Simulated adhesion between realistic hydrocarbon materials: effects of composition, roughness, and contact point

Effects of -H and -OH Termination on Adhesion of Si-Si Contacts Examined Using Molecular Dynamics and Density Functional Theory

The contact between nanoscale single-crystal silicon asperities and substrates terminated with -H and -OH functional groups is simulated using reactive molecular dynamics (MD). Consistent with previous MD simulations for self-mated surfaces with -H terminations only, adhesion is found to be low at full adsorbate coverages, be it self-mated coverages of mixtures of -H and -OH groups, or just -OH groups. As the coverage reduces, adhesion increases markedly, by factors of ∼5 and ∼6 for -H-terminated surfaces and -OH-terminated surfaces, respectively, and is due to the formation of covalent Si-Si bonds; for -OH-terminated surfaces, some interfacial Si-O-Si bonds are also formed. Thus, covalent linkages need to be broken upon separation of the tip and substrate. In contrast, replacing -H groups with -OH groups while maintaining complete coverage leads to negligible increases in adhesion. This indicates that increases in adhesion require unsaturated sites. Furthermore, plane-wave density functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed to investigate the energetics of two Si(111) surfaces fully terminated by either -H or -OH groups. Importantly for the adhesion results, both DFT and MD calculations predict the correct trends for the relative bond strengths: Si-O > Si-H > Si-Si. This work supports the contention that prior experimental work observing strong increases in adhesion after sliding Si-Si nanoasperities over each other is due to sliding-induced removal of passivating species on the Si surfaces.

Molecular dynamics study on thermal conductance between a nanotip and a substrate under vertical forces and horizontal sliding

The heat transfer between a nanotip and its substrate is extremely complex but is a key factor in determining the measurement accuracy in tip-assisted nanomanufacturing and thermometry. In this work, the heat transfer from the nanotip to the substrate during sliding is investigated using molecular dynamics simulations. Interfacial interaction and bond formation are analyzed during the sliding process. The results show that the increase of vertical force would greatly improve the interface thermal conductance between the nanotip and the substrate. It is found that more bonds are formed and there are larger contact areas at the interface. In addition, we found that the thermal conductivity of the nanotip is another obstacle for heat transfer between the tip and substrate and it is greatly limited by the nanotip diameter near contact which is close to or even smaller than the phonon mean free path. Meanwhile, the dynamic formation and breakage of the covalent bonds during the sliding could gradually smoothen the tip apex and enhance the thermal transport at the interface. This work provides guidance for the thermal design of a nanotip-substrate system for nanoscale thermal transport measurements.

Thin Layer Buckling in Perovskite CsPbBr3 Nanobelts

Flexible semiconductor materials, where structural fluctuations and transformation are tolerable and have low impact on electronic properties, focus interest for future applications. Two-dimensional thin layer lead halide perovskites are hailed for their unconventional optoelectronic features. We report structural deformations via thin layer buckling in colloidal CsPbBr₃ nanobelts adsorbed on carbon substrates. The microstructure of buckled nanobelts is determined using transmission electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy. We measured significant decrease in emission from the buckled nanobelt using cathodoluminescence, marking the influence of such mechanical deformations on electronic properties. By employing plate buckling theory, we approximate adhesion forces between the buckled nanobelt and the substrate to be F_adhesion ∼ 0.12 μN, marking a limit to sustain such deformation. This work highlights detrimental effects of mechanical buckling on electronic properties in halide perovskite nanostructures and points toward the capillary action that should be minimized in fabrication of future devices and heterostructures based on nanoperovskites.

Coupling Molecular Dynamics and Micromechanics for the Assessment of Friction and Damage Accumulation in Diamond-Like Carbon Thin Films under Lubricated Sliding Contacts

Diamond-like carbon (DLC) coatings have proven to be an excellent thin film solution for reducing friction of tribological systems as well as providing resistance to wear. These characteristics yield greater efficiency and longer lifetimes of tribological contacts with respect to surface solutions targeting for example automotive applications. However, the route from discovery to deployment of DLC films has taken its time and still the design of these solutions is largely done on a trial-and-error basis. This results in challenges both in designing and optimizing DLC films for specific applications and limits the understanding, and subsequently exploitation, of many of the underlying physical mechanisms responsible for its favorable frictional response and high resistance to various types of wear. In current work multiscale modeling is utilized to study the friction and wear response of DLC thin films in dry and lubricated contacts. Atomic scale mechanisms responsible for friction due to interactions between the sliding surfaces and shearing of the amorphous carbon surface are utilized to establish frictional response for microstructure scale modeling of DLC to DLC surface contacts under dry and graphene lubricated conditions. Then at the coarser microstructural scale both structure of the multilayer, substrate and surface topography of the DLC coating are incorporated in studying of the behavior of the tribosystem. A fracture model is included to evaluate the nucleation and growth of wear damage leading either to loss of adhesion or failure of one of the film constituents. The results demonstrate the dependency of atomistic scale friction on film characteristics, particularly hybridization of bonding and tribochemistry. The microstructure scale modeling signifies the behavior of the film as a tribosystem, the various material properties and the surface topography interact to produce the explicitly modeled failure response. Ultimately, the work contributes towards establishing multiscale modeling capabilities to better understand and design novel DLC material solutions for various tribological applications.

Sliding History-Dependent Adhesion of Nanoscale Silicon Contacts Revealed by in Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy

Nanoscale asperity-on-asperity sliding experiments were conducted using a nanoindentation apparatus inside a transmission electron microscope, allowing for atomic-scale resolution of contact formation, sliding, and adhesive separation of two silicon nanoasperities in real time. The formation and separation of the contacts without sliding revealed adhesion forces often below detectable limits (ca. 5 nN) or at most equal to values expected from van der Waals forces. Lateral sliding during contact by distances ranging from 3.7 μm down to as little as 20 nm resulted in an average 19× increase in the adhesive pull-off force, with increases as large as 32× seen. Adhesion after sliding increased with both the sliding speed and the applied normal contact stress. Unlike cold welding, where irreversible material changes like flow occur, these effects were repeatable and reversible multiple times, for multiple pairs of asperities. We hypothesize that sliding removes passivating surface terminal species, most likely hydrogen or hydroxyl groups, making sites available to form strong covalent bonds across the interface that increase adhesion. Upon separation, repassivation occurs within the experimentally limited lower bound time frame of 5 s, with full recovery of low adhesion. The results demonstrate the strong sliding history-dependence of adhesion, which hinges on the interplay between tribologically induced removal of adsorbed species and repassivation of unsaturated bonds on freshly separated surfaces by dissociative chemisorption.

Covalent Bonding and Atomic-Level Plasticity Increase Adhesion in Silicon-Diamond Nanocontacts

Nanoindentation and sliding experiments using single-crystal silicon atomic force microscope probes in contact with diamond substrates in vacuum were carried out in situ with a transmission electron microscope (TEM). After sliding, the experimentally measured works of adhesion were significantly larger than values estimated for pure van der Waals (vdW) interactions. Furthermore, the works of adhesion increased with both the normal stress and speed during the sliding, indicating that applied stress played a central role in the reactivity of the interface. Complementary molecular dynamics (MD) simulations were used to lend insight into the atomic-level processes that occur during these experiments. Simulations using crystalline silicon tips with varying degrees of roughness and diamond substrates with different amounts of hydrogen termination demonstrated two relevant phenomena. First, covalent bonds formed across the interface, where the number of bonds formed was affected by the hydrogen termination of the substrate, the tip roughness, the applied stress, and the stochastic nature of bond formation. Second, for initially rough tips, the sliding motion and the associated application of shear stress produced an increase in irreversible atomic-scale plasticity that tended to smoothen the tips' surfaces, which resulted in a concomitant increase in adhesion. In contrast, for initially smooth tips, sliding roughened some of these tips. In the limit of low applied stress, the experimentally determined works of adhesion match the intrinsic (van der Waals) work of adhesion for an atomically smooth silicon-diamond interface obtained from MD simulations. The results provide mechanistic interpretations of sliding-induced changes and interfacial adhesion and may help inform applications involving adhesive interfaces that are subject to applied shear forces and displacements.

Mechanochemical Effects of Adsorbates at Nanoelectromechanical Switch Contacts

Herein, classical molecular dynamics simulations are used to examine nanoscale adsorbate reactions during the cyclic opening and closing of nanoelectromechanical system (NEMS) switches. We focus upon how reactions change metal/metal conductive contact area, asperity morphology, and plastic deformation. We specifically consider Pt, which is often used as an electrode material for NEMS switches. The structural evolution of asperity contacts in gaseous environments with molecules which can potentially form tribopolymers is determined by various factors, for example, contact forces, partial pressure and molecular weight of gas, and the fundamental reaction rates of surface adsorption and adsorbate linkages. The modeled systems exhibit significant changes during the first few cycles, but as the number of contact cycles increases, the system finds a steady-state where the morphologies, Pt/Pt contact area, oligomer chain lengths, amount of Pt transfer between opposing surfaces, and deformation rate stabilize. The stress generated during asperity contact increases the rate of reactions among the adsorbates in the contact region. This makes the size of the adsorbate molecules increase and thus more exposed metal, which implies higher electrical conductance in the closed contact, but more plastic deformation, metal-metal transfer, and mechanical work expended in each contact cycle.

Mechanisms of Contact, Adhesion, and Failure of Metallic Nanoasperities in the Presence of Adsorbates: Toward Conductive Contact Design

The properties of contacting interfaces are strongly affected not only by the bulk and surface properties of contacting materials but also by the ubiquitous presence of adsorbed contaminants. Here, we focus on the properties of single asperity contacts in the presence of adsorbates within a molecular dynamics description of metallic asperity normal contact and a parametric description of adsorbate properties. A platinum-platinum asperity contact is modeled with adsorbed oligomers with variable properties. This system is particularly tailored to the context of nanoelectromechanical system (NEMS) contact switches, but the results are generally relevant to metal-metal asperity contacts in nonpristine conditions. Even though mechanical forces can displace adsorbate out of the contact region, increasing the adsorbate layer thickness and/or adsorbate/metal adhesion makes it more difficult for metal asperity/metal surface contact to occur, thereby lowering the electrical contact conductance. Contact separation is a competition between plastic necking in the asperity or decohesion at the asperity/substrate interface. The mechanism which operates at a lower tensile stress dominates. Necking dominates when the adsorbate/metal adhesion is strong and/or the adsorbate layer thickness is small. In broad terms, necking implies larger asperity deformation and mechanical work, as compared with decohesion. Optimal NEMS switch performance requires substantial contact conductance and minimal asperity deformation; these results indicate that these goals can be achieved by balancing the quantity of adsorbates and their adhesion to the metal surface.

Wear Resistance Limited by Step Edge Failure: The Rise and Fall of Graphene as an Atomically Thin Lubricating Material

Owing to its intrinsically lubricious property, graphene has a high potential to be an atomically thin solid lubricant for sliding interfaces. Despite its ultrahigh breaking strength at the nanoscale, graphene often fails to maintain its integrity when subjected to macroscale tribological tests. To reveal the true wear characteristics of graphene, a nanoscale diamond tip was used to scratch monolayer graphene mechanically exfoliated to SiO₂ substrates. Our experimental results show that while graphene exhibited extraordinary wear resistance in the interior region, it could be easily damaged at the step edge under a much lower normal load (∼2 orders of magnitude smaller). Similar behavior with substantially reduced wear resistance at the edge was also observed for monatomic graphene layer on graphite surface. Using molecular dynamics simulations, we attributed this markedly weak wear resistance at the step edge to two primary mechanisms, i.e., atom-by-atom adhesive wear and peel induced rupture. Our findings shed light on the paradox that graphene is nanoscopically strong yet macroscopically weak. As step edge is ubiquitous for two-dimensional materials at the macroscale, our study also provides a guiding direction for maximizing the mechanical and tribological performance of these atomically thin materials.

Atomic-scale wear of amorphous hydrogenated carbon during intermittent contact: a combined study using experiment, simulation, and theory

In this study, we explore the wear behavior of amplitude modulation atomic force microscopy (AM-AFM, an intermittent-contact AFM mode) tips coated with a common type of diamond-like carbon, amorphous hydrogenated carbon (a-C:H), when scanned against an ultra-nanocrystalline diamond (UNCD) sample both experimentally and through molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. Finite element analysis is utilized in a unique way to create a representative geometry of the tip to be simulated in MD. To conduct consistent and quantitative experiments, we apply a protocol that involves determining the tip-sample interaction geometry, calculating the tip-sample force and normal contact stress over the course of the wear test, and precisely quantifying the wear volume using high-resolution transmission electron microscopy imaging. The results reveal gradual wear of a-C:H with no sign of fracture or plastic deformation. The wear rate of a-C:H is consistent with a reaction-rate-based wear theory, which predicts an exponential dependence of the rate of atom removal on the average normal contact stress. From this, kinetic parameters governing the wear process are estimated. MD simulations of an a-C:H tip, whose radius is comparable to the tip radii used in experiments, making contact with a UNCD sample multiple times exhibit an atomic-level removal process. The atomistic wear events observed in the simulations are correlated with under-coordinated atomic species at the contacting surfaces.

The role of substrate interactions in the modification of surface forces by self-assembled monolayers

Detailed pressure and strain mapping of atomistic contact simulations elucidate the mechanical and tribochemical mechanisms of surface force modification with SAMs.