One-dimensional thermotropic dilatation area of lipid headgroups within lamellar lipid/DNA complexes

Malonic acid based cationic lipids - The way to highly efficient DNA-carriers

Cationic lipids play an important role as non-viral nucleic acid carriers in gene therapy since 3 decades. This review will introduce malonic acid derived cationic lipids as nucleic acid carriers which appeared in the literature dealing with lipofection 10years ago. The family of amino-functionalized branched fatty acid amides will be presented as well as different generations of malonic acid diamides. Both groups of cationic lipids yield lipid mixtures with highly efficient nucleic acid transfer activities in in-vitro cell culture models. The DNA transfer screening of lipid libraries with directed structural variations in the lipophilic as well as in the hydrophilic part of the amphiphiles yields structure/activity relationships. Furthermore, the detailed characterizations of selected lipid composites at the air/water interface and in bulk systems are summarized with regard to transfection determining physical-chemical properties. The findings are also discussed in comparison to results obtained with other families of cationic lipids.

Structures of malonic acid diamide/phospholipid composites and their lipoplexes

As a continuation of previous work, the self-assembly process of cationic lipid formulations in the presence and absence of DNA was investigated with respect to binary lipid mixtures suitable as polynucleotide carrier systems. The lipid blends consist of one malonic-acid-based cationic lipid with a varying alkyl chain pattern, either N-{6-amino-1-[N-(9Z)-octadec-9-enylamino]-1-oxohexan-(2S)-2-yl}-N'-{2-[N,N-bis(2-aminoethyl)amino]ethyl}-2-hexadecylpropandiamide () or N-[6-amino-1-oxo-1-(N-tetradecylamino)hexan-(2S)-2-yl]-N'-{2-[N,N-bis(2-aminoethyl)amino]ethyl}-2-hexadecylpropandiamide (), and one neutral co-lipid, either 1,2-di-[(9Z)-octadec-9-enoyl]-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPE) or 1,2-di-(hexadecanoyl)-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPPC). Although the cationic lipids exhibit only slight differences in their structure, the DNA transfer efficiency varies drastically. Therefore, self-assembly was studied in 3D systems by small- and wide-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS and WAXS) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) as well as in 2D systems by infrared reflection-absorption spectroscopy (IRRAS) on Langmuir films. The investigated lipid mixtures show quite different self-assembly in the absence of DNA, with varying structures from vesicles (/DOPE; /DOPE) and tubes (/DOPE) to discoid structures (/DPPC; /DPPC). Twisted ribbons and sheets, which were stabilized due to hydrogen-bond networks, were found in all investigated lipid mixtures in the absence of DNA. The addition of DNA leads to the formation of lamellar lipoplexes for all the investigated lipid compositions. The lipoplexes differ in crucial parameters, such as the lamellar repeat distance and the spacing between the DNA strands, indicating differences in the binding strength between DNA and the lipid composition. The formation of associates with an ideal charge density might emerge as a key parameter for efficient DNA transfer. Furthermore, the structures observed for the different lipid compositions in the absence of DNA prepare the way for other applications besides gene therapy.

Size and charge of nanoparticles following incubation with human plasma of healthy and pancreatic cancer patients

When nanoparticles (NPs) enter a biological environment, proteins bind to their surface forming a protein coating, which alters NP features giving it a biological identity, which controls its physiological response. The NP biological identity (size, charge and aggregation state) does strictly correlate with its physicochemical properties and the nature of the biological environment. While the former relationship has been extensively investigated, whether and how alterations in the physiological environment affect the biological identity of the NPs remains unclear. In this work we enrolled healthy and histologically proven pancreatic cancer patients. A statistically significant reduction in the level of clinically relevant proteins in cancer patients occurred. Positively and negatively charged lipid nanoparticles with two different surface chemistries (plain and PEGylated) were incubated with human plasma from both groups and characterized thoroughly by dynamic light scattering and zeta potential measurements. Only when plain positively charged NPs were tested, significant difference in zeta-potential between healthy and pancreatic cancer groups was found. This result implies that pooling human plasma from healthy volunteers might lead to a bias and thus unpredictable consequences in regard to previously optimized targeting profile.

Demixing and crystallization of DODAB in DPPC-DODAB binary mixtures

The crystallization mechanism of one lipid component within multicomponent lipid mixtures remains unclear. To shed light on this issue, we studied the demixing and crystallization behaviors of a binary lipid system using neutral dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) and cationic dioctadecyldimethylammonium bromide (DODAB) as model molecules. The results indicate that when DODAB is no more than equimolar (e.g., DPPC/DODAB = 2/1 and 1/1), DPPC is miscible with DODAB and hinders the crystallization of DODAB, and the samples undergo reversible gel-fluid phase transitions upon heating and cooling. However, when DODAB is dominant in the mixture (DPPC/DODAB = 1/2), cooling of the mixed fluid phase results in the formation of a DODAB-rich gel domain and a DPPC-DODAB mixed gel domain. Such phase-separated mixed gels can undergo further demixing and crystallization, producing a DODAB-rich crystalline domain and a DPPC-rich tilted gel domain upon prolonged (or plus low-temperature) incubation. Besides, evidence has been given that the crystallized DODAB-rich domain remains in the same lipid bilayer as the DPPC-rich domain. All the three binary lipid mixtures can hold large amounts of water in the lipid interlamellar regions, allowing the incorporation of a large number of water-soluble substances such as DNA or proteins, which can be used for the fabrication of functional biofilms and biomaterials. Influences of water content and salt concentration on the phase structures (e.g., repeat distances) of the binary mixtures have also been studied.

New views and insights into intracellular trafficking of drug-delivery systems by fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy

Biomaterials in the nanometer size range can be engineered for site-specific delivery of drugs after injection into the blood circulation. However, translation of such nanomedicines from the bench to the bedside is still hindered by many extracellular and intracellular barriers. To realize the concept of targeted drug delivery with nanomedicines, research groups are studying intensively the extra- and intra-cellular mechanisms involved as a response to the physicochemical properties of the nanomedicines. In this review, we highlight the contributions of fluorescence fluctuations spectroscopy techniques to better understand, and in turn to bypass, the major hurdles to therapeutic delivery, focusing mostly on the intracellular dynamics of drug-delivery systems.

Evolution of the protein corona of lipid gene vectors as a function of plasma concentration

The concept that the effective unit of interest in the cell-nanomaterial interaction is the particle and its corona of associated proteins is emerging. Here we investigate the compositional evolution of the protein corona of 1,2-dioleoyl-3-trimethylammonium propane (DOTAP) cationic liposomes (CLs) and DOTAP/DNA lipoplexes over a wide range of plasma concentrations (2.5-80%). The composition of the hard corona of lipoplexes is quite stable, but that of CLs does evolve considerably. We show that the protein corona of CLs is made of both low-affinity and competitive-binding proteins whose relative abundance changes with the plasma concentration. This result may have deep biological implications for the application of lipid-based gene vectors both in vitro and in vivo.

Structure and phase transformation of oligodeoxynucleotide/lipid lipoplexes on solid supports

Lipoplexes are composed of lipids and nucleic acids and have an ordered multilamellar structure with a periodic 1D array of parallel nucleic acid strands in the lipid bilayers. We report a low-angle X-ray diffraction study on solid-supported lipoplex films composed of synthetic single-stranded oligodeoxynucleotides (ssODN) and lipids. The ssODN molecules distribute sparsely in the headgroup regions when the weight concentration of the ssODN in the lipoplex is low. The lipoplex separates into two phases, an ODN-poor phase and an ODN-rich phase, when the weight concentration of the ssODN is increased beyond a level at which the ssODN molecules contact each other so that some regions of the lipid bilayers must accommodate two layers of the ssODN. The phase separation is a result of the fusion of such regions to minimize the total interfacial energy of the system. The ssODN molecules distort the lipid bilayers in the ODN-poor phase. The local area per lipid molecule is increased by the distortions so that the interbilayer distance of the lipoplex film is smaller than that of the lipid film without the ssODN. The ODN-rich phase has a much larger interbilayer distance because two layers of ssODN are intercalated into each lipid bilayer. The ssODN molecules are tightly compacted, and the lipid bilayers are not distorted in the ODN-rich phase.

Effect of cholesterol on the formation and hydration behavior of solid-supported niosomal membranes

The effect of cholesterol on the formation and hydration behavior of solid-supported polysorbate 20 (Tween 20)/cholesterol self-assemblies was investigated by means of in situ energy-dispersive X-ray diffraction in a wide range of relative humidity (0.4 < RH < 1). At low hydration, Tween 20 and cholesterol were found to demix, with the latter molecules forming crystallites with a pseudobilayer structure (d approximately = 34 A). Water adsorption promoted the progressive solubilization of cholesterol crystallites. When in the presence of enough cholesterol, the formation of niosomal bilayer membranes rich in Tween 20 occurred (RH approximately = 0.985). Upon further hydration, two distinct regimes associated with remarkable changes in the niosomal membrane structure were identified. In the first regime (0.985 < RH < 0.988), the swelling of the lamellar d spacing was due to the enlargement of the membrane thickness. In the second regime, the structure of Tween 20/cholesterol membranes was quite insensitive to hydration, and the thickness of the intermembrane water layer increased substantially. Remarkably, the curve of the calculated number of waters per surfactant molecule showed a distinct break at RH approximately 0.988, suggesting that the observed structural change in niosomal membranes was most likely due to the completion of the filling of the Tween 20 hydration shell. At full hydration, niosomal membranes exhibited the same lamellar d spacing of niosomes vesicles in aqueous solution. The process completely reversed upon dehydration.

Structural stability and increase in size rationalize the efficiency of lipoplexes in serum

We have investigated the effect of serum on nanometric structure, size, surface potential, DNA-binding capacity, and transfection efficiency of DDAB-DOPE/DNA and DC-Chol-DOPE/DNA lipoplexes as a function of membrane charge density and cationic lipid/DNA charge ratio. In the absence of serum, the nanometric structure and DNA binding capacity of lipoplexes determined the transfection efficiency. When serum was added, the transfection efficiency of all lipoplex formulations was found to increase. We identified structural stability and an increase in size in serum as major parameters regulating the efficiency of lipofection. By extrapolation, we propose that serum, regulating the size of resistant lipid-DNA complexes, can control the mechanism of internalization of lipoplexes and, in turn, their efficiency.

Transfection efficiency boost by designer multicomponent lipoplexes

Cationic liposome-DNA complexes (lipoplexes) have emerged as leading nonviral gene carriers in worldwide gene therapy clinical trials. Arriving at therapeutic dosages requires the full understanding of the mechanism of transfection. We investigated the correlation between structural evolution of multicomponent lipoplexes when interacting with cellular lipids, the extent of DNA release and the efficiency in transfecting mouse fibroblast (NIH 3T3), ovarian (CHO) and tumoral myofibroblast-like (A17) cell lines. We show, for the first time, that the transfection pattern increases monotonically with the number of lipid components and further demonstrate by means of synchrotron small angle X- ray scattering (SAXS) that structural changes of lipoplexes induced by cellular lipids correlate with the transfection efficiency. Specifically, inefficient lipoplexes either fused too rapidly upon interaction with anionic lipids or, alternatively, are found to be extremely resistant to solubilization. The most efficient lipoplex formulations exhibited an intermediate behaviour. The extent of DNA unbinding (measured by electrophoresis on agarose gel) correlates with structural evolution of the lipoplexes but DNA-release does not scale with the extent of transfection. The general meaning of our results is of broad interest in the field of non-viral gene delivery: rational adjusting of lipoplex composition to generate the proper interaction between lipoplexes and cellular lipids may be the most appropriate strategy in optimizing synthetic lipid transfection agents.

Structural stability against disintegration by anionic lipids rationalizes the efficiency of cationic liposome/DNA complexes

Reported here is the correlation between the transfection efficiency of cationic liposome/DNA complexes (lipoplexes) and the structural evolution that they undergo when interacting with anionic membrane lipids. Multicomponent lipoplexes, incorporating from three to six lipid species simultaneously, presented a much higher transfection efficiency than binary lipoplexes, which are more commonly used for gene-delivery purposes. The discovery that a high transfection efficiency can be achieved by employing multicomponent complexes at a lower-than-ever-before membrane charge density of lipoplexes was of primary significance. Synchrotron small-angle X-ray diffraction (SAXD) experiments showed that anionic liposomes made of dioleoylphosphatidylglycerol (DOPG) disintegrated the lamellar phase of lipoplexes. DNA unbinding was measured by electrophoresis on agarose gels. Most importantly, structural changes induced by anionic lipids strictly depended on the lipid composition of lipoplexes. We found evidence of the existence of three different regimes of stability related to the interaction between complexes and anionic membranes. Both unstable (with low membrane charge density, sigmaM) and highly stable lipoplexes (with high sigmaM) exhibited low transfection efficiency whereas highly efficient multicomponent lipoplexes exhibited an "optimal stability". This intermediate regime reflects a compromise between two opposing constraints: protection of DNA in the cytosol and endosomal escape. Here we advance the concept that structural stability, upon interaction with cellular anionic lipids, is a key factor governing the transfection efficiency of lipoplexes. Possible molecular mechanisms underlying experimental observations are also discussed.