Conformational and Interaction Landscape of Histone H4 Tails in Nucleosomes Probed by Paramagnetic NMR Spectroscopy

NMR-Based Measurements of Site-Specific Electrostatic Potentials of Histone Tails in Nucleosome Core Particles

Electrostatics play a dominant role in guiding many biological processes. This is especially the case in the context of chromatin, where charge interactions modulate diverse activities such as DNA repair, transcription, replication, condensation, and phase separation. Using NMR experiments quantifying solvent paramagnetic relaxation enhancements of backbone amide and side chain methyl protons in the presence of paramagnetic cosolutes and focusing on the nucleosome core particle (NCP), we report near surface electrostatic potentials of tail residues of each of the four histone components of the NCP. These are all negative, despite sequences comprising a high density of positively charged amino acids, emphasizing the strong contribution of the negatively charged DNA with which the tails interact. Changes in electrostatic potentials of as much as 60 mV between isolated histone tails and tails in the context of the NCP are calculated. Notably, the tail potentials can vary significantly from each other, with enrichment in glycine residues correlating with less negative values, highlighting differences in the interactions with DNA.

Histone tetrasome dynamics affects chromatin transcription

During various DNA-centered processes in the cell nucleus, the minimal structural units of chromatin organization, nucleosomes, are often transiently converted to hexasomes and tetrasomes missing one or both H2A/H2B histone dimers, respectively. However, the structural and functional properties of the subnucleosomes and their impact on biological processes in the nuclei are poorly understood. Here, using biochemical approaches, molecular dynamics simulations, single-particle Förster resonance energy transfer microscopy, and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, we have shown that, surprisingly, removal of both dimers from a nucleosome results in much higher mobility of both histones and DNA in the tetrasome. Accordingly, DNase I footprinting shows that DNA-histone interactions in tetrasomes are greatly compromised, resulting in formation of a much lower barrier to transcribing RNA polymerase II than nucleosomes. The data suggest that tetrasomes are remarkably dynamic structures and their formation can strongly affect various biological processes.

Solution NMR goes big: Atomic resolution studies of protein components of molecular machines and phase-separated condensates

The tools of structural biology have undergone remarkable advances in the past decade. These include new computational and experimental approaches that have enabled studies at a level of detail - and ease - that were not previously possible. Yet, significant deficiencies in our understanding of biomolecular function remain and new challenges must be overcome to go beyond static pictures towards a description of function in terms of structural dynamics. Solution Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) spectroscopy has emerged as a powerful technique for atomic resolution studies of the dynamics of a wide range of biomolecules, including molecular machines and the components of phase-separated condensates. Here we highlight some of the very recent advances in these areas that have been driven by NMR.

Histone N-tails modulate sequence-specific positioning of nucleosomes

Spatial organization of chromatin is essential for cellular functioning. However, the precise mechanisms governing sequence-dependent positioning of nucleosomes on DNA remain unknown in detail. Existing algorithms, considering the sequence-dependent deformability of DNA and its interactions with the histone globular domains, predict rotational setting of only 65% of human nucleosomes mapped in vivo. To uncover additional factors responsible for the nucleosome positioning, we analyzed potential involvement of the histone N-tails in this process. To this aim, we reconstituted the H2A/H4 N-tailless nucleosomes on human BRCA1 DNA (∼100 kb) and compared their positions and sequences with those of the wild-type nucleosomes. We found that removal of the histone N-tails promoted displacement of the predominant positions of nucleosomes, accompanied by redistribution of the AT-rich and GC-rich motifs in nucleosome sequences. Importantly, most of these sequence changes occurred at superhelical locations (SHLs) ±4, ±1, and ± 2, where the H2A and H4 N-tails interact with the DNA minor grooves. Furthermore, a substantial number of H4-tailless nucleosomes exhibit rotational settings opposite to that of the wild-type nucleosomes, the effect known to change the topological properties of chromatin fiber. Thus, the histone N-tails are operative in the selection of nucleosome positions, which may have wide-ranging implications for epigenetic modulation of chromatin states.

Fuzzy protein-DNA interactions and beyond: A common theme in transcription?

Gene expression regulation requires both diversity and specificity. How can these two contradictory conditions be reconciled? Dynamic DNA recognition mechanisms lead to heterogeneous bound conformations, which can be shifted by the cellular cues. Here we summarise recent experimental evidence on how fuzzy interactions contribute to chromatin remodelling, regulation of DNA replication and repair and transcription factor binding. We describe how the binding mode continuum between DNA and regulatory factors lead to variable, multisite contact patterns; polyelectrolyte competitions; on-the-fly shape readouts; autoinhibition controlled by posttranslational modifications or dynamic oligomerisation mechanisms. Increasing experimental evidence supports the rugged energy landscape of the bound protein-DNA assembly, modulation of which leads to distinct functional outcomes. Recent results suggest the evolutionary conservation of these combinatorial mechanisms with moderate sequence constraints in the malleable transcriptional machinery.

Structural and dynamic studies of chromatin by solid-state NMR spectroscopy

Chromatin is a complex of DNA with histone proteins organized into nucleosomes that regulates genome accessibility and controls transcription, replication and repair by dynamically switching between open and compact states as a function of different parameters including histone post-translational modifications and interactions with chromatin modulators. Continuing advances in structural biology techniques including X-ray crystallography, cryo-electron microscopy and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy have facilitated studies of chromatin systems, in spite of challenges posed by their large size and dynamic nature, yielding important functional and mechanistic insights. In this review we highlight recent applications of magic angle spinning solid-state NMR - an emerging technique that is uniquely-suited toward providing atomistic information for rigid and flexible regions within biomacromolecular assemblies - to detailed characterization of structure, conformational dynamics and interactions for histone core and tail domains in condensed nucleosomes and oligonucleosome arrays mimicking chromatin at high densities characteristic of the cellular environment.

Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Nucleosomes Containing Histone Variant H2A.J

Histone proteins form the building blocks of chromatin-nucleosomes. Incorporation of alternative histone variants instead of the major (canonical) histones into nucleosomes is a key mechanism enabling epigenetic regulation of genome functioning. In humans, H2A.J is a constitutively expressed histone variant whose accumulation is associated with cell senescence, inflammatory gene expression, and certain cancers. It is sequence-wise very similar to the canonical H2A histones, and its effects on the nucleosome structure and dynamics remain elusive. This study employed all-atom molecular dynamics simulations to reveal atomistic mechanisms of structural and dynamical effects conferred by the incorporation of H2A.J into nucleosomes. We showed that the H2A.J C-terminal tail and its phosphorylated form have unique dynamics and interaction patterns with the DNA, which should affect DNA unwrapping and the availability of nucleosomes for interactions with other chromatin effectors. The dynamics of the L1-loop and the hydrogen bonding patterns inside the histone octamer were shown to be sensitive to single amino acid substitutions, potentially explaining the higher thermal stability of H2A.J nucleosomes. Taken together, our study demonstrated unique dynamical features of H2A.J-containing nucleosomes, which contribute to further understanding of the molecular mechanisms employed by H2A.J in regulating genome functioning.

Histone Tetrasome Dynamics Affects Chromatin Transcription

During various DNA-centered processes in the cell nucleus, the minimal structural units of chromatin organization, nucleosomes, are often transiently converted to hexasomes and tetrasomes missing one or both H2A/H2B histone dimers, respectively. However, the structural and functional properties of the subnucleosomes and their impact on biological processes in the nuclei are poorly understood. Here, using biochemical approaches, molecular dynamics simulations, single-particle Förster resonance energy transfer (spFRET) microscopy and NMR spectroscopy, we have shown that, surprisingly, removal of both dimers from a nucleosome results in much higher mobility of both histones and DNA in the tetrasome. Accordingly, DNase I footprinting shows that DNA-histone interactions in tetrasomes are greatly compromised, resulting in formation of a much lower barrier to transcribing RNA polymerase II than nucleosomes. The data suggest that tetrasomes are remarkably dynamic structures and their formation can strongly affect various biological processes.

Structural dynamics in chromatin unraveling by pioneer transcription factors

Pioneer transcription factors are proteins with a dual function. First, they regulate transcription by binding to nucleosome-free DNA regulatory elements. Second, they bind to DNA while wrapped around histone proteins in the chromatin and mediate chromatin opening. The molecular mechanisms that connect the two functions are yet to be discovered. In recent years, pioneer factors received increased attention mainly because of their crucial role in promoting cell fate transitions that could be used for regenerative therapies. For example, the three factors required to induce pluripotency in somatic cells, Oct4, Sox2, and Klf4 were classified as pioneer factors and studied extensively. With this increased attention, several structures of complexes between pioneer factors and chromatin structural units (nucleosomes) have been resolved experimentally. Furthermore, experimental and computational approaches have been designed to study two unresolved, key scientific questions: First, do pioneer factors induce directly local opening of nucleosomes and chromatin fibers upon binding? And second, how do the unstructured tails of the histones impact the structural dynamics involved in such conformational transitions? Here we review the current knowledge about transcription factor-induced nucleosome dynamics and the role of the histone tails in this process. We discuss what is needed to bridge the gap between the static views obtained from the experimental structures and the key structural dynamic events in chromatin opening. Finally, we propose that integrating nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy with molecular dynamics simulations is a powerful approach to studying pioneer factor-mediated dynamics of nucleosomes and perhaps small chromatin fibers using native DNA sequences.

Histone N-tails modulate sequence-specific positioning of nucleosomes

The precise mechanisms governing sequence-dependent positioning of nucleosomes on DNA remain unknown in detail. Existing algorithms, taking into account the sequence-dependent deformability of DNA and its interactions with the histone globular domains, predict rotational setting of only 65% of human nucleosomes mapped in vivo. To uncover novel factors responsible for the nucleosome positioning, we analyzed potential involvement of the histone N-tails in this process. To this aim, we reconstituted the H2A/H4 N-tailless nucleosomes on human BRCA1 DNA (~100 kb) and compared their positions and sequences with those of the wild-type nucleosomes. In the case of H2A tailless nucleosomes, the AT content of DNA sequences is changed locally at superhelical location (SHL) ±4, while maintaining the same rotational setting as their wild-type counterparts. Conversely, the H4 tailless nucleosomes display widespread changes of the AT content near SHL ±1 and SHL ±2, where the H4 N-tails interact with DNA. Furthermore, a substantial number of H4 tailless nucleosomes exhibit rotational setting opposite to that of the wild-type nucleosomes. Thus, our findings strongly suggest that the histone N-tails are operative in selection of nucleosome positions, which may have wide-ranging implications for epigenetic modulation of chromatin states.