Caution in the Use of Nonlinear Effects as a Mechanistic Tool for Catalytic Enantioconvergent Reactions: Intrinsic Negative Nonlinear Effects in the Absence of Higher-Order Species

Enantioselective Spirocyclization of Pd-Enolates and Isocyanates

An enantioselective cyclization of Pd-enolates and isocyanates to form spirocyclic γ-lactams is reported. This reaction proceeds under mild reaction conditions and utilizes a novel Meldrum's acid derivative to achieve catalyst turnover, delivering enantioenriched products in up to 97% yield and 96% ee. Preliminary mechanistic investigations suggest that the reaction may proceed via the formation of higher-order species.

Recent Advances in Asymmetric Organometallic Electrochemical Synthesis (AOES)

ConspectusIn recent years, our research group has dedicated significant effort to the field of asymmetric organometallic electrochemical synthesis (AOES), which integrates electrochemistry with asymmetric transition metal catalysis. On one hand, we have rationalized that organometallic compounds can serve as molecular electrocatalysts (mediators) to reduce overpotentials and enhance both the reactivity and selectivity of reactions. On the other hand, the conditions for asymmetric transition metal catalysis can be substantially improved through electrochemistry, enabling precise modulation of the transition metal's oxidation state by controlling electrochemical potentials and regulating the electron transfer rate via current adjustments. This synergistic approach addresses key challenges inherent in traditional asymmetric transition metal catalysis, particularly those related to the use of redox-active chemical reagents. Furthermore, the redox potentials of molecular electrocatalysts can be conveniently tuned by modifying their ligands, thereby governing the reaction regioselectivity and stereoselectivity. As a result, the AOES has emerged as a powerful and promising tool for the synthesis of chiral compounds.In this Account, we summarize and contextualize our recent efforts in the field of AOES. Our primary strategy involves leveraging the controllability of electrochemical potential and current to regulate the oxidation state of organometallics, thereby facilitating the desired reactions. An efficient asymmetric synthesis platform was established under mild conditions, significantly reducing the reliance on chemical redox reagents. Our research has been systematically categorized into three sections based on distinct electrolysis modes: asymmetric transition metal catalysis combined with anodic oxidation, cathodic reduction, and paired electrolysis. In each section, we highlight our innovative discoveries tailored to the unique characteristics of the respective electrolysis modes.In many transformations, transition metal-catalyzed reactions involving traditional chemical redox reagents and those utilizing electrochemistry exhibit similar reactivities. However, we also observed notable differences in certain cases. These findings include the following: (1) Enhanced efficiency in asymmetric electrochemical synthesis: for instance, the Rh-catalyzed enantioselective electrochemical functionalization of C-H bonds demonstrates superior efficiency. (2) Expanded scope of transformations: certain transformations, previously challenging in traditional transition metal catalysis, can be achieved through electrochemistry due to the tunability of redox potentials. A notable example is the enantioselective reductive coupling of aryl chlorides, which significantly expands the range of accessible transformations. Additionally, our mechanistic studies explore unique techniques intrinsic to electrochemistry, such as controlled potential electrolysis experiments, the impact of electrode materials on catalyst performance, and cyclic voltammetry studies. These investigations provide a more intuitive understanding of the behavior of metal catalysts through the study of electrochemical mechanisms, which can also guide the design of new catalytic systems.The advancements in this field offer a robust platform for environmentally friendly and sustainable selective asymmetric transformations. By integrating electrochemistry with transition metal catalysis, we have developed a versatile approach for organic synthesis that not only enhances the efficiency and selectivity of reactions but also reduces the environmental impact. We anticipate that this Account will stimulate further research and innovation in the realm of AOES, leading to the discovery of new catalytic systems and the development of more sustainable synthetic methodologies.

Atropisomeric Carboxylic Acids Synthesis via Nickel-Catalyzed Enantioconvergent Carboxylation of Aza-Biaryl Triflates with CO2

Upgrading CO2 to value-added chiral molecules via catalytic asymmetric C-C bond formation is a highly important yet challenging task. Although great progress on the formation of centrally chiral carboxylic acids has been achieved, catalytic construction of axially chiral carboxylic acids with CO2 has never been reported to date. Herein, we report the first catalytic asymmetric synthesis of axially chiral carboxylic acids with CO2, which is enabled by nickel-catalyzed dynamic kinetic asymmetric reductive carboxylation of racemic aza-biaryl triflates. A variety of important axially chiral carboxylic acids, which are valuable but difficult to obtain via catalysis, are generated in an enantioconvergent version. This new methodology features good functional group tolerance, easy to scale-up, facile transformation and avoids cumbersome steps, handling organometallic reagents and using stoichiometric chiral materials. Mechanistic investigations indicate a dynamic kinetic asymmetric transformation process induced by chiral nickel catalysis.

Cobalt-Catalyzed Asymmetric Reductive Alkenylation and Arylation of Heterobiaryl Tosylates: Kinetic Resolution or Dynamic Kinetic Resolution?

Herein, we report a cobalt-catalyzed atroposelective reductive cross-coupling of racemic heterobiaryl tosylates with a C(sp2)-X type electrophile. Both aryl and alkenyl halides are competent precursors for this reaction, providing a variety of heterobiaryls as the products in a highly enantioselective manner with high functionality tolerance. The related asymmetric arylation and alkenylation are discovered to proceed with divergent mechanisms. The reaction pathway changes from kinetic resolution (KR) when alkenyl bromides and aryl iodides bearing strong electron-withdrawing substitution on the para-position are employed as the starting materials to an enantioconvergent transformation via dynamic KR of configurationally labile cobaltacycles when relatively electron-rich aryl iodides are used. The change of the reaction mechanisms turns out to arise from the relative rates of two competing elementary steps, which are the epimerization of the cyclic Co(I) intermediates and their trapping by the coupling electrophiles of the C(sp2)-type via oxidative addition.

Enantioselective Reductive Cross-Couplings of Olefins by Merging Electrochemistry with Nickel Catalysis

The merger of electrochemistry and transition metal catalysis has emerged as a powerful tool to join two electrophiles in an enantioselective manner. However, the development of enantioselective electroreductive cross-couplings of olefins remains a challenge. Inspired by the advantages of the synergistic use of electrochemistry with nickel catalysis, we present here a Ni-catalyzed enantioselective electroreductive cross-coupling of acrylates with aryl halides and alkyl bromides, which affords chiral α-aryl carbonyls in good to excellent enantioselectivity. Additionally, this catalytic reaction can be applied to (hetero)aryl chlorides, which is difficult to achieve by other methods. The combination of cyclic voltammetry analysis with electrode potential studies suggests that the NiI species activates aryl halides by oxidative addition and alkyl bromides by single-electron transfer.

Enantioselective Copper-Catalyzed Fukuyama Indole Synthesis from 2-Vinylphenyl Isocyanides

Enantioenriched chiral indoles are of high interest for the pharmaceutical and agrochemical industries. Herein, we present an asymmetric Fukuyama indole synthesis through a mild and efficient radical cascade reaction to access 2-fluoroalkylated 3-(α-cyanobenzylated) indoles by stereochemical control with a chiral copper-bisoxazoline complex using 2-vinylphenyl arylisocyanides as radical acceptors and fluoroalkyl iodides as C-radical precursors. Radical addition to the isonitrile moiety, 5-exo-trig cyclization, and Cu-catalyzed stereoselective cyanation provide the targeted indoles with excellent enantioselectivity and good yields. Due to the similar electronic and steric properties of the two aryl substituents to be differentiated, the enantioselective construction of the cyano diaryl methane stereocenter is highly challenging. Mechanistic studies reveal a negative nonlinear effect which allows proposing a model to explain the stereochemical outcome. Scalability and potential utility of the enantioenriched 3-(α-cyanobenzylated) indoles as hubs for chiral tryptamines, indole-3-acetic acid derivatives, and triarylmethanes are demonstrated, and a formal synthesis of a natural product analogue is disclosed.

Molecular Understanding and Practical In Silico Catalyst Design in Computational Organocatalysis and Phase Transfer Catalysis-Challenges and Opportunities

Through the lens of organocatalysis and phase transfer catalysis, we will examine the key components to calculate or predict catalysis-performance metrics, such as turnover frequency and measurement of stereoselectivity, via computational chemistry. The state-of-the-art tools available to calculate potential energy and, consequently, free energy, together with their caveats, will be discussed via examples from the literature. Through various examples from organocatalysis and phase transfer catalysis, we will highlight the challenges related to the mechanism, transition state theory, and solvation involved in translating calculated barriers to the turnover frequency or a metric of stereoselectivity. Examples in the literature that validated their theoretical models will be showcased. Lastly, the relevance and opportunity afforded by machine learning will be discussed.

Nickel-Catalyzed Enantioconvergent Carboxylation Enabled by a Chiral 2,2'-Bipyridine Ligand

In contrast to previous approaches to chiral α-aryl carboxylic acids that based on reactions using hazardous gases, pressurized setup and mostly noble metal catalysts, in this work, a nickel-catalyzed general, efficient and highly enantioselective carboxylation reaction of racemic benzylic (pseudo)halides under mild conditions using atmospheric CO₂ has been developed. A unique chiral 2,2'-bipyridine ligand named Me-SBpy featuring compact polycyclic skeleton enabled both high reactivity and stereoselectivity. The utility of this method has been demonstrated by synthesis of various chiral α-aryl carboxylic acids (30 examples, up to 95 % yield and 99 : 1 er), including profen family anti-inflammatory drugs and transformations using the acids as key intermediates. Based on mechanistic experimental results, a plausible catalytic cycle involving Ni-complex/radical equilibrium and Lewis acid-assisted CO₂ activation has been proposed.

Mechanistic interpretation of orders in catalyst greater than one

Orders in catalyst greater than one can be attributed to several different reaction mechanisms. Differentiating among these possibilities requires careful analysis of their rate laws, rational experiment design and accurate measurement of the progress of the reactions. We have compiled the most popular mechanisms proposed for reactions with an order in catalyst greater than one and derived their steady-state rate laws. We have analysed the rate laws and proposed experiments to discern between mechanisms. Finally, we have examined 100 case studies that showcase good practices to propose robust mechanisms and to avoid common pitfalls.

Kinetic Rationalization of Nonlinear Effects in Asymmetric Catalytic Cascade Reactions under Curtin-Hammett Conditions

Observations of nonlinear effects of catalyst enantiopurity on product enantiomeric excess in asymmetric catalysis are often used to infer that more than one catalyst species is involved in one or more reaction steps. We demonstrate here, however, that in the case of asymmetric catalytic cascade reactions, a nonlinear effect may be observed in the absence of any higher order catalyst species or any reaction step involving two catalyst species. We illustrate this concept with an example from a recent report of an organocatalytic enantioselective [10 + 2] stepwise cyclization reaction. The disruption of pre-equilibria (Curtin-Hammett equilibrium) in reversible steps occurring prior to the final irreversible product formation step can result in an alteration of the final product ee from what would be expected based on a linear relationship with the enantiopure catalyst. The treatment accounts for either positive or negative nonlinear effects in systems over a wide range of conditions including "major-minor" kinetics or the more conventional "lock-and-key" kinetics. The mechanistic scenario proposed here may apply generally to other cascade reaction systems exhibiting similar kinetic features and should be considered as a viable alternative model whenever a nonlinear effect is observed in a cascade sequence of reactions.

Mechanistic studies on nickel-catalyzed enantioselective [3 + 2] annulation for γ-butenolide synthesis via C–C activation of diarylcyclopropenones

Detailed mechanistic studies on Ni-catalyzed C–C activation of cyclopropenones, and enantioselective [3 + 2] annulation with α-CF₃ enones or 1,2-diones toward the efficient synthesis of γ-butenolides.

Copper-Catalyzed Enantioselective Formation of C-CF3 Centers from β-CF3 -Substituted Acrylates and Acrylonitriles

The catalytic asymmetric synthesis of β-trifluoromethylated esters or nitriles is reported. The use of an in situ formed chiral Cu-H complex allowed the enantioselective reduction of β-trifluoromethylated acrylates or acrylonitriles. The reaction proceeds smoothly affording the corresponding enantioenriched products in good to excellent yields and outstanding enantioselectivities (up to 98 % ee). The mechanism of the reaction was studied, and a plausible reaction pathway was suggested accordingly. Finally, the versatility of the products was highlighted through functional group manipulations.

Enantioselective Palladium-Catalyzed Intramolecular α-Arylative Desymmetrization of 1,3-Diketones

An efficient enantioselective protocol has been reported to build highly oxygenated and densely substituted bicyclo[m.n.1] skeletons through intramolecular asymmetric α-arylative desymmetrization of 1,3-diketones. Employing Pd catalyst and FOXAP ligand, various bicyclo[m.n.1] skeleton with different size can be accessed with high enantio- and diastereoselectivities. Utilizing the present method as a key step, formal asymmetric total synthesis of the (-)-parvifoline has been demonstrated.