporated 3-D supramolecular networks. Using selective catalytic oxidation of styrene as the model reaction, compounds 1-4 as heterogeneous catalysts display excellent performance with the double advantages of high styrene conversion and benzaldehyde selectivity owing to the synergistic effect among POM anions and transition metal (TM) centers. Among them, compound 1 exhibits the highest performance with ca. 96% styrene conversion and ca. 99% benzaldehyde selectivity in 3 h. In addition, compound 1 also displays excellent substrate compatibility, good reusability, and structural stability. Thus, a plausible reaction pathway for the selective oxidation of styrene is proposed. This study on the structure-function relationship paves a way for the rational design of POM-based heterogeneous catalysts for important catalysis applications.

Direct Observation of Ammonia Storage in UiO-66 Incorporating Cu(II) Binding Sites

The presence of active sites in metal-organic framework (MOF) materials can control and affect their performance significantly in adsorption and catalysis. However, revealing the interactions between the substrate and active sites in MOFs at atomic precision remains a challenging task. Here, we report the direct observation of binding of NH3 in a series of UiO-66 materials containing atomically dispersed defects and open Cu(I) and Cu(II) sites. While all MOFs in this series exhibit similar surface areas (1111-1135 m2 g-1), decoration of the -OH site in UiO-66-defect with Cu(II) results in a 43% enhancement of the isothermal uptake of NH3 at 273 K and 1.0 bar from 11.8 in UiO-66-defect to 16.9 mmol g-1 in UiO-66-CuII. A 100% enhancement of dynamic adsorption of NH3 at a concentration level of 630 ppm from 2.07 mmol g-1 in UiO-66-defect to 4.15 mmol g-1 in UiO-66-CuII at 298 K is observed. In situ neutron powder diffraction, inelastic neutron scattering, and electron paramagnetic resonance, solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance, and infrared spectroscopies, coupled with modeling reveal that the enhanced NH3 uptake in UiO-66-CuII originates from a {Cu(II)···NH3} interaction, with a reversible change in geometry at Cu(II) from near-linear to trigonal coordination. This work represents the first example of structural elucidation of NH3 binding in MOFs containing open metal sites and will inform the design of new efficient MOF sorbents by targeted control of active sites for NH3 capture and storage.

Binuclear copper iodine cluster-based coordination sheets as photocatalysts for decarboxylative cyanation

We synthesized two new MOFs (Cu-Tpxa-1 and Cu-Tpxa-2) that were used as heterogeneous photocatalysts, combining photocatalysis and copper catalysis to achieve decarboxylative radical cyanation reactions. This new heterogeneous catalysis method optimized the redox properties and excited-state lifetimes, providing a new idea for exploring photocatalytic mechanisms.

Modulating Chemical Environments of Metal-Organic Framework-Supported Molybdenum(VI) Catalysts for Insights into the Structure-Activity Relationship in Cyclohexene Epoxidation

Solid supports are crucial in heterogeneous catalysis due to their profound effects on catalytic activity and selectivity. However, elucidating the specific effects arising from such supports remains challenging. We selected a series of metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) with 8-connected Zr₆ nodes as supports to deposit molybdenum(VI) onto to study the effects of pore environment and topology on the resulting Mo-supported catalysts. As characterized by X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) and single-crystal X-ray diffraction (SCXRD), we modulated the chemical environments of the deposited Mo species. For Mo-NU-1000, the Mo species monodentately bound to the Zr₆ nodes were anchored in the microporous c-pore, but for Mo-NU-1008 they were bound in the mesopore of Mo-NU-1008. Both monodentate and bidentate modes were found in the mesopore of Mo-NU-1200. Cyclohexene epoxidation with H₂O₂ was probed to evaluate the support effect on catalytic activity and to unveil the resulting structure-activity relationships. SCXRD and XAS studies demonstrated the atomically precise structural differences of the Mo binding motifs over the course of cyclohexene epoxidation. No apparent structural change was observed for Mo-NU-1000, whereas the monodentate mode of Mo species in Mo-NU-1008 and the monodentate and bidentate Mo species in Mo-NU-1200 evolved to a new bidentate mode bound between two adjacent oxygen atoms from the Zr₆ node. This work demonstrates the great advantage of using MOF supports for constructing heterogeneous catalysts with modulated chemical environments of an active species and elucidating structure-activity relationships in the resulting reactions.

Stimuli-Modulated Metal Oxidation States in Photochromic MOFs

Tuning metal oxidation states in metal-organic framework (MOF) nodes by switching between two discrete linker photoisomers via an external stimulus was probed for the first time. On the examples of three novel photochromic copper-based frameworks, we demonstrated the capability of switching between +2 and +1 oxidation states, on demand. In addition to crystallographic methods used for material characterization, the role of the photochromic moieties for tuning the oxidation state was probed via conductivity measurements, cyclic voltammetry, and electron paramagnetic resonance, X-ray photoelectron, and diffuse reflectance spectroscopies. We confirmed the reversible photoswitching activity including photoisomerization rate determination of spiropyran- and diarylethene-containing linkers in extended frameworks, resulting in changes in metal oxidation states as a function of alternating excitation wavelengths. To elucidate the switching process between two states, the photoisomerization quantum yield of photochromic MOFs was determined for the first time. Overall, the introduced noninvasive concept of metal oxidation state modulation on the examples of stimuli-responsive MOFs foreshadows a new pathway for alternation of material properties toward targeted applications.

Ethylene polymerization with a crystallographically well-defined metal–organic framework supported catalyst

Crystallographic characterization of a heterogeneous ethylene polymerization catalyst elucidates a chromium–carbon bond after alkyl aluminum activation and provides mechanistic insights.

Nanochannel-Based {BaZn}-Organic Framework for Catalytic Activity on Cycloaddition Reaction of Epoxides with CO2 and Deacetalization-Knoevenagel Condensation

Because of the integrated properties from chemically dissimilar metals, microporous heterometallic MOFs have wider potential applicability, which prompts us to explore the tendency collocation of different metal cations in the...

Investigation on the catalytic behavior of a novel thulium-organic framework with a planar tetranuclear {Tm4} cluster as the active center for chemical CO2 fixation

Herein, the exquisite combination of coplanar [Tm₄(CO₂)₁₀(μ₃-OH)₂(μ₂-HCO₂)(OH₂)₂] clusters ({Tm₄}) and structure-oriented functional BDCP^5- leads to the highly robust nanoporous {Tm₄}-organic framework {(Me₂NH₂)[Tm₄(BDCP)₂(μ₃-OH)₂(μ₂-HCO₂)(H₂O)₂]·7DMF·5H₂O}_n (NUC-37, H₅BDCP = 2,6-bis(2,4-dicarboxylphenyl)-4-(4-carboxylphenyl)pyridine). To the best of our knowledge, NUC-37 is the first anionic {Ln₄}-based three-dimensional framework with embedded hierarchical microporous and nanoporous channels, among which each larger one is shaped by six rows of coplanar {Tm₄} clusters and characterized by plentiful coexisting Lewis acid-base sites on the inner wall including open Tm^III sites, N_pyridine atoms, μ₃-OH and μ₂-HCO₂. Catalytic experimental studies exhibit that NUC-37 possesses highly selective catalytic activity on the cycloaddition of epoxides with CO₂ as well as high recyclability under gentle conditions, which should be ascribed to its nanoscale channels, rich bifunctional active sites, and stable physicochemical properties. This work offers an effective means for synthesizing productive cluster-based Ln-MOF catalysts by employing structure-oriented ligands and controlling the solvothermal reaction conditions.

Acetylene Separation by a Ca-MOF Containing Accessible Sites of Open Metal Centers and Organic Groups

Efficient separation of acetylene from a ternary acetylene-containing mixture is an important and vital task in petrochemical industry, which is difficult to achieve using a single material. Herein, a new Ca²⁺-based metal-organic framework (MOF) [Ca(dtztp)_0.5(DMA)]·2H₂O (1) was constructed using the N,O-donor ligand 2,5-di(2H-tetrazol-5-yl)terephthalic acid and the less-studied alkaline earth Ca²⁺ ions. The MOF shows a 3D honeycomb framework based on unique metal-carboxylate-azolate rod secondary building units. Owing to the presence of high-density organic hydrogen-bonding acceptors and open metal sites (OMSs), the activated MOF shows high adsorption capacity for C₂H₂ and selectivity for C₂H₂ over CO₂, C₂H₄, C₂H₆, and CH₄. Dynamic breakthrough experiments indicated the actual C₂H₂ separation potential of the MOF from binary (C₂H₂-C₂H₄ and C₂H₂-CO₂) and ternary (C₂H₂-C₂H₄-CO₂ and C₂H₂-C₂H₄-C₂H₆) mixtures. Simulations revealed that the synergistic interactions between the OMSs and N atoms in MOF and C₂H₂ molecules play an important role in the separation of C₂H₂.

A MOF Multifunctional Cargo Vehicle for Reactive Gas Delivery and Catalysis

Efficient delivery of reactive and toxic gaseous reagents to organic reactions was studied using metal-organic frameworks (MOFs). Simultaneous cargo vehicle and catalytic capabilities of several MOFs were probed for the first time using the examples of  aromatization, aminocarbonylation, and carbonylative Suzuki-Miyaura coupling reactions. These reactions highlight that MOFs can serve a dual role as a gas cargo vehicle and a catalyst,  leading to product formation with yields similar to reactions employing pure gases. Furthermore, the MOFs can be recycled without sacrificing product yield, while simultaneously maintaining crystallinity. The reported findings were supported crystallographically and spectroscopically (e.g.,  diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy), foreshadowing a pathway for the development of multifunctional MOF-based reagent-catalyst cargo vessels for reactive reagents, as an attractive alternative to the use of toxic pure gases or gas generators.

Thermochemical Investigation of Oxyanion Coordination in a Zirconium-Based Metal-Organic Framework

Porous materials possess high internal surface areas and void fractions that make them valuable in several applications, including gas storage, heterogeneous catalysis, and water purification. Despite the plentiful effort allocated to porous materials research annually, few methods exist to directly monitor and characterize chemical events occurring within a pore's confines. The crystalline nature of zeolites, covalent organic frameworks (COFs), and metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) permit structural characterization by X-ray diffraction; yet, quantifying the thermodynamics of chemical processes and transformations remains tedious and error ridden. Herein, we employ isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) to determine the full thermodynamic profile of oxyanion adsorption in a zirconium-based MOF, NU-1000. To further validate this method, which we recently introduced to the field, we replicated ITC experiments as bulk adsorption measurements to demonstrate the correlation between the extracted stoichiometric parameter from ITC thermograms and the MOF uptake capacity. Moreover, based on the calculated association constants, we accurately predicted which analytes might be able to displace others. For example, dihydrogen phosphate can displace selenate and sulfate because of its higher association constant (ΔGphosphate = -5.41 kcal/mol; ΔGselenate = -4.98 kcal/mol; ΔGsulfate = -4.77 kcal/mol). We monitored the exchange processes by titrating oxyanion-functionalized MOF samples with a more strongly binding analyte.

Ru(III) -based polyoxometalate tetramers as highly efficient heterogeneous catalysts for alcohol oxidation reactions at room temperature

A novel ruthenium-containing polyoxometalate-based organic-inorganic hybrid, K₄Na₉H_7.4[(AsW₉O₃₃)₄(WO₂)₄{Ru_3.2(C₃H₃N₂)₂}]·42H₂O (1), was successfully synthesized by a one-step hydrothermal method under acidic conditions, which applied a self-assembly strategy between inorganic polyoxometalate based on trivacant [B-α-AsW₉O₃₃]^9- {AsW₉} fragments and an organic ligand, imidazole (C₃H₄N₂). Compound 1 was further characterized by single-crystal X-ray diffraction, PXRD, IR spectroscopy, UV-Vis spectroscopy, ESI-MS, elemental analysis and TGA. Single-crystal X-ray diffraction data reveal that the polyanion consists of four trivacant Keggin-type polyanion {AsW₉} building blocks bridged by four {WO₆} units, leading to a crown-shaped tetrameric structure [(AsW₉O₃₃)₄(WO₂)₄{Ru_3.2(C₃H₃N₂)₂}]^20.4-. The ESI-MS result reveals that the polyanion unit has excellent structural integrity in water. Moreover, the catalysis study of 1 was also further investigated, and the experimental results indicate heterogeneous catalyst 1 presents high efficiency (yield = 98%), excellent selectivity (>99%), and good recyclability for the oxidation of 1-(4-chlorophenyl)ethanol to 4'-chloroacetophenone with commercially available 70% aqueous tert-butyl hydroperoxide {TBHP (aq.)} as the oxidant at room temperature.

In Situ Implanting of Single Tungsten Sites into Defective UiO-66(Zr) by Solvent-Free Route for Efficient Oxidative Desulfurization at Room Temperature

Design of single-site catalysts with catalytic sites at atomic-scale and high atom utilization, provides new opportunities to gain superior catalytic performance for targeted reactions. In this contribution, we report a one-pot green approach for in situ implanting of single tungsten sites (up to 12.7 wt.%) onto the nodes of defective UiO-66(Zr) structure via forming Zr-O-W bonds under solvent-free condition. The catalysts displayed extraordinary activity for the oxidative removal of sulfur compounds (1000 ppm S) at room temperature within 30 min. The turnover frequency (TOF) value can reach 44.0 h^-1 at 30 °C, which is 109.0, 12.3 and 1.2 times higher than that of pristine UiO-66(Zr), WO₃ , and WCl₆ (homogeneous catalyst). Theoretical and experimental studies show that the anchored W sites can react with oxidant readily and generate W^VI -peroxo intermediates that determine the reaction activity. Our work not only manifests the application of SSCs in the field of desulfurization of fuel oil but also opens a new solvent-free avenue for fabricating MOFs based SSCs.

Tuning the Structural Flexibility for Multi-Responsive Gas Sorption in Isonicotinate-Based Metal-Organic Frameworks

Flexible metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) are of high interest as smart programmable materials for gas sorption due to their unique structural changes triggered by external stimuli. Owing to this property, which leads to opportunities such as maximizing deliverable gas capacity, flexible MOFs sometimes offer more advantages in sorption applications compared to their more rigid counterparts. Herein, we elucidate the effect of transition metal identity of a series of isonicotinate-based flexible MOFs, M(4-PyC)₂ [M═Mg, Mn, and Cu; 4-PyC = 4-pyridine carboxylic acid] on the structural dynamic response to different gases (C₂H₄, C₂H₆, Xe, Kr, and SO₂). Isotherms at different temperatures show that C₂H₄, C₂H₆, and Xe can form sufficiently strong interactions with both Mg(4-PyC)₂ and Mn(4-PyC)₂ frameworks resulting in gate-opening behavior due to the rotation of the linker's pyridine ring, while Kr cannot induce this phenomenon for the two MOFs under the measured conditions. In contrast, the gate-opening behavior occurs for Cu(4-PyC)₂ solely in the presence of C₂H₄, and no other measured gas, due to the open metal sites of Cu centers. In comparison, SO₂, a strong polar molecule, triggers the gate-opening effect in all three MOFs. Interestingly, a shape memory effect is observed for Cu(4-PyC)₂ during the second SO₂ sorption cycle. When comparing the different gate-opening pressures of each gas, we observed that the structural flexibility of the three frameworks is highly sensitive to the chemical hardness of the Lewis acidic metal ions (Mg²⁺ > Mn²⁺ > Cu²⁺). As a result, the gate opening behavior is observed at lower pressures for the MOFs containing weaker M-N bonds (harder metal ions), with the exception of Cu(4-PyC)₂ toward C₂H₄. These observations reveal that different transition metals can be used to finely control the structural flexibility of the frameworks.